Conference and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government at Columbia University.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

20 September 2010 · Conference and subsequent discussion at Columbia University · Columbia University

Context
Zapatero addressed an audience at Columbia University on September 20, 2010, discussing global economic recovery and the Millennium Development Goals ahead of UN evaluations.
Main themes
Global economic recovery, Millennium Development Goals, new world economic order, financial regulation failures, unemployment crisis, poverty reduction, emerging vs advanced economies, lessons of the 2008 financial crisis, wealth distribution, climate change, global governance reform
Duration
~39 min
90th percentile
Words
4,663
90th percentile
Sentences
133
76th percentile
Readability
31
18th percentile
Grade
17.5
91st percentile
Syntax
3.56
96th percentile
Vocabulary
2.13
33rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 50%50%
  • Ceremonial 16%16%
  • Social 13%13%
  • Geopolitical 10%10%
  • Institutional 7%7%
  • Environmental 3%3%
  • Technological 1%1%
  • Not in focus 2%

133 sentences in 64 paragraphs

Good afternoon. Columbia University is one of the most prestigious academic institutions in the world, a prestige acquired over 250 years by being the "alma Mater," as the bronze statue on the staircase leading to this "low library" reminds us, of many men and women who, with their thought but also with their action, have contributed to shaping and understanding the world; men and women, professors and students who have been able to stand out, both for their talent and their commitment, joining a select group of Nobel Prize laureates, or distinguishing themselves in their support for causes of human dignity, like the students who, in the late 1970s, did not hesitate to go on a hunger strike here to protest against the apartheid regime.

You can understand then, ladies and gentlemen, to what extent I feel satisfied and grateful to the organizers of this event for having the opportunity to speak today before you, here, at a university that is home to people I admire greatly and who honor me with their friendship, such as Professors Stiglitz and Sachs, or where the much-loved and respected Edward Said served until a few years ago, whose memory I wish to evoke now expressly.

Friends,

I would like to talk to you at this meeting about the new world economic order that may be emerging and must emerge after the crisis, and the role that the Millennium Development Goals should play, the compliance with which we are now evaluating at the United Nations ten years after their approval by all world leaders.

As we mark this month two years since the collapse of the major investment banks in the United States and Europe, all signs point to the fact that in 2010 the global economy will return to the levels of activity prior to the economic crisis. Thus, global growth is expected to be around 4 percent this year, something that, fortunately, contrasts with the situation brought about by the Great Depression, which is the precedent of our modern economic history with which the crisis we have experienced is compared, due to its severity and intensity.

After the financial crash of 1929 -- it is worth remembering -- the global economy took almost a decade to return to pre-activity levels, and in the case of trade, this recovery was delayed even further by the effects of the World Wars. Today, the recovery of the global economy is a fact, but it is an uneven recovery, led by emerging and developing economies, and with less vigor in the case of the more advanced economies.

It is a recovery that has not, so far, generally been accompanied by job creation, and this is the most serious problem; it has not yet been able to reduce the sharp increase in unemployment. More than thirty million additional unemployed, two-thirds of whom are in developed countries; that is what the global crisis has produced. It is, at the same time, a recovery still subject to the uncertainty of financial markets and the very growth in the immediate future of the United States and Europe.

This is the current situation, but what are the lessons of this crisis? Allow me, even if only for a moment, to refer to them because, based on them and the reading we make of them, which is not exclusively a technical reading or an interchangeable dissection, but also a political assessment, and as such, debatable and verifiable, is how we will be in a position to characterize the world economic order we aspire to.

Well, over two decades of apparent stability, the global economy had been incubating the crisis that erupted in 2008, largely as a consequence of a set of practices in the economic and financial sphere. The process of financial regulation taken for granted, when not seen as a demonstration of ideological coherence, led markets to behave in a pernicious way and, instead of displacing dubious and irregular practices, completely alien to any functional virtue, many of them became structural and systemic.

I will not explain what these practices consisted of to those who would do it much better than I, like Professor Stiglitz. What is relevant is that it generated the illusion that we could live with a financial sector that functioned on its own, increasingly abstracted from real activity, when in truth we became increasingly exposed to its fragility and excesses. These practices in developed countries, combined with greater growth in savings in emerging countries than in the development of their own financial system, fueled the emergence of bubbles and littered the real economy with mines.

