Transcription of the speech by the President of the Republic, Emmanuel Macron, at the congress of Mutualité Française in Montpellier.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

14 June 2018 · Congress of Mutualité Française · Montpellier, France

Context
Macron addressed the congress of Mutualité Française in Montpellier on June 14, 2018, outlining his vision for reforming France's welfare state and social protection system.
Main themes
Social protection reform, republican promise and equality, dignity and social justice, welfare state modernization, real vs. formal rights, inequality of opportunity, solidarity, economic growth and redistribution, mutualist movement, education reform
Duration
~75 min
97th percentile
Words
8,960
97th percentile
Sentences
266
94th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
16.1
84th percentile
Syntax
3.51
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 71%71%
  • Economic 15%15%
  • Institutional 10%10%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 1%

266 sentences in 25 paragraphs

Thank you, Mr. President, thank you for this speech and your welcome, Mr. President, Madam Minister, Ladies and Gentlemen Parliamentarians, Madam President of the region, Mr. Mayor, Ladies and Gentlemen.

Thank you, Mr. Mayor, for welcoming us to this beautiful city of Montpellier. I understand that once a century, this city hosts the Mutuality, and that this is the moment – not the only one – when presidents come forward to speak, and just a little over a century ago, it was President POINCARE who, in this very city, met with you, proof, if it were needed, that your movement is rooted in the history of the Republic and has always had that particular link, Mr. President, that you just recalled.

Social justice, solidarity, dignity, these are the republican commitments, and you have just outlined, in a few fundamental sectors, on some essential issues of our society, the importance of these commitments and values. Of course, we continue to promise every French man and woman their fundamental rights; of course, we continue to operate a social protection system that gives solidarity a universal dimension. But in reality, what we observe is that every day the effectiveness of these rights is called into question. Every day, many of our fellow citizens find that universality is riddled with exceptions, disparities, dead ends, that the situations or promised rights are not real rights, and they discover this too late, when urgency strikes, when distress is present, at the moment when they would need a solid foundation of national solidarity, they often feel, too often, it slipping away beneath their feet.

We live in a country where the republican promise is thus too often disappointed, because we have maintained formal rights without caring enough to make them real rights for everyone. In school, in the world of work, in the world of health, the French are viscerally attached to rights, but they too often find that for many, they exist only on paper and no longer in reality; that is the contemporary French indignation. Yet, and this is a real paradox, we dedicate an ever-increasing share of our national wealth to social protection. So yes, we can be proud of our social protection system; it honors us, and it has, over the decades, responded to these indignations, the same ones I am echoing at this moment, but it would have, in a way, spared us from an even more demanding effort, that of facing the reality of our society, the effectiveness of each of the rights, the folds of society, the dark, cursed parts where these promised rights are lost, where these formal rights are no longer reality. A society that generates ever more inequalities of fate, of paths, of opportunities, a society that excludes entire segments of our population without recourse, a society that cannot solely redeem this political and moral failure through monetary redistribution, which is always necessarily insufficient. And it is this misunderstanding that I would like to begin to clarify with you this morning; I heard many commentators say, "he is going to go before the mutuals and he is going to make a great social turn."

But I will tell you, I do not feel that when we revive the economy, when we enable people to produce more, we are against the social model; you are a living example of this. But it is about producing in order to redistribute. I do not feel that when we carry out reforms in schools, colleges, high schools, and universities that have been made for a little over a year, we are the enemy of justice; rather, we are tackling the root of the problem. The fact that for decades we have been content with formal rights, with strictly monetary redistribution, forgetting the inequalities of fate, our system today is more unequal than it was 30 years ago in terms of education, in terms of access to the most qualified jobs, whether in business or in the higher civil service. Our system is more deterministic than it was 30 years ago; that is a reality. Therefore, addressing inequalities means tackling their roots; it means wanting to shake up a society that has become a society of status; it means wanting to recognize that all these challenges are not simply monetary; it means wanting, in a way, to reinvent – but you may boo me at the end if you wish, but let me finish, especially since I do not see you – and it is about knowing how to reinvent our welfare state, which too often offers only the last essential safety net, which we will maintain, but it does not sufficiently guarantee the conditions for a dignified life. That is the fight I want for this term, a dignified life! And a dignified life does not mean promising to stay where one was born; it does not mean promising to stay where one has fallen; it means being able to choose at every moment where one can lead one's life, and it means having a society that provides the conditions for that dignity.

