Interview with the President of the Government on "Las mañanas de Cuatro"

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 June 2009 · Interview on "Las mañanas de Cuatro" · Cuatro television studio

Context
Zapatero appeared on the Spanish morning television program "Las mañanas de Cuatro" on June 16, 2009, discussing the economy, taxes, and unemployment amid the financial crisis.
Main themes
Economic crisis and recovery, tax policy, unemployment, fiscal pressure, corporate tax cuts for SMEs, energy taxation, public services, opposition criticism, Bank of Spain forecasts, Spanish economy outlook
Duration
~68 min
97th percentile
Words
8,154
97th percentile
Sentences
373
97th percentile
Readability
53
71st percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
3.06
56th percentile
Vocabulary
2.17
41st percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

373 sentences in 190 paragraphs

Concha García Campoy: I am going to greet the President of the Government, thanking him very much for coming to our studio because you have been away for a while... It was about time.

President: It was a pending debt.

C.G.Campoy: Thank you very much, really. Thank you for fulfilling that commitment we had.

President: Late, but well...

C.G.Campoy: But well... It is important, moreover, I appreciate it a lot, because there are always important issues to address; now, a lot. In addition, there are many viewers who are very attentive to what you might say, because life, in many cases, and the economy depend on it.

This morning you have already had time to practically argue with the leader of the opposition, Mr. Rajoy.

President: Yes, to exchange some ideas, let’s say.

C.G.Campoy: They have reproached you for raising taxes five days after the elections, which has been a somewhat perverse strategy. They have reproached you. What do you...?

President: The reproach would be to anything, because they always reproach. But I must say about fiscal policy, as I recalled today in Parliament, that the Government I preside has lowered taxes: it has lowered the Personal Income Tax; it has lowered the Corporate Tax, we have been the first Government to help companies create economic activity, and we have eliminated the Wealth Tax, which is mainly paid by the middle classes and which was an obsolete tax compared to other countries. Therefore, we have made a tax cut of around twenty billion euros, which is 2 percent of the Gross Domestic Product.

Now we have raised tobacco taxes as a measure, not for revenue, but for the fight against smoking and a measure, therefore, in favor of health, as has been done in recent years; and also the hydrocarbon taxes, which have more revenue implications, which will bring in one billion euros more to the public treasury, the amount is one-tenth of the Gross Domestic Product and which, moreover, goes in the direction of saving energy, because we have to save energy and we have...

C.G.Campoy: But can you categorically say, Mr. President, that you will not raise taxes any further this year?

President: There is a very clear position: we have low tax pressure, we have reached 32.8 percent tax pressure. In 2004, when I came to Government, it was at 34 percent and, therefore, now we have less tax pressure. The European average is at 40 percent and, therefore, I have no intention... We must maintain state services, we must maintain benefits and in the Debate on the State of the Nation...

C.G.Campoy: You now have to collect. On the other hand, it has always been leftist to raise taxes.

President: I have an instrumental position towards taxes. There may be occasions, and depending on which taxes, where you can lower them to promote economic activity. I have announced, and I am going to do it, a further reduction of the Corporate Tax for SMEs, to generate employment, for those companies that maintain or create jobs, and, for example, raising the tobacco tax or the hydrocarbon tax, on gasoline, also has a positive purpose for the overall economy and society.

C.G.Campoy: So, we could say, for now, there will be no more tax increases.

President: No.

C.G.Campoy: Will there be no modification of the IRPF?

President: No.

C.G.Campoy: No. Radically, no.

President: No.

C.G.Campoy: Have we hit the ceiling with unemployment or not?

President: We will wait. What we are convinced of is that the most intense process of job loss, of job destruction, that process will not continue. We had a positive month of May, the month of June will also be positive in relation to employment and unemployment, we estimate that this may also be the case in July and August, and perhaps in October or in the fall we will have somewhat worse data; but, in any case, the process has slowed down in terms of losing jobs.

It is our great objective, it is the great objective of all Spanish society. This is related to the evolution of the economy: if the economy falls, unemployment increases; if the economy recovers, employment tends to stabilize.

C.G.Campoy: I believe you have said that the worst of the crisis has passed.

President: Yes.

C.G.Campoy: The Bank of Spain, I believe I understand, has also said that, indeed, there is a low point of inflection, that it may have bottomed out; however, unemployment will continue to rise until 2013, no less. So, that ceiling, let’s say, of five million seems to be something we could reach, right?

President: I think it is better to evaluate the forecasts, because, of course, when the Bank of Spain or the Government comes out with forecasts, it is that...

C.G.Campoy: The Bank of Spain has been giving you a hard time, its Governor, right?

