Press conference with the President of the Government, taking stock of the previous semester
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed a press conference on 29 July 2010 to give his six-monthly assessment of government action during the legislative session amid Spain's economic crisis.
- Main themes
- Economic recovery, fiscal consolidation and deficit reduction, financial system reform, labour market reform, sovereign debt crisis, austerity measures, savings banks restructuring, sustainable economy strategy, legislative activity, Eurozone stability, social cohesion
- Duration
- ~85 min
- Words
- 10,246
- Sentences
- 334
- Readability
- 41
- Grade
- 15.0
- Syntax
- 3.26
- Vocabulary
- 2.08
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
334 sentences in 125 paragraphs
President of the Government. Good afternoon. I am here to fulfil my duty to provide a six-monthly assessment of the action undertaken by the Government, coinciding with the period of sessions.
I think we would all agree that the last six months have had more than their share of difficulties, serious difficulties, but that they have also been full of intense Government action and reforms aimed at stimulating change in the Spanish economy. As you are aware, we began this period of Government sessions with the fundamental objective of consolidating, initiating, a process of economic recovery following the decline of our economy and Gross Domestic Product in 2009 and that, around the month of May, we experienced an unexpected resurgence of the crisis, fundamentally in the financial sector, as a result of the support provided to Greece, which spread to the sovereign debt of other countries in the Eurozone.
That required us to take extreme measures in this period, which have recently culminated with the process of publishing the "stress tests" on the financial system, on all the financial entities, in a joint fashion with the rest of the European Union, but to which we in Spain wished to provide maximum transparency by applying it to all our financial entities with favourable results. That, along with actions in various other areas to encourage reform, has generated the recovery of stability and confidence in the markets. The cost of the debt held by our country has fallen drastically and, although we must remain prudent and continue implementing the plans and reforms, we hope that will be a continuing trend into the future.
As an initial summary, this has been a six-month period of difficulties in the consolidation of economic recovery, in tackling the crisis that arose around the stability of debt and the financial system, which we understand has been overcome and, of course, in implementing the reforms as best we could.
As I said, these difficulties were accompanied by intense activity by the Government. I will now refer to some of the fundamental issues, but I would like to offer you some data that is as relevant as it is significant: in this period, over the course of these last six months, 38 Laws and 11 Royal Decree-Laws were approved by the Government, to which I would like to add 20 sectoral plans approved by the Government in various areas, all of which were aimed at reform and combating the economic crisis within the spheres of education, universities, energy, industry, innovation, etc., etc. This clearly demonstrates the intensity of the work, as well as the absolutely fundamental nature of the work itself.
As you know, we launched the Sustainable Economy Strategy at the end of 2009. This strategy had various objectives that include a commitment to reduce the public deficit by reaching the target of 3% by 2013. We have approved two plans to achieve that; an initial plan and another plan implemented as of May, 12 May to be specific, in order to accelerate the deficit reduction. These plans are being fulfilled and we can say today that we are on track to fulfil the commitments we made to reduce our country's deficit to 6% by 2011 and 3% by 2013.
With this in mind, the 2011 Budgets we will present in September will be necessarily restrictive and austere because they must achieve an average reduction in spending by every Ministerial department of approximately 15%, thereby ratifying total commitment to austerity, savings and expenditure reduction in order to guarantee the stability and solvency of our public finances and the financial system. I repeat, austerity, reform and social cohesion.
On the issue of the reforms, it can be said that we have lived through six months of decisive reforms for the future of our economy. Decisive reforms for the future of our economy have been implemented and are being fulfilled.
We have completed a reform of the financial system to restructure and strengthen the savings banks so they may be in a position to widen their growing financing possibilities to companies and families because access to capitalisation has now been opened up to them, which will therefore bring strength and solvency to these entities.
Yesterday, the Lower House of Parliament approved the text on the labour reform in Committee. The text must now pass to the Upper House of Parliament where, and I hope that process will be just as rapid, we will continue to make every possible effort to maintain dialogue with all possible groups so that the labour market reform can achieve the objectives for which it has been created: to favour more stable employment instead of so many precarious and temporary jobs and to enable both our companies and our economic system to adapt better to the changing circumstances of the economy and for those circumstances not to force and mainly result in, as we have seen during all the economic crises since the Transition, the loss of so many jobs as we have seen in this crisis.
However, besides these two large-scale reforms, I must also remind you that other changes are already in motion, such as those contained by the Draft Sustainable Economy Bill; the education reforms within the framework of Universities and the Education Action Plan; the justice reforms; the science reforms with the Science and Innovation Strategy Act; the transport reforms, the energy reforms and the reforms that complete the changes already undertaken in the services sector to favour increased competitiveness in that field.
We therefore stand at a crucial crossroads, a decisive moment, for the renewal of our economy and our growth model. We are steadily undertaking the most ambitious reform efforts in the economy that can be remembered in a long time by the Spanish economy. Of course, those reform efforts continue to progress and I can tell you today that, once the labour reform has been approved, the Government wishes to introduce significant changes and reform to the employment policy. In particular, in the next few months, we are going to tackle an in-depth reform of the active employment policies system in order to increase their capacity to marry job demand with job offers and to ensure that workers, especially the unemployed, receive the most suitable training and education to enable them to participate in the development of the new production model.