At the same time, it was believed that uninterrupted global economic growth would contribute to a similarly constant improvement in global living conditions. Advances in wealth distribution and poverty reduction, as well as in relation to other challenges, such as demographic issues or the fight against climate change, were entrusted to the extension of global awareness of the need to address them, which almost assumed the inevitability of an insufficient pace in doing so.

Therefore, a financial crisis incubated in deregulation and imbalances, and global challenges not faced with sufficient determination in the context of poor international governance led us to a profound transformation of the economic order. The outbreak of the crisis has put us before that urgent need, as Professor Stiglitz has well explained.

We have learned that markets can indeed be blind to imbalances and can generate and feed them indefinitely, until one morning they emerge starkly into reality. We have learned that markets left to their own devices due to the absence or insufficient presence of democratic public power can represent a serious threat to the general interests that it is called to defend, including the market itself and its socially virtuous role, which is to be defended by states and international organizations under a logic that is certainly different. We knew this, but we may also have forgotten it in the face of the individual logic of maximizing, sometimes uncontrollable, profits.

Perhaps what is newer is that this dialectical relationship, inherent to the need to preserve a reciprocal space for both poles of the same -- markets on one side, and public financial oversight on the other; defense of individual interest on one side, and defense of general interest on the other -- is now more than ever raised, but on an international level, on a global level.

These are some lessons from the crisis. What, then, is the economic order that should emerge from it? There is broad consensus that the objectives of the new economic order must be: stable growth, based on solid foundations and supported by sufficient and effective international governance; environmentally sustainable growth, not only compatible with the fight against climate change, but that includes it as an integral part of the productive model; and globally balanced and inclusive growth of regions, countries, and citizens.

These are three elements that can only be conceived as interdependent and inseparable from one another. If we do not act against climate change by treating it as a structural dimension of the productive model, we will not be able to achieve stable and lasting growth, and without solid and lasting growth, we will not have resources for the fight against climate change.

If our growth continues to marginalize large segments of the global population, we will have instability and conflict, and a smaller number of societies and citizens contributing effectively to the development of the global economy. At the same time, if growth is not solid and lasting, it will not be sufficiently inclusive and will not promote stability and peace.

In any case, the effort of economic governance and international cooperation is necessary. It is already helping us to emerge from the crisis and must constitute the main hallmark of the new global economic order. In this sense, the role that the G-20 must play must be forged and consolidated, and alongside it, we need international financial institutions that have sufficient resources to fulfill increasingly important tasks and in which all relevant actors feel represented. The upcoming reform of the quotas and the Executive Board of the International Monetary Fund will be key to this end.

I will now refer to the position of the Millennium Goals in this new economic order. I am aware of how bold it is to do so precisely at this Columbia University, which is home to one of the people, Jeffrey Sachs, who has contributed the most to the conception and dissemination of the Goals, and for which he deserves all our recognition.

What I would like to highlight here is that the Millennium Goals, the fight against poverty and for the access of all humanity to minimum levels of education and health cannot only obey a moral impulse of solidarity. Undoubtedly, this is very commendable, very valuable, essential in reality, and thanks to the powerful feeling of rejection that the intolerable and painful reality of extreme poverty provokes, the mortality of millions of men, women, and children, their condemnation to illiteracy and the radical denial of their dignity in a world where in many places there is overabundance and where, above all, the material disappearance of extreme poverty is conceivable; thanks to that feeling, humanity is advancing, has advanced in recent years, and the formulation of the commitment to the Millennium Goals is the best testimony of that.

But it is not enough. The Millennium Goals are not, or should not be, just a moral desideratum, an ethical imperative. We must conceive them, moreover, as a true structural element of a new international economic order that we are building.

The global perspective, which is essential, must be truly global: global on growth, on international trade, on the financial system, on energy sources, and global also on the territorial distribution of wealth, which must be incorporated into its understanding as a functional element of the economic order, in addition to projecting onto the requirements of stability and peace.

I believe that what this qualitative step entails is better understood by paying attention, as we are doing these days in the United States, to the criteria for financing development cooperation. The conception of cooperation and the international fight against poverty as a requirement of solidarity corresponds to the financial aid decided voluntarily by each country, according to its possibilities and budgetary forecasts, which are always difficult in times of crisis.

