Speech by the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, at the Court of Auditors.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

22 January 2018 · Solemn hearing at the Court of Auditors · Court of Auditors

Context
Macron addressed the Court of Auditors on January 22, 2018, outlining his government's new approach to public finances and budgetary discipline.
Main themes
Public finance reform, budgetary discipline, public spending reduction, taxation policy, public debt, role of the Court of Auditors, structural reform vs. symptomatic spending, economic inefficiency, European fiscal commitments, public investment, government accountability
Duration
~60 min
96th percentile
Words
7,231
96th percentile
Sentences
180
86th percentile
Readability
30
16th percentile
Grade
18.6
95th percentile
Syntax
3.71
98th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 57%57%
  • Economic 23%23%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Ceremonial 8%8%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

180 sentences in 67 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Court, Mr. Attorney General, Mr. President of the Senate, Ladies and Gentlemen Ministers, Ladies and Gentlemen Elected Officials, Representatives of the Authorities, Ladies and Gentlemen Magistrates, Ladies and Gentlemen.

You have rightly reminded us, Mr. President of the Court, that the meeting between the President of the Republic and the Court of Auditors on the occasion of this solemn hearing is part of a tradition that is quite recent considering the venerable age of your institution. I see it as a characteristic feature of our modernity that grants public finances a particularly democratic importance.

Every citizen is now acutely aware that public money is, in part, their money, and the proper management of public finances has become the foremost expression of the sense of the general interest and therefore the primary duty of a government. Nevertheless, and the last few decades have shown this, we live in a form of French paradox where I believe everyone agrees that it is good to reduce public spending, just as it is good to lower the level of taxation, and that disagreements begin when it comes to defining which expenditures to cut. And even though it has sometimes been declared that many cuts should be made, the support is not the same when it comes to tackling the issue. It is therefore not with the fatality that accompanies Sisyphus, but with the rigor that accompanies action, that we must share and exchange.

Your remarks have candidly addressed the limits that have been encountered in recent times in fulfilling the duty I mention, and this solemn hearing is an opportunity for me to express how, in an extremely frank manner, I wish to follow a new path in public finances that allows, in this regard, many of your recommendations, and the experience that is collectively ours, to achieve, I hope, some progress. It is good, Mr. President of the Court, that these circumstances provide us with a moment of direct exchange of views and convictions, for that is indeed how I envision my relations with the Court of Auditors.

The budgetary and financial approach that the government has chosen is based on what I believe are new choices in public finances, which were clearly presented to the French people last spring; we aimed to take a different look at public spending and its use. It is indeed constant that public spending has been the response to the economic and social questions posed to successive governments for several decades. Public spending has become chronic, fueled by a taxation system perceived by our fellow citizens as sometimes confiscatory, leading to the accumulation of massive public debt, because public spending has, in a way, become the major adjustment variable that treats symptoms rather than addressing the root causes.

We have created public spending in the main sectors of economic activity in our country, as well as for the main public policies, because we wanted to correct injustices and inefficiencies, rather than addressing the root causes of these issues. And if we do not pause for a moment to reflect on this mechanism, we will remain in a simplistic logic that consists, as soon as we make savings, of wanting simply to cut symptomatic treatment, but not to tackle the root causes that led to it.

It is therefore important, in light of the work being done, to conduct a thorough evaluation each time in the proposed public finance strategy, to precisely address the root causes of the inequalities or inefficiencies thus created, gradually allowing for a reduction in the spending that was addressing the effects. Whether it concerns vocational training, employment, or housing, it is time to rediscover a lever that the State has effectively seized in the past, which is that of public transformation, based on a policy of investments and profound reform.

