Speech on the occasion of the reception in honor of the Pritzker Prize winners

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

24 May 2019 · Reception in honor of the Pritzker Prize winners · Élysée Palace, France

Context
Macron addressed Pritzker Prize laureates and architects at the Élysée Palace in May 2019, welcoming them to France for the prize ceremony held at Versailles.
Main themes
Architecture as political art, Pritzker Prize ceremony, living spaces and society, architectural heritage and history, modernity and innovation, urban design, cultural identity, Arata Isozaki laureate recognition, French architecture, memory and time in architecture
Duration
~36 min
88th percentile
Words
4,340
88th percentile
Sentences
155
82nd percentile
Readability
43
43rd percentile
Grade
14.2
68th percentile
Syntax
3.20
72nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.27
65th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 55%43%
  • Ceremonial 25%19%
  • Institutional 9%7%
  • Geopolitical 5%4%
  • Economic 3%2%
  • Environmental 3%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 23%

155 sentences in 30 paragraphs

Mr. Minister,

Mr. President of the Pritzker Organization, Dear Thomas Pritzker,

Mr. President of the Jury, Dear Stephen Breyer,

Mr. 2019 Pritzker Laureate, Dear Arata Isozaki,

Ladies and Gentlemen, architects,

Ladies and Gentlemen,

I am aware of the risk one takes in inviting an assembly like yours to the Élysée because the venue is immediately considered in its architectural and symbolic dimension; moreover, for those who are accustomed to attending the Pritzker Prize ceremonies, the locations must always be exceptional, and the expert's or artist's eye reconsiders and scrutinizes it, thus the risk taken in showing you this restored ballroom is significant.

But more broadly, I wanted to welcome you all here, along with French and international architecture, to share with you some convictions on this day, which is also somewhat special for French democracy. And I am very pleased that the organizers of the Pritzker Prize have chosen France for the award ceremony this year.

Thank you, dear Thomas Pritzker, for continuing with talent the work of your parents, thank you for your unwavering commitment to architecture, that is to say, in favor of our housing, our neighborhoods, our monuments, our cities, in short, the world in which we live. And I believe that you could not have chosen a better place than Versailles this year to host your event, and that is also why I wanted to welcome you for this interlude at the Élysée to both congratulate this year's laureate and to share a few words about architecture.

Among you are some of the best architects from around the world and so many former Pritzker laureates, and I want to extend a special greeting to the two French recipients present here, Christian de Portzamparc and Jean Nouvel, and I also want to honor the memory of Yao Ming Pei, who left us a few days ago; he too received the Pritzker Prize, in 1983, and he also left his mark on many cities, but particularly the city of Paris with a place that is especially dear to me and that, at the time, also had the audacity of modernity and innovation despite much criticism in a place that seemed it should not be touched at all.

All of you here are among those who design and shape our world, who give it its contemporary face, who invent the ways of life of today and tomorrow, our ways of occupying space, inhabiting places, living together. In a word, being in the world, for you create works that have this particularity that they are not only creations to be contemplated, but they are indeed lived works, sometimes transforming with use, that we traverse, that we inhabit, in which we learn, we work, we meet, which can lead to rediscovering places to which we had become accustomed, where we move and are moved. And thus, designing living spaces at the intersection of geographical, economic, and technical constraints, both as engineers, artists, and citizens; creating places that inspire us, that help us work, think, and gather. I believe there is not much art that is more political than yours in the strictest sense of the term. Being an architect is to be the one who decides to organize life in the city, the one who does politics in the most trivial sense of the term, the one who tries to define its rules. When the rules do not correspond to the places, difficulties arise. When the places no longer correspond to the rules or uses, misfortune can settle in. And that is why your art is perhaps the most fundamental and the most political of all. It certainly responds to a necessity or utility, it fulfills a function, but it must at the same time always bring its vision of an organization of society, of this living together, of this other world I mentioned. And it is the most visible, most material, and most accessible manifestation of our art and our culture. It is an art in which we live and that we do not move. Because architecture is human history as it is written in stone and wood, in marble and iron, in steel and glass, perhaps in earth and straw tomorrow; it is this dialogue of times that is written in space, and it is, I would say, also a way for us not only to be in space but in our relationship to time. The architecture of a country is the palimpsest of its history. And for the nations that we are, it is about working with a space that is already occupied by existing architecture, except in rare occasions, by already existing uses, by already existing places, whether they are happy or broken. And thus, it is always something to do with the most extreme contemporary and the sedimentation of centuries. And we read our past, our identity in open books, and this imposes a certain humility on us, reminding us that we belong to a great human chain that attempts from generation to generation to make the world a place worth inhabiting.

