Transcription of the speech by the President of the Republic regarding the strategy and method for ecological transition.

France Emmanuel Macron · President of France

27 November 2018 · Speech on the strategy and method for ecological transition (meeting on energy transition)

Context
Macron addressed Members of Parliament and elected officials on November 27, 2018, to outline France's ecological transition strategy amid the Yellow Vest protests over fuel prices.
Main themes
Ecological transition strategy, climate change action, carbon tax, Yellow Vest protests and fuel prices, political leadership and responsibility, France's climate commitments, COP21, High Council for Climate Action, economic and social fairness, environmental debt, disinformation and political integrity
Duration
~74 min
97th percentile
Words
8,823
97th percentile
Sentences
380
97th percentile
Readability
53
70th percentile
Grade
11.7
41st percentile
Syntax
3.17
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.04
17th percentile

Translated from French

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Environmental 26%25%
  • Economic 26%25%
  • Institutional 25%24%
  • Social 17%17%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Not in focus 2%

380 sentences in 107 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen, Members of Parliament, Presidents, ladies and gentlemen, elected officials, dear friends.

This meeting has been organized for a long time so that we can define and build together the strategy of our Nation regarding energy transition. These words – I agree – are a bit abstract, but the subject has been on the minds of the French for many years.

The climate issue, which many citizens, scientists, businesses, and actors in economic and social life have committed to, creates an urgent situation for all humanity. France has made commitments, particularly during COP21, and we have a strategy in Europe, at the G7 level, as well as at the United Nations, to pursue.

For it is a challenge for all contemporary societies, both to mitigate everything that leads to warming and disruption of our climate, and to adapt as well. And it is about building an economic and social model that must take these consequences into account, seek to prevent new effects, and build a new productive, educational, and social model that is fairer.

This is the initial reason for our meeting, to plan our decisions, to agree on the major choices that are those of our generation, and to present the options between which we must choose.

It is my responsibility to tell you what the priorities and main steps of this strategy are, but today, this meeting obviously takes on a particular resonance. For several weeks, a broader movement of protest, sparked by fuel prices, has grown in the country. This movement has led to significant demonstrations and also to unacceptable violence in mainland France as well as overseas.

I want to say here that I do not confuse these unacceptable acts with the demonstration to which they are attached; I do not confuse the rioters with citizens who want to convey a message. I have understanding for these citizens, but I will not yield anything to those who want destruction and disorder, for the Republic is both public order and the free expression of opinions.

I will also tell you shortly what my understanding of this crisis is, what it entails, and the responses that it should lead us to prepare. But naturally, as the two subjects are concurrent, I will not ignore the implications that the second will have on the first. When we talk about the actions of the Nation to respond to the challenges of climate change, it is clear that we have done too little.

When I say too little, I am not talking about citizens, for they are increasingly numerous in multiplying small gestures that, added together, make great strides. By too little, I indeed mean the leaders that we are, political leaders, business leaders, and leaders from all sides, that is to say, all those who are in a position to engage more than themselves, those who, if they do not change enough, will bear the main responsibility for adding to the economic and social debts that our children and grandchildren will have to bear, an environmental debt of an entirely different nature.

For it will not only depend on it whether our society will be a little more or a little less prosperous, a little more or a little less just, but it will simply raise the question of the future of our society altogether. So for a political leader, what could changing mean, how to rise to this immense collective responsibility?

First of all, I must say it, by not changing my mind; that would indeed be a significant change, that is to say, by standing by one’s convictions and actions. What is said in a campaign, whether presidential or otherwise, before the French, commits, regardless of the election result; one cannot be for the environment on Monday and against the rise in fuel prices on Tuesday.

One cannot have decided on the carbon tax a few years ago and denounce today the rise in fuel prices. This tax, I remind you, was voted in 2009, in 2014, in 2015, engaging many political leaders of various sensitivities. Then, by not changing the truth. That a thousand false information and rumors flourish on social networks is distressing. But that political leaders, that is to say, those whose ultimate ambition is to hold the destiny of the country in their hands, echo this, refusing, for example, to see what the rise in fuel prices is due to the global geopolitical situation, which explains three-quarters of the increase in recent months, or failing to recall their historical position, is not dignified.

It is also for this reason that I wanted, just now, to establish this High Council for Climate Action, which must allow us to restore facts, scientific truth, elements on which the debate must then be nourished, and opinions confronted. But we cannot confront opinions based on false information or untruths.

Finally and above all, when one is in a position of responsibility, by not changing course, I know that the political habitués expect from me a renunciation, an evasion, in short, to let the present prevail over the future. But it is because we have always acted this way that we find ourselves in such a situation today. And the longer we wait, the more painful the effects will be.

