Message from President Emmanuel Macron to hospital staff

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

14 November 2019 · Dormans

Context
Macron addressed French hospital staff during a regional visit on a day of nationwide hospital mobilization, acknowledging their grievances and outlining reform commitments.
Main themes
Hospital staff working conditions, healthcare system reform, caregiver appreciation, underfunding of hospitals, doctor shortages, numerus clausus reform, hospital bed capacity, health spending policy, public service mobilization, French healthcare system dysfunction
Duration
~21 min
67th percentile
Words
2,481
67th percentile
Sentences
98
62nd percentile
Readability
53
72nd percentile
Grade
12.1
47th percentile
Syntax
3.13
65th percentile
Vocabulary
1.96
6th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 65%65%
  • Economic 18%18%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

98 sentences in 13 paragraphs

Hello to you,

Hello Ladies and Gentlemen,

I wanted to take a moment to say a few words in perhaps a more solemn and organized setting, during this day of travel, after the time spent this morning together in Dormans to honor our soldiers from the First World War and particularly from the two battles of the Marne, after a discussion in Épernay with the agricultural sectors of the department, and before a municipal council that will take place in a few moments, which I will attend to follow up on all these topics, and then a meeting with all the state services to ensure the implementation of some of our priorities. But obviously, this trip also falls on a day that is important, which is that of mobilization at the hospital. And I wanted, as I have already said several times, to express myself on this subject in a very specific manner.

First of all, to express my appreciation to the healthcare personnel, doctors, midwives, nurses, nursing assistants who have made, I must say, one of the most beautiful life choices, which is to dedicate themselves to others, to care, to be there in the difficult moments of the lives of the French, when illness, injuries, or death occur. And we, the French, know what we owe them. I wanted to express on this day all my appreciation for what their activity is, often their commitment beyond this, and the mobilization that is theirs today. I have heard their anger and indignation in the face of working conditions that have sometimes become impossible. Faced with compressed salaries, frantic rhythms, concrete material difficulties in services where there are no longer enough caregivers present, and material difficulties that have accumulated, with, fundamentally, a lost sense that is thus felt when nothing works anymore in the daily services, neither the elevator, nor the missing equipment, nor the absence of beds, nor the schedules to be filled when it is necessary to replace absent staff at a moment's notice. This is indeed the reality in too many places.

This situation did not start a month ago, six months ago, or a year ago. Let us be clear-eyed and honest with ourselves. We inherit it, and it is the result of years and years of pressure that have placed the bulk of the effort to control health spending on the hospital. It also results from a collective disorganization in our healthcare system where, ultimately, burdens have been placed on the hospital that were not always meant for it, either because the continuity of services is no longer assured in one part or another of our territory, because doctors have begun to desert, because there is a scarcity of medical personnel and everyone goes to the hospital, or because the continuity of care and emergency services are no longer assured and habits have sometimes been taken and everyone goes to the emergency room. And so the hospital has become, if I may say so, the place where all the difficulties have now concentrated, these accumulating with organizational problems, the financial difficulties I mentioned, and under-investments year after year.

At the end of this logic of economy, one consequence: caregivers have gradually distanced themselves from their profession, regardless of their commitment, their passion. Some have sometimes stopped, which is the whole problem of unfilled positions that we have in many services. Some are exhausted, for many the sense is lost. And this is also what makes the hospital less attractive, sometimes unable to recruit even when it has the means. And when we talk about reopening beds, let us also agree on the terms; it is about having the doctors who allow reopening where in the same hospitals the positions are open but we can no longer recruit or retain the doctors who, just a few years ago, were there. All this, I say, we inherit, and we do not discover it. I reiterate here with strength, which means that these are not simply words today; it is also the confirmation of a commitment.

From the moment I was elected, I wanted to put a stop to this trend, a break. We thus interrupted the deflationary spiral where hospital rates had been decreasing every year for 10 years. For the first time in 2019, they increased. And so I also ask for a form of collective honesty. For more than 10 years, hospital rates – that is to say, what is behind each act performed in the hospital, whether public or private – had been decreasing. And so year after year, hospitals had less revenue. We put an end to this deflationary logic; this year these rates have increased again. We have also ended the numerus clausus. The shortages of doctors that we have, whether in private practice, in our rural areas, in the most difficult neighborhoods, or in the hospital, are the result of a conviction established over long decades that we needed to reduce the number of doctors to spend less on health. We have today, as I announced a little over a year ago, massively reopened. But it takes 10 years to train a doctor, 10 years. The decisions, the right decisions in my eyes have been made, but it takes time to implement them, the legitimate time of training. We have also bet on new professions: advanced practice nurses, medical assistants in the city. We have allowed pharmacists to vaccinate, which frees up medical time. And so a series of reforms that go in the right direction to allow for better work and to free up useful time.

All this has been done. These measures and many others have been gathered in a strategy that was presented a year ago: "My Health 2022." This strategy consists of putting the patient back at the heart of the system and organizing around them better-coordinated care in proximity. It is a strategy that first puts prevention at the center because we can better treat by preventing many pathologies, which breaks down the barriers between hospitals and city medicine by reorganizing our healthcare system in a much simpler and more efficient way, which has also recreated new structures by encouraging doctors to group together in the areas where we need them most, by paying them medical assistants when they group together in these structures, by recruiting salaried doctors in the necessary places (we are starting right now with school exits) and to have a medicine that is also more individualized in the pathways and which is therefore both more effective and allows our healthcare system to be much better organized and to gradually move away from the activity-based pricing that has done a lot of harm to hospitals, to emergency services, to be in a logic of follow-up and care pathways increasingly in the months and years to come. These measures have been announced, they have begun to be implemented, and they are decisive for restoring to the hospital its rightful place, to allow it to regain its soul, its power, to also allow patients to regain confidence in this institution. They have been complemented by the Minister of Health, by our pact for the restructuring of emergency services, which is where the dysfunctions are most exacerbated. I tell you all this to say that we inherit this situation, we know the cause, and we did not wait until today to respond and react to it.

