Speech by the President of the Republic at the international meeting for peace of the Sant'Egidio community.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

22 September 2024 · International meeting for peace of the Sant'Egidio community

Context
Macron addressed the Sant'Egidio international meeting for peace in Paris on September 22, 2024, reflecting on global conflicts and the challenge of imagining peace.
Main themes
Peace and war, interfaith dialogue, conflict mediation, global conflicts, Ukraine war, Gaza and Middle East, terrorism, nationalism and imperialism, climate change, hope and solidarity, moral legacy of the 20th century, Sant'Egidio community
Duration
~32 min
84th percentile
Words
3,804
84th percentile
Sentences
171
85th percentile
Readability
55
77th percentile
Grade
11.0
32nd percentile
Syntax
3.18
70th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
20th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 55%49%
  • Social 23%20%
  • Ceremonial 13%12%
  • Institutional 5%4%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Environmental 1%1%
  • Economic 0%0%
  • Not in focus 11%

171 sentences in 34 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, in your ranks and qualities,

I want to tell you how happy and proud we are to welcome you all for your work. And I want to thank my friends from the Sant’Egidio community, Mr. President, Mr. Founder, dear Andrea, for this initiative and to express the immense pride we have in having you here and being able to reflect together. Coming from all continents, from all religions, and bringing together our youth.

Dear Andrea, I considered you a friend, and asking me to come and speak to conclude such a panel is obviously more than a challenge, because pretty much everything has been said. And the most relevant things.

But I must say that nevertheless, you offer me a unique opportunity in the life of a contemporary leader, which is that where so much of our time is dedicated to imagining possible forms of wars and innovations to wage war, you invite me to speak for a few moments to imagine peace. And so thank you immensely for this breath of fresh air.

The question is whether the norm should not, in fact, be reversed. I thank you for being here, as I mentioned, and we were together two years ago in Rome, where the idea was born, but beyond the honor I mentioned, I believe it is a return to the roots for you.

Tradition tells us that your tutelary figure, Sant’Egidio, lived in France in the 6th century, and this return to the roots, paradoxically, is a first since 1968. And Paris, as Madame Mayor admirably recalled, as did Monsignor Ulrich, is a city deeply attached to peace. Because it has been profoundly marked by wars, repeatedly, over the centuries. And there have not always been Saints Genevieves in history to protect our capital from the Huns; sometimes we were taken, then liberated, and we celebrated and commemorated together, a few weeks ago, the 80th anniversary of the liberation of Paris.

So here you are, to imagine and work together, to imagine peace, in a context, as you have recalled, where war is returning at an unprecedented level.

About fifty conflicts are recorded around the world. The return of war to our European continent, for more than 10 years now, in truth. But in a particularly intense form since February 2022. A terrible war in the Middle East, since the terrorist attacks by Hamas on October 7, followed by the bombings on Gaza that are being carried out, and the war in Gaza is now in southern Lebanon. And from the Great Lakes of Africa to so many regions of the world.

War seems to be lurking again, challenging the moral and political legacy that was ours and emerged from the 20th century, and shows how much the peace we are talking about today is the true struggle. And it is the one you have been leading from the beginning. The one that through dialogue, mediation, from Mozambique to so many places, has made your success and fully justifies the calls of Chief Rabbi Korsia, just a moment ago.

Nevertheless, even as war returns in all its forms and is, moreover, the result of nationalist imperialism, of terrorist movements, even as it sometimes occurs, as you said, in the name of religions, which is a consequence of contemporary disruption, whether climatic or technological, there are sources of hope. Those through which unanimity is formed that allows us to build the great agreements that we still know how to find, such as indeed that for the climate. What we saw a few weeks ago right here in Paris. Around these Olympic and Paralympic Games, the one that Monsignor Ulrich mentioned, that we have all seen over the past 5 years around the reconstruction of Notre Dame.

And so, yes, we are still capable of carrying great illusions, of leading great just struggles, which allow us to circumvent war, which allow us to put it in parentheses or at least to build something positive. So much has been said since earlier, and I have a very well-prepared speech that has been given to me, but I will not repeat what has been said.

