Interview with the President of the Government on CNN+

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

29 March 2009

Context
Zapatero was interviewed by CNN+ journalist Richard Quest on March 29, 2009, discussing Spain's response to the global financial crisis.
Main themes
Spanish banking sector intervention, Bank of Spain supervision, fiscal stimulus package debate, economic recovery, budget deficit, G-20 and European coordination, green economy, GDP growth
Duration
~15 min
52nd percentile
Words
1,793
52nd percentile
Sentences
85
55th percentile
Readability
54
73rd percentile
Grade
10.9
32nd percentile
Syntax
2.98
45th percentile
Vocabulary
2.06
19th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

85 sentences in 38 paragraphs

Richard Quest.- Tonight there has been a development in the news that they have taken over a small bank, one percent, but they have had to intervene in a bank. What is the significance of this?

President.- It has relative importance, first, because it represents 0.8 percent of the financial entity; second, because we were not facing a solvency problem. The Caja was solvent but had a risk within a certain timeframe of having a problem. What we have done... The Bank of Spain has decided to intervene, the Bank of Spain, which has great experience in supervision and control, has replaced the administrators and the Government has provided a guarantee of up to nine billion euros to inject liquidity and restore the normal functioning of the entity.

R. Quest.- Do you think it might be prudent to analyze the other Spanish banks and subject them to testing? If they have already done so, could it be that the time has come to do it again?

President.- The Bank of Spain has an exemplary supervision system. It has been recognized worldwide and has been ensuring the solvency and viability of our financial entities. It is always anticipating events, unlike what has happened in other countries and with other financial systems, and that is why we can be very calm. If it needs to make any intervention, it will do so, always preventively and always in a limited scope, in a small segment of our financial system. We can be very calm.

R. Quest.- But then, don’t you feel that it might be wise, as has been done in the United States and the United Kingdom, to take another look to ensure there is nothing lurking that could be dangerous in the future?

President.- The Bank of Spain has a very rigorous and thorough analysis system. Its inspection and supervision ensure that a financial entity cannot go bankrupt. There are always means to anticipate and intervene.

R. Quest.- Let’s talk about economic growth now. Last week you said that if another stimulus package were needed in four or five months, you would be willing to carry it out. However, your Minister of Finance says there is no room for another stimulus package. What is it? Stimulus package or not?

President.- We have implemented a stimulus package of more than 2 percent of GDP. According to the International Monetary Fund, we are among the countries that have provided the most fiscal stimulus, and in 2008 we made a significant tax cut.

What is my position? My position is that we analyze the results of the effects of the fiscal stimulus package that all European governments approved in December. Let’s do it in June, let’s see if it is yielding good effects, and if it is yielding good effects, let’s remain calm so that it can produce the consequences in the economic recovery.

If it were necessary to make a new fiscal stimulus package, I would set three conditions: first, it must be much more limited than the previous one; second, it must be very coordinated among European governments; third, it should focus on what renewable energies and the entire green economy represent.

R. Quest.- That said, there seems to be a disagreement either between you and the Minister of Finance or between Gordon Brown and the Head of the Bank of England. There seem to be two very clear and separate visions: one that insists on the economic viability to be able to do another stimulus and another that says yes, and it will be more necessary sooner rather than later, and that may confuse people.

President.- I believe it is a debate among economists; it is in the scientific community because there is no exact rule. There may be countries that are more in favor of more fiscal stimulus, which also depends on their monetary system, and there are countries that may have a more cautious position regarding new fiscal stimuli. It is logical that we discuss it among ourselves. In any case, the differences will not be, from a quantitative point of view, of a large margin.

In Europe, so far we have had great consensus and great unity, and I believe that both in the G-20 and in Europe, at the Summit next June, we must preserve that unity.

R. Quest.- So you are not thinking of looking for a new Minister of Finance in the near future?

President.- No, we are thinking about moving towards economic recovery.

R. Quest.- What do you consider to be an acceptable level of budget deficit? What percentage would be acceptable to you?

President.- We must be prudent regarding the evolution of public revenues, but we are living in a very exceptional circumstance regarding the budget. The important thing is not that this year and next year we have a high public deficit, which we will have, but that we have a parallel plan to return to the path of 3 percent in the coming years starting in 2011.

