Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

16 June 2009 · Parliamentary control session · Chamber of Deputies, Spain

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on June 16, 2009, addressing tourism support for the Canary Islands and youth employment policies during the economic crisis.
Main themes
Tourism in the Canary Islands, economic crisis response, airport fees reduction, tourist infrastructure renewal, youth employment policies, self-employed workers support, parliamentary oversight, government stimulus measures, regional cooperation, ICO financing lines
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,369
65th percentile
Sentences
81
53rd percentile
Readability
45
48th percentile
Grade
13.5
62nd percentile
Syntax
3.21
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 70%70%
  • Social 14%14%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Institutional 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

81 sentences in 46 paragraphs

Mr. President, I want to remind you of the main measures approved by this Chamber in March: the Infrastructure and Tourist Public Spaces Renewal Plan, the opening of a special ICO financing line for the Canary Islands for the renewal of accommodation facilities, the execution with the Government of the Canary Islands of an important tourism promotion and marketing program, and the initiation of a coastal and beach regeneration plan.

Furthermore, there is an urgent need for the temporary suspension of airport fees, as other countries have successfully done, as well as the reduction of visa costs, the streamlining of their processing, and the opening of new consulates to facilitate the arrival of tourists from Russia and other emerging countries.

Mr. President, on the eve of the celebration of that Summit with the Government of the Canary Islands on June 29, I ask you: has the Government implemented the urgent measures approved by Congress to strengthen the tourism sector in the Canary Islands in the face of the threat of the economic crisis?

President.- Ms. Oramas, the Government is implementing specific measures in the tourism sector. Specifically, as you know, the Tourist Facilities Renewal Plan is already endowed with one billion euros following the recent extension of six hundred million additional; from the first package of four hundred million, the Canary Islands have obtained financing for 135 operations, and we are working, to be specified ahead of the Summit on the 29th, with a specific line for the Canary Islands. Within the fund for the modernization of public tourist infrastructures, the Canary Islands will have more than eleven million euros.

In addition, there are some specific initiatives: the Canary Islands has one of the three major comprehensive requalification plans for mature tourist destinations, the San Bartolomé de Tirajana consortium is a clear example of cooperation between administrations, and the Parador de la Cruz de Tejada in Gran Canaria has recently been inaugurated, whose rehabilitation has involved an investment of fourteen million euros, of which more than 60 percent is provided by the State.

We have already taken initiatives regarding air fees to stimulate tourist traffic at Spanish airports in general, and especially in the Canary Islands, which, along with the Balearic Islands, will have a greater discount on airport fees, which will increase from 15 to 30 percent. This discount from July 1 to December 31 may be extended for another six months if the employment situation in the sector requires it.

Additionally, the Council of Ministers has approved an increase in the allocation of Imserso places for the season starting in October amounting to twenty million euros and two hundred thousand places that will undoubtedly have a beneficial impact on tourism in the Canary Islands.

We will evaluate, study, and specify the set of measures during my visit on June 29, which I will undertake accompanied by several Ministers and which will constitute a Summit with the Government of the Autonomous Community of the Canary Islands.

Ms. Oramas.- Mr. President, the fees have not been implemented, and moreover, the proposal that has been made has not served any purpose. Lowering one euro for tourists coming from the Peninsula will not increase the number of tourists coming to the Canary Islands. We have made other serious proposals for the elimination of fees, as Greece did, and we hope...

President.- I believe it would be advisable to wait for the effects of the measures, specifically those of the fees, and, of course, we will discuss this and all the measures we are implementing in favor of tourism and employment in the Canary Islands with the Government of the Canary Islands, such as the comprehensive strategy for the Canary Islands, which the Government is working on and which we will approve before the end of the year.

Thank you very much.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President, what policies is the Government promoting to support young people in times of crisis?

President.- Mr. Duran, in summary, in terms of employment, we have promoted bonuses of up to 1,500 euros per year for two years for companies to hire those under thirty years old, and we have maintained the bonus for converting temporary contracts to permanent ones for young people who were enjoying training or internship contracts.

Regarding young self-employed individuals, the approval of the Self-Employed Workers Statute has resulted in a 30 percent reduction in Social Security contributions during the first thirty months of activity for young people under thirty or women under thirty-five. And in the Self-Employed Workers Table, it has been agreed to increase the capitalization of unemployment benefits for those who want to start an activity as self-employed to 85 percent.

As for the immediate future, social dialogue is advancing on aspects directly linked to the labor situation of young people, such as the improvement of the public employment service and vocational training.

In terms of education, we have doubled the education budget in the last five years, which has allowed us to reach this year the highest number of scholarship recipients in history, one and a half million, and also the largest budget volume.

We have adopted new initiatives, such as the credit of 155 million euros approved by the Council of Ministers to develop the School 2.0 project, and to offer training assistance to unemployed graduates, which will reach about eighty thousand young people.

And in terms of housing, to place the third key sectoral policy regarding youth, alongside employment and education, I must remind you that more than one hundred thousand young people are receiving the aid of 210 euros for rent payment, and up to 180,000 young people can benefit from the extension of the deadline to enjoy tax bonuses for housing savings accounts.

In summary, Mr. Duran, these are, in brief, singular measures that, in terms of employment, education, and housing, the Government has adopted to support young people in the face of the crisis and the unemployment situation.

Mr. Duran.- The data I am going to discuss contradict, in any case, a positive result of those measures and initiatives that you have just mentioned.

Eurostat, on June 3, regarding youth unemployment in Europe reminds us that since 2008 we have gone from 22.4 percent to a youth unemployment rate of 36.2 percent in April 2009. If we talk about housing, to which you referred regarding the emancipation scholarships that you mentioned reaching about 100,000 families, we find that of the 11.3 million young people between 18 and 34 years old, only five million have been able to emancipate themselves, seven or eight years, in any case, after what is happening in Europe. And, if we talk about training, only 15 percent of students receive any scholarship.

