Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

18 December 2007 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session in the Spanish Congress on 18 December 2007, addressing tax policy and institutional advertising.
Main themes
Fiscal policy and tax reform, social spending and welfare commitments, Wealth Tax abolition, institutional advertising law compliance, Dependency Law implementation, budgetary surplus, early childhood education funding, government self-promotion vs. public information, Spain's convergence with EU social standards
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,176
61st percentile
Sentences
75
49th percentile
Readability
51
65th percentile
Grade
12.3
48th percentile
Syntax
3.22
74th percentile
Vocabulary
2.05
18th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 56%53%
  • Institutional 35%33%
  • Ceremonial 6%5%
  • Social 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 4%

75 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Mr. President of the Government, with the money that you will stop collecting by abolishing the Wealth Tax in this country, early childhood education for children from zero to three years could be generalized, more than 1.5 billion euros. But, moreover, it is raining on wet ground, Mr. President, because during this Legislature, instead of fulfilling the commitment, as I mentioned earlier, that we had acquired as the left to converge with the European Union in social spending, you have dedicated yourself to reducing taxes by 8.7 billion euros. 8.7 billion euros in taxes that would have allowed us to reduce what today separates us from the European Union, which is almost nine points of social spending, to five points of social spending and to reduce what today means a third in lower social spending.

Your Government has not moved faster because it has dedicated itself to launching messages of fiscal demagoguery and has not been consistent in social matters.

President.- Mr. Llamazares, the Wealth Tax is a tax that practically no longer exists in the European Union. It is only present in countries like Sweden or France. In Spain, it was born as an extraordinary and provisional tax. It had a very specific and determined function, which was to assist the Income Tax in the collection policy. It is not an incentive for savings and, as is well known, it does not affect the most significant fortunes that logically have other types of companies to declare their assets. Therefore, it is absurd.

Secondly, during this period, we have indeed reduced taxes, and revenue has remained high, allowing us to implement social policies; but we have done something more in case the cycle does not come with such growth: we have had a surplus, and since we have a surplus, we will have no problem, and there will be no need to make any social cuts because we have done things well. If things or if the evolution were to lead to an economic slowdown, we would continue to maintain social commitments because we have saved. That is to implement a sound economic and social policy, thinking about the future of Spaniards and not just their present.

Thank you very much.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Does the President believe that his Government complies with the often-cited Law on Institutional Advertising?

President.- I have the feeling that this question has already been asked of me today, but well... I tell you, Mr. Durán, if you remember, first of all, that the Government sent this Congress the Draft Law on Institutional Advertising and that it is the first time; that the Law does not question the need for institutional information, I want to remind you; that it prohibits that which conceals the self-promotion of the corresponding Administration; that it considers that advertising legitimate; that, of course, the Law imposes that campaigns be conducted with transparency and that they are normally foreseen in an institutional advertising plan, which has been sent to the Chambers.

In short, the Government believes that it complies with the Law on Institutional Advertising, depending on what Your Lordship says at this moment.

Mr. Duran.- Our criteria is not yours, and evidently, only a court would decide whether the Law is complied with or not, and of course, this Parliamentary Group does not intend to resort to those terms.

However, I will remind you, Mr. President, of some expressions used by your Vice President in relation to the Law when it was presented: "this Law will put an end to the confusion that often occurs between institutional information and pro-government information, and ensures the institutional security of the informative campaigns promoted by public authorities"; "this Law will restrict advertising according to strict criteria of austerity and with loyalty between public institutions." And the Socialist spokesperson himself said: "it is the State Government to whom it is directed, it is the State Government to whom it submits, to whom it obliges, to whom it demands, and to whom it controls."

Mr. President, you are conducting a campaign, for example, about the Dependency Law, which I believe is more propaganda or an explanation of the Government's management than anything else; but, in any case, I think the Government should reconsider whether it can really carry out the advertising it is doing when, for example, I tell you that in my Community there is still not a single person who has received a cent from the Dependency Law. In any case, it has been announced that in the coming days 150 people will receive something, when the Law has been in force for a year.

A campaign has been made, Mr. President, which I believe is not informative but rather propaganda; it is not necessary to inform citizens about when the AVE arrives when the media publish that information on the front page when necessary, an advertising campaign that later had to be withdrawn and about which our spokesperson in the area of Development, Jordi Jané, has made various questions that have not received an adequate response, nor any response, regarding the cost. It could be said that it was necessary, that it was institutional information. At this moment, the information provided is not true. So where do we stand, then?

You are conducting a campaign, which has been mentioned, about energy savings. Is it only necessary to save energy three months before the elections? Not eight, nine, or ten, or two or three years before? Would it not be better for the Government to dedicate its energies to developing a strategic plan rather than doing propaganda about energy consumption, which obviously needs to be done, but not at the expense of spending money?