President: Each one plays their role and there are times when the Bank of Spain is wrong; at other times, it is right. Regarding the forecasts, look, I am going to give you a piece of data; I gave it today in Parliament, but I recall: the International Monetary Fund and the European Commission have revised economic forecasts five times in the last year. Why? The evolution of the economy changes. There is no one today who can assure what the growth will be in 2010 or 2011. They are forecasts.

So, I think it is a bit absurd to have a debate about forecasts that leads us nowhere, because the Government has to make forecasts. We have had --it was our turn now-- to present compliance with the Stability Pact to present to the Autonomous Communities the deficit targets for next year. We have a series of milestones in which we are obliged to review the forecasts. But this is how it is.

C.G.Campoy: I also believe, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, that people, when they say "there will be more unemployment," more than wanting to talk about figures, what they often refer to is: "will we be worse off than we are?" Because it seems that the Government is indeed making a forecast to pay people who are left without any type of benefit, I believe it is four hundred euros; but then there are the middle classes, those impoverished classes, who are suffering a lot. And I can tell you that we do many reports here on middle-class families, on professionals, who are in social dining rooms. That is to say, there are very dramatic elements at this moment in many people in our society.

President: I must remind you that we have a fairly strong social protection system, that there are more than two million, 2,400,000 people receiving unemployment benefits, which is a guarantee; that we are going to improve, within the framework of social dialogue, unemployment benefits and that we have, in addition, an important level of family income that we have been achieving in recent years.

It is true that in a situation that produces difficulty, anguish, and concern, we have experienced this crisis very abruptly, very intensely; but the country as a whole, society, has strength, even in a crisis situation, to reach the maximum number of people, to maintain protection, to provide support and, more importantly, to recover economic activity and employment as soon as possible. For this reason, we are putting in a lot of effort, I believe they are starting to yield results, they will continue to yield results, and we hope, as some people think, that the international organizations in the next forecasts they revise, which they continuously revise, those revisions will be upward.

C.G.Campoy: And will there be labor reform? Because the Governor of the Bank of Spain also made that proposal: a permanent contract but with a reduction in the cost of dismissal, in some way.

President: What we need to reform in Spain is the growth model, because in recent years we have had a growth model where too much was invested in the real estate sector and that detracted resources from more innovative sectors, with more technological potential, with more added value, with more sustainability, with more future. This is the change we need to make and that is why in the Debate on the State of the Nation I announced a whole set of measures, including a Sustainable Economy Law, which fundamentally aim at that: to dynamize that the investment of a country, that the savings of families, of companies, of what is financed by banks, goes more towards that process.

C.G.Campoy: That is to say, there will be no labor reform. Change of growth model, but that issue will not be touched.

President: The labor reform, no. What we do need is an adaptation of the company to the new growth model. That will require dialogue and an agreement in collective bargaining to make it more flexible and adapt production to the conditions of the company and to the conditions of the economy.

But if, when we talk about labor reform, it is understood as facilitating dismissal more, reducing the cost of dismissal or restricting workers' rights, from here I say no, because it is not a solution, it does not contribute anything positive and the only thing it does is establish conditions of greater weakness for many workers.

C.G.Campoy: Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, the banks are in the spotlight; I mean banks, I mean savings banks. Many viewers call us and often say: "I am a person who can guarantee solvency, but they do not give me any credit."

These days, and forgive me because it may sound demagogic, but it has really been a big debate, there has been a credit of 152 million euros for the purchase of a football player from Real Madrid. And people say: "Is there money for that and I do not have money to lift my small business, or to get ahead, or to be able to practically eat"? That has been viewed negatively by many people. How do you judge that?

President: There are two things that it is convenient to clarify. In that, the Government has no intervention.

C.G.Campoy: No, of course. I wanted your impression. It is a private entity, of course.

President: Of course. But we cannot demand a free market economy, which is what is always demanded, and then, when there is something that is not liked in the market, and there are many things that I do not like, demand government intervention.

C.G.Campoy: But even Congress has already entered into whether such transfers can really be made.

President: It will enter, as is logical. But I must say that banks are an industry, they are the money industry, and we have moved from a stage, until the crisis, where the financial sector in general easily granted credits, to now, to a moment where banks have a huge fear, after what has happened, to facilitate credit.

C.G.Campoy: But the Government is behind and the Government is supporting, and they maintain that exaggerated fear towards their own clients.

President: It is supporting to guarantee deposits, because we had a financial crisis last autumn that was unprecedented, where large financial entities, the banking giants of the United States, Germany, or Belgium, collapsed. We have been fortunate that no bank has collapsed and, moreover, to be the country in Europe that has had to support banks with the least money.