Budgetary discipline is, however, the condition for such ambitions; you know that the budgetary entry of this five-year term has not been easy, and you have just reminded us, Mr. President of the Court, of the first decisions taken in this regard. As early as June, the Court of Auditors indeed submitted an audit to the Prime Minister, alerting him to a problem of overspending in 2017, which was underestimated in the Finance Law passed in December 2016, and which could lead the public deficit to 3.2%, unless very rigorous management measures were taken, and according to your report, the deficit forecast was even closer to 3.4% because reaching 3.2% already required regulatory measures. The government did not resign itself to this overspending and took the necessary measures, as it would have been contrary to our European commitment, Mr. Commissioner, and, more profoundly, it would have been contrary to my campaign commitment made before our fellow citizens to respect the stability pact throughout the five-year term. Moreover, it would have continued to give the impression that the increase in deficits and the rise in debt would not be serious for the country.

To this announced drift of public spending was added in October the censure by the Constitutional Council of the corporate tax surcharge, 3% on dividends, creating an additional gap of about 10 billion euros. Here too, the government chose responsibility, deciding to reimburse over two years, partly through an effort from businesses, partly through an effort in spending.

The government therefore took the necessary measures while respecting the commitments made, that is to say, without increasing taxes and without the ease that a budgetary collective would have offered us. This determination to do what has been promised reflects the government's sincere desire to control spending and reduce the public deficit in the coming years. And I emphasize this word, sincerity, which has guided the construction of the budget for 2018 and the budgetary trajectory of the five-year term; I know what it means for this institution.

The budget that the government has presented, with clear and assumed choices, both upward and downward, is therefore, in this respect, historic. We have chosen to initiate first transformations in areas of public policy where the need for efficiency was most pressing, such as housing, employment, or infrastructure, and I will not detail here the various plans that have emerged in these areas; all respond to a similar concern: to rethink the very structure of public policies, to restore efficiency to public spending and thus, in the long term, to reduce it. In each of these public policies, it is the very logic of the organization of this policy that has been reviewed, with initial effects as early as 2018.

Of course, the full effects will take time, longer than a cut or the shaving you mentioned, but it is to have a more secure hand, so that the effects are more durable. Thus, it will be easy for you to understand that such a transformation policy is also accompanied by an investment policy. I want to take a simple example here; the government has implemented significant reforms in employment, and it will continue to do so, which will lead to real savings because, whether it concerns vocational training or compensation mechanisms, our inefficiencies cost money, and the dysfunctions in the labor market are reflected in the unemployment insurance figures and are a cost to society.

Should we remain prisoners of a debate that we know perfectly well, which would consist of determining whether to reduce the duration or level of benefits? That would only address the symptom. The reforms undertaken since last summer regarding the labor market, which will be complemented in the coming months regarding continuing education or apprenticeships, are likely to resolve, over the coming months and years, part of this equation, if they are simultaneously accompanied by a determined investment policy that will allow for the retraining of women and men who, without this investment, would have no prospect of returning to employment.

This illustrates the complexity of the situation we are in, which you have both perfectly described, addressing both short-term problems while knowing how to achieve savings by tackling the structural issues of our public policies and preparing for the future. That is why the objectives for this five-year term are simple: to reduce, as I have committed to, public spending by about 60 billion euros, while at the same time knowing how to invest in the most critical and necessary areas to accelerate this transformation and enable sustainable savings.

The employment policy I have just described, and the savings that result from it, would have absolutely no resistance to the facts if we did not decide, at the same time, to invest about 15 billion euros in the least trained unemployed, particularly in young people at risk of dropping out. Because, regardless of the growth figures in the coming months and years, given our labor market situation for several years, it is only through a proactive training policy that we can bring nearly 2 million women and men back to employment.

And so, we must always focus on the short, medium, and long term in this matter, and these spending cuts must thus be the result of both profound transformations, which encounter resistance, and they are quite legitimate, because they have sometimes also settled into situations of rent, ineffective organizations, and a resolute investment policy. This will be the case in employment, vocational training, or housing, and I do not underestimate any of the resistances we face in this regard; they will continue, they will be expressed regularly, because on each of these subjects we had collectively become accustomed to the inefficiency of public spending. And what you denounced, report after report, was not simply numbers; it was also pieces of sectors of public or private action that had settled in, that had become accustomed to living, and that we must, through these decisions, somewhat shake up. That is why, alongside the commitment to profound reforms, which for me cannot be distinguished from measures of savings, it accompanies and makes them possible, there is also this necessary investment in several sectors of our economy.

