Press conference of the President of the Government after the meeting of the European Council.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

13 December 2007 · Meeting of the European Council

Context
Zapatero addressed press after the December 2007 European Council meeting in Lisbon, reporting on the Treaty signing and the establishment of an EU Reflection Group.
Main themes
Lisbon Treaty signing, Portuguese EU Presidency, EU Reflection Group establishment, Felipe González chairmanship, future of the European Union, European economic model, sustainable development, migration and energy policy, climate protection, global security and terrorism, Spain's role in Europe
Duration
~41 min
91st percentile
Words
4,885
91st percentile
Sentences
152
81st percentile
Readability
36
27th percentile
Grade
16.2
84th percentile
Syntax
3.53
95th percentile
Vocabulary
2.12
32nd percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

152 sentences in 68 paragraphs

President.- Good afternoon. I am going to report on what this Council has represented under the Portuguese Presidency, which is coming to an end at this moment.

That is where I wanted to start to express my most enthusiastic congratulations to the Portuguese Presidency, to Prime Minister Sócrates, for carrying out an extraordinarily positive and effective management for the European Union; a Presidency that began with the Summit with Brazil, which represented the definitive agreement and the signing of the new European Treaty, which also developed a very significant Summit of the European Union with Africa and which today, in addition, has culminated in a forward-looking decision, such as the establishment of a Reflection Group for the European Union to address the main issues that concern citizens and that logically relate to the challenges of public policies that the European Union must face in the coming decades.

Therefore, congratulations to the Portuguese Presidency, with which, by the way, we have worked in a fraternal manner, as could only be the case.

Yesterday we signed the Treaty of the European Union in Lisbon and with that we set the European Union in motion for a more effective functioning of the European institutions in responding to the challenges that Europe faces ahead. And today Europe, twenty-four hours later, decided to set up a Reflection Group to plan and build ideas for the future of the European Union in light of the main challenges.

As you know, and I want to make a special reference to this decision today, that Reflection Group, which is to present a report to the Council in June 2010, under the Spanish Presidency, by the way, will be chaired by Felipe González, former Prime Minister of Spain. I want to express my deepest satisfaction with the choice of Felipe González. It is very good for the European Union, it is a success for Spain, and it is a great recognition of the figure, the trajectory, and the political weight of Felipe González.

I simply want to make a reflection. At the Council table, we sit twenty-seven Heads of Government and Heads of State, and I can assure you that the name of Felipe González garnered from the very first moment a broad support among leaders from the North and the South, from the right and from the left. Therefore, as the Prime Minister of Spain and as a Spanish citizen, I feel deeply proud that a former Prime Minister of my country has garnered this support and, above all, that he has been entrusted with such a significant and far-reaching task as providing long-term vision for the European Union to consider what its policies should be in light of the main challenges that the Reflection Group must address and include in its report.

Felipe González is among the political leaders who have contributed the most to European construction. He has referred on more than one occasion to the "founding fathers" of the European Union, as many other leaders have done, and now it is his task to guide the thinking of the Europe we want for our children and grandchildren.

As you know, the mandate of that Reflection Group includes determining aspects for the future of our societies; specifically, what affects the strengthening and modernization of the successful European economic model, competitiveness, and social responsibility; sustainable development as one of the main objectives of the European Union; global stability; migration; energy and climate protection, as well as the fight against global insecurity, international crime, and terrorism.

These are the specific issues that, as you can understand, from the enumeration it is clear that they are the major issues that European society undoubtedly faces and that also define the role of the European Union in the international concert for the coming decades.

As you know, the Group is not tasked with addressing issues related to institutional or legal-political aspects. We already have a Treaty, and therefore, it would not make sense for it to focus on the issues we have just decided. It must focus on addressing the fundamental issues, the issues of the major European objectives, the issues of the major challenges and the major changes that the material policies of the European Union must develop after so many changes we have experienced in the European Union and, logically, after the changes that are taking place in the international order.

I want to express, as it could not be otherwise, that Felipe González will have all the backing, all the support, and all the assistance, of course from the European Council, but also from the Government of Spain to carry out his task, which I am convinced will be extraordinarily rich in content, creative, and very positive for the European Union.

I also want to thank him for his availability. Just two days ago, the night before last, I had the opportunity to have dinner with him and exchange opinions on what the task and function of chairing this Reflection Group could be. Once again, he has shown a willingness to serve Europe and, in this case, very specifically, his country, Spain.

