Speech and subsequent discussion with the President of the Government during the New Economy Forum
José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Zapatero addressed the New Economy Forum in January 2008, presenting his government's economic record ahead of Spain's upcoming general elections.
- Main themes
- Spanish economy, electoral campaign, economic policy credibility, social agreements, gender equality, minimum wage increase, Iraq troop withdrawal, research and development investment, growth model reform, public accounts surplus, social welfare, democratic accountability
- Duration
- ~96 min
- Words
- 11,488
- Sentences
- 382
- Readability
- 46
- Grade
- 14.0
- Syntax
- 3.26
- Vocabulary
- 2.01
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other382 sentences in 177 paragraphs
Good morning.
In the first place, I would like to thank the New Economy Forum for this opportunity, and I would like to thank its sponsors for having invited me to take part in a Forum that has progressively become more prestigious, widespread and influential in our society. We all know that this is a particularly relevant moment. Now the time has come; in two months. That is the most transcendental moment for a country, every four years, for a democratic country, as it is then that citizens have a say and can decide about the future of their country.
We have heard over the last few days that our pre-electoral debate is going to deal with economy. I am glad that some have realised the importance of economy three years later. Of course, that is not the case of my Government, which has applied a successful economic policy for Spain. Today, I am also going to focus on economy and I am going to do it in order to say that I trust the present and the future of Spanish economy, which is the same as trusting the capacities of businessmen, workers and citizens in our country in order to keep generating richness, in order to keep creating employment and in order to implement a policy of cohesion and social welfare.
Of course, we want and we can improve things, and we are going to do it, in our economy and in our productive system; but we won't make it by means of a ruthless decree, we will do it by means of a rational policy, mainly based upon agreements and dialogue with businessmen and unions.
I am going to tell you why I think that we can trust our expectations for the future and our expectations for the present, both in the economic and in the social area. This has a lot to do with trusting the democratic life and trusting the democratic life has to do with fulfilling the compromises assumed. Thus, let me refer, briefly, to the compromises that I acquired time ago with Spanish citizens and to de degree of observance of such compromises.
A few days ago I said that this Legislature had started with the fulfilment of a compromise, a transcendental compromise, the withdrawal of our troops from Iraq, and it had concluded with the fulfilment of a promise of a great social scope, the approval of 600 Euros for Minimum Salaries which, thanks to this amount, have increased 30 per cent during this Legislature, helping to recover the purchasing power that citizens had lost over the previous eight years, and it has been the result of one of the twenty social agreements that we have subscribed.
But apart from the withdrawal of the troops from Iraq and apart from the approval of the increase of the Minimum Salary, which amounts to 600 Euros, a set of decisions have been made, and these have to do with the fulfilment of other compromises.
I will mention, for instance, the recognition of the development of new rights in favour of equality between men and women, which are particularly important for the impulse that our economy, our labour market and our productive system need. If women are fully integrated in the different levels of the production chain we will be ready to achieve our goal and place ourselves among the most developed countries in the world.
Fulfilment as far as equality between men and women is concerned, attention to dependence or to marriage between people of the same sex. But also the strict observance of the increase of the minimum pensions, which have increased more than ever in the whole democratic period; the support of young people, facilitating their emancipation through aids to housing; matching the protection of self-employed workers through the Statute of the rights of self-employed workers, and the validation of subsidies and rights for all Spanish citizens abroad, for they had remained practically forgotten ever since the last elections.
Similarly, I would like to mention that we have fulfilled, strictly, the compromise of implementing an increase of one hundred per cent - because investments in Research, Development and Innovation increased to more than double - in order to renew or to modify the growth model so as to achieve productivity through innovation and in order to reduce our dependence on construction. As we will see further on, that change in the growth model is no longer a desire today; it has already started and it has generated very favourable expectations for the future.
I think that having fulfilled the essential compromises as far as economy and social issues are concerned makes us deserve great credibility, and those compromises were also related to tax policies, with a more favourable treatment of earned incomes, with a reduction of the Corporate Income Tax and with a tax policy that brought about saving and, thus, for the first time, a surplus in public accounts; also in 2007, because the surplus for the year that is now coming to an end will match that of 2006 and, therefore, it will place us in a prosperous position, as compared to the other European countries, in order to face any situation in the future.