Regarding the method, we have made a threefold choice, that of predictability first. There is no good reduction of public spending or taxation if there is no visibility given to the actors. After so many back-and-forths in fiscal and budgetary matters, which have tarnished the credibility of the State, it is crucial to provide all economic actors with perfect visibility on what we are going to do, because that is what they demand, that is what they need to invest, to develop their businesses, to continue to have confidence, sometimes even in their daily lives, and that is what we need to ensure this sometimes difficult path of profound reform. This predictability, in terms of public finances, is embodied around three key figures: 1 percentage point less in compulsory levies over the five-year term, 3 percentage points less in public spending, 3 percentage points less in public spending as a percentage of GDP over this five-year term, and 5 percentage points reduction in debt, because, let us not be mistaken, our real challenge in public finances, as you have reminded us, is to contain and then reduce our indebtedness. Not because it would be an end in itself, but because it is both a duty in terms of intergenerational justice and the very condition of our true sovereignty, of our ability to continue to offer the country a path and to be able to shape it ourselves, for ourselves and by ourselves.

The second methodological choice is that of sincerity, this sincerity that you yourself, Mr. President of the Court, have rightly highlighted in the opinion issued by the High Council of Public Finances on the draft budget for 2018. A great country like ours must present a true image of its finances; it is a matter of respecting the commitments made and the trust of the voters who have placed their confidence in us. And this trust is necessary to restore economic momentum and strengthen the social pact that binds us; it is the foundation upon which we can prepare for the future.

The third methodological point, finally, is the priority given to reasoning through public policies. It is certain that the budgetary aspect of a public policy is essential and serves as its framework; however, we must go beyond this dimension, as I have just said, and my conviction is that within the framework of a controlled budget, public policy is primarily the expression of a response to a given problem, to a challenge posed by the evolution of the world, and spending is neither inherently good nor bad, but it is its results that our fellow citizens judge. Therefore, the democratic debate must focus on public policies, on their overall effectiveness, and not solely on budget lines, whether in education, vocational training, housing, or security; effectiveness takes precedence over the strictly financial dimension, and this is a matter of democratic hygiene, and you yourself just reminded us of this; it is the very spirit of the LOLF.

I am certain that the Court of Auditors will be the vigilant guardian of the commitments to return to a structural balance in our public finances, and this applies to all three branches of public administrations; this is its role and its fundamental utility within republican institutions. To successfully carry out the transformation of the State, the government has initiated the "Public Action 2022" project, which will provide us, for each area of public policy, with a clear trajectory of reforms, accompanying what I have just mentioned for the various public policies, and what has already begun this year by the government. And I assure you, the Prime Minister's intention is not to wait until 2022, but to start now, while acknowledging that we need to set a medium-term horizon that is democratically credible, and on which responsibility is assigned, in order to also fully realize the effects of the initiatives undertaken. Because the great difficulty is that we have a situation that, year after year, always seems to be an emergency situation, but true transformations, true reforms, can only be carried out over several years so that all managers have an interest in implementing them; no manager has an interest in carrying out a difficult reform for the coming year, as we all know here, and many of you have had these difficult tasks to manage; if we do not encourage them to deploy their actions over several years, they will not be able to fully reap, as managers, the full benefits and the completeness of the effects.

Reforms in favor of budgetary efficiency, of course, will be carried out within this framework, but also reforms to strengthen the effectiveness of public service provided to users. Often, the same levers, such as digital technology, will be mobilized on both fronts. This reform must also restore meaning and pride in action to public agents. I absolutely do not believe in the ticking clock in which we live, year after year, on the subject of public service; there would not be, on one side, people who do not like public service and wish to make cuts, and on the other side, people who defend it to change nothing; no, there is a sense to be regained in public service, there is a responsibility, and the essence of it to be rediscovered. There is a reward offered to those who transform, there is also a fair evaluation owed to those who do nothing, and there is collectively an energy to be restored to public service through the transformation of its daily action, and it is indeed in this direction, which is not median, but which I believe is just, that we want to build this transformation.