So, dear Arata Isozaki, you have been distinguished by your peers this year for illustrating this art with rare talent. You thus join the illustrious lineage of Pritzker Prize laureates while also being part of a nation that has given birth to some of the best architects in the world, as you are the 8th Japanese to receive this prize, making your country the most awarded alongside the United States. And fundamentally, your vocation begins in a form of paradox. Many, and sometimes some in this room, claim to have come to architecture through the discovery of a monument, an experience, a place, an emotion, and I believe I can say under your control that your foundational relationship with architecture was first the observation of desolation. For you were a very young teenager when the war devastated your country, when Hiroshima and Nagasaki were bombed, when your hometown was burned, and all around you were nothing but ruins. There was nothing left, only rubble and remnants, and you said your first experience of architecture was paradoxically that of an absence of architecture, of a void, of a need. And it is precisely thus confronted with a tabula rasa that you asked yourself how your country could rebuild, reconstruct its houses and cities, and this is undoubtedly the burning, I would say, vital source of your vocation. You began your career under the best auspices of Kenzō Tange, the first Japanese Pritzker laureate, who passed on to you his taste for purity, his sense of scale and harmony. And it was in 1963 that you founded your agency. Japan had regained its sovereignty and was seeking to rise again. There was no shortage of work. And you first built buildings in your hometown, then in several other cities in Japan.

And very quickly, you became one of the first Japanese architects to build beyond the borders of your country in the United States, Spain, Australia, China, Italy, Vietnam; in 60 years of career, you have designed more than 100 buildings with very varied functions: libraries, museums, office towers, event or convention centers, hotels, and never, never have you repeated yourself. You have always been able to imagine different forms and styles, to vary materials, lines, and colors. In a way, as a chameleon architect, you adapt to sites, shades, tones, and the energy of places. You thus move from the red brick of the Museum of Contemporary Art in Los Angeles, which responds to the sun of the city, to the gleaming titanium of the superb hard Tower in Mito, a twisted, soaring, and sparkling metal tower. You are responsible for the playful and colorful gaiety of the Walt Disney World Resort headquarters in Orlando. But on the other side, the seriousness of the Alliance Tower in Milan. The geometric purity of the Turin Sports Palace, the imposing National Convention Center in Doha, Qatar, with its spectacular entrance representing jujube trees, these trees of the Qatari desert that support here a canopy roof, so many other places. You are not a man of one way, but an architect who invents a new perspective for each new project with the guiding thread of a style, your own. Your work has thus constantly evolved throughout your career, according to the places, the projects, the various currents that have inspired you, and you have constantly sought from the very first years to establish a new and fruitful architectural dialogue between the West and the East, building both in Japan and abroad and complementarily drawing on the deep philosophies of geographies, and being perhaps one of the first truly international architects, your works have also sought to be bridges between cultures and peoples. Your crowning, dear Arata Isozaki, is also, as I said, that of a nation, Japan, which has managed to produce an exceptional lineage of architects and which is today one of the most creative in this field.