I will summarise this into one idea: the public services in Spain have demonstrated a high degree of modernisation and progress over the course of these last thirty years, in every field and in the vast majority of areas that we can evaluate. It is clear that everything from healthcare to education, security or pension management, each and every area of activity, is a demonstration of a modern and advanced country. Notwithstanding, we must also recognise that the policies we implement through the public service, from the public arena, to encourage support for the unemployed, to favour employability and to more effectively manage intermediation and training are far from what we wish for as a country. And this must be a contributing factor, together with the labour reform and the economic recovery and the new production model, to providing a different outlook in regards to unemployment and the unemployed once and for all.
If, as I am convinced we will, we are to stabilise the financial system, the public accounts, to continue the process of cleaning up the economy and continuing with our economic growth, the great challenge that lies before us as a society is to definitively change the situation regarding unemployment and encourage employment in our country.
There have been two clear characteristics surrounding this problem for the last thirty years, a problem that must be resolved for the sake of our society, our people and our economy: firstly, we have always, or more often than not, had a rate of unemployment above the European average; secondly; whenever there is a crisis of this sort, our economy reacts by generating a large number of unemployed and, what's more, a much more widespread situation of temporary employment than the average in Europe.
Therefore, the economy must be improved in order to create jobs, the labour framework must be changed to help change employment, but we must also give the Government and all the public authorities one priority objective: to directly support each and every individual in seeking employment, to encourage training, to bring them closer to the labour market and to help companies to also have that possibility.
This will require far-reaching change; a target that I have set myself and that I intend to implement. The Authorities of this country must have the ability to know, support and help all Spaniards in many facets of their lives or in the relations they have with the Authorities.
This relationship must also be far more effective and direct with those people who find themselves without a job because that is, without a doubt, one of the great social priorities.
Total commitment to the reforms, new reforms, and, at the heart of those reforms, services and support to those people seeking employment. Many things need to be changed and it will not only depend on the State Government. In order to overcome this difference that separates us from the most advanced countries of Europe, we will need to depend on all the authorities and on society as a whole. Within the context of the comparative parameters with the most advanced countries of Europe, we are in a very good position, we have made great progress in thirty years, we have risen to their level. However, there remains one outstanding issue that we must resolve during our exit from this crisis and it must be resolved for the sake of our young people, for the people who have been without a job for so long. We need to change our priorities, our methods and, of course, ensure the main priority and objective for all our public authorities is direct support to each and every person in search of a job.
During these reforms, we seek to continue progressing with an attitude of dialogue and collaboration with the political forces and, as far as is humanly possible, with the social organisations. You are aware of my opinion on this issue: dialogue is always useful and agreement is very useful. There have been many agreements in recent months, such as the measures that were approved during the "Zurbano Process", there have been agreements relating to the reform of the financial system and there have been and still are certain areas where it would be very helpful to reach agreements, such as on energy policy, industrial policy, innovation policy or reform policies in favour of competitiveness.
Austerity, reforms and social cohesion. You will know that social cohesion is a core issue for the Government in regard to the crisis. I would like to briefly mention the unemployment protection measures. As you know, the rate of coverage currently stands at 80%; the highest rate ever recorded in our history for the support of the unemployed, and the Government promoted an extraordinary protection measure of 428 euros that came into force from 2009 until the end of June 2010 and which has, to date, supported 570,000 unemployed people.
The Government, in application of the corresponding legal capacity and in accordance with the Resolution adopted in the State of the Nation Debate, will extraordinarily extend this temporary programme of unemployment protection for a further six months. This extension will be approved in the Council of Minister to be held on 20 August, although it will come into effect from 16 August. It will be an extension that takes into consideration the Resolution approved last week by the Lower House of Parliament and that, therefore, focuses this programme extension on those people under the age of thirty or over the age of forty-five and who are classified as among the long-term unemployed, i.e. having consistently remained on the job seeker register of the employment services for at least twelve months, as established by the regulations.
I do not wish to linger on this issue for too much longer but allow me, before I start taking your questions, to conclude this initial presentation by referring to the situation of our economy. The Active Population Survey corresponding to the second quarter of the year was released today and there is one piece of positive data I would like to highlight: for the first time in two years, the Spanish economy has managed to create new jobs - we have 82,700 more jobs now than we did in the first quarter. However, partly as a result of an increasing active population, in other words, the number of people who wish to join the labour market, we continue to see an unacceptably high unemployment rate of 20%. This is the greatest concern of Spanish society and the Government, and the single greatest challenge lying before us, as I said before.
Based on the activity indicators we have been shown, we are convinced that our economic recovery has continued in the second quarter of the year and that growth in this second quarter is greater than that seen in the first quarter. This is suggested by the industrial production data, export data and business volume data in the services sector. We trust that it will also be reflected in the registered unemployment data and social security contributions data for the month of July, which will be released within the next few days.
We have also received another piece of important data within the last few days: we are managing, as we had previously committed ourselves to, to reduce the deficit. The combination of expenditure control and the positive trend in revenue has enabled us to reduce the deficit by 25% compared with the same month of 2009.
All these data demonstrate that the Spanish economy has the strength to grow but that this growth, as yet still weak, must be accompanied by consolidation, stability in the financial system, standardisation and improvement of credit and persistence in the application of the reforms in order for this growth to continue and strengthen.
As far as those issues that depend on the Government are concerned, we are going to persevere on the path we have laid out: austerity, more reforms and upholding our commitment to social cohesion. That is what we will be doing in the months to come, working hard in the coming weeks and, of course, with total confidence in the strength of Spanish society. If the Spanish economy has the strength to grow, as we will soon see, it is because Spanish society also has that strength to recover from this difficult period of economic crisis.