Not changing one’s mind, not changing the truth, not changing course, does that mean that nothing should change? I have seen, like all the French, the difficulties that the situation brings to those who drive a lot and who were already struggling to make ends meet.

They say that it is always the same people who make the efforts, and they are right. They are told, they have been told, more precisely, for years: you cannot afford to live in the big city? It doesn’t matter, go settle in a peripheral city. You cannot move and live next to where you work? It doesn’t matter, you just have to buy a car.

Because there is no public transport between your workplace and your residence, they have been told: you cannot afford to buy a gasoline car, buy a diesel, it’s better, and they have been led into the situation, mechanically, collectively, where many of our fellow citizens are today.

They are not the authors of this situation; they are simply its first victims. But today, we are presenting the bill for 40 years of small adjustment decisions. We all have our share of responsibility on this issue. We must therefore hear the protests of social alarm, but we must not do so by renouncing our responsibilities for today and tomorrow, because there is also an environmental alarm. I would even say more, that the social and territorial inequalities that many of our fellow citizens rightly denounce today are often accompanied by environmental inequalities.

Who has children who breathe poorly because they live in an area saturated by transport? Often, it is the French who are in the most modest or fragile situations. Who lives in thermal sieves, in poorly insulated housing, and spends the most while polluting? Our most modest fellow citizens.

And so wanting to somehow address social urgency by renouncing all environmental and energy ambition is to install our most vulnerable fellow citizens, our most modest workers, in the situation where collectively, progressively, imperceptibly, we have plunged them for decades, and I refuse to do so.

In this context, everyone must play their role, their full role, including me. And my responsibility is simple: to guarantee our fellow citizens access to energy for mobility, heating, lighting, and work that is sufficiently low-cost so that no one is deprived of it and sufficiently clean so that our children do not pay the price with their health or their own future.

This responsibility is embodied in a main objective; we must move away from what are called fossil fuels. In 30 years, that is to say, in one generation, we must move from a France where 75% of the energy consumed is of fossil origin, that is to say, coal, fuel, natural gas, to a France where, by 2050, energy production and consumption will be completely decarbonized.

Because the massive use of oil, fuel, coal, and natural gas has dramatic consequences for our country.

First, there are health consequences; every ten minutes, a French person dies prematurely due to pollution, particularly from particles that come from the combustion of fossil fuels. This death toll is 48,000 deaths per year, more than all road accidents, all suicides, all murders, all drownings, and all domestic accidents combined.

Then, building this exit from fossil fuels is to respond to the problems of greenhouse gas emissions; fossil fuels currently represent 70% of greenhouse gas emissions. It is simple: if we succeed in moving away from them, then we will have won the battle, the battle of our international commitments, and our share of responsibility in this fight. If we fail, on the contrary, then the risks of cumulative disasters described by the latest IPCC report will become reality.

Finally, fossil fuels are the name of a form of French submission to foreign countries, to international markets, to geopolitics, and ultimately to the strategies of other countries. Concretely, the price of a full tank of gas or the amount of the gas bill today depends mainly on the decisions of Russia, Saudi Arabia, or Iran. That is the reality. And so building this gradual exit for our economy, our society, is also about building our independence, our true sovereignty, and we do not fully have that today.

This is indeed the primary and foremost goal of our energy policy: to detoxify ourselves from fossil fuels. This course requires a method, and we must build, on the subject of energy transition, a coalition that transcends political boundaries and takes its roots directly in society, in all our territories. That is why I have gathered you here today. I want to outline the main lines and directions and propose a method.

Detoxifying ourselves from fossil fuels, therefore, is first and foremost about consuming less energy.

In France, we use what are called fossil fuels, and notably oil, primarily for mobility. Our strategy cannot, and must not, be to move less. First, because we need it to function every day. Moreover, because many of our fellow citizens are obliged to move. We must not make it seem that it would be, in some way, to stay at home, or to impose this change on those who have no choice. And that is what they tell us.

But that is also why what we want to build are also new forms of mobility: by promoting public transport, the rise of carpooling, innovations, and concrete solutions with local authorities on the ground.

Consultation has taken place with regions, departments, and municipalities to precisely build this solution. The mobility orientation law, presented yesterday in the Council of Ministers after an intense phase of consultations, proposes part of these solutions that will need to be built on the ground.

At the same time, we believe that, yes, the car has a future in France. We want to produce cars that consume less, pollute less: by innovating, by creating industrial jobs. This is the purpose of the conversion bonus that we will therefore strengthen starting next year, as the Prime Minister announced, but more broadly of our entire industrial strategy for the automobile.

