Press Conference by the President of the Government following his meeting with the leader of the Partido Popular
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed press after meeting opposition leader Rajoy on May 4, 2010, to announce bipartisan agreements on Greece's bailout and Spanish savings bank restructuring.
- Main themes
- Economic crisis management, Greece bailout support, Spanish financial system restructuring, savings banks reform, Eurozone stability, bipartisan political agreement, public deficit reduction, Spanish economy confidence, FROB restructuring fund, Euro project solidarity
- Duration
- ~55 min
- Words
- 6,653
- Sentences
- 217
- Readability
- 47
- Grade
- 14.2
- Syntax
- 3.36
- Vocabulary
- 2.08
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
217 sentences in 84 paragraphs
President. - Good afternoon. I should like to inform you about the content of the important meeting I have had today with the leader of the opposition, Mr. Rajoy.
The purpose was to especially analyse, discuss and agree on essential aspects related to exiting the economic crisis, with the aim of consolidating confidence in the Spanish economy and, in particular, to share the support for Greece that the Eurogroup, with the International Monetary Fund, have decided, as well as to jointly move forward with the process of restructuring and consolidation of the Spanish financial system.
In addition, as it could not be any other way, we have exchanged views during the meeting on our perspectives of the economic situation, on the economic trends of the markets and on the latest figures regarding the Spanish economy.
I have to say that, in my opinion, the meeting has been useful and positive because there were two important agreements for our country, but also important for what represents the European project, for the Euro and for the countries forming part of the Euro.
It is important for there to be full agreement on the decision for support to Greece. You know that it is a long-term decision that means undertaking loans to guarantee the solvency of Greece and that, in addition, is going to commit our country to a contribution of approximately ten billion Euros within the overall 110 billion agreed: 80 billion that the Euro countries are contributing and 30 billion from the International Monetary Fund.
I must say that it is an unprecedented operation and also with scarcely any previous history, of a loan from our country to another country in the Eurozone, it seems vital to me to have the full agreement of the Government and of the main opposition party.
I have passed on all the information about the loan conditions to Mr Rajoy, on the legal channels we have before us to adopt it and, in the same way, on the plan that Greece has agreed with the International Monetary Fund and the Commission, that will act as the coordinator for the countries of the Eurogroup in meeting the reduction of its public deficit. And I see it as positive that Mr Rajoy has again publicly stated his support for the agreed rescue policy for Greece.
Along with that, we have agreed that one of the essential aspects for economic recovery, for confidence and the solvency of our economy and our businesses is to complete the restructuring of the financial system that, as you know, basically affects a large proportion of the Savings Banks.
I must remind you that our financial system has shown strength and exemplary solvency. After two years of a financial crisis, an acute financial crisis, it is one of the few countries where the public sector has not had to inject capital into the financial sector, to financial entities and where Banks and Savings Banks, especially Banks have demonstrated and are demonstrating great strength. We should value this fact because it is an indicator of confidence; we should remember this fact because it is an asset of our solvency, and we should make it known to all, and I would like the leader of the opposition to also do so, because it is only fair.
As we know, the financial crisis forces a restructuring of the financial system in all developed countries. In some of them it has been a traumatic process, because it has meant the fall of financial giants, and in our country we are going to do it in a rational manner, without traumas, as we are doing. That restructuring was planned through an FROB [orderly bank restructuring fund] instrument, approved by a Royal Decree-Act last June. It has started and, as I have told you, it affects the Savings Banks, and I will give you a summary of the up-to-date information so that you know what we have done and what remains to be done.
Approximately one third of our credit entities, the Savings Banks, have carried out an integration and restructuring process that is on the point of completion this month, or at the beginning of June. We have another third of the Savings Banks whose situation does not force them into any merger or restructuring process. And we have the final third that has to be restructured through mergers, and this is where we have to focus our attention. In order to do this we have agreed to aggregate political and institutional efforts so that we may have the final restructuring map of the Savings Bank on the 30 June, so as to guarantee and maintain - and I stress "maintain" - the solvency and efficiency of our financial system.