But we must continue tackling the situation with caution, caution in regard to what has demonstrated itself to be such a difficult and complicated crisis as the one we have experienced in recent months. Such caution is, without question, an obligation; the same obligation that the Government must diligently fulfil through all its commitments and duties and by calling on confidence and political collaboration in order, as soon as possible, to conclude this period of reforms and economic reactivation that will enable us to remain on the path that we have, albeit timidly, begun to follow towards the creation of new jobs.
Q. You have repeatedly stated that these six months have been plagued with a multitude of serious difficulties. Would you classify them as the hardest six months since you came to power, here in Moncloa?
I would also like to ask whether the Government or the Socialist Party are prepared to foster or accept any initiative endeavouring to overturn the decision of the Parliament of Catalonia to ban bullfighting or attempt to prevent any other autonomous region from doing the same in the future?
President of the Government. I said that these have been six trying months, six months with great action on the part of the Government in favour of reforms and against the instability of the markets in an attempt to guarantee the solvency of the Kingdom of Spain.
There have undoubtedly been difficult weeks and difficult days. I am sure that you can appreciate that for a President of the Government to have a large part of the public opinion at an international level focusing on the strength and solvency of the Spanish public accounts is somewhat trying. And, as I always understood that this feeling should not relate to reality, I feel that all the decisions we have taken, such as the reforms or the publication of the stress tests, have slowly but surely helped put things in their rightful place, resulting in greater solvency and credibility of the Spanish economy, both today and in the future, than at the beginning of this year and, above all, than in the months of May and June.
As regards the second question, I believe that President Montilla made a statement that gets the point across. He explained how he had voted and I feel that this reflection coincides with respect for all positions and the unsuitability of not using legislative mechanisms on prohibition. Aside from that, the Government is and always will be respectful of the powers of the autonomous regions, and, of course, the Government will be prudent and responsible, as should all sides be, in not politicising everything. We will reach a time in this country when absolutely everything becomes politicised. There is a debate at the moment and some people are in favour of bullfighting while others are opposed to it. One autonomous region, through the exercise of its powers, has taken a decision to ban bullfighting. Whilst one may disagree with this decision, it should not be politicised.
Q. As regards the reform that has just been announced regarding active employment policies, I would like to know why it has not been possible - taking into consideration that it is a reform that has been talked about for nearly two years - to incorporate it into the labour reform that is currently being passed through Parliament.
Secondly, in the interview given to the newspaper "El País" a week ago, the only question you left unanswered was the one regarding whether you would somehow accept to become the party's candidate once more. I would like to know, at any event, what approximate deadline exists to show your hand.
Finally, as regards the pending Government reshuffle and the rumours and speculation that are rife, and which, to some extent, affect your economic team, I should like to know if you would be prepared to renew your trust in the economic team, and in particular, in the Vice-President, Elena Salgado.
President of the Government. The truth is that, as a technique for asking questions, taking for granted certain things that are not facts is an interesting ploy to see if one falls into the trap when furnishing an answer, but I shall endeavour to be prudent.
I shall begin by going to the heart of things and responding to the first question. I believe that there is a distinction between what is, per se, the labour reform and the reform of active employment policies. I have insisted on a major overhaul of both policies and that the latter reform of active employment policies, of training and of support from the public authorities, also needs substantial social support - something we shall endeavour to achieve, and it needs, above all, a change in the orientation of the management of contributions and the organisation of the central authorities themselves.
This sector needs an intense process of modernisation, in other words, in the capacity that a State such as Spain should have so that each person who is unemployed feels, both directly and effectively, that the State is endeavouring to support and assist in seeking employment, this being undoubtedly the principal objective of those who are unemployed. This will force many things to change, and as I mentioned, autumn will be the time to present this reform.
As regards the second question, there is nothing new to say and neither am I going to satisfy your curiosity as to when there will be anything new.
As regards the pending reshuffle, I respect the fact that this idea may exist. For me, however, it doesn't. There is nothing pending, and of course, the task being carried out by the Vice-President in economic matters is a task set against an extremely complicated backdrop and she has my full support.
Q. I would like to insist on the matter of the labour reform, and more specifically, on the data from the Active Population Survey that was published today. As regards the call to dialogue that you made, I would like to know what possibilities you feel exist after what, for example, the main trade unions, and more specifically, the General Secretary of the union to which you belong, Cándido Méndez, have stated today: that this labour reform is heading in the direction of yet more job losses, and yesterday, together with the General Secretary of Comisiones Obreras, where they said that it was the most aggressive labour reform of the last thirty years. I would like to know what possibilities you feel exist for dialogue with the main trade unions in this matter.
As regards the political groups, we saw in the State of the Nation Debate, where you were supported by the CiU political group, but where the Catalans said that as soon as the reform period was over that they would drop their support for you definitively. When this moment should arrive, would you try to make any changes so as to promote your Government? I ask this in the conditional: would their be some kind of change in the Government so as to drive it forward or would you consider, as the Partido Popular is demanding, bringing the elections forward?
And if you would allow me, since we are talking about elections, do you support Tomás Gómez, the General Secretary of the PSOE in Madrid, in his candidacy for President of the Autonomous Region of Madrid?
