Interview with the President of the Government in the programme "Hoy por hoy", on Cadena SER

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

9 September 2010 · Interview on the programme "Hoy por hoy", Cadena SER · Cadena SER

Context
Zapatero gave a radio interview on Cadena SER's "Hoy por hoy" programme on 9 September 2010, addressing Spain's labour reform and an upcoming general strike.
Main themes
Labour reform, general strike, trade unions, unemployment in Spain, permanent vs temporary contracts, workers' rights, economic crisis, European labour models, job security, dismissal regulations, social dialogue
Duration
~88 min
98th percentile
Words
10,522
98th percentile
Sentences
463
98th percentile
Readability
58
83rd percentile
Grade
10.2
22nd percentile
Syntax
2.87
30th percentile
Vocabulary
2.14
35th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

463 sentences in 197 paragraphs

President of the Government. - Good morning.

Carles Francino. .- I imagine that sometimes you must have heard the shouts of "Zapatero out" from the mouths of the trade unions?

President of the Government .- You have to be ready for everything in this job - I took on this responsibility and I accept that democratically.

Carles Francino. Are you nervous about the general strike, or does it frustrate you?

President of the Government .- I respect general strikes. I deeply respect the trade unions, their social sway and their opinions, although I disagree with them, but you won't hear me criticising the unions. I have always felt that they play a fundamental role in our democratic system, and whilst I disagree with them, particularly as regards the labour reform, I still respect them.

Carles Francino. .- But do you not think that they have good grounds for calling this strike?

President of the Government .- I understand that they disagree with regard to the labour reform, that is legitimate; but I understand less the fact that they don't take on board the fact that Spain has an unemployment rate double the European average, one of the highest temporary employment rates in the EU and that part of this scenario is the result of our employment framework.

As a result of the labour reform that was approved yesterday by the Congreso [Lower House of Parliament], our model converges somewhat with the European model, although … In other words, the labour reform we have approved brings us closer to our European neighbours.

It is a labour reform that fundamentally deals with three areas, we should remember that. The first of these is that it helps create jobs once the economic recovery becomes more consolidated, as it facilitates and stimulates new hirings on the part of companies.

Secondly, it avoids the massive volume of lay offs that has taken place each time we are faced with a possible crisis. But the criticism that this makes dismissals easier, defending the situation in which close to two million dismissals have taken place in two years is at least arguable. We shall endeavour to avoid dismissals to such a large extent in the future by making labour conditions more flexible. We will make our system more similar to the German system, where the same number of working hours has been lost as in Spain during this crisis but where unemployment has hardly risen at all. Why? Because the working day has been reduced and salaries have been reduced. We shall try to emulate this in our labour reform.

Finally, and this is the hard part, we are trying to stimulate more permanent and fewer temporary contracts, because job insecurity in Spain is excessive, especially for young people. To that end, we shall extend the permanent 33-day contract which, by the way, was created in an agreement between Aznar's Government and the trade unions and we shall insist on more objectives grounds in the case of dismissals.

Gemma Nierga .- I'd like to continue with the labour reform. Just half an hour ago, we were debating here, on the "El Abierto" programme, the reduction in workers' rights. You have always stated that workers will suffer no reduction in their rights. Yet this reform does reduce their rights. My question is, have your betrayed your principles? And a further question, can one govern whilst betraying one's principles?

President of the Government. .- I would like to say two things. We have to wait and see the results of this reform. That will take some time, at least a few months.

What are the basic rights of workers within an employment framework? Firstly, the right to work, in my opinion; secondly the right to job security, and in Spain there is too much job insecurity because there are too few permanent contracts; and thirdly, maintaining a principle and certain bases of a collective right to defend workers' interests, and this right is indeed maintained under our model of labour reform.

I do not feel that I have betrayed my principles under this labour reform. Moreover, the labour reform, as you are aware, has been negotiated and talks have been held with business leaders and trade unions, so it would only be fair to wait and see the results.

Again returning to my previous argument, are we satisfied with the old labour model, which in each of the last three major economic crises since the arrival of democracy has resulted in Spain recording the highest unemployment levels of any country in the European Union? No, we cannot be satisfied with that. We had to make changes, reforms. We have made them and let's wait to see the results. That is the one thing we should convey to the trade unions at this time; let's wait to see the results.

As regards principles, I should say that since I have been leader of the Government, I have made a policy of extending social and civil rights. So much so that the previous four years of legislature were the four years with the greatest increase in social costs in Spain in living memory. Why? Because social costs increased in our country by 40% between 2004 and 2008 and because social benefits per inhabitant rose from 3,900 euros to 5,200 euros.

We have increased social rights: dependency, paternity rights, equality rights, grants have been increased, improvements made in education, improvements made in health benefits and improvements, as never before, in minimum pensions. Hence, this whole period has been one of increasing social rights.

Gemma Nierga .- Yes, Mr. President, but tell me about May. You also had to freeze pensions, cut civil servant salaries…

President of the Government .- That leads me on to a reflection I wished to make in conclusion.

During the worst economic crisis in the last fifty years, I have tried to maintain a principle of social cohesion above all else. What is the most negative effect of the crisis? At a social level, unemployment. For those people who have been affected it is extraordinarily negative. What has the Government's response been? To take social protection for the unemployed to its highest level ever. 80% of the unemployed in this country receive protection, although strangely nobody seems to remember this, or almost nobody. Yesterday there was a vote on labour reform, but there was also a vote on a Royal Decree Law that extended a 420-euro benefit for those people who lose care benefits as a result of being unemployed.