Supporting these new forms of mobility is also about developing innovation, creating jobs in all our territories and for all our fellow citizens. And some industrialists have already trusted us, who have decided to invest in our territories, to recreate industrial jobs, because they support this strategy called clean mobility, which corresponds to this objective.

We then use fossil fuels, oil, and gas, for heating. On this subject, our craftsmen and our businesses know how to build low-energy or even positive-energy buildings. They must continue to do so, and our strategy is precisely to encourage them to do so. But the building stock only renews at a rate of 1% per year. We must therefore also and above all work to evolve heating methods, to better insulate existing homes, factories, buildings, and businesses.

Measures and means are on the table, 9 billion euros as part of the investment plan, but the results today are too timid. Funded renovations are on the rise, but we are not meeting expectations on this issue. We must accelerate, not by setting prohibitions or limits. I know the concerns that some have in our territories. They have understood that we want to ban oil boilers in 10 years. No, what we want to achieve through a proactive policy is to ensure that we have renewed all of them by then. It was not a logic of prohibition, but of solution. Therefore, we need, through collective work, to provide concrete solutions with industry professionals to move much faster on insulation solutions, including at lower costs, and to renew equipment to meet this challenge. Ambition and solutions are needed.

The industry, finally, is a consumer of fossil energy to produce cement, steel, glass, and plastic that allow us to build our infrastructure, our housing, but also to manufacture the food we eat and the consumer goods we use. The challenge here is to invent the factory of the future that recycles everything and emits nothing.

I have seen, also in our regions, numerous projects that, by bringing together companies, research laboratories, and local authorities, are at the forefront of what is called low-carbon industry. We must also prepare to scale up on this issue, to ensure that the innovations currently in the pipeline can be generalized. Again, this requires investments, training, and the mobilization of industrial sectors.

We must therefore reduce our energy consumption and our needs for oil, coal, and gas, and do so in a concerted manner. With the method I will outline to you, by planning public investments, which are budgeted with these 9 billion from the investment plan. By providing concrete solutions everywhere on the ground, solutions that are adapted and coordinated.

We also need, to succeed in this transformation, to stop producing these carbon-based energies on our territory. It is in this sense that we have decided to close all coal-fired power plants by 2022. This is a pioneering measure because the reality is that, unfortunately, not only is there no closure happening worldwide, but too often new coal plants continue to be opened.

If we achieve these objectives, and if we create the conditions to do so today, we will have completed a large part of the journey in terms of climate. A large part of the journey, but not the entire journey. Because to continue to move, to heat ourselves, to produce and consume under good conditions, we must also be able to produce substitute energies for oil, coal, and gas. And that is the goal of this programming.

First, and the Prime Minister and the Minister of State will return to this, there are the needs for heat and gas. To address this, our strategy provides for a ramp-up of geothermal energy on one hand, which has a lot of potential in many territories, and methanization on the other. Methanization indeed allows for the production of biogas from agricultural residues and waste, and it is through this diversification that gas will continue to play an important role in our energy mix, while also allowing for production closer to the ground, offering prospects to our farmers, some of whom wish to accelerate this transformation, and for whom it is a useful source of additional income in our territories. It is therefore an agricultural strategy, a strategy also in terms of biodiversity that must be taken into account on this subject, in all our territories, which must be implemented.

But the most fundamental question is obviously that of transforming our electricity production. It is all the more so as electricity will take on an increasingly large role as we cease to use oil, coal, or natural gas. And this is an even greater challenge tomorrow since if we invite our fellow citizens to move towards new modes of mobility, more electric vehicles, to change their way of heating their homes, we will need more and more electricity production. What will profoundly mark the evolution of our electrical mix, as we call it, in the coming years, will obviously be the rise of renewable energies.

By 2030, the production of the onshore wind farm will thus be tripled. The amount of energy produced from photovoltaics will be multiplied by 5. The Prime Minister and the Minister of State will return to all these ambitions and the timeline and will also outline the method. These issues are important, they are supported by many of you, but each of these issues, when it comes to concrete projects, must be able to fit into a territory's strategy, also taking into account, as we know, sensitivities, a landscape logic, and balances that must be supported.

We will also develop offshore wind energy. During this term, we will commission the first farm off the coast of Saint-Nazaire and we will launch 4 new calls for tenders. The electricity produced in France tomorrow will thus be, in a way, the child of the era of the sun, and I do not forget water, as we will maintain our hydropower production while strengthening it wherever possible. And this hydropower is a strength of our territories and a strength of our low-cost, low-emission electricity production.

So does all this strategy cost? Yes, of course. The State currently allocates 5 billion euros per year to the development of renewables, fully funded by fuel tax revenues. With this plan, it will be 7 to 8 billion euros per year. But because we are concerned about public spending, we focus our efforts on developing the most competitive renewable energies, and because we are attentive to the purchasing power of the French, we will be demanding with professionals on cost reductions. Because we are attentive to the purchasing power of the French, we will also ensure the development of interconnections with all our European neighbors to benefit at all times from the least expensive energy.

