Speech and subsequent discussion by the President of the Government at Tribuna Barcelona
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed the Tribuna Barcelona forum on July 22, 2010, outlining Spain's economic reform agenda amid the European financial crisis.
- Main themes
- Economic reforms in Spain, banking stress tests and financial transparency, savings bank restructuring, labor market reform, public spending austerity, economic recovery, Catalonia's economic role, welfare state preservation, production model transformation, employment growth, fiscal stimulus withdrawal
- Duration
- ~35 min
- Words
- 4,258
- Sentences
- 119
- Readability
- 26
- Grade
- 18.4
- Syntax
- 3.38
- Vocabulary
- 2.19
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other119 sentences in 62 paragraphs
President Montilla, dignitaries, ladies and gentlemen,
Firstly, I would like to start by thanking the Tribuna Barcelona [Barcelona Forum] organisers, Grupo Zeta, for having invited me to take part in these anniversary celebrations.
This is my third appearance at this Forum. I first did so as leader of the opposition in 2002 and then again, a few years later, in 2006, as President of the Government. Back then, President Montilla was just starting out on his current mandate and I must, Mr President, give you my thanks for your presentation, for your work and for your constant attitude of collaboration with the Government of Spain, even though you are never backwards about coming forwards, obviously.
As it happens, we are celebrating this anniversary on a day that is also very important from an economic point of view. And I would like to start with the economy.
As you are aware, the results of the so-called 'stress tests' will be published this afternoon; tests that have been performed on all major European financial entities. As you will also be aware, this is an exercise in transparency that Spain has promoted from its position in the European Council aimed at revealing the actual situation of the financial system. Our country, Spain, is going to make a unique effort to apply this exercise in transparency to more than 95% of the financial system, compared with 50% in other Member States of the European Union.
Furthermore, the institutions of Spain are going to provide a more extensive breakdown in order to furnish more details of the risks associated with the real estate sector. This will enable the financial markets to gain sufficiently detailed knowledge of the current state of the Spanish banking system and its capacity to resist highly adverse circumstances. And that will be a decisive factor for the economic stability and recovery of our country.
Ladies and gentlemen,
Seeing as the spotlight is firmly placed on this event, which I consider to be extremely important and which will take place within a few hours, it provides me with the perfect backdrop to this speech offering my perspective of the economic outlook for Spain and Catalonia.
I am convinced that this outlook will be marked by the process of reforms that we are currently implementing.
Unlike the other variables that make up this crisis and that are beyond the control of any one country, it is within our power to conclude and apply these reforms. They are reforms that will strengthen our position as we exit the crisis and that will offset the faster-than-expected withdrawal of the fiscal stimulus packages in the vast majority of European economies. They are reforms aimed at boosting economic recovery, at encouraging change in the production model to achieve a more competitive and sustainable economy, to achieve a return to employment growth (which is our main challenge) and to preserve and strengthen our Welfare State. They are reforms, I know, that are not easily implemented and that require new efforts and demands, but in the medium and long term they will reap rewards which reflect the ambition we are capable of showing now.
They are, therefore, reforms that, along with the firm guidelines of rigor and austerity applied to public spending, will continue to absorb the energy and determination of the Government of Spain over the coming months and until the end of its Legislature. And they are reforms that are intended to significantly boost economic activity throughout the country but particularly in certain Autonomous Regions such as Catalonia, due to its considerable industrial weight, its export capacity, the composition of its production fabric and its early and sustained commitment to innovation.
I have spoken at length about these reforms during the recent parliamentary debates. Today, I will simply remind everyone that, firstly, the reform of the financial system is already at a very advanced stage and that the Lower House of Parliament has recently ratified the Royal Decree Law reforming the Constitutional Law on Savings Banks that makes widespread changes to the legal regime governing these financial entities in order to strengthen their solvency, favour their access to the capitals markets and increase professionalism in their management structures.