The renovation of the social framework, with public agents, is at the heart of "Public Action 2022"; it will be particularly carried by the Minister of Public Action and Public Accounts. It must indeed provide more freedom and flexibility to implement the transformation. I made this commitment as early as the presidential campaign, I reaffirmed it in the Senate last July, during the National Conference of Territories, and constantly, speech after speech, before my administrations. I believe in a more decentralized, more empowered administration, with all that entails, but also one to which we give precisely the latitude of action in terms of budgetary organization, or services, to which we give more recognition, and remunerations that can also be different. This project will be initiated this year, in all its aspects, legal, and constitutional if necessary, to support the dynamic we will give to local authorities, regulatory and obviously budgetary. It is an essential reform for the transformation of public action, to decentralize it, give more responsibilities, and evaluate more.

The Prime Minister will convene ministers in an interministerial committee for public transformation at the beginning of February, which will allow for a progress report on "Public Action 2022," not only on the level of ambition, which we want to be maximal, but will validate the first orientations and detail the means implemented to achieve them with decisions made as early as the beginning of February. From that moment on, every week, in the Council of Ministers, reports will be made on the reforms conducted, ministry by ministry, not only obviously for the coming year, but until 2022, so that the most ambitious actions can thus be fully deployed, fully conducted, and fully quantified.

Regarding resources, we have notably set up a fund for the transformation of public action, which will be endowed with 700 million euros over the five-year term; this is an essential component of the major investment plan, with the same logic for the State as what I have just mentioned for all public policies. This fund is based on the simple and shared idea that, to reform, we must first accept to invest, while changing practices, not investing, as I sometimes hear, simply to dematerialize; no, you have perfectly described it just now, Mr. Attorney General, it is to transform practices. And what the State needs for itself, and what it needs to support everywhere in our economy, is its capacity to rethink its action and invest, in due proportion, so as not to fear change. Allow me, Mr. Attorney General, this remark: wherever you are in this room, you will not be protected from this change, because it will not happen in 20 years; it is underway and will come much faster than any of us in this room thinks. I am fairly certain that we will all experience it.

The only point is that we can continue in our country, as we have often done, to think that we will protect our own daily lives or those of our fellow citizens by shielding them from an inexorable change; the promise may hold for a time; your speech in this regard is encouraging because you are beginning to think about it and act accordingly; it is here and it will happen. This change will involve profound transformations, and it is not a matter of resisting it, but of thinking it through, organizing it, giving it a framework, and ensuring, in terms of public action, that our principles are maintained, that our institutions, the philosophy that animates them, are preserved, but that we can precisely reap all the benefits from it, and that collective efficiency is thus improved without our organization, the principles that underpin it, and the meaning we give to our action being deteriorated.

Whether it concerns the State, Social Security, or local authorities, these changes underway will indeed accompany public action and must, in the coming years, be fully deployed. But whether it concerns all these public administrations, I want our action to also respond to two imperatives. First, it must make sense for all our citizens. Social protection, for example, even as our economy becomes more unstable, our lives more diverse, must be constantly reinforced; that is why I refuse what I call "parametric reforms," the accounting approaches that cut rights without offering new perspectives. Giving meaning is explaining this change that is underway, to explain that we will protect our fellow citizens differently, not simply by correcting the shocks of life, which will be more numerous, in a knowledge and innovation economy where change is permanent, but by having a real policy of initial and ongoing training, and by thinking precisely about these protections in light of these new risks. And whether it concerns old age, illness, unemployment, or family, it will be the same.