Therefore, the guarantee to the banks, which, by the way, is not giving money to the banks...

C.G.Campoy: No, no. That is understood. But it is an important support.

President: It is in any case lending, and moreover, I can predict that the public money that the Government has dedicated to that will not be lost, but rather, on the contrary, that, because we logically charge commissions to the banks, we will calmly recover the guarantee we have given them.

Now banks are in a situation of risk aversion, as it is said; they are very afraid to give credit because they have to maintain their solvency. That is why the Government has launched a package of lines, a volume of lines, from the Official Credit Institute, up to 49 billion, which I know does not reach everyone and that I know there are many SMEs that are demanding.

C.G.Campoy: Mr. President, when, in my talk show, here, in the political talk show, some commentators say: "yes, but then the Government does not enforce this with the banks." Is that demagoguery or what is it?

President: The Government shares the risk with the banks, because the Government does not have a public bank. We do not decide the risk of granting a credit and, in my opinion, it would be bad for the Government to say to a company this credit yes, this credit no, or to an individual a mortgage. It has to be the private sector that assumes the risk. We share that risk, but banks have a relevant part in the function.

It is true that they are being overly cautious and fearful. I hope that as the financial system, and this is fortunately happening, stabilizes, normalizes, and we do not have more major scares of banks collapsing in the world, we can see how the financial system gradually recovers normality.

It is true that the Government, through the ICO, must seek, and in that task the economic Vice President is working, greater agility, greater ease, so that the ICO credits, which have the backing of the Government, reach, above all, small and medium-sized enterprises.

C.G.Campoy: Mr. President, allow me to ask you this question, because it has been a national debate and I know you will have an opinion, surely, on this. What do you think of Cristiano Ronaldo's signing by Madrid?

President.- I don't know if I am the most suitable person to talk about signings for Real Madrid, given...

C.G. Campoy.- As a "culé," at least, Mr. President.

President.- Of course, that's precisely why.

C.G. Campoy.- Let's step away from your position for a moment.

President.- That's precisely why I think I shouldn't make an excessive pronouncement. To me, all these amounts seem excessive, I say it as I feel it; but Real Madrid says it will make it profitable. The truth is that in football, if it didn't have so many people following the matches on television and going to the stadiums, we probably wouldn't see these figures in individuals.

Therefore, I don't like it in principle; but then, if it happens, it's because it has evident social strength. Let's be, shall we say, measured.

C.G. Campoy.- That is to say, that in some way you could somewhat agree with Mr. Laporta when he made those statements. He even talks about "imperialism." Perhaps he already used a very high terminology.

President.- I think that's already a bit of an exaggerated term, isn't it?

C.G. Campoy.- How do you think the Popular Party is handling its issues related to corruption?

President.- The truth is that what it has to do is facilitate collaboration with Justice. That is what, in my opinion, the citizenry must do in general, and in particular, those who represent the citizens and have public responsibilities. And, in my opinion, the rest of the political formations must be prudent.

I have not referred to this issue at any time, under any circumstances. The gentlemen of the Popular Party who are indicted, which is a long list, have the right to defense; but, in my opinion, the Popular Party and the leaders of the Popular Party have the political obligation, the duty, to facilitate the action of Justice, and the rest of the political forces must be prudent and respect the action of Justice. This seems fundamental to me.

What is not good for the rule of law, what is not good for democracy, is that when there is a judicial action that affects one or another political party, we question it based on who is involved. This seems to me to be a regression, and moreover, the citizenry does not believe it. That is to say, there may be actions that affect some and others, and all must be respected.

C.G. Campoy.- What do you feel when "El Mundo," specifically, has reported that the director of the CNI was using CNI funds to go hunting, fishing in South Africa, and for other private activities?

President.- He has denied that information. At the time, he appeared before the corresponding Commission in Congress, he explained it there, he will explain it again, and therefore, we have to be attentive to what he explains, as is logical and natural.

C.G. Campoy.- Has Mr. Chaves explained to you exactly what is happening with those subsidies to the company where his daughter worked?

President.- Nothing is happening. You see, Mr. Rajoy, on the same day he commented on the high number of indicted individuals and the possibility that the Supreme Court would analyze serious crimes by members of the PP, subsequently demanded responsibilities from Chaves. I believe there is no judicial action or any situation of which they are accusing Vice President Chaves, who for me is a very honest person.

C.G. Campoy.- At this point in the game, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, would you put your hand in the fire for anyone? For Chaves, for example?