President of the Government. As regards the reform and the attitude of the trade unions, I have a great respect for the unions and I know that yesterday and this morning they have made a rather strongly-worded statement. And this, above all, as a result of an amendment approved yesterday on the economic grounds for objective dismissals. I am going to do something rather unusual; I am going to read the text of the amendment, because it seems to me that in the last twenty-four hours it hasn't been read closely enough or that any initial evaluation made requires further thought.
The amendment textually states: "It is understood that economic grounds exist when it can be deduced from a company's results that there is a negative economic situation, such as when the company has recorded a current or foreseeable future loss, or a persistent reduction in turnover which may affect the viability of the business or its capacity to maintain its current level of employment". What economic grounds could justify an objective dismissal? That a company is not viable. What may cause a company not to be viable? A persistent reduction in turnover or losses.
Furthermore, the amendment goes on to state: "For these purposes, the company shall have to substantiate the alleged results and justify that it can be deduced from the data that it is reasonable to lay off staff in order to maintain or improve its competitive position in the market". In other words, economic grounds that justify the dismissal: that the company is not viable as it is making a loss or due to insufficient revenue, and moreover, that the business owner has to justify this to a judge.
As a result of this amendment and through this reform, the objective is that within our legal system, there truly exist objective grounds for economic reasons to justify this dismissal. Can anyone understand how, in 2009, out of all the dismissals in Spain, only 20% were based on the formula of an objective dismissal on economic grounds? Quite simply, it is impossible, because in 2009, there was a fall in the GDP of 3.6%, and as all Spaniards are aware, it was on economic grounds that so many companies dismissed so many people.
If we allow the possibility that the business owner is aware that there are objective grounds that provide for more legal certainty when hiring, we are fostering new hirings and ensuring that our legislation responds to the reality and not to fiction.
But I would like to go further than that. This is a discussion about dismissals. I have insisted on this to the unions: the fundamental objective of the labour reform being approved is to avoid dismissals. I would like to reiterate this statement, I reiterate it, I maintain it and I will defend it wherever necessary. Why? Because the reform is, above all, a reform to provide companies with flexibility where there was no flexibility before. Why? So that when faced with adverse economic circumstances, measures can be taken prior to dismissing workers, something which did not exist before. Two concrete examples of this: firstly, a reduction in the working day or a salary reduction, and secondly, what is known as the salary loophole of the collective bargaining agreements, whereby it is possible to lower salaries without laying off workers.
This is what the reform is and the reform deals with what it needs to. Hence, through the internal flexibility measures, which were not previously incorporated into our legal system with sufficient clarity, we are seeking to avoid layoffs and avoid going through what we have just been though in the event of a future crisis.
I have explained this on other occasions and I will say it again now. No more working hours have been lost in Spain than Germany, nor vice versa: they have lost practically the same working hours, however, Spain has lost a good deal more jobs. Why? Because all the adjustments in our country have taken place en masse, and in relation to jobs whereas in Germany, the majority of the adjustments have affected salaries and hence allowed jobs to be maintained. And the million dollar question is what do we want? Do we want a labour model or a job market in which, when a company is in a difficult situation or when faced with an economic crisis, where there are twenty workers, each employee takes a 5% wage cut or the company has to lay off five workers? This is what we are talking about, this is the change of model, the labour reform. It is a change to ensure fewer dismissals and a change so that our labour market becomes more European, in the same way as we have done in many other areas of the economy and society in general.
The second major reform contained in the Royal Decree Law is intended to reverse the trend from temporary employment towards stable employment, from so many individual employment contracts towards indefinite contracts.
I know that my answer has been somewhat wordy, but it seems essential to me. The labour reform exists to avoid dismissals. As if this need saying! I think that you can consider that a labour reform helps to create employment and I have stated on the record that it helps to create employment. However, it is not the decisive catalyst in the creation of jobs, the economy is, but what we do know is that, in times of crisis, the way in which the job market adapts to the circumstances of the crisis is decisive as to how many jobs are lost or not.
And the truth is that the current model cannot be defended, as can be evidenced by the fact that the level of unemployment has shot up to 20% under this labour model during each crisis suffered. I cannot defend this. Should there have been any remaining doubts, this third economic crisis since the Transition - the eighties, the nineties and now the third - has reconfirmed that in times of crisis our labour model is incapable of reacting to adapt to the reality. For this reason we have taken on this reform and, of course, at least - I must say this to the political parties and the trade unions - they should be cautious enough to wait and see the results vis-à-vis the two objectives: avoiding dismissals and saving companies, and increasing job stability.
We have worked in favour of social dialogue and, during the last legislature, in times of growth, we reached twenty agreements with the trade unions and with business leaders. There is now a significant discrepancy as a result of the labour reform and the policy of readjustments that we have been forced to pursue. The trade unions have their forms of reacting and protesting, and I respect that deeply; but we are always open to dialogue and, of course, we do not doubt that they will be called to dialogue in all the reforms mentioned; which to me is essential.
As regards the political groups, it is true that we have had to work hard with these groups to reach a consensus for each major reform. I am extremely grateful to those groups that have allowed or fostered the approval of the reforms and the deficit reduction plan. I am extremely grateful to them. I believe that they have served the country and the future of the Spanish economy well. As I have mentioned on various occasions: the Government is doing what it needs to do and this includes many difficult tasks, but they are necessary and we shall do them. We know that the responsibility lies with the Government and that the people demand this of the Government. But I am very grateful to those political groups that have favoured this dialogue and support. I would like the number of these political groups to be greater, but that is no easy matter. I understand that it is not easy to say yes to unpopular measures. But the Government has an obligation, a basic principle of responsibility to your country when difficult measures need to be taken and for those groups not in Government, they are measured for their capacity to commit and be responsible to the country.
