Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government at Tribuna Barcelona.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

22 July 2010 · Tribuna Barcelona, Barcelona, Spain

Context
Zapatero addressed Tribuna Barcelona in July 2010, outlining Spain's economic reform agenda amid the financial crisis, with particular reference to Catalonia.
Main themes
Economic reforms, labor market reform, fiscal consolidation, financial system restructuring, competitiveness, productive model transformation, welfare state, savings banks reform, SMEs, pension reform, infrastructure and innovation, Catalonia's economy
Duration
~79 min
97th percentile
Words
9,431
97th percentile
Sentences
306
95th percentile
Readability
39
34th percentile
Grade
15.2
77th percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 38%38%
  • Economic 31%30%
  • Ceremonial 13%13%
  • Social 9%9%
  • Geopolitical 7%7%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

306 sentences in 124 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

The call to attention regarding this event, which I consider of utmost importance and which will take place in a few hours, gives me the opportunity to begin this address by offering my perspective on the economic horizon of Spain and Catalonia.

I am convinced that this horizon will be marked by the process of reforms that we are undertaking.

These are reforms that, unlike other variables of the crisis that are beyond the control of each country, are within our reach to complete and implement. They are reforms that strengthen us in the face of the exit from the crisis and that will compensate for the faster-than-expected withdrawal of fiscal stimuli in the vast majority of European economies. They are reforms to boost economic recovery, to foster a change in the productive model, to achieve a more competitive and sustainable economy, to create jobs again, which is our main challenge, and to preserve and reinforce our welfare state.

These are reforms, I know, that are not easy to undertake and that involve new efforts and demands, but that in the medium and long term will yield as much benefit as the ambition we are capable of putting into them now.

They are, therefore, reforms that, alongside the firm pattern of rigor and austerity applied to public spending, will continue to absorb the energy and determination of the Government of Spain in the coming months and until the end of the Legislature.

And they are reforms, finally, that are set to produce a strong mobilizing effect on economic activity throughout the country, but, in particular, in some Autonomous Communities like Catalonia, due to its industrial weight, its export capacity, the composition of its productive fabric, and its early and sustained commitment to innovation.

I have referred to them at some length in light of the recent parliamentary debates. Today I will limit myself to recalling, first of all, that the reform of the financial system is well advanced and that Congress has just validated the Royal Decree Law reforming the Organic Law of Savings Banks, which profoundly modifies their legal regime in order to strengthen their solvency, facilitate their access to capital markets, and professionalize their management.

This is one of the most significant milestones of the process that, with a high degree of consensus, we initiated with the approval of the Fund for the Ordered Restructuring of Banking, which in a very short time, just a few months, has resized the savings banks in our country. The resizing has been very significant in Catalonia, with the formation of three large groups of savings banks that, with a total of more than 380 billion euros in assets, will be able to continue supporting, under even better conditions than in the past, the economic development of this land.

At this moment, the reform of the labor market that the Government has presented is also in parliamentary process to effectively reduce duality, promote greater job stability, and facilitate the adaptation of companies to the demanding conditions of a changing and highly competitive economic environment. This labor market reform, which is the most ambitious in recent decades, aims to establish a framework of labor relations that facilitates the implementation in our country of that renewed productive model that we need, with greater training for workers and more innovative effort from companies.

The Government's intention is to conclude the reform with the broadest possible consensus and, in this regard, we have expressed our full willingness to incorporate into the parliamentary process all those amendments that may increase its effectiveness. The coming days will be decisive for forging this consensus and introducing improvements to the norm initially approved by the Executive. And I am confident that we will achieve this.

Some of the measures of the labor reform, as they aim to increase the adaptability of companies by relaxing the conditions established in sectoral collective agreements, will benefit smaller companies more, in which it is difficult to have their own collective agreement. Therefore, and given that the relative presence of SMEs is greater in Catalonia than in the rest of Spain, both in terms of turnover and employment, it is reasonable to expect that the effects of the labor reform will be even more positive in the case of the Catalan economy.

Ladies and gentlemen,

Fiscal consolidation, the restructuring of the financial system, labor reform, or the pension system reform, which we also want to conclude in the coming months, are necessary and essential, but not sufficient; we must also complete the other changes of very varied nature that affect the competitiveness of our economy.

The Government has been working on improving competitiveness as a whole since 2004, particularly with a focus on three areas: infrastructure, R&D+i, and training, which are determinants of labor productivity.

The effort to modernize infrastructure in Catalonia has had special significance in the last five years: more than twelve billion euros, which materialize in realities such as the new terminal at El Prat, the completion of the High-Speed connection, which continues its journey towards the rest of Europe, and the firm commitment to the Mediterranean Corridor, so that the port of Barcelona will be the first connected with Europe this year in terms of international gauge.

The budgetary restrictions that we have had to adopt additionally as a consequence of the commitment to accelerate the reduction of the deficit will condition the execution of some of the proposed projects; however, if we adhere to the criterion of the volume of investment, which is the most relevant, it can be seen that this impact has, in relative terms, a very limited, minimal significance.

In terms of education, Catalonia stands out particularly for the quantity and quality of its undergraduate and postgraduate university educational offerings. Its great potential has been recognized with the granting of two of the five mentions of International Campus of Excellence 2009, which comes with a commitment of loans of more than thirty million euros.