President.- My conviction is that the majority of people in public service do so with honesty. That is my conviction and my experience of what I have seen in my environment. Does that mean there are no people whose behavior is inappropriate, illegal, and criminal in public life? No, there are, and what we have to assess is whether there is a response from Justice and whether they pay for it.

Everyone can agree that, in light of the multiple judicial proceedings, especially in the area of urban corruption, that have been taking place at the request, in most cases, of the Attorney General's Office or as a result of complaints that reach the Anti-Corruption Prosecutor's Office, that is what is important: that anyone who may have committed a crime is held accountable for it.

But it is, in my opinion, unfair to make a general assessment of the behavior of political representatives in general from there. And we must be, in my opinion, very respectful, collaborators with Justice, and consider these situations, alert to these situations, with the demands that citizens require.

C.G. Campoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, we have had European elections. You, if I'm not mistaken, have said that "the result has been very dignified." Did you go out to lose and did not lose by too much?

President.- No, but always, when you have millions of votes from citizens and close to 40 percent, which is a very high percentage, you have to value and deeply thank those who vote for the Socialist Party. I have enormous gratitude.

Therefore, it seems to me that, out of respect for the millions of people who have voted for you, who maintain their loyalty and support, which is our main asset, because the PSOE is what it is because of the citizens who vote for it and the people who vote for it, it seems to me that making any other type of consideration does not sufficiently take into account all the people who support you.

I will tell you more, in recent years --I will not refer to the moment I took over the leadership of the Socialist Party-- the Socialist Party has won more elections than it has lost. We must get used to the fact that on the same day we lost in Galicia, we won in the Basque Country. This is normal. We won the last European elections by two points and now we have lost by three; we have lost the last two general elections.

The only thing I have clear in my mind is that I took the Socialist Party, with the leadership of the colleagues who gave it to me, and we have won two general elections, we govern more Autonomous Communities than we did, we have more municipal power, because the Federation of Municipalities is ours, and therefore, we have significant strength.

Do we want to win the next elections, the municipal and regional ones? Of course, and we are going to put all the meat on the grill. Do we have the conditions to win them? Yes. Have we not won the Europeans? Yes.

C.G. Campoy.- But you know, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, perfectly well that there are people who are very irritated by that permanent optimism, that seeing the glass half full, because the glass is what you are saying, but it is the full part. There are people, I believe even voters of the Socialist Party, who would like to see a bit more humility, because that discourse of "we all won"... No. They haven't lost spectacularly, it is true; but there should be recognition, some self-criticism, right?

President.- Let's distinguish humility from respect for voters.

C.G. Campoy.- I know that the issue of humility touches you a lot, that you don't like being attacked for anything else.

President.- I believe that my political trajectory, and if I compare myself with other political leaders, I sincerely believe that...

C.G. Campoy.- Is the second term affecting you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, which is very dangerous?

President.- I believe that in the area of humility I can compete and that I have never made any display of any kind in what is political leadership and in what is my trajectory so far; no. Moreover, I believe that it is the most harmful thing that can exist for power.

Another thing is that we assume, with democratic naturalness, that you lose a European election by three points or win by two points is a normal situation in democracy when we have a competitive scenario with two major parties. I insist, on the same day you lose in Galicia, and it hurts us, and on the same day we win in the Basque Country.

C.G. Campoy.- Indeed. Leire Pajín was here the other day. If you had to make the decision to propose her again as Secretary of Organization of the party, I suppose you will obviously say yes, but she has also been rained down with criticism. Well, she has somehow focused the campaign's criticisms. It’s not bad to have a lightning rod, President of the Government.

President.- She coordinated the campaign but, honestly, what happens is that she is less known, from what I can tell, she has received more signs of support and backing, especially, of course, from the Socialist Party and from Socialist leaders, than criticism.

Leire Pajín is a very good leader of the Socialist Party, who has great support in the party; it is not just that she has support, she has it. Time will tell us. She has faced the first campaign, we did not win but we had a dignified result. I am certainly convinced that with her at the helm we can win many elections.

C.G. Campoy.- Mr. President, don't you think it is a mistake, as some people in your party think, that the issue of abortion has been handled in the way it has? That there will be a reform of the Law seems clear, but the issue of sixteen years, parental consent, as it has been raised, do you not think it is a mistake that has even hurt some people, some voters of the Socialist Party?

President.- My opinion is that the debate has been raised in terms that surprise me, I have to say it right off the bat, because until 2002, when the Law was changed by the Popular Party, this worked like this. That is to say, no young woman of sixteen or seventeen had to inform or ask for consent from her parents. And I wonder: all the voices we have heard now, what did they do from 1985 to 2002? Does anyone remember that this was a subject of debate?