Angels Barceló .- At any event, Mr. President, as regards these measures, on many occasions the controversy or debate is generated not so much in respect of what is done but rather of how it is done. And speaking about the labour reform, to give but an example, this Government spent months denying the necessity of even having a debate on labour reform, when this was requested from many forums and even for example by the Governor of the Bank of Spain. And it was a matter that caused concern. Suddenly, the markets and Europe gave a warning and, blow me down, we do in fact need a labour reform.

President of the Government .- I would like to clarify something, Angels: we spent two years in talks with business leaders and trade unions regarding the labour reform. You will remember that there were times when they were held up.

A. Barceló .- It was impossible to pass anything.

President of the Government .- Exactly. But we got to a point where it could be seen that there was no way to reach an agreement between business leaders, trade unions and the Government. Why? Because we have a model, the one that has been in operation for the last few years, which perhaps needs revising, where, in order for there to be social agreement, it is necessary for at least the business leaders and the trade unions, and the Government to be present. Hence, I believe that the labour reform has a different perspective.

It is true that a labour reform has been demanded by all the international organisations and any analyst that studies our economy knows that even in periods of growth our unemployment rate is much higher than the European average and that there is greater instability than in other European countries, but in other aspects of our economy and in respect of our social reality we are on a par, fortunately. For example, as regards income per capita, we have even climbed up the European rankings. Hence the labour reform has this trajectory.

The adjustment measures are quite another matter, and it is true that I did have to change a policy. That's the way it is and everyone can understand that many governments have had to adapt to changing circumstances.

It was not my objective, in my head, in my political plan, to reduce civil servant salaries, nor freeze pensions. I had to do it through a sense of responsibility, because our deficit was so high it was necessary to correct this since if not, the markets, our creditors, could begin to question our future solvency. I had to adopt this tough adjustment plan, especially tough for public workers and, above all, as regards pensions, when everyone knows that the policy that has characterised this Government has been the steady improvement of our pensions.

Montserrat Domínguez .- Some day, Mr. President, you will have to tell us about that terrible night you had from 9 to 10 May, in which, as you told us, you didn't get a wink of sleep. But, the thread of what I was saying, you have brazened it out, and I believe that rightly so, to reach this increase of 40% of social costs and this level of social protection. How long can we maintain this situation? Is it sustainable?

Yesterday the OECD reported in Paris that, as regards fiscal adjustments, the countries that are doing well can begin to relax, but Spain of course cannot, and we remain in the spotlight of the markets and the European and international regulators. Can we sustain this level of social cost, this level of unemployment cover?

President of the Government .- Yes, in my opinion we can. If we carry out the reforms that are underway, if we apply them effectively and if we send a message to the whole country, in short, that consists of us being in the group of countries in the world and in Europe that has a Welfare State, with rights, social benefits, education, a health system, pensions, dependency laws, etc. To have these, we need to work and be more productive. This means making an effort in training, both individually and collectively; this means making an effort in innovation, such that technology and research an enormous collective task throughout the country; we need to take these two conditions on board.

And since this country can do this, because it has done so on numerous other occasions and we in a position and on the way to doing this, my best guess is that we are going to maintain our Welfare State because, and I would like to clarify this, all these increases in social costs, for which I would welcome some recognition, have only marginally affected cuts in this 40% increase in social costs.

Now the school year is starting and, for the first time, our country is contributing 5% of GDP to education. There have never been so many grants as now. And we are forging this perspective of trying to maintain our Welfare State. But no country can maintain an advanced Welfare State if the country isn't awash with work, and productive, and competitive, with innovative companies and incorporating talent, technology and training as a fundamental pillar of our economic activity, which is where the problem of the last few years lies, because our growth was based, in part - mind you, we shouldn't exaggerate this - in the construction sector, which was not particularly productive. Other sectors have indeed grown and made a contribution.

M. Domínguez .- Do you have a Plan B of cuts planned which you can resort to?

President of the Government. .- No, that won't be necessary. Fortunately, as has been shown - I appreciate that this will not console public workers at all - since taking the measures under the Savings Plan to adjust and correct the deficit, since the stress tests were carried out to see the real situation of our banks, and since we approved this whole raft of reforms, the pressure on Spanish sovereign debt has fallen considerably. The Treasury issues, in other words it finances in a more reasonable manner and - most importantly because it was what is behind everything - our banks have started to be able to issue and finance on the wholesale market, in other words, with other banks or together with the major investment funds, because the problem of the Spanish economy, although the decision and the response was in the public sector as regards the sovereign debt or deficit, is that there is significant private debt.

Sometimes when we discuss or I am challenged about "the Spanish sovereign debt is twenty points below the European average", it is true, this is right and we want to reduce it; but the pressure on the sovereign debt is not so much due to public debt, but rather due to high levels of private debt, corporate and family debt which, logically, is in the hands of the banks; the banks need to refinance it, but to refinance it they need to seek funds from overseas and this situation has now improved.

Carles Francino. .- Tell us one thing, Mr. President. If in a crisis such as the present one the workers are contributing and paying their part by way of job losses, and tens of thousands of small and medium-sized enterprises have fallen by the wayside, and civil servants' salaries have been frozen and other workers have cut their own salaries, what are the banks contributing to help exit the crisis? How are they lending a hand?

President of the Government .- The banks, as you are aware, are now going to be subject to a new tax; but let's not kid ourselves nor play our cards close to our chests. The fact that our banks are in a good state is good for the economy. If the banks don't have a solvency margin, a profit margin, they can't finance companies and companies can't invest, and if the banks aren't solvent, they can't finance consumers so that they consume or so that they take out a mortgage.

Hence, the economy is everything and, of course, the financial system is our backbone. Fortunately, the financial system in our country has weathered the storm well, and we haven't had to invest public funds in the banks; we should remember that. We have provided them with guarantees so that they can seek funding and we have acquired their assets; but the value of these assets is in the hands of the public sector and hence we have charged them. In other words, we are going to make a profit, in the public sector, for having supported the banks.