And in terms of research, we have undertaken a first stage consisting of strengthening the foundation of our R&D system with an increase in public investment in research that simply has no precedent in our history, as we have practically tripled the volume of public spending on R&D. And now a new stage has opened in which, with criteria of maximum responsibility and austerity in spending, we will optimize the use of these resources and capabilities that we have all increased over the last few years. A magnificent example of our effort and cooperation in this area has been the recent inauguration of the ALBA Synchrotron in Cerdanyola del Vallés, the largest scientific infrastructure built in Spain and all of Southern Europe.

I also want to highlight three other key areas for improving competitiveness and decisive, in particular, for the present and future of the economy of Catalonia: industrial policy, innovation, and the internationalization of companies to increase their export capacity.

After a prolonged period in which industrial policy has not received the attention it deserved, we are designing a framework that frames the Government's actions in this area. I recall that starting in 2004, when I took over the Government, I recovered a ministry of industrial policy, a Ministry of Industry, which the President of the Generalitat knows well. And we are carrying out this industrial policy in collaboration with the Autonomous Communities and social agents.

I want to expressly thank, in this regard, the collaboration and contributions that the Generalitat de Catalunya has made to the Comprehensive Industrial Policy Plan that aligns and complements the Generalitat's Industrial Policy Plan for the period 2010-2020.

The objective of the State Plan is to increase the weight of industry in the economy by three percentage points, from the current 15% of GDP to 18% of GDP, which is the European average, by 2020, to position ourselves at that average. Most of the large European countries have between three and four percentage points more of their industrial GDP in total GDP, such as Germany, France, etc.

In the case of Catalonia, where a quarter of industrial turnover is concentrated, that average is already reached, already reaching 18%, and the objective should be more ambitious: we must exceed 20% of the weight of industry in the total GDP of Catalonia, that is, position ourselves in Catalonia at the same level as Germany or Sweden, which are above 20% in terms of industrial weight in total GDP.

The same can be said, alongside the industrial policy strategy, of the Innovation Strategy. We are already the ninth scientific power in the world, that is, we occupy the same place in the ranking as our Gross Domestic Product, the ninth industrial power in the world; but we are far from occupying that place in innovation, in the ability to transform the science we produce and publish into the economy. Our productive fabric must take advantage of all the potential that our Research and Development system has.

We have set ourselves a goal: to double the number of innovative companies by 2015, which means 40,000 additional innovative companies in Spain. And again, here Catalan companies, due to their longer track record in innovation, are in a better position to capitalize on this joint effort; an effort that should translate into greater export strength, which we are supporting with various actions in favor of the internationalization of companies.

And I want to emphasize at this event the good performance, the excellent performance, that our export sector is having, which has withstood the crisis better than the European average and which at this moment, in the exit from the crisis, is growing above the European average and is set to play a decisive role in recovery and in the change of the productive model. As we expand and increase our exports, we will generate more savings in our country, we will generate a greater capacity for investment, and we will limit the indebtedness that has characterized a good part of Spain's economic development for too many years.

In Catalonia, there are 37,000 exporting companies, and their growing penetration in Asia, the market with the greatest potential in the world, is particularly noteworthy, where we are making a special effort to strengthen our diplomatic and commercial ties. But here we have a great window of opportunity for companies in general in Spain and, in particular, for Catalan companies because they already have solid foundations in Asia, especially in China. Here, without a doubt, we will intensify that task, and it is certainly one of the Government's priority agendas and one of the priority agendas of my work.

In short, decisive reforms for our competitiveness, decisive for the renewal of the productive model, decisive for the long-term sustainability of our Welfare State and social cohesion, which is the hallmark of the European model and must continue to be so. And they are reforms, moreover, that point to the very heart of the Catalan economy, to its identity markers as such, and to the unleashing of its energies and great potential.

To emerge from this crisis, as we are doing, and to grow economically again, with healthier growth, with a new economic growth, with a new model of economic growth, Spain needs Catalonia and Catalonia needs Spain.

Now more than ever, it is not rhetorical to say that Catalonia must do it with Spain and Spain with Catalonia, and there is only one way to conceive this coexistence: within a common project based on respect and recognition of those who make it up. Only in this way.

Allow me to make a personal reference in this act. As you know, and as President Montilla recalled, it has just been ten years since I received the trust of my colleagues to occupy the General Secretariat of my party. These days I have had the opportunity to reflect on all this time, on how things have evolved, sometimes in a dizzying and surprising way as in recent months, and on how I myself have been able to evolve to adapt and respond to many of the changing circumstances we have to live through.

Well, I believe that if I had to summarize in three the ideas or values that give meaning to my political commitment and my political task, I could affirm that they have not changed at their root in these years and that, to admit as the main parameter for judging my actions and decisions by others, I would place my vision of plural Spain, of Spain inseparable from the recognition of the political identity of Catalonia, at the same level as my conception of democracy, of the importance of dialogue, of respect for the adversary, of tolerance, of ideological pluralism or, if you will, of spirit; and, on the other hand, the political action committed to the most disadvantaged, to equality of opportunity, and in the fight against all forms of discrimination of one human being by another.

