Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

26 June 2007 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded in Spain's parliament on 26 June 2007 to a question from CiU's Duran i Lleida about the delayed Barcelona-Figueras-Perpignan high-speed rail line and contractual fee obligations.
Main themes
Barcelona-Figueras high-speed rail delay, Figueras-Perpignan international rail section, contractual obligations to TPFERRO concession, infrastructure investment and progress, route consensus and environmental impact, gauge changers and freight trains, 2009 vs 2012 deadline dispute, Convergència i Unió proposals, Catalan rail connectivity, government accountability in parliament
Duration
~21 min
68th percentile
Words
2,527
68th percentile
Sentences
95
60th percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.15
66th percentile
Vocabulary
2.24
58th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 38%21%
  • Ceremonial 36%20%
  • Institutional 19%11%
  • Geopolitical 6%3%
  • Technological 2%1%
  • Social 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 44%

95 sentences in 42 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- The question to the President of the Government is how the Government plans to meet the contractual obligation to pay the international exploitation fee for the Figueres-Perpignan High-Speed Train, starting from early 2009, regardless of whether trains run or not.

President.- Mr. Duran, I am sure we share the good performance of High-Speed Rail on its route to Tarragona and the satisfaction we will soon have when it reaches Barcelona.

I regret, as you do, the concern over the delays in the commissioning of the Barcelona-Figueras route. Allow me to remind you briefly that when we came to power, the two most significant sections, the urban tunnels of Barcelona and Girona, did not have an environmental impact declaration or an approved information study. They did not even have a defined route agreed upon with the other administrations, and the solutions had not been subjected to public information.

The degree of progress of the works along the entire corridor between Barcelona and Figueras was only 1 percent of the total planned investment. However, the current Government has made a great effort, which is reflected in, first, reaching a consensus on the route; second, multiplying the annual investment executed by twenty, increasing from six million euros to 122 million euros in this Legislature. This will allow all the works to be either underway or tendered by the end of this year. Additionally, we have sought alternatives so that, without waiting until 2012, trains can run on the international section Figueras-Perpignan, thus allowing us to meet, as much as possible, the expectations of the concession. We will expedite the construction of the western variant of Figueras to connect the conventional network with the High-Speed line and the international section Figueras-Perpignan, south of Figueras.

The installation of gauge changers at the beginning and end of the sections where trains will run on the conventional line is also planned, and additionally, other options are being studied to enable the passage of freight trains from Barcelona to Figueras.

We are therefore working to mitigate the consequences of the delay. Initially, arrival was scheduled for 2009.

Mr. Duran.- Thank you, Mr. President, for your response. During the days of the municipal electoral campaign, when the change of route through the city of Barcelona was raised, it was argued that this was impossible because it would cause a delay in the overall objective of reaching Perpignan. On the 30th, three days after the electoral campaign, it was stated that it was not possible in 2009, that it was postponed to 2012, and that this was a consequence of what you have just recalled: what was foreseen in the environmental impact study.

I want to remind you, Mr. President, that I am not asking about the past, but about the commitments of this Government, and, knowing the situation, in June 2004 this Chamber approved with the votes of your Parliamentary Group the reaffirmation of a commitment, and the Minister has stated on several occasions that the deadlines were in that sense uncorrectable, that they were non-negotiable. It was agreed in this Chamber that it would reach Perpignan by the year 2009, and it has just been announced that it will not, that it will be for 2012.

I see that the Government points to some possibility. We have a concrete proposal, and this week we will present it to Catalonia. We are not throwing in the towel; I hope the Government does not either, and I would like the Government to listen to the proposal that Convergència i Unió will present in the Catalan Chamber, and I hope to be able to convey it personally to you and to the Minister of Development.

We sincerely understand that the additional economic cost that may arise will always be less than the breach of the concession that was contracted with the company TPFERRO, the concessionaire of that international section. It would be noted that the infrastructure could have been completed three years ago and, however, not used, because at this point, it is practically 80 percent executed, and therefore, we have no doubt that, ultimately, the work will be ready in 2009. Since the work will be ready in 2009, what needs to be enabled is for High-Speed trains to run in 2009, not just freight, but also passengers. There is a solution, both through Vallés and through the Girona loop, which I insist we will expressly convey to the Minister of Development and the President of the Government, and which we will detail appropriately this week.