This morning, around twelve-thirty, I informed him that this would be the proposal that the Portuguese Presidency would put forward and, of course, he expressed his satisfaction and his utmost interest in carrying out work that leaves Spain at the level we deserve, and that I am sure he will carry out, and that will be a great report that will set the major objectives of the European Union for a long time.

I can tell you, on a more personal note, if you will, that this decision is perhaps the most satisfying moment I have experienced since I became Prime Minister in the context of European Councils for what it means for Spain, first of all, in value for Spain, and also because you know that I have great respect and appreciation for the figure of Felipe González. In this decision and in this appointment, there is much recognition of his trajectory, and I believe that it is something that for a country like ours should be very present in the collective memory of all citizens.

In addition to what this election and the establishment of the Reflection Group represent, the European Council has addressed some other issues that I wanted to refer to; specifically, those affecting immigration.

I emphasize with satisfaction that the European Union in all Councils during this stage addresses immigration as a fundamental issue. There is always, in this case, a contribution from the Commission, which I have also valued very positively and in which it insists again on aspects that Spain has been working on in recent times: the need for immigration to become increasingly a global policy and a European policy of the European Union; that is, that it be part of common policies. You know that in that direction there are two very clear objectives at this moment, which are to strengthen cooperation in Sub-Saharan African countries and to reinforce what the role of the Border Agency, FRONTEX, means.

I want to highlight, as the Commission's report does, that the joint effort between member countries and the European Union through FRONTEX has allowed us that in this year 2007, as we are finishing the year, the number of illegal immigrants trying to reach Europe has been reduced by 70 percent compared to 2006.

Europe reaffirms a basic principle of its migration policy, which is a no to illegal immigration, a no to human trafficking, a no to the exploitation of immigrants, and a yes to legal and orderly immigration as a demographic and economic factor, positive for the present and future of the European Union.

Along with this, as you know, the Council has also addressed some other politically important issues for the future of the Union. In this case, what affects Kosovo, given the circumstances in the Balkans and the commitments that the European Union has in that area. The Council has decided today to send an institutional civil mission to reinforce stability in the area, particularly in Kosovo.

As you know, Spain already has a security commitment with the presence of six hundred personnel in Kosovo and, as you know, the European Union, above all, and that has been the spirit of the Council, wants to maintain a common position, a unified position regarding what the future status of Kosovo represents and stability in the Balkans, and in its relationship and dialogue with Serbia.

From the perspective of the Government of Spain, there is a priority objective, to which all actions of the European Union must be subordinated, which is to guarantee peace and stability in the area. That is the priority objective. As you know, the area has suffered a devastating war, with a very high number of fatalities. The International Community has made an effort to guarantee peace and stability, and that effort must be the great priority at this moment and for the future.

You also know that the Government of Spain is more in favor of uniting than dividing, and you know that we are facing an area and an exceptional situation. Today there has been no pronouncement that has gone beyond what the European Council has already discussed regarding the issue of Kosovo. What there is, as I said initially, is an unequivocal will that the European Union maintains a common, unified position, whose first objective must be, I insist, peace and stability in the area.

I also want to mention some other issue, because it is of interest to Spain, such as a Decision of the Commission, which appears in the Council Resolutions, regarding a set of proposals that the permanent governing institution of the Union, the European Commission, will present on the outermost regions, no later than 2008. It is the first time in five years that the European Council includes the outermost regions in its final agreements. In this way, the importance of these regions, such as the Canary Islands, is notably underscored so that they have all the possibilities of adapting to the evolution of the European Union and to the challenges it faces.

The Commission's proposals will cover demographic aspects, maritime transport aspects, and financial aspects, and undoubtedly, we will be very close to the work of the Commission to encourage and, of course, to include those aspects that, in a very evident way, have a reflection in the Canary Islands when we talk about outermost regions.

In short, the European Union signed a new Treaty yesterday that allows us to function more effectively. The European Union has decided today not to wait until tomorrow, but to start thinking about the future of the Union with the establishment of this Reflection Group, and the European Union has given Spain great joy today with the appointment of Felipe González who, without a doubt, will carry out his high mission with what has characterized him throughout his political career: with a profound vocation for public service.

Q.- Would the Spanish commitment to consensus on the issue of Kosovo reach the point that, if the agreed but not consensual solution were independence, Spain would immediately recognize the new State? That is one question.