Reforms. I have asked all Ministers to be effective in the reforms and set those pending in motion, and I have told the political groups that this is a time for reforms and agreements. What we are doing during 2010 and the first half of 2011, until 2012, these two years are going to define the economy and the well-being of Spain for the next twenty years. That is what is important about this situation. Only if we change things, if we improve the economy and if we are brave, however hard this may be, can we be confident that we are making the economy stronger, that we shall maintain our Welfare State, that our prosperity shall be the basic ingredient of our way of life and that we shall be as strong as the strongest in Europe.
There are countries which we currently considered to be more competitive, which are more developed and where this is a more advanced Welfare State, which have achieved this situation coming out of an economic crisis. Some of these are in Europe and there are clear examples; they have known how to react and devise forward-looking policies. And that is what government is all about.
Regarding the other matter, I don't feel that Moncloa is the right place to comment on an internal issue of the Socialist Party.
Q. I am going to change the subject. Last Sunday in an interview, you stated your satisfaction regarding the attempt in 2006 to do away with ETA and you said that you hope this leads the way to a definitive solution to the problem. Since this statement comes at a time of celebrating a whole year without any deaths, or better said, without attacks from the terrorist group, and comes at a time in which the Ministry for Home Affairs is moving prisoners to prisons close to the Basque Country, my question is: should the conditions be right, would you once again attempt this?
And then, a clarification. You were asked earlier about your personal future and you have now told us on various occasions that you do not wish to reveal your future until after the elections for the autonomous regions, but I would like you to tell us the decisive factors as to whether you stand again in 2012.
President of the Government. I am not going to tell you. And that's final.
As regards the first question, which is very straight-forward, fortunately - and, furthermore, I know that this is one of the things that the Spanish people value most highly due to what we have all had to suffer - the fight against terrorism has had some very positive results. The whole anti-terrorism policy of harassment to put an end to ETA has shown a positive balance, not only statistically, but also because a conviction exists, both in the Basque Country and in Spain as a whole, that in this final phase, over the course of the last few years, we are definitively winning the battle against violence and against ETA.
In this battle to definitively reach a peace process, there was undoubtedly an instrument which accelerated the conditions necessary to win the battle and see violence brought to its knees: weaken ETA clearly, weakening the support for violence and increasing the voices, the will and the political commitment in favour of the eradication of violence.
All the policies made by the Government in this matter, including the penitentiary policy - which among its missions includes an anti-terrorism mission - are aimed at bringing an end to ETA within a clearly-defined legal framework and moreover, effectively, with great effectiveness on the part of the Ministry of Home Affairs in this matter.
There may be political controversy and the opposition may make political controversy of anything it wishes, as is normal and even reasonable as regards those things which are objectively difficult for the Spanish people and for the country; but in all sincerity, I cannot understand why someone would wish to make political controversy in general out of the fight against terrorism, and moreover, with the positive balance in the fight against terrorism and against ETA that this Government has had, I find is absolutely unacceptable.
Q. In the "Road Map" that you have established, it seems that Spain needs until the end of 2011 to get to grips with the reforms. In the State of the Nation Debate, we saw that the political party Convergència i Unió committed itself to the reforms but not the State Budgets, while the political party PNV is still undecided. While drawing up the State Budgets for the coming year, are you taking into account the possibility that they will need to be extended in the event of not receiving sufficient support? Perhaps you consider the mechanism to be inadequate and hence, you would feel compelled to call elections in the event of the Budgets not being passed, or do you not consider it to be serious, although perhaps it is a negative sign for the markets that the Budgets need to be extended?
President of the Government. We are working to draw up, propose and take decisions on reforms, and also on the tests that were carried out, and also to call on sufficient political support for the reforms, as we will do with the Budgets. We work with a purpose: to draw up Budgets that will help to reduce the deficit, that include the content necessary to improve the productive model, to maintain basic social cohesion because this is vital for the Spanish economy.
Of course we are going to work to get the Budgets passed, and as everyone can appreciate, we will do this calmly, but without providing a running commentary on our work, because logically, it is a task where the commitment, dialogue and agreement are difficult; as has been the whole process of reforms, but where I have always felt that conditions prevail for the responsible attitude of MPs and parliamentary groups when drawing up the State Budgets and approving the reforms.
Of course there are still reforms to make, I have just indicated some of them while others I have not drawn to your attention so as not to bombard you; the reform of the pension system is still outstanding, for example. This is a fundamental commitment and a generational commitment. It is a pension system so that today's workers can have a decent pension that continues improving, in the same way as it has been improving over the last few years, and that this is feasible. It is necessary to take this reform on board and it needs to be done today to pave the way for tomorrow. Let's not wait for tomorrow when we will do a worse job because our backs are against the wall. If we do this today, it will be a fair, progressive and acceptable reform which, moreover, will strengthen the expectations regarding the stability of the economy.
Hence, we are going to work to gain support for the State Budgets and we shall not think outside of this box, as you can imagine, because it is within that box that we believe the conditions exist for this to take place and, of course, to continue accompanied by the suitable reforms.
Q. I would like to ask you about the willingness of the Government of Spain to negotiate with the autonomous regions that have declared they are suffering from extreme financial difficulties in regard to next year, and above all, about the proposal from the Regional Government of Galicia, which was joined by that of the Canary Islands yesterday, to postpone the reimbursements of the advance payments made in 2008 and 2009.