President.- Mr. Duran, as you have acknowledged, I have provided in my response some of the alternatives that the Ministry has planned for the situation we are in. In any case, we are, of course, willing to listen to the alternatives that Convergència i Unió proposes and to discuss them, to see if we can all, logically, meet the deadlines as soon as possible with the best possible service to citizens and compliance with the fee.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Parliamentary Group of the Popular Party

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- On February 21 of this year, Spanish soldier Idoia Rodríguez Buján died in Afghanistan as a result of a criminal attack while traveling in a BMR vehicle without a frequency inhibitor. Seven days later, in this question time, I asked the President of the Government what he was going to do to guarantee the safety of our soldiers. He did not respond at all, as is almost always the case, and limited himself to speaking ill of the previous Government, as always.

Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, a few days ago, four months after the death of soldier Idoia Rodríguez, six soldiers died in Lebanon as a result of a criminal attack while traveling in a BMR vehicle without a frequency inhibitor, the same one in which Idoia Rodríguez had died four months earlier. What are you going to do, Mr. President of the Government? What are you going to do to guarantee the safety of our soldiers?

President.- Allow me to say, Mr. Rajoy, that the case you cited of the soldier, who is also Galician by origin, who died in Afghanistan has nothing to do with the issue of inhibitors. You know what the cause of the explosion was, and you also know that the soldiers in Afghanistan and the soldiers in Lebanon today have the best security means they have ever had in the history of our peace missions. That is the first statement I must make: that it has been a constant concern of the Government, constant.

The first inhibitors for our military vehicles outside of Spain were installed in the summer of 2005, with this Government. You were in power for eight years and could have thought about inhibitors just once during those eight years… Just once.

In the summer of 2005, inhibitors were installed, starting with Afghanistan, as you know, and today all heavy military vehicles have that system as standard. Last October, the Defense Staff, despite military intelligence reports on the situation in Lebanon, where, as is known, there is a large number of military contingents and they do not have the use of this system, one more security measure that obviously does not guarantee what could be a terrorist attack, decided to extend the presence of inhibitors to all military vehicles abroad as a preventive measure. As you know, they were delivered in May. It is a unique company, also Galician, that manufactures them, they were delivered in May, and the installation process, which requires a complex technical process, has begun on all vehicles.

Thus, for the first time, and surely one of the few countries in the world, we will have, of course, the best security means, such as armored vehicles, which are the vast majority of peace missions today, in all the places where our soldiers go.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President of the Government, allow me to say that this is a disgrace. You decided to have soldiers in Lebanon and Afghanistan, and I supported you and asked for two things: that you tell the Spaniards the truth: that our soldiers were going to risk their lives to defend certain values and a model of society. You were unable to say it, and you will know the reasons.

But I also asked for security for our soldiers, because it is my duty as the leader of the opposition, and the Minister of Defense appeared here, in the Cortes, on September 7 and said that the troops would go trained, protected, and with means. You intervened that day and said nothing. You spoke again, as always and as you have just done now, ill of the previous Government; but you, Mr. President, are today the President of the Government of Spain.

In the Senate, in June, in an oral question, we asked the Minister of Defense again about security in Lebanon and Afghanistan, and on June 18, ten days ago, we asked him again in a Commission. Mr. President, they have died in the same type of vehicle and they did not have inhibitors, and that is a disgrace. Among your many obligations as President of the Government is to explain yourself to the Spaniards and guarantee the safety of the soldiers.

By the way, the Lebanese Government awards the six fallen soldiers the war medal and the medal for valor. When I am President of the Government, those yellow medals will be medals with a red distinction, and you should know that, Mr. President.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, the disgrace and the most blatant demagoguery are your words.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Agustín Cerdá, of the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana de Catalunya

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Cerdá.- Mr. President, is the Executive in a position to guarantee that it will comply with the investment criteria of the General State Budgets contemplated in the third additional provision of the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia?