It is true that the generalization of the commitment to reach 0.7 percent among rich countries already entails a certain modulation of this model of voluntary national aid; but what would imply, what will imply, a qualitative leap consistent with that paradigm shift in the fight against poverty and for inclusion from voluntary solidarity to a structural principle of the new economic order is to establish new stable, objective, and sufficient financing pathways to serve the fulfillment of the Millennium Goals.

If the challenges we face are global, from the most powerful to the poorest country on Earth, if the responsibility for what happens to us and the responses are global, and if we need to articulate global governance, it is necessary to have a system of global revenues. The establishment of a tax on financial transactions as a financing instrument for the Millennium Goals would be very effective as a revenue-generating tool. Even if the amount of the tax were small, and therefore non-distorting, it fits within that framework of analysis and, in my opinion, its establishment makes full sense.

The Government of Spain is firmly committed to ensuring that we have within that essential chapter of new innovative sources in the fight against poverty and in favor of the Millennium Goals a tax on international financial transactions. We will do this with other countries and we will extend with society and NGOs that global awareness and that demand so that a small minimum contribution from each international financial transaction can represent the definitive effort to eradicate extreme poverty from the Earth and hunger and painful misery.

Allow me to say that there is no more ambitious and noble goal than achieving that end, even when we know that it is possible to achieve it and after suffering this very harsh economic crisis, when we have seen that imbalances are behind many of the difficulties that citizens in both developed and developing countries are facing today.

The decisive moment has arrived; the moment of truth for governments has come, for governments to confront the worst scourge that history still has among us, which is poverty and extreme misery. The time has come to move from voluntarism to will, from good intentions to determination, and from chance in aid to the necessity of it. I say this from a country that in recent years has been the developed country that has increased development aid the most in the fight against poverty and misery, practically doubling our contribution in relation to our Gross Domestic Product; and from a country that maintains its goal of reaching 0.7 percent by 2015.

The Millennium Development Goals represent the most noble collective task that humanity has ever set before itself, which all world leaders at the United Nations subscribed to, and we have five years left for their effective fulfillment. To be the first living generation to eradicate extreme poverty, misery, and hunger in the world constitutes the highest, most stimulating motivation that we governments can have alongside non-governmental organizations.

Professor Stiglitz, we must achieve this. We need to get the governments of the world to agree to establish that tax on financial transactions and to be able to meet the Millennium Development Goals in five years and, in a short period of time, to end misery and hunger in the world. This will be the best tribute to so many NGOs, to so many volunteers, and to so many professors who have bravely and dignifiedly pointed out the key problems of the global economy, the most important of which is wealth inequality and misery.

Therefore, I wish to commit from the Government of Spain all political action to contribute to this new economic order, to a new sustainable growth capable of creating the much-needed jobs in many countries, as it is at this moment in Spain; a Spain that is part of the European Union and an increasingly united European Union with a growing will to establish that international economic order that is governed.

We must remember that the G-20, which has been key to responding in a coordinated manner to this crisis, was convened at the European initiative, has been largely consolidated by European impetus, and must have a foundational period, as a great institution for that global economic order, in the next period. Certainly, Europe is deeply committed to achieving that system of cooperation and coordination in the economic, financial, and climate change areas, as well as the Millennium Development Goals as the four major pillars for responding to the new times ahead of us.

We are in the fight against the economic crisis, working to achieve recovery, to change the productive model — to which Professor Stiglitz referred — and to set aside so much investment seeking short-term interest and to promote investment in education, innovation, research, and development; all of this with a commitment that is the commitment to maintain social cohesion in the exit from the crisis, fundamentally with those who are unemployed or have lost their jobs.

We are living, then, in decisive times. The crisis has highlighted the urgent need to establish a new world economic order; but this new economic order will not be born on its own, nor will it arise spontaneously, nor will it be the result of something invisible. This new economic order that we are already working on and trying to build must be characterized by a greater recognition of our interdependence, of the dependence that we have on each other as countries, economies, and regions, to articulate a true realm of global governance, which must propose a new and better balance between the market and public regulation and supervision, which must incorporate as structural principles of that new order the fight against climate change, which I have hardly referred to today but which has the same level of necessity and commitment as the fight for the Millennium Commitments and, of course, the fight against poverty.