President of the Government. The Government has shared the deficit reduction plan with the autonomous regions, it has shared the fiscal consolidation plan, and, of course we do not intend to change any decision that has already been taken, specifically in regard to the subject of your question. That will remain under the terms established, because this is logical and fair.
Q. Allow me to insist on the subject of Tomás Gómez. I don't know if you think that the whole debate that has taken place, or rather should I say combat, within the Socialist Party of Madrid regarding whether the candidature of Tomás Gómez is due to electoral concerns or in order to gain control of the party.
President of the Government. I have already refused to answer one question regarding party policies because I do not believe Moncloa is the forum for that debate. I will take the first opportunity available outside of the institutional scope of the Presidency of the Government to answer that question. To me it seems to be much more respectful to this institution and to the minimal degree of separation that should exist between the Government and the party, and between the President of the Government and the General Secretary of the party. Of course I have an opinion on the subject, but I will give that opinion in another time and place.
Q. I would like to ask for a reflection that will surely be more subjective than objective. We are getting ever closer to an electoral process in which we are used to votes being swayed by ideological labels and by the reforms approved by the Government, particularly the last ones, such as the labour reform, which have ended up in a sort of no man's land. The minority groups to the left of the Socialist Party reject this reform; the Partido Popular, as the principle representative of the right, also rejects these reforms and you can only find sporadic support from two forces that are somewhere between nationalist forces and right-wing forces.
Bearing this in mind and taking into consideration the role of ideological labels, where do you see yourself and the Socialist Party as a result of all these processes?
President of the Government. Regarding opinions on the reform, I am going to tell you what my feeling is. Firstly, when we approved this reform, the Royal Decree Law, we said that it was a balanced and important reform, and the facts are confirming that it is balanced, because, let's say it is under fire and criticised by those who would prefer that dismissals did not come before a judge in this country - of course they criticise it - who would prefer there to be no grounds or some such thing, or on the other hand those who consider that a company, although it loses 50% of its revenue, can maintain its entire workforce and not take measures.
This is not possible, as we know, and the hard reality has shown this to be true.
Hence, the reform is balanced, but there is more: a labour reform is not easy and a certain political determination is necessary. I am extremely surprised by those who have spent years in Government and made practically no labour reforms, they didn't begin to tackle internal flexibility or grounds for dismissal, nothing was touched in a serious manner and yet now, when the Government presents a reform that tackles the fundamental issues… moreover, after yesterday, with the incorporation of the amendment, there also exists a mandate so that, if in six months business leaders and trade unions do not reach an agreement through collective bargaining, then the Government will participate in the collective bargaining.
In other words, they made no kind of reform and yet when we propose a significant labour reform of the labour market and they haven't presented any kind of alternative whatsoever, after I have been in Parliament listening to Mr. Rajoy banging on for a year and a half about "the labour reform, the labour reform…" We have taken a labour reform to Parliament following the period for dialogue between business leaders and the trade unions, and once it is there before them, they say to us, "I have nothing to say about the labour reform". Either he doesn't have a clear idea of what needs reforming in the labour market or he doesn't dare to say what needs reforming in the labour market.
Think about it, and I don't say this because I think that they could propose initiatives or amendments that would be more or less attractive, no, I say this because I believe that public debate on different alternatives is very positive. Whenever someone makes a proposal regarding the temporary nature of contracts, or regarding flexibility, I believe this is interesting and it is dreadful that such an alternative has not even been proposed.
And, if you will allow me, from an ideological point of view, as was noted in regard to the electoral confrontations, the Spanish Socialist Workers Party can be characterised by two core features since the democratic transition: it is the party that has placed most emphasis and made most effort in passing modernising reforms for Spain, while at the same time, it is the party that has done most for the Welfare State and for social cohesion in Spain. The figures regarding the increase in social cohesion during Felipe Gonzalez's mandate and the consolidation of the Welfare State cannot be argued with. Neither can the figures regarding the management of the Government that I have presided over since 2004 in terms of the increase in social protection and social costs be argued with.
Hence, this is our political and ideological position: we are very ambitious in our modernising reforms and, of course, those of us who lead the parties that may govern or have governed are very ambitious in terms of social cohesion and social policies. And what's more, these two things are inseparable, because in order to continue making social policies to improve pensions, education, grants and housing subsidies, and to enact laws such as the Dependency Act, to extend it and improve it, two things are necessary: the growth of the economy, which increases wealth, and the political will to distribute it through expenditure, and this is what ideologically distinguishes one Government from another - how it distributes this expenditure and what part of it goes on social costs, on costs that unite people.
Q. I would like to know, in relation to the anti-terrorism debate, what is your criterion regarding whether ETA and Batasuna or the 'abertzale left' is the same.
You have also announced a reform of the public employment policies. I would like to know why you do not trust the companies that are already participating in this kind of activity and which are doing so reasonably well and why you have not opted for public-private collaboration.
In terms of employment, I would like to know the date on which you think there is going to be a swing towards recovery in employment. I ask this because you have already mentioned various dates and these have not come to pass.
Finally, you stated that there has been an improvement in the credibility of the solvency of the Spanish economy, but just yesterday, Banco Santander indicated that, despite the stress tests taking off some of the pressure, this remained high and was due to a lack of credibility. I would like to know what your Government is going to do to improve this credibility to reach 3% by 2013 and, more specifically, if there are going to be any new tax figures, if there is going to be an increase in taxation or if you are going to introduce co-payment of healthcare or education.