I was trying, while listening to you, to reflect, and I had just a few remarks that I wanted to make. Indeed, imagining peace seems to be a challenge because peace is something much more precarious and apparently less justified than war. Let us think, a war when it is waged, with the limits you mentioned, because at the moment it is launched, one thinks one can stop it at any moment, war always has a very strong legitimacy; it corrects an injustice. War is waged to regain territory that has been taken, and whether it relies on historical revisionism or ethnic purity, it is strong in a deep justification. War is sometimes holy, as you said. And so there is an extreme force in war, and the more war advances, the more its force is there. For certainly, if the weariness of the combatants may set in, the martyrs of war justify it more and more each day.

To yield something to war is to betray those who fought alongside us yesterday. In contrast, peace has a form of ontological precarity, because it is made of renunciation.

And because peace is unstable, at the very moment when one is plunged into a conflict, it is the most difficult thing to think about, because it is what most contravenes our daily lives. Making peace is to betray. Making peace is not to honor all those who have fallen for a cause alongside which we stood and which justified this struggle. Making peace is to renounce something that justified the beginning of hostilities.

That is why indeed, we spoke together two years ago, of a peace that is always impure, of something that is achieved through compromises, through acceptances. But peace is always infinitely more fragile in this, even from the moment the second the war has returned.

This is all the more true in the world we live in, because this world is fundamentally made of a tyranny of negative emotion. I have often said this in recent years, and the more I practice the charge that has been entrusted to me, the more I am convinced of it. We live in a world where, precisely, the ability to dialogue, to think and build peace or useful things is threatened because more and more of our compatriots, but our planet, all of us, live in a space, in a public order where the hierarchy of things has changed. It is a digital public order where many things are determined and where argumentation is always weaker than emotion and where negative emotion is always more powerful than positive emotion. If you take this order of merit as it is being established in the world, nothing is more powerful to move things than negative emotion. This order, which prevails in our social networks, is a formidable instrument of war. It is a formidable lever to never be able to imagine peace. For every day of a war, a negative image occurs that justifies continuing it. For every day, in societies where the climate of war, to paraphrase dear Andrea, there are images that justify no longer being able to accept the other, no longer being able to tolerate these unbearable images. What was a violence, a part of evil that has always existed in our societies, because it spreads through this, because it is shown in this form, becomes unbearable, relentless, and fundamentally does not allow reopening things.

So in the face of this, imagining peace is a strange challenge. It seems to me that there are at least three things we must do.

The first is a question of perspective. Several of you have said it, I believe it was the Chief Rabbi who spoke of humanist obsession. You have obviously, on several occasions, spoken of respect, of dignity, but I have been struck in recent years and I am struck in our societies to see how much war takes root in dehumanization, and that is what nourishes it. There is in our societies today a capacity that rests precisely on this clamor, this rise of negative emotions, on ignorance, on the separation that is gradually taking place to dehumanize the other or the foreigner and even more the enemy.

A few days after the terrorist attack on October 7, while the bombings had already begun on Gaza, I met with the teams of UNRWA and several, as one can imagine, were devastated, some of their colleagues having already been killed. When I asked them: "But how can we get to this point?", several had come fifteen years, twenty years before to the territory of Gaza and told me - returning a few months, sometimes for some, just a few years before these terrible terrorist acts and this war -: "What struck us the most is that twenty years ago, in Gaza, there was not a Palestinian family that did not speak Hebrew and that in the neighboring colonies, there was not a family that did not speak Arabic." They knew each other, they understood each other, they spoke their language and fundamentally, behind the rivalries, sometimes the hatreds that had settled, there was the knowledge of the other, the respect, the patience of a culture, that perspective. And several of them told me: "When we returned, they no longer knew each other." Where in Gaza, which is undoubtedly one of the youngest territories on our planet, all these young people born in recent years no longer speak Hebrew. And on the other side, all the young Israelis who are there no longer speak, do not know the Palestinians. They have become for each other, not simply the foreigner, perhaps what was the enemy for their parents, but beasts. A slow, insidious process of dehumanization has taken place.

It is the same process that we see at work in our societies when there is the essentialization of some of our citizens because they are Jewish and that, in doing so, their humanity is denied. Because everything simplifies, everything collapses. This unbearable conflict, this atrocious war whose images we see, they are responsible for it. We no longer look at their faces. And such a student, such another in the street, you said it, Monsignor, just a moment ago with very strong words, speaking of young demonstrators, and we see it, denies the humanity of the other.