In conjunction with that, we have agreed to amend the Savings Bank Act within three months. Why? Because, thinking of the future, the sustainability and solvency of the Savings Banks, even with restructuring, modifications to their governing bodies are advisable, meaning the professionalization of them and opening up to capital through proportional stakes with political rights. The Government is going to prepare the text for the amendment of the Savings Bank Act and is going to deliver it to the Partido Popular so as to reach agreement and so that within the forecasted period of three months we should have that amendment to the Savings Bank Act.
As a result we have all the conditions, first, because our system has been solvent and secondly because we have been working on this since last June and thirdly, because now there is political commitment to do it and to take the definitive steps to convey a message of confidence about our financial system, that the facts are confirming daily.
I should detail another matter here, because I believe it is advisable for everyone to be aware of it so that we have all the facts on hand. Mr Rajoy said that the restructuring process through an FROB approved last June depends on the Government and on the Bank of Spain, and I have to say that he has left something out, because it is obvious that it depends on the Savings Banks in the first place, and secondly on the regional governments.
The Government sets the regulatory framework, which is what it has done and the resources for the restructuring through an FROB, an amount that is, by the way, quite limited, and the Bank of Spain guarantees, monitors and requires conditions.
Therefore, I believe that it cannot be asked of the Government, as they are neither under their jurisdiction nor its control, that the chairman of a Savings Bank resulting from a possible merger in Galicia should be "X" or "Y".
I think all of us should be clear about the meeting of minds and the scope of responsibilities. The Government started the Restructuring Plan. How? With regulations and resources, and it did it on time and in the right way, last June. It opened the door and gave the Bank of Spain, uniquely to the Governor, the instruments to guarantee that the resulting merger processes should be solvent and efficient. Then the entities, specifically the Savings Banks come into play because in one third that represent that third in the Savings Banks system there are certain Chairmen and they are from Autonomous Regions of a certain political colour.
What do I mean by that? One, that the restructuring process has progressed, the Government started it with the support of the Parliamentary Groups of the Partido Popular; two, that in that process there is a meeting of minds and of responsibilities - this is not an action that is being done by decree of the Government, no; it cannot, because it requires the willingness of the Savings Banks - and what makes us more strong today is that there is agreement between the two major political forces so that we shall have the merger process completed for the 30 June, and furthermore, thinking further ahead, the amendment of the Savings Bank Act.
Therefore, it is a good agreement. I congratulate myself that it has happened because there is also harmony on the essential aspects that are going to be incorporated into the amendment of the Savings Bank Act.
Those are the agreements. Allow me to share some thoughts with you about the discussion we had on the economic situation, on the situation of the markets and on our future prospects. In the first place, we are going to meet the Heads of
State and Prime Ministers of the Eurogroup next Friday to ratify the agreement of support for Greece; but, apart from ratifying the agreement of support for Greece, we are going to ratify something more important: we are going to ratify our commitment and determination in favour of the Euro, of its strength and of its solvency, and in defence of the same; we are going to ratify our commitment to the Stability and Growth Pact, and to the mechanism to comply with that pact through the Fiscal Consolidation Plans that are evaluated by the Commission and prepared by each of the Governments; we are going to ratify our commitment to the policies in favour of competition included in the 2020 Strategy that the Council has approved and prepared by the European Commission, and we are going to ratify our commitment to the European social model, to the Welfare State.
The ratification of those commitments means reinforcing the coordination of economic and monetary policies to demonstrate that we are capable of having a strong currency, that we are capable of committing and being co-responsible with a country in difficulties, and that we are capable of reducing our deficit, of relaunching our competitiveness and of recovering economic growth.
Economic growth is key for the recovery of employment; economic growth is key in order to meet the fiscal consolidation plans and reduction of the deficit; economic growth is key to improving the prospects of the financial system and at the present time when the recovery of that economic growth is beginning to produce sound figures, we must state our firm backing for economic growth. Without a doubt it will be the vital condition to respond to the number of challenges we need to overcome the crisis.