President of the Government. I'm sorry, was that just one question?
As regards employment, this quarter has seen job creation and there are now 82,000 more people in work. With unemployment levels as they are, this is a mere drop in the ocean, but at least it is a positive sign; let's hope that this trend continues to consolidate towards the end of the year, and in particular, in 2011. Job creation will be a slow process, we should be aware of that, because in order to reduce the unemployment levels, which are so high, we need to create many jobs.
In relation to active employment policies or the task of intermediation, the reform of the labour market represents an act in line with what I mentioned regarding confidence, as long as there is more participation and more possibilities for those from the private sector who intermediate in the labour market. But the public authorities in a country like ours, in an advanced State, cannot resign themselves to holding such a low percentage of labour intermediation for the workers. Those who find work as a result of the actions of the public authorities is such a small percentage; we know that we have to improve training and training actions, which are the two key conditions for being employable.
I said that stability and credibility have improved, that things have calmed down. We have had two issues of Treasury bonds where the interest rates have been slightly reduced. This is a figure which supports this calm, this increased stability, but this does not mean that we don't have to carry on with many other actions to consolidate and improve them.
I would say that two things are fundamental in this area: the first, fully consolidating the reform of the financial sector. Our entities, the banks, have come out of the stress tests well; the majority of our savings banks too, but no-one doubts that the financial system could be even sounder, have even more credibility and help the economy even more if capital is increased. I believe this is a suitable measure for the savings banks to take, or at least for the majority of the savings banks. I am convinced that the savings banks are thinking along these lines but that this will take some time. This is an important factor.
The second factor is complying with the reforms. I believe that it is recognised that the reforms have been approved, but, as is natural, it will take time to analyse and verify the effective compliance with the reforms. Of course, the deficit reduction is essential, but not only the deficit reduction, also the labour reform, also the pension reform and all the other structural reforms, and if the economic figures help, so much the better.
If the growth figure for the second quarter, as we expect, is a positive growth figure and an improvement on the first quarter, this will boost confidence. And if we can manage to reduce our external deficit, in which there has been a very significant reduction, which was one of the main imbalances of the Spanish economy, then this will boost confidence, but there is still an awful lot to do.
But if you will allow me to say it, I believe we are heading in the right direction and we only need to comply, comply and comply with the reforms.
As regards the first part of your question, I have already answered it. The anti-terrorism policy is giving some very positive results, although all of society is aware that ETA and its policy of violence are seriously weakened while democracy is increasingly stronger.
And what I would ask as President of the Government is that we don't reopen this matter in political debate. The recent past has been very positive, in fact, the vast majority of this legislature, and this has helped the fight against terrorism to be successful. Should we continue in a climate of not using anti-terrorism policy, whichever one it may be - whether penitentiary or whatever else in the fight against ETA - this will help us to be successful.
The Government has been very clear and very firm in its position: firstly, there can be only one fate for ETA, only one and with no strings attached, and that is that it lays down its weapons and expects nothing in exchange, absolutely nothing. It can only do one thing, lay down its arms; secondly, those who do not separate and reject violence can have no political-institutional representation in any way whatsoever.
These are the two principles and I can assure you these are the two principles with which we have worked, and after the peace process, as I said before, and the capacity to demonstrate to the vast majority of Basque the uselessness, the cruelty and the absolute and radical unfeasibility of any kind of support for violence or proximity to violence, this determination to do away with ETA is increasingly stronger. It would be highly appropriate for this subject, which has been dealt with calmly by the main political parties, to also become calm. The Government is well aware of what is going on and the Government knows that the fight against ETA is always hard and difficult and that one needs to be extremely tenacious; but tenacity also bears its fruits.
Q. The new aspect that the debate on anti-terrorism policy has introduced into politics is that regarding prisoner releases. What I would quite simply like to ask is whether there is, as not only the PP but also the victims have said, a possible change in penitentiary policy and a possible change in anti-terrorism policy revolving around this recovery of the process that you yourself assessed a moment ago as positive in the history of anti-terrorism policy.
Secondly, by way of confirmation, I understand, as a result of what you mentioned earlier, that the Government has completely ruled out any support for the PP initiative to maintain bull-fighting throughout the national territory?
Finally, I would like you to give me a political balance on the situation of relations between Catalonia and the rest of Spain following the ruling on the Estatut by the Constitutional Court - on whether they have deteriorated or not?
President of the Government. As regards the first issue, the penitentiary policy being applied by the Government of Spain is the same penitentiary policy that has been applied for years in our democracy by all the governments; a penitentiary policy designed - among other things, this being one of its objectives - to weaken ETA and do away with ETA, in accord with the strictest legality, and of course, aware of who should be aware of it.
As regards bull-fighting, I have already stated our position on the matter. We would have preferred for their to have been no attempts to ban it, and I coincided in this position with President Montilla; but, of course, we are not going to politicise this like some would like us to, and, of course, we are not going to enter a debate which, objectively only has one answer, which is that the autonomous regions are competent in respect of the regulation of public spectacles, something they have regulated on many times in the past. As you can imagine, nobody had planned for this dilemma.
Regarding Catalonia, I have made many assessments on the consequences of the ruling on the Estatut. I think we have some work ahead of us. I have commissioned the Vice-President for Regional Policy to set up and intensify dialogue with the Regional Government of Catalonia in order to evaluate the steps necessary to develop the Estatut, and of course, to carry out political initiatives that lead to a climate of increased trust among the Catalan political forces, the Catalan institutions and the rest of the country; in particular, as regards the responsibility of the Government of Spain.