Now, that this situation is being restored, that we have gone to make a law in line with the European average... And this is the objective: a law that, above all, has as its primary interest to avoid unwanted pregnancies, because there is a very large ground that can be gained in this direction; to make a law with more guarantees, with more guarantees for the woman and for the process of what is the process of voluntary interruption of pregnancy, and with the parameters of the average that exist in Europe. So, it surprises me that thirty years later we cannot have a much more... Everything can be debated, but to have a more dispassionate debate.

This is a debate that in other European countries, when laws similar to this have been made and promoted by center-right governments and by center-right majorities, is done in a more dispassionate manner and does not use the assertions, the statements, that have been made here.

We are trying to address a problem of reality, to do it openly, not hypocritically.

C.G. Campoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, apart from the fact that you have two daughters and I imagine that, logically, you would already be sensitive to these issues with daughters at home, I also have a daughter and one is very sensitive, logically, I think there is a question: you are always reproached for the poor communication that your Government has on this aspect. Things need to be explained well.

Bibiana Aído was here, she was with us, very kindly, but she said a phrase that sat badly with many, that of saying: "if a sixteen-year-old girl can get breast implants --she said literally--, she can make decisions about whether she is going to have a child or not without consulting anyone." That raised hackles. One must be a little sensitive with language too and how things are communicated, right?

President.- Yes, that is true. But things are also said about what this Law entails and about those of us who support this Law that are much more serious, much harsher, and yet, I do not see that such a debate is formed.

Objectively, I am not going to talk about communication, because we are in a free country and communication, above all, is an open system of media. What is strange, in this specific debate, are those two things that I highlight: one, that we are going to a law in line with the European average in terms of deadlines, in terms of guarantees and in terms of requirements, and this surprises; two, in the issue of sixteen years, which was so until 2002, curiously there was no debate nor did anyone tear their garments.

The Government is always open to improving and perfecting the Law, but from there to the great disqualifications, to the great adjectives, it seems to me that there is a path that leads us to absurdity, because my sincere opinion is that there is an excessive attempt to politicize advances of normality.

C.G. Campoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, there is a very important economic issue for this country, which is energy; nuclear energy yes or no. Garoña is in the background, whether it closes or not. By the way, in this regard, have you made any decision?

President.- We are making progress. We are logically studying the file and all the circumstances.

Regarding nuclear energy, I would like to say two things about it. There should be the essential nuclear power plants, for a reasonable time and with the maximum guarantee of safety.

I want to say that Garoña has been in operation for 38 years and, therefore, has two years left to reach forty; that in the world there is only one nuclear power plant in operation that is over forty years old and it will be closed in two years, which is in the United Kingdom; that in the United States, twenty nuclear power plants have already been closed, which were from the generation prior to Garoña, twenty; that France, Italy, Germany, and Japan have closed 39 nuclear power plants that did not reach forty years, and that at this moment there are six nuclear power plants, only six, that have a scenario for extension to exceed the age of forty years, which is the age considered as design life or useful life.

When we arrive at a plant that has already existed for four decades, the norm has been that it ceases to operate; I am not saying that it has to be automatic. The exception, the extension.

Therefore, we must take all these elements into account. Furthermore, in the case of Garoña, I must remind you that it has a neutral impact regarding what it represents in our energy system. In other words, it does not represent any...

C.G. Campoy.- It’s about 1 percent more or less, right?

President.- Yes. We export three times more electricity.

In short, we must take all these elements into account to make the decision.

C.G. Campoy.- I want you to hear this from a person that all Spaniards know, who has governed this country for many years and whose name is Felipe González: "There is an absolutely independent body, which is the Nuclear Safety Council, which says that the conditions of the plant allow for an extension of the useful life, at least, of ten years. Therefore, the Government can make one decision or another. I cannot influence that; I state my opinion. My opinion is that if it has a useful life of ten more years, taking into account all the factors (energy crisis, climate change, etc.), the life of the plant should be extended."

That is Felipe González's position. What do you think of Felipe González's opinion on Garoña, specifically?

President.- I find it respectable. It is true that this is a controversial issue, it is true that when he came to power he imposed a nuclear moratorium, even stopping several plants that were underway, and that there have been various changes regarding nuclear energy.

But always, even with some other comment that I heard him make in this interview, things are never seen the same way when you are in government as when you are outside. I always listen to Felipe González's opinion with great attention because I think he has been a very good President and is a great leader, but things are never seen the same way.