Another question I wanted to ask is regarding the acceptance by the Strasbourg Court of the Batasuna lawsuit. I wanted to know how the Government views that decision and whether you think it could have any impact on the process of banning ANV, for example.

President.- Regarding the first question, the consensus, the unity of the European Union around Kosovo is a desire of the Government of Spain and of the twenty-seven Governments. This means that we will take steps in a concerted manner always, logically, depending on the situations that may arise in the future, with respect to what each country's decisions entail. The consensus and unity that I understand are essential is that the entire process has as its essential purpose to guarantee peace and stability, and the best guarantee of peace and stability is maximum unity of action by the European Union and dialogue with all parties.

Regarding the admission of the appeal filed at the time regarding what represented the banning of Batasuna as a consequence of the Law of Parties, there are two statements I want to make: first, let us respect, logically, the actions of the Court, which acts and will act with respect to the Law—I say this because I have heard some statements making interpretations of what this partial admission was due to—and I suppose that no one is calling into question that the members of that Court act strictly with respect to the Law; second, my conviction that the entire banning process, of course, that stems from the Law of Parties is a process respectful of legislation, democratic values, and human rights.

Q.- President, the news of Felipe González's appointment, in principle, does not lead the Spanish Government to give up on Javier Solana continuing to be the representative of European foreign policy. But is that decision already made or not?

President.- We must logically respect the timing. Javier Solana is another great figure in Spanish politics. He has done a brilliant job, building what is called the mission of the European Union's foreign and security policy, and he enjoys broad support within the European Union. Of course, it is deeply satisfying that we currently have two Spaniards at the very forefront of the European Union, Javier Solana and Felipe González, and, of course, the Government of Spain wants them to remain at that forefront: Javier Solana and Felipe González. In due time, it will be resolved, but we have good confidence in the qualities and support that Javier Solana has.

Fortunately, Europe works most of the time and makes decisions based on the merit of individuals and also, logically, on national balances; but in this case, we are faced with two Spaniards of the highest level, of top level. Luckily for us, of course.

Q.- Two questions about Kosovo. The first, President Sarkozy has said that the process towards independence was inevitable, and I would like to know if you share this analysis on one hand, and on the other, for a Government that has made the United Nations a main banner in foreign policy, I wanted to know if they really consider the current Resolution, that of 1999, as a legal basis to act in Kosovo.

President.- I respect the prediction made by the President of the French Republic. I believe we must have a certain expectation of what the evolution of events will be. It is not dismissible at all; rather, it is likely the circumstance to which President Sarkozy refers.

Regarding what the legal basis represents or what is inferred from the United Nations Resolution, I must say that there are various interpretations. Of course, the Government of Spain has, logically, its own position and reservations regarding what is legally deduced from the United Nations Resolution and the basis that would support a possible unilateral act of independence.

But, as is evident, until that eventuality occurs, we should not be anticipating events. If it occurs, the Government of Spain will have and will take a very clear position on this matter.

Q.- President, I had two questions. One relates to the Council, and it is that, logically, the Spanish Government has supported the proposal of Nicolás Sarkozy and Angela Merkel regarding Felipe González; but I wonder why the Spanish Government did not propose him. On one hand.

On the other, a simple comment on the rise in the CPI that occurred in the last month of November.

President.- As is more than evident, the name of Felipe González and any candidate is always the result of prior dialogues. Allow me to be prudent regarding the prior dialogues that have taken place. I must state, because it is quite notable, that the most eloquent initiative has been that of the President of the French Republic with the support of the German Chancellor, Angela Merkel, which you can understand I find extraordinarily positive, and I believe that, with the proposal or formulating a proposal from France and Germany, to which Italy quickly joined and which England, or Great Britain, has also shown its support and adherence today, represented having the most important cards for someone to represent or be elected by the European Council.

Regarding the second question, I have analyzed it at some point. As is well known, we have a rise in prices in the world, in Europe, in the United States, and in Spain due to two factors: one, the evolution of oil prices, and two, what the evolution of cereal prices has represented due to a supply crisis caused by a very high increase in demand in Asian countries, which has generated that pressure.

The important thing is that we look at how we are, in terms of the inflation differential with the rest of the European countries, which remains stable in what is traditionally the Spanish economy in relation to the economies of the European Union.