R. Quest.- But, in terms of allowing the deficit to head towards necessary sectors and reach 6, 7, or 8 percent, would that be acceptable to you?

President.- Yes, it is an amount we can work with and manage until 2012.

R. Quest.- And could you handle a 10 percent?

President.- That is somewhat excessive. Excessive for me.

R. Quest.- Let’s talk about the European Central Bank now and its response. It is a relatively new bank compared to other central banks, like the Bank of Spain or the Bank of France. Do you think it should have done more, that the European Central Bank should have done more? I know it is independent and you do not want to exert political pressure, but could the European Central Bank have done more at the beginning of this crisis?

President.- I believe that starting in October, the Central Bank has done things very well. It has expanded facilities for financial entities, and that has allowed the interbank market to function again; it has drastically lowered the Euribor, facilitating the income capacity of families in volumes, for example, in Spain of thirty billion euros, and it has also lowered interest rates.

Perhaps until October it maintained an excessive concern about inflation without lowering rates, but we are talking about two months when the crisis accelerated. From October onwards, the Bank has done things well.

R. Quest.- Do you understand that there will be more cuts in interest rates by the European Central Bank, which will complement the fiscal stimulus you are going to introduce, in addition to other non-traditional methods like "quantitative easing"?

President.- It is possible that the Central Bank will lower interest rates, but in our founding treaty as the European Union, the functioning of the euro establishes limitations on the Central Bank regarding its capacity to issue currency or to acquire debt from euro countries. Let’s allow the Central Bank to take the steps it has ahead to lower rates, which is an autonomous decision of the Central Bank, and also to evaluate other mechanisms to continue facilitating liquidity in the system.

R. Quest.- That is exactly the problem for the countries that entered the euro: they have lost that monetary margin of interest rates and are somewhat limited by the fiscal policy of the euro, because they no longer have that possibility. Would it perhaps have been better with the peseta instead of the euro?

President.- No. Without a doubt, no. Being part of the Euro has given us a strength and a capacity for growth that is very, very important in recent years. It is true that, like almost everything in life and almost everything in economics, there are some positive aspects and at some point some limits that you have for being part of the euro; but, without a doubt, we are much better off with the euro, because it gives us monetary discipline, it gives us a weight and monetary strength, and it requires us, in return, to only have the margin of fiscal policy to act. But I prefer this situation.

R. Quest.- The draft communiqué from the G-20 has already been published by the Financial Times this morning; perhaps you have seen it in one format or another. There are now two very clear visions in the G-20: the first says "yes, there will be major changes, we will move forward" and in the second there are people like Angela Merkel, who says "don’t expect too much." You have said in the Spanish response to the G-20 that you were going to seek some strong decisions in a sense of direction and send a signal. What does that mean?

President.- There are three major objectives in the G-20: first, the union of all the major countries in the world, of the major economies in the world, to reform the financial system.

We need to democratize the international financial system. What is democratizing, what is the most democratic? The most democratic is that it is transparent, that it can be verified with data, that supervision is effective, and that tax havens disappear. That is democratizing the financial system. There is a rule in democracy that is that what cannot be counted always represents something negative. It is not about more rules, or more norms, or complicating them; it is about them being clear and applied.

Second, we need to coordinate and strengthen the International Monetary Fund as a lender to help emerging countries.

And third, we need to make a commitment to call on the world to say: the economic recovery, the economic future of the world, has two major drivers: the green economy and achieving the Millennium Development Goals. For us to be richer, we all need to ensure there are fewer poor people, and for the economy to have a period of innovative, solid growth, we need to change the energy model.

These are the three objectives, for me, of the G-20.

R. Quest.- Finally from me, are you concerned that the G-20 could really fail?

President.- In my opinion, we are going to succeed, because never before in the history of humanity in the face of a crisis has there been so much capacity for concertation, dialogue, and sharing and pooling decisions. We are going to succeed in the G-20 in London, and that will be a good message of confidence. We would all like that confidence to have an immediate translation, with recovery next month, for example, but we know that is not possible. Always the ruler struggles with time, and the citizen demands more speed from us. That is the greatness of democracy.

R. Quest.- Thank you very much, Mr. President.

President.- Thank you very much.