Press conference of President Emmanuel Macron following the European Council.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

18 April 2024 · European Council

Context
Macron held a press conference following the April 2024 extraordinary European Council in Brussels, summarizing discussions on Ukraine, the Middle East, and EU competitiveness.
Main themes
Ukraine military support, European defense capabilities, sanctions against Russia, Iran attack on Israel, Middle East de-escalation, Gaza ceasefire, Israeli-Palestinian conflict, Lebanon stability, European competitiveness, EU internal market, European elections, information warfare and interference
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,882
91st percentile
Sentences
248
93rd percentile
Readability
48
57th percentile
Grade
11.6
40th percentile
Syntax
2.92
37th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

248 sentences in 66 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your patience. We have held several discussions today and yesterday, and I want to first thank His Majesty the King of the Belgians for the warm welcome he extended to us yesterday during this extraordinary Council meeting.

We were then able to hold this Council, which was the last before the European elections in June. Last night, we focused our discussions on major international issues.

First, regarding Ukraine, we remain more united and determined than ever in our support for as long as it takes and as intensely as necessary. The priority is very clearly military support for Ukraine, and this was evident from our discussions with President ZELENSKY. Specifically, it involves implementing what we have committed to over the past few months, which was reaffirmed and intensified on February 26.

In particular: the provision of munitions, joint production of military equipment, cyber defense, demining, securing borders with a specific focus on strengthening, you know, the coalition led by Germany and France on ground-to-air defense.

We each have a responsibility to do better with our capabilities so that we are collectively effective in supporting Ukraine. Moreover, given the strategic challenges for our Europe, we must also equip ourselves without delay with sustainable European instruments to strengthen our defense capabilities, including through innovative financing avenues. This is the essence of the work entrusted to the Commission and the High Council in preparation for the upcoming European Council in June.

Furthermore, we are unanimous in intensifying our sanctions against Russia and continuing to hinder the Russian war machine by prioritizing the strengthening of the fight against any circumvention. We must also target those who, at Russia's initiative, support destabilizing actions in Europe, particularly in terms of information manipulation and interference in our electoral context. In this regard, we will enhance our capacity to defend ourselves and retaliate, and this is the purpose of the proposal that France has made with several partners: the Baltic States, Poland, the Netherlands, to create a new European sanctions regime against the actors of these destabilizations. We wish for its adoption as soon as possible.

Regarding the Middle East, the European Council has condemned in the strongest terms the direct attack carried out by Iran during the night of April 13 to 14 against Israeli territory. This attack marks a dangerous escalation and a serious threat to the stability of the region as well as to European security interests, from a country that also contributes to Russia's war against Ukraine. We have therefore drawn the consequences and decided to sanction Iran, particularly to target the production and transfer of Iranian missiles and drones to the Middle East and Russia.

In this moment of uncertainty, our goal remains de-escalation and bringing together all those who want and can contribute to peace and security in the Middle East. This is why the European Council calls for an immediate ceasefire in Gaza. This is even more important than yesterday given the number of victims in Gaza. And today, beyond the victims, so many civilians are suffering—women, children, the elderly—these situations also create an unsustainable context for the future. This situation has led us to reiterate the request and our commitment to a ceasefire as well as the acceleration of a sustainable solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict so as not to leave the field open to dangerous forces that threaten regional stability.

European partners are acting together both to respond to the humanitarian emergency in Gaza, combat terrorism, and open a political perspective; this is the triptych we initiated in the region last October, which we remain committed to and which the attack carried out by Iran makes even more necessary. The priority must be to rebuild regional convergence and a regional alliance in the face of the threat posed by Iran above all else.

It is also in this context that we must ensure the stability of Lebanon. The European Council has therefore decided to provide enhanced support to the Lebanese armed forces. Assistance will be provided to implement the essential responses to Lebanon's economy and to take care of Syrian refugees. In this regard, I will receive in Paris tomorrow Prime Minister MIKATI and Chief of Staff AOUN to clarify this roadmap.

Today, the European Council focused on competitiveness issues. First, with the presentation of the report submitted by Enrico LETTA on the future of the internal market. And I want to thank him here, to congratulate him on the quality of the work done, which also clearly points out the risk of industrial and technological disengagement of Europe. For several years, we have identified and begun to address our vulnerabilities: strategic dependence, internal fragility. But it is clear that we must accelerate our work on the issue of productivity and European competitiveness. We must hold together the balances of productivity gains and competitiveness, the defense of our sovereignty, and therefore, the maintenance of the necessary value chains on our territories, the necessary green and digital transition that we have acknowledged and on which we have engaged the continent, and the establishment of fair and equitable trade rules. It is around this balance that we were able to have the subsequent discussion on our conclusions.

