Remarks by Prime Minister Netanyahu at the memorial ceremony for the fallen fighters of the Irgun in the battle for Jaffa.

Israel Benjamin Netanyahu · Prime Minister of Israel

21 April 2025 · Memorial ceremony for the fallen fighters of the Irgun in the battle for Jaffa · Jaffa, Israel

Context
Netanyahu addressed a memorial ceremony on April 21, 2025, honoring Irgun fighters who fell in the battle for Jaffa prior to Israel's establishment.
Main themes
Irgun battle for Jaffa, restraint vs. response debate, Zionist security activism, Arab violence and Jewish defense, heroism and sacrifice of fallen fighters, establishment of the State of Israel, Jabotinsky and revisionist Zionism, legacy of underground fighters, Tel Aviv's survival, memorial and remembrance
Duration
~4 min
12th percentile
Words
467
12th percentile
Sentences
29
17th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
9.4
14th percentile
Syntax
2.72
14th percentile
Vocabulary
2.35
83rd percentile

Translated from Hebrew

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 82%79%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 4%3%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

29 sentences in 6 paragraphs

Zahav Gross Midan; and good friends I see here, and of course, the members of the 'fighting family', veterans of the Irgun; the dear families of the fallen.

A prolonged, sharp, and intense debate crossed the settlement in the land before the establishment of the state – a debate that dealt with the appropriate response to Arab violence, which erupted every few years. It erupted here as well – on the border of Jaffa. This fundamental debate can be summarized in three words: restraint or response. Each of the two approaches – in the reality of a forming national society – sought to justify itself. The advocates of restraint favored moderation, self-control, and discipline. They were greatly concerned about worsening relations with the foreign rule.

In contrast, those in favor of response believed in security activism. They criticized the helplessness, the surrender of national will, the passivity, and the weakness. Jabotinsky spoke out in 1936 against those who deluded themselves into thinking that the Jews would hold out in the land of Israel only thanks to British bayonets. And it must be said: restraint or response – it is not a matter of black and white. There are situations where the wisdom of timing requires restraint when necessary, and to attack when necessary. There is a whole array of considerations that influence the desired timing for action.

The problem began when a significant response was required to murderous riots – but that response came. Blood was shed without answer. Terror spread – and encountered helplessness. The gangs ran rampant – and the achievements of Zionism were in real danger. This happened in Jaffa, in the six months leading up to the establishment of the state. The Arab gangs that established themselves in Jaffa regularly threatened the southern neighborhoods of Tel Aviv – and other settlements in the heart of the land.

Life turned into a nightmare. Gunfire, sniping, bombings, arson, booby traps, dead and wounded, thousands of refugees, and even a greater danger: the danger was that the port of Jaffa could become a hostile base for Arab armies – from which they would invade into the Jewish state and destroy it step by step. So, then, the question – restraint or response? After long and frustrating months – the Irgun decided: response. We go to battle so that Tel Aviv does not fall.

And indeed, the underground fighters did this with courage, heroism, and extraordinary determination. They did this under the confident command of 'Gidi' – Amichai Paglin – they charged wave after wave at the positions of the assailants. They broke holes in the walls of the houses, advanced from position to position, cleared the area. In the face of obstacles and challenges – none of them raised their hands in surrender. No one said: