Press conference of the President of the Government after the extraordinary European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

15 September 2010 · Extraordinary European Council (press conference after)

Context
Zapatero addressed press after an extraordinary European Council on 15 September 2010, focused on EU foreign policy strategy and external trade relations.
Main themes
EU foreign policy, transatlantic relations, trade with Asia, G-20 cooperation, emerging economies, EU-South Korea trade agreement, Millennium Development Goals, Middle East peace process, EU-Russia relations, climate change, financial system reform, global security
Duration
~35 min
87th percentile
Words
4,168
87th percentile
Sentences
143
79th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.45
92nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

143 sentences in 62 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. As you know, we held an extraordinary European Council today focused, almost exclusively, on the European Union's foreign relations policy; a foreign policy that has gained new strength since the Lisbon Treaty and constitutes an essential pillar of the projection of a Europe that we want to be increasingly strong and more relevant in the international context.

I must remind you that Europe is the world's largest donor of development aid, it is the world's largest trading power, it has a coordinated defense and security policy, and it has a role and a great responsibility in the international concert.

Within the debate we held today to set the main strategic lines of foreign policy, without a doubt, economic and trade relations have occupied a central role. I would say that, within the economic area, from the perspective of external action, of trade relations, without a doubt, Asia must focus a good part of the attention, work, and efforts of the European Union; Asia and, in general, emerging countries. You know that it is in this area, in this part of the world, where economic growth is and will be strongest. The development of emerging countries will concentrate a large part of global growth.

Consequently, a major trading power, such as the European Union, must prioritize Asia and countries like China, South Korea, or India. We have celebrated the trade agreement that has been signed today between South Korea and the European Union, and we hope that the upcoming Summits with Asia will also yield progress and results in economic matters.

Likewise, in the economic sphere, the Council's debate has focused, to a large extent, on the upcoming G-20 meeting and the role of the G-20 in the future; specifically, on the role it will have, starting January 1 of next year, with the French Presidency. President Sarkozy has outlined a whole program, both for the G-20 and for the G-8, of great interest that, of course, must occupy a fundamental part of the attention of the European Union's external action, because economic globalization demands cooperation; the response to imbalances requires cooperation; the fight against climate change requires cooperation, and those phenomena that fundamentally concern the majority of countries in the world in the economic field, which we have experienced as a consequence of the severe economic crisis, must also have a response in the realm of cooperation.

Therefore, the G-20 Summit in Seoul and the French G-20 Presidency aim, once we perfect the new regulation of the financial system and the renewal or reform of the International Monetary Fund, to also address the management of the evolution of commodity prices as a factor of macroeconomic stability and risk prevention.

In the more general political sphere, in this case no longer economic, the relations of the European Union with the United States, the transatlantic relationship, are highlighted, given that we have an upcoming EU-U.S. Summit that must also address the economic sphere, but which undoubtedly has a very, very focused dimension on the global security challenges; just as those policies that, of course, the European Union must support the most important challenges for security in the world, such as the dialogue process, hopefully for peace, in the Middle East and, of course, all those conflicts or all those tasks in conflict prevention.

By the way, for Spain, it is very satisfactory that the Conclusions on this foreign policy debate make an explicit reference to the upcoming Union for the Mediterranean Summit as an important factor that can contribute to that process, always difficult and always complex, of dialogue for peace in the Middle East.

Russia is another strategic partner for the European Union and, consequently, occupies a prominent place in the Resolutions. The relationship with Russia in the economic and energy sphere, the modernization agenda of this country, the fight against global threats, against terrorism or organized crime, are undoubtedly important aspects.

In the more multilateral aspect of the European Union's foreign policy, there is a reference, which I want to highlight, to the Millennium Development Goals, because, as you know, next week the debate of the United Nations General Assembly will focus on the assessment of the fulfillment of the Millennium Development Goals to fight against poverty, against misery. I mentioned a moment ago that Europe is the region that constitutes the world's largest donor, and we certainly have a responsibility and a leadership in maintaining the pressure, even in a time of severe economic crisis, of fiscal crises, in favor of the Millennium Development Goals.

And in that multilateral framework, I must also highlight that there has been a reference in the debates to the relationship with NATO.

I will conclude now. There is a specific statement on Pakistan, which has been approved by the foreign ministers, expressing solidarity after the floods and the serious humanitarian consequences that this country has faced.

All of this, in summary, constitutes the fundamental objective regarding the foreign policy debate.

The Council has also received a first report on the work of the "Task Force," the work of the High-Level Group for the economic governance of the European Union, for the reforms that must lead to a new model of economic governance of the European Union; a report that has been presented to us by President Van Rompuy and that, based on its content, shows that we are weeks away from reaching a conclusion on those reforms, although there are still important issues to discuss.

You know that in that High-Level Group, in the "Task Force," the new conditions of the Stability Pact, the new requirements for macroeconomic stability, and the sanctions for non-compliance are being discussed; ultimately, significant issues that will undoubtedly contribute to strengthening stability and, more importantly, the economic governance of the European Union.

Q.- President, the UN, the European Parliament, the European Commission, and even the Pope have expressed their concerns about Nicolas Sarkozy's security strategy regarding the Roma. Just now, a moment ago, Sarkozy said that all Heads of Government and State have supported him in what he called "a hurtful and scandalous campaign by the European Commission." I would like to know if you share that security strategy or if, on the contrary, you believe that the file opened by the European Commission is fully justified.

President.- Indeed, the twenty-seven members of the European Council have agreed on four fundamental points: first, that France, as President Sarkozy has expressed, respects the file that the Commission has opened regarding the returns of Romanian and Bulgarian citizens from France, known as settlements through or by means of caravans. Respect for the Commission's actions.

Second, we have considered the statements of the Vice President of the Commission to be inappropriate, as the Commission President Barroso said yesterday. Speaking of "disgusting policy" or comparing it to what happened during World War II seems absolutely out of place to us. Furthermore, President Barroso expressed himself in that direction yesterday.

Third, President Sarkozy has provided a summarized report of the legal steps of the decisions he has made and the judicial support for them. It is appropriate to wait for the Commission to investigate, analyze, evaluate, and rule. I believe that is what we must do.

And it is also desirable that the Council take note — as President Van Rompuy has conveyed — of the need to strengthen integration policies as much as possible, in the case of certain minorities. This has also been a very addressed aspect by the President of Romania in the European Council debate.

Therefore, let us respect the procedures. If the Commission, which is exercising its competencies, believes that there may be a violation of Community Law, it can open a file; what it cannot do is judge beforehand. That cannot be done.

In any case, the Twenty-Seven agree that respect is the principle of relations between the European institutions and the States that are part of it. By the way, the Vice President in question, at the time, as the Spanish Presidency, also made some statements about Spain that were very unfortunate.

Q.- President, to follow up on this topic for just a second, I would like you to confirm whether it is true that Sarkozy and Barroso have engaged in a violent discussion regarding this matter. I just wanted to close that.

I had a couple of other questions. You are going to meet next Monday in New York with King Mohammed VI. I would like to know if the incidents that occurred this summer at the Melilla border or that kind of provocative letter written by the Prime Minister regarding today's visit of Mariano Rajoy, the leader of the opposition, to Melilla will be on the agenda of that meeting. In any case, I would like to hear your opinion on that visit.

I would also like to know if there is any news regarding the four detainees you mentioned yesterday in Congress concerning the murder of the two Spanish Civil Guards and the translator. Do you have any updates to share, as the Minister of Defense said that the operation was still open?

President.- The debate in the Council has been an intense debate, but it is a debate, as always occurs in the European Council, correct. Let’s say that, beyond the problem itself, of what has happened with those returns, on which, I insist, President Sarkozy has explained the legal steps that have occurred and under what circumstances those people are or were, I must say that the President of Romania has said that it is probably the same phenomenon that was experienced in Italy two years ago, that surely there were people who were the same and that we will probably experience it in another European city next year.

What has occurred, beyond the substantive debate, has also been a debate about institutional relations and about what the position of the Commission is, what the Commission must do in defense of the Treaties, because it is the guardian of the Treaties; but also about the respect that European institutions, in this case a Commissioner, must have for a State like France or any State. That has indeed been very present in the substantive debate.

Regarding what you mentioned about the agenda in New York, you know that it is a Summit that will likely be attended by a significant number of Heads of State and Government, and I will have various contacts. It is likely that one of them will also be with the King of Morocco, and with the King of Morocco, logically, if the meeting takes place, we will talk about the relations between Spain and Morocco, which, as you know, is a priority of Spanish foreign policy to have positive relations.

And regarding Mr. Rajoy's trip to Melilla, I have nothing more to express than my respect, of course. That would be the least! And the statements I have been able to read today while I was in the debate seemed correct to me. I hope that we all contribute to something that has an important interest, as is well known, for Spain, which is that on all the points that are usually used as friction between Spain and Morocco, we do so responsibly. But, I insist, I respect, of course, the trip and I have found that his statements have been correct, that they have gone in the right direction.

And there is no news regarding the four detainees.

Q.- I would like to know if you were able to intervene in the debate on the issue of the Roma during lunch, if it was a bilateral matter between the French president and the Commission president, and, in any case, to know a bit about your position on the matter, because today we heard the spokesperson for the PP clearly state that Nicolas Sarkozy's actions were respectable. Do you share this position? Is it a good assessment?