G. Nierga .- Mr. President, let's get back to the worker. I think I heard you say that there will be no more changes, that you won't undertake more reforms…

President of the Government .- Cuts.

G. Nierga .- In the case of unemployment benefits, will there be any further changes, in other words, will any other tough measures be put in place? For example, I have heard… if a worker does not accept a job in the first month, then his unemployment benefit will be taken away. Is the Government thinking along these lines?

President of the Government. .- The Government is now, I have already stated this and I'll repeat it, undertaking a reform of active employment policies at the level of the labour market. We invested eight billion euros in active employment policies in our country and the results are not positive. We have to put more emphasis on training than on tax credits, because the society that we live in and the best models for workers to have the best employment opportunities and to keep their jobs are those that place most emphasis on training their workers. In other words, it is a question of thinking more about the individual worker and his specific needs than in his job or in the company receiving tax breaks.

This is the reform that we seek to undertake and we wish to carry it out through dialogue with the trade unions and business leaders; but it is vital that we invest more resources and work more closely with the worker who needs work and, of course, with the worker that needs training to keep his job.

A. Barceló .- The problem is, Mr. President, that when you say "there won't be any more cuts", this seems somewhat incompatible with the statement of yours to the effect that "I will take more measures come what may, whatever it takes". It makes one think that when the President is thinking about "whatever it takes", he is thinking about unpopular measures, to put a name to it, and this seems incompatible with "there won't be any more cuts".

President of the Government .- I have said that we don't have any more cuts planned, and there is currently no objective need to do so, that the progress of reducing the deficit is being met and that what lies ahead is continuing with reforms. I have just spoken about the reforms of the active employment policy and I consider this essential, because I believe that all people agree that the economy is going to recover and growth is going to consolidate, although…

M. Domínguez .- When?

President of the Government .- We already have growth, there was second-quarter growth, albeit weak, and we hope that by the end of the year or at the beginning of 2011 this growth will allow us to create clear employment, albeit weak.

G. Nierga - In other words, the worst is behind us, Mr. President - an expression we have heard on various occasions? President of the Government.- That depends on what perspective you look at it from.

G. Nierga .- And what perspective do you look at it from?

President of the Government .- I believe that from a general perspective it is reasonable, according to the possibilities that the European economy, or the world economy or our own data has of growth, for us to consider that we are in a position to consolidate the path to economic recovery in order to grow, that it will be hard for this growth to be significant, that it will be hard for this growth to go hand in hand with clear job creation and that for these reasons we need to continue with our reforms: reforms of active employment policies, reforms of energy policies, reforms of industrial policies and pension reforms. This is a politically difficult chapter and agenda, but absolutely essential for us.

Carles Francino . - Shall I set a deadline? Well, I shan't set it, it was set the other day here in SER by the Minister for Work, Celestino Corbacho. He said, "if things go according to plan, in three or four years we will revert back to the employment rates of prior to the crisis". Is this a realistic assessment? Is this overoptimistic? Is it accurate? Three or four years to get back to where we were before?

President of the Government ..- If things go according to plan, and if the world economy recovers at a reasonable pace, it is a forecast that could be defended. But we have all gone through things in this crisis, more than ever before, that can change in twenty-four hours. We would certainly not be talking about wage cuts of public workers or freezing pensions if there hadn't been a crisis in Greece, that's clear; but there was a crisis in Greece and we were faced with two choices: ignore it, but the European Union couldn't ignore it, the markets couldn't ignore it… This affected us decisively and we had to make a plan to reduce the deficit much quicker than we had previously forecast.

So, who can tell us if, in six months' time, the North American economy - hopefully not and that wouldn't seem to be the case - has…

Carles Francino .- Which applied other very different measures, by the way.

A. Barceló .- Absolutely.

President of the Government .- We can argue about this all you want, but I should remind you that investment in infrastructure in Spain, as a percentage of GDP, is significantly higher than in the United States, and I should remind you that the Local Investment Plan of five billion euros is in force this year.

We have applied stimulus and adjustment policies, but I understand perfectly that you sometimes say "the Government rectifies". It is an epithet attributed to us continually.

Carles Francino .- But there is nothing wrong with rectifying. President of the Government.- Understood in the sense that is sometimes understood, I think this should at least be clarified. The Government is assessing the situation, but the Government does not have its route planned out, it responds to the landmarks along its route. If the pressure on our sovereign debt is mitigated, if the deficit is corrected sufficiently and if State revenue operates well, we will have a bigger margin than when we had to adopt these tough measures in May. It would be ridiculous to stick to a fixed heading when the economy changes and the reality and the perception of the markets and international bodies changes, in the same way as consumer trends change. There are months in which confidence falls and other months in which consumer confidence recovers. It changes, things change.

M. Domínguez .- You talk about confidence and this is key because, when talking about Greece, Spain has a problem of credibility. The banks were forced into a corner, moreover, for Spain to have to take these solvency tests, these stress tests; well they came out of it well; but you, as President of the Government, do you think they have passed this confidence test, this credibility test? Because it seems as if they don't believe us and we don't know if there is no confidence in the Spanish economy or if they don't believe the Spanish President of the Government.

President of the Government .- I beg to differ. Since we carried out the fiscal adjustment plan, when this situation took place regarding pressure and questions being asked of the Spanish economy, with the austerity plan, with the reforms that we have applied and with the stress tests, there can be no doubt whatsoever and you have the data - in this respect you can't argue with the markets and investors - that the pressure on our sovereign debt has fallen and today our issues are at a much more reasonable price, and as regards our banks, which just two months ago received no funding, no-one would lend them money and the interbank system was virtually closed, well now the doors are open.