I want to commend the proposals in this report, the very complementary agenda with that of Versailles that we built on industrial and technological sovereignty, and our desire is now to implement it.

The rest of the Council was dedicated to this and to the necessity of responding to financing needs. If we want to succeed in the challenges of the digital climate transition, strengthen investments in innovation for our productivity, respond to strategic security needs, and face enlargement, which is a geopolitical necessity, there is a need for European investments. These investments must be partly public. This is the essence of what we have begun to do, and we will need to go further. This is partly what we will discuss in June. But we must also better mobilize private financing. And that is why we have, at our level, opened a new chapter today in the Union of Capital Markets or the Union of Savings and Investment. It is about how to better circulate the savings we have on European soil and how to better invest it in the European economy. Today, because we do not have a sufficiently integrated market, there are enormous transaction costs, a poor allocation of savings, and thus, savings are concentrated, and Europe has more savings than the United States of America. But this savings is currently concentrated in certain regions and among certain actors. It is not well allocated. And every year, about 300 billion euros of this savings goes to finance the American economy because the mechanisms there are more advanced and because there is a higher return on certain products. In the face of this, we must evolve our rules because we currently have too many constraints, I apologize, on our institutional investors who have, post-crisis, shunned risk. This is also why we have a real convergence to move towards greater securitization of assets and allow the use of the money held by institutional investors to finance our industrial actors and our innovation with equity.

But we have also made progress towards mechanisms of unique supervision, towards mechanisms for resolving the financial difficulties of major savings actors, and thus mechanisms for bankruptcy and organization of these actors, and towards mechanisms for the convergence of our tax systems to finance them. This new cathedral, if I may say so, that will be this union of finance, savings, and investment, is an indispensable complement to the banking union on which we have been working for 10 years and which has already made significant progress and which we are currently finalizing. And it is the key to mobilizing private financing for our priorities and those I just mentioned. Therefore, it is a work of simplification, a work of mobilizing our savings.

There was a very long debate because we have divergent starting positions. But it is also an essential struggle if we want to succeed in the next steps. And this also relates to the conclusions of the Letta report, which rightly reminds us that Jacques DELORS laid the foundations of this single market and that we have, in recent decades, worked on the single market, but leaving aside a few rare sectors, including energy, telecommunications, and precisely financial markets. This union of capital markets is what allows us to respond to this and to build a true single market in terms of savings and investment, which is a key condition for better mobilizing private capital around our priorities. Today, we have therefore acknowledged a method, principles, those I just mentioned, but also a timeline. And as early as June, we will return to this subject with the first feedback from the Commission and the relevant formations of the Council.

There you go, I do not want to be longer here. We could talk more extensively about the importance of training, skills, elements of simplification, but I will return to that if you have questions on these points. I will now rather respond to your inquiries.

Journalist

When Volodymyr ZELENSKY cites the defense of Israeli airspace against the Iranian attack to illustrate how effective defense unity can be when it is based on sufficient political will, do you understand his frustration today? Furthermore, he also urges other Western countries to follow Germany's example, which announces the dispatch of an additional Patriot system. What do you respond to him? Finally, do you still plan to go to Ukraine, and if so, on what date? Thank you very much.

Emmanuel MACRON

Yes, always. And yes, within the same timeframe as already indicated, I do not have a more precise date to communicate today. Of course, President ZELENSKY—but he has been saying this since day one—you may recall that from the very first days of the conflict, he called for a no-fly zone, rightly emphasizing the importance of ground-to-air defense. It is absolutely key for the conflict and for facing Russian aggression. This is what has led us to deploy, alone and with partners, systems like the SAMP/T, which is equivalent to the Patriot, or shorter-range systems like the Crotale or even shorter-range like the Mistral. So, we have deployed the entire range, if I may say so, of the offer that is ours, and it is very important that we deploy precisely all that we can deliver. And fundamentally, to help Ukraine defend itself, we need to do several things.

First, to have its batteries. Then, medium and long-range missiles to neutralize Russian reserves on Ukrainian soil and the launch points of these attacks. And also, air-to-air defense systems, which is why you also have a coalition that has formed with F-16 systems in particular, coordinated by the Netherlands. On this range, we are all providing a response.

