Conclusion of the Council for Ecological Planning.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

25 September 2023 · Council for Ecological Planning

Context
Macron addressed the Council for Ecological Planning on 25 September 2023, presenting France's strategy to cut CO2 emissions and advance ecological transition.
Main themes
Ecological planning, CO2 emission reduction, climate change, biodiversity, just transition, energy sovereignty, reindustrialization, resource scarcity, sobriety policy, technological innovation, behavioral transformation, France 2030
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,242
87th percentile
Sentences
162
83rd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
13.7
64th percentile
Syntax
3.21
73rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
51st percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 47%47%
  • Economic 28%28%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Social 7%7%
  • Ceremonial 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 0%

162 sentences in 42 paragraphs

I would like to thank the Prime Minister and all the ministers who were present for this Council on ecological planning.

Our objective, which we debated for 2 hours and 30 minutes and which has been the focus of the Government's work for the past 14 months, is to build a French ecology that responds to a triple challenge, which is not only ours but that of the planet. The challenge of climate change and its consequences, the challenge of the collapse of our biodiversity, and the challenge of what I referred to a little over a year ago as the "end of abundance" and, fundamentally, the scarcity of our resources, whether it be water, materials, rare earths, etc.

To achieve this, we have developed a strategy for reducing CO2 emissions and adapting that also aims to strengthen our sovereignty, and thus reduce our dependencies, compatible with our goal of reindustrialization and full employment, and which also aims to support both the territories and the most vulnerable individuals, thereby building a path for a just transition.

During the presidential campaign, I made a commitment: that the Prime Minister would be in charge of ecological planning, that she would have a general secretariat for the transition alongside her, which was established at the beginning of this term, and that two ministers would be primarily responsible for these issues, one minister in charge of ecological, environmental, and territorial transition, and one minister in charge of energy transition. These commitments have been honored, and the planning, which was validated today, is the result of 14 months of work and consultations within the framework of the National Councils for Refoundation that have been widely debated.

The plan validated today outlines several dozen actions that will allow us to reduce our CO2 emissions. It will be complemented by a biodiversity strategy that will be presented in October and an adaptation plan that will be presented in December. And it is in this triptych that we will advance the country.

This plan, I want to say here, is based first and foremost on a record, and that is what gives us our credibility. In recent years, we have begun the work for biodiversity by fighting against soil artificialization, protecting our forests, and also abandoning major projects, from the Montagne d'or in Guyana to Europa City in the Paris region.

We have also strengthened an ecological sovereignty policy in recent years. For cars, we have a battery strategy that allows us to have four major battery factories, particularly in Hauts-de-France, which are the result of this work. We have developed a clear strategy for aviation with the prohibition of domestic flights whenever there is a train alternative, revived small lines, night trains in connection with our regions, and relaunched the project for both the regeneration of our rail network with reforms and reinvestments, and high-speed lines wherever they are appropriate.

So it is on this basis, and I do not want to dwell too long on the record, but it is this entire record that allows us to first have results: we have reduced our CO2 emissions over the past five years twice as fast as before. And where we were reducing them by about 1% per year, we reduced them by 2% per year between 2017 and 2022. For our compatriots to understand the effort that is required, fundamentally, if we take the total effort since 1990, we have completed half the journey. It is the other half that remains for us to achieve a 55% reduction in CO2 emissions by 2030. This is therefore a path that is achievable; it requires us to go 2.5 times faster over the next five years. And so, where we have reduced emissions by 2% per year over the past five years, we need to succeed in reducing emissions by 5% per year during the period from 2022 to 2030. And to do this through a strategy that corresponds to the overall philosophy that has always been ours, which is a policy of measured sobriety – what we have done on water, what we have done on energy in recent months – where efforts are shared.

A policy of innovation, where we also invest in technological innovation, is what the France 2030 mission and each of the ministries carry; and a policy of transforming all behaviors, those of consumers through, among other things, labeling, accountability, those of producers, those of financiers, whether public or private, with eco-conditionality mechanisms. So it is this whole that we will continue to develop.

Ultimately, this French ecology, for me, rests on a few simple principles that I want to detail here to conclude our remarks and the action plan, which is contained in a few dozen pages and is much more ambitious than I can detail here.

First, I emphasize this point: it is an ecology based on science and objective results. Everything presented in this plan is based on the studies of the IPCC, on everything I have just mentioned from the first term, and therefore on elements developed and documented by our scientists. That is why it is neither an ecology of denial nor an ecology of cure that would be incompatible with maintaining a productive and social model that is ours. Next, it is a sovereign ecology. And I emphasize this point. Our sovereignty is indeed strengthened by decarbonization. Indeed, fundamentally, this entire strategy will allow us to reduce our dependence on what we call fossil fuels, primarily coal, oil, and gas; energy that, by the way, we do not produce and on which we depend. Studies have shown very well, and they have supported this strategy, that we will go from 60% fossil energy to 40% by 2030 thanks to this strategy.