Credibility; credibility for having fulfilled the compromises and, therefore, credibility with regards to the electoral programme that we will present citizens with over the next few years, which will also be supported by a macroeconomic frame and by a tax frame in order to finance each of the projects that will be developed during that period and during that Legislature- and this is an innovation.
If we have a look, a brief, objective look, at the results attained, there are also several reasons to trust the managing capacity of the Government: in the first place, credibility; in the second place, its managing capacity.
To put it in the usual pre-electoral jargon, we must say whether or not now, in 2008, we are better or worse than in 2004. This question has never had such a clear, firm answer before as far as the economy, the strength and the development of a country are concerned.
Spain is stronger after this Legislature of changes and reforms: two million inhabitants more; an upward tendency of birth rates; an economic dimension that has turned us into the eighth industrial power in the world; we have progressed and converged with the European Union as far as our per capita income is concerned, we have surpassed Italy, and, besides, and this is the most important thing, Spain offers now a greater personal prosperity and a greater prosperity for families, which places us beyond the average of the European Union as far as the per capita income is concerned and makes it possible for us to surpass or to approach other countries that had been way beyond us for decades.
As I said before, we have just surpassed Italy and now it is France's per capita income that we must surpass. That is one of the goals and one of the national aims that we can think about and that we can achieve.
Today, Spain provides more opportunities than ever. We have a historical record of twenty million workers, with the lowest unemployment rates of the last thirty years and with a better development of employment for women and young people.
Today, Spain provides better and fairer protection to the social collectives that need it more, and it distributes growth and welfare with a greater territorial balance.
During this period we have grown at an average pace of 3.7 per cent, leaving behind the industrialised countries we are competing with.
At the same time, we have been able to change the growth model into one that is less dependent on construction and internal demands, one that is oriented towards added value sectors and towards a greater internationalisation of economy.
Rigor and economic austerity have marked the management of public accounts, and we have achieved tax surplus in each Budget; the last few years, it has reached levels that approach 2 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product.
The Spanish economy has spread its prosperity towards employment creation, more directly and more intensely than during any previous growth period, and the social dialogue has made it possible to move forward in the reduction of temporary employment. And I can guarantee that it is a privilege to govern this country with the attitude of the organisations of businessmen and of the unions, which are factors of balance and coherence, and highly positive factors in order to build up and assume responsibilities.
It is true that we have developed new ambitious policies from the social point of view, but at the same time we have set up productive expenditure as a priority.
Social Security is now more efficient and better provided than ever, with a Fund, a reserve, that amounts to 5 per cent of the Gross Internal Product: 50,000 million Euros.
To sum up, we have grown, shared and saved. We have done it thanks to both companies and workers, subscribing more than twenty agreements with them, and that has made it possible for us to live the Legislature with less social conflicts of our democracy or rather, the Legislature with more social peace.
The different indicators, I say, all the economic and social indicators have improve substantially over the last four years:During the first quarter of 2004 economy was growing at 2.9 per cent, by the end of 2007 it would have grown 3.8 per cent, almost one point more.
At that time, the investment in equipment goods was growing at 4.3 per cent, and now it is growing almost three times faster, 11.2 per cent. The exports have progressed from 5 per cent to 8 per cent.
Investment in Research, Development and Innovation did not even reach 3,000 million Euros and in 2008 it already surpasses 7,600 million Euros, more than twice and a half.
Productivity, the axis of our capacity to advance the future in order to increase the per capita income, has turned around the negative tendency that we had accumulated over the years: in 2004 it grew 0.1 per cent, very far away from the European average, and now it is growing at 0.8 per cent. While during the two previous Legislatures productivity per hour caused our real convergence with Europe to lose 1.3 points, yearly average, during the first three years of this Legislature it has added an average of 0.6 points.