For example, what has caught my attention the most about his statements regarding the European Union is whether the European Union lacks strength or leadership; of course, comparing the European Union of twenty years ago with that of now, where there are twenty-seven countries, where we have made the historic operation of integrating all of Eastern Europe into the European Union, I sincerely believe that it cannot be compared. From within, the functioning of what is today the European Union, which has much more complexity, has nothing to do with the Europe of Fifteen, which was much more governable, which was only within the realm of traditional Western Europe, with what has been the operation that has marked Eastern Europe.

C.G. Campoy.- This statement has not sat well with you, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero! It has not sat well at all!

President.- No, no. Not at all. Moreover, he is in charge, at my proposal, of making a report on the future of the European Union. What I want to say is that it is seen... If I am asked, are you satisfied with the functioning of the European Union?, I say: I would like a European Union with more leadership, with more decision-making capacity, and with more strength. But when you are inside, in the European Council, with twenty-seven, you realize that this is very difficult until a period of maturity of governance is acquired with such a different reality.

Antonio San José.- The question, Mr. President, is whether there is a real alternative to nuclear energy in Spain, if renewable energies alone are sufficient, also considering combined cycle plants.

Then, I would also ask you for more specificity regarding the closure of Garoña. You say that you are studying the matter. When do you think Garoña will put an end to its useful life?

President.- That is the decision. There is always a debate about useful life and design life, right? The design life is forty years; it is something conventional.

A. San José.- And useful life, with the renovations that are made, the time it lasts.

President.- The useful life can be more or less than forty years; less, if the conditions advise that it does not reach forty years.

What, in my opinion, we must keep in mind is that our country needs, because it has the best conditions to do so, a strong push for renewable energies. They are the energies of the future, not only because they are safe, clean, and provide us with more energy self-sufficiency, but also because we have conditions, due to entrepreneurial strength and innovative strength, to be a reference in renewable energies in the world.

C.G. Campoy.- Mr. President, you are going to close Garoña. I am sensing that. That is clear.

A. San José.- The question is when.

President.- The decision must respect the procedures and it is an important decision because, as everyone can understand, ultimately the Government assumes the responsibility or not of saying that a plant over forty years old, and the vast majority of those plants have been closed in the world, can remain.

A. San José.- Can we function in Spain without nuclear energy?

President.- Certainly, Garoña contributes...

A. San José.- No. Without Garoña. We consider Garoña to be amortized. But with the rest of the plants, as they go...

President.- I must say that the rest of the nuclear power plants still have more than ten years of useful life, the majority of them. There is a process that is being fulfilled. Logically, at each moment, when the process of that forty-year life is fulfilled, it must be analyzed; but, in the meantime, let us develop renewable energies, which we know is good and is, energetically and economically, very positive for the country.

Carmen Morodo.- Mr. President, there is a technical report from the Nuclear Safety Council that suggests it is extendable. That is, you are talking about those forty years, but it could continue for another ten years, and that is the justification for businesses, trade unions, from all sectors, even from the nuclear energy field, to suggest that the closure of Garoña would be more for political reasons than for real technical reasons. So, what is the position, once again, given that there is that technical report that says it is possible to extend it for another ten years?

President.- For political reasons, if you refer to energy policy and the sense of responsibility that the Government...

C. Morodo.- Ideological political reasons, rather.

President.- No; ideological, no.

That is to say, renewable energies. I have just laid out the characteristics: clean, safe, and with great innovative potential for our industry. We have leadership in wind energy in the world and we have leadership in solar energy; therefore, we have great development potential.

And, surely, as happens in all sectors, as we make more effort to enhance technology, innovation, and research, we will make that energy cost less and it will help us a lot to reduce our energy dependence, which is fundamentally on fossil fuels.

Therefore, that is my position. To the extent that we can extend renewable energies in our energy mix, we will advance, always ensuring the supply, logically, of electricity in the country.

José Ignacio Wert.- You said, Mr. President, "clean, safe," and in fact I think we all agree, and also expensive. With renewables, today, it costs much more to produce a kilowatt based on renewables, in general.

The essential issue is the electoral commitment of the Socialist Party regarding nuclear energy. I believe that, in my interpretation of that commitment, the renewal, the extension, of the operation of Santa María de Garoña would be admitted on the basis that, if we have, as we do, a technical body that dictates that with fifteen adaptations it can extend the useful life by ten years, it would still fulfill the commitment to close it when its useful life ends in ten years.

President.- Yes, but the responsibility is of the Government. If the Nuclear Safety Council were the ultimate responsible for ensuring that with the forty-year design life we will not have problems, the Nuclear Safety Council would decide. It is the Government that decides, but the ultimate responsibility will be of the Government and you will agree with me, Mr. Wert, that it is a transcendent responsibility. It is not about deciding whether to extend or not any other economic activity; it is a nuclear power plant that, in addition, produces waste and that, if we extend it, will continue to produce waste. And we have a problem, we and humanity, everyone, very serious with nuclear waste. I hope that is not debatable.