This is one of the most important milestones in the process that, with a great degree of consensus, we were able to implement through approval from the Fund for Ordered Bank Restructuring and that within a very short space of time, a question of months, has drastically transformed the Savings Bank sector in Spain. This transformation has been highly significant in Catalonia, with the creation of three large Savings Bank groups which, with a total of more than 380 billion euros in assets, will be able to continue supporting the economic development of this region under even better conditions than in the past.
Also in the process of being passed through Parliament is the labour reform that the Government has presented to effectively reduce duality, promote more job stability and facilitate the adaptation of companies to the demanding conditions of a changing and highly-competitive economic environment. This reform of the labour market, which is the most ambitious reform in recent decades, is intended to configure a framework of labour relations that can facilitate the implementation in Spain of that renewed production model we so greatly need, with more training for our workers and more innovative efforts from our companies.
It is the will of the Government to be able to conclude this reform with the highest possible level of consensus and, to that end, we have stated our absolute willingness to incorporate any amendments that may increase its effectiveness into the parliamentary process. The next few days will be decisive in forging that consensus and introducing improvements to the regulations initially approved by the Government. And I have confidence in our ability to do so.
Certain aspects of the labour reform, insofar as they are intended to increase the adaptability of companies by increasing the flexibility of the conditions established in the sectoral collective bargaining agreements, will more greatly benefit the smaller companies that have greater difficultly in arranging their own collective bargaining agreements. To that end, and given that the relative presence of SMEs is higher in Catalonia than in the rest of Spain in terms of both turnover and employment, it can be expected that the effects of the labour reform will be even more positive in the case of the Catalan economy.
Ladies and gentlemen,
The fiscal consolidation, the restructuring of the financial system, the labour reform and the reform of the pensions system, which we also wish to conclude in the coming months, are necessary and essential but insufficient on their own; we also need to conclude a wide variety of other changes that affect the competitiveness of our economy.
The Government has been making efforts to improve competitiveness in general since 2004, with a particular focus on three specific areas: infrastructures, R&D+i and training, which are decisive factors for work productivity.
Efforts to modernise infrastructures in Catalonia have been particularly important in the last five years: more than twelve billion euros have been invested in the new El Prat airport terminal, the completion of the High-Speed Railway connection (which links the system to the rest of Europe) and the firm commitment to the Mediterranean Axis (with the Port of Barcelona being the first this year to be connected with Europe using international gauge railway lines).
The budgetary restrictions we have also had to adopt as a result of our commitment to speeding up the deficit reduction process will condition the undertaking of certain projects; but if we focus on investment volume criteria, which are extremely important, it can be seen how those effects, in relative terms, have been limited, very limited indeed.
In terms of education, Catalonia particularly stands out for the quantity and quality of its graduate and postgraduate university education offer. Its great potential was recognised when the region was given two of the five 2009 International Campus of Excellence awards, which is accompanied by a loan commitment of more than thirty million euros.
And in terms of research, we have tackled an initial stage that has consisted of strengthening the basis of our R&D system through increased public investment in research that, put simply, is unprecedented in the history of Spain because we have practically tripled the volume of public spending on R&D. We have now begun a new stage using criteria of utmost responsibility and spending austerity in which we are going to optimise the use of these resources and capacities that, between us all, we have managed to increase over the course of these last few years. One magnificent example of our efforts and cooperation in this field is the recent inauguration of the ALBA Synchrotron in Cerdanyola del Vallés; the largest scientific infrastructure built in Spain and southern Europe in general.
I would also like to highlight another three decisive areas for the improvement of competitiveness and particularly important for the present and future of the economy in Catalonia: industrial policy, innovation and the internationalisation of companies in order to increase their export capacity.
Following a long period in which industrial policy has not received the attention it deserves, we are now designing a framework to provide structure to Government actions in this field. I remember how in 2004, when I took charge of the Government, I reinstated a ministry of industrial policy - a Ministry of Industrial Affairs; a ministry that the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia knows very well. And that industrial policy is now being implemented with the Autonomous Regions and the social stakeholders.