We have inherited from the 20th century a welfare state of insurance, and we must strengthen it, but we must build for the 21st century a welfare state of dignity and emancipation, and we need a collective organization of fraternity that ensures the dignity of each person. That is my main objective; it is that of the state, but you are absolutely right, it cannot do it alone. It is that of local authorities, all of which are engaged in this action: regions, departments, metropolitan areas, municipalities; it is the work of social partners in contact with reality, with the social every day. And it is that of all social actors and those somewhat special actors whose history and strength you have recalled, namely the mutualists, actors of national solidarity, committed to this cause that, as you mentioned, both protect and act, have built over the centuries this capacity to provide answers in terms of protection, but also to act on the ground, to offer care, attention, and I will not forget, in other times, the hours spent not far from Lorient, in Kerpape, seeing the work that had been done and the excellence of it. But it is also the commitment, the time given voluntarily in councils and in grassroots action to change. It is the participation of your movement in the republican project that will allow, with all the actors I have mentioned, this radical refoundation that we need today. Our choice is simple; it is the choice between, in a way, two loyalties: either we remain loyal to a system that no longer meets the social justice objectives it originally set for itself and which is, moreover, no longer in line with the expectations of our fellow citizens or the actors who make it. Or we choose together to be loyal to the values that unite us, to reinvent a system that makes rights effective and concrete for all our fellow citizens. It is this second path with you that I will choose; it is more difficult, it undoubtedly takes more time, it cannot be resolved simply by budgetary promises or commitments that will be kept late. It requires our immediate action and invites us collectively not to yield to cynicism or hypocrisy. The most precious part of our social system is the spirit that gives rise to it. It is this visionary solidarity of the members of the National Council of the Resistance who invented the system perfectly suited to a wounded people and a nation in reconstruction. Our mission is to reconnect with that spirit, not to be afraid of change, for society has changed, and not to become the vestals of a social order that, for 25 years, the evolution of the world, of morals, of society has shaken to its foundations and whose effectiveness it has undermined. We could, like so many others, yield to the adoration of totems, but I will always prefer effective social justice to incantations, and efficiency to fetishism. That is why what we must do in terms of national solidarity is a profound revolution that restores to the French their rights, their dignity, their hope, and I will summarize it around three principles: prevention, which tackles inequalities before it is too late, because it is both more effective and more just; universality, which gives the same rights to everyone, transparently, because it is the only way to rebuild trust in our system; dignity through support, assistance, presence, and work as the key to emancipation for all those who can access it, because that is what allows everyone to truly build their life. The solution is not to spend ever more money or to consider that there are, on one side, those who believe in social transformation and who would align the lines of credit, and on the other side, those who do not believe in it and who would necessarily be for reducing expenditures. First, bad news: you pay for social spending; we pay for it, and too often, in our country, we consider that when it is the state, it would be the other; it is us. Worse still, it may be our children when accumulated deficits become debt.

The question is to face three major challenges that I would like to revisit, in a way following in your footsteps, and to try, in light of the three principles I just mentioned, to provide some answers: health, age, and exclusion. Regarding health, things have been profoundly disrupted over the past decades; our system is in crisis, but it has not been so for just yesterday. The impatience is there, and it is legitimate; suffering is a daily reality for women and men who care for those who cannot wait, for those who suffer, and for those who call for an immediate response. And if we look squarely at our health system, it provides good care, and we should be proud of that; it is effective when compared to other major systems, but it is much less effective at prevention, which is undoubtedly its primary characteristic. If we do not prevent well, we allow our fellow citizens to develop more serious and therefore more costly pathologies, sometimes leading to their exclusion from society. Having a system that prevents better is preferable both for collective health and for the efficiency of our system. This is what the policy, pursued and intensified by the government, for example, in the area of tobacco, has been enabling us to do, with initial results that will gradually show their effectiveness over time; prevention policy is one of the keys to addressing this contemporary challenge. If we look at the second characteristic of our system, I do not want to be exhaustive, but I will try to highlight its imperfections in broad strokes, which you have perfectly described: it is the excessive renunciation of care, for geographical reasons, for monetary reasons, or due to complexity, or for social reasons related to stigma. I will not elaborate on this point; you have described it perfectly, and I fully agree with the assessment you have made. The third element is undoubtedly, and in a way, the twin symptom of the lack of prevention: the excessive number of unnecessary procedures, over-medicalization, because when we arrive too late or in a system that has sometimes become too blind, we perform too many procedures. And when we are in a system where the incentives are not right, because it prices activity or procedures too systematically, well, if we compare ourselves, we indeed have a health system where there are more unnecessary procedures or over-medications than in many of our neighbors. Is this better for our fellow citizens? Does it provide better protection? Does it provide better care? No. Is it more costly? Yes. And you see, here, that trying to save money does not necessarily mean reducing the quality of the response provided, because we have too often and for too long responded to quality issues with the quantity of procedures; that was not the right answer. A fourth observation we could make is that pathologies have changed; our health system was wonderfully adapted to systems where it was necessary to treat acute, complex diseases very well, and it was designed for that. The excellence of our system, particularly the hospital system, the quality of our medicine, especially our specialized medicine, has been entirely directed in this sense, and that has been the excellence, and it remains the excellence of French clinical care, research, and treatment. But increasingly, our healthcare system has to deal with chronic diseases, pathologies related both to aging and to societal transformations in collective health. The response is different, and it requires a journey, a long-term support, and not simply a series of isolated procedures. Finally, the professionals have changed, and the collective choices are no longer the same, which has indeed created a different organization in the territory. Today, young French men and women who embrace a medical career no longer want to have the life of their parents; the on-call systems are no longer the same; the continuity of care in the territory is no longer ensured in the same way, because it is also a choice that has been made, because society has changed, and we must know how to respond to these aspirations collectively, by organizing care differently, at least by addressing the issues posed by these transformations. Our system is one of excellence, but it has been shaken by these transformations, these challenges I have just mentioned, and it is today torn between medical deserts, poorly covered pathologies, expenditures that no longer always meet the required quality, and a hospital system that is suffering, because it is becoming, particularly in emergencies, the one that somehow bears all the existing tensions of the system, as you described when talking about access to emergency services.