We will reduce our dependence with, for me, an objective that is absolutely fundamental in this decarbonization, which is the exit from coal. I believe that the priority we have set for the country and that we will carry to Europe and internationally is, under this mandate, and therefore by January 1, 2027, to be completely out of coal for the production of our electricity. And it is this exit from coal that we must advocate as Europeans and for the world, which again corresponds to the objectives set by the IPCC, which sets the bar for 2030 to exit coal. France will be ahead of this deadline thanks to this strategy.

Sovereign ecology is also that which we have deployed through the so-called Belfort strategy, that is to say our triptych: sobriety and energy efficiency, deployment of renewable energies, and nuclear energy. So, on this aspect, the strategy we validated today, also based on what we have consolidated, will allow us to consult on our multiannual energy policy starting in October, to have a political meeting in October and November on the deployment of offshore wind, which will allow us to launch the public debate on offshore wind and which will enable us to meet the objective of calls for tenders for offshore wind by the end of 2024, which is absolutely key, and to have a law on energy production by December. This is how we will consolidate the strengthening of our sovereignty, this decarbonization of our energy production.

All this is also accompanied by our European strategy, because this sovereign ecology is the one we advocate in Europe with the carbon tax at the borders, it is also the one that has led us, and I will return to this in a moment, to develop industrial sectors on our soil and to have a made-in-Europe strategy.

The second element, precisely, is an ecology that creates economic value and is based on an industrial strategy. This is what lies behind this plan and on which we must insist here. Fundamentally, our dependence on fossil fuels costs us 120 billion euros per year. And our compatriots must keep this in mind; it is the price of our dependence. What we want to gradually do is to be able to reinvest it, which will improve our trade balance, depend less, and also avoid, when there are imbalances in global prices, having to compensate for them as we are currently doing with fuels or other elements that we import and on which we are totally dependent. This is also why it is the right economic strategy and purchasing power strategy in the long term, this strategy of decarbonization and this ecological strategy that we advocate.

So, in terms of an ecology that creates economic value, we launched a year ago the decarbonization of the 50 largest industrial sites that emit the most. They were received at the Élysée a year ago. All now have a plan, factory by factory, that allows for a reduction in emissions of 45% by 2030. These plans will be signed by the end of October to early November for all of them, which will allow us to meet the objective. All this has been done thanks to collective effort, a massive investment from the State to change production methods and decarbonize. And we will then extend it to our small and medium-sized enterprises and our intermediate-sized enterprises.

Next, we will accelerate on the industrial side with two major projects opening up before us. First, a major inventory of mineral resources necessary for the ecological transition, because we need to have a precise map of the resources in lithium, cobalt that are found on our territory to secure this sovereignty of our raw materials. This is where scarcity is in some way twin to decarbonization. And we must also look closely at the deposits of natural hydrogen that could play a major role in producing this energy of the future.

And then, the second project on which we will accelerate in terms of industry is that of breakthrough technologies, particularly hydrogen and carbon capture and sequestration. And on this latter subject, a consultation is underway, and as a result, we must be able to develop at least one site in France, again to reduce our dependence on the outside.

And finally, industry and its sectors, but also research, are the laboratories for solutions to this immense challenge. And this is at the heart of the multiannual law on higher education and research and the France 2030 mission, which will focus on these issues.

I will emphasize a few other major industrial sectors and economic transformation regarding this value-creating ecology, particularly in transportation. This is a question of land use planning, equality of our territories, but also of sectors, because we have very strong industrial players in this area. We launched a year ago an ambition to develop these metropolitan RERs to promote the transfer from individual cars to less emitting collective transport. This is both a land use planning project and an industrial project. In total, it will represent 10 billion euros. It will massively employ French industrialists, and we have selected 13 projects; again, our objective is exceeded. There are several other less mature projects that are, if I may say, in the queue. And so, these metropolitan RERs, we are committing today 700 million euros from the State to support the projects, and they will lead to planning. We will therefore have the signing of the State-Region planning contracts in October, the deployment of funding for these first 13 projects at the same time as the rail plan. All this is extremely coherent and will also allow us to launch projects for our rail industry and the jobs that go with it.

The other major issue in transportation is obviously electric cars. On this, I said, we have made significant progress. We have first structured volumes. We will have at least 1 million electric cars produced by 2027 on French soil, we will also have opened the four major electric battery production plants from Dunkirk to Douai, in this battery valley that will allow us, again, to be an exporter of electric batteries by 2027. And we continue to increase investment in this area.