It is in this context, of course, of restoring meaning, and with it full effectiveness to our policies, that I wish the pension reform to be conducted. The preparation has been entrusted to Jean-Paul DELEVOYE. It must primarily be a major shock of readability and simplification of our pension system. Readability for users, who must be able to understand in real time where they stand regarding their retirement rights, and who must not be penalized by non-linear careers, moving from public to private, from salaried employment to entrepreneurship, and vice versa, but also readability and efficiency for the financial management of our pension system, in order to pull it out of this state of perpetual crisis where each pension reform is, in a way, a last-minute modification, necessary and always justified in terms of public finances, but which damages trust and does not change the fundamental rules of its operation.

This major project, which will lead us to bring our system, heir to a productive consensus dating back a few decades, closer to a simplified, readable system, and thus restore the awareness of each individual, will open this year; I hope that all the texts can be finalized by the summer of 2019.

Our action must also rely on all the actors of public action and trust them. I am of course thinking of public managers; the budgetary framework and public accounting in which they work must be re-examined; it will involve reflecting on greater accountability for these managers through budgetary regulation, as you mentioned, Mr. First President, intentionally flexible, since the share of credits put in reserve this year is historically low, and through better budgetary incentives for those who innovate and thus become very efficient.

Within the State itself, we have decided to change our logic; the usual precautionary reserve that allowed last-minute decisions has been reduced to a historically low level, but we will ask each public manager to do better from the beginning of the year, but also to reward those who perform better. This approach is already partially underway, partially included in the framework of Public Action 2022, in which some of you in this room participate, and I thank you for your involvement.

I have also taken good note of your desire – which I share – to open a reflection on the responsibility of the ordonnateurs and the evolution of the Court of Budgetary and Financial Discipline. On this point – and you have reminded us, one after the other – you are absolutely right; there is no effective public action if there is a dilution of responsibility. And we have, in recent decades, collectively led to the evolution of our system by creating a form of relative irresponsibility in daily matters, only to end up all in a form of untenable criminal responsibility for each individual.

This system, if we allow it to prosper, will lead to the triumph of the cautious, perhaps even the ineffective, because it is only a reward for that. I therefore wish that there can be, as I mentioned last week at the Court of Cassation, on the one hand, an evolution of the responsibility regime for ministers, which cannot be a trivialized regime of criminal responsibility, especially with the abolition of the Court of Justice of the Republic, but a greater responsibility in the daily management acts, because we will need to continue to assign responsibility without which indeed fatalism triumphs.

And we will need to be able to continue to draw all the consequences from it; this is a project that lies ahead of us, within which the proposals you make, it seems to me, are profoundly relevant. And I hope that they can, in doing so, come to fruition. This trust in the actors is also the one we want towards local authorities; the refusal to unilaterally lower allocations, as well as the choice of the contractualization instrument, are emblematic of this approach based on trust. It is unprecedented.

And it must, there too, be accompanied by everyone, it will only work if responsibility meets the trust that is granted; I can already hear voices rising when our accounts are scrutinized; sometimes a few hundred kilometers from here, what does this contractualization mean? That we would not have the results, as if the matter were already lost in advance.

I believe in the spirit of responsibility of local authorities that will have to contract with the State in a framework that is more intelligently mechanical than a unilateral and blind reduction of the grant, but I think that each and every one, now, has their share of responsibility to bear.

I finally think of the actors in the social sphere who will also have important reforms to carry out, but with the same spirit, we have set a growth target for Health Insurance at 2.3%, it is stable over the five-year term, it is a target of financial control but which will allow, within this envelope, to have the policies for adapting the supply, which also requires, in some cases, realistic investment, and the national health strategy will dedicate our strategy based on prevention which will also allow, I know it, to generate savings in the medium and long term.

As for unemployment insurance, the ongoing reform will allow for the establishment of new rights, without undermining financial balance, and by improving the accounts, given the investments made and the transformation of the labor market that I mentioned. The ambitions of this transformation are high, they must be followed attentively, that is why I also wanted to engage in the inseparable task of this transformation which is that of evaluation.

