Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

23 June 2009 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Zapatero responded to parliamentary questions on bilateral aviation agreements and the international flight status of Barcelona's El Prat airport versus Madrid-Barajas in June 2009.
Main themes
Bilateral aviation agreements, airport liberalization, El Prat airport, Madrid-Barajas centralism, AENA management model, international flight routes, decentralization of airport management, Spain-EU aviation policy, Catalonia infrastructure
Duration
~22 min
70th percentile
Words
2,621
70th percentile
Sentences
94
60th percentile
Readability
40
36th percentile
Grade
14.3
70th percentile
Syntax
3.27
79th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 36%35%
  • Geopolitical 26%26%
  • Institutional 25%24%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Technological 2%2%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 2%

94 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Joan Ridao, of the Parliamentary Group of United Left-Initiative for Catalonia Greens

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Ridao.- Excuse me, Mr. President of the Government, but today the question is about airplanes and airports. Specifically, why does your Government maintain bilateral agreements with twenty-three countries that make Madrid-Barajas Airport the only destination for international flights in the Spanish State?

President.- Mr. Ridao, I appreciate your comment and I hope it will not affect, without a doubt, the content of my response.

I will tell you that, first of all, I express my satisfaction with what the new terminal at El Prat represents, which has received very positive feedback from public opinion since it began operations, and I hope it represents a very important boost for Catalonia and for Barcelona.

As for the specific content of your question, I wanted to tell you that outside the scope of the European Union, the establishment of regular international flights does indeed require bilateral agreements between the affected countries, although the creation of a "single European sky" means that many of the new agreements are already established between the European Union and third countries.

Apart from these agreements of the European Union, Spain maintains eighty bilateral agreements. In 57 of these eighty agreements, the airlines with which the agreement is signed can freely choose the Spanish airport of destination. Only in twenty-three cases, which refer to developing countries that do not have their own airlines or that present some other specificity, is this freedom of choice not granted.

Our objective, when we update these agreements, is also the total liberalization of the airports and the companies that operate in them. To this end, we have updated agreements in the last two years with the United States; Algeria; Australia; Brazil; Ivory Coast; Gambia; Mauritius; Mexico; and Oman, and we are negotiating with three more countries: Costa Rica, Uruguay, and Mauritania. Furthermore, as stated in the study by the Chamber of Commerce of Barcelona, the existing exclusions in the old agreements do not hinder the creation of new routes.

In short, the Government, of course, does not promote any policy that discriminates against one airport over another, and in the renewal of the agreements I have referred to, we will rather promote the opposite: facilitate transit to airports, including, logically, El Prat.

Mr. Ridao.- Indeed, the inauguration of the new Terminal at El Prat has been good news that will not only increase its capacity but will also allow for more and better flight connections.

But you know that El Prat airport does not only have a problem of space or capacity, although it is good to anticipate future collapses, because in fact the old Terminal, with five times less space, can already manage a transit of up to thirty million passengers and, therefore, is perfectly capable of all types of operations with Europe and internationally.

In fact, a good facility is a necessary condition, but not sufficient. In fact, there are smaller airports than Barcelona, such as Manchester, Milan, or Vienna, that have more intercontinental flights. Barcelona only has 5.4 percent of the total in the State. What is the difference between these airports and Barcelona? First, there is great potential, and Barcelona has that, and second, they have a decentralized and much more competitive management, because there are no political interferences of any kind and the managers depend, evidently, on their success.

By the end of this year, there will be that new management model. We will see it, even if it is delayed, as you committed to it a year ago. It is about putting an end, ultimately, to that radial, centralist model of "kilometer zero"; to that model, even ideological, of large infrastructures that are for you a tool for organizing territorial power to articulate Spain and to ensure that its capital is well connected to the world, and that is precisely why AENA was born. That is the model of the former Soviet Union, Mr. President. For that reason, El Prat today is still a subsidiary airport, a second-rate airport, and an airport that functioned as a major feeder for Madrid-Barajas airport.

The example of this is precisely your centralism and interventionism when you still maintain today, and I celebrate that you wish to change them, those twenty-three international agreements that state that El Prat airport is the only international destination and that the only operating company is Iberia.