Hence, if this is the acid test, then yes they have recovered their credibility and confidence.

M. Domínguez .- In the banks yes, but the Government is sending out conflicting signals: taxes are going to be raised; it is not only the workers who are going to foot the bill of this crisis. Are we going to put taxes up? No, not now. One minister says one thing, another says another thing, and we are seeing the local authorities making rectifications. Don't you think that the Government's route planner needs re-tuning

President of the Government .- No. I repeat, if now, compared with May, the 12 May which was the day on which I presented Parliament with this tough adjustment plan, the situation has improved, it would seem reasonable that we can, in some respects, such as infrastructures or the debt capacity of the local authorities, open up the possibilities a bit more. This is the reason. It is not a rectification, it is a response to an improvement and if only…

Carles Francino. .- A correction, which is different.

A. Barceló .- A toning down.

President of the Government .- No.

G. Nierga .- For me it is a rectification, Mr. President. I think it is forcing the issue when you say that you are constantly rectifying, changing course or even, when ministers contradict each other.

President of the Government .- In all truth, for me the worst thing would be if we were a Government which sought to obfuscate and which, if things improved, wouldn't invest more or allow the local authorities… That would be obfuscation. As if we made a plan on 12 May, that is untouchable! That type of Government would be a disaster. We must pay heed to circumstances, that's normal, and let's hope that conditions improve to finance our debt, that the deficit keeps improving and that next year, or within two months or perhaps three, the margin improves to reduce the cuts we made. That's sufficiently clear, isn't it?

A. Barceló .- At any event, would you recognise, Mr. President, that - Gemma insists that it is a rectification - this legislation was doomed from the start, that is to say, the legislation was published, the correction was a mistake, in inverted commas, in the Official State Gazette (BOE in Spanish) and four months later there is a rectification, toning down or clarification, I don't care which. Which one is the right one? Because now you can convince me that the things have changed, but as it was something complicated from the start, it is hard to believe, I agree, that things change, but is it not impossible to prepare a route map with different Plan Bs, in other words, if things get better we can take this road? Because this is not the sensation that the Government gives when it announces a measure.

President of the Government. .- Are we not seeing that President Obama has now launched a new stimulus plan and before he launched an adjustment plan, and that Chancellor Merkel has launched a deficit reduction plan? It changes to fit the circumstances. Plan B is having initiatives and measures already drawn up in case things get better or worse, as the case may be.

This is like in a company or a family. Or do companies have an untouchable five-year investment and expense plan? No, because it all depends on whether they sell more or less, on how the market evolves. Or can companies rectify but not the Government? Please! Surely you can understand this.

G. Nierga .- You spoke before about the tax on banks. Can you give us more information? What will this new tax consist of?

President of the Government. .- I think the European Union has established a framework for the financial entities - in Spain we have the so-called Deposit Guarantee Fund - to contribute so that they can be salvaged in the event of a crisis. We don't have all the details yet. At any event, the banks, or under our model, savings banks, are going to be asked to make a preventive effort and have increased funds compared with current capital levels to be able to deal with a particular potential bankruptcy or a crisis situation.

Carles Francino. .- The name of the Minister for Work and Immigration, Celestino Corbacho, cropped up earlier. Are you going to take advantage of his leaving the Government to carry out a major reshuffle? Yes or no?

President of the Government .- That's not my plan.

A. Barceló .- Is the Government going to remain the same?

Carles Francino. .- The Minister for Housing, for Culture, for Science…? Are things going to remain the same?

President of the Government. .- Yes.

A. Barceló .- And this "for the time being"? How long will it last? How long will this "for the time being" last"

President of the Government. .- In this sense, I think that we can be assured from a certain point of view, in that I believe the Government is currently carrying our highly responsible tasks. I have said this before, these months are going to be decisive, depending on how we do things, for the future economy for the next two decades or so and also for our future prosperity. The Government is ready for this economic task and any factor that might prejudice this circumstance would surely only waste time and that doesn't seem right.

M. Domínguez .- Has Minister Garmendia asked to leave?

President of the Government .- Far from it. She is astounded by this rumour. But as we all know, sometimes rumours and news… I have spoken with her…

G. Nierga .- Where did the rumour start?

President of the Government .- Don't ask me.

G. Nierga .- From her Ministry, didn't it?

President of the Government .- No, of course not. I was with her in Japan and China, which, from an economic point of view was very interesting and all I saw was her laden down with projects and work. So …

A. Barceló .- Mr. President, would you sacrifice Celestino Corbacho as Minister for work because you are afraid of what might happen in Catalonia, because you believe Catalonia needs Celestino Corbacho, such as things are, in the elections?

President of the Government .- This was a decision taken by him and the PSC. The Minister for Work told me that he was interested and that he had received a proposal to appear on the parliamentary lists for Catalonia, and I feel my answer should be one of respect, because I understand that Corbacho is someone with a very high profile in Catalonia and I believe he could contribute to the struggle, to the difficult electoral struggle ahead of us from now to November.

G. Nierga .- Do you fear a debacle? Resuming Angels' words, are you afraid of what might happen. Are you afraid of a socialist debacle?

President of the Government .- What will happen, will happen.

G. Nierga .- And what will happen?

President of the Government. .- There will be a clear winner, a very clear winner and we will come out of it with a certain modesty knowing that it is a difficult competition, since we cannot ignore that we are going through a tough economic crisis, which also affects Catalonia and that, moreover, things have happened in relation to the Estatut. But the Socialist Party always goes out to compete and, in my opinion, it competes seriously in the form of President Montilla.

G. Nierga .- But for that reason you would prefer the elections to take place before the ruling on the Estatut is given, wouldn't you? But Montilla wouldn't, isn't that true?

