PRESS CONFERENCE of Emmanuel Macron and Jacinda Ardern

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

15 May 2019 · Meeting of the Christchurch Call to Action

Context
Macron and New Zealand PM Ardern held a joint press conference in Paris on May 15, 2019, launching the Christchurch Call to Action against online terrorism.
Main themes
Christchurch Call to Action, online terrorism and violent extremism, government-tech industry cooperation, social media regulation, counter-terrorism initiatives, internet safety, multilateral cooperation, Tech For Good, G7 and UN engagement, Franco-New Zealand partnership
Duration
~38 min
89th percentile
Words
4,588
89th percentile
Sentences
189
88th percentile
Readability
42
41st percentile
Grade
13.4
61st percentile
Syntax
2.94
40th percentile
Vocabulary
2.18
45th percentile

Translated from French

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

189 sentences in 60 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, welcome to you.

Madam Prime Minister, dear Jacinda,

The Prime Minister of New Zealand, Madam Jacinda ARDERN, and I have just co-chaired the meeting of the Christchurch Call to Action to eliminate terrorism and violent extremism online. Exactly two months after the terrorist attacks against the Muslim community in Christchurch, the heads of state and government from Jordan, Senegal, Indonesia, Norway, Canada, the United Kingdom, Ireland, and the President of the European Commission joined us for a working meeting with representatives from the internet industry and civil society. Companies such as Twitter, Microsoft, Google and YouTube, Facebook, Dailymotion, Qwant, and Amazon were represented at the highest level, along with the Wikimedia Foundation and the New Zealand and French civil societies of the internet. Beyond those present, several other companies and governments have already expressed their support for this initiative.

We all experienced two months ago, particularly in our country which has faced terrorist attacks, the pain that you may have felt. But you decided, Madam Prime Minister, to respond by taking action, and that is why I proposed to you a few weeks ago that we join our efforts, so that the initiative you had begun to combat online terrorism could align with the Tech For Good initiative launched last year by France, and that we could act together; this is what led to this call, this call to action.

And in this period where we also mourn the Easter attacks in Sri Lanka and our soldiers engaged on the front lines in the fight against terrorism, our goal was simple: that what happened in each of these places never happens again.

What happened in Christchurch was not just an abject terrorist attack. It is the transformation, once again, of the internet into a mad propaganda machine serving the fracture of our societies, the war of all against all, a goal sought by both far-right terrorists and Islamist terrorists.

We have long been engaged in this fight and we had the opportunity this afternoon to remind ourselves of it: a Franco-British plan was launched in June 2017 following the attacks in Great Britain right here; work from the Global International Forum to Counter Terrorism was then conducted; the Paris Call for Trust and Security in Cyberspace brought together 70 states and 300 organizations; Tech For Good last year began to address these issues; a European directive in 2018 was put forward to allow for the removal of terrorist content online, and we continue this work at the French and European levels, particularly with new actions.

But the goal of our joint initiative, and of this call that Madam Prime Minister will present in a few moments, was, on the one hand, to broaden the scope of mobilization:

We had representatives from all continents present, as I mentioned, Senegal, Indonesia, Canada beyond the Europeans already mentioned, and thus for the first time governments from around the world were gathered at this level with such strength.

Next, it is an approach that brings together both governments, civil societies, and internet actors, and thus is fully inclusive.

And above all, it is an approach that will be followed with concrete effects that we expect from each: there will be a technical follow-up starting in June in Aqaba, it is the initiative taken several months ago by the King of Jordan who was with us; we will then meet again and ensure a common secretariat for this initiative with all the actors; there will be the meeting in Biarritz and the G7 where we wish to adopt a Charter for an open and non-violent internet; and we will meet in this format – I hope even expanded – to take stock of concrete actions in September in New York on the sidelines of the United Nations.

We have therefore decided to act, and I must say that beyond this action I was very happy, Madam Prime Minister, once again to welcome you to Paris after your visit in the spring of 2018 and to tell you that, beyond the pain we have shared with you and your people, it is also the joy of seeing you again and the will to act strongly together. And that is why I was very proud and very happy to welcome you today. I give you the floor.