In this regard, I would like to express my gratitude for the collaboration and contributions made by the Regional Government of Catalonia to the Integrated Industrial Policy Plan being implemented alongside and in addition to the Industrial Policy Plan of the Regional Government of Catalonia for the 2010-2020 period.
The objective of the State Plan is to increase the contribution made by industry to the economy by 3%; from 15% of GDP to 18% of GDP (which is the European average) by 2020 in order to put Spain on a par with that European average. This industrial percentage of GDP in most of the largest European countries, such as Germany, France, etc., is three or four points higher overall.
That average of 18% has already been reached by Catalonia, where a quarter of industrial turnover is concentrated and the objective here should be even more ambitious: we should exceed 20% of GDP for industry in Catalonia as a whole, in other words, put Catalonia on the same level with Germany or Sweden, where more than 20% of GDP is contributed by industry.
A similar situation to the industrial policy strategy exists with the Innovation Strategy. We are now the ninth largest scientific producer in the world, in other words, we hold the same position in the global ranking as our Gross Domestic Product would suggest - the ninth industrial power in the world. However, we are far from that position in terms of innovation; our capacity to transform the science we produce and publish in the economy. Our production fabric must take advantage of all the potential offered by our Research and Development system.
We have set ourselves a target: to double the number of innovative companies by 2015, in other words, another 40,000 innovative companies in Spain. And, once again, Catalan companies stand out in this field. As a result of their extensive history in innovation, they are in the best position to capitalise on that joint effort; an effort that should be translated into greater export strength, something we are supporting through various actions in favour of the internationalisation of Spanish companies.
I would like to underline at this event here today the good results, the excellent results, from our export sector; a sector that has withstood this crisis better than the European average and that, at this time, on the verge of our exit from the crisis, is growing at a faster rate than the European average and that is being called upon to play a decisive role in our recovery and the change to our production model. As we broaden and open up our export horizons, we will generate greater savings in Spain, we will generate a greater capacity to invest and we will limit the debt that has characterised a good portion of the economic development to have taken place in Spain for too many years now.
There are 37,000 export companies in Catalonia and their growing penetration into the Asia market is particularly noteworthy; the market with the largest potential in the world and where we are making special efforts to reinforce our diplomatic and commercial ties. But we have here a large window of opportunity for companies in Spain in general and Catalan companies in particular because certain good foundations already exist in Asia, a solid basis, especially in China. Here in Spain, there is no doubt that we are going to intensify those efforts and, of course, it is one of the priority items on the Government's agenda and one of the priority items on my own agenda.
In summary, these reforms are decisive for our competitiveness, decisive for renewing our production model, decisive for the long-term sustainability of our Welfare State and social cohesion, which is the defining feature of the European model and which must continue to be so. Furthermore, they are reforms that go to the very heart of the Catalan economy, to its defining features and to the liberation of its power and great potential.
In order to exit this crisis, to continue that process, and in order to return to economic growth of a more healthy nature, with new economic growth, with a new economic growth model, Spain needs Catalonia and Catalonia needs Spain.
Today more than ever, it is not simply rhetoric to say that Catalonia has to work with Spain and Spain has to work with Catalonia.
There is only one way to imagine this co-existence: at the heart of a common project based on the respect and recognition of the parties involved. That's the only way.
Allow me to make reference to a personal issue here. As you know, and as I was reminding President Montilla, ten years have just passed since I received the trust of my colleagues and was appointed as General Secretary of my party. I have had occasion to reflect on this period over these last few days, on how things have changed, sometimes at incredible and surprising speed (as we've seen in the last few months), and on how I have been able to change myself and adapt and respond to the many changing circumstances in which we live.