However, I look at the situation of our public hospital, which I care about. I see the anger, I see the daily difficulties, I see the indignation, the great difficulty of functioning, and in a very concrete way the plan that has been implemented, which is the right one, which goes in the right direction but which is not going fast enough. I have already had the opportunity to say this a few weeks ago. We cannot explain today to a nurse, a nursing assistant, a doctor in a service where half of their colleagues have disappeared, "We have a wonderful plan, the full effects will be there in 5 or 10 years." Let us be clear-eyed. The risk is that in some places our hospital is too weakened to be able to recover in 5 or 10 years. Therefore, we need to be able to complement what has been announced with a form of acceleration, intensification, a real accelerated transformation plan, an emergency plan that responds to this malaise much more quickly and that allows us to accelerate the transformation underway, to draw inspiration from examples that work, to also assume restructuring when necessary, and to respond very concretely to the urgency we are facing: patients, families of patients, caregivers. I do not want us to have to wait; I do not want to take any risks with our public hospital. I care about it. The public hospital is the foundation of our system for training our doctors. It is the foundation of our healthcare system, welcoming the most disadvantaged as well as excellence in health. It is the foundation of our healthcare and medical research system. It is what we managed to build after the war, particularly with the great DEBRÉ laws a little over 60 years ago. We must preserve it, more than that, reinvent it.

Everything that has been done by the Government is therefore going in the right direction, but I have asked the Government, the Minister of Health, several of her colleagues, and under the authority of the Prime Minister to work vigorously for a strengthened action plan and strong decisions that will be announced by the Prime Minister at the end of the Council of Ministers next Wednesday. This decision will restore financial leeway. More resources, but not only that. It is a plan that is also much broader and must respond to the current situation. We must invest and take on the responsibility of investing more strongly than we initially planned to do because the situation is even more serious than we had analyzed. This means investing in our emergency services but more broadly in the hospital, investing in resources when justified, in personnel budgets and improving certain salaries, in the daily medical equipment or working conditions. Invest very concretely with the most effective financial mechanisms that will be announced by the Prime Minister and the Minister of Health. I say invest because in this case, that is indeed what it is about. These are not current expenses; it is investing in the health of our fellow citizens and the ability to work for those who provide that care.

Then, thanks to this, we will be able to recruit and ensure what we call the attractiveness of the hospital, as I mentioned a moment ago, the key to responding to many difficult situations. I think particularly in the Paris region but in other hospitals as well; I was a few weeks ago near Mulhouse where the problem is the same in emergency services, doctors have left the hospital, it was too hard, not well equipped, sometimes not well paid, it is no longer attractive. We have problems recruiting sometimes doctors, nurses in certain hospitals in Île-de-France because it is not well paid and above all, one can no longer find housing. And so we need to very concretely address these questions in this emergency plan to be able to recruit again in the public hospital, and thus recreate attractiveness, careers, working conditions, and resources. Then, as I said, it is about investing in the working tool, the daily life, the quality of care provided. It is about providing visibility, and in the responses that will be given next Wednesday, I want there to be emergency measures but that we also give ourselves visibility until the end of the five-year term. Care teams, hospital management need to have, over three to four years, visibility to know where they are going, to be able to reinvest, hire, reorganize things, because behind that, if we are smart, we will need to group certain services, arrange the organization of a particular hospital differently with perhaps a care center next door. All this work can only be done if we have visibility and the means to invest. This is what we need to accelerate, and so that we can respond to it. This budget over several years will allow us to accelerate the reorganizations that have been started and that are necessary.

And then I wish that this emergency plan announced by the Prime Minister can also carry within it true logics of reorganization, as we have begun to do for emergencies, where we also need to reorganize our reception systems, reorganize the articulation between paramedical and medical professions, succeed in freeing up useful time for doctors in the services where they are under the most pressure, and review what is called governance in hospitals. What does that mean? We need to give more space, to give more meaning to those who care for others, so that they can participate better, be more involved in the most fundamental decisions. I believe that this was at the heart of the French hospital system from the beginning. We also need to give a more intelligent and relevant place to our healthcare personnel. I deeply believe in the strength and future of our healthcare system. The hospital, and particularly the public hospital, is its backbone, its foundation. We must work intelligently with all other sectors, the non-profit private sector, the private sector, health structures, and liberal medicine. But if the public hospital no longer functions, I tell you very sincerely, the French healthcare system cannot function well, and therefore we must react, not only to respond to the emergency but to strengthen its excellence and universality.

I want to once again express my gratitude to all those who keep it alive every day. I believe in the excellence and responsibility of our healthcare personnel as well as those who are not caregivers in the hospital. That is why I listen to them, I consider them, and I want us to respond to this alarm that has been raised here. Our model of social protection, the public hospital, is something all French people are attached to. It is part of the Republic. It is part of our strength. That is why I believe that the decisions announced a year ago remain more than ever the right ones. They must be accelerated, intensified, and we must take on a stronger and more massive investment in our health in the short term for the good of all. Those are the few words I wanted to share with you on this day of mobilization. I thought it was important to do so in a somewhat solemn manner and to go into a bit of detail. I hope that was clear and that it meets expectations.