I have also informed Mr Rajoy that the Government is fully determined to meet the Plan sent to the European Commission to reduce the deficit down to 3% in 2013. I reminded Mr Rajoy that the commitments in relation with the Budget and the 2010 financial year to reduce that deficit are being met: the commitment for the non-availability of credit of five billion Euros, the commitment to reduce the Offer of Public Service Jobs by up to 10% of the replacement rate and that we are prepared to provide periodical information on meeting the deficit forecasts in Parliament or in any other forum, as I repeat, we shall be at 3% in 2013. We shall strictly adhere to the Plan in 2010, as we shall do so in 2011, and that is how it will be stated in the preparation and presentation of the General State Budgets.
Lastly, I must repeat that in order to achieve the recovery of economic growth and to beat the competition, that will be the future sustainability of our development, of our progress and of our public accounts, we must continue effecting reforms. We have acted in a major sector, the transposition of the Services Directive, but we have to work on other fields. So the energy policy and the industrial policy are the two major areas in which we shall continue working in the next few weeks to seek that agreement and that accord. They are sectorial reforms, but they do have great significance for our economy.
I shall add one last thought that is aimed basically at society, to people, to the economic transactors and to companies: we have the first positive indicators of coming out of the crisis, of economic recovery, and therefore, that must be a lever for confidence. These are facts, not rumours, nor hypothesis. We have the first figures on that concerning industrial production, on that affecting consumer spending, State income, and although still very cautiously, and there is still a lot to do in this field, on unemployment and jobs; but we do have these positive indicators, they are true. And, if we recover economic growth - in a few days time we will know the figures for the first quarter - we will have begun to have the conditions to see the exit from the crisis coming closer, much closer.
There are reasons to be confident. They are not opinions or value judgements, they are facts and figures. And I repeat, I place great importance on the figures of the GDP's evolution in the first quarter, that we will know in the next few days, from the Bank of Spain and then, from the National Statistics Institute. Now I am prepared to answer your questions.
Q. - President, after the dive that the Stock Market took yesterday due to the doubts or wariness of investors in the Spanish economy, there was even more attention given to it in this meeting. Do you think that with the two agreements that have been finalised around the financial system it is possible to convey a message of confidence to the markets, or do you think that the fact that there are still differences regarding the reduction of the public deficit because the leader of the opposition has just said here that a plan would have to be made beforehand and not leave cuts for the following years may continue to convey that message of wariness, and carry on with the markets doubts.
President. - We should put this into perspective. The market doubts and activities that are largely speculative are related to the Euro and with the response to the debt problems, especially of Greece that the Eurozone and Euro countries have given, and with the strength of our unity.
I hope, because it is key to that confidence, that the leaders of the Eurogroup should be a solidary group in defence of the Euro next Friday, of the European project and of our economic strength, and with the commitment to galvanize all the influence that we have as countries, all economically strong countries, to demonstrate our strength and future solvency.
Therefore, we are of the view that activity and the markets, beyond what happens in one day and recently it has been like that, that there will be heavier losses on the Spanish Stock Exchange… I believe that you were the first to comment yesterday on a series of rumours that I believe everyone today considers as ridiculous. But of course, if a day's trading on the stock exchange begins with the sensitivity that we have, with the rumour that Spain's rating is going to be downgraded, and then that Spain is going to ask for a loan of I don't know how many millions of Euros from the International Monetary Fund, and it turns out that it is false information, just rumours, obviously it is going to have some effect. But what is important is that we should take the view that this is a debate and deserves a European response.
Secondly, from the point of view of confidence, all the areas of discussion and of agreements that take place between the Government and the main opposition party are positive, especially for giving confidence to citizens on our economic possibilities, that I want to highlight today, and that we are on the side of the facts not on the side of the rumours. We should all take the side of the real facts and of the effort that we are making, in the first place, for people who have no job or who have lost them and secondly, the workers; and many business owners, small companies and the self-employed. We should take the side of the facts and not of speculations and rumours. This seems to me to be essential so that we should assert that confidence that Spanish society deserves and that I hope can become consolidated in the coming weeks.