As you know, the constitutional revision that I wanted to launch aims in particular to give Parliament an increased role in the control and evaluation of government action. The President of the National Assembly submitted his report a few weeks ago, the President of the Senate will do so in a few days, and I know that both are participating in this useful open reflection during the constitutional revision of 2008, which you recalled a moment ago.

And it is to find the very heart of what parliamentary exercise is, Parliaments had the right to remonstrance, that is to say, to contest the Edicts when they appeared contrary to the interest of the people or to the fundamental laws of the kingdom, but we have somewhat lost this culture of evaluation. And we need to succeed in having perhaps fewer a priori debates and principles on texts that are poorly illuminated by practice, to know how to take more risks sometimes and be more innovative.

And we will need, I wish that the constitutional revision can open all avenues, within the framework of public action in all its forms, whether it concerns the State, social actors, or local authorities, to allow a right to experimentation and innovation that is much greater, but, at the same time, we will need to increase the powers of evaluation and control, because in the world, the society as we live it, it is impossible in a priori debate to evaluate all the impacts, to have a form of "Praemeditatio malorum" of absolutely everything that will happen or a fair quantification, by the way, we do not succeed in that.

We must sometimes go faster, dare more in certain territories that are candidates or in certain parts of public action, in order to be able to evaluate much better and draw all the consequences. We are in an economy of innovation and competence, we are in a society whose rhythm has changed, public action must draw all the consequences from it, but illuminate the debate and the upcoming action of these essential evaluations.

And I indeed wish that Parliament can have a particularly important role in this matter, by also revisiting our budgetary procedure. Our Assemblies spend almost a third of their year voting on finance laws and financing of Social Security, I say this in front of the presidents of the relevant committees and many parliamentarians who participate in it, we are undoubtedly one of the democracies that spends the most time debating these financial laws, but look at the spring debate, it is, for its part, totally expeditive, we have very few debates on the past exercise and its realization.

And if we honestly look at the nature of our financial laws, they often remain quite close to the initial proposal of the government. This, I believe, is neither in line with the spirit of the institutions nor with that of the organic law relating to finance laws, nor optimal for the good management of public funds. The government spends too much time convincing and too little time accounting for its action.

It will therefore be – I hope – to rebalance the parliamentary calendar, go faster on the project and ask the government to better account to the national representation for its execution. I think this is the very spirit of our institutions and it will also be an opportunity to give more strength to all the evaluation work that is thus conducted.

In good intelligence with the presidents of the National Assembly and the Senate, I have thus wished that we reflect on ritualizing an annual evaluation time in the first half of the year, primarily embodied in the renewed examination of the Settlement Law, but also in a hearing of each of the ministers by the parliamentary committees on the assessment of the past year and on the work program for the coming year.

By assessment, I mean of course the report on budget execution, but also the presentation of ministerial results, both in the application of laws and in the performance of public policies. The Court is already fully invested and present in this moment of budgetary and parliamentary life, since you will present on this occasion no less than two summary reports of budgetary and financial results, one retrospective, the other more prospective.

But your work could feed a form of exercise of this responsibility before Parliament that is somewhat different. It is therefore natural that the government and Parliament rely on you to nourish this new democratic rhythm that we want to initiate. To do this, we also need to go further in the culture of evaluation and the analysis of the results of public action. I had committed to working towards a systematic measurement and display of quality indicators of public service and user satisfaction. I am committed to this, and we will do it, because I hold the deep conviction that transparency, including accompanied by the digital revolution that you mentioned a moment ago, is an opportunity.

Objectively measuring the results, both quantitative and qualitative of our public services, will help us to restore meaning to the action of the administration, to value the most efficient teams and to better identify good practices to also generalize them, to react more quickly to an action that is not in accordance with the text or with the proper use of public funds. And the Court of Auditors, always maintaining an equal distance from Parliament and the executive, can and must play a central role in this new demand for results.