And I must clarify one thing about the cost. The production cost is today, indeed, cheaper for nuclear than for wind energy, but the cost in the electrical system is not, because in the electrical system it is not determined by what it costs now to produce, but by the marginal cost, which is the last. Therefore, a kilowatt of nuclear energy and a kilowatt of wind energy cost the consumer exactly the same, because we have that model. Therefore, economically it is neutral, with a particularity, which is that, to the extent that more non-flexible energy contribution operates, such as nuclear, logically, that reduces space for more flexible energies, such as wind energy, for example.

We have already experienced in 2009 that, to guarantee what inevitably nuclear energy contributes to the electrical system without continuity solution, it is not gradable, as is a combined cycle thermal plant or as is a wind plant, where you can let the windmills generate wind and produce electrical energy, we have had moments when wind energy has been stopped from contributing to the electrical system.

Therefore, I must say that I believe the decision is significant; that part of the future we want as a country in energy terms, responsibly and sensibly, and that, ultimately, I try to convey that situation, the responsibility, the safety, when forty years are fulfilled, is greater, logically --I have given the data on how many nuclear power plants have closed-- when it comes to making a decision. I insist, because the ultimate responsibility is of the Government, it is not of a technical report.

Arturo González.- Apart from the fact that I do not believe that the responsibility should be of a Government, but rather of a state agreement, what scientific studies did you have when you decided to renounce nuclear energy in your electoral program or was it a romantic decision?

President.- No, we have logically a whole process of technical, scientific debate and commitment. Our program states: "forty years is the useful life of nuclear power plants. To the extent that we can replace, because there are no problems for electricity supply in our country, we will progressively replace nuclear energy with renewable energies, because we understand that they are the future, we understand that it is beneficial for us as a country." From all perspectives, that is the commitment that exists in the vast majority...

A. González.- No, not in the whole world. Currently, there are, as you very well know, 450 nuclear power plants and what amazes me is that you declare yourself so against it when we belong to a core of countries, including the United States, where nuclear energy is on the rise or, in any case, in combination with other energies.

Renouncing nuclear energy seems to me like renouncing gunpowder, or renouncing nuclear medicine in favor of acupuncture, or renouncing...

President.- It is not about renouncing nuclear energy. It is about progressively combining the nuclear energy we have with more renewable energies. And to the extent...

A. González.- Yes, but not promoting more.

President.- No. But let’s see. At this moment, there is only one nuclear power plant being built in the world, which is in Finland, with tremendous problems because the cost is brutal.

A. González.- Yes, but it is not just a cost problem, it is also a conceptual one.

President.- What is happening with the cost in Finland? The Government, the State, is having to assume what are multimillion-dollar investments, as here, by the way, we have had all that was the nuclear moratorium, which has incurred a very strong cost to all citizens.

A. González.- Yes, but do you consider yourself capable of renouncing, on behalf of all Spaniards, nuclear energy? That is, do you renounce nuclear energy?

C.G. Campoy.- He is the President of the Government.

A. González.- I believe it should not be a matter for a President of the Government. First, I believe that to rectify is wise and I think that, moreover, with politicians with a sense of state, perhaps what was needed was a great state agreement so that, inescapably, a high-level commission would say whether nuclear energy is beneficial for us or not.

President.- Logically, the electoral program belongs to the entire Socialist Party; one. Two, this is a political option, but above all it is an option for the future, because we are not now talking about this debate being concretized regarding the future of nuclear power plants in four, five, eight, or ten years. No, no; we are thinking about the generations to come and that our country can, and that is a great bet for the country, and we want to lead it perfectly aspiring to have an energy contribution system and an electrical system where we have less and less nuclear energy and less dependence on hydrocarbons and more renewable energies.

This, in our opinion, is a modernizing and future-oriented bet.

C.G. Campoy.- I believe that this position is certainly very clear.

I would like, with the minutes we have left, Mr. President; but, of course, there is going to be a planetary conjunction, as Leire Pajín announced: you, in the Presidency of the European Union, and Obama, in the United States. How do you imagine that moment?

President.- Positively. In my opinion, we have a great opportunity, as Europeans and in the international order in general, with what the American Administration means, which has undoubtedly put on the agenda a way of doing things and some very different priority objectives from the Bush Administration regarding the vision of conflicts, regarding collaboration, regarding commitment to the fight against climate change or the Millennium Development Goals. Of course, I hope that this renewal of the Transatlantic Agenda during the Spanish Presidency of the European Union will be very fruitful.