I believe that the first duty to be able to begin, is even before imagining peace, this need to rehumanize and therefore to know, to understand, to have the patience, to look, to learn the language. And this path, it seems so trivial, is essential: everywhere we have the weak signals of this, the drama is already there and announces itself and war becomes unstoppable. So, everywhere we can – and the religions you represent here play a fundamental role in this regard, and France is honored to help them, particularly in the Middle East – everywhere we can save a school, protect a class, we save a bit of this possible path. The perspective, then, rehumanize first.

The second thing is coexistence and recognition. Fundamentally, when we wage a war, it is because we want to eliminate the other because he has become unbearable, either in my place or in a place I consider to be mine, or in a territory that belonged to me and that he has taken, or next to it. Ultimately, not so many solutions; if contemporary technologies and some spirits of the moment can tell you: "there are other much simpler solutions," some tell you: "don't waste time with all that, we are going to Mars."

This exists, some carry it with great strength. It is striking, by the way, in these movements that can be philosophical, libertarian, in what several entrepreneurs, including the most renowned, carry, on which sometimes you communicate, but who have other projects. Their grand project is Mars: that says a lot of things, notably let us no longer bother with these wars, with the ability to coexist or with the place of the other, we will find a new space. We who do not know how to build peace in such a small space as Gaza, for sure, we will conquer another planet and do something much more harmonious.

A solution in which I do not believe much, as you have understood. There is another solution which is to totally destroy the enemy. When one starts a war, in order to stop it, one must destroy the other. Obviously, with the moral collapse, the impossibility and often the exhaustion that goes with it. Like you, I have seen many leaders, dear Mario, in recent years, telling me: "I stop when I want, I finish when I want," and they are still there to talk about these wars.

Peace is only possible when each party in the war understands that it will be necessary to find a path of coexistence and recognition, that is to say that in a given space, with the impurities mentioned, nothing will be perfect. I will recognize the right to live of the one who has until now been my enemy, his possibility of being, and we will have to, if not live together in harmony, inhabit there. And for what is at stake today in the Middle East, that is the key. All those who explain and make anyone believe that the solution lies in the destruction of the other create eternal war.

Peace is only possible through coexistence and therefore in what is most difficult. In that moment, there will be a place, a land, a state, coexistence, the recognition of each other's existence, the recognition of each person's right to live in peace. And this is true in all those spaces where war has taken hold. This need for recognition, this necessity for coexistence and acknowledgment is essential to begin to imagine peace. And it is often because, precisely considering the order of merit that I mentioned, the negative emotion is always there and prevails, that the capacity to imagine, to even endure the imbalance that comes with coexistence, is diminished. What could be more difficult than living next to my enemy? Everyone believes there is a simpler solution, to destroy them, right?

This need to think, to build coexistence, the recognition that goes with it, in doing so, to accept the face of the other. The existence and place of the enemy is indispensable. And that is why, and this is my third and final point, imagination is so important.

Two years ago, we were shouting in Rome, it was the cry for peace. There, you invite us to imagine, and that is much more difficult. But I wanted to try, with you, to reflect on what lies behind the verb you have chosen. Precisely, to imagine is not to replicate. You referred to those very beautiful lectures that were recently republished by Paul Ricœur, which he gave in Chicago during difficult years for him, where he delivered this long course on imagination. One of the great distinctions around which he builds his course on imagination—he does it in English, it’s in Chicago—is between picture and fiction. Imagination is on the side of fiction, meaning an image that we invent, a capacity to have a dynamic, poetic, and practical mediation, he says. Where picture is the image, the copy, something that reproduces what has already been and serves as a reference point. What I mean by this is that imagination is a function of representation, but very different from the one by which we copy or reproduce. It builds an image in which we can find ourselves, in which reality will have elements of resemblance, of harmony. But it is eminently new, dynamic, and poetic. That is the strength of imagination, and that is what differentiates the copier from the creator.