Our country knows this well, and if it has never had the chance to be your field of expression, it has singularly opened up to the talents of your contemporaries and compatriots to rethink these cities and these buildings. The Centre Pompidou-Metz and the musical scene of Boulogne-Billancourt: Shigeru Ban, Pritzker Prize 2014, with Jean de Gastines. The Louvre-Lens and the new Samaritaine: Kazuyo Sejima and Ryūe Nishizawa, Pritzker Prize 2010. The former Paris Bourse de commerce, which will soon house contemporary art collections: Tadao Ando, Pritzker Prize 95. The Japanese garden of UNESCO: Isamu Noguchi; the "Thousand Trees" project, this project of a forest building that reconciles urban architecture and nature: Sou Fujimoto with the Frenchman Manal Rachdi, so many examples of our openness to your architecture.

And this long list, which is far from exhaustive, testifies to the fact that France has always opened itself to talents from elsewhere to design its spaces, shape its cities, build its monuments. This is true today and was true yesterday. During the Renaissance, when Boccador was invited to design the City Hall of Paris and Leonardo da Vinci participated in the construction of the Château de Chambord, which he would never see, but whose plans inspired; even in the neoclassical era, when we sought new sources of inspiration in Greek or Roman antiquity. The Church of La Madeleine, not far from here, as well as the Palais Bourbon, where our National Assembly sits, owe much to this Greek art, particularly to the Parthenon. There are so many places that have been inspired by architects from around the world. So many places that have welcomed architects from around the world for their achievements, for France is indeed a land of architects. Not only because we are a homeland that has trained generations of builders, not only because we have inherited one of the richest architectural heritages in the world and that we, as a people, are deeply proud and in love with it, but also precisely because we have always welcomed influences, talents, because by relying on our own genius, our history, our traditions, we have managed to open ourselves to the world and to the geniuses from elsewhere. This is the double thread of the history of French architecture, a bit of this art of being French that I mentioned earlier and that our architecture undoubtedly carries more than any other art in our country.

This is also why I want to take this moment, this solemn welcome, this bold thread that I have just woven to say a few words about our architecture today and about a great project that will be at the heart of debates and attention in France over the next five years. This project is obviously that of Notre-Dame de Paris.

I find that what has happened in France in recent weeks says a lot, emotionally, profoundly, about what I have just told you.

The emotion stirred in our country, among our compatriots, but well beyond, stirred in the whole world when the fire broke out. As soon as a building is alive, when a monument is part of everyone's life, both of a history, a representation, of its emotion and is not simply a series of dead stones, it fulfills an extremely important function on a cultural level.

It also becomes a place of civilization, of emotion, of relationship to others, to a city, to a continent, and the emotion that many have expressed to us shows what architecture can carry and signify. Many have told me they felt an unprecedented emotion and felt deeply European when seeing Notre-Dame burn and thinking they might never see it again. To have the emotion and the experience in front of such a part, such a reflection, such an angle of this cathedral. And all of humanity felt that day a terrible sense of losing a part of itself. The French, Europeans I believe, first and foremost. Fortunately, thanks to the admirable courage of the Paris firefighters, and at the same time thanks to the mobilization of the architects of Historical Monuments and all the professions of heritage conservation that we saw intervene with the minister, from the very first minutes, intervening and taking all the risks to save the treasures, protect the places, leaving its part to the fire so that the rest could be saved, this jewel was able to be saved, its structure preserved.

So very quickly, we were able to consider the future. And I confess, I wanted to do it that very evening because when difficult decisions are made, like those our firefighters made, to leave their part to the fire, that is when we manage to save that part of the building by taking all the risks; I believe we do not have the right to give way to affliction. And very quickly, the international community, the architects shared their reflections, their proposals with us, and the shock and desolation soon gave way to hope, to the effervescence of ideas, to the fervor of projects, to passionate debates about what must be done. So I know that many were concerned about my decision to carry out this work on a tight, ambitious schedule. And I fully accept it. And this decision was not based on any detailed analysis or any form of expertise, and I fully own it. It was primarily a will, because I deeply believe that at the base of any decision to do and to be able to do, there must be a will. It must be reasonable, achievable. But if the will becomes an expertise, we see it every day, quickly, we explain that nothing can be done anymore. And this will to do was not the negation of expertise; it was the profound decision not to leave any room for sadness, for despair, it consisted of saying to ourselves that within a perceptible, achievable horizon, given what the place was, we could rebuild. This five-year timeframe is possible. It is possible without ever compromising on the quality of materials and the quality of processes, because this ambition cannot do without excellence, know-how, and all that the professions will have to contribute to this endeavor.