The second challenge we face is that of age; you have – and I will not revisit it – perfectly described one of our collective successes, the success of our developed economies and societies: we live longer, and we also live longer in good health. This obviously raises several questions for our collective organization that must not be overlooked. Can the retirement system remain completely unchanged in a society that continues to age, where life expectancy – and we should rejoice in this – in the time after active life, as we have thought of it until now, is lengthening, where the time for studies has also lengthened before entering active life? The chronology of our lives is no longer what it was 20 or 30 years ago; the time for studies has lengthened, the time for lifelong learning is becoming established, and the duration of retirement is also increasing. However, we spend a lot on our retirement system, often more than our neighbors, but despite all the reforms of our predecessors, we have not managed to fully establish the viability of this system over time, and above all, we have not managed to rebuild our fellow citizens' trust in the long term. A very large majority of the younger generation entering the workforce believe that they will not have a pension, that their retirement will not be guaranteed by a system of intergenerational solidarity, this system of redistribution that I care about and that will be maintained, because distrust has taken hold. Distrust has also taken hold because we have 42 schemes, which, through sedimentation, have created small differences, and with them, the small inequalities that may have had their justification, but do they still? Most of the time, no. Because they responded to a society of status, but they no longer correspond to contemporary challenges. However, as you said, there are still real inequalities in old age, but often they do not align with statuses or pension schemes, because they correspond to fairly particular, individual situations, linked to life accidents, to exposure to certain risks that each has experienced, and not to the status one embraced at a moment in life and which will change for the generation that is now entering active life. And so this system, which has gradually been conceived over time and which responded to the challenges of a post-war, industrial, long-cycle society, is no longer suited to an aging society, where paths are becoming increasingly disrupted, where paths are becoming increasingly individualized, and where inequalities have become statutory. Our ability to respond to this will be the condition for collective trust in the system.

But the aging of our population raises a second challenge, which you have perfectly mentioned, that of old age, of dependency, a subject that both disturbs us and that many of us would like to keep at bay. Our society no longer wants to see both great vulnerability and the place of death, which, at a certain point in this journey, arrives. This says a lot about us, and I will not dwell on this point today; otherwise, I would be too long. But dependency is there, and this new vulnerable age of life is beginning to establish itself. Not seeing it or considering that it would be the concern of a few is not treating ourselves with dignity; it is not treating with dignity the women and men who, once again, bear the daily burden of caring for those who sometimes live their last hours, their last weeks, and who are, those who care for them, often their last family. Our inability today to respond to this challenge has created social suffering in nursing homes, among dependent individuals or for their families. We must face this; it is a collective failure, and I carry it from where I am with the solemnity that must be mine. We will not resolve it overnight, but we must face this changing society, understand it, and consider that our response is not at the right level in terms of collective solidarity and that, because our oldest fellow citizens are entering nursing homes or facilities later and later, they also need care earlier and earlier. These establishments that were created to accompany a moment in life, when one could no longer stay with family, are transforming and becoming places where care is also needed, where medicalization does not exist everywhere or is not sufficient, and therefore for which our response must be different, and on which we must think about a collective reorganization.