So, the system that is indeed much more comprehensive is that of Israel, which Israel has built over the last few decades and has financed over time. And it is impossible to build exactly the same system, which would not fully meet the needs of Ukraine because it is the result of decades of investment and effort, and also because we can all mobilize what we have available, what we can produce. And that is why we are continuing to mobilize each according to our skills, our availability, our capacities, but in a complementary manner; that is the meaning of the coalitions we forged and specified on February 26. Germany has more Patriot systems, and that is why it has delivered a third one, which is a very important decision. And I thank Germany and the Chancellor for that. And it is a system that is much more shared by allies, and there is therefore a depth to provide missiles that are compatible with this system. France and Italy have another SAMP/T system that is used by fewer actors, so there is less depth in terms of missile supply, but especially given our specificities, we use it very differently. France, having nuclear deterrence, has many fewer systems available for itself, and we have systems that are there to secure our nuclear facilities on French soil.

So, it is a different approach; that is also why we have deployed what we could deploy in Ukraine and on the eastern front, since I remind you that we have one in Romania, and we, on the other hand, have deployed more Crotale and are continuing to work on this system, which is a bit more short-range. Conversely, we have a missile system in depth, which are our famous SCALP, complementary to the British Storm Shadow. And those, we have supplied, where Germany could not supply its Taurus for tactical and political reasons. And so that is exactly where Europe is useful; we are complementary. And so, Germany delivers what it has in greater capacity, and we deliver what we have more easily. And because the SCALP missile is also used by more partners and in its qualities, its specificities are more suited to the situation on the ground. So there you go, we are doing everything that is useful and the most useful, and we are all in a race against time. That is what I reminded you of 10 days ago in Bergerac, to produce more and also to recover some of these capabilities from our partners, which we are currently doing for the SCALP.

Journalist

Yes, hello. Charles MICHEL says: "We need to stop the geopolitical commission, make an economic commission for the next commission." The 27, I have not yet read the conclusions, but I imagine it has remained a call for a pact for competitiveness following the Green Pact. Does that mean we have a European Union today whose top priority is the economy?

Emmanuel MACRON

While we are living in a geopolitical situation that I have mentioned, I believe not. But on the other hand, I think that when we talk about geopolitics, everything is interconnected. And what is a geopolitical Europe? It is a Europe that knows how to secure its borders and weigh in as a stabilizing power in the major conflicts of the world. That is what we want to do in Ukraine and the Middle East. It is a Europe that builds a grammar of balances and its interests far and wide. That is what we have done with the European Indo-Pacific strategy, which we have strongly promoted. It is also a Europe that builds its own sovereignty, that is to say, its capacity to weigh in. That is the entire agenda of Versailles. And that is where it is a continuum; these are our defense capabilities, but also our technological capabilities and the essential building blocks of our value chains. And that is why, when we say we defend a competitiveness agenda and an economic agenda, it is also a geopolitical question. Because geopolitics is also played out through the economy. Look today at the decisions being made by China on one side and the United States on the other. These are very geopolitical decisions, those to secure on their territory the capacity to produce technological solutions to face the energy transition, those to secure the capacity to produce key elements for their defense, those to secure the capacity to produce technological building blocks. We, Europeans, if we want to be geopolitical in the most political, diplomatic, or military sense of the term, we must be so economically; otherwise, we will not be able to decide for ourselves. And so, we need a Europe that is more autonomous, without being autarkic, to produce its solutions in the face of the digital and green transitions, that produces these financing solutions and that produces the key elements of its economic sovereignty. Finally, this sovereignty also goes through climate ambition. And I am very deeply convinced of this; we must not oppose them; it is the capacity to build responses on our soil that allow us to reduce emissions while continuing to create jobs and have an industrial offer. And that is exactly the articulation between the Green Pact and the Competitiveness Pact. So, it is not just about the economy; having a geopolitical European Union means having a European Union that looks at the challenges of the world around us; it is peace and security; it is competitiveness and dependencies; and it is the digital and climate transition. In the face of these three challenges, if we want to have a Europe that weighs in, we need a Europe that knows how to provide its own answers for itself.

Journalist

Regarding the next commission, it will not be economic; it will remain geopolitical...