In the same way, this ecology that creates economic value is the one we want for housing. I mentioned this yesterday when speaking to the French people, where we could have, like some others, completely banned gas boilers; we decided, because we are a great nation of gas boiler production, to adopt a policy of incentives instead. We decided to encourage our fellow citizens, without prohibition but by urging them to change more quickly, to develop an industrial sector for the production of heat pumps, which is a tremendous lever for substitution, which is much less consuming and emitting. We have decided to triple the production of heat pumps by 2027 and thus to produce 1 million heat pumps in our territory and to train 30,000 installers in parallel. This goal will allow us to meet our emission reduction targets, but it will also enable us to truly create and develop all these sectors. And so, you see, across this entire spectrum, we truly have an ecology that creates economic value.

I could also talk to you about our agricultural strategy, our forestry strategy, biomass, etc. This is what is in this plan.

The other principle element is that we want a competitive ecology, and this is a key point. If we want to be sovereign, if we want to create economic value, then we must have decarbonized solutions that are fully competitive. First of all, this is consistent with our economic strategy, the one we are deploying through the program that allows us today to be the most attractive country in Europe, and we will continue to do so. In this regard, the bill that will soon be implemented for the green industry will allow us to maintain this competitiveness by lowering the investment cost for large industrialists as well as for our farmers, and by promoting the green industry in a competitive manner to, in particular, stand up to China and the United States. It is this competitiveness that also drives us to have a European policy that must invest more to win the European battle in terms of competitiveness.

And above all, there is a very important point that is at the heart of this project and that we will announce in October, which is to regain control of the price of our electricity. There is no competitive ecology if we do not regain control of the price of electricity, which, in a way, does not allow us to be sustainable for both our businesses and our households. Because we have nationalized Électricité De France, because we have the advantage of our nuclear installed base, because we have this Belfort strategy that I mentioned, we will be able in October to truly announce electricity prices that are compatible with this competitiveness and that will provide visibility to both households and our industrialists, and have prices that put us in a very favorable and competitive situation at the European level. We will regain control over the prices of our electricity at the French and European levels by the end of the year.

Next, we want a planned ecology, which is the very purpose of this plan presented and validated today and financed, first financed at the state level. Where we are investing 33 billion euros in 2023, we will increase to 40 billion euros in investments, thus making an additional 7 billion starting in 2024. We have a multi-year trajectory that is inscribed in our texts and that is consolidated with a green budget methodology that is validated, which meets OECD criteria and is now the standard. Our objective in the coming weeks will be to consolidate our multi-year trajectory, to better mobilize other public actors, particularly the Caisse des Dépôts et Consignations, to develop a common methodology with local authorities so that they also equip themselves with green budgets with homogeneous criteria and to have a coherent strategy across all public administrations with this funding.

Then, we must have a European policy consistent with this approach. That is why one of the battles we will fight in the coming months will be to have a stability pact consistent with this approach. Europe must invest more in the ecological transition, and there cannot be a European ecological transition and a real European decarbonization strategy if there is only regulation and no investments. Therefore, France will fight for a massive investment strategy for all our territories. And finally, we need to have better incentives for the private sector. At the heart of this planned and financed ecology, there is a whole effort we will undertake on carbon credits and their sincerity - today they do not work because they are too weak - and the establishment of biodiversity credits on which we will take stock at the end of the year.

Next, we want an accessible and just ecology, meaning an ecology that leaves no one without solutions. This is indeed the core of our investment and the investment of the nation. It is to support those who are the furthest away. Enabling access means particularly setting up very innovative mechanisms; we will be the first to do so in Europe, for example, for electric vehicles. That is why, starting in November, we will be in a position to reveal this leasing scheme at 100 euros for the first models of electric vehicles. For the year 2024, it will only be a few tens of thousands of models, but it will be the opening of this window. Why? Because first, we want it to be fair, well-targeted. And then, we want it to allow access to electric vehicles that are produced in Europe to avoid having an access policy that, in a way, would contradict our industrial policy. But we will therefore set up mechanisms to make electric vehicles accessible.

In the same way, the thermal renovation of buildings must be doubled with a policy of justice and accessibility. We will therefore need to support the most modest households. Beyond what we have started to do with MaPrimeRénov’, we are continuing its reform and transformation. And this, with a strategy that will launch in social housing, starting in October, with the finalization of all our support mechanisms for the renovation of housing in November, which will allow us to better support the most modest households but also middle-class families while also supporting social landlords and the most structuring actors to be able to renovate the stock more quickly, with also an exemplary approach from the state. We will therefore accelerate our investments for the thermal renovation of our own housing.