President.- Mr. Ridao, I must tell you that, indeed, you are right when you say that the new Terminal is the guarantee for improving the conditions of El Prat and its capacity for interrelation. We agree that the management model needs to be modified. We will work on it. It is a commitment that the Government has, and of course, we are also fully committed to ensuring that in the modification of the agreements, new opportunities are opened for El Prat.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josu Erkoreka, of the Basque Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, in the budget agreement that my Parliamentary Group celebrated with your Government to support the public accounts for the year 2006, a budget item was included to finance the efforts that were to be made for the construction of a large scientific facility, a neutron source by spallation, which was to be located in the Technological Park of Zamudio, in Bilbao.

Since then until today, in a gesture of loyalty very typical of the socialist Government, we have heard nothing about it. Neither you, nor your ministers, nor even in your Parliamentary Group, have had a single minute to inform us about the progress of the efforts. However, they appeared whenever they could before the media to sell as their own and exclusive a project that was of shared genesis and that would never have been born if it had not been for that parliamentary agreement. They gave headlines like this one, which I now show you, in which just six months ago your Minister of Science and Innovation described the Bilbao candidacy as the favorite in this race.

A few weeks ago, we learned, also through the media, that the European Council of Ministers had agreed to forget about Bilbao and assign this infrastructure to Sweden, to a city in Sweden. The favorite candidacy of Bilbao, according to your Minister, was left only with the support of Portugal, and the rest of the community countries supported the Swedish candidacy.

In light of such failure, I ask you the question that appears on the agenda: what place has the project for the location of the European Spallation Source in Bilbao occupied in your international agenda in the last three years?

President.- You can imagine, Mr. Erkoreka, that, indeed, the Government has made continuous efforts regarding the spallation source of neutrons in Bilbao, that great technological installation. You know that we have allocated ten million euros to increase scientific and technological capacity in Euskadi or a mixed center of the Superior Council at the University of the Basque Country.

Indeed, the outcome, and you have explained it partially, basically means that Sweden will host the main headquarters of the project and Bilbao, a complementary headquarters; I believe that the nuance is important. Bilbao will have three facilities: a Technological Center for Accelerators, a Testing Laboratory, and a Computer Development Center. Spain will hold 10 percent of the ownership of the entire project and will hold a Vice-Presidency.

The development of these infrastructures in Biscay will involve an investment of 180 million euros over five years. Already in 2009, the Basque and state governments, as a result of the agreement we had, have committed thirty million so that the works can begin immediately and be completed in 2011.

That is the situation. At no time, and I believe you have heard me rather affirm the opposite, have I denied the effort, the initiative, and the collaboration that the previous Basque Government and the Government of Spain have had in the objective of the spallation source of neutrons. We have not achieved, as is evident, the objective we set out, but the final agreement gives considerable possibilities to the Basque Country in its technological capacity, which, from our point of view, are very positive for the future of research in that Autonomous Community and in Spain.

Mr. Erkoreka.- Mr. President of the Government, we will have the opportunity to discuss the Bilbao sub-site extensively when your Minister sees fit to appear before the corresponding Commission. The Commission was to be held on Monday, as you well know, and they have sent her off on a trip, probably to evade the appearance.

But, look, we are going to talk about the fundamental project. For a project of this nature to prosper, two things must happen: a competitive candidacy and effective diplomatic "cooking." The candidacy of Bilbao was good, it was excellent, it was hardly improvable, your Minister said so, and it was the favorite. What went wrong? The diplomatic "cooking" failed, Mr. President. Precisely the part that you were supposed to handle, which never took seriously the need to convince your community partners that the prevailing candidacy, the one that should prevail, was that of Bilbao.