The third challenge we face is that of exclusion. If we do not look at our poorest fellow citizens, if we do not look at this part of society, what nation are we? I have often been criticized for only being for the metropolises, sorry for Montpellier, only for this France that succeeds, only for the wonderful people, etc. Yes, I want to encourage them because if they do not succeed, there is little chance that the rest of society can make it, I confirm that to you. And so I want those who can produce, succeed, and hire to do even more, because I look all around us, and putting a ceiling on success has never solved the problem of exclusion. But I say it, I repeat it, and I will tirelessly continue to do so: when those who succeed do not want to look at those who are left by the wayside, in what kind of society do they want to live? Let them look around them at the rising extremes, at the hate speech igniting our democracies. This is the fruit of these selfishness and this blindness. And so we must, while making our economy a stronger, more productive economy, while being the unapologetic promoters of innovation, of a revitalized economic force, also want to respond to the issue of poverty and exclusion in our society. And here too, let us face reality. Over the past few decades, we have spent more and more on this issue. And have we solved the problem? No. Have we better prevented it? No. Have we changed trajectories, allowed people to get out more? No. Have we better supported? Rarely. When I look today at the figures, the reality, we have numerous mechanisms in place, but the children born into poverty still too often remain there, and determinism has taken hold. Today, what is the face of poverty? One in five children, one in three single-parent families. That is the face of poverty; it is plural, it is diverse; it is not a great whole into which we could somehow include a static part of our society. We have created a system that has gradually, in terms of the state, become dehumanized. We thought that the answer to exclusion and poverty was money. Over the past ten years, we have increased the RSA by 80%, but we have reduced support by 40% in terms of expenditures. This figure says it all. Today, we have 50% of those on the RSA who, after four years, are still on the RSA. We have 30% of women and men who do not go towards the benefits promised to them because they are too complex or stigmatizing, and so we have a system that prevents poorly, that still stigmatizes, and is too complex, which is not very humane and does not allow those who fall into these situations of exclusion or poverty to get out as quickly as possible and regain their place in society. And here too, we must, with all the harshness of the observation I make, and I make it primarily for myself, I make this observation for us; I do not make it for those who are in these situations, because they are the first victims, because one does not choose one’s situation. But if we do not face the reality that is ours and the failures of our actions, how can we provide a response?

On these three major challenges: health, aging, and exclusion, this is where we stand. So, in my view, the solution is to tackle the problem at its roots, to address the dysfunctions of a social system that is too focused on the actors and not enough on our fellow citizens, to have more prevention, more support, more collective responsibilities from each of us, and to try to bring about, through a profound transformation that will take time, which may be less stunning than money put on the table, but I am sure much more effective, because it will go hand in hand with investment in certain public policies, and indeed with the expenditure that we will assume, but also with the transformation and savings that we will need to make on the unnecessary parts of the expenditures I just described.

I want us to carry out this collective transformation together on the three challenges I just mentioned. First and foremost, regarding health, we show a total out-of-pocket expense on health expenditures of about 8.5%. But what is the reality of this system for those who have a little less money, a little less access to practitioners, a little less habit of consulting regularly? And regarding basic services that make up daily life, what is the reality of the system? If we want it to prevent better and to treat better, as close to the ground as possible, and as early as possible in relation to realities. The out-of-pocket expense for dental prostheses is currently on average 43%, which means an average of €200 for a crown, it is 22% for optics, which is on average, even if the differences are very significant in this sector, €65 for the correction of myopia. It is 53% for hearing aids, which means an average of €1,700 to be equipped. I am talking here about the out-of-pocket expense. This means that many of our fellow citizens, presenting simple pathologies, must give up on getting treatment? But what does this mean very concretely? Because we use words that are sometimes a bit technical. It means that the possibility of smiling, seeing, hearing, sometimes eating normally, our fellow citizens, who due to the out-of-pocket expense do not have access to these prostheses, are deprived of it. This means that behind this, there are children who cannot read at school as they should, since indeed the ability to be equipped with glasses is one of the primary causes of poor learning and illiteracy by the end of primary school. This means that some of our fellow citizens, who are excluded from work, cannot return, because they cannot afford to treat their teeth or because they cannot afford to correct a defective hearing, it means that our older citizens, when they start to lose their hearing and cannot afford to correct it, will fall more quickly into great dependence. I apologize for being concrete, but that is the reality. And behind what I describe as concrete situations, which are more prosaic than our words that sometimes shield us from reality, there are always individual tragedies, it is this inequality of trajectory that I was talking about. It may seem insignificant, but after a while, it becomes irretrievable. So yes, we must intervene earlier, faster, more massively, it is the best way to fight against inequalities, and that is what we have succeeded in doing, with zero out-of-pocket expenses or 100% health. The profound transformation we have undertaken will certainly be presented first in its financial aspect, it is real and it is obvious that allowing all those who until now could not, for monetary reasons, benefit from hearing, dental, or optical care, is an essential social achievement, and it is an investment that I take on, an investment that we will share together, and which will allow us to reduce this out-of-pocket expense to zero.