These would be my three great political convictions: plural Spain, democratic advancement, equality, and non-discrimination. I place them on a level of parity, of value, among the three. They are three priorities or principles on which I would not like to fail or fall short of my own demands and the demands of others.

With this attitude, I have always approached the position of Catalonia within democratic Spain and, in particular, any relevant event for it. That is why I do not have to make the slightest effort to appreciate that the problems that Catalan society, the majority of its citizens, and its political forces feel as such are problems of Spain; they are problems that we all have, that concern and challenge us all, and first and foremost the President of the Government, because as President of the Government, I am also, and I feel very particularly, President of the Catalan citizens and, consequently, responsible to them in the exercise of my position.

My position in defense of the Statute is well known. I have always believed that we should give way, in accordance with the procedures and norms of the Constitution, to the Statute, to the Statute that is currently in force, and that we should give way to the majority will of the representatives of Catalan society to renew their self-government and to see the recognition of their political identity reinforced.

The difficulties are also well known, because the Statute of Catalonia was and is a great step in plural Spain; difficulties that we had to navigate during the process of gestation and approval of the reform; difficulties and pressures to which, by the way, we did not shrink back, since what we did was legitimate and through the legitimate path, in addition to being very majority here, in Catalonia, and more than sufficiently majority in the Cortes Generales.

The second part is equally well known: a challenge before the Constitutional Court that questioned the Statute globally and fundamentally, in an irritating difference -- irritating the difference -- from the attitude shown by the challengers with other analogous statutory reforms, and a process before this body, the Constitutional Court, that was too troubled and that also excessively delayed the decision.

I cannot say it more clearly, and this statement should not surprise anyone: constitutionally, I do not feel, nor politically, responsible for the ruling, nor for its verdict, nor for its reasoning. I accept it, of course; I comply with it and will enforce it, and I provide, of course, the due institutional support, as I have provided at all times, fulfilling my obligation, to the body that issued it in the exercise of its competencies: the Constitutional Court.

I am not responsible for the ruling, but I do feel responsible for its political consequences. I take charge of those political consequences.

I believe that the legal effects of the ruling are limited, very limited compared to the extent and intensity of the challenges it responds to; that the Statute has been globally validated, even more so, that it no longer hangs over the legal uncertainty of the challenge and that its validity is guaranteed and the horizon of its development and application is cleared. But I am aware that the circumstances and events that have surrounded the entire process may have generated discomfort in a broad sector of the Catalan citizenry. And I take note of it. How could I not?

It is not necessary to have a special sensitivity towards the strong political identity of Catalonia for that. It is enough to be and act as a democratic President to take note and listen to the expression of that discomfort. Not only can one not silence or disdain those who express it; it is a free, legitimate expression that must be heard.

In this sense, I find it concerning that the right in our country is still unable to adopt an integrative project of coexistence that includes full recognition of Catalonia's identity. Because those who pass without continuity from confrontation to inhibition, as the leaders of the Popular Party have done, lack that project, and I do not believe that this is solely due to Mr. Rajoy's natural tendency to inhibit.

Well, my reaction, not to the ruling, I reiterate, but to its political consequences and, more broadly, to the process of challenge against the Statute, involves the following positions:

The first is to reaffirm respect for the identity feelings of the citizens of Catalonia. As I said when I defended the Statute before the Congress of Deputies, I find the defense of "the national identity of Catalonia" completely legitimate, as this is also compatible with the constitutional consideration of Spain as "the nation of all." I see the same compatibility in the defense of national symbols and the Catalan language. And I believe I have been consistent with this conviction to the extent that my capacity and political responsibility could reach.

The second position is to analyze the possibility of regulating, through the appropriate legal channel, the issues declared unconstitutional by the Court, not for reasons of material unconstitutionality, but for the correct choice of the normative source, which are several. We therefore have a wide field of advancement in matters of justice, in the configuration of local autonomy in Catalonia, or in the daily action of the State to ensure that it operates within the competitive margins in the exercise of its basic competencies. And we already have state legislation in financial matters that includes commitments such as the consideration of fiscal capacity or the guarantee of non-inversion of the organization of the Autonomous Communities after the mechanisms of inter-territorial solidarity.

And, thirdly, to reiterate the commitment to continue developing and applying the Statute. We have done so in the last four years with the new financing agreement, with the increase in state investment in infrastructure, with the transfer in areas such as coastal protection, RENFE commuter services, work permits for immigrants, or labor inspection.

We have done so by working together with Catalan institutions on projects of interest for all of Spain, such as the Alba synchrotron or the centers of research excellence in Catalan universities. We have done so, even before the Statute came into force, with the presence of Catalan Councilors in the Councils of the European Union, with the possibilities of using Catalan in European institutions, in the General State Administration itself, or, as of two days ago, its expansion in the Senate.

And we have done so, even proposing constitutional reform to strengthen the capacities for autonomous participation in the Senate and for our Senate to definitively fulfill that role of a chamber of territorial representation, with a clearly federal role. It is a pending reform that would bring to political discussion, which is its venue, many of the competitive and legal arguments that today can only be substantiated in the Constitutional Court.

You know that we proposed that reform to turn the Senate into a chamber of territorial representation, but you know that the reform requires the participation and majority will, that is, an agreement in which the Popular Party must participate.