The European energy market means lower bills for all the French.

The remaining subject, which I know is awaited, is nuclear energy. I say remaining, because the ramp-up of renewable energies in France is inevitable and is at the heart of the government's commitments. It is in no way linked to the pace of closure of nuclear power plants in the coming years. And let us stop saying that we must force the rapid closure of nuclear reactors for renewable energies to find their place; that is not true and that is not the case.

Nuclear energy allows us today to benefit from decarbonized and low-cost energy. This is a reality, and that is why we will engage in work on a new regulation of the existing nuclear fleet. Because the current system, which allows the French to have some of the lowest electricity prices in Europe, will end in 2025. It is essential that the French can benefit from it beyond that, as long as the nuclear reactors are still operational.

I was not elected, for my part, on a program to exit nuclear energy, but on a reduction to 50% of the share of nuclear energy in our electricity mix. And I will uphold this commitment.

I would have liked to be able to do it by 2025, as provided for in the Energy Transition Law, but it has turned out, after pragmatic expertise, that this figure, brandished as a political totem, was in fact unattainable. We have therefore decided to maintain this target of 50%, but by postponing the deadline to 2035. We have especially decided to be transparent about the trajectory we want to follow to achieve this objective.

Concretely, 14 reactors of 900 megawatts will be shut down by 2035. This process will begin before the summer of 2020, with the definitive shutdown of the 2 reactors in Fessenheim. There will then be a need to organize the closure of 12 reactors between 2025 and 2035. 4 to 6 reactors by 2030, the rest between 2030 and 2035. And the pace will vary depending on the evolution of the energy mix in our own country and in our European neighbors.

We cannot today say with certainty when we will be able to close a specific plant. The programming, and the Prime Minister and the Minister of State will return to this, will provide reference scenarios with variations. But I want to be clear here, this scenario will be all the more ambitious as we manage to innovate in renewable energy storage. Today, it is false to say that we can replace a nuclear energy production capacity with a renewable energy production capacity; the latter is intermittent. However, if we manage to innovate quickly enough, at the French and European level, and have real storage technologies, we will then be able to substitute one for the other much more quickly.

If we have stronger European integration, we can also modify this trajectory. The coherence of a European transition strategy would be that all countries that still have many coal-fired power plants close them. And then, that we close gas plants more quickly and that everyone converges first towards nuclear, then towards renewables.

And so the more we have a concerted strategy, the more we can have an intelligent adaptation over time. We can see that this strategy therefore depends on technological milestones, innovations, and our ability to have a truly integrated European strategy.

That is why today it is a reference scenario and the credibility of an ambition that we must provide, but with regular review clauses to adjust this trajectory to the realities of our environment, that is to say, the choices of other countries and technological innovations.

So, as you have understood, it is a pragmatic and adaptive approach that we have decided to adopt. An approach that does not preempt the decisions of the Nuclear Safety Authority because perhaps for nuclear safety reasons we will be led to close a specific reactor or plant. We must also take into account the elements of security of our supplies. I do not want us to rush to close plants if it means re-importing energy produced elsewhere, which is less good than what we have today, and depending on other economies. But this is also how we must take into account the control of the electricity bill for the French and the competitiveness of our companies.

I do not want us to be in a situation where, because we move faster on nuclear, we are led to close coal plants more slowly, which would be ridiculous in terms of emissions, or to have to massively increase the cost of electricity in the coming years, which would weigh on households as well as on our businesses.

To prepare in the best conditions for this scenario of shutting down 14 nuclear reactors, the sites concerned will be specified soon. The method I have just outlined will also be detailed.

I set a rule for EDF from the outset: no complete closure of sites. Reducing the share of nuclear energy does not mean renouncing nuclear energy, as you have understood. In the current state of available solutions, nuclear energy remains a promising avenue to continue to rely on reliable, decarbonized, and low-cost energy. We must therefore continue our research in this field and, here too, make clear commitments. The EPR, in particular, must be part of the bouquet of technological options for tomorrow. And while we are not making any decisions today regarding the construction of new reactors, because we do not have an immediate need and because we do not have the necessary hindsight, particularly regarding the Flamanville plant, we must take advantage of the few years ahead of us to make progress.

I therefore ask EDF to work on developing a new nuclear program, making firm commitments on price to ensure it is more competitive. Everything must be ready by 2021, so that the choice presented to the French can be a transparent and informed choice.

