Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

31 March 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions during a government control session on March 31, 2009, addressing unemployment and economic crisis measures in the Canary Islands.
Main themes
Unemployment in the Canary Islands, economic crisis response, active employment policies, tourism sector decline, public infrastructure investment, state financial transfers, parliamentary oversight, regional autonomy cooperation
Duration
~20 min
65th percentile
Words
2,388
65th percentile
Sentences
71
47th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
16.2
85th percentile
Syntax
3.62
97th percentile
Vocabulary
2.29
70th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 49%46%
  • Institutional 40%38%
  • Ceremonial 9%8%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 6%

71 sentences in 49 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Ana María Oramas, from the Mixed Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Ms. Oramas.- Is the President concerned about the evolution of unemployment in the Canary Islands?

President.- Ms. Oramas, it is a fundamental concern for the Government. That is why we have been developing a whole set of actions, specifically for the Canary Islands, which I can summarize for you.

During this year 2009, the State has transferred 161 million euros to the Autonomous Community of the Canary Islands for the development of active employment policies and also finances hiring bonuses amounting to 79 million euros in 2008.

In addition, always aware of the uniqueness that the Canary Islands have presented in terms of employment, this Government has promoted and is executing the III Comprehensive Employment Plan for the Canary Islands 2007-2010, which is structured through annual agreements with the Government of the Canary Islands that allow for the availability of a fund of 42 million euros annually, which must be added to the fifteen million euros contributed by the Autonomous Community.

Alongside this, we expect that the employment situation in the Canary Islands will benefit from economic promotion measures that we have promoted, such as the Plan Renove in tourism, financed by the ICO with 59 million euros for the Canary Islands, in addition to other actions in this sector.

During 2009, we will also invest a total of eight hundred million euros in the Canary Islands for transport infrastructure and hydraulic works. From the Special State Fund for the Dynamization of the Economy and Employment, we will allocate 92 million euros to the Canary Islands, and from the Local Investment Fund, 359 million euros will be allocated to the Canary Islands.

Furthermore, the Government is well aware of the motion adopted on March 24 by the Congress of Deputies, and I can assure you that it is part of the Government's objectives and will be developed in full dialogue and agreement with the Government of the Canary Islands to multiply efforts with the aim of reducing unemployment in the Canary Islands.

Ms. Oramas.- Mr. President, as you know, the Canary Islands is the most externalized economy in this country, and that is why the crisis arrived earlier, more intensely, and with unemployment rates seven points above the national average: 22 percent unemployment, the highest in Spain along with Andalusia. And this, as you know, while the tourism sector remained stable during 2008, as you and I discussed.

At this moment, things have changed, and we must stop the decline that tourism has entered, because this sector, along with construction, accounts for 50 percent of the Gross Domestic Product of our Community.

For all these reasons, we need policies different from those of the rest of Spain to prevent the massive destruction of jobs, with urgent short-term measures jointly from the central and Canary Island governments that save the tourist season, but also the promotion, expansion, and execution of public infrastructure agreements and plans, which will not only place the thousands of unemployed Canarians from the construction sector but also change and improve the connectivity of the Canary Islands, the competitiveness of our economy, and the quality of our tourist destination.

That is why, last week, twenty short, medium, and long-term measures were approved in this Parliament, with the support of all parliamentary forces, which will allow us to face the difficult times ahead.

The Canary Islands cannot return to having a 30 percent unemployment rate as it did not so long ago, when so many Canarians had to emigrate to Venezuela. We need your commitment that everything that can be done will be done and that we work together so that the Autonomous Community, where two million people live, emerges from this crisis strengthened, with our main industry, tourism, transformed and improved, and with agricultural and industrial sectors that can compete on equal terms.

That is what we, the Canarians, ask for. Do not let us down, Mr. President. Our economy is at stake, as is the social stability of our land.

President.- Ms. Oramas, I can assure you that we share the sensitivity and that we have a wide range of action plans and instruments, which I also intend to share directly to evaluate their development with the President of the Canary Islands in a forthcoming…

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Gaspar Llamazares, from the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana-Izquierda Unida-Iniciativa per Catalunya Verds

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Llamazares.- Before asking the question, and on behalf of all citizens, on the 70th anniversary of the end of the Civil War, I want to remember all the victims from both sides and also the victims of the subsequent repression of a cruel dictatorship.

In any case, Mr. President, what do you plan to do regarding Caja Castilla-La Mancha and the consolidation of our financial sector?

President.- I share your opening words.

Regarding Castilla-La Mancha, I will tell you: the Government has been supporting the actions of the Bank of Spain, which, as Your Honor knows well, has the legal powers of control, monitoring, and intervention of financial entities. That is what has been done in the case of Castilla-La Mancha. It has been a preventive action to avoid a financial entity entering a state of insolvency, a financial entity that represents 0.80 percent of our financial system, which is strong and solid.

Furthermore, the Government sent to this Chamber, after the collapse of the international financial system in October, significant measures to support the financial system: two, basically: Asset Acquisition Fund, with fifty billion euros, of which twenty billion euros have been used, and guarantees for emissions from financial entities, in addition to having guaranteed deposits of all savers, of all citizens, up to one hundred thousand euros.

At this moment, and in accordance with a preventive policy based on the evolution of the financial system, which, I insist, is solid and robust, the Bank of Spain, in compliance with a motion approved by this Chamber, is developing a protocol of action to have useful instruments adapted to the needs of our financial system that can reinforce its capacity for intervention, prevention of the system, and restructuring where necessary.

Therefore, we have acted, specifically, the Bank of Spain has acted in the case of Castilla-La Mancha, in my opinion, correctly, and we are working on a preventive action plan in defense of our financial system.