Well, I believe that if I were forced to summarise the ideas or values that give meaning to my political commitment and my political work into three, I can assure you that the fundamental aspects of those three values have not changed over the years and that, as the main guideline for my judgment ruling my actions and my decisions, I would place my vision of a plural Spain, of an indivisible Spain that recognises the political identity of Catalonia on the same level as my conception of democracy, as the importance of dialogue, as respect for one's adversary, as tolerance, as ideological pluralism or, if you like, open-mindedness; and, furthermore, committed political action with the more disadvantaged, with equal opportunities and on the fight against all forms of discrimination by one human being against another.
These would be my three main political convictions: a plural Spain; democratic progress; and equality and non-discrimination. I put all three on an equal plane, of equal value. They are three priorities or principles on which I would not like to fail or fall short of my own demands and the demands of others.
I have always viewed Catalonia at the heart of democratic Spain with that attitude and, in particular, any other aspect of paramount importance. Therefore, I need make no effort at all to appreciate the problems being experienced by the Catalan society in general, by the majority of its citizens and by its political forces because they are problems of Spain, problems we all share, that concern and affect everyone, and first and foremost the President of the Government because, as President of the Government, I am also, and I very much feel, President of the Catalan people and, as a result, answerable to them all in the exercise of my post.
My position in defence of the Estatut is well-known. I've always thought that room needed to be made for the Estatut, in accordance with the procedures and rules of the Constitution, the Estatut we have today, and that room needed to be made for the majority of those who represent Catalan society to renew their self-governance and to see the recognition of their political identity strengthened.
The difficulties are also well-known, because the Catalan Estatut was and is a great step in that plural Spain; difficulties that we had to resolve during the reform definition and approval process; difficulties and pressures to which, by the way, we did not surrender because what we were doing was legitimate and the right path, as well as supported by the majority here in Catalonia and by more than a sufficient majority in Central Parliament.
The second chapter in this story is equally well-known: an appeal before the Constitutional Court questioning the Estatut in general and from the bottom up, irritatingly different - the difference was irritating - to the attitude shown by those appealing against other similar statutory reforms, and a process before this body, the Constitutional Court, that was overly troubled and also excessively slow in reaching a decision.
It would be impossible for me to say this clearer and this statement should not come as a surprise to anybody: neither constitutionally nor politically do I feel responsible for the decision, nor its ruling nor the grounds on which it is based. I respect it, of course, I comply with it and will enforce it, and I will also, of course, give it the appropriate institutional support, as I have given at all times through the performance of my duties to the body issuing the ruling: the Constitutional Court.
I am not responsible for the ruling, but I do feel responsible for its political consequences. I will deal with those political consequences.
I think the legal effects of the decision are limited, very limited if compared with the scope and strength of the disagreement to which it responds; that the Estatut has now been ratified globally, what's more, that it no longer depends on the legal uncertainty of the appeal and that its validity is guaranteed and the fog hanging over its development and application has been lifted. But I am aware that the circumstances and changes surrounding the entire process have generated discontent in a large part of the Catalan public. I have taken note of that. How could I not?
There is no need to be particularly sensitive to the strong political identify of Catalonia, it is enough to be and act like a democratic President to take note of and listen to the expression of that discontent. Not only would it be wrong to cover the mouths of those who express that feeling but it is a free and legitimate expression that must be heard.
Therefore, it concerns me that the right wing in our country is still incapable of adopting such an integrating project of coexistence that includes the full recognition of the Catalan identity. Because he who moves on without a solution for continuity from confrontation to inhibition lacks such a project, as is the case of those leading the Partido Popular, and I do not believe that is solely due to the natural tendency of Mr Rajoy towards inhibition.