When I speak of an accessible and just ecology, it is obviously also the work we must do to support our farmers. Having an accessible ecology means never leaving farmers without solutions. This is the policy we have adopted for glyphosate, that of always seeking the right balance. Nevertheless, in France, we will reduce our dependence by 30%, which is unique in Europe. We will never leave farmers without solutions and without a way out. This will therefore be done through a strategy of investment in research, in support, without over-transposition, and ensuring that there are no differences between European countries so that we never find ourselves in a situation of losing our competitiveness.

And then, this accessible and just ecology also involves coherence at the European and international levels, the mirror clauses that we defend internationally and that protect our industrialists and our farmers. The carbon tax at the borders, which is an absolutely essential mechanism for justice and fairness towards our producers.

But more broadly, when we talk about justice, I want to emphasize that many of the transformations we are undertaking carry elements of justice in themselves because they are necessary for the most modest among us. Reducing emissions means reducing pollution in our cities, having a prevention policy to combat bronchiolitis or respiratory distress that often affects the most vulnerable among us, and the elderly as well as pregnant women or children from the most modest backgrounds. This is true justice.

Next, we want an ecology that protects the French people and nature. This is the mission that has been given to us. This is also why I believe that ecology has something regal in this regard. And this is at the heart of the overall strategy that is ours. Working with farmers to enable them to have, through ecology, a response to declining yields through agrivoltaics, biomass, and sustainable fuels, which are mechanisms for complementary income but will also help protect their revenues. Working with foresters to enable them, too, to protect and restore the forest, which will complement our forestry strategy, which is both about protection and planting a billion new trees by 2030. Working with our overseas territories, which concentrate most of our biodiversity, to have this strategy that we will deploy in October. Working to fundamentally protect our nature and our landscapes, which shows that our ecology is also a strategy for preserving our living environment, our biodiversity richness, and, fundamentally, our landscapes that constitute the deep identity of France.

Next, we want an ecology that is territorialized. The strategy presented today is detailed point by point, and it is the result of a significant amount of work and consultation that has involved all stakeholders. The Prime Minister and the minister in charge of the Transition will launch a debate in October, on the ground, in each region. Our objective now is for these national objectives to be shared at the territorial level and to be translated with, fundamentally, objectives that are intangible and a freedom given on the means and the path of indicators and clearly established responsibilities. This is so that we can distinguish, if I may put it this way, those who are engaged and have results from those who, in a way, decide not to play the game, and for it to be clear for all our fellow citizens.

And so we will set up territorial green budgets, real freedoms of action, but at the same time clear objectives and shared responsibilities at the territorial level. The scale is regional, but it is fundamentally each living area that will be held accountable, and thus our municipalities will have a very important role to play. Our agglomeration intercommunalities and obviously the departments will be integrated into this process with support in terms of territorial engineering to ensure that the right responses are provided on the ground.

Finally, it is an ecology that we carry everywhere in the world. We are the first country to equip ourselves with a national strategy. But it corresponds point by point to what we advocate internationally. The exit from coal before 2030, industrial decarbonization, the investment strategy, the biodiversity strategy based on the protection and strengthening of our forests and the protection of our oceans, is a strategy that we carry at the heart of Europe and internationally, which we have defended again and which is at the heart of the Paris Pact for peoples and the planet.

It is this coherence that, I believe, gives us a lot of strength, and it is all these points that structure this French ecology that I mentioned. Who does not decide to reopen coal-fired power plants. Who decides not to abandon its objectives, even when it is difficult, but who knows how to reconcile climate ambition with more sovereignty, with an industrial strategy, with job creation through the principles I have just mentioned.

I wish that all political formations that contribute to the life of the nation, when they sometimes too quickly condemn nuclear energy, realize that all scientists tell us that there is no strategy that exists without nuclear energy. That those who explain to us that, fundamentally, the carbon tax at the borders would not be a good thing, when they refuse to vote for it in Europe, align themselves with our solution because there is no loyal policy without a carbon tax at the borders for our Europeans and that on each of the points I have just mentioned, we can build the maximum of concord.

I understood that this was what emerged from the political consultations that the Prime Minister had held, with the exception of one political formation that chose not to attend for reasons that still escape me. But I cannot imagine that it was out of disinterest; it was probably out of forgetfulness.

In any case, on all these subjects, I want to thank Madam Prime Minister, the ministers in charge, and the General Secretariat for Ecological Transition. Very good work, we can see it. The coming weeks will be marked by the implementation of everything we have discussed, by new investments, by actions that we will carry out, and by this absolutely essential territorialization; and on the international level, by European-international meetings that will lead up to COP 28 at the end of the year, where we will carry each of these objectives. I congratulate you, in any case, for the work done.

We now have the implementation, which will not be any easier, but in which we will need to involve all the active forces and share responsibilities. I am counting on you for this, and I thank you for all the work that has been carried out.

Thank you. Thank you very much, gentlemen, ladies.