[Interjections from the audience regarding tax reductions]

THE PRESIDENT: So, for everyone to be clear, I believe that the two interjections are convergent, it is the proposal to revisit the taxation of the sector, to allow it to invest more. I will be perfectly clear: the agreement built thanks to the involvement of all, and I really want to thank you for that, and through the work and commitment of the minister, is independent of these measures. So, if we were to go in this direction, I would ask for more, but I am ready to open this discussion. However, I do not want there to be any misunderstanding between us, that the agreement obtained is not subject to a reform of the sector's taxation. Now I am completely ready to open a discussion on the sector's taxation, so that together we can do more and be more effective in its commitment. And you will always have by your side if we need to go in a sensible system on which you are calling me. I return, but I do not want this improvised dialogue to lead us into the pitfalls that I denounced, where the State would discuss with the mutual sector forgetting that behind it are our fellow citizens and their interests.

So let us return to our dental, optical, and auditory prostheses and their reimbursement. The logic behind this fundamental advancement, as I said, has a monetary character, but it is primarily based on increased access to care. It is thus about preventing the relevant pathologies from becoming more serious, more disabling, and for that, it is about significantly strengthening prevention, especially among the youngest, with systematic screenings, and that is what, for me, you have collectively succeeded in negotiating in recent months and which is essential. We will implement screening for visual and auditory disorders, reinforced at a young age, with three new consultations with the treating or school doctor. To reduce the reliance on dental prosthetic care, we will establish an examination for children at 3 years old, but also for young people up to 24 years old. That is prevention, it is ensuring that as early as possible, for our fellow citizens, there is access to consultations that allow us to see if there is a need for care, or if there are behaviors to change. And this is part of the agreement, and this is also interesting for mutuals, for professionals, for the State, because by establishing these consultations as early as possible, we prevent better and therefore we will spend less. This prevention also goes hand in hand with a responsibility of all professionals, and the revaluation of certain acts. This is the coherence on which I want to insist here, of the agreement that has been obtained. For example, for dentists, the fact of significantly revaluing conservative care, because today professionals were not adequately paid for these services, where they primarily made their income, which was legitimate, on later and more costly acts for our fellow citizens, as well as for the community. But we must also be responsible; we want dentists who can live well from their profession, who can continue to set up practice, and therefore the collective choice made to better reimburse conservative care goes in this direction, and also allows for a much more coherent approach to curative care.

The other part of the prevention revolution will rely on easier access to health professionals, because the full reimbursement of glasses, essential, is useless if it takes 12 months to get an appointment with an ophthalmologist. And so, for that, we will go further in organizing professional cooperation. The profession of dental assistant will be expanded, we will go further in the training of opticians and increase the number of audioprosthetists. It is a whole organization of the professions that we must move towards. But what I want to make you grasp here, through this reform, is that we will, through collective commitment, through the illustration of what you called for, Mr. President, that is to say the commitment of the State, the commitment of mutuals, insurers, all health professionals and those who ensure their protection, the commitment of social partners and health insurance, we have found an intelligent solution that allows, on the one hand, to have a response in terms of purchasing power, we will go from €1,700 to zero, from €200 to zero, from €65 to zero! So that is purchasing power for our fellow citizens. We will allow for better prevention and we will enable a much more intelligent organization of these three professions in the healthcare system, which responds to the challenges I just described. And so, on these three subjects, collectively, you have managed to provide a response to the challenges, to the deadlock we were in until now. Purchasing power, prevention, better services because of better collective organization of care. For this, as I said, and that is why I also wanted to thank you, we need the commitment and responsibility of all. And you are the example, ladies and gentlemen, of this commitment regarding 100% health. Mandatory health insurance will participate in the financing of the reform, by doubling its coverage for hearing aids for adults by 2022, but alongside mandatory health insurance, the complementary organizations you represent have also committed to taking their share in covering this 100% health basket. Responsible complementary health contracts, which cover more than 90% of the French, will be required to cover this basket. And of course, this reform cannot lead to a specific increase in the cost of acquiring complementary health insurance for the insured, that is the collective commitment we have made and there is no deception in this matter. And I have seen the emerging controversies, not about this agreement but about the past, the increase of certain complementary insurances, it is the commitment of the collective responsibility of the actors that allows us to control costs, which you have managed to do in several sectors. It is also complete transparency, healthily organized competition that helps avoid practices of which our fellow citizens are the first victims. It is your commitment here, and I thank you for it and I count on you to succeed in this challenge to meet the expectations of the French for a full implementation, over the next three years, since this reform will be finalized by 2021. So yes, we must intervene earlier, faster, more massively, by mobilizing everyone. It is the best way to fight against health inequalities, which I recalled earlier. And we have also invested significantly in this area, as I said, we are, as I mentioned, justifiably proud of our healthcare system, of the performance of our hospitals, but there are also situations of failure that I referred to.

