Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

30 September 2008 · Parliamentary control session · Chamber of the Congress of Deputies

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions in Spain's Congress on September 30, 2008, defending his government's family support policies amid the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Family support policies, economic crisis impact, social policy priorities, 2009 budget measures, dependency law, early childhood education, minimum pensions, birth grants, OECD family spending comparison, demographic concerns, parliamentary debate
Duration
~14 min
47th percentile
Words
1,630
47th percentile
Sentences
62
41st percentile
Readability
45
49th percentile
Grade
12.8
55th percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.21
50th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 42%40%
  • Social 32%31%
  • Institutional 20%19%
  • Ceremonial 5%5%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

62 sentences in 29 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President of the Government, on September 10th in this very Chamber, there was an economic debate in which you participated with your appearance, along with the Spokespersons of the Parliamentary Groups. In your speech, you emphasized the need for support for families, depending on the economic situation we were going through and the social impact that the crisis would have.

Almost a month has passed, and undoubtedly, the news about the crisis worsens the possible outcomes and social impact. Does the Government, Mr. President, plan to promote new specific policies for families for the year 2009?

President.- The Government will continue along the lines of making social policy to support families one of its major priorities. We are living in a time when we have reached unprecedented levels in our country, and we will reach 1.5% of the Gross Domestic Product in measures to support families.

I remind you of the most important ones: the birth grant, which has been established for the first time in our country; the Dependency Law; the extension of paternity leave; a 30% increase in minimum pensions; the expansion of Early Childhood Education from three to six years and now from zero to three years, and a series of other social policies that have been decided within the framework of social dialogue.

Therefore, I can assure you that for the upcoming budgetary exercise, for 2009, we will maintain this social policy, and maintaining means increasing, in this case: a 6% increase in minimum pensions; a 6% increase in scholarships, and we will reach for the first time one and a half million scholarship recipients in this country; we will increase spending on Dependency to 1.2 billion euros, a 33% increase, and together with the Autonomous Communities, as I mentioned, we will extend Early Childhood Education from zero to three years. For now, we have already allocated 130 million, which we have distributed with the Autonomous Communities.

Therefore, yes, Mr. Duran, the social policy to support families has been the axis of our policy and will continue to be, even more so in this adverse economic situation.

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President, regardless of the fact that time does not allow me to debate what constitutes a direct support policy for families and what should not be considered as support for families, I would not like to talk about the past, but about the future. Speaking of the past, however, while acknowledging the 2,500 euros when a child is born, the Consumer Association itself considers that it only covers 40% of the cost of that child in the first year of their existence, and it is logical that support for families goes far beyond what is the first year of a person's life.

However, Mr. President, talking about families is talking about the future, and in that sense, the figures you provide regarding Spain's GDP investment in family policy do not match. The OECD places us at the bottom of European countries, at one-third of the support of the countries of the European Union, including Eastern countries, and at one-sixth of what would be direct support to families in countries like Luxembourg or Denmark.

I will give you, Mr. President, on behalf of this Parliamentary Group, several reasons to support families. The first, Article 39 of the Constitution, which clearly states that public authorities will ensure social, economic, and legal protection, and they do not do so today in all its aspects.

Secondly, you will recall some words from Tony Blair when he said that society is stronger the stronger families are. Yesterday, it was recalled from the seats of the PNV, in the context of the debate on a Bill from our Parliamentary Group, that the family is the basic cell of society and, of course, a school of values that is needed in the moments our society is going through.

Finally, demographic reasons, Mr. President. If one does not believe in the family, for reasons of birth rate, it must also be supported. One cannot simply rely on foreign immigration to guarantee the democratic and demographic future of a country.

Yesterday, Mr. President, this Chamber approved, and our Parliamentary Group is proud of it, an initiative on the universalization and expansion of child benefits that I hope your Parliamentary Group and your Government will support until the end.

President.- As you know, Mr. Duran, your initiative had the backing of our Group and, of course, it will have the support of the same and, logically, of the Government.

There are things that are evident. I have cited a range of historically significant measures to support families such as the Dependency Law or the birth grant. We could say that 2,500 euros may be a limited amount, but when we came to Government, there was not a single birth grant in this country, and this is the first Government that established the 2,500 euro grant. It is fair to recognize it. When we came to Government, there was no Dependency Law, zero euros for dependency, and now we are already at 1.2 billion for Dependency. And I have told you and I reiterate that we will reach 1.5%...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, the unemployment rate in Spain is 11%. This is a Eurostat figure from July, based on EPA sources; 2.8% more than in July 2007. In that same period of time, unemployment in Germany decreased by 1.1% and in France by 0.9%, according to Eurostat.

You said that your best figures would always be better than the worst of the Popular Party. This is already a lie, but in the General State Budgets that you present, you speak of an unemployment rate for next year of 12.5%, and the item dedicated to unemployment is the one that increases the most in the Budgets, by 24.3%. We are going to spend more than three trillion pesetas to assist the unemployed, the second largest expenditure item.

These are your figures that I will not dispute, but while spending on unemployment rises by 24.3%, active employment policies decrease by 1.7%, and the investment chapter also decreases by nearly 3%. Can you explain this, and can you explain what measures you will take to prevent unemployment from continuing to rise in Spain?

President.- Mr. Rajoy, I remind you that the unemployment rate for the second quarter of 2008, which is the last official EPA figure, is at 10.4%. It is simply a nuance. Nothing more, and it has the importance it has.

But I have read your question, and you talk about the unemployment rate and the dramatic evolution of unemployment. Was unemployment dramatic when it was higher than what we have at the moment, for example, in the years 2004, 2003, 2002, 2001, and 2000, when it reached or was at 14%? You were part of that Government, and certainly, at that time, what is now dramatic was a miracle: an unemployment rate that can be between 11% or 12% when it was at 14%.

Mr. Rajoy is surprised by the spending we are going to dedicate to unemployment. In this, he has shown a gesture of sincerity, because I understand that perhaps he does not like the spending allocated to unemployment, and it is logical that he does not like it or is surprised because you, in 2002, in the face of a rise in the unemployment rate, what you did was a "decretazo" to cut rights for the unemployed, which cost a general strike. Therefore, your interest in the unemployed, as you already demonstrated in Government, is zero. What our Government has done is, in agreement with the unions, improve protection for the unemployed to reach the maximum coverage that has existed throughout the democratic period and, of course, guarantee better benefits in the situation of unemployment.

For employment to regain a pace of creation, which is what we all desire, it is evident that two conditions must be met: a good economic policy and an adequate... Yes, a good economic policy like the one that has led this Government to create almost three million jobs in the last Legislature and bring the unemployment rate down to 8%, the lowest in history; a good economic policy fundamentally reflected in the Budgets and appropriate international economic conditions.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, Mr. Solbes left an unemployment rate of 23%, and the unemployment rate next year is higher than when you came to Government. That is the balance of your management.

You talk a lot about the past and should talk about the future. Your economic policy consists fundamentally of doing nothing. You do not govern, you make many statements, some very reckless, like those you made in New York or those you made yesterday in the Senate. You make many wrong decisions, and when you have to make decisions, you make even more mistakes.

The General State Budgets are Budgets, and you say it, with more deficit, with more unemployment, with more taxes, with less money for productive investment, without any measures that serve to generate employment in Spain, which is the capital objective, or should be, of any Government, and on top of that, you do not make structural reforms. Frankly, your economic policy is a complete failure and is creating many problems for Spanish citizens.

President.- With my economic policy, we have surpassed Italy in per capita income and the European average, and with my economic policy, we have social spending at 52.8%...