We trust that there will be stability in what represents the evolution of prices. I simply want to emphasize that in the last Legislature there were five occasions, five, in which the CPI was at 4 or above 4 percent, which is why I want to emphasize that this is a figure that the Spanish economy, from time to time, when there is a rise, especially in energy prices, and even with a much lower rise in energy prices, has exceeded. We hope that the evolution will be one of containment and reduction starting from the middle of next year.

Q.- President, regarding the Reflection Group, I do not know if you agree that the issue of the borders of the European Union should also be addressed. Or are all the leaders in agreement that this should not be a matter to be discussed?

Then, some information is coming out in Spain regarding irregularities in clinics that perform abortions. I wanted to know if the Government is going to take any measures within its competencies in this matter to prevent the fraudulent use of the third assumption of abortion use.

President.- Regarding the first point, the Reflection Group's deliberation has a catalog of topics, all of them of great magnitude, as can be inferred from the reading I have made of the Council's Resolutions. Logically, it is not dismissible that within the set of those topics, some reflection is also made on what represents the dimension of Europe in the future. But let us allow the reflection to be made and to be made by those who have to do it, which is by the Reflection Group that, as you know, will have to be approved, after the proposal is made by the President and the Vice Presidents, by the Council itself with a total of ten members.

It is absolutely clear and evident that the President of the Group, who is Felipe González, will carry out a dialogue process with all European leaders, with leaders, with experts, and with Governments, on the topics to incorporate the maximum possible number of elements into that reflection and into that constructive initiative. I would not rule out, therefore, that there would be consideration, although it is evident that it is not the expressly established object, which has much more to do with economic aspects, environmental aspects, and security aspects.

The major themes are: economy, competitiveness, environment, climate change, energy, and security in Europe, in the face of the challenges we have of insecurity, fundamentally due to terrorism.

Secondly, of course, the Government, within the scope of its responsibilities, and the most important in this case is to ensure compliance with the law… Whenever we are faced with possible voluntary interruptions of pregnancy that do not respect the law, we are faced with criminal cases. I want to remind you that the case that occurred in Barcelona is the result of a judicial action in collaboration with the Prosecutor's Office, as could not be otherwise, and, of course, do not have any doubt that the Prosecutor's Office will fulfill its role to ensure that the law is respected in this area.

Q.- You have said, Mr. President, and forgive me for returning to the declaration of independence, that it is not dismissible at all, but rather probable that there will be a consensual or agreed declaration of independence of Kosovo; a declaration of independence agreed with the United States and the European Union. The specific question is: will Spain recognize that agreed independence of Kosovo with the European Union? And, secondly, since we have decided today to send a mission to Kosovo, a civilian mission, will Spain participate in that mission?

President.- I must make a clarification: I said that it is probable that a declaration of independence will occur; I did not say that it is probable that a concerted declaration of independence will occur, much less that of the United States, a country I did not mention, at least on this occasion, and the European Union. Therefore, I refer to what I have said.

If that occurs, if that declaration occurs, and I am thinking more of a unilateral declaration, the Government of Spain will adopt a clear and forceful position. But we should not anticipate events. I have expressed a substantive position, a fundamental idea. We believe it is better to unite than to divide borders within what can be the European space. I do not refer, logically, to the space of the European Union, but to the European space in a broad sense, and, of course, we wish and will work for a common position of the European Union. But all States, and Spain as well, will reserve their position for the moment, if it arrives, regarding the recognition or not of a possible unilateral declaration of independence.

Regarding Spain's participation, we are already there participating in a military mission for peace and stability. The Foreign Ministers must establish the modes of participation, but Spain is always committed to peace and stability. When the Foreign Ministers establish the formulas, the personnel, and the means, we will take a position; but, I insist, Spain is always committed to lending a hand in favor of peace and institutional stability in a region like the Balkans, and in Kosovo, in particular.

Q.- Two questions about the conclusions: one, about Kosovo, although I reiterate a bit, and another about enlargement.

Regarding Kosovo, it is said that it is a sui generis situation and that it cannot serve as a precedent for other situations. Do you believe that this sui generis situation and lack of precedent will be understood by all parties in the world, for example, in the Basque Country, and will it not create tensions for you? Mr. Sarkozy has said in his press conference that the path being followed generates tensions for you, but that you accept it in the name of that union, that consensus.