So, my reaction, I do not mean my reaction to the ruling but rather my reaction to the political consequences of that ruling and, more broadly speaking, to the process of rejection applied to the Estatut, means I will take the following position:
Firstly, I will reaffirm the respect for the feelings of identity felt by the citizens of Catalonia. As I said when I defended the Estatut before the Lower House of Parliament, the defence of "the Catalan national identity" seems entirely legitimate to me because it is also compatible with the constitutional conception of Spain as "the nation of all". I also see similar compatibility in the defence of the national symbols and the Catalan language. And I believe I have acted in accordance with that conviction insofar as the scope of my capacity and my political responsibility allows.
Secondly, I will analyse the possibility of regulating, through the appropriate legal channels, those issues declared as unconstitutional by the Court, not on grounds of material unconstitutionality but on grounds of choosing the correct regulatory basis, which are various. We therefore have plenty of room for progress in terms of justice, the configuration of local autonomy in Catalonia and the daily actions of the State in order to guarantee they are undertaken within the limits of its competency during the exercise of its fundamental powers. And we already have state legislation on financing that contains commitments such as the consideration of fiscal capacity or the guarantee of not overturning the organisation of the Autonomous Regions following the inter-regional solidarity mechanisms.
And thirdly, I will reiterate the commitment to continue developing and applying the Estatut. This we have done over the last four years through the new financing agreement, through increased state investment in infrastructures, through transfers of power in areas such as coastline protection, RENFE local railway services, work permits for immigrants and labour inspections.
We have done so by working together with the Catalan institutions on projects of interest for all of Spain, such as the Alba Synchrotron or the centres of research excellence at Catalan universities. We have done so, even before the entry into force of the Estatut, with the presence of Catalan Councillors at the Council of the European Union, with the possibilities of using Catalan at European institutions, within the General State Administration Services themselves and, for two years now, its increased use in the Upper House of Parliament.
And we have even done so by proposing constitutional reform to enhance autonomous regional participation capacities within the Upper House of Parliament and for our Upper House of Parliament to definitively fulfil that role of Chamber of Regional Representation of a clearly federal nature. This is a pending reform that would lead to political discussion on many of the competency and legal arguments that can only be discussed today in the Constitutional Court.
You are aware that we proposed that reform in order to convert the Upper House of Parliament into a Chamber of Regional Representation, but you should also be aware that the reform requires effort and willingness from the majority, in other words, an agreement for which the Partido Popular must be on board.
Therefore, we still have work to do. As I discussed during the meeting with President Montilla this very week, we must resolve certain power transfer processes through discussion and we must strengthen our mechanisms for relations in several areas, such as cultural investment, operations on policing matters and mechanisms of autonomous regional participation in certain State competencies.
We have made a firm commitment to progressing on these issues calmly but thoroughly; calmly because we need to recover trust and recover the sense of affirmation represented by the development of a plural Spain; calm and confidence because the Catalan political forces, first and foremost the Generalitat, must also take some constructive steps forward, such as those that took place at the meeting I held with the President at Moncloa, in order to open that space for confidence, agreement and collaboration.
It should therefore come as no surprise, and the President also mentioned this, that trust is the first thing that must be recovered: trust in the relationships between institutions and trust in the relationships between the political forces and, basically, in society as a whole. I am going to consider that task a priority because, and I stress this again as I did a few minutes ago, that the consequences of the decision form part of my political responsibility.
My political responsibility leads me to understand how absolutely essential and necessary a strong Catalonia is - strong in its political identity, strong in its history and strong in its economic capacity - it must feel heard, it must truly feel like an important player, a decisive player for the common project that is Spain, a plural Spain, and must truly feel its identity, its symbols, its history and its culture are respected.
The task that lies before us is a task worth fighting for. Laying a path for cooperation, trust, respect, unification and union is far more motivating and has always resulted in more improvements throughout history than any other temptation to de-unify, confront, embattle or create conflict.
You will always have me on this side, on the side of those who want to gain trust, respect Catalonia and progress together towards a democratic, plural and diverse Spain, which is the Spain the rest of the world knows and the Spain the rest of the world respects and values.
Thank you very much.