Jacinda ARDERN

(translation)

Thank you very much and again thank you for this welcome, thank you very much for collaborating with New Zealand. After a phone call about six weeks ago, we find ourselves here with an action plan to move forward with business leaders, leaders from different countries, gathered around a table, which shows the success of our cooperation. I want to thank you again. The attack on March 15 in Christchurch was an unprecedented event, meaning it used social media to spread this message of terrorism and extremism. 51 women and children from the Muslim community were killed, and their murder was broadcast online. The online broadcast was viewed by only a few hundred people, but then the video was shared at such speed that YouTube recorded one upload per second during the first 24 hours: the dimension of social media made this attack unprecedented.

Today we are responding with the adoption of the Christchurch Call to Action, which is also an unprecedented response. Never before have countries and internet companies reacted to an attack and committed to such an action plan, which will allow us to work together, to use new technologies, to develop new technologies so that our communities are safer. Today we have seen the first steps, the first steps of the call to action - Facebook has launched the movement with new rules on live streaming. These are first steps and we will seek to prevent social media from being used as tools for terrorism, so that they are instead used as factors of connection.

Furthermore, there is a sovereign fund from New Zealand that supports this call to action, a group of 55 funds representing 5 trillion New Zealand dollars, these sovereign funds that support the call to action by monitoring the behavior of companies and ensuring that these companies respect the commitments of the Christchurch Call. These funds will also raise their concerns with companies. Additionally, New Zealand internet service providers support this call to action, and we invite all organizations to contribute to the success of this call to action. Join us, today is the first day of change, as was said at the meeting by one of the companies, "today is the first day of a four-month period."

The Christchurch Call to Action is a roadmap focused on action. The internet giants have committed to implementing independent and collaborative measures, it is a 9-point commitment that I hope will lead to a transformation of social media to eradicate terrorism from these platforms. New research and strengthening of terms of use, the establishment of a crisis response mechanism, these are very concrete things, very pragmatic, very concrete and visible actions. Today marks exactly two months since the attack in Christchurch, the Christchurch Call to Action is an international response to an attack committed in one country, my country, but it is an attack that resonated around the world. We will seek to make our communities safer, this encourages us to work together in concert to achieve results. And above all, this call commits us to create a more humane internet, an internet that cannot be used hatefully by terrorists, and I am convinced that we can make progress through this call. Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

Thank you very much, Madam Prime Minister. We will now answer your questions.

Unidentified speaker

(translation)

This question is for both of you. Mark Zuckerberg was here last week and he is not participating in this meeting, what message does that send? There was also no representative from the United States even though they are participating in the G7, is this a message that shows there is not necessarily respect for the Muslim community?

Jacinda ARDERN

(translation)

I will let President MACRON speak specifically about the meeting he had with the CEO of Facebook. So of course today there were representatives from Facebook, they announced transformations of their platform, these are first steps and they support this call and endorse this call, they have adopted it. This was something very important, a very significant step for the Christchurch Call to Action.

Regarding the United States, you know the statement they made clearly shows that there is quite broad support for the Christchurch Call to Action. The United States supports the principles, there is a level of commitment, a level of support, and I think that this support clearly shows that everyone wants to eradicate terrorist and violent extremist content - and these are ambitions shared by the United States. We had a very good representation around the table, there were countries but also, and this was a novelty, companies. This was a very good thing, meaning that this meeting was very different, the approach was very different compared to the past. This is what has allowed us to move forward, and it is what will allow us to move forward in the future as well, and I think that this is something very important.

Emmanuel MACRON

As for Facebook, Mark Zuckerberg was indeed present in Paris last week. We had a long discussion and Facebook has been at the heart of many difficulties related to these issues, and we have seen it and we have clearly talked about it also regarding the different modalities of Facebook that have been used by terrorists in the context of attacks, or by hostage-takers. France has experienced a very specific case: fortunately, there were no victims, but a hostage-taker used the facilities of Facebook Live to showcase his actions.