We will therefore continue research on this subject, and we will, as you have understood, also intensify our research strategy in renewable energies, storage, hydrogen batteries, that is to say, all forms of innovation that will allow us to advance more quickly in our renewable strategy and our progress in energy storage.

We will make clear choices on this subject. We are committed to this at the French level, but I also want us to be able to make clear European choices. If we want to move faster, for example on the development of our electric cars, we need to have more autonomy at the European level in battery production. Today, we are completely dependent on Koreans and Chinese. And as we develop these vehicles, they are increasing the price of batteries. We need to have at least a Franco-German strategy and, if possible, a European strategy for research, innovation, and production in this area to meet this challenge.

You understand that on this subject, ladies and gentlemen, the course is set. The Prime Minister and the Minister of State will shortly return to you with the details of the timeline for each of these levers. And believe me, we will stick to it because it is in line with our international commitments, because it is in line with the moral commitment we have made to ourselves, to our children, and to our grandchildren, because it is also in the interest of France and the French people.

But this transition must not come at any cost. I do not want the inequalities in income generated by globalization to be compounded for our fellow citizens who work or have worked by inequality in the face of ecological transition. I refuse to allow a two-speed France to emerge, where the wealthiest, because they have made the right environmental choices, will have reduced bills, and where the less fortunate, because they would not have had the means to invest, whether in a fuel-efficient vehicle or in the insulation of their homes, will have to pay even more.

I also refuse to let the ecological transition exacerbate inequalities between regions and make the situation even more difficult for our fellow citizens living in rural or peri-urban areas. And that is fundamentally the fear expressed by many of our fellow citizens in recent days, to be left behind, to pay for the energy transition without benefiting from it. And I can only understand and share this fear. Everything will therefore be put in place to socially support this transition, so that the French-style ecology we are bringing about can be a popular ecology.

And fundamentally, I refuse this alternative into which we would be plunged, which would say: ecology would be an urban and bourgeois issue, and social reality would impose making other choices. We are in the same nation, the same country; this is false. Because, as I said earlier, the first victims of our renunciations, of our lack of choices or clarity, are often those who live in the most difficult situations.

On the other hand, we have not succeeded today in our method to include all territories and the entire population and ensure that solutions and support are available for everyone. This is true, and it is what the current movement tells us.

It is also this new method that I want to inaugurate today with you. The course is clear, and the choices have been made. I have just presented them to you. A set of concrete solutions and practical proposals must now follow, and that is what I hope you can build with the Government. If I have gathered you here this morning, it is because you are political, associative, trade union, employer, elected representatives, and actors of this transition everywhere on the ground, and it will not happen in the same way in Paris and in the overseas territories; the solutions will not be the same in the countryside and in the metropolises. That is why I want this strategy to be not only debated but constructed with you, at the national and local levels, giving ourselves the time and the will to build this in the coming three months.

In the next three months, I want you to structure not just this debate, but as several of you have proposed, a method of construction to provide concrete solutions, solutions that can be differentiated on the ground or depending on the sectors.

I want this debate to obviously be a national debate, but also to be rooted in the territories, and therefore that all the territories and elected representatives present here, and I thank them, be fully involved. Not involved to observe decisions that would be made down to the last detail, but to have their say and to build them with the Government.

And to make choices on proposals that are put on the table, improvements that undoubtedly need to be made, and a support strategy that needs to be implemented, I want this decision for consultation to be rolled out across the territory, and that everywhere in our territories, on social networks as well, this debate can take place, and that all interested associations can participate, including locally. And that thus the representatives of the yellow vests in each region can also take part and propose solutions because we cannot be in mutual denunciation. We are at the moment of providing concrete solutions.

The Prime Minister will clarify shortly the methodology and what he will establish today and in the coming days, with you, to also build this common working method. This large grassroots consultation on ecological and social transition will therefore have the mission, fundamentally, to build this new economic, social, and territorial model that we need. To build it by providing solutions, methods of support. Fundamentally, what I take away from these last few days is that we must not renounce the course because it is just and necessary.

But we need to change our working method because many of our fellow citizens have felt that this course was imposed on them from above through decisions and changes in rules or through taxes without always providing them with solutions that were as concrete, if I may say so, as the tax itself.

I hear the discontent. The criticism that has been made has focused on the price of fuel. Why? Because at the same time as the increase in the tax, which was part of the campaign of many candidates, which was part of the commitments, which was voted by Parliament long before and which, as I said, corresponds to many votes that have been made by many majorities, regardless of their colors, because, in addition to this reality that was foreseen, the global prices of fuel rose. That is what happened. And so we also need to build a method together to protect ourselves from such phenomena. And therefore, to adapt any new increase in the fuel tax to the evolution of international oil markets, so that if prices were to soar again, we would not find ourselves in the same situation.