Therefore, we have work to do. As I discussed in the meeting with President Montilla earlier this week, we need to resolve some transfer processes under discussion and we must strengthen our mechanisms of relationship in different areas, such as cultural investments, operations in police areas, or mechanisms for autonomous participation in certain competencies of the State.

We have made a firm commitment to advance in these matters calmly and rigorously; calmly because we need to regain trust and recover the sense of affirmation of what the development of plural Spain means; calmly and confidently because the political forces in Catalonia, first and foremost the Generalitat, must also take constructive steps, like those that occurred in the meeting I held with the President in Moncloa, to open that space of trust, concertation, and collaboration.

Therefore, it is not surprising, and the President has referred to it, that first and foremost we must recover trust: the trust of relations between institutions and the trust of relations between political forces and, ultimately, in society as a whole. I will dedicate myself to that task as a priority, because I reiterate, as I stated a few minutes ago, that the consequences of the ruling are part of my political responsibility.

From my political responsibility, I understand it to be absolutely essential and necessary that this strong Catalonia -- strong in its political identity, strong in its history, and strong in its economic capacity -- feels heard; feels that it is truly a fundamental, decisive actor in the common project that is Spain, plural Spain, and truly feels that it is respected in its feelings of identity, in its symbols, in its history, and in its culture.

This task that lies ahead of us is a task worth pursuing, because always charting the horizon and the course of cooperation, trust, respect, of adding and uniting is much more motivating and always represents an improvement in the history of peoples than any other temptation to disunite, to confront, to create conflicts.

You will always have me on this side, on the side of those who want to gain trust, respect Catalonia, and move forward together in a democratic, plural, and diverse Spain, which is the Spain that the world knows and the Spain that the world respects and values.

Thank you very much.

DIALOGUE OF THE PRESIDENT OF THE GOVERNMENT AT TRIBUNA BARCELONA

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Domingo Jaumandreu.- Mr. President, I wanted to talk to you about transportation infrastructure and the cuts that were announced yesterday. For the last twenty-five years, I have had the honor of working for, and then leading, an important multinational in Spain, and for the last ten years holding positions of responsibility in Europe. From the European perspective, it is very difficult for me to explain to my former colleagues, with whom I was speaking this morning, such drastic decisions as the cut in connections with Europe.

Twenty-five years ago, when Felipe González was in power and President Pujol was in Catalonia, our multinational made a strong commitment to invest in Catalonia as a place from which we could manufacture and serve products for Europe based on two elements of competitiveness: the high qualification of personnel, especially in engineering, which has never disappointed because Catalan universities, as you have rightly said, prepare excellent professionals, but with a great promise of developing communication infrastructures with Europe. And twenty-five years have passed, and we are still with the same toll highway with two lanes that connects us to Europe. In these twenty-five years, tariffs disappeared, customs disappeared, and we still lack communication with Europe.

How can it be explained that yesterday it was decided to cancel the duplication of the A-2, which is the alternative to the toll highway, and also suspend the connections of the A-7 with the A-2, which are the ones that need to provide the necessary fluidity for the port of Barcelona to be more accessible?

President.- I will be brief, and I hope to be briefer than the question; but at least I want to give you and provide you with some data that I find relevant about investment in infrastructure and the adjustments. I have to make some initial considerations.

Spain today occupies a leadership position in the field of transportation infrastructure. We have transitioned from a historical deficit that hindered our ability to compete to being a reference for many countries in the process of modernizing infrastructures. Now we must necessarily make an effort to contain spending to reduce the deficit, which is essential, in an area where, I insist, we have made a significant effort in recent years.

In the years between 2009 and 2012, the average investment in infrastructure will be similar to that executed in the period 2005-2008, which was a period of prosperity and economic growth; I say this to situate what the reduction represents. We will be in years where there was economic growth.

Catalonia. In Catalonia, we will not stop either, and I want to make this very clear because only 0.6 percent of the contracts that the Ministry of Development currently holds in Catalonia will be rescinded. And I must remind you that in 2009, the Ministry of Development executed more than 2.6 billion euros of investment in Catalonia. It is the first Autonomous Community in investment executed by the Ministry of Development, and since we came to power, between 2004 and 2009, more than 12.8 billion euros. I invite anyone to compare this with any previous period of any Government's investments in transportation infrastructure in Catalonia. And in 2009, it was also the first Autonomous Community in investment tendered.

With the new budgetary scenario, of the 182 contracts that the Ministry of Development has underway in Catalonia, with an investment exceeding 5.5 billion euros, five contracts are being rescinded, with 181 million euros pending execution; however, three will be re-tendered: one funded by the General State Budgets and two through the public-private collaboration system. This would leave two contracts rescinded, 1.1 percent of the existing contracts, less than the Spanish average, which is 1.61 percent; 0.6 percent, as I mentioned earlier, of the current investment, less than the national average, which is 2.7 percent.

Five in roads --specifically, since I believe you referred to the connection between the A-2 and A-7 highways, I must tell you that a new tender is planned for that highway funded by the General State Budgets--, none in railways, none in airports, and none in ports. That is the balance of the resulting situation as a consequence of the budgetary adjustment we have made in infrastructure matters.