The Assemblies will need to be firmly supported each year in this spring of evaluation whose contours we are drawing, and who better than the Court of Auditors could assist Parliament in this role. The government, for its part, will more than ever need to be audited and advised to make evaluation the engine of its transformation, and I wish that the Court of Auditors can fully invest in this project.

To impartial evaluation, we must be able to associate the heart of public action and its control in all its forms. To do all this, the Court will need to venture a little further out of the familiar waters of budgetary control, and who better than the magistrates of rue Cambon to further develop the culture of evaluation. We have here Article 15 of our Declaration of the Rights of Man which reminds us of your primary vocation.

The evaluation of the performance of public policies is at the origin, at the very root of the Court, and it must gradually enter our professions, in the ongoing dialogues between the government and Parliament, and there are many major areas of public action where the Court has prompted us to think, and most often to act, I think of housing policies, I think of solidarity policies, I think again of public broadcasting, or the reform of the networks for collecting mandatory levies and the decentralized services of the State.

In terms of public policy evaluation, the Court has also brought new insights to the public debate, I think of smoking or the fight against alcohol, but more recently, of its work on autism, an eminently sensitive subject of our health policies or the report commissioned by the committee for the evaluation and control of public policies of the National Assembly, on the organization of the evaluation function of the educational system.

In all these areas, you have managed to combine a penetrating analysis of the existing situation and innovative proposals to evolve the role of the State towards greater efficiency, even effectiveness, I also encourage you to continue to demand accountability on the follow-up of your controls and recommendations. I have no doubt that you will be able to further broaden your horizons to fully support the transformation that I have just mentioned and that I deeply wish for the coming months.

Your centuries-old institution has repeatedly proven when necessary its plasticity, just recently, the reorganization of the Chambers, which came into effect on January 1, showed that the Court knows how to adapt to continue to fully fulfill its mission, and I have no doubt that the Court of Auditors will continue to demonstrate its competence in mastering the 360-degree evaluation tools of public policies, combining accounting and financial analysis with the tools of econometric analysis, or why not, digital in a more distant future. And you have just mentioned all the consequences on your action and your work that the ongoing digital revolution will produce, it is indeed essential to seize it.

For I believe very deeply that if certain tedious tasks, which have already been largely alleviated, can be modified in this way, it is to another form of control that we will have to proceed, as you mentioned, but control will not be diluted in innovation, and data, even in large quantities, must not indeed dilute the mechanisms of responsibility that are at the very foundations, not only of public action but of democracy.

These challenges will undoubtedly require increasingly seasoned profiles, and that is why management experience will increasingly be at the heart of the required know-how, technical expertise in certain areas as well. The multiplication of back-and-forth exchanges between the Court and the active administration is thus a natural perspective for magistrates, and what is true for the Court is no less true for the regional Chambers, whose action I salute here.

Performance can no longer be a taboo of public service, it is a duty towards users, towards taxpayers, but also towards public agents who aspire to be recognized in excellence and supported in difficulty; the measurement of performance and the definition of public policy objectives thus primarily involves a vast work of defining indicators to answer the essential question of the objective we assign to the action thus conducted.

That is why I asked the Prime Minister, within the framework of Public Action 2022, to make proposals so that a framework for the development and publication of performance indicators for all administrations is defined before the end of the year, in connection with representatives of civil servants and users. Do not be mistaken, this is not a culture of performance for its own sake that we are aiming for, that would not make sense, and it is not what I committed to, but it is to reconnect with the culture of service, for one always serves someone, and it is the right one to measure it.

And so, to think of defending the culture of service without ever asking the citizen user what they think of it, what they see, what they measure, is in a way to lose its foundations. This is the spirit of the bill for a State at the service of a society of trust currently defended by the Minister of Action and Public Accounts before Parliament, which will notably establish the right to make mistakes, on which I had committed, but a new form of relationship between the administration and our fellow citizens, restoring trust, changing the modalities of the first control, the daily relationship and valuing, giving a legal basis to these indicators that I have just mentioned.