Mr. Llamazares.- Without trivializing, I do not think it is good to trivialize and say that we only have a liquidity problem in Caja Castilla-La Mancha; for that, it would not have been necessary to call an extraordinary Council of Ministers on a weekend, but also without dramatizing, as I believe there are no reasons to dramatize, for the apocalypse that has occurred, especially in the political sphere regarding the assessment of this intervention; we believe that in relation to Caja Castilla-La Mancha, two major problems of our financial system are seen: we not only have a problem of toxic assets that come from the global financial system crisis; we have our own toxic assets, the real estate assets that weigh like a burden on our banking system, Mr. President. And in that matter, we have not made decisions, and I believe we need to make decisions.

In light of this intervention, I would say that the first thing the Government must do is guarantee deposits and ensure security: that of citizens, that of workers, that of those protected by social work.

Secondly, I believe that responsibility must also be guaranteed; that is, when management is carried out, including the management of a banking entity, there is responsibility, and that responsibility must be assumed.

But, from the general perspective of our financial system, we believe that, first of all, the Government must stop with half-measures and speak clearly about our financial system, which is a more solid financial system than others, but which also has significant weaknesses. Therefore, first, clarity; secondly, Mr. President, the situation of our real estate sector must also be clarified, it is essential, and, thirdly, Mr. President, the evolution or involution of the Savings Banks towards a private system is a mistake, it is not…

President.- Mr. Llamazares, I share with you that our financial system is stronger and more solid than that of most developed countries.

Secondly, the Government, as it has expressed and embodied in the appropriate regulations, guarantees the security of deposits in our financial system.

Thirdly, the Bank of Spain has demonstrated great professionalism when evaluating and intervening in any entity when necessary, and the Government will continue to support the Bank of Spain.

I will tell you that the Royal Decree Law on Sunday was because the regulatory instrument that supported what the Bank of Spain was doing was that, and it does not respond to any other circumstance.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, from the Popular Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, the decisions made on Sunday regarding Caja Castilla-La Mancha and the statements made yesterday by the Governor of the Bank of Spain reveal the existence of, at least, some difficulty in part of our financial system.

I will forget the statements that have been made in the past because I want to talk about the future and I want to ask you, specifically, two things: if you have a real diagnosis of what is happening in our financial system and if you have decided on any type of procedure to act in the event that there are difficulties, as the Governor of the Bank of Spain referred to yesterday.

I ask you this because your actions in the case of Castilla-La Mancha, first, the merger with Unicaja that was announced with great fanfare, and then the intervention on Sunday, give the impression that there is a lot of improvisation and little planning. And that is concerning and does not generate confidence. Mr. President, you need a plan, and that is what I ask of you.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, we can agree that, in light of what we have seen in most developed countries, the Spanish financial system has a good regulatory body, which is the Bank of Spain, and good legislation for supervision and control.

Therefore, the Government has placed its trust in it, and it is also its obligation, because the legal competencies are with the Bank of Spain. I would like to clarify: the Government has not intervened in Caja Castilla-La Mancha; the Bank of Spain does that. The Government supports the actions of the Bank of Spain.

Does the Government have knowledge of the situation of the financial system? Yes. It does because it receives information, as is logical, from the Bank of Spain and has been acting at every moment based on what the Bank of Spain has transmitted and requested.

At this moment, we have a plan or a protocol for prevention against risks in the financial system that will, in any case, be limited, if they occur, and perfectly manageable from the Bank of Spain.

The answer is yes, and you know it. Yes, you know it because the Bank of Spain and the Ministry of Economy have been working with you and your Group to convey to you what that protocol, that plan is, which we want to agree upon with your Group and all Groups, because we will agree that preventing, ensuring, and strengthening our financial system is a matter of State and is a matter for all, which is also in the hands of an autonomous, independent institution of great credibility, such as the Bank of Spain.

We want to do this to provide security, to ensure that responsibilities are assumed by those who have them, to minimize costs for the taxpayer, to respect competition rules, to do it transparently, and, of course, to maintain that private solutions are, in principle, the best. Thus, the Bank of Spain will work in all cases, including Caja Castilla-La Mancha, and, of course, with the support of the public sector.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, it is true that I have spoken with representatives of the Bank of Spain and your Government, but it generates a lot of insecurity for me, and that is why I ask for clarity, because for a long time I was told that nothing was happening in Caja Castilla-La Mancha, that a merger with Unicaja was going to take place, and in the end, I found out an hour before a Council of Ministers was held that there was simply an intervention.

Mr. President, yesterday the Governor of the Bank of Spain, whom you mentioned, spoke about the need to use public money, he talked about the restructuring of small and medium-sized entities; something similar was said by the OECD; today a former Vice President of the Government and President of Caixa de Catalunya, Mr. Serra, said that it was necessary to recapitalize all the savings banks and you acted on the Caja de Castilla-La Mancha. This is a difficult process and it is true that savings are guaranteed, and that is why people should be calm; but for people to be calmer and for all of us to be at ease, you need to generate confidence.

You have said that the case of Caja Castilla-La Mancha is merely a formality, a minor issue. I do not know if such statements generate confidence, I believe they do not. And then people are also unclear about what procedure you are going to use: whether you are going to do what you have done here, which is to replace the managers, give a loan from the Bank backed by the Government, or inject liquidity, or provoke mergers, as you wanted to do in the case of Castilla-La Mancha.

I ask you for clarity, transparency, and a procedure that gives us all security, because we all...

President.- I simply want to tell you that the Bank of Spain, I repeat, intervenes on Saturday and that, fortunately, you and many members of the Government find out the next day. I say this because at other times, in important circumstances, other Governments did not inform anyone.