I could elaborate further and provide details on which infrastructures the Government of Spain is currently investing in Catalonia; but, given the opportunity, I will do so. We are working on the Northeast Highway Madrid-Barcelona: there are 85 kilometers in project and ten kilometers under execution, with an investment of fifty million euros, and thirty kilometers are in service. We are working on the Mediterranean Highway, on the A-7: in project, 163 kilometers with 900 million euros of investment; under execution, eight kilometers, with 47 million euros. And I will go quickly now: we are working on the Lleida-Viella-France Highway, on the Huesca-Lleida Highway, on the Figueras-Olot Highway, on the Tarragona-Montblanc Highway, on the B-40 ring road, on the improvement of the Mediterranean Highway, on the A-7, and we are working in several urban environments: in the Barcelona area, five kilometers are already under execution and 240 are in project; in the Girona area, in the Lleida area, and in the Reus area.

In railways, we are working on the Mediterranean Corridor; we are working on the AVE Tarragona-French border, the international connection; we are working on the Barcelona commuter trains with the new Infrastructure Plan, with a planned investment of four billion euros to be tendered by 2015, and more than six hundred million euros have already been invested in Barcelona commuter trains; we are working on the international station of La Sagrera; we are working on the port of Tarragona and on the port of Barcelona, with the southern expansion; we have acted in airports, in El Prat, and we are working in Girona and in Reus.

And I will not delve into hydraulic and environmental infrastructures.

There are 5.5 billion euros currently in various phases of execution of infrastructures in Catalonia during a time of economic crisis. Now we have to reduce, yes, but I have given the figure: 0.6 percent. In any case, I have seen that you have expressed a special interest in one of the duplications, and I will instruct the Minister of Development to review whether it is indeed as important for the economy, because we are always willing to listen, and moreover, the effectiveness of the Minister of Development in this matter is well known.

But thank you for the question, and it has given me the opportunity. As everyone here can see, I have come well prepared with data to highlight the efforts in infrastructure that we are making in Catalonia.

Luis del Olmo.- Mr. President, with what is happening, with what happened a few days ago here nearby, on the Diagonal, in that massive demonstration, it takes courage to come here, to the eye of the hurricane. Only a politician from León could do it.

I have listened very attentively to your speech; you said that in the coming days we will see an improvement, you spoke of the development of plural Spain, and you talked about the end of the crisis; I don’t believe any of it. I would like to believe you, fellow countryman, but I don’t believe it.

But my question was going in another direction. President, do you, as Head of Government, really believe that Catalonia is slipping out of your hands? I ask you the question from another angle: if your colleague, President Montilla, were from another party and not your comrade from the Socialist Party, would you act more firmly in the face of any independence proposal? Just that, President.

And, taking advantage of having the microphone and taking advantage of my dear Catalan colleagues, allow me. Catalonia is a historical nation, no one doubts it, but let me remind you of our land. And León, which has had laws, and charters, and kings, is it not a historical Community?

President.- Thank you, Luis. You started very well and then, well… I have to say in your honor and in our friendship that you were perhaps the first journalist to predict and anticipate several years before the XXXV Congress who could be and who would be the Secretary General of the PSOE. It was you, Luis del Olmo, and for that reason, apart from our friendship as people from León, I have great respect for you.

I was going to say that it could be more or less relevant whether you believe or not some of the things I have said, but I only settle for one thing, and that is that when it happens, you say it publicly, as you have always done. When the economic recovery, which we are already in, because we have grown in the first quarter and the second quarter we will have economic growth higher than the first, better than in the first quarter, and therefore, we have two quarters of growth, we must maintain that pace and, above all, we must create jobs, which is undoubtedly the great problem.

Two, that I have come to the hurricane. Whenever I have come to Catalonia, I have felt very comfortable because this is a society, above all --in my work I have been able to meet many Catalans--, of respect and cultured. Therefore, I always come happy. That there is now a difficult climate due to the ruling obliges me more, and perhaps I come more, because I believe, I have the firm conviction, that any risk that could exist in the line of what we have talked about deepening the disaffection and allowing the idea of disaffection towards what represents plural Spain to minimally consolidate from Catalonia is a grave historical error. I will not allow it, and I will put all my effort, I will give my all to ensure that does not happen.

And, as I have great confidence in Catalan society, great confidence, I am convinced that we can, with time, with a certain time ahead and with effort, turn this into a bad moment. We will do it, because the vast majority of Catalans and the vast majority of all Spaniards wish to walk together, with respect and recognition of what Catalonia means, and it means a lot for history, for identity, for economic capacity and for the strength of its citizens, the strength that I have always interpreted as a democratic, civic strength, of the majority. There are some positions that I do not share at all and that may respond to other objectives or other legitimate interests, but of the majority.

I believe that Catalonia has exemplarily known how to be in the democratic transition, in the constitutional pact, in the modernization of Spain and at the forefront of civic freedoms, of a competitive economic model, of its Europeanism and of its openness to the world and the Mediterranean, and for a reason the headquarters of the Union for the Mediterranean is here. Catalonia has known how to be and will know how to be, and Spain and the Government will know how to be with Catalonia and do what is necessary to deepen that trust.

As sometimes happens, these are difficult moments but they are great opportunities. It is a great opportunity for that kind of latent tension, that sometimes diffuse and sometimes explicit discomfort, to be definitively overcome. We have to do it, but I also have to tell all Catalans that it is not a task solely for the Government or the President of the Government, because Spain is broad, politically plural, there are diverse positions.