President of the Government. .- That is another of the things I have read and it is like the case of Garmendia. I believe that the elections in Catalonia should take place when the President of the Regional Government…

G. Nierga .- Isn't it true that you asked President Montilla to hold them before the summer?

President of the Government. .- No, because there is a mutual respect between presidents, let's say. It would also be strange if the president of a regional government asked me for a decision on something extremely personal, such as dissolving Parliament and calling elections.

G. Nierga .- But there is also mutual respect between general secretaries but Tomás Gómez was asked not to stand, wasn't he? Isn't there also respect there?

President of the Government. .- Yes, but we are talking about the party; institutions are quite another matter. They are clearly different situations.

M. Domínguez .- If Tomás Gómez wins the primary elections in Madrid on 3 October, will you take it as the flood gates opening in protest at Rodríguez Zapatero as general secretary of your party?

President of the Government. .- For me there are two important things in the primary elections in Madrid: the first, moving from the party to society, is that the militants feel free to vote - and they do feel this, have no doubts about that, they are going to vote with all the freedom in the world - and, moreover, they can feel proud of being politically active in a party which fights its battles through a democratic process to see who the candidate is.

I have mentioned on several occasions that everyone knows that I have preferences, but that, as Federal General Secretary of the party, I wish to be as respectful as possible in the primary election process. Whoever wins, the Socialist Party wins, whoever wins will be my candidate and, of course, whoever wins the Party will be fully behind that candidate.

My second consideration; I am convinced that there are possibilities, and this will be strengthened by the primary elections, of there being changes in the Regional Government of Madrid and that Jaime Lissavetzky for the City Council and Trinidad Jiménez or Tomás can make this change. You all know my preferences.

M. Domínguez .- Yes, but whoever wins, Mr. President, your authority remains in doubt..

President of the Government. .- That is a model of leadership that I simply don't share.

Carles Francino. .- But although you don't share it, how can you convince people that you haven't been defeated?

President of the Government .- I share a model of democratic leadership, and that is the model I have employed since day one, wholeheartedly, and I shared this when I won the election to become General Secretary of the Socialist Party. In my career as a political leader I have appointed many people, I have formed many Executives and Governments, but I have never thought, I have never looked to see who had the support or who had the support of who in the Congreso [Lower House of Parliament] when I was elected as General Secretary.

In all sincerity, I believe that one of the things that makes the Socialist Party so strong is its attitude towards the people, because it seems normal to me that, as General Secretary of the Socialist Party I have an opinion. I have one because I know Trinidad Jiménez very well. I know Trinidad Jiménez much better than I know Tomás Gómez., and if I were asked to choose someone on the grounds of their values of generosity, of capacity for dialogue and integration, and also having seen how his capacity for management has triumphed in the public administration, I am sure that Trinidad Jiménez would always be at the top of the list. But I also have great respect for Tomás Gómez, as is natural.

But, and I insist, whoever wins I will feel strengthened, because that will be the way in which the Socialist Party of Madrid is going to be strengthened - I have no doubts about that - and no-one can take that away from us, neither from the Party or from me. No-one is going to take away our pride at going out to vote and when the results come in, whoever wins, they can say "here we all are, standing together as one".

G. Nierga .- But Mr. President, if you are so proud of the primary elections, singing their praises, why did you try to avoid them? President of the Government.- I did not try to avoid them

G. Nierga .- You asked Tomás Gómez not to stand.

President of the Government. .- It so happens that I could have avoided them, because the Federal Executive is empowered to refuse to hold primary elections, but I didn't do that. I conveyed to Tomás Gómez - as I believe to be right, with the style of leadership that I wish to have - my opinion regarding the elections in Madrid and that we had, we have, someone in a position to win.

Furthermore, I even remember the expression I used, an expression from the legal world: "whoever exercises a right offends no-one". We are going to resolve it democratically if Trinidad is appointed as candidate.

We have spent years saying that the parties are not very democratic and criticism would be comprehensible if I had said "there are no primary elections and we'll turn to the Federal Committee to appoint the candidate of my choice".

G. Nierga .- I would still criticise the attempt not to hold primary elections. Whilst it is true that this was not imposed, an attempt was made nonetheless.

President of the Government .- And you could criticise it if there were primary elections… No, no I didn't try to stop them. I repeat, I could have stopped the primaries and it falls under my powers as General Secretary of the Socialist Party to give an opinion in that respect - I have never been someone to avoid taking responsibility - on calling elections.

A. Barceló .- This opinion has been given because of the opinion polls, opinion polls that, at this time, as leader of the Socialist Party, are not very favourable to you. Can we apply the situation in Madrid to the leadership, to the General Secretary of the party? President of the Government.- I believe that elections are more important than these polls.

A. Barceló .- Yes, but polls are put forward when deciding if there are primaries and Tomás Gómez doesn't come out of the polls well.

President of the Government .- That is another statistic in this case. I think there are other statistics, other aspects that are quite reasonable. I look at the polls - which are used on some occasions but not on others. They have their value, but it would be ridiculous to consider them definitive.

We are now looking to the 2011 elections. The other day in a meeting of the Government someone made a reference to the 2012 elections. They will arrive in their own good time; what we are faced with now, as a Party task, is firstly Catalonia, and secondly the elections in May 2011. We are getting our candidates ready and we will try to choose the best candidates for the people.

Carles Francino. .- Is there any hypothesis regarding early elections? That is to say, will there be an agreement with the Basque Nationalist Party [PNV in Spanish] on the Budget and, if not, will there be an extension? In other words, is there any hypothesis regarding early elections?

President of the Government - We are working on an agreement with the PNV. Approval of the 2011 Budget would be good for the economy, it would be good for stability, it would be good for confidence and it is necessary for some of the measures that we have to apply and that have been approved already.