A. San José.- Mr. President, is Spain's agenda for the upcoming G-8 meeting in Italy already closed? Do we know what our role will be and your contribution in your intervention there?

President.- The truth is that the agenda is very important for Spain. It is the first time that Spain has been invited to a G-8 meeting, just as for the first time we attended the G-20 meeting, two momentous meetings. Therefore, I go to that meeting with a strong sense of responsibility and gratitude to those who have invited us, and to participate actively.

I find it, at least, amusing -- I will say it that way -- that, being the first time, after what we have heard for so many years about the G-8, that Spain is going to a G-8 meeting, now the problem is the agenda.

C. Morodo.- It seems that it had almost become a custom for you to meet with the leader of the opposition every political season: in July of last year, also the previous summer... A year is about to pass, and the question is whether you plan to call Mr. Rajoy to talk to him about some of the pending issues, especially what interests us Spaniards, which is the economic crisis.

President.- The truth is that I have been the Prime Minister who has called the leader of the opposition the most times.

C. Morodo.- Of course, that’s why I say it was almost a custom.

President.- Therefore, yes. It’s not that I have a specific date now, but I am sure that in a reasonable time, soon, I will have a meeting again, because I think it is important, with Mr. Rajoy.

C. Morodo.- Before the summer?

President.- I don’t know if before the summer or immediately after. We are currently in an important negotiation, which is the Royal Decree Law for the financial sector, for the Savings Banks; I hope we reach an agreement.

Therefore, dialogue exists, although perhaps the photos are less so at this moment; but, of course, yes, I will call him. It may be before the summer or it may be in September, at the beginning of the new political season.

C.G. Campoy.- We almost have a date.

J.I. Wert.- Mr. President, this weekend there is a Czech Summit, there is a Brussels Summit, and the deadlines are practically running out to decide who will be the President of the Commission. Is Spain still betting on Durao Barroso, is the Prime Minister still betting on Durao Barroso, and, above all, do you think that the renewal of Durao Barroso's mandate is compatible with the leadership ambition that Felipe González is calling for?

President.- Yes, we are still betting. Moreover, I believe he will have a broad consensus in the European Council. That is my prediction, because I know what the Prime Ministers think.

Of course, the leadership that the European Union needs has a lot to do with the entry into force of the Lisbon Treaty, which we hope will happen and that Ireland will also ratify; we will talk about this in the European Council, that we have a President of the Council and that the governance of Twenty-Seven is much more operational and effective.

Of course, I believe that the Commission, in the figure of Durao Barroso, can also fulfill that role of assisting the leadership of the Council.

A. González.- If we reach 2012 with four million unemployed, do you think that elections can be won like that?

President.- Elections are always decided by the citizens, and therefore, citizens evaluate the circumstances at each moment. Of course, we are going to try to reduce, logically, the number of unemployed, just as we managed to do in the last Legislature. I want to remind you that the lowest unemployment rate in the history of our country occurred in 2007, with this Government.

A. González.- That is not what Elena Salgado has said.

President.- The lowest unemployment rate occurred in 2007, in a normal economy.

Regarding the elections of 2012, yes, we are convinced that we can win them.

A. San José.- Mr. President, Mr. Fried, the envoy of President Obama, is in Spain today to study the fate of the Guantanamo prisoners in Europe. How many Guantanamo inmates can Spain accommodate or is willing to accommodate?

President.- The number has not yet been determined, and I must also say that it requires a legal study, because it is a complicated situation from a legal point of view, from the perspective of International Law and from the perspective of domestic law. Until we have this absolutely clarified, we will not be able to confirm the reception. Our predisposition is favorable, and of course, the number in any case will be a reduced number; that is highly probable.

C.G. Campoy.- Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, I take it for granted that you will be the Socialist Party's candidate for the upcoming elections.

President.- For that, we must wait until 2012, as is logical, among other things, because of what my party says and also because of my own disposition. I think I have explained it on more than one occasion, and that should be the case.

I am immensely grateful to the citizens because they have given me the opportunity to be the Prime Minister of Spain, of my country, on two consecutive occasions, and to the Socialist Party. Therefore, when that moment arrives, I believe it will be the time to talk.

C.G. Campoy.- Mr. President, I also express my gratitude for having fulfilled that commitment to come to "Las mañanas de Cuatro," to our studio.

President.- I usually keep my word and my electoral programs.

C.G. Campoy.- Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. President.

President.- And I believe that programs are meant to be fulfilled.