On the other hand, regarding enlargement, the eventual accession of Turkey has disappeared from the conclusions and therefore also that of Croatia, which seems to be paying the price, and what were previously accession conferences are now referred to as intergovernmental conferences. Does this mean that the Union no longer sees Turkey as a hypothetical partner to integrate, or does it mean that it is yielding a bit to the pressures of Mr. Sarkozy?

President.- Regarding the first issue, that the situation in Kosovo and the Balkans is exceptional is absolutely evident; very exceptional. So exceptional that it is the result of a brutal war and a great military conflict, and it has taken a long time to restore a certain stability and a certain peace by the International Community. An exceptional situation, of course, but I reiterate that Spain, the Government of Spain, will make its decisions, if a unilateral declaration eventually occurs, based on its own conviction, always trying to make the most constructive contribution to what, in my opinion, is very desirable, which is for the European Union to lead the situation that exists in Kosovo today and tomorrow.

Logically, the position of our country, of our Government, and of the State will be the one we adopt at the appropriate time. And I will clarify that it will depend a lot on the procedure of how things are done and the dialogue that is established between the parties.

Today, addressing what represents the possible enlargement and, specifically, the negotiation process, which remains open with Turkey, was not on the agenda. There has not been a single minute today regarding Turkey. We will undoubtedly have it in the upcoming Councils, of course, and it will be a topic of debate. I can also assure you that this is what my intuition tells me.

Q.- President, I wanted to change the subject a bit. I wanted to ask you a question with a "z," as in "viz," about a negotiation that is very important, that of the Common Market Organization for wine, a sector that is very important for Spain, for many of its regions. I would like to know what Spain's position will be in this negotiation and if some sectors, such as in the case of Castilla-La Mancha, the must and the alcohols for consumption, will be somewhat subordinated to what may happen with the use of sugar that countries like Germany and other Northern countries use.

President.- Spain will continue to defend that the result of the negotiation of the organization of wine trade is, logically, favorable to the interests of our country. That is what we have been doing and what we will do next Tuesday. And we hope to have sufficient support for that to be the case within the Council itself.

Q.- President, I wanted to return to the rise in the CPI. This rise and subsequent rises in the coming months that the European Central Bank has already announced represent a constant loss of purchasing power for workers. I wanted to know if you still recommend wage moderation.

President.- I want to make a clarification that seems essential to me because, first, the European Central Bank has not made any decision regarding the increase in interest rates, as far as we know, and, as you well know, even what has been the evolution of the Euribor, which is an important reference, of course, for mortgage payments, has had a downward spike.

Regarding the purchasing power of workers, the majority of workers in our country have a salary clause established by collective agreement and have revisions based on the evolution of the Consumer Price Index (CPI) of their salary clauses. Then, as is known, pensioners are guaranteed by law what represents the revision of their pensions based on the evolution of the CPI, which is also referenced to the month of November, and what represents an increase and greater contribution is made effective in the month of January. That is the situation.

I want to emphasize that the only reliable data we have so far indicates that in 2007, in the first two quarters of 2007, as a result of the increase in productivity in our country, purchasing power increased by 1.4 percent for the first time in several years. Those are the official figures we have, although it is evident that the price increase, such as the one we are experiencing, which also affects a number of direct consumption items, undoubtedly forces many families to make a stronger commitment to what their spending expectations and consumption expectations represent.

But, and I have expressed this many times, the Spanish economy is growing at 3.8 percent, which was the last figure, one point more than the economy of the Monetary Union, of the countries that make up the euro. It has created three million jobs in the last three and a half years, and I affirm: the Spanish economy will continue to grow above the average of European countries, it will continue to create jobs in the coming years and, therefore, the disposable family income will continue to increase and its convergence in per capita income with the European average.

If, in addition, price increases and inflation are moderated, it will logically be a very important contribution, especially for job creation. This is complemented by an outstanding fact about our economy, which is the health of public accounts. We are the only country that has a surplus close to 2 percent among the countries that make up the Monetary Union, among the most developed countries, among the most economically powerful countries in the world, and this gives us a wide margin of action to invest and, if necessary, to increase social benefits, which is the government's objective.

Consequently, the economy in Spain will continue to grow, that is, it will continue to have a positive balance; employment will continue to grow, it will continue to have a positive balance, and if the economy grows and if employment grows, well-being increases, which is what, by the way, the Spanish economy has been doing in recent years and very evidently in the last three years.

Thank you very much.