In this evolution of mindsets, senior officials, the great bodies, like yours, will have an increased responsibility and duty of exemplarity. If the senior executives of the State do not embrace this transformation project, it will go nowhere. For this, I wish for a reform of the public service, and particularly of the senior public service, to accompany the movement, not a reform conducted under somewhat populist towers, as we have sometimes seen in recent days, which would consist of making lists of salaries, for people to go and make lists of salaries in the private sector for comparable responsibilities; it is simply wanting to finish driving away, in certain areas of State activity, the talents we want to attract back there. No, it is about having a fully established framework of responsibilities that we bring to life, but also being able to rebuild careers, the meaning of those careers, which makes our senior public service the place of excellence that it is today but must continue to be tomorrow.

An attractive sector for the talents of our economy, with a clear ethical framework allowing the transition between the public and private sectors, but which will enable us to carry out the public action we desire with the required vigor. I believe in this reform of the senior public service, essential, because we need to give, as I said, more maneuverability to our senior officials in positions of responsibility, because, in central administration, as well as in the field, we need to give clarified responsibilities, redeployed resources to those who lead public action.

That is also why I deeply wish for officials from the great bodies to engage with reality, to choose difficult positions, to meet the challenges of the field at every stage of their careers. In this context, I wish for the exit from ENA, as well as the career during the first years of service, to be modified to take into account government priorities. You have wonderful talents; we just saw them in front of you a moment ago. You need them – I know – for your essential evaluation work, but public action needs them to renovate Education, Housing, Social Affairs, of which the ministers tell me they have resource problems. Therefore, we cannot continue to have the same recruitment rites and the same rites of passage.

In this regard, we must profoundly change career entry points and the beginnings of careers, knowing how to value these moments of campaigns; they are not military, but they are at the heart of public action. In other times, when our country was at war, it knew how to do it. There is a form of war against complacency, languor, habits of failure, or incompetence. I deeply believe that we can modify and transform public action profoundly; we just need to give ourselves the means to do so. This is what I have asked the Prime Minister to do.

The interministerial committees for public transformation will be the opportunity to announce more precisely the axes of this transformation and to outline the concrete measures. You will have understood, I assign to Public Finances a new use and a new path, and this path is difficult; I do not underestimate it, but I believe we can collectively rise to the challenge if each and every one of us, within our competencies, takes our responsibilities. And my political concerns align with your strategic reflections because we have this in common: our commitment is exclusively in service of our fellow citizens and of France.

So, I do not know if the geographical writing of Julien Gracq in "Le rivage des Syrtes," sometimes relishing a strange conflict, corresponds to this moment of our Republic. I believe it is rather a moral of action that we need to follow, less aesthetic, because we must not get used to this strange conflict, to this invisible enemy, and to the generosities of life that can accompany these periods. It is a daily struggle; it is not, I assure you, that of Sisyphus, because I think that – and many examples around us show it – I believe that if we have this moral of action, this demand for public transformation together, if we do not get used to anything, but with realistic determination, let us decide to act and to hold firm, we can do it collectively.

That is what I wished to say, Mr. President, Ladies and Gentlemen, this morning, hoping that this exchange will be followed by many others, nourished by the same freedom of tone and the same concern for our country. And as the year opens, as you reminded us, there is still time to extend our wishes. I spoke of the moral of action; there is a philosopher dear to me who loved action, it was Alain, and I have had the opportunity to recall it a few times. He had, in what we call his remarks, but which were his life notebook, one of those moments when the year turned on its hinges, a phrase to say that we must never despair; we must think of spring.

So, I do not know if it will be next year the spring of evaluation that I mentioned, but let us think of spring, knowing that this spring is made, is crafted at all times of the year, that this spring is the fruit of action. Alain spoke of the action of nature that we do not see budding when the trees make lace in January but which works underground. It is this same work that we have to carry out for our State, our public action, which will allow not only to think of spring but to make it happen, and I hope it can be done in the years to come. Thank you.