President.- Mr. Cerdá, the third additional provision of the Statute was applied immediately, without waits or delays of any kind. Already in the 2007 Budgets, the regionalized investment of the State in infrastructure rose to 18.8 percent, thus equating to the relative participation of Catalonia's GDP in relation to the GDP of the entire State.

That 18.8 percent means an investment of almost 3.2 billion euros this year, which is allocated to various projects in transport, infrastructure, communications, and environmental matters, all essentially in accordance with the competencies of the State Administration in Catalonia and projects that received broad support from a majority in this Chamber in December, including from your own Group.

The Budget is faithfully executed by the Government, and the result of this, which all citizens can verify, will be the rapid advancement of major projects, such as the new terminal and the expansion of El Prat Airport or the arrival of the AVE in Barcelona, as well as necessary investments for the maintenance and improvement of essential service infrastructures, such as roads, ports, or railways.

With all this, we will be able to correct now and avoid in the future operational problems stemming from the historical investment shortfalls in Catalonia; but I must tell you that yes, we faithfully comply with the third additional provision and we will comply with it for the next Budgets.

Mr. Cerdá.- Mr. President, I regret to disagree and, moreover, to remind you that you are mistaken when you say that our Group voted for the Budgets. Our Group abstained in the last Budgets. Just for these reasons, we abstained from these Budgets, precisely because the third additional provision of the Statute was not being fulfilled.

There is a difference between civilized countries and uncivilized ones or those with a high or low degree of maturity, which is that those countries that respect the Law and adhere to it loyally are countries with a high degree of civility, and those that respect authority are those countries with a low degree of civility. I believe we should be among the countries that have a high degree of civility and therefore respect and are loyal to the fulfillment of the Law. We ask for nothing more than compliance with what was agreed. We ask for nothing more, and that is already significant, than to comply with the Law.

Today from Catalonia, there is considerable concern regarding what is an evident paralysis of the deployment of the Statute of Autonomy. I am not saying this; it is said by everyone from President Montilla to Minister Puigcercós, including prominent senior members of the Government such as Mr. Antoni Castell or Mr. Joan Saura. I believe that some attention should also be paid to this.

We have started the budget negotiation with the same uncertainty that we began with last year: whether your Executive intends to comply with the investment criteria in infrastructure set forth in the additional provision three of the Statute. You know that you have already acknowledged, you have acknowledged it in this Chamber, the historical deficit in investments that Catalonia has suffered, and one example that Mr. Duran just mentioned a short while ago is the delay in the arrival of the AVE to the border, which the spokesperson for Convergència i Unió mentioned a few minutes ago.

The additional provision three, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, says what it says. You and Mr. Solbes made a restrictive reading of it and wanted to apply the investment criteria to only two Ministries: Development and the Environment. Wow! That energy, telecommunications, health, and justice infrastructures are not infrastructures, according to you. This criterion, in addition to contradicting those of the International Monetary Fund, which seems to us to be quite significant, contradicts your own Executive. The Avanza Plan of the Ministry of Industry defines broadband Internet as infrastructure, everything related to communication in telephony. Wow, everything linked to telecommunications! We find this, in this case, quite incongruent.

So do not cheat with Catalonia. Play fair, and I believe we will all win.

President.- Mr. Cerdá, I cannot express how pleased I am to see how Esquerra Republicana de Cataluña advocates for the Statute of Catalonia and how it champions an additional provision, like the third, which was the subject of extensive debate and controversy. Welcome to the Statute, welcome to its advocacy, and welcome to the commitment to the Statute of Autonomy of Catalonia.

I reiterate that we fulfilled that additional provision in the Budget for 2007, we will fulfill it in the Budget for 2008, and its application and compliance are verified in the Monitoring Commission between the State and the Catalan Generalitat. This is how things will be done, and the Generalitat will be able to inform about what that compliance represents and what the investment and agreements we are developing between the State Government and the Government of Catalonia represent.

Thank you very much.