President.- The European Council had a debate today and we reached a common position, which is what I have expressed here: one, the principle of respect between the Commission and States; two, France and any State respect the work of the Commission and the investigation that the Commission conducts; let us not prejudge it; third, there are certain statements that, of course, the European Council considers inappropriate, as those made by the Vice President of the Commission, who later apologized; and fourth, we must pursue a policy in favor of integration.

It is a shared, common position, after much debate, and I think it is very good that it is so. Therefore, I will not judge what the Popular Party has said on this issue. From the beginning of responsibility, as President of the Government and as a member of the Council, out of respect for the work of the Commission, let us allow the Commission to work and for France to present the arguments it has, which it does have—I have listened to them today, as always in these matters, more thoroughly—and at the appropriate time, when the Commission decides, that will be the moment when the Council will also express its opinion; do not have any doubt about that. But, since the issue has reached that institutional level, we must all be prudent and align with what we have committed to in the very debate of the Council.

Q.- Mr. President, we have been informed that this morning you had a brief conversation with Mr. Barroso regarding the coal problem and the delay in the approval of the Royal Decree regulating aid for coal. I do not know if you have made any further efforts or what the result of this management with the President of the Commission has been.

This Royal Decree, in reality, contemplates short-term aid, but there is a long-term problem regarding the continuity of coal mining activity in Spain, and there is an open conflict. I wanted to know what your long-term idea is and what alternatives exist.

And allow me to return to the issue of people of Roma ethnicity, because you yourself have said that, probably, next year in another European city we may encounter this problem again, perhaps in a Spanish city.

President.- Let us not give clues.

Q.- Let us not give clues; but beyond the problem of competencies between the Commission and the States, there is a deeply human problem here, and Spain is perhaps one of the European countries with the largest Roma population. How do we address this problem?

President.- I believe we need to delve a little deeper. In this case or in some other cases that have occurred, not all the citizens who have been expelled from those we are talking about are Roma, far from it, and we cannot speak of the Roma population in general, as if people belonging to this ethnicity had similar behavior or were in the same circumstances; no. I believe we need to, as always, delve a little deeper and not make a generic view of the circumstance.

I insist, we have listened, and it has been, as you can understand, very interesting, to the President of Romania, because they are his compatriots. By the way, there is a coordination and a very intense relationship between France and Romania, and France and Bulgaria, on this issue; in fact, I believe that in the coming days they will have a Summit, among other things, to address this issue.

Therefore, we must be precise. We must always be, logically, cautious and always try to prevent these types of settlements from occurring; that is my opinion. In fact, in Spain on some occasions we have had settlements, and I believe it is a bad practice for them to occur. Another thing is how the returns are carried out: if there is legal protection, if community directives and the principle of free movement are respected… That is what they now have to analyze. But, certainly, it is a problem that has occurred in European countries for some time.

Regarding coal, I know the coal problem well. The Royal Decrees of aid have always had to be endorsed or permitted within the framework, logically, because we are talking about state aid to an economic sector, by the European Union, and previously by the European Economic Community, and they have always had a certain end horizon and then there have been many extensions. We know that the circumstances are increasingly difficult, as is natural, due to what coal represents and its impact on CO2 emissions. But the Government of Spain will work to ensure that this deadline is as long as possible, and if we now contemplate it from here to three or four years, in three or four years there will logically be another dialogue with the Commission.

What I said the other day is that it is essential to expedite, accelerate, everything related to research so that coal production is not so polluting. That is carbon sequestration, and for that objective, we have a great project in Ponferrada, in the province of León, a mining area par excellence, with a large subsidy from the European Union, which we hope will yield results. And that will undoubtedly open a much more positive door for the use of coal as an energy source that is of interest to Spain, because it is an indigenous source, a domestic source, and because, for reasons of energy security, always having a percentage of coal is good.

However, we know that coal today needs significant state aid, public aid. Consequently, that has its difficulties, especially when it is an economic activity that produces such significant emissions of polluting gases.

Q.- Mr. President, you yourself have referred to the fact that Vice President Reding already had a clash, I suppose you were referring to Minister Caamaño, during the Spanish Presidency; also when she was Commissioner for Telecommunications, she had her ups and downs with Francisco Ros, and now she has had them with President Sarkozy. Does Spain not think, does France not think, or has no one requested the resignation of Reding as Vice President of the European Commission?

President.- No. I respect the institutional game, but in the atmosphere of the Council, I believe that President Barroso, who is an intelligent politician, knows very well that there are certain statements that Commissioners should not make. Specifically, this Vice President has occasionally made statements that provoke a natural sensitivity in the States that is not convenient.