Emmanuel MACRON

It must be geopolitical because the economy is included. And I see little how we could ignore questions of peace and war at the moment we are speaking. So the three will be included. However, what is key and what we see rising in all our debates in our countries is that we have a need for investment and simplification where we have, for good reasons, had a phase rather focused on norms and standardization during the last five years. On issues, for example, climate, we have set the rules and milestones. Now, we need to provide the flexibilities to implement them in each country. But above all, we need investments to support the efforts of norms that have been made.

Journalist

Mr. President, could you tell me what's the reason behind still the Iranian regime army not in the list of terrorist organizations? Yesterday, we know the European Union, most of the countries decided to sanction against Iran, but still the Iranian regime's revolutionary army is not on the list. So this is the first question. And the second question, the USA military right now, they are building the defense system, Patriot in Erbil, the capital of the Iraqi Kurdistan region. They try to protect their soldiers, but also, you have soldiers in Iraq, in the Kurdistan region. Don't you think the French also, you have to think about building the defense system, Patriot? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

We have our own systems, and we have...

Journalist

Could you, in English, please?

Emmanuel MACRON

Sure.

Journalist

Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

So for your first question, as you mentioned, this is an open debate, as you know, between member states, the question you raised and the legal question of classification. But there was and there is a strong consensus to sanction, which is largely the most important issue, and to take clear decisions to sanction, not just the officials and the army, but all the key players and industrialists and financiers involved in the production of missiles and drones. And we will follow up. And I think it's very important; it is to rebuild and strengthen the coalition in order to contain regional destabilization, ballistic activities, and nuclear activities of Iran. And you know it's my priority. And if you remember what France advocated in 2018, when the US just decided on its solid basis to clearly withdraw from the JCPoA, we advocated not to kill the JCPoA, but to enlarge it and have a broader view. It is still the case. As for Erbil and Kurdistan, you know how much we are attached to the security of our armed forces, but also to the security of our key partners in the whole region. So we remain very committed. And we do have our own systems being deployed there. We don't have the Patriot system, but we have adapted our own systems; they are deployed with our soldiers and special forces being there to secure our own capacities, but also to secure our friends.

Journalist

A question about the capital markets union. Finally, what you have renamed the Investment and Savings Union. How do you plan to convince and what gives you hope to convince the 14 states that still oppose it today? And Paris is already hosting ESMA. Is this also an opportunity, by the way, to strengthen the role of Paris in the financial attractiveness of Europe, but also in the regulation of these activities?

Emmanuel MACRON

On the second point, that is not the goal. Because, moreover, we will preserve many sectoral systems that already exist in other capitals. So that is not the objective of this approach. The goal is to have a system that works better with actors whose domestic market is immediately European. That is always the goal of the single market. And that means you have actors who are stronger, more profitable, more competitive, which in turn attracts more savings.

Today, we have actors whose domestic market is multiplied by 27, the number of European markets, when they want to operate in Europe. It is inefficient. I wanted to emphasize the point that several member states had raised remarks. That does not mean that all 14 are opposed for the same reasons. And that is what the discussion clarified well today.

That is why I would like to clarify the debate as it has appeared and as it has allowed us to reach a consensus that was far from being acquired at the beginning of our exchange and which, for me, is a real achievement of this collective discussion. First, we saw that for several countries, and not the least, the priority was, with many ambiguities and perhaps misunderstandings, to fight against elements of tax harmonization.

First of all, I think the debate has clarified. We are not talking here about harmonizing corporate tax for all sectors. One of the key points that goes with the bankruptcy regime is the progressive harmonization or convergence of the taxation of the main actors and mechanisms involved in capital markets. It is very technical, but it concerns investment funds, arbitration mechanisms, technical operations. So, I think this debate has helped to clear up misunderstandings that existed because, as you know, for many countries, the ability to have low taxes is an element of attractiveness. So, that is something that, in the long term, will have to be addressed because it is part of a better convergence of our Europe. But I think we have set aside this debate.

Then, we all acknowledged that the question of tax convergence was not the most urgent. However, we consolidated the fact that moving towards a single supervision was important. That is why we specified the mandate we give to the commission. Then we set a date for all of us in June and indicated very clearly that the goal was to move towards a single supervision, but with criteria of efficiency. Because for several voices that had been raised or that had doubts, I was afraid that it would be a single supervision system that would come to add to the national supervision system, which would recreate bureaucracy, heaviness, which is not at all the intention; it is even contrary. The intention is to gradually have a unique system, which reduces coordination costs, which lightens things up and allows for good circulation. That is what we clarified in the text, which allowed us to gain their agreement.