Therefore, if we want that new international order to be born, to be consolidated, to govern structural changes, and to balance accumulated risks, it is essential that we establish additional financing pathways to serve the fulfillment of the Millennium Development Goals.

Someone who is progressive must sense that there is always an opportunity for change at the exit of a crisis and in the fight against an economic crisis; in this case, for change in the international economic order. These changes can only have one meaning; they can only be guided by the values of solidarity and freedom; of a solidarity and freedom that imperatively demand extending rights and opportunities to all of humanity. And in a time like this, we must be faithful to seek those changes that extend opportunities, that know how to interpret the historical moment, and that place us all before the dimension of the changes we have and the policies that must be carried out.

My gratitude to Columbia University, my satisfaction for being here, and my full commitment to the Millennium Development Goals.

Thank you very much.

COLLOQUIUM WITH THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT

------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Q.- President Rodríguez Zapatero, since Juan Bosch, the great Dominican thinker, I have not heard a conference like this. Regarding that solidarity expressed in that wonderful speech to eradicate poverty, has the G-20 ever thought that, along with that scourge, as you called it, there is another scourge, especially in Latin America, from where I come, such as drug trafficking? Have you also thought about budgeting and reaching agreements with the governments of the region to confront that evil that is bringing so much blood and pain to Latin America?

Q.- Mr. President, welcome to Columbia. I just wanted to say that I feel a bit saddened to see that in your entire speech the only proposal you made was, again, to increase taxes, to establish a new tax, especially from someone who said several years ago that lowering taxes was a leftist thing. Why is it not proposed once and for all that perhaps to combat poverty what needs to be fought for is to bring freedom and democracy to poorer countries, and not to be continuously defending or allying with countries, especially in Latin America, that really contribute very little to democracy because, Mr. President, the land may belong to the wind, but the societies that are established on the land are the result of many generations and a lot of work, and that is what needs to be exported to those countries?

And one last thing. This morning you said you would fight for Spain to become a more competitive economy. Can you provide any more concrete proposals on how to do that?

Q.- My question follows a similar line, but it was specifically oriented towards financing and how funds can be found in this situation where a series of austerity measures are being applied.

Q.- President, what can the rest of the world learn from Spain in the field of renewable energies?

Q.- Mr. President, regarding your comments about changing from a productive model of issues like, for example, real estate to things like innovation, research, etc., how does this contrast with the reduction of scientific budgets that has occurred in Spain? For example, I am here doing postdoctoral research funded by the European Union and I have just obtained a teaching position at the University of Barcelona, the salary of which is lower, not only than a salary of a professor here, but than my current salary as a postdoctoral researcher here.

Q.- Regarding interdependence and countries in Latin America, which sounds very nice, what can we do, for example, in countries, like the one I come from, Venezuela, where there is no guarantee of any kind and where it really seems that we are heading towards poverty? How can we ensure interdependence with countries like this?

President.- Many questions have been raised, and I will try to respond to all of them point by point.

Regarding drug trafficking, I must say that it is one of the issues on the global agenda, it is one of the areas of greatest cooperation of the European Union with Latin America, in particular; also of Latin America with the United States and, of course, in the dialogue between Spain and the United States. There are various programs of the European Union that finance the fight against drug trafficking and the alternative to certain crops in Latin American countries. And I agree that this is a scourge of such magnitude as the scourge of misery and poverty.

I take note with interest of the possibility that this issue appears in the debates of the G-20, which have so far been very focused on the financial crisis, on the new international financial order, and on tax havens, where progress has been made in recent times in different territories.

There was a question — more than a question, an assertion — about financial transactions and the comparison or equating it to a tax. This would be a fee, not exactly a tax, on financial transactions that would practically be a small-scale fee for each financial transaction with a volume of potentialities and spectacular results.

Of course, democracy, institutions, and the rule of law are needed to consolidate progress in countries. We completely agree, and we Spaniards know this well, as we have fortunately spent thirty years in the struggle to establish ourselves as a solid, democratic, and stable country. But, as Prime Minister, I can have an experience and a conviction: the vaccines financed by Spanish Cooperation with the taxes of Spaniards are saving many lives of many children in Sub-Saharan Africa, and the schools financed by Spanish Cooperation with the taxes of Spaniards are saving and allowing children in Sub-Saharan Africa to be educated and whose destinies are radically different.