And my conviction at heart, that is why this struggle is emblematic of what we have to carry out in our country and for contemporary architecture, is that we must trust the builders of today and we must trust ourselves. Very often, we take refuge behind texts and regulations because it is the fig leaf of distrust. But if the right people who know are there to do it, the best will be mobilized. It is a power to do that we activate and not a tree of impossibilities. And I believe that our citizens today need to see this and that we need to prove to ourselves that we can do this. And so yes, within five years, Notre-Dame will be restored, its frame and roof reconstructed because we have the knowledge, the techniques, the know-how that allow it.

And I said on the evening of the fire that we will build Notre-Dame even more beautifully by rethinking its surroundings: the forecourt, the square Jean XXIII, the promenade on the south side of the Île-de-la-Cité, in constant dialogue, particularly with the clergy and the City of Paris, and by relying on the work that has been done more than two years ago by several present here, and by giving it back a spire. My special representative on this file, General Georgelin, and the Minister of Culture, whom I thank for his unwavering commitment to this file since April 15, will ensure this. It is in this spirit and by broadening the project that we will carry out this endeavor. To accomplish this great work of restoration and reconstruction, we must proceed step by step with all the method that your profession is capable of, first allowing experts, architects of Historical Monuments, study offices, engineers, art historians, researchers, curators, restorers, to establish a solid diagnosis of the state of the cathedral. This has already begun with unprecedented enthusiasm. We must then mobilize all creators beyond borders, prolong and amplify the tremendous momentum of ideas for projects that I mentioned.

This cathedral of all must not become the edifice of one alone. So I wish that within the framework of the international competition, groups of talents be formed, bringing together both contemporary architects and architects of Historical Monuments, artists and researchers, historians and sociologists, experienced personalities and younger ones full of promise as well, because in this ability to trust ourselves and to trust, we must not forget that the monuments we admire today were often made by very young architects. Renzo Piano was 27 years old when he designed the Centre Pompidou. Louis Le Vau was barely 30 when he imagined his first grand private hotels. And we must also regain this trust in the future, in imagination, in innovation. And I believe that is what Viollet-le-Duc did in his time. Both to restore the cathedral, to give it back the luster and beauty it could have had in the Middle Ages, and to complete the edifice by infusing it with the innovations allowed by the techniques and culture of the time. For Viollet-le-Duc, there was no quarrel between the Ancients and the Moderns. No. An alliance of tradition and modernity. A respectful audacity. An inventive restoration and reconstruction.

And I deeply believe that this alliance of tradition and modernity, which simply corresponds to the way history is written, to the way the genius of humanity is inscribed in time and space, is what we owe to ourselves.