Hence, talks with the PNV are currently underway. I hope, not only the PNV, but also the other parliamentary groups, such as the Canarian Coalition [CC in Spanish] or the Navarrese People's Union [UPN in Spanish], in other words, those who traditionally have a more favourable approach towards understanding and towards facing up to a challenge…

Yesterday you saw the votes on the labour market reform despite a general strike having been called. I understand that the parliamentary groups abstain because they don't govern and they are part of the opposition; taking on commitments of responsibility is never easy. And hence the infamous 12 May, and the measures of the adjustment plan, those groups who lent their support, although from at a distance by abstaining in respect of the Government - I have said this publicly and I will say it again - they made a great contribution to this country. We wouldn't be talking today about discussing the rectification of local authority debt, which benefits local authorities, and hence the people, if those measures had not been taken.

A. Barceló .- Mr. President, you are in talks with the PNV, where does that leave the President of the Basque Regional Government, Patxi López?

President of the Government. .- Patxi López is, of course, fully involved in the talks. The Socialist Party is in talks, the Government is in talks and a large part of these talks involves possible transfers.

A. Barceló .- That's why I am asking, because the transfers should be negotiated with the Regional Government rather than with the opposition party.

President of the Government. .- My opinion, taking into account that the Basque Nationalist Party is a very important party in the Basque Country , is that we need talks with both groups. This is what the Government is going to do and it will try to reach some kind of common ground, above all, in a matter that bizarrely, has been on the table for many years now and - and probably most of you don't know this - the Basque Country is the only autonomous region that has not had active employment policies transferred, because there was a discrepancy regarding the scope of this transfer, but we are now trying to reach the end of negotiations so that the Basque Country - and, by the way, this has a lot to do with how the Basque Regional Government runs its affairs; it has very favourable economic figures; in addition tourism figures have risen this summer and everyone has told me that they have had a good time in the Basque Country - can control its own active employment policies.

M. Domínguez .- You cannot imagine everyone's satisfaction, shared I imagine, to hear the Basque Country spoken about in economic terms and not in political terms; but we cannot ignore the fact that ETA has made a statement on a ceasefire, which has been very sceptically received everywhere and that previously Batasuna had requested ETA to call a ceasefire. What conditions will they have to meet but which they haven't yet met for Batasuna to stand in the upcoming elections?

President of the Government .- Two things are clear. The first is that Batasuna, or what we call Batasuna, the 'izquierda abertzale' makes an outright condemnation of violence and hence, that is does not deal ambiguously. It won't work just saying "we request a democratic process"; no, there must be a condemnation of violence.

M. Domínguez .- And what they have done to date is not enough?

President of the Government .- No.

And secondly, this hypothesis would be greatly reinforced by the clear condition that ETA has to be brought to an end definitively.

The truth is that this process, during which we have seen this statement and we have seen that the 'izquierda abertzale' is asking ETA to stop, this will have to be substantiated sooner or later with an end to violence and to ETA, which will certainly not be easy because it is an experience that we haven't gone through before and it will be hard, as always.

But there is no doubt that our antiterrorism policy and the weakness of those who have practised violence or who support violence in one way or another is a clear fact and this Government has modestly contributed towards that. It is a merit of all democracy but, without any doubt, our antiterrorism policy, and this should be highlighted, has been very successful.

Carles Francino. .- Mr. President, as regards this latest statement from ETA, much has been said and it has been said very clearly and unanimously, without any rifts. Let's put ourselves in the best-case scenario; if ETA issues a statement tomorrow announcing that it will disarm, what will the Government's first step be?

President of the Government .- The Government's first step must be to count on the democratic political forces. The other day I pointed out that the best aspect of the statement from ETA has been the reaction of the parties, because it was unanimous. We cannot predict events. The Government must have, as was mentioned, a Plan B and in this matter, a Plan C even; but the most important thing, the step that the Government would take consists of sharing this hypothesis with the democratic political forces. The response has to come from all sides and it seems to me that for prudent reasons, I shouldn't make any comment about what steps would need to be taken.

G. Nierga .- Is the Government currently in contact with any part of ETA or is anyone in contact on behalf of the Government? President of the Government.- No, absolutely not. Nobody, no-one. And furthermore, you know that …

G. Nierga .- Hence, the Government has no information as regards whether the possibility of ETA definitively disarming is being tackled?

President of the Government. .- No, we don't have that information. We may have, as is logical, information about the channels that the Government uses in a matter that affects State security, but we don't have any firm information about ETA's intentions and, since we don't have any firm information, and taking into account their track record, we have to be wary.

The Minister for Home Affairs said it the other day: ETA has stopped partly because it can't go on and partly because of what 'izquierda abertzale' is doing, but they should know that we are wary. And 'izquierda abertzale' is well aware of that, because fresh in everyone's mind, in the Government's mind, in their mind, in 'izquierda abertzale's' mind and very clearly in my mind is the attack on Terminal 4 and the victims of Terminal 4 right in the middle of a process of dialogue. Hence, we are very wary. The evidence they will need to put on the table for democracy and the Government to be convinced to take them seriously, that they are going to disarm, that it will end, will need to be very compelling.

That is what I want them to know and I am convinced that the majority of Batasuna appreciates and is aware that this is our position.

Carles Francino. .- Mr. President, we are talking about terrorism and we are doing so on the eve of 9/11 - another type of violence or terrorism. You have a meeting today with the Secretary General of NATO, it is now nine years since the attacks and we have also had a presence in Afghanistan for a long time now. Is a date going to be set soon for our withdrawal or will we remain there, I wouldn't say indefinitely, but for a long time still?