Then, on bankruptcy law, we were able to preserve, which was very important to me because there had been many divergences. This time, rather between the justice ministers of our continent, we were able to converge things. So, overall, I believe we have consolidated a text that has alleviated the concerns of the 14 member countries. After that, there are economic models that rely heavily on the attractiveness of these financial actors. And so, there were inevitably some reticence. But I think what is important is that we have consolidated this triptych of unique supervision, bankruptcy law, and progressive convergence of taxation by giving it more time.

It was agreed that this is a point to address the 300 billion euros per year of European savings that are invested in the United States, and thus this outflow. There was total consensus on securitization and savings products, which is a very good thing. And then, we provided guarantees by saying that this is a union that must benefit everyone, that it also preserves national markets. Because, and this is a point that we all need to keep in mind, we are only dealing here with systemic actors as we did for banks. This is also a point, I say this for all my colleagues, to you who are in this room and who come from countries for whom this is a very sensitive issue, it is exactly like for the single banking supervision, what we are doing. That is to say, all actors who are not systemic will remain in national regulatory systems, and systemic actors will move to European regulation. This has also lifted a lot of ambiguities.

Then, it is also about allowing access for all to the raised capital and ensuring that there are no mechanisms of crowding out on member states or, for example, SMEs. And we have consolidated that in the text. So, there you go, sorry, it’s very technical, but the subject is. But I believe that in doing so, we have been able to lift ambiguities, reduce concerns, build convergences, and above all, achieve a real consensus on the deep interest of moving in this direction.

Journalist

According to Russian sources confirmed by our correspondent in Moscow, France is the European country that has been importing the most Russian LNG since last February. The Russian press does not hesitate to say this to criticize Paris. Is there not a contradiction between this public support for Kyiv and the fact of continuing to buy gas, Mr. President?

Emmanuel MACRON

No, because you know, today, first of all, this is largely part of the disinformation that is being circulated. Today, Russian LNG is purchased by traders, by the whole world, including, by the way, I will also clarify the ambiguity, Russian oil, since it is refined in India and is purchased by pretty much the whole world. It happens that France, thanks to its model, is probably the least dependent on gas. So, we can blame France for many things, but frankly, if there is one country that, before the war, did not finance Russia and the preparation of the aggression in Ukraine with gas and its financing, and that today imports, wherever it comes from, little gas, it is France. Precisely because we have a model that is essentially based on nuclear and then on renewables.

So, I believe that these attacks, which do not surprise me coming from Russia, should be viewed with a bit more perspective regarding ourselves. Because France today is one of the countries that is the least dependent on gas, wherever it comes from. And it is quite true, I have denounced it several times right here, that there is Russian gas and oil that is resold by intermediaries, countries that transform it or that today have contracts. That is the whole purpose of what we want to do through the fight against circumvention mechanisms.

But I reiterate, France is very clearly one of the countries in Europe, along with a few Northern countries, that depends the least on gas, whatever it may be. And thus, in doing so, we are far from being those who have contributed the most to financing the Russian economy, yesterday as today. We are committed to this. That is also why we continue to reduce these dependencies, wherever they come from, to move towards mechanisms where we increase both nuclear and renewable energy.

Journalist

I would like to ask you if you have seen the diplomatic debates between Italy and Spain on voluntary termination of pregnancy. There is a bit of a concern in Italy because of the case of pro-life associations. There is a possibility that they may enter clinics. So, I wanted to know if, for you, the rights of voluntary termination of pregnancy should be a European issue?

Emmanuel MACRON

So, as far as France is concerned, as you know, we are fortunate to have predecessors who fought: feminist associations, political leaders… to ensure that this right is in our law, that it is consolidated, specified, and to have strong provisions in this area. We decided to enshrine it in our Constitution through a constitutional reform that was sealed on March 8th. That is for France. We are proud to have this model which, regardless of future jurisprudence from the Constitutional Council, has placed this right of women in the Constitution.

Now, as for Europe, France advocates for the inclusion of this right for women in the Charter of Fundamental Rights. So, I think this is a very important debate and that it is a fight to be waged on the occasion of these elections. I made this commitment on March 8th and I believe that for all women in Europe, living on our continent must mean having, precisely, this right, being free to exercise it, and that it is part of our core fundamental values and is essential.

Thank you very much! Thank you all! Have a good evening!