And I can assure you, now that we are in this stage of memories with the ten years, that the months in which we discussed the Statute --I supported the approval of the Statute and negotiated with the Catalan political forces to reach that majority for the Statute-- were not easy months, eh!, for the Government for supporting the Statute; for recognizing the national identity of Catalonia; for affirming the value, the appreciation and respect in the use of the Catalan language; for voting in favor of national symbols for Catalonia; for expanding its competences; for establishing a bilateral relationship; for setting an additional provision that increased infrastructures or for betting on a financing model, which we later concluded in a great agreement, which was presumed to be unsolidary and which led some political force across Spain to say that "now the money from the poorer Communities will go to the richer Communities."

That was said in Spain by those who are part of the constitutional pact, and in the constitutional pact is the formulation of taking maximum care of that inclusive capacity of the 1978 Constitution, where latent discussions remained, but a space was sought where everyone or the vast majority could feel comfortable.

We will overcome this stage, without a doubt, but we have to make a great effort. Look, Luis, I do not do it as a reproach to other political forces; but, to truly consolidate plural Spain, a model with federal traits, with greater participation of the Communities in the formation of the State and definitive respect for identity and self-government, we need the center-right political forces to also be in that task and in that position. That is the way it is.

Therefore, let us do everything necessary to convince, as I am convinced, that the strongest Spain is plural Spain, that the best united Spain is the Spain that recognizes diversity and, in particular, the diversity of Catalonia. And let us also make an effort to tell the Catalans that the best project is the common project from respect for sensitivities; but doing things together is more useful for everyone and that any temptation is an uncertain and senseless path in light of our history and in light of what the vast majority of Catalans think.

Therefore, Luis, when you see the economic recovery more consolidated and see that Catalonia knows how to be, as it has known and is knowing again, and the whole of Spain knows how to be, I hope you recognize it.

And, of course, our land has history. How could it not have history! And laws, and charters, and it has even had caciques. What matters to me is that the democratic history, the history of constitutional Spain, is a history of success, and there is no history of success for constitutional Spain if that history does not carry plural Spain and the recognition of diversity. The success of Spain, which has been great in these thirty years, is a success that depends, to a large extent, on that integration of diversity, and of course of Catalonia. And, as Catalonia is a society of success and works for success, I am convinced that it will also do so in a united way and cooperating with Spain.

Luis, I am not optimistic because your predictions came true, because I get along well with life, that is the truth; no, I am optimistic because I know what Catalonia is capable of and what the whole of democratic Spain is capable of, which, by the way, is much more than we sometimes think, feel, and say, and much less than we believe they consider and value us outside; but they respect us and admire us. Let us give reasons for that to continue.

Pere Yufera.- The legal profession has been concerned for many years about the issue of access to the profession. A law was enacted five years ago, a "vacatio legis" of five years, and since then a series of regulatory projects have been issued, and to this day it is still pending a joint ministerial order to discuss the content of the master's degree and the qualification exam. We are a year away, and it seems that this will never arrive. The question is: is there really the will for that Law of access to the legal profession to finally arrive and that what is really sought is the training of lawyers, which is what is truly needed, and to be equated with the European Union?

President.- It is a law known and dear to me, and I can confirm that this Law will be applied at the time it corresponds according to the period of "vacatio legis" that it contemplated. Furthermore, I can affirm that the work for its application and the access requirements to the legal profession are quite advanced on the part of the Ministry of Justice and that we will have them within the expected timeframe.

I can also confirm that a few weeks ago it was the subject of deliberation in the Government. The task is advanced and will be concluded within the expected time, but I can confirm that it will be so and that the Law will be applied.

Joaquín Coello.- In times of crisis, regulatory changes must be made, and I was referring to several of these regulatory changes. One of them is the autonomous management of ports, and others are the autonomous management of airports, the transport of goods, and universities. I believe that the fact that this is not working for us is demonstrated by two things: in Spain, 4 percent of goods are transported by rail, while in Europe, it is between 20 and 25 percent; that our universities are not optimal from the perspective of teaching and Research and Development is evidenced by the fact that in any international university ranking, Spain —as you have said— the ninth largest economy in the world, the top university is the University of Barcelona, and it ranks between 150 and 200.

In reality, the uniqueness of the management of these issues in the Western world and in Spain is absolutely singular, absolutely special. Only Spain, Portugal, and Greece have a law on airports like this. In any country in the European Union, from a federal one like Germany to a centralized one like France, they do not have this system that we have. Changing this regulation is returning to the usual practices of the West and improving efficiency in the management of these issues.

I think, Mr. President, that this is easy to do for three reasons: the first, because you have a magnificent Minister of Development, and I take this opportunity to say that this has not always been the case, but now it is; because you have an excellent Minister of Education, also before, but now as well; because this, Mr. President, does not cost money, no further investment is needed, and it can be done without more investment, it is simply a change in the management model; and, thirdly, because it is something that many Autonomous Communities would defend and accept. In the change of the airport model, I am sure that Madrid would agree, I am sure that Andalusia would agree, I am sure that the Balearic Islands would agree, and probably, the Canary Islands. In the port model, probably Galicia, probably Valencia, and probably the Canary Islands.