President of the Government. .- There will be a NATO Summit in Lisbon in November. In that NATO Summit, Afghanistan will be one of the main topics of debate and a medium-term strategy plan may well be drawn up. As progress is made in our current work, which is the most difficult, as we have unfortunately seen, we can see that Afghanistan could be a country which could work on its own and which could guarantee its own security, hence the time until our withdrawal is getting ever shorter. To achieve that, it is fundamental that we train the military and the police force. The extent of the progress made will determine the time of our withdrawal.

A. Barceló .- Are you not operating with an approximate date in mind?

President of the Government. .- I believe that in November, at the NATO Summit, we could have a more approximate date. A. Barceló.- Allow me to ask you about Iraq. One of the first things, if not the first thing that you did was to withdraw our troops. Subsequently a commitment was made to the United States to return there with a small force of Guardia Civil. Does that commitment still exist?

President of the Government. .- It will not be necessary. In the foreseeable future it will not be necessary.

A. Barceló .- So no Guardia Civil will need to go there? President of the Government.- No. In principle, no.

Carles Francino. .- Does fear remain the main actor on the international stage nine years on from 9/11, Mr. President?

President of the Government. .- I think that, rather than fear, the collective and shared conscience is that the most significant risk for world security is Islamic terrorism and for that reason Afghanistan is important, because Afghanistan has been a country, in inverted commas, which has provided, supported and trained radical Islamic terrorists. The Taliban regime and the Taliban themselves are a fundamental factor.

Hence, there is a great collective conscience and there also exists an approach from the international community and from the important countries, I would say unanimously, that says that as well as military intervention, such as in Afghanistan, it is necessary to consolidate such interventions and carry on to the very end; a whole preventive policy needs to be made. What we are going through in the last few hours with this American Protestant pastor…

Carles Francino. .- It's inconceivable.

President of the Government. .- It's totally inconceivable, but the reaction is very important. In other words, the fact that we have seen President Obama involved in stopping these acts is a factor that contributes towards there being no argument, no excuse for radical Islamists to seek to extend this radicalism to the vast majority of pacific Muslims who do not support the jihad. And this resounding reaction towards an attempt to attack Islam, more so due to the methods that this man seeks to use, I sincerely believe that this helps and that there are many Muslim and Islamic countries who are contributing to this collective security and towards this shared policy.

Carles Francino. .- Is Spain, Mr. President, playing any kind of important role in the sidelines, that we don't know about, in the Middle East peace process?

President of the Government. .- Yes it is, and that is easy to understand because, if there is a Minister for Foreign Affairs in the world that has the capacity for dialogue and exchange with Palestinians and Israelis, it is Minister Moratinos. And not only with Palestine and Israel, but with all countries in the area, where we have a great capacity for dialogue. We are constantly working in this area, in contact with the North American Administration and, of course, in contact with the Quartet.

M. Domínguez .- You spoke about President Obama. Will we be seeing him in Spain or will we have to make do with his wife and daughter's unofficial visit.

President of the Government .- Which was no bad thing. M. Domínguez.- It's great, particularly for the South. But is there… A. Barcelo.- President Obama will soon be in Portugal. He will be attending the Summit in Portugal.

M. Domínguez .- And since he will be in Portugal, have you talked about or looked at the possibility…?

President of the Government. .- No plans have been made and we should be careful because expectations always run high. Let's be prudent. President Obama has an agenda, as you can imagine…

M. Domínguez .- A very complicated agenda. And he also has elections.

President of the Government. .- Yes, in November

G. Nierga .- Mr. President, this week Santiago Carrillo said, on Cadena SER, that each time he sees you he is reminded of Adolfo Suárez and I asked him why. He said that because you are out there all on your own, "he reminds me of Adolfo Suárez at a time when television broadcast a lot of security and I thought 'you don't realise what's behind you'". And he then made that comment. I would like you to think about or, for you to give us some kind of reaction to this comment from Santiago Carrillo.

President of the Government. .- I greatly admire Santiago Carrillo and, since I know that he greatly admires Adolfo Suárez, I take it in a very kind manner.

G. Nierga .- No, it wasn't a kind comment at all, quite the opposite. If you have understood it in that way, then I have expressed myself awfully.

M. Domínguez .- Do you feel that you are out there all on your own? President of the Government. .- Gemma, you can interpret Santiago Carrillo and I can too. I insist, I have a very good relationship with Santiago Carrillo and I greatly appreciate him. There are times in Government, and this is one of them, when decisions which need to be taken and responsibilities which need to face up to are difficult. This, shall we say, make the sensation of difficulty even more profound and it always seems that in difficult times you are on your own. But I can say that I have a deep conviction that I am taking the right decision for Spain, that I am facing up to my responsibilities and that - and Angels Barcelo just reminded me of this - I said this to the Lower House of Parliament and I was quite clear, that I am going to take them come what may, because we need Spain to make reforms if we want to have a sound economy and continue increasing prosperity, a Welfare State and social policy.

G. Nierga .- But do you feel you are out there on your own?

President of the Government. .- No. Fortunately, as I could show you, I have a Government team, a party and a parliamentary group that back me in an exemplary manner each day. You can understand, and I think that all our citizens do understand, that the Socialist Parliamentary Group is not keen on voting, it doesn't vote enthusiastically, salary cuts - no-one makes them - and yet there has been a sense of responsibility which, by the way, transcends the President of the Government at this time. I believe that this shows a sense of responsibility from the Socialist Party, which has shown it from back in 1977, and that any President of the Government… There was Felipe González, who had his difficult moments, who had to make some very difficult decisions, who also had to face difficult situations in regard to the economy. It is in the very DNA of the Socialist Party to never try to hide; it faces up to its responsibilities.

A. Barceló .- Mr. President, you don't feel like you are out there on your own, but are you up for fighting for a further four years? President of the Government.- That's a leading question

A. Barceló .- It's a question, Mr. President.. President of the Government.- I am as enthusiastic and strong as on my first day. Full stop.