You did not do your homework, Mr. President, or, worse yet, you did your homework and no one took you into consideration in Europe, because we were left only with the support of Portugal and you have multiple meetings with your community partners and I do not know exactly what you talk about with them, but you do not work effectively. You do not carry out the efforts…

President.- I do not doubt, Mr. Erkoreka, that the candidacy was a good candidacy; the Swedish one was also. I believe you know the community method and that, as is normal, candidacies for different options of technological centers or other types of headquarters, of institutions, have a natural process in which a reasonable balance is attempted. Obviously, Spain sometimes achieves its objectives and sometimes does not, like all countries; but I can assure you that I worked with all the…

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Mariano Rajoy, of the Popular Parliamentary Group

--------------------------------------------------------------------

Mr. Rajoy.- Just a few days ago, the Governor of the Bank of Spain appeared here and said some things that, in my opinion, are very reasonable. The most important was his statement that we need to change the economic policy that consists of increasing spending and debt to infinity, and not making reforms.

The Governor said that we need to return to budgetary stability. I agree, and I have been saying so for a long time. If not, confidence will deteriorate further, credit for companies and families will become more expensive, new tax increases will be forced, and there will be more recession and more unemployment.

I would like to know your opinion on the Governor's statements, whether you are going to rectify your economic policy, and whether or not you are going to raise taxes, because no one can clarify it, Mr. President.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, let’s get to the things that are clear.

It is clear that the Government I preside over had a surplus in the four years of the previous Legislature; it is clear that the objective of the Government is to recover the Stability Pact, as requested by the European Commission, in 2012, after the fiscal effort we are making to combat the economic crisis; it is clear that the Government I preside over has reduced the tax burden in Spain, as a result of the reduction of the Corporate Tax and the Personal Income Tax, and the elimination of the Wealth Tax; we had a tax burden, when we came to Government, of 34 percent in relation to GDP and now we are at 32.8 percent of GDP, and it is clear that the objective of the Government is to continue maintaining a reasonable fiscal balance to meet the objectives we want, which are: one, to maintain productive investment so that the country recovers its economic capacity, to maintain social protection, and to reach that target of 3 percent, according to the Stability Pact, in 2012.

That is the objective of the Government and those are the clear things that have happened. And, logically, regarding what we are going to debate in the next Budgets, we have to wait for the moment of the Budgets and know the different positions of the Chamber.

But what the Government has done in these years is: surplus and tax cuts. Now we have a new situation, which we will face from now until 2012 to achieve that Stability Pact in which we have been, which we defend, and with which we have a firm commitment.

Mr. Rajoy.- Mr. President, all I see clearly is that there is no clear criterion in the Government's economic policy.

Spain is the second country, out of twenty-seven, where public debt has increased the most; Spain is the second country, out of twenty-seven, with the highest public deficit, only surpassed by Ireland; public accounts are out of control, both in their expenditure chapter and in their income chapter, and the worst part is that we do not know what you are going to do on essential issues.

What economic policy are you going to implement? Are you going to raise taxes, as you agreed at 2:00 PM yesterday, or are you not going to do it, as you said at 6:00 PM yesterday? Are you going to carry out a labor reform, as you said at 7:00 PM on a Monday while negotiating with Convergència, or are you not going to do it, as you said at 9:00 AM the following Tuesday? Are you going to control the deficit or, on the contrary, are you not going to control it? Are you going to close the Garoña Nuclear Power Plant, as your program states, or are you not going to close it, as the Nuclear Safety Council says and as the Minister of Industry wants? Are you going to negotiate your economic policy with Izquierda Unida or with other groups? Because, evidently, it is not the same, Mr. President.

Here, with you, nothing is predictable, everything is unpredictable, and it is impossible to generate trust this way. And forgive me for saying that this seems like a circus and it is not funny at all, because we are talking about four million unemployed, and in a situation like this, the worst thing that can happen to our country is a government without a clear criterion on economic policy, a government that wavers, that one day says one thing, another day says another, and that only generates distrust and uncertainty.

President.- Mr. Rajoy, it is true that you are only an expert in glossing over the possible alternatives of others' policies, because in your alternatives you remain unpublished day after day, session after session, debate after debate. You have absolutely no alternative.

And what is indeed predictable is that you do not listen, because I just told you in the first part of my response what the objectives are in relation to the Stability Pact, to fiscal policy, what we have done and where we want to go. That is predictability.

And I must remind you that our country is twenty points below the average public debt in relation to GDP and that our country, like the vast majority, is incurring a deficit this year, next year, and in 2012 we will return to stability.