To respond to these challenges, we must also, both for the hospital, for all healthcare professionals, and for our fellow citizens who rely on our healthcare system, succeed in providing a more appropriate response and transforming our historical model. We are faced with considerable disparities, with an inadequacy of this model, which is oriented towards an individual and curative approach to acute care, as I mentioned, while new needs for prevention and long-term care are emerging, with chronic diseases and aging. If we want to prioritize quality and prevention, we must also, beyond this initial agreement reached, lead a reorientation of the organization of the care system, in order to address pathologies much earlier, to rethink our collective organization. We need to gradually shift from a logic of managing the supply of care, from a too rigid mapping, from an approach that is too numerical and budgetary, to a logic of demand based on the services to be provided to the population in the territory, in their living area, and a more individualized logic, that is to say, patient-centered. To meet these needs for local care, stakeholders must organize into networks, breaking down the barriers between city medicine and hospitals, also ensuring access to at least five services, access to a primary care physician. Continuity of care and access to unscheduled care, continuity of care, gradation of care, screening, and vaccination. And beyond these five minimum services, we need to build this medicine, which will be patient-centered and which will allow, I apologize, to construct their journey within the healthcare system, and at every moment to protect them as best as possible. I do not want to comment here on work that is not yet fully completed; the minister is continuing consultations, and we will have the opportunity to revisit this in the summer, and I will speak in the summer, at the conclusion of all these consultations. You will also have your share of responsibility to take, ladies and gentlemen, in the transformation of the healthcare system. The role of complementary health insurance is not limited to the reimbursement of care; you are also providers of health, not just payers, and therefore you know the intricacies, if I may say so, of the complexity I just mentioned, from care services to health centers, through nursing homes. And the mutualist spirit is also about helping to build care pathways in sometimes the most isolated territories, for the benefit of the most vulnerable patients, investing in prevention, cooperating with professionals. Ultimately, you have in your genes a part of the answers we wish to provide to this contemporary challenge. And so, you can see, on this subject, we will have to take a position in the summer on a profound transformation, which is not simply a monetary issue, but which will involve a deep reorganization, and which will also require us to review all the structures we have become accustomed to over the past 10 years, from fee-for-service to activity-based pricing, from the sacred summa divisio between city medicine and hospital medicine, and we will also need to revisit habits, so that all those who provide care can take full responsibility.

The response to the second challenge, which is aging, and I will be quicker on this point, is also essential. You mentioned it for the first point that matters to me, that of prevention. We must, and this will be at the heart of the pension system that is being constructed under the authority of the minister and for which consultations are ongoing, we must better prevent, and therefore throughout life, encourage employers, encourage the entire community, to also prevent so that everyone can age better and that inequalities are gradually smoothed out in the face of old age. And we must take into account all the disparities in the pension system, as we are in the process of constructing it. We must then provide non-negotiable solidarity responses, which is what my commitment to the minimum pension was about, which increased by €30 per month on April 1st and will increase by €30 on January 1st. And I hear murmurs in the room; few people on the minimum pension pay the full CSG rate. So these are people who have only gained purchasing power. No, but it is a reality. But it is a reality; it is important not to let misunderstandings settle in. Every person on the minimum pension or who has a modest retirement pays a CSG, which is quite normal, and the choice was made not to change it, which is a reduced CSG; I do not want to leave the impression that the people whose minimum pension we have increased would have a CSG that has increased. Regarding old age, the response, and therefore regarding retirement, the response is obviously the complete overhaul of our pension system, with principles that I want to be clear and simple. I want us to maintain our pay-as-you-go pension system and the solidarity between generations. This is the choice that has been made, it is the choice that has been made, on which I have committed, and it is the solidarity that is at the heart of our Republic. Simply, this complete solidarity goes hand in hand with the end of a status-based society, and therefore it leads to a system that we are in the process of constructing, negotiating, consulting, which will allow that one euro contributed gives the same amount of rights. And so that we gradually converge all existing regimes, which had been built on differences that have now become inexplicable. This is the key to establishing what? On the one hand, the justice of the system over time, having a transition period that we assume and also allowing trust in the system, so that everyone can in a clear, immediate way know their rights and so that they know that their rights for €1 contributed are the same as their neighbor's. This is the key to responding to the collective distrust in which we have settled, and also to respond to the challenges of aging, which I just mentioned. On this subject, a law will be presented at the beginning of 2019 and will be voted on in the first half of 2019. Decisions will be made; they will be clear, a transition period will then be granted, and we have chosen, ultimately, not to make yet another budgetary reform favoring the short term, to finally make the reform that allows us to overhaul the structure, rebuild trust and justice, by accepting a long-standing tradition.