Carles Francino. .- So you will be standing for re-election? A. Barcelo.- That is even more of a leading question. President of the Government.- Exactly. I said that I would talk about this when the time is right and now is not the right time; let's allow democracy to take its course and talk next year.

M. Domínguez .- Are there better candidates than yourself to win the Socialist Party elections?

President of the Government .- On some occasions you will have heard me say that no-one can consider themselves better than anyone else. Of course there are good candidates in the Socialist Party, as in Madrid, where we have good candidates to fight in the primaries. But all things in their own good time. I am currently almost exclusively focused - to say exclusively would be an exaggeration - in carrying out the reforms, in getting the Budget sorted out, in ensuring that we have an outlook which, in my opinion, is going to be crucial, at around January or February when things are calmer in terms of the consolidation of economic recovery, when we have a horizon for healthy public finances permitting our banks to start providing finance and that we start to see job creation.

The months between now and January and February are decisive and there is much to do. We have to devote ourselves to that.

A. Barceló .- The vagueness, or lack of awareness of what Rodríguez Zapatero is going to do can cause certain movements within the Party, of people starting to jostle for position in case Rodríguez Zapatero doesn't stand in the end. That is why I ask will a situation of calm help Rodríguez Zapatero to reach a decision? President of the Government.- My decision will be taken when it needs to be taken, but I can assure you that the Party is very relaxed.

I have just mentioned that we have had to tackle an extraordinary situation due to its difficulty and we have tackled it as a mature political force, responsive and united. When the decision is taken about 2012, it will come about in a natural way.

M. Domínguez .- As a socialist or a social-democrat, there are those that affirm that Brussels has left us no room to manoeuvre and you are adopting the same policy that Mariano Rajoy could adopt if he were President of the Government. Is there any room at the moment to manoeuvre to govern as a socialist or as a social-democrat, or would all Governments be doing the same as you if they were in your shoes?

President of the Government. .- Of course there is room for manoeuvre and we have shown this even in the crisis. I have given an example of this: we have increased unemployment benefits, even at a time of crisis, to reach 80% cover, which means that we have more unemployment protection than the vast majority of European countries despite having the highest unemployment rate.

That is a reflection of a social-democratic policy. Not touching education or the health system is a reflection of a social-democratic policy; but a social-democratic policy has to be a forward-thinking policy and looking at the future we can see that we have to create a more productive and more competitive economy; that for me is a progressive value.

You have never heard me say to the people that I am in favour of reducing the working day. I believe that in order to be a powerful country with extensive social policies we have to work and we also have to think about pensions in the year 2015. I am proud that this Government has been the one to most raise pensions ever and I believe that within eight, ten or fifteen years we will be able to continue raising them.

G. Nierga .- We started by talking about the general strike. So that it is quite clear, if the general strike is a success, will there be consequences, will there be changes?

President of the Government. .- I said at the start of the interview that I would like to continue talks with the trade unions. If you ask me about labour reform, my commitment and my decision is to maintain them. But I would say again that we have areas of dialogue, active employment and pension policies, where, of course, where I will call the trade unions. And I hope that, as they have done at least over these years where they have acted so responsibly, they will maintain their capacity for dialogue and I believe that they will continue to do so.

G. Nierga .- For my part, just one last question, but I would like to tell our listeners first that we are in a room with a photograph of Suárez playing the tambourine, another photograph of Felipe tending to his bonsais and Aznar riding his bike. What photograph of Rodríguez Zapatero shall we put on the wall?

President of the Government. - I haven't thought about that.

G. Nierga .- Which one would you like? Jogging, perhaps?

President of the Government .- The idea is a good one since it shows the plurality that exists in Moncloa.

G. Nierga .- The one of Suárez playing the tambourine is fazing, isn't it?

President of the Government. .- It is true that this building is full of photos of my predecessors, which I think is great. I see them almost every day in the photos, and hence you share the fact that they have also gone through hard times. Which photo would I like? Yes, a photo of…

M. Domínguez .- In your tracksuit.

President of the Government. .- Yes, something simple. That's the best thing that should go with power.

Carles Francino. .- Two very simple things to finish off on. Firstly, in all these hard times, have you felt at any time a sense of failure? Have you felt yourself a failure at any time?

President of the Government. .- A failure as such? I don't know if that's the word, but a certain incomprehension, above all as regards the market behaviour which, in my opinion, overharshly punished the economic situation and the public finances in Spain, yes. In that sense, we have tried to turn over a lot of work to explain the economic strength of our country so that this sensation that existed a few weeks ago, which was truly overwhelming and very harsh on Spain, could be turned around.

Carles Francino. .- And finally, which has changed most in these last six and a half years, Rodríguez Zapatero or Spain?

President of the Government. .- I imagine that a bit of both, don't you think? But Spain, in my opinion, has changed in respect of its position in the world in a very clear way, not only because we have established a foreign policy very closely linked to certain pacific values, of cooperation and dialogue, but also because we have been seen and we are seen as a very modern country as a result of all the changes we have made in our national legislation. During this time we have improved social rights, I remind the trade unions of that often, and now it is true that we are facing a great challenge, because we have been hard hit by the economic crisis over the last year and a half, above all in terms of unemployment, and we have to know, as we have always known, how to get back off the floor and work with confidence towards the future.

Carles Francino. .- And how have you changed?

President of the Government .- Basically I have learnt many things. It would be absurd to say I haven't changed. But in respect of my great passions and my vision of life, I haven't changed much, or so I hope.

Carles Francino. .- Mr. President, thank you for accepting this choir practice and we wish you luck.

President of the Government .- Thank you all very much and I would be pleased to come back again.