And so, on this subject, what I want to see done in the next three months is, on the one hand, to build a method to make this tax, which is currently a bit blind, smarter, and to allow for quarterly meetings that would, in a way, mitigate the impact for our fellow citizens if there were to be a surge in global prices. No one can predict that today, and we cannot say that it is only our fellow citizens who have necessary travel who would be the sole victims. We must also be pragmatic. But we must also, for each of our fellow citizens, more quickly and more strongly, provide concrete answers. And that is what I expect from these coming three months.

I hear the dialogue today that exists between the government and our fellow citizens. I am not naive. There are people who are using this situation with a lot of bad faith because they would like us to stop everything. Because, fundamentally, they are against the project put forward by the government and they would like to redo the elections of May 2017. This is, if I may say so, undoubtedly part of democratic life. It is taking on more violence today. It is characterized by more demagoguery and a kind of degradation of democratic debate. We are plunged into this world; it is up to us to rise above it.

But I hear the anger that has its share of legitimacy from our fellow citizens who say, I am willing to understand what you are proposing, but you are not providing me with a solution. In any case, your solution is not concrete. You talk to me about an energy voucher; I do not know the phone number to get it. I do not understand how it works. But what does that mean concretely for my boiler? You talk to me about changing cars, but no one explains to me how much it will cost to change, and when I have 10 euros left at the end of the month, it is not possible to ask me to change my car. And you can see that the problem we have today is the pragmatic implementation of the solutions we provide. And so in the next three months, we need to build. The Prime Minister has already made proposals. We have made budgetary commitments. But the real methods of support to make them concrete and accessible to people? What I want is for our fellow citizens, at the moment when this situation is imposed on them, to know how much a vehicle that consumes less costs them, the savings it brings them each month, and that we have built with banks and manufacturers a real solution so that what they have to pay in the first month is achievable for them. And that the remaining costs are largely limited and spread over time.

I want us to provide them with the real solution to renovate their apartment or home or change their boiler at a cost that is accessible to them. There too, because we will have provided our solutions. What this crisis indicates a bit, of what we have been doing for decades, is that the responses we provide are too abstract, too far from people, too far from the ground, or too uniform.

People express their suffering, and we respond with an energy voucher. But they do not know what the energy voucher is. And the truth is, concretely, I do not either. And so we need to make things tangible on this subject. There are, and in good faith, those who defend it, saying it is not true, there is money, and it allows us to do things.

But it is not concrete enough, not tangible enough, not simple enough. And when it is not concrete enough, not tangible enough, not simple enough, people do not use it. And that is also why everything that has been thought out today to make this transition more social is not used by the most vulnerable. And so, we need during these three months of co-construction to provide pragmatic solutions as close to the ground as possible and to do so with economic, social, and territorial actors so that it becomes a tangible, perceptible reality for our fellow citizens. I know that there are many proposals that have been made; they will be part of this debate and these three months, at the end of which we must maintain this course that is essential for the country and of which I have recalled the major equations, but build acceptable solutions for each and every one.

The change of method that I wish for is, in a way, to provide concrete solutions accessible to each of our fellow citizens. The change of method is also to better support the territories affected by the transition, whether because we are closing a coal-fired power plant or because we will have to reduce our nuclear capacities. That is why we will systematically implement energy transition contracts between the State, local authorities, and economic and social actors to support, from Cordemais or Le Havre, with associated resources, involving all the actors on the ground from now on to restore perspectives. Because we know that there is a change to be made; we should not be afraid of it, but it should not be those who live in this territory who become its victims.

This requires involving the companies that are in this territory very early on; it requires planning financing, planning substitution mechanisms. For example, in Saint-Avold: we have worked with major industrial players; it has already begun to be done to create jobs. They are already in perspectives that exceed those that will be lost due to the closure of the coal-fired power plant. Jobs in, precisely, the new professions of energy production, with the major industrial players present in the territory. This is what we must do everywhere with all social partners, territorial partners, and economic forces.

You understand, this method is, in a way, to build over the next three months by mobilizing all territories, by mobilizing all economic, industrial, artisan, agricultural, social, employer, and political actors, a genuine transition that is an agenda of solutions and an agenda of protection. This is what we need for the country. I am deeply convinced of that. More broadly, we can see it well, and this is what we must build together during these three months. It is the beginning of the transformation of our economic and social model.

In a way, what we are beginning to grasp today is the fact that the consequences of ecological, environmental, and energy transition cannot be treated as separate, as an external result to the rest of the functioning of our territory and our economy. They must be placed at the center, and we need to have a real concrete budgetary strategy for our fellow citizens that accompanies them.