Speaker: (Inaudible)

THE PRESIDENT: But you are absolutely right; we are in a room of free questioning, but I like that. On this subject, on this subject, you are absolutely right, we must not forget women, nor forget broken and fractured careers, nor forget women and men living with disabilities, nor forget also those in great difficulty and the inequalities faced with socio-professional risks, and so it is all this that a transparent system will integrate into the parameters and which will be transparently consulted, negotiated, and voted on by Parliament. You are therefore absolutely right.

Finally, regarding old age, it is clear that we can no longer delay the response to be provided in terms of dependency. I mentioned earlier the reality, the daily life for many of our fellow citizens, for the healthcare staff, for those who share these often dramatic realities. We need, on this point, while also improving prevention, to mobilize all stakeholders, to recognize the role of family solidarity and to give it a status and a place. The role of collective, social solidarity, to finally build the responsible financing mechanisms and finally to accept to have the necessary national debate, which will allow us to respond to this new risk, which is here and to which we must therefore respond. We know the initial evaluations; some say it will be between €9 to €10 billion. We also know that the response lies in mobilizing all stakeholders, in innovation, in the ability to give a place in society and to better recognize and remunerate the work of those who support dependent individuals, and to ensure the transformation of establishments into more medically oriented facilities than they are today. This great transformation will not happen overnight; the minister provided some essential and urgent initial responses a few weeks ago. I know that they do not fully address the suffering experienced by those who work in these establishments. I know that they do not fully address the legitimate indignation of many of our fellow citizens. We will not resolve this overnight; I will not make you sweeping promises, promises from the podium, and it is not simply a financial commitment; it will be there, because we need to invest in this issue. No, we need to build a new risk; we need to respond to this new social vulnerability, which is dependency. On this subject, the year 2019 will also be dedicated to a law that will be voted on before the end of the year.

Finally, I spoke about this third challenge, which was exclusion, the great poverty in which our society has not settled, but to which it has sometimes become too accustomed, and which must continue to outrage us. On this subject, how must we gradually transform things? Here too, a consultation is underway, which will lead me to express myself in the coming weeks, and which, under the authority of the minister, has involved many of you around a poverty strategy. But it is the entire government that is mobilized to rethink our collective organization, our national solidarity. I hear all the debates that have stirred in recent weeks, as true as it is that the response to poverty cannot be monetary, the solutions we must provide to the problem cannot be budgetary. It is in the overall transformation, in prevention, support, and accountability, that we must fight against this scourge. Prevention is our first battle against exclusion and poverty, and in this regard, the battle is obviously at school. We have, with the obligation of schooling from the age of 3, with the halving of the number of students per class in the most difficult areas, with educational investment, with meritocracy in school, at every stage of life, including in guidance and access to the first cycle, put an end to the assignment to residence. The fruits will come with time, and the children who grow up, but it is the end of a system that has continued to assign, to be deterministic, because where was illiteracy in school? In the poorest areas. Where were the places where children did not go to kindergarten or only went a little? In the most modest neighborhoods. Where were the places where access to university was not available or was by lottery? In families that were not advised, not guided, and therefore the school formed is the first response to prevent, to prevent is also to support, to avoid lives falling apart, that vulnerability, when it settles at work, does not become even more serious, and this is the issue of single-parent families, absolutely fundamental, which we will return to within the framework of the poverty strategy, but on which, here, I want to reiterate that the decision to increase child care assistance by 30% for single-parent families is a preventive act against poverty, it is to prevent women or men, and often, it is single women, because they are already vulnerable, because they have a child, from being unable to take up a job or keep their job, because they cannot have their child looked after or do not have the means to do so. This response provided, voted by parliamentarians last autumn, and in effect since January 1, is a beginning of a response, and it will be complemented by the poverty strategy. Prevention is, here too, an essential, indispensable battle. Next, we must also assume collective solidarity for the most fragile and vulnerable, we must assume social spending that supports those who cannot, who are unable to return to work, they are, due to accidents of life or physical accidents, assigned to this situation. On this subject, our monetary commitments will not only be maintained but must also be complemented, complemented, by what? By support. We must, here too, for the most vulnerable in society, who are, each time, particular lives, individual journeys, the thickness and brutality of existence that cannot be reduced to numbers or boxes, we must also provide support, presence, and here, it is our failure, I say this frankly. We thought that by providing social benefits, by having people we called beneficiaries, we were responding to everything, that is not true, firstly, because the most fragile among them are often those who do not seek out these aids, because they do not know, because they have not been supported, because the fatigue, the bites of life are such that at a certain point, one does not even have the courage to go and seek it. And so we must take responsibility for this part of exclusion, for these lives that are the most fragile, the most broken, to have social support. And on this, I do not underestimate the wonderful role played by social workers, many associations, but we must recognize it more, institutionalize it, not to say that it is the State that should take it on, but to say that we must recognize it, better remunerate it and give it a place in society, we must recognize that here too, great exclusion needs a part of care, of human care and attention, of precautions. Then there is the part of those who can return to work, but for whom nothing encourages or supports them to make this journey. And this is where we must both support and hold accountable, and I take responsibility for this double discourse, this "at the same time," there are those who, being on social minima, remain there because they cannot take up full-time employment for family reasons, for reasons of supporting themselves or the rest of the family, and for whom going towards a few hours of work, going, with social support, towards work is the right response; what the Abbé Pierre Foundation or several other actors on the ground do, what several local authorities are doing by experimenting with these methods. This is what we need, it is useful support that helps those who are in a situation of exclusion to make this journey, and it is therefore to assume that the response, here too, is not simply monetary, but it is support, which allows a return to dignity in and through work, even if it is adapted work for people living with disabilities, whom we must bring back to work and who wish to, or if it is modified work, for the most fragile, the most wounded, who cannot take up full-time work in a professional environment without being helped or supported. And this support goes with accountability, also goes with control, goes with follow-up, because there are, you were right to remind us that they are not the majority, but situations where people have settled into a form of exclusion, but where they have built their existence and where in the economic situations we are in, we must also support them, hold them accountable and help them find work, because they are capable of it. Because, through this means, they will regain their full dignity, because through this path, they will also help the community to spend its money on the truly vulnerable. And we must take responsibility for this discourse, which is a discourse of support and accountability that must also transform our social policies. And so, we need to do, not only on the RSA, but on all the support policies for the excluded, the most modest among us, whether they are national, whether they are local, first, a work of synthesis and transparency, but then, also, this work, which will allow us to make the reverse journey of the one we have made over the last ten years, and to have, not a reduction of more than 60% in support for the RSA, forgetting the commitment to integration that went with the beautiful promise of the RMI, and a doubling of the amount of allowances paid, it is the reverse path that we need to take.