I hope that it does not happen again, and I hope that the declarative force that she sometimes has is contained in the future. That is what we all wish.

Q.- Mr. President, two issues. Regarding the topic that occupies us today, Sarkozy has made a passionate defense of the right of States to protect their security by dismantling settlements that are illegal in any case. I wanted to know if, beyond the French case, you agree with this principle.

Secondly, regarding the "Task Force" on economic governance, does Spain support in any case new sanctions to reinforce the Stability Pact? And if not, in what other way?

President.- Regarding the first point, of course, each State must have mechanisms aimed at guaranteeing, within the laws and with judicial backing, security. I previously mentioned that this type of settlement has also occurred in Spain, and some of them have been dismantled. I will not provide the details that President Sarkozy gave in the Council; but he provided details that, as they will be subject to scrutiny by the Commission, the Commission will evaluate and decide; it does not fall to us, the members of the Council. But he provided information, in my opinion, relevant about how actions have been taken and why they have been taken.

From there, as the principle of free movement may have been called into question, the institutional mechanisms function, and the Commission will evaluate. But it cannot prejudge before evaluating. One cannot judge before instructing and investigating. This is what seems most important to me, and, of course, in this you can already imagine that all States agree before the powers of the Commission. But the powers of the Commission are also subject to the Treaties. Are the guardians of the Treaties the Commissioners? Yes, but they also have to respect the procedures of the Treaties to arrive at a possible, if it were to arise, incompatibility of the decisions and actions with the Treaty or with Community Law, in this case with a Directive.

I do not want to recall the facts, but at the beginning of the Spanish European Presidency, I advocated for sanctions to strengthen the economic governance of the European Union. It was in a meeting in Moncloa with journalists, I believe they were from foreign media, European media, and the truth is that I received a lot of criticism; I do not have it in my memory, but I am sure it was from Spanish newspapers, from some. And now we are in the full debate on sanctions because, if we truly want the risks of fiscal, macroeconomic imbalances not to reach situations that put the Economic Union, the euro, in difficulty, there must be effective, automatic, and direct sanctions. This is going to be an intense debate, but they must exist, and my conviction is that they will exist.

Keep in mind that regarding the Stability Pact, which establishes a percentage of deficit and public debt that cannot be exceeded of 3 percent and 60 percent, respectively, a re-reading of the Stability Pact was made when some countries at the time did not comply, and now, after the economic crisis, we have an evident need to reduce deficits and contain debt so that it does not go much beyond that 60 percent that few countries comply with in relation to GDP.

In my opinion, there must be sanctions. That is my position, it is coherent, and what gives me satisfaction is that now everyone is already engaged in a debate on sanctions.

Q.- Mr. President, if you allow me, to return a bit to the previous question, we have heard the arguments of the French President, Nicolas Sarkozy, but for more than a month, almost a month and a half, the President, through an administrative circular, has focused the expulsion on a specific ethnicity. Do you think that France has forgotten during that month and a half about European values?

President.- President Sarkozy has said, and he has said it in the Council as well, that that circular was a mistake and that it was immediately annulled. Of course, it is not a circular that could merit anyone's approval, and the first to say so has been President Sarkozy himself.

France is a country subject to law, it is a state of law, and President Sarkozy, I insist, has informed about the judicial process of the procedures in the decision-making of the returns. I have also heard the Romanian President in the debate, and you can imagine that it was really important to see what the President of Romania said, and he said that he was in full relationship, in coordination with the French President.

We have heard the arguments from France; now it is up to the Commission to investigate, and of course, the Government I preside over will support the information and the investigation carried out by the Commission. And I must say that the most important thing, beyond the intense debate, is that this is what President Sarkozy has said, that he is, of course, willing for the investigation to take place, as could not be otherwise, and for the evaluation by the Commission.

Q.- When you were talking about sanctions, the other day the Economic Vice President, here in Brussels, spoke of sanctions being of a preventive, moral type, "name and shame," and that, in any case, it is about applying those already provided for in the Treaty or the Stability Pact; that is, not new sanctions. When you talk about there needing to be sanctions that are very clear, automatic, direct, are you not talking about anything new, then; are you talking about applying exactly what is already in the Treaty and preventive actions, but not new ideas?

President.- Yes, yes. I am talking about new ideas, new time frames, new mechanisms for establishing sanctions, within, it is true, the legal possibilities provided by the Treaty. And there you can imagine that there is, as always, a legal discussion.

We know that when there are opposing political positions, arguments of legal validity are always resorted to. But we are going to have a new scenario of sanctions, and that is my prediction and my desire, within what the Treaty can be, and we will see what the conclusion is regarding the "Task Force" and what the content of the Commission's report is, thinking about the future and the Treaties as well.

Thank you.