Therefore, it is easy. What is the drawback? Mr. President, the drawback is a traditional drawback in Spain, and it is the strength of our entities and our bodies, let’s say, para-state or parapublic, like AENA, ADIF, Ports of the State, etc., and naturally the power and strength of certain high-level state officials. These reforms, Mr. President, are necessary for Spain, and we believe they are necessary for Catalonia. They are certainly, and you know it well, highly demanded in Catalonia. Can you make any comments on this?

President.- I can make some comments. There are some things where I share the opinion and others where I think your opinion requires some nuance.

For example, port management is a management that is developed with a wide degree of autonomy. Certainly, the national government, since the current Ports Law, has, let’s say, only the responsibility of financing investments in the ports and securing money from Europe, which sometimes generates problems for us because it is the consortia that approve the investments in the ports. However, in terms of ports, the data has nothing to do with what you referred to regarding the transport of goods by rail in our country, which is where we have a "gap," a competitive disadvantage, spectacularly compared to Europe. Here we need to make a change, we are making a regulatory and investment change, to facilitate the transport of goods and, of course, with the liberalization that Europe is going to implement.

University. Regarding university management, it is true that there are a majority of examples in the world where universities manage with even more autonomy and with a management model that is much more directly linked to their relationship with business, as a key factor, moreover, to reduce that inequality of positions to which I referred between what we produce scientifically and what we innovate. But, more than regulation, it is a task of action and commitment from the governments, of course from the regional governments with the universities, which have a wide responsibility for competencies, and from businesses with the universities themselves.

I can say that the framework of "intervention" of the government in the university field does not go beyond the law, as we have a law that recognizes university autonomy. The responsibility for the relationship, management, and financing lies with the Autonomous Communities, and we can move to a model of more autonomy legislatively, we can move to a model of different management, but we must have the consensus of the university community. And the last reform we have made in the framework of university legislation has been done with that consensus.

Airports. Yes, and I believe we have discussed this more than once, there are several projects and several regulatory works underway. The airport model needs a management change, although I must emphasize that the airport results in Spain are good, because AENA has done, in comparative terms, in terms of productivity and in terms of traffic volume, a good management. But we need to make a change so that each airport can have an expectation and a planning and results capacity closer to its interests.

Therefore, yes to a certain extent, but we are not only facing a regulatory problem in some cases, we are facing a cultural problem. I have thought about whether it is the legislative framework. No. I am going to give some interesting data now. Why have we reached the average investment in R&D from the public sector to the European average, and why are we very far behind in the average investment in R&D in the private sector? Is there any aspect of legislation or incentives? No. We are practically the country with the most tax deductions for R&D.

What is the reason why our companies or the number of companies in our country is still limited and the volume of resources and investment from companies in R&D? I believe there are two fundamental factors: one, the lack of involvement with the university, because we are one of the developed countries with the least involvement between university and business; but this is a matter of culture and attitude, not just legislation and incentives, because no matter how many tax incentives we have for R&D, and we have been expanding them, private spending grows very little. And the second factor I believe is related to what largely represents the size of our companies; that is, there is a direct relationship between the capacity to invest in R&D and the size of the company.

We need to promote, and we are working on an incentive plan, the existence of more medium-sized companies, because small companies have limitations for investing in R&D. We are implementing a plan for the consolidation and growth of companies. In Spain, it is not easy for two companies, two SMEs, to merge. We need to provide incentives and promote mechanisms, because one of the differences that places us… There is a table that is very, very evident. The European countries that have a higher percentage of medium and large companies are the ones that invest the most in private R&D; the countries that have a higher percentage of smaller companies are the ones that invest the least in private R&D.

Enric Hernández.- You will not be surprised that I return to talk about the Statute. A few minutes ago, you came to say that you have understood the message from Catalan society, that you assume the political consequences of the Constitutional Court's ruling and that you are willing to amend them. I will not say, like Master Del Olmo, that I do not believe anything, I will not say that much; but I will tell you that, although the music sounds good, it would be good to know a little more about that text that you agreed upon or discussed last Wednesday in La Moncloa.

That is why I will ask you if there is a "roadmap" for those conversations with the Generalitat, if they will be maintained immediately or postponed until after the Catalan elections, and, above all, how you will prevent that negotiation, in the long run, from turning into the permanent negotiation in exchange for parliamentary support that has so often conditioned the development of Catalan self-government.

President.- There are many questions. I already knew that, Enric, you were going to ask pure political questions.

I must say one thing, and I will start with this statement: the Statute is the norm that has recognized the most self-government in history for Catalonia. The self-government contained in the Statute, after the ruling, is a self-government that is at the maximum levels of any federal country we put on the table, and, moreover, with a broad recognition of Catalonia's identity. It was promoted by the Parliament of Catalonia and by the Catalan political forces, but it was approved under my mandate as President of the Government and as the person responsible for the parliamentary majority, and, of course, not to guarantee my majority. That does not correspond to the truth; moreover, as is well known, I ultimately negotiated the Statute with Convergència i Unió, and, of course, it has not been characterized by providing parliamentary support to the Government on many occasions. And, as is also known, the Statute did not have the support of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya, which was a force that, by sharing government in Catalonia, one might think or we could approach that it should have a more favorable attitude towards that support, no.