Mark Zuckerberg first committed with his company to a real innovative cooperation with the French government, within the framework of this smart regulation that we wanted, meaning that he allowed the teams of the French regulator to come into the machine, share the most confidential information to see how we could – in order to combat terrorist content but also any form of hateful content or harassment methods that can sometimes lead to the use of Facebook – how we could better regulate. And we will indeed translate the fruits of this exchange and this intelligent regulation into a draft law that is being prepared by our parliamentarians. So there is work underway, he could not be with us today for very personal reasons but he had sent Nick CLEGG, who was present around the table and with whom we had a long discussion. And Facebook has also committed to a cooperation procedure with governments to deprive Facebook users of the live features when they are identified as dangerous, either by the platform or by governments that can signal it, which is a real advance compared to what we know. It is clear that we still need to go further, and the Christchurch Call goes in that direction, but I believe we would be unfair to Facebook if we let it be said that they have been indifferent or uncooperative following the initiatives taken.

Then, regarding the American administration, first of all, I see the progress that has been made since the summer of 2017. I was talking about the Franco-British initiative taken in June 2017, and I remember a G7 that followed where we did not manage to reach a common position. And the presence, particularly of Prime Minister TRUDEAU with us, is a strong element that shows that in the North American world, where, as you know, freedom of expression is a very strong, essential value, well, it is recognized that it is important, while protecting it, to move towards more regulation of the Internet, because we must create a public order of the Internet that allows for the free expression of ideas but also better regulation of content, especially when it comes to terrorism. And I believe that the presence of Prime Minister TRUDEAU during this period that Canada is experiencing - he is a few months away from elections - marks his personal commitment, the commitment of his country, and that was very important for us, and it shows that the entire North American world is also moving. Then, the American administration has expressed that it supports the objectives, that it will do everything to cooperate. It has not formally endorsed the Christchurch Call at this stage, but we will do everything to ensure that there can be a concrete and, I would say, more formal commitment. I consider that the progress already made, and the fact that the American administration deemed it important, while we were meeting, to say that it shares the objectives and the will is a very positive element.

Sam SCHECHNER

Hello, Sam SCHECHNER from the Wall Street Journal. How is the Christchurch Call and the commitments made different from previous commitments made against the spread of terrorist content? In three months, let’s say, specifically, what will have changed for digital actors and malicious individuals? Thank you.

Emmanuel MACRON

So, perhaps to start this time, in a very concrete way, the Christchurch Call is different in that it brings together, as I said, all the actors of the Internet, who are precisely co-responsible for the implementation of what we have decided today. Then, these commitments are part of the context, as I said, of continuous exchanges over the past two years with the private Internet sector and with heads of state and government, but what we wanted to do is go further. The ambition of the call we launched together allows, on the one hand, to be more precise, with clear commitments to remove terrorist content online, to allow us to expand what we have decided but which was strictly European within the framework of the directive and which now has a much broader geographical scope, since it includes, as I mentioned, New Zealand, Senegal, Indonesia, Canada. Then, because we are setting a common framework to guide the action of Internet operators in the fight against terrorist content, and they themselves have committed, I just gave an example for Facebook, to concrete actions to support the call.

The call today is an expansion of what has been done geographically in recent years, what we have done in (Europe?) European, now we have a real expansion and we are doing it in a much broader way, and then, in terms of method, we are involving Internet actors, free foundations, and civil society, and behind that, we have technical and political follow-up for this action. That’s why I detailed it in my introductory remarks. Based on this call, the leaders, the CTOs of the companies present with our technical teams will meet in Aqaba to see how to implement it very concretely, typically, how we ensure cooperative processes so that all governments that have signed the Christchurch Call can, as quickly as possible, alert a platform about an individual who is deemed to have a history or who is dangerous, what type of commitment the platform takes, how it implements it concretely. We will also have very concrete and technical questions: beyond all terrorist content and the commitments regarding the speed of removal by the platforms, how do we prevent this content from going viral? These are very technical exchanges we had this afternoon on the sidelines of our discussion, but you can ask a platform to remove all terrorist content or content that can be seen as terrorist, with sometimes this gray area, that is often the argument they oppose to us.

There is another way to do it as well: you can ask them to remove it within the hour, which is what we have been working on until now; there is another way to do it, which is to ask them to act on content that is starting to become viral, and therefore to have a much stronger action at that moment.

