Transcription of the joint press conference of the President of the Republic and Giuseppe CONTE, President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

15 June 2018 · Joint press conference of the President of the Republic and the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy, following a working lunch

Context
Macron held a joint press conference with Italian PM Giuseppe Conte in Paris on June 15, 2018, following a working lunch focused on migration and eurozone issues.
Main themes
Migration crisis, eurozone reform, European solidarity, Franco-Italian cooperation, Mediterranean migration routes, Dublin rules reform, humanitarian response, Libya, asylum applications, European collective organization
Duration
~14 min
47th percentile
Words
1,620
47th percentile
Sentences
39
24th percentile
Readability
29
15th percentile
Grade
19.5
97th percentile
Syntax
3.58
96th percentile
Vocabulary
1.98
9th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Geopolitical 59%59%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Economic 10%10%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

39 sentences in 15 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Council, Ladies and Gentlemen,

I am very pleased to have welcomed today the President of the Italian Council, dear Giuseppe, for a working lunch that allowed us to extend the discussions we have had several times over the past few weeks, both by phone and in person a few days ago during the G7 we shared in Canada.

These exchanges have allowed us to identify convergences of views on the many issues for which cooperation between our countries is essential, and our discussion focused essentially on two topics: migration and the eurozone. For me, these two topics are, in our case, to be placed in a comparable situation: they are a test for the Europe in which we believe and a test for our countries. On these two issues, Europe has lacked effectiveness and solidarity in recent years. I have been calling for a deep reform on each of them for several months, which alone will allow us to meet the challenges we face. And I believe the time has come. The situations we have experienced in recent days regarding migration have shown it: our collective organization is not the right one, and we do not know how to respond to the challenge that is ours today.

On the first topic, which is migration, there are, first of all, when we talk about this subject, we must remember, human dramas, human lives, individual situations, deeply affected trajectories that are at stake, and we must never lose sight of the collective duty that is ours. I also do not forget on this subject what Italy has had to endure since 2015, with massive arrivals in 2015 and 2016, particularly from the coasts of North Africa and this central Mediterranean route. And I want to remind here the reality of the issues because I have heard many falsehoods about the figures and the reality of what we have to experience. Italy has faced many direct arrivals, but through extremely important work, these arrivals have decreased, and the first half of 2018 was marked by a 77% drop in arrivals from North Africa, particularly from Libya. And France itself is not a country that benefits from the European collective system, particularly from what are called the Dublin rules, since we are a country to which more and more women and men arrive, whether through the Western, Central, or Eastern routes. And on this, I want to recall the figures: if Italy had 18,000 asylum applications during the first four months of 2018, France had 26,000. France had nearly 100,000 last year, and Italy had 129,000. And so many people make mistakes by confusing all the figures, but we are also a country of asylum applications and arrivals because we are a country, not of first arrivals, which is the great challenge for Italy, particularly for the Mediterranean routes, but a country to which women and men who may have faced a first refusal or a first registration in another Schengen country come to apply for asylum again.

And so France, like Italy, today has to manage this migration crisis. And we have to provide answers together, and I believe that our entire discussion has first illustrated this shared responsibility and this common will to act; this will to have both more humanity and efficiency in addressing this issue and to have a cooperative approach together and advocate for European solutions. I deeply believe that on this issue, there cannot be a national response; the right response is European, but the current European response is not adequate, and the current European solidarity, particularly in recent years towards Italy, has not been up to the task.

Thus, on this subject, we have decided to move forward on several fronts: the first is to strengthen the partnership work we could do with several other member states regarding other Mediterranean countries, particularly on the southern shore of the Mediterranean. We have begun a work of cooperation, training, and development in recent years; we need to continue and intensify it, including by taking new initiatives, and our wish is to be able to start a work together that should also involve Spain, as well as Germany, and I will be exchanging with the Chancellor in the coming hours before the summit and the Franco-German Council of Ministers next Tuesday – President Conte will himself be in Germany on Monday – and so we wish to be able to launch complementary concrete initiatives with our partners that will allow us to better prevent these flows and have a real humanitarian response because the humanitarian response does not begin when boats arrive in our waters; it begins the day when women and men are put in the situation of having to take to the sea and risk their lives. And so this cooperation must be further strengthened, even if we have already taken several initiatives in this direction in recent years.

In this regard, we will also continue our political cooperation on issues such as Libya, and I want to thank the President of the Council again for the good cooperation we have had politically during the conference organized by Paris and a follow-up that we will do together so that we can organize follow-up conferences on this extremely important subject.

Our wish is also that we can move forward together on – I proposed this a few months ago – a greater common protection of our borders, a greater investment from Europe in what is called the Frontex mechanism, and a convergence of our asylum systems. This reform is essential if we truly want to move forward and make progress, and it cannot simply be the responsibility of the first arrival countries in the European Union; and on this subject, I have always supported the Italian position, and it is part of the proposals I made last autumn.

Finally, we wish to be able to move forward together with our partners in the coming months also on a profound overhaul of the so-called Dublin system, to better articulate the rules of responsibility and solidarity. Today, the current system does not work; the solidarity systems that were once desired by quotas, as we can see, do not allow for satisfactory results; we therefore need to find suitable mechanisms that allow for the responsibility of each state when non-Schengen nationals arrive on its territory but also allow for solidarity so that our geographical situation does not put us in untenable political situations. And so on this subject, I believe we share the desire to also bring to the Council in June, common initiatives and to work with our partners in this direction.

We have, as I said, achieved very significant results over the past year. We can improve the situation, and we must improve it, and my conviction is that on the issue of migration, we need to carry out practical, political initiatives in deep European cooperation in the coming weeks to truly face the crisis that is ours.

It is also a stronger European response that, in my eyes, is necessary in light of the economic situation of many countries, and even if the eurozone is doing better today, it has not succeeded in addressing its fundamental imbalances and dysfunctions. We have therefore discussed this topic at length with the President of the Council, and on this point, I recalled France's positions, our desire to move towards a eurozone budget that allows for strengthening its convergence, additional investment through stabilization by mitigating the impact of economic crises on the most fragile states. The wish also that is ours to obtain very concretely in the coming weeks a deepening of the banking union that should strengthen the stability of the European banking market and enable it to better ensure the financing of the economy.

These topics will also be at the heart, along with the issue of migration and a few others, of the meeting I will have with Angela Merkel in a few days and the topics we will have with Italy, with Germany, and our partners to discuss, advocate for, on which we must make decisions and structural orientations at the next Council in June.

We also discussed other topics of joint interest that feed and animate the bilateral relationship and our place in Europe; the European defense and the European intervention initiative on which we wish to build a common strategic culture; obviously the projects we have started in terms of the European defense fund and PESCO, cultural and educational projects that link our two countries, and a bilateral agenda that has and will still have much news.

So, Ladies and Gentlemen, I will not be longer for this opening statement, but I want to reiterate that I deeply wish that in the coming days, weeks, and months, France and Italy work hand in hand, together, to contribute to acting and proposing European solutions, particularly with their partners, namely Spain, Germany, and all other states that wish to join, and that we carry concrete European initiatives to respond to these two main contemporary challenges, which are the issue of migration and the convergence and economic development of the eurozone.

I really want to thank President Conte for coming to Paris today; I know what the first days, the first weeks of taking office are like and how heavy they are, and I believe that the discussion we had allowed us to work towards this common position on many subjects. I want him to know that he has here a President of the French Republic who loves Italy and wants to succeed with it in a stronger Europe. Thank you, and thank you, dear Giuseppe.