The facts are the facts. I did not support the Statute out of a need for votes in Parliament; I supported the Statute out of political conviction and I supported the new financing model, which improves the financing of Catalonia like never before, out of political conviction and because it was a commitment to the Statute. And now, as I said today, I take responsibility for the consequences, for the effects, of the ruling to recover, without haste, with actions, the trust and make Catalonia feel that it can perfectly work on a plural Spain project that respects identity, self-government, potential, capabilities, and feelings.

The first thing we need to do in the "roadmap" is to find ourselves in feelings because, if we do not find ourselves in feelings, I am convinced that this is not a matter of transferring scholarships, no. If we started there and I came here to say "I bring so many transfers and I bring so many resources and more investments and so on"… No, either we feel close in what we are and in what we represent, in our identities and in our ways of seeing a plural Spain, or going towards that other path seems to me to be a mistake.

Therefore, let us recover feelings and approach trust. I have mentioned in my speech three necessary paths in political, legal, and factual terms: one, laws that can regulate what the Constitutional Court ruling says: "attention, legislator, you can regulate this, but not in the Statute; it has to be in an organic law," and there is a task to be done and it is identifiable; two, pending transfers, as we have made many transfers of competencies since I have been President of the Government and before the Statute and after the Statute, 31 matters have been transferred to Catalonia, and there are pending transfers; and then, there is a third area, which is very important and which is a political area: that the Statute tried to reach as far as it could. In some cases, we knew, when we approved the Statute, that we were at the limit, and it is that the State, ultimately the Government, but not only the Government, but on other occasions the Legislative, respects the statutory and competency framework. This is a matter that is surely very, very, decisive for the President.

In those three areas, we need to work. This has nothing to do, and I think you can already imagine, with the elections in Catalonia, whenever they are, in the fall or until December, I do not know when the deadline is; whenever they are. It has nothing to do with it. This is a much deeper issue that transcends the elections, of course, these and probably the next ones.

The ruling has put a question on the table for all of us, and we must answer that question. It has opened up a question, and we must close it with our actions, with our words, and with our sensitivity. That is the task.

José Sanclemente.- Perhaps elaborating on what Enric said, you have said "to walk together." It gives us the impression, Mr. President, that it will be difficult to walk together from now on. The Catalan people have felt offended. You said "I will support" and Mr. Rajoy said "I will challenge." He has fulfilled his word and has challenged it fully.

I believe that Catalonia has helped for many years with the governance of Spain. We, the Catalans, now do feel, let’s say, offended. I believe that relations with Spain at this time will be difficult to recover. One single example: something as absurd as "La Roja." Many people would prefer that they had lost because they do not feel, they feel… Well-known people, yes. Perhaps those in the room do not, but I can express it… And people already with a certain level.

We support very much what President Montilla says, we trust a lot; perhaps we trust less in the twenty-five deputies from Madrid at this moment. So, many independentist voices are already emerging at this time. Do you think this can be resolved with these three points and this joint path? Perhaps before, yes; now, President, I believe it will be very difficult from now on. The Catalan sentiment, what was seen in the demonstration on July 10, that was very important. It was the heart of Catalonia that was manifesting, and people came from all over. I believe that "Houston, we have a problem."

President.- I don't know if this is a question or a mini-conference, but I will say two things.

First, today "El Periódico de Cataluña" publishes a survey that is eloquent, it is clear: the vast majority of the citizens of Catalonia, of course, wanted "La Roja" to win. I am convinced that it was so, and a statement in the opposite direction seems to me not to correspond with the reality of what I know about Catalonia and the Catalans.

Second, of course there is a moment of difficulty, but the know-how and the ability to be of Catalonia and of democratic Spain have been what has allowed us to advance successfully over thirty years, and I have a deep conviction that Catalonia will know how to be and that Spain, through its central institutions and certainly the Government, will know how to rise to the occasion.

I have as much confidence in the twenty-five deputies of the PSC as in President Montilla. Why? Because those twenty-five deputies of the PSC express nothing more and nothing less than the overwhelmingly majority vote of the Catalans. Up to forty-something percent voted for the deputies of the Socialist Party so that, by the way, we could form a Government in Spain.

No, it is not the time to emphasize the different sensitivities, no; it is time to emphasize everything that can help to build positively and not to deepen feelings or divisions further. I ask that no one plays with that. Catalonia, through many of its citizens, has expressed its discontent, and the President of the Government of Spain has come, has said here, here and in the chamber of the Congress of Deputies of Spain, where sovereignty lies, that people could not be silenced when they expressed themselves, nor could feelings or identities be stifled; that we had to listen. Listen to work together, recognize the discontent, as I have expressed here, and set to work with the will to know that this may have been a difficult moment, a bad moment, but that we will overcome it. Do not have any doubt.

This is the last thing I want to say today: we are going to work together, we are going to do many things together, we are going to get out of the crisis together and we are going to ensure that the Estatut, desired and cherished by Catalan society, does not remain a negative memory due to the ruling. It can be done and we must do it. Let us put in the will, and when the will is put in that joint direction, things are achieved. Of course, the twenty-five of the PSC, President Montilla and I are going to commit ourselves and we are going to do it, you know, no matter the cost, no matter what it costs me.

Thank you.