The more agreements there are, the better, without a doubt. I am always grateful and delighted that particular policies are supported. I just want to remind you of a fact that I think is relevant: The Government has always taken the initiative to convene a meeting with the opposition, it is always the Government that takes the initiative, either at leader of the opposition level, and also during the last few months members of the Government have spoken on many occasions with representatives of the Partido Popular, and of course, with all the Parliamentary Groups, that were very intense in the Palacio de Zurbano, that led to an Agreement and a Royal Decree-Law. And I do appreciate it, every time that support is given. And I have thanked Mr Rajoy personally today that we have reached this agreement on the two specific points that I put to him.
Therefore I defend the Government's willingness for dialogue and initiative or offer.
Regarding the deficit, that was a point we discussed when it arose that there is a disagreement. It's not that there is a disagreement, it is necessary to opt for an alternative which means that if one makes a drastic reduction of the deficit, it may compromise recovery and growth, and, if one makes a reasonable and measured reduction of the deficit and, therefore, withdrawal of fiscal incentives, which is what the Government has done, it may encourage and not frustrate the recovery towards economic growth. These are the two alternatives and, if we recall, international organisations, both the IMF as well as the OECD, and even the European Commission are sometimes inclined for one option and in others are more partial to preserving the fiscal incentives or reducing the deficit.
The aim is to reach 2013 with a 3% deficit. We have the plan to do it and, of course, if the economy grows again, there is no doubt that its' full achievement and a shortening of the time scales will be easier. Cutting the deficit, yes. Doing it drastically, no, because it would compromise growth in a phase in which private investment is very subdued, although it is now beginning to show signs of taking off.
This is the question. The dilemma is fictitious or the suggestion to say "it should have been done earlier" is fictitious or "the deficit should have been reduced earlier". No. If we had made a bigger effort to reduce the deficit, for example, in 2010, I can guarantee now that we would not be in conditions of economic growth this year, and jobs can only be created if it grows.
Q. - You just said confidence is vital to the future of the European project and for that the leaders of the European countries should appear as a solidary group.
Nevertheless, having heard the leader of the opposition and yourself, allow me to say that in my opinion at least, you are not perceived as a solidary group because, beyond the agreements - and this is not subjective, they are specific expressions from the leader of the opposition -, the only thing he didn't ask for was early elections. He said "there is an alternative here, it is necessary to govern, time has run out…".
Do you think that these two agreements, the contents of which are very specific, but do not transmit that idea of a general consensus are going to reach people better, or with sufficient importance? And in searching for that solidary impression, are you going to call on other parliamentary leaders or leave it at this bilateral meeting?
President . - In relation with the first, when I referred to leaders, I was referring to governmental leaders, as is to be expected, as those of us who form part of the European Union bodies, in this case the Eurogroup; those of us who represent the countries. And I attach great importance to that affirmation of that which we have to do, that we are going to do, on Friday.
Europe is strong, very strong and we in the Eurogroup countries are economically strong, and that should be clear. We have to let the strength of the Euro be known and the strength of the European Union. Secondly, in all countries there is a certain dialectical Government-opposition, as is to be expected. It's being discussed in all Parliaments, support for Greece is being discussed in European countries and I will say that precisely Spain is one of the countries where there is most consensus about support for Greece.
That is a good example, because there are other countries where there is a lot more debate and far more confrontation. It is a good example.
Take note that it is a State matter, a major topic and one of the most relevant that the European Union has decided in recent years, and we do have consensus. We must value this.
The financial system is the other major pillar for exiting the crisis that is a financial system crisis. Is there an agreement? It is very positive. It is valuable to us because the two major parties are in agreement on the Spanish financial system and this is very important.
There's a disagreement about reducing the deficit more or less drastically? I don't want to play it down, but it doesn't seem to me that it should create economic uncertainty.
If there is a disagreement in that a reform of the employment market has to be done by a decree and others of us think that it has to be done with the agreement of unions and business people, and yes, as soon as possible. It does not seem to me to be a worrying difference, amongst other things because it is obvious that for there to be a worrying difference we would have to recognise that the Partido Popular, or Mr Rajoy in his day, made some labour reforms. But precisely what he did, it's not that it works very well, because the result, in his opinion… If Mr Rajoy complains about the labour framework we have, and the Partido Popular, which it does every day, is a disaster, and that's the one we inherited. I get the impression that the margin we have in that area is rather more the result of political discussion than the reality of the facts.