I said it in Barcelona and I say it again here: the Government is not responsible for the ruling, but the Government is responsible for the consequences of the ruling. If at this level, as it could be in another autonomous region, this upsets many citizens of Catalonia, then the Government, logically, must listen and strive, through dialogue, to improve this situation. This is what we are going to do.
Q. Continuing along the same lines of the Estatut and the Catalans, a survey was presented this morning in Barcelona by the Centre for Opinion Studies of the Regional Government of Catalonia, which concluded that the Socialist Party would not win the general elections in Catalonia for the first time in its history. Knowing this, together with another survey which was disseminated a few months ago in Andalusia, which are two bulk voting areas for your party, I would like to know whether, in your role as President of the Government, you consider this is caused by your late response to the ruling and to your reaction to the upset caused by the ruling?
How are you going to become more involved in the Catalan political agenda, something you mentioned in Barcelona last Friday?
To what extent are you concerned by these two surveys, the one in Andalusia and the one in Catalonia?
President of the Government. When we work, we try to do things right, particularly in our political relations with Catalonia. That has been my objective since day one. Of course, one should always respect surveys, but we are working to win the elections, not the surveys, and we have a certain respect in Catalonia and we try to nurture this - of course the PSC will do this now and when the general elections come around - in order to obtain once again, as the Socialist Party, wide support in Catalonia. My opinion is that this will continue in this way.
Q. Mr. President, I would like to ask you two questions regarding the same matter.
On the one hand, you gave thanks earlier for the support that you received, both for the economic reforms undertaken and for the forthcoming General State Budgets. I would like to ask you if you believe that the CiU and the PNV political parties are doing more for the stability of Spain than the PP.
Secondly, and you spoke about this earlier, in autumn the electoral campaign begins with the Catalan elections. I would like to know what your expectations are, aside from these surveys. Did you speak with President Montilla about what the future may hold there in his recent visit to Moncloa?
President of the Government. The question suggests a dramatic, remarkable headline; but I am not going to fall into that trap. I will say that I am grateful to the political groups that are supporting the reforms. I have no doubts that, in perspective - the things talked about in politics are lasting and give a certain perspective - this task and this attitude will be recognised. Aside from that, the rest of the groups can do what they see fit; but it is my heartfelt conviction that this role in supporting the difficult reforms will be recognised. Voting on the Government's side in something straight-forward has a limited merit, whilst voting on the Government's side on a difficult reform is noteworthy.
That is how it is and the whole world knows it. And, of course, also the strength and the cohesion of the Socialist Party and the Socialist Group, and the Socialist Party's capacity to generate these agreements. It is a common saying that the political forces which truly count in the great democracies are those which show most strength in the most difficult times. That is what makes a great party and the PSOE has shown that it is a great party, because in such difficult times as these, with difficult measures for a socialist party…, we stand like a rock. You know that this is what makes a country and what being committed to your country means. If only more parties had this character, or better said, this DNA.
Q. I had two questions. Firstly, I would like to go back a second to the labour reform. You have read us the amendment and I wanted to ask you if you are confident or afraid that in the hands of certain unscrupulous business owners, certain provisions may give rise to abuses to workers' rights. Do you intend to implement some kind of trial period to verify how the reform is going and whether there are certain dysfunctional aspects?
Secondly, in light of not only the forthcoming General Budgets, but looking further ahead than that, in the State of the Nation Debate, you proposed to the PNV a stable agreement to terminate the legislature. I wanted to ask you if this objective is still viable, if, in the light of the demands of the PNV, you would be satisfied with the agreement as to the Budgets and if you would be prepared to negotiate a condition such as the one proposed by them, which would mean respecting the most voted list in the forthcoming local and provincial elections.
President of the Government. Regarding the reform and the economic grounds for dismissal, when a reform is carried out, in this field as in others, it is carried out with the presumption that the business owners fulfil their role and the workers theirs. We cannot carry out a reform thinking about unscrupulous business owners or workers who are not going to fulfil their side of the bargain, because it is a case, in a logical process of defending interests, where there are clear interests in respect of what is the company and what are the workers, a fair balance exists.
I have tried to reason logically in respect of the amendment. Is it reasonable that a company suffers economically when its turnover falls in such a way that the business loses its viability or cannot maintain employment? It would seem that this is reasonable logic. Furthermore, should someone verify this? Yes, the judge.
Therefore, what is reasonable takes place in a process of this nature: there are objective grounds for an objective dismissal, and moreover, this takes place under the tutelage of the courts. Your arguments alone are not enough. If you are unscrupulous, you cannot simply argue in your own favour, you must substantiate this.
It seems to me that it is fairly balanced and would be a good idea for the whole text of the article, together with the amendment, to be read as one, as I have done today, and that all those who have made clear statements in this respect between yesterday and this morning, read the text more leisurely, as the authors of the text did yesterday with my full approval, of course.
Parliamentary stability. Exactly, it is clear that with the PNV, as I mentioned in the State of the Nation Debate, we are well disposed towards dialogue and that this, surely, is a day-to-day task involving many areas. Of course, as far as the responsibility of the Government is concerned, these areas should be the reform, the Budgets and the content. If there are other areas, they will be areas of responsibility for the Socialist Party, not for the Government, in this dialogue.
Thank you very much