Invest more in people, support them so that they regain their dignity at every moment they can, and support all those who can return to work towards it, because emancipation is built through work, as soon as one can, there will always be those who cannot, and we must protect them, and be there, and take care of them, and recognize their part in our society, but that all those who can be supported to do so, and allow our public policies, our collective commitment, your commitment too, to be this path of support and accountability that allows emancipation in and through work. Because if all those who can make this journey do not do so, we will not legitimately have the means to finance the legitimate risks and the great vulnerability that I mentioned earlier, that is not true, and we must also face that, because otherwise, we would be lying to ourselves, and that all those who would not want to change anything, who consider that in some way, the technological frontier of social justice would be to spend more without holding anyone accountable, tell me who finances in the end? Always someone, you or your children or those who are not yet born. And so let us do this work of transformation, here too, of our social policy, by providing this support, by also transforming the place of social work, and in my eyes, this transformation is essential if we want to succeed in this path that I am talking about. And it is also for this reason that what we are doing to allow this emancipation is to build, at every stage of life, new individual securities, the new securities are no longer of status, it is no longer in the society of tomorrow nor unemployment as it existed, nor the RSA, it is the possibility at every moment of life to be retrained, reoriented, to be both protected and supported to be able to emancipate at every moment through this work. The heart of the law that is currently coming to Parliament on the transformation of apprenticeship and vocational training is this, and it is a continuum, from great poverty to life throughout work. What we need to do is reinvest in the person, to support more, to hold accountable more, and not to consider that the only response is the money of the community for personal situations that have become impersonal. We need to move away from a counter logic to a logic of support.

There you go, Ladies and Gentlemen, this is what I wanted to tell you about these three challenges. I will return in the coming months to both poverty and health. But I fully assume this discourse of truth, of collective responsibility which makes it so that in my eyes, the responses to our contemporary challenges cannot be the solutions of yesterday, because they did not respond to these challenges and because they led to what? To spending more and more while responding a little less each time to daily reality. What I want us to be able to rebuild together, to inspire deep values, which are yours, which are those of the Republic, which are those of the spirit of 1945, is to face the society that is ours, a society made of ruptures, of great transformations, of great anxieties, of this aging that we have long discussed, so that the heart of our response is to better prevent, to re-humanize and to support, not to help live in illness or to live in poverty, but to help get out of illness and to get out of poverty.

And to enable accountability for all actors, to make sure that everyone in this society is not treated as being in a state of social, intellectual minority but that everyone has a part of the solution. So yes, Mr. President, to succeed in this transformation, I do not think for a single second that the State can do it alone, I deeply believe that this transformation will now be a question of decisions, of actions, of details, it will be a daily work of a laborer, where the State will have to take its share of responsibility, but where all the actors, who make up national solidarity, will have to learn to reinvent their role to think about these challenges and participate in this transformation. I know you are capable of this, I know we are capable of this. Long live the Republic and long live France.