Therefore, I value that the agreements in these two major issues… I repeat the two major issues in respect of the economic crisis have been, I repeat, in this order, one, the financial system and solvency and there is agreement; two, solvency regarding public debts, in this case the problems of Greece, and there is agreement. They are the two major issues. Hence, logically, there is a whole series of policies that will contribute to recovery or to create jobs when we can differ; but it's quite satisfactory for the government that there is agreement on these two issues.
Q. - President, in relation with the Savings Banks, and apart from the political agreement that has been reached with the Partido Popular, which is important, how will today's meeting change the plan and the schedules that the Government had pre-established for the process of the Savings Banks mergers? That first of all.
Secondly, I have a question that is perhaps anecdotal, but I believe it is relevant. You have just sent a message to society, to the markets, to business people and to citizens. What has prevented you today, for example, from appearing together with the leader of the opposition in this press conference?
President. - I don't recall there being a precedent for a joint appearance. I can assure you that nobody had considered that possibility. I'm not opposed to that at all. I appear with and have discussions with Mr Rajoy whenever it is necessary, there's no problem and discussions with him go smoothly and easily. But I think it's better this way and it is more reasonable that each one should appear and say what he thinks is appropriate.
Have we been successful today in relation with the restructuring of the financial system? Two very important things. The first one is an undertaking at the top level of those with political representation in the regional Government's, who have a big say, as is well known, in our Savings Banks so that the process will be finished by 30 June. As you can imagine -now is not the time to give an account of it, and neither has Mr Rajoy - we have put the Savings Banks processes under the microscope and we know, both of us, exactly how and where work has to be done to get to the 30th of June. Therefore, this is clearly progress.
Secondly, it's the first time that the upper echelons of the Partido Popular and the Partido Socialista have committed to amending the Savings Bank Act, and with agreement on matters of such importance for the future of the Savings Banks, as I mentioned earlier, and as I also explained to Mr Rajoy.
These are two major steps forward that are going to give confidence to the banking system overall, as in the end, the financial system, even though we have Banks and Savings Banks, has clear intercommunication and interrelation, and also to the markets that without a doubt have that restructuring process very much under the microscope, which some consider has been going slowly.
It's true that we should recall that it concerns processes in which decisions are taken by Assemblies and Boards, the balance sheets have to be analysed, viability plans for each merger, amounts required for that merger and what the FROB has to transfer. We are talking about tens of millions of Euros and therefore demands the minimum amount of well considered work.
The 30 June is a reasonable date and we have to, I stress, make an effort to expedite approximately one third of the Savings Bank sector. And you can imagine that there are political and territorial issues that have nothing to do with the decree that a Government may issue, but rather with the formation, accumulation and a meeting of minds; many minds, by the way.
Q. - I thought I understood that during the meeting you specifically dealt with the merger of the Savings Banks of Galicia. Firstly, I would like to know if you could confirm if that is the case.
Secondly, you said that apart from the Government and the Opposition that the Savings Banks themselves should also be asked to be responsible. I would like to know if you could tell me if you consider it responsible or justifiable that in the case of Galicia, the Chairman of the Caixanova should demand as a non-negotiable condition for the merger that he himself should be the Chairman and even that his term of office should be extended for a further five years.
President. - I don't have an opinion on as to whether it's responsible or irresponsible, but it is eloquent and a fact that that does not depend on a decree from the Government or on my personal preferences. That's clear isn't it? It depends on whether an agreement is endorsed. This is what seemed important to me to point out in the light of what Mr Rajoy said, and what is said many times that the Government has been slow to act. No, no; the Government approved a Royal Decree-Law last June with the framework, the resources and the funds. Hence, the Savings Banks are those who have to act and merge. The Bank of Spain has to guarantee that the merger works and the Autonomous Regions Governments, as everyone knows, also like to pass opinions on this, and we have witnessed this.