At its core, what I want to make clear to the French people, and especially to all those who say in a way: "We hear the President of the Republic, we hear the Government. They talk about the end of the world, but we talk about the end of the month." is that we will address both and that we must address both. Because, in a way, your difficult end of the month today is because for years we have considered that you were not important enough, in a way, to participate in our collective response to the end of the world. It is because for years we have collectively said or tacitly said: "You are not important enough for society, and therefore it is you who will buy the most polluting cars, the least well-insulated homes, and you will adjust." What you are saying is stop, I hear it, and therefore we must change our method.

I have deep confidence in our ability to meet this challenge because our country always knows how to come together when the essential is at stake. And again, I believe that solutions will come from the ground, from the economic, associative, and citizen actors in our communities. The governmental and budgetary ambition is there, it must be there. And at the end of these three months, if it needs to be revised, I am ready to revise it with the Prime Minister, but everyone must be faced with a real solution for themselves.

That is why I want to give you a clear mandate to go out and meet our fellow citizens on the ground to explain the measures decided, to verify and ensure that they are accessible to all, and to build this overall strategy, these support mechanisms, and to make this transition just, democratic, and clear.

Finally, to conclude, I want to add a word about the crisis we are experiencing as agreed because it is not limited to the price of fuels. We must be lucid and honest about this. And I am determined, not only to acknowledge but to take on all the deep feelings that have been expressed during this crisis and that I have identified.

In the face of these feelings, and even I would say these resentments, I will not shy away. And what I ask of you is not the only response to what we hear. I say it again and I will be clear: I will have no weakness towards those who manipulate, instrumentalize, or in a way seek violence. To them, the response will be clear and firm: public order and nothing but public order. Because that is the protection we also owe to our fellow citizens who live in neighborhoods today shaken by these demonstrations, to merchants, artisans, and economic actors who are deeply disrupted in their daily lives and also their turnover by what is happening.

But there is in what is expressed or in the tacit or explicit support in our country for this movement, something that comes from further back and undoubtedly from several decades. The idea I have of my mission prevents me from hiding behind the responsibilities of others, whether those of predecessors or other actors, and I renounce here to seek any form of excuse. Because I believe I understand very deeply the expectations and frustrations, this silent anger, these grudges and resentments that citizens feel in front of powers they sense are distant from them, indifferent, and, at the core, in front of what they feel to be blocked lives.

Blocked by taxes, regulations, by a loss of meaning of what the collective adventure of a nation is, and this comes from far away. And I consider that our duty, and this is part of my primary responsibility, is to provide a response to it. It does not happen in one go, and those who think that it is a measure or a speech that resolves it are mistaken. I do not believe it, and it is impossible. But beyond what I propose to you today and this method and this work, I deeply believe that what has been said must be heard more profoundly.

It tells us something first about a society that wants solutions to be brought to it rather than having changes imposed on it through regulations. It is a profound change in our collective organization, starting with the State but also involving all our structures. And I say this here because we have all co-produced this world for decades where the best intentions in the world ended up as regulations. You believe in what I say, and this is true for local elected officials, the Government, economic and social actors. You believe in what I say, give me a law, a regulation to show it, and these are new norms for the people. We have all done this, and these new norms applied uniformly across the territory often create blockages, constraints, and burdens. And so, it is also a mental conversion of all decision-makers that we must achieve.

Then what this crisis says, I hear, is the deep sense of consent to taxation. I hear people everywhere saying: "We have too many taxes, too many levies. We no longer see the benefit, the account no longer adds up." Where I say there is a lot of demagoguery is that if political, union, social, and employer leaders do not engage in education, no one else will, because many intellectual opinion leaders have given up doing so. But our taxes and levies are facing something, and we cannot ask indiscriminately on the same poster or in the same slogan: "Lower taxes and create more daycare centers, more schools, more rights, more public services."

This paradoxical injunction is very nice when one has no responsibility. It is unacceptable when it is supported by people who have responsibilities, but it ends very sincerely badly. And so, we need to educate again about what our system is. I have been deeply convinced of this for several months; it is part of this mission that is collectively ours, which is also that of our generation and which is undoubtedly the twin fight of the ecological transition I just mentioned, which is to build a new social contract for the 21st century. And many of the issues you will have to work on over the next three months are also this.

But that means we must explain to people what is in front of their money. But if no one educates about it, people, our fellow citizens, will all end up believing that school is normal for it to be free; that hospitals are normal for many to be free and for others at a very reduced cost; that when one reaches the end of life, it is normal for the community to pay. All this has a cost, it is what is paid for by taxes. And so, there is undoubtedly a form of re-evaluation and education to be done again. But I also hear what many of our fellow citizens, particularly those who work and who work with modest incomes, tell us: "It is no longer worth working because we fall into a category where we are too rich to receive aid and not enough to really be free."