So now, based on this call, what we are going to define in this forum, in June, are the technical conditions to implement it, and there will be, in September, a meeting where we will do two things: we will list the concrete actions that have been taken based on today’s call, we will list the content removed based on the commitments made today, and we will try to expand the circle of companies and countries that join this call. So the main changes I see are the geographical expansion, the intensity of the relationship, including on a technical level; with Internet companies, and especially a follow-up mechanism, because we have decided, with the Prime Minister, to set up a permanent secretariat together to ensure follow-up, we will work very closely with the Jordanians, who launched the Aqaba process, and with the United Nations to be able to ensure the technical and political follow-up of all this.

Jacinda ARDERN

(translation)

Thank you. To build on what President MACRON said, it’s all about who and what, in particular. As the President said, it is unprecedented to have a call that involves Internet companies and countries. In the past, it was either one or the other, and sometimes, it was divergent. Today, together, we are committing to a common direction. Furthermore, the what, the what is different, the content. There are forums that exist, for example, the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism, a forum that revolves around the emergence and presence of ISIS. In the Christchurch Call, we talk about violent extremism and terrorism, about terrorist content, but we keep in mind that the ideology behind the Christchurch attack was much broader. It was an extremism, a violence, and so there is also a difference regarding the content. Moreover, the conclusions, the practice, what we are seeking is different. We talked about data, algorithms, research, the expectations around technological developments. We see that there is a role to be played by the GIFCT, the Global Internet Forum to Counter Terrorism. This forum has a role that should be expanded, and we had a very practical conversation about this today.

Furthermore, we are seeking to have a crisis response unit. If a new attack occurs, how do we ensure that we have a response unit to ensure that Internet companies can react properly? We can have a coordinated unit that can react immediately to remove content. National laws cannot really achieve this kind of results.

Unnamed speaker

(translation)

Hello, I come from the New Zealand Herald. You talked about the Christchurch attack. Can you guarantee that this Christchurch Call will pass the Christchurch test? Were the United States represented?

Jacinda ARDERN

(translation)

As I said earlier, we have had high-level contacts with the Americans, even today, and I hope that we will continue to work together in the future. We see it... The United States made a statement, and I do not have to speak on their behalf. I think their statement clearly shows that they support the principle of the call.

Regarding the Christchurch test, I am convinced that we must continue to be pragmatic. We are working today, this work will make a difference in the future. We know very well, since Facebook made a statement, that with their change of practices, terrorists will not be able to live stream an attack again. Of course, this is one element among many in our work. Obviously, we want to try to prevent attacks and avoid loss of life. That is why we also talked about the role of governments, governments that must try to eliminate radicalization, fight against ideologies of hate. These are even more thorny issues, but I am convinced that this is what the Christchurch test represents: can we eliminate live streaming, and above all, can we eliminate hate itself?

Emmanuel MACRON

Just a word to return to how, indeed, what has been said today could help prevent and pass the "Christchurch test." On the one hand, Madam Prime Minister just said it, the commitment made by Facebook clearly, given the characteristics of the terrorist, would have prevented him from using the Facebook Live feature.

But I believe that what needs to be seen very clearly regarding what we are advancing on, on terrorist content, the commitment made by the companies, today, who were around the table, is an immediate and permanent removal. The commitment we are going to expand by Facebook, which would have touched the specific case, is to better regulate live streaming and to move away from this ease of sensitive audiences, including this person. That is what we are doing on content that is strictly speaking terrorist and individuals defined as sensitive.

And then there is a whole other continent, which is hateful content or what can lead to these actions, which is this much more complex gray area that we are working on. And there, the forum we created will allow us to advance, and it’s all the discussion I mentioned earlier and that we have already had with Facebook, that is to say: typically, this person was led to this point, and indeed, it has been shown, because they had access online to racist content, which can be the case for anti-Semitic, racist, hateful content, promoting Islamist terrorism, so all forms of hateful content that can lead to acts of terrorism even if they are not defined as terrorist. It is on this subject that we must advance with intelligent regulation, because on this subject, the platforms rightly tell us: you cannot prohibit us from this, it is not terrorist. It is this gray area. First, there is what we prohibit in each of our countries by law, and then there is a new cooperation to be made with the platforms to allow, on the one hand, to define the responsibilities of the platforms when they convey or spread such hate speech. Then, there is to define the modes of cooperation that these platforms must have with governments, that is to say typically, when we have defined the characteristics in our laws on a legal level, to ensure that the platforms cooperate very quickly, remove this content, and allow us to identify those who disseminate it, which, in terms of prevention regarding what you have experienced, would have allowed, I think, to have effectiveness.