We have made a general review, but it is not the first time I have spoken with Mr Rajoy about the process in Galicia. I hope it will be the last because we have agreed that the maximum effort has to be made in order to decide on something specific and finalise the merger. I hope that we will get the green light for that merger in the next few days and I am not going to prejudge who should be the chairman, nor if this gentleman should carry on or not. However, I do hope that everyone will rise to the responsibility and we will provide our assistance.
Q. - President, going beyond how you and also the leader of the opposition have stressed that it is positive to have reached these two agreements about Greece and on the Savings Banks, it is obvious, and it does seem to be evident after you have both spoken, that there are still differences, both in so far as the reduction of the deficit, that Mr Rajoy has again complained about here, as well as the reform of the labour market, that Mr Rajoy insists you are putting off. If these differences persist, what kind of image of confidence or of unity that is called for, it is true, from many sectors by the way, do you think you are giving?
And I would like you to give me your opinion on that respect, for you to give me your opinion on that statement that you made at the end to the leader of the opposition offering as an alternative, and that call for early elections that Spokesman González Pons specifically made on Radio Nacional today.
President. - In my opinion, and referring again to the assessment that an agreement on the most important financial operation made for support to a country that the European Union has made, is of great significance for what it means to be in agreement on what Europe should do to defend the Euro and in support in this case to Greece that by the way has to apply a very tough adjustment plan, as we know.
Two, an agreement on the Spanish financial system that is the major pillar of the economy, when the economy is suffering problems that have arisen from the financial system, is highly worthwhile.
Regarding the deficit, the Government has a plan to reduce the deficit that it is going to meet; I repeat; but we are going to meet it without putting the recovery at risk. Therefore, the one who is wrong on this issue is the Partido Popular. Does the deficit have to be reduced? Yes, to 3% in 2013. What is the condition? The condition is that it should not impede economic growth. Of course, if we repeat the fiscal incentives suddenly, that will curb economic growth.
We know that the reduction of the deficit means sacrifices and decisions that the Government has already taken, such as for example, the increase in VAT. What does not seem consistent to me, and I have to say so, is to ask for the deficit to be reduced today and tomorrow voice intentions in the Congreso de los Diputados of all the PP Mayors asking for more money for Councils; that is inconsistent. It is inconsistent that it is being said that public deficit should be further reduced and, at the same time, vote for extending aid to the automobile industry, because that is a cost and means more deficit; that is what is inconsistent. So, when the positions are inconsistent, agreements are more difficult.
On the financial system the Partido Popular voted for a policy of guarantees and purchase of assets in due course, it voted for the FROB and now we are agreed on the definitive restructuring and amendment to the Savings Bank Act. There has been consistency. Then agreements are possible but, when they have inconsistent opinions on what something is worth today and tomorrow the opposite, of course it's not easy to reach an agreement.
Q. - President, you talked to us before about facts and the need to focus on facts and not on opinions and you gave us some that are beginning to be positive: industrial production…, you mentioned several.
Nevertheless, there are others that continue to be very negative and it seems to be that these are the ones that the financial markets have clearly focussed on, and about which speculation is levelled at. So, based on that, I would like to know, if you are convinced that is necessary and if you have a clear plan of action in relation to pensions reform, that was already launched, and seems to have been put on the back burner, and as regards labour reform and those formulae that were proposed for a new Austrian style contract, that was also launched some time ago, but later on the Government itself seems to have pulled out.
President. - The truth is that in the last few days the economic figures that we are getting are positive, I think the vast majority. They are positive as regards consumer spending, industrial production, which I value highly, State income and the latest figure on unemployment for April, although I want to point out that all the unemployment figures, whilst we have the unemployment rate that we have, it is not easy to say they are positive. But the trend is that it may improve.
The employment trend will only improve if we consolidate economic growth and growth that has to have better figures in the future, especially for the next year. In order to do that commitments and plans that we have to be met and that have been stated in a fiscal incentives policy that involves deficit but helps recovery of growth; in a policy of reforms, as I indicated beforehand, in the services sector, in energy and in industry, and in a policy for modernisation of the labour market.