The conclusion, Mr. President, is that youth is not a priority for the Government in areas such as training, employment, and housing. I am sure that in your remaining reply and in the part you have presented, you will enumerate a limited number of actions, but in any case, it does not change at all the overall balance that I have just reminded you of.

You have lived, as I have, the Bologna Process. Undoubtedly, there was a reason that justified the students' attitude. It was a single one, the lack of scholarships and, therefore, the lack of foresight on the part of the administrations in this regard.

In terms of employment, in the last twelve months, Mr. President of the Government, 77,000 permanent contracts have been created, but 1,044,000 temporary jobs have been destroyed, which mainly affect young people and implies that unemployment rate of 32.2 percent.

You insist on stating, Mr. President, that the productive system must be changed and that the important thing is not labor reform. You may continue to philosophize, but undoubtedly, the current labor situation clearly harms young people, who are the ones subjected to temporary contracts.

Finally, if we talk about housing, your priority is to reduce tax incentives for the purchase of homes. A recent study by the Youth Housing Observatory, dependent on the Youth Council, states that for a young person to buy a home, they should earn 3,500 euros a month, that is, three times what a young person earns. Remember, Mr. President, your proposal of seventeen thousand euros and you will see that it has nothing to do with it and that, in any case, it cannot benefit a young person in the purchase of a home.

President.- Mr. Duran, I share with you that there is still much work to be done in favor of young people, but it is undeniable that there are more scholarships and better scholarships, that there is more assistance for young people in housing, and that we are making every effort to incentivize the hiring of young people in favor of employment. That is...

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- On Friday, the Council of Ministers, among other measures, approved the following: a credit supplement to address unemployment spending amounting to seventeen billion euros, almost three trillion pesetas, which is the unavoidable consequence of the enormous increase in unemployment.

They also told us that the recovery would be delayed until 2011 and that this year GDP would fall by 3.6 percent, two data points that demonstrate the falsity of your forecasts and the falsity of your Budgets.

They also told us that the spending ceiling for next year, 2010, will decrease by 4.5 percent. It is a lie, and it must be said. The spending ceiling for 2010 will increase by 15 percent compared to the beginning of 2009, which is how, as the Minister knows, things are done. And, as spending increases, taxes on diesel will rise by 10.4 percent; on gasoline, by 7.2 percent; on tobacco products, by 30 percent; and on cigars and cigarettes, by 24 percent. All this, five days after the holding of elections where they spoke to us about "green shoots" and the imminent economic recovery. Another deception, Mr. President.

What I ask you is: now that there are no elections, are you going to start telling the truth? And can you tell me if you are going to raise taxes again during 2009?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I greatly appreciate your question about tax pressure, because this way we can have some clarifying data for the Chamber and the public opinion.

The tax pressure today in Spain is 32.8 percent of GDP, the lowest since 1995. When we came to power, the tax pressure was 34 percent of GDP. Therefore, tax pressure has decreased. Do you know why? Because this Government has lowered taxes in personal income tax by ten billion euros, in corporate tax by four billion euros, and in wealth tax, because we have eliminated the Wealth Tax, which means a lower tax pressure of 1.8 billion euros.

That is to say, we have lowered tax pressure by almost two points of Gross Domestic Product, and now we have produced an increase in hydrocarbon taxes that, by the way, during our time in government, is lower than the increase you made in hydrocarbon taxes, which was 10 percent, and in 2002, 6 percent. It is true that when you raise hydrocarbon taxes, it is an update, as Mr. Montoro has said, and for us, it is a tax increase.

The reality is that tax pressure today is lower than when you left the Government because we have lowered taxes. Everything else, Mr. Rajoy, is pure demagoguery.

And, regarding forecasts, the International Monetary Fund and the European Commission have changed their forecasts five times in the last year, but for you, they will also be compulsive liars. I will tell you: economic forecasts have been changing by all international organizations. And I will add next: the Government believes that the worst of the crisis has already passed and considers that our recovery will occur progressively and more intensely in 2010, until reasonably reaching 2011 with positive growth.

That is why I tell you, Mr. Rajoy, to show a little seriousness, less demagoguery, and remember before the Chamber, and have the courage to acknowledge it, that this Government has lowered taxes by twenty billion euros and two points of GDP.

Mr. Rajoy.- More seriousness and less demagoguery is what you need to do. If you have lowered tax pressure in Spain, it is because activity has decreased and collection has decreased, and that has been the consequence of your terrible economic policy.

Mr. President, everything I am going to tell you was said yesterday in this Chamber by the Governor of the Bank of Spain: your constant increase in public spending is mortgaging the future of Spain. Of course, we already know that what matters to you is the short term.

So far this year, you have issued more public debt than in all of 2008, which mortgages the future and harms access to credit for small and medium-sized enterprises and self-employed individuals. Now you are raising taxes, which is a slap in the face to the middle classes and the working classes of this country. We are talking about gasoline and diesel, and if you continue like this, you will delay recovery, prevent sustained and stable economic growth, and cause more unemployment and generate more jobs.

Since you do not listen to me, at least listen to the Governor of the Bank of Spain and everyone who tells you that you need to change economic policy. You are doing very poorly, Mr. President.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, demagoguery and lack of seriousness is to deny that this Government has eliminated the Wealth Tax, which amounts to 1.8 billion euros, to deny that this Government has reduced the Corporate Tax by five points, which saves companies four billion euros, and that we have lowered personal income tax by an amount of ten billion euros. That is why the tax burden has decreased, and to deny that is to engage in demagoguery.