Unnamed female speaker

Mr. President, Madam Prime Minister, (---00:27:06) for Politico. The European regulation currently under discussion in Brussels requires platforms to remove hate and terrorist content within one hour. The Christchurch Call speaks of immediate removal. Which deadline will prevail and how will you be able to enforce it? And I want to add one last question also to President MACRON: we see an alert from AFP quoting Madam Angela MERKEL, who acknowledges having a contentious relationship with you in an interview. What can you comment on that?

Emmanuel MACRON

On the first point, I would like to be very precise, because I know the complexity of this subject. The European directive talks about this famous golden hour.

For terrorist content, not hateful, because there is this gray area regarding hateful content, that is what I was referring to, which we will define in the law, the so-called Avia bill, and which then leads to a whole process of regulation and sharing. It is about terrorist content, because there the definition is clear, it is strict, it is firm. Honestly, when we remove it within the hour or immediately, we are almost at the same point. It is simply… I believe that we should not make a distinction on this, and there is none. We are on the same objective, the same firmness. This is where the Christchurch Call, as I mentioned, allows us to broaden what has been decided, what is established within the framework of the European directive, to other geographies and other countries.

But beyond that, the Christchurch Call allows for the establishment of a methodology for cooperation with internet actors and civil societies, where a directive, which is normal, states the law and the rules. Our goal is indeed, beyond terrorist content, as provided for by the European directive, to strengthen this by being much stricter on the removal of hateful content, which can therefore lead to terrorism but more broadly to violence in society, and thus hateful content, whether it is, as I said, anti-Semitic, racist, which can lead to terrorism in the same way as online harassment, it is all this space that we now want to better regulate, and that is what we will do at the level of French law before we can progress in European law and have this international cooperation.

Then, I believe that Chancellor MERKEL, in her interview, said the same thing that I said a few meters from here when talking about fruitful confrontation. She said: we work together constantly, we find compromises, we try to build them, but there is discussion. You know, in a relationship, particularly between France and Germany, what are the options? There is the scenario of sterile confrontation, we do not agree and we cannot move beyond our disagreements. We have experienced that in the past, it can lead to the worst, either to impotence or to war. There is another scenario which is sterile agreement, that is to say that we do not want so much to say or let it be said that we can disagree that we no longer decide anything. We have also experienced that in the past. We hold useless press conferences and let Europe fall asleep because we do not want to disagree on anything. I do not believe in sterile confrontation, nor in sterile agreement. I believe in fruitful confrontation, that is to say: we propose, we test the partner, and we try together to build a compromise. We proposed at the Sorbonne, in the fall of 2017, a new vision for Europe. People said: "it's terrible, France is alone." Six months earlier, they said: "it's terrible, France is not proposing anything." We worked for months, in this fruitful confrontation, and we reached the Meseberg agreement. The Meseberg agreement is not the entirety of the Sorbonne project, but it allowed us to advance many things and to find, through this fruitful confrontation, a Franco-German advancement that then allows Europe to move forward. Last week, we proposed, with the Netherlands, an ambitious text on climate that aligns with what the Prime Minister has passed in her country: carbon neutrality by 2050. We managed to gather 9 countries, 9 member states. Many told me: "it's terrible, Germany is not with you, confrontation, you will not succeed." Two days ago, Germany joined us around this text and these climate ambitions. Fruitful confrontation. We are making progress. And so, we must succeed in accepting temporary disagreements, not being completely in agreement on everything in order to have the courage to assert what we want. What is expected of France in Europe is to clearly state what it wants, what it stands for, what its ambitions are, and then to build a compromise with Germany in order to move forward. That is our history, and it is the heart of our relationship. That is how we have advanced on many issues, and how we will continue to do so with the same spirit of construction and future that drives us, Chancellor MERKEL and myself.