We are, as I said, at a decisive point in the search for an agreement to modernise our labour market, an agreement on social dialogue; of a plan for the reduction of the deficit, which we have, and on which we have already taken the first steps relevant to those that I referred to: offer of public service jobs and a reduction of five billion.
Therefore we have the specific plans underway and what we are all waiting for are the results. Some policies and plans take longer than others, but the prospects of the results will open up when we are in economic growth and we can, from that growth, consolidate confidence: the confidence of savers, the confidence of consumers and the confidence of companies to invest and contract staff when they begin to notice that those improved figures in their turnover, in their orders, have a horizon of stability. But the plans have all been rolled out and all are underway.
We now consider it vital, and hence this meeting in this context, after what the meeting to rescue Greece has meant, that the financial system requires unique attention and, for its' importance, it is a major agreement that we have between the two major parties, and I applaud it.
Q. - I would like to carry on a bit further with this last question. The impression is that you and Mr Rajoy have marked out the differences on what is the struggle against the deficit, basically, and on labour reform, the timetables, etc. So, in doing battle with the deficit, it gives the impression that although you have all the plans up and running, as you said, the markets don't end up with the feeling that it is like that, or at least, at the pace they would like. The question is: what is the Government going to do, what is the Council of Ministers going to do on the coming Fridays, so that the cut in public spending is more visible, if they are going to do it?
Secondly, on the subject of labour reform. What guarantee can you give to people, to the financial intermediaries and to the markets - we come back to the markets - what is that labour reform going to do for business people and unions? And if that labour reform does not happen, do you think that no labour reform is better than an enforced labour reform that is rather what one deduces from your words?
Lastly, in the heat of the moment yesterday, you said, as a result of the Stock Market nose-dive that it is intolerable and has to be contended with. My question is if you are thinking of proposing to the Eurogroup leaders, this Friday or in future meetings, of curtailing the power of the rating agencies in terms of the influence they have for the purposes of declaring or evaluating the solvency of the States?
President. - I shall start with the last question. This is without a doubt going to be an issue for the meeting of the Eurogroup leaders next Friday: what can we Governments do to guarantee that information works properly, of the transparency on the markets and also to defend and support a currency that we understand is very strong and very solvent, as is the Euro. It is going to take some time, of course, and there are some ideas on the table. It is premature to talk about them and, logically, we shall have to wait until next Friday.
In relation to the comments on the differences over the deficit, there is a difference as regards the speed of the deficit reduction, because the Government maintains that we have to reach what has been set by the European Union, that is 3% in 2013, and the difference is in a difference of analysis, that it seems to me I have explained three or four times today and I don't want to go over it again now. We have to reduce the deficit in a reasonable way so that it does not prejudice growth. If we reduce the deficit and withdraw public investment, it would be very easy for the economy to get stuck in the recession and that is not a good option.
Labour reform. What is the disagreement? The disagreement is that we have put a document on the table, inspired by the Austrian model that, incidentally, on that subject and on others, remains very strong, that we are trying to agree with the unions and with business people, and that the Partido Popular has talked about labour reform but has not put any document or initiative on the table, and that it wants to do it by decree. These are the differences: a labour reform by decree, with an unknown content and a labour reform that is agreed and its objectives are known, that can be summarised in that it would facilitate contracting for business owners, make contracting less costly for them and maintain workers' rights.
Q. - Thank you for taking the last question because the Catalan group still wanted to ask you why you have not dealt with the overhaul of the Constitutional Court with Mr Rajoy that he raised with you, when you are maintaining that it requires urgent overhaul and that it is blocked by the Partido Popular.
President. - Because one has to know when things are appropriate and when they are not appropriate. In the first place, the top priority for the country today is the economic crisis, the financial system, and that is what the fundamental concerns of the meeting with the leader of the opposition were.
There is also another snippet of information. Mr Rajoy is meeting with Mr Montilla tomorrow. Let's wait and see what's provided from that meeting. I have my hopes.
Thank you.