While we consolidate democracy and while we fight, which is as important as the other, for there to be institutions, it is essential, if we want children not to die, that they can be educated and that we finance Development Aid. To finance it, it should not only rely on the voluntariness of states, which is fundamental, and the solidarity of citizens, which is commendable, but also, why not, establish a stable, solid, lasting mechanism, where financial transactions are taxed to contribute, with the volume of financial transactions that exist at this historical moment thanks to openness and globalization, to the fight against poverty and misery. It seems fair to me.

It has nothing to do with being an option that opposes the need for democracy and the rule of law to ultimately consolidate the capacities for development, progress, well-being, stimulation, and initiative of citizens. But, if we do not have financing, we do not prevent extreme misery and poverty, and with financing for development aid only from states or citizens at this moment is not enough.

Therefore, it must be done, and in this case, as in almost all, the debate on whether to impose taxes or not does not necessarily have an ideological color. I always see it as a tool for an end, and it may be that raising taxes at a given moment is a useful, progressive option, and lowering them, too. Indeed, I do not have a dogmatic view. If one thing teaches the lesson of the task of government, and certainly, facing a crisis like the one we have had even more, it is that fundamentalist positions usually lead to failure and that a government with a progressive orientation can, as we have done, lower taxes, certain taxes, for a purpose, or can establish new tax figures also for a purpose, depending on the circumstances.

R&D&I. I liked this question, which I have seen has received quite a bit of support, about salary conditions. Normally, these issues always generate applause. But I must speak with conviction because the government I have presided over since 2004 has tripled public spending on Research, Development, and Innovation; tripled. It is the period of greatest increase in public spending in the field of Research and Development; it has no comparison. It has allowed us to reach 1.37 percent of spending on R&D&I, and also, allow me to say, it is the period in which the most rights and improvements have been recognized for research interns, who when we came to power were in a rather precarious situation in terms of Social Security and rights.

They are still not well, I agree, but the figure I have given is indisputable, and with the economic crisis, the budget items that have been least affected in the General State Budget, both in 2009, in 2010, and will be in 2011, are those related to R&D&I in our country.

Do we have a long way to go in investment in R&D? Yes, but in the last six years we have made more progress than in any other period. That is the reality, and the proof is that today we are the ninth power in scientific production, that fortunately we are already at the threshold that corresponds to us in the return of the framework program in research from the European Union — we had always been far below — and that the private sector must make an increasing contribution and investment in Research and Development.

Renewable energies. Spain has a leadership in renewable energies, it has the strongest companies in the world in solar energy and in wind energy, and that is not the result, like almost everything, of chance; it is the result of a determined policy to promote renewable energies, which are an essential option in the fight against climate change, which bring innovation, which bring technological capacity, and which generate stable and qualified employment. Consequently, we will continue to bet on that option.

Latin America: some countries have been mentioned, such as Venezuela, and the fight against poverty. The extension and consolidation of democracy, as I mentioned earlier, are absolutely essential for growth, well-being, and development. And I must say that, despite the difficulties or the specific circumstances that may exist in a country, Latin America at this moment has two characteristics that should make us approach it with a globally positive outlook: it has resisted the economic crisis quite well, it is the occasion when it best withstands the economic crisis, and, secondly, with some very minor exceptions that we have recently experienced, in Latin America we know a period of uninterrupted democratic governments longer than in modern history.

Spain, due to its special connection, always works for institutional consolidation, for the improvement of democratic practices in all countries, for fostering political dialogue within each country, and, of course, for economic consolidation and social development in this young continent, with five hundred million people, which has great potential and, moreover, where the United States should have a very intense dialogue.

Professor Stiglitz, I have tried to answer all the questions in detail, leaving nothing unaddressed, I hope, thanking you for them, explaining clearly the objective data, the real facts, and, of course, very pleased to be able to establish commitments around the Millennium Development Goals.

Spain has fulfilled its commitment to development aid thanks to the solidarity of its citizens, and that translates into lives, into hopes; and if the world adopts the tax on international financial transactions, that will translate into lives, into education, into opportunities, and into health. That is what we want, and that is why we are here.

Thank you very much.