Finally, you are doing propaganda or advertising, which was the term to choose, President, about housing. You spoke of austerity and loyalty to institutions. Would it not seem more logical to you, Mr. President, that instead of doing propaganda, which costs almost as much as is spent on housing, the Autonomous Communities should not do propaganda but have that money to exercise their competence, which is not the State's but the Communities', in housing matters?

President.- Mr. Duran, you usually do not slip into the realm of demagoguery, but you have just said something about housing policy that makes me call you to order from the point of view... Mr. Duran, you may interpret that I am not calling you to order in the parliamentary sense, obviously; I am calling you to order because you are not a person who slips into the realm of demagoguery, I have told you and I reiterate it, because in housing policy the advertising campaign is 0.1 percent of the total expenditure of the Ministry of Housing, which amounts to eight billion. Do not say that we spend more on advertising than on housing.

Secondly, by the way, to those who talk so much about Spain and the State, why does it bother you that there is an informative campaign about the Dependency Law of the Government of Spain, which is the one that promoted the Law, and if the Autonomous Communities can do it, which they have been doing for months, about dependency?

I publicly told all citizens who have the right to benefits under that Law that, as it has to be managed by the Autonomous Communities, the Government of Spain would take charge, because it is its responsibility and commitment, to inform and demand from all Autonomous Communities that they manage it and fulfill their obligation so that citizens, who are the beneficiaries and who have rights, because this Parliament has approved it, have the dependency benefits. We could not allow the Autonomous Communities to conduct information campaigns about the right to dependency and that the one who made the Law and promoted it, with the approval of this Parliament, which is the Government of Spain, could not do it! We could not allow that!

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Spaniards are suffering from rising prices, which have increased one and a half times more than in the European Union, and the price of food and other basic products, among others, milk, meat, bread, fruit, and vegetables, has risen twice as much as in the European Union. On the other hand, the Euribor has risen again and is now close to 4.9, bad news for the eight million households with mortgages. And we know that Spain is the country where salaries have lost the most purchasing power.

What has the Government done to alleviate this situation and to mitigate the effects of this price increase and the loss of purchasing power of salaries? Reforms, none, Mr. President, and we have been asking for them throughout this Legislature, and the messages have only been three: that we are facing a long-term problem, that they should eat rabbit at Christmas, and that they deserve it for giving tips.

By the way, Mr. Vice President, Spaniards know that one euro is worth 166 pesetas. Do you, Mr. President of the Government, have any message to give to all Spanish citizens, besides spending thousands and thousands of millions on advertising?

President.- Yes, three messages: first, that the Government is aware of what the rise in inflation and, of course, the increase in prices represent; second, a message of calm; and third, a message of explanation that, evidently, you should know, because this is due to the rise in the price of oil and the price of cereals that has occurred worldwide.

In November, inflation in the eurozone reached its highest level in six years; American inflation has risen to 4.3 percent, and Germany, which you always like to use as an example with Mrs. Merkel, has had the highest increase in the CPI in 13 years. The behavior of the Spanish CPI is growing as other CPIs are growing across the European Union. Our inflation differential remains around 1 percent, and our underlying inflation has only increased by one-tenth, standing at 3.2 percent.

Consequently, price increases are occurring throughout Europe and North America, inflation is rising, as a result of the increase in oil and cereals.

And I also give another message to all Spaniards: do not trust your analyses and economic forecasts because you have not been right in four years.

Mr. Rajoy.- Bad argument, Mr. President of the Government, because blaming the opposition for making analyses to evade your responsibilities for rising prices does not seem to me the most reasonable.

I have been saying for a long time that economic reforms are needed and that you have been living off the inheritance and inertia, and now it seems that you blame the rise in oil or cereals; but oil and cereals are rising worldwide, and in Spain, food prices are rising twice as much as in the rest of the countries in the European Union.

Mr. President of the Government, it would be worth spending less money on advertising and focusing on the real problems of the people. I will eliminate the Income Tax for those who do not earn sixteen euros a year, I will raise pensions, I will implement economic reforms, I will establish more competition, and I will work for market unity and greater budgetary austerity.

Mr. President, your economic policy has not been good for Spaniards, and we have been warning you for a long time. You will not solve it with advertising and waste; criticizing the opposition will not help either.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, as you recall, you froze the Minimum Interprofessional Wage and scholarships and made a "decretazo" to cut rights that cost a general strike and then had to backtrack. That is what you did with the lowest incomes.

I will tell you that the disposable income of households has increased by 24 percent in four years. On average, each Spanish household has 940 euros more per year in real terms. Do you know what that is due to? Because today we have more than ten and a half million families in which all their active members work as a result of having three million more workers, employees, in our country.

During this Legislature, per capita income has grown more than in the previous one, as we have just debated. Eurostat has made it known: our per capita income has exceeded the European average by five points and has just surpassed that of Italy.

And for the first time in 2007, in fifteen years, the increase in productivity is allowing a slight gain in the purchasing power of salaries, as shown by the figures from the National Institute of Statistics and the National Accounting of 1.4 percent, which has not happened in fifteen years.

Those are the data and not the things you say.

Thank you.