I believe that the time we are living in, where there are many experts, is perhaps a time when we have too many copiers and not enough creators. Because we are always the experts of a past world by definition. Expertise is built on something that has already been. And we always think we will find the solutions for an unprecedented world by looking at what has been done in the past or by continuing the same rites, the same forms, the same things. I do not believe so. Worse still. By placing ourselves on the side of the copier, we nurture a form of nostalgia for something that has been, which we believe was happier. And I believe that the solution is not there. It is rather, indeed, you are right, on the side of imagination, and we see it in many of our societies that are caught in this climate of war. The response that is imposed rises everywhere in Europe, it is nostalgic. It is made through identity. I heard that word a lot. We have an identity, it is made of stories. It is much more a torrent that carries many different things than a fixity. But identity and the obsession with identity have something of the copier. The foreigner comes to jostle me. Modernity and its transitions come to jostle me. I respond to this climate of war with a copier's attitude. I will go and seek what I know, what has already been, what was there and reassures me.

Conversely, I believe that the audacity of the one who creates, who imagines, is indeed that of a dynamic will, of that power, of that dynamic, poetic, and practical mediation, to use Ricoeur's terms. This is in continuity with Searle as well, who says to himself, I will think of something new that, while obviously respecting the tradition of where I am, helps me to think of the new. That is why imagination is indeed indispensable to peace. There can be no nostalgia for peace because peace, by definition, emerging from a war that did not exist before, can only proceed from something new that sweeps it away, and it is therefore a function of imagination, the capacity to perhaps find compromises, new solutions, but it is a will to transcend towards the new. And having the strength to imagine peace is therefore to place oneself indeed on the side of imagined peace rather than nostalgic peace, of will rather than identity, of a taste for the future rather than an obsession with the past, so many of our wars being nourished by an obsession with the past, even a fantasized past. Imagining peace is therefore to build new forms, territorial, organizational, conceptual, ethical. You said it, Mr. Permanent Secretary, when speaking of our innovations, without which we will not be able to end these wars. And that is why, and I will conclude on this point, we indeed have a tremendous need for imagination today. After all, our continent, emerging from the most terrible conflict it has ever known and the moral collapse that followed the Holocaust and the worst civil war in Europe, was able to imagine. We imagined Europe, which is the most unprecedented creation there is, a non-hegemonic political creation, building peace and prosperity, mutualizing what had previously led France and Germany to war, starting with coal and steel, the two weapons of destruction. There was nothing bolder. All the experts at the end of World War II. Madness. Never do that. The cautious would have said never do that, the war will return. The educated rightly said: you are fools. It took imaginative people to think of this European peace. We need to be sufficiently imaginative to think of the peace of tomorrow. A peace in Europe in a new form. Who will think with it, forgive me, Your Excellency, this is not insolence, but a coincidence, the possibility of across the Channel, reconciliation with the Balkans and the reality of a Europe in its geographical form that is neither quite the European Union nor resolutely NATO. We are trying to move forward with this European political community, but we will need to think of a new form of organization for Europe and rethink our relationship with Russia afterwards and with peace on this continent.

And in the same way, as you said, we have to build a new international order. This is undoubtedly the greatest challenge of the moment, because our order today is incomplete and unjust. It is incomplete because it was conceived at the end of World War II and therefore did not have at its heart concerns that later emerged and became predominant: climate, obviously, is one, the technological revolution is another. And so many countries tell us: you ask us to choose between development and climate, you give us contradictory demands in a way.

And then the second thing is that most countries on the planet and many of the most populous countries did not exist when the seats were distributed. And so the international order in which we operate today, which is blocked as everyone can see, I will return to this at the UN this week, is unjust because it is not representative. And so we need, to imagine peace, to conceive of an order that allows us to think all together about issues of peace and war, issues of development, technological issues, climate and planetary issues, without priorities. This is what we tried to do with the Paris Pact for peoples and the planet. And it must be done in an order where one or another cannot block the others and where countries are represented with dignity. So to do it with much fairer bodies, whether it be the United Nations, the World Bank, or the International Monetary Fund. This contributes to this necessity, indeed, to imagine peace. Those were the few remarks I wanted to make this afternoon alongside you.

And after all, ladies and gentlemen, dear presidents, dear friends, dear Andrea, after having been indignant, allow me to thank you for allowing me, alongside you, modestly, to try to imagine peace. I do not know if we will succeed, but we have this duty. I have confidence that the debt we owe to those who allow us to be here, in peace today, and the debt we incur towards all the young people like you, Madam, who are here today to testify and who have lived and continue to live in your flesh the war, is to be tireless builders of peace, and therefore to imagine every day the paths, even the most difficult, to make it possible.

Thank you very much!