Ladies and gentlemen, there are many projects I would like to mention, but I know you are expected in Versailles and time would be lacking for me, but beyond this project, I am deeply convinced that many of the problems we have in our democracies, which we have often tried to solve in an organizational or institutional manner, find their solutions in the organization of space and therefore in and through the work of the architect, the urban planner, the creator. I will not speak tonight due to lack of time, and I will return to it in a few weeks about what has long been called the "Grand Paris," an essential project in which I deeply believe. This project has long been bogged down in administrative-political quarrels and the desires of each to preserve their share of space or power. One of you, Roland Castro, handed me a report a few months ago to help rethink it. And what I wish to propose to the Nation, drawing on what this experience of Notre-Dame has inspired in us, is that we can rethink our major projects for organizing living space, not just Greater Paris, but Greater Marseille, Greater Lyon. The projects that in many of our cities or spaces of the Republic allow us to weave back together urban organization through great contemporary architectural projects, where fractures have settled and where things have not been rethought. And to move beyond futile institutional debates to rethink very deeply how to suture spaces that have been deconstructed. To reinvent perspectives that until now did not exist, ways of being in the city, as I mentioned earlier. Convinced very deeply, and I will conclude on this, that architecture today must allow us, and that is what we wish to do with the minister, to respond to the heart of some contemporary challenges that are ours. When I look at what has crossed France in recent months and what will continue to cross us for years and decades and what crosses many democracies, it is fundamentally the uninhabitable nature of the world that is ours. Very often, we have built our space without thinking about our space. And it has been constructed as if groping through direct or indirect choices. And the last twenty years have led to more and more people moving to metropolises, that insecurity has settled in spaces that were depopulating. And then we built, because it was the choices of the moment, somewhat dense urban spaces, less than in other countries, and then housing developments. We created these extensions on either side. The taste then turned to mass consumption, so we created these scars that are commercial or logistical structures at the edge of these cities. We deserted our city centers. We have gradually unraveled the habitable space and too often installed the "ugly" in our nation, at least solitude, and we have created a daily life for which we neither conceived the terms nor thought through all the consequences. What we have had to experience are the consequences of a world that has become uninhabitable. It is the daily life of someone who has gradually been pushed 40 km from where they work without public transport and who has no other solution than to take an increasingly expensive vehicle, to pay for increasingly expensive fuel, etc. And so, in what we have called this social and territorial fracture, we must rethink how to inhabit our space and compose it.

But the second contemporary challenge that some have sometimes wanted to oppose is this anxiety that our youth expressed again this morning while marching in the streets of Europe. The climate anxiety. And if the world is becoming less and less habitable for them, it is because it seems to them that our behaviors, our organization no longer allow us to face the climate challenges, lead to maintaining them, to aggravating them, because we do not provide them in their daily lives with the solutions to live with it and that the city thus constructed, the habitat thus conceived, are less and less adapted to this warming world, to these changing uses. And we can see it clearly. The two main challenges we have to live with, with which we have to cope, to which we try to respond through rules, new norms, changes in habits, is this necessity to make our world habitable again and respectful of the future. The heart of the political challenge that is ours is architectural; it is to rebuild and reorganize life together differently and to rethink these spaces to recreate cohesion, to make them beautiful for everyone and to allow movement, to live differently in this rethought space.

And so, the challenge is not simply aesthetic, as I mentioned in my introduction; it is today perhaps more than ever eminently political. Because these two great contemporary battles that I mentioned require an architectural thought, an architectural and urban organization, research, and creation that are profoundly different from what we have sometimes done gropingly. They must also create assemblies of this complexity to be able to think more broadly about the problems we face and therefore to know how to recreate this habitable world where our fellow citizens are increasingly confronted with global problems, think about the world, but want to be rooted, live in a place, and whose sensitive, aesthetic, and political experience is in this tension between what is palpable around me and the concerns of the world that I think about and live.

That is why the choice I made not only to have the pride of receiving the Pritzker Prize here but also to celebrate you and to welcome you all in this format was for me also a way of saying that in this new phase of the project, both national and European, that I want us to think about, the choice I made is to give architecture a very special place. Perhaps not the one that has always been given. Perhaps not simply a disciplinary, classic place, but at the level I just mentioned. We are a few days away from an important choice about Europe. And to build a true Europe, we will also need to talk about architecture.

A few days ago, I received about thirty intellectuals from all countries. We talked about values. We talked about concrete subjects. But in the end, Europe has always been made through places as well. The Agora is a place. The café is a place that is a unique component of European sociability. The university is a place, a way of being together that has also made Europe. We also need to invent the places of tomorrow's European democratic consciousness.

And so on each of these challenges, the task that is yours is no longer simply yours, but it will therefore be invited to express itself in order to participate in this movement that I wish our country could inspire, that is to say, to make this world livable and profoundly universal. A world rooted and aware of the stakes of the 21st century, where more and more people are moving, shifting, and thus reinventing what our civilization is, knowing how to rebuild with a great deal of humility, but with the right dose of audacity. I thank you and I congratulate you.