And these blocked lives of those who work hard every day but do not earn enough to live well, or of those who have worked hard and have a modest pension, we must be able to respond to. That is not what I am asking you for in the next three months, I assure you, but I consider that it is at the heart of the response that I must provide in the coming months. Part of what has been done by the Government responds to this, and I consider that the Government's strategy for the past year and a half is the right one and corresponds to this observation.

When we lower employee social contributions compensated by an increase in the CSG, but all workers earn more, that goes in this direction. But what our fellow citizens are telling us is that it is not happening fast enough. When we start to lower the housing tax, it is primarily for the middle and lower classes. But what our fellow citizens are telling us is: "It is not happening fast enough," because alongside that, there are taxes that are increasing and the cost of living is rising.

When we take measures for education, particularly for the most modest households and middle classes across the territory, that goes in the right direction, but it is not happening fast enough. And so, what we will need to assess in the coming months is, on the one hand, how we can deeply look to accelerate, intensify this project to respond to the legitimate impatience of those who work hard or have worked hard. And so, we must undoubtedly proceed with profound changes. This requires us to renew our working methods and the organization of the State and also of public spending, thus of all public spending actors, to do better and provide more services with less, and therefore to open a new chapter in our collective reform. All this to tell you that today's response is not the last, but that on each of these subjects, we have to build a new social contract but also another effectiveness of collective public action to rebuild trust in the nation.

I will therefore take strong initiatives on this subject in the coming times, and I will also consult everyone and re-explain a method. But the problems facing France today are not new; they have been around for a long time. And this France that fears change, because it is a France that has been asked a lot, we cannot consider that the upcoming changes will be made despite it or without it. And so, there is what I ask you to do with the Government on environmental transition, but there are also the choices we will have to make more broadly to rebuild this new social contract, but also to rebuild a greater effectiveness of public action and to succeed in providing better public service, to have a better response to their aspirations by spending less and thus being able to more quickly lower their taxes and levies.

And you know, and I will end on this, I believe that what we are experiencing can be useful and favorable. Because there are too many problems of frustration, of unspoken issues that have lingered for several decades. In the literal sense, these questions that are now coming to the surface have never really been addressed, and they poison the life of the Nation, and we must evacuate these poisons. We must do so without abandoning any truth of the country, the truth of the world around us, of our responsibilities. Because at some point, we must make choices, and we cannot promise or commit to everything and its opposite, but we must be able to address this issue.

None of the problems we have to address is an expert problem. They are all, without exception, problems of conscious and responsible citizens and problems of public decision-makers that we are. And my deep feeling goes even further: these problems, all contemporary democracies have to face them. All of them, but they express them differently. Brexit nearly two years ago in Great Britain is the same issue. These are British citizens who simply say: "The world you are proposing to us is no longer for us. We do not see ourselves in it. We who work hard have no more prospects, we can no longer build projects for our children, we live less well, and it is made for the City, not for us." And they make a clear, democratic choice. All contemporary democratic societies have this challenge before us.

I believe that the deep reaction of our country, what I feel rising from the nation with you, expresses this part of the French truth. And we have a chance, because I believe that we have the collective capacity to face it if we decide now together to confront these issues, to roll up our sleeves, to say: "There is no miracle solution, but we can build honest and ambitious solutions." This ecological transition that scares you, we can take it on because we have the best actors in the world to do it. When it comes to managing complicated cities, when it comes to managing energy, transportation in the rest of the world, we call on French companies, so we can do it here because we have this democratic demand.

We have always had this democratic innovation in our history that has allowed us to address these issues. And so I am confident about the period that is opening up. It will be demanding for us, but it requires us to hear this anger, this just part of anger in order to respond to it because it comes from far away. I will do it from where I am with you with great humility. I will do it keeping two principles in mind at every moment. The first is that every citizen is necessary. There is no change that happens by disregarding a single citizen in the country. There is none. This also implies that respect, common decency must prevail everywhere in the country and that what I also see rising as a loss of civility among us, we must put an end to it. Condemn it, never glorify it.

My second conviction and my second basic principle is that our nation is greater than each of us and that many of the choices we will have to make will require a spirit of responsibility. Because we are bound by a history, an adventure, and a future that surpasses us and makes us stronger: it is France and a part of our common destiny, and I believe that it is also a good part of our European destiny, of the project of re-foundation that we have to carry forward.

So, ladies and gentlemen, these are the few convictions I wanted to share with you today. I deeply believe that we can transform the expression of oppositions into a momentum to build the future, that we can transform anger into solutions.

Thank you.

Long live the Republic and long live France.