Public accounts, when we entered the Government, were undergoing a real deficit and now they show a surplus that amounts to 1.8 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product, approximately. By 2008 we would have reduced the ratio of the public debt over the Gross Domestic Product in twelve points as compared to 2004, and we will be the country of the OECD with the greatest reduction over the last few years, which will enable us to attain a highly favourable debt level with regards to the financing capacity in the public sector and, therefore, a highly favourable level for productive investments in our country.
Even though the last piece of data concerning inflation, and this is merely circumstantial, is doubtlessly negative and the Government is worried about it; it must be assessed taking into account the average inflation during 2007, which amounted to 2.8 per cent, which is the lowest rate since 1999, in spite of this effect, which was brought about in four months, September, October, November and December, a period during which there has been a noticeable increase of inflation.
To sum up, we received an acceptable heritage, which I have never intended to discredit, as far as economy is concerned, among other things, because the interests of my country are at risk, but it was somewhat modest as compared to the economic and corporate capital that we have accumulated over the last four years. That heritage was accompanied by mortgages, mortgages that we have managed or that we are managing to clear off in just a few years.But this period has also brought forward a very positive balance for citizens. This is so in the areas of employment, salary recovery, family income, taxes and welfare policies.
During this Legislature, which we could call the Legislature of employment given the fact that three million employments were created, more than six hundred and thousand of them were created during 2007; six hundred and thousand over the last year.
These are the better results of our democracy and they surpass, of course, those of Germany, France and the United Kingdom, considered together, as far as employment creation is concerned. I am legitimately proud of Spain, as a country, for I can say, for the first time after so many decades during which unemployment was our biggest drama, that this country is able to create more employment than Germany, France and the United Kingdom together, and that, as a country, we are able to defeat the blot of unemployment and to try to achieve full employment. That is what we are achieving as a country.
The unemployment rate has grown almost six points and it has already attained the aim of 66 per cent established for 2010 by the National Reform Programme. And the unemployment rate has decreased attaining its minimum levels in history: when we entered the Government it was 11.5 per cent and now it is 8 per cent, approximately, the lowest in history.
Jobs have benefited women in particular, for they have obtained 54 per cent of the new jobs created; young people, whose unemployment rates have decreased five points, and long-term unemployed people, whose rates are the lowest ones of the European Union. Ten or fifteen years ago, one of our biggest worries as a country was the long-term unemployed and now we are one of the countries of the European Union with the lowest unemployment rates.
Stability, one of the greatest concerns of our labour market, has progressed, for the temping rates have been reduced two and a half points.
More employment, more stable, less unemployment, better salaries and more income for the families. The real average salary has recovered its purchasing capacity. In 2004 it decreased to 0.4 per cent and now it is reaching 1.4 per cent. The available income of families has augmented almost 24 per cent, in nominal terms, and families have now a yearly average income of nearly one thousand Euros more, in real terms, which has been logically favoured by the fact that there are three million jobs more.
Today, there are more resources available for Spanish citizens, as the Income Tax has been reduced 17 per cent -as an average- in the case of the lowest incomes, which affects 60 per cent of the taxpayers. And let me remind you of the fact that two million people do not pay this Tax anymore.
Many citizens and families have attained the average social rates that have brought about progress for many collectives that, considered as a whole, involve a wide part of our society: three million citizens whose minimum pensions have increased nearly 30 per cent; hundreds of thousands who are paid the minimum salary, having passed from 460 Euros to 600 Euros; those who have started to receive attention to dependence; those who, in a few weeks' time, will receive the Basic Emancipation Subsidy, which will benefit 360,000 young men and women; those who have already received the new subsidy of 2,500 Euros per birth or adoption and those who receive the aids for housing, and whose resources double the existing resources four years ago.
To sum up, judging by the efficiency of the results obtained during our management, and I have just referred to the issues concerning economy, employment and social policies, we deserve confidence to keep on developing this project over the next four years.
Ever since last summer, as you all know, the international economic context has shown a greater uncertainty, whose well-defined origin is far from us. It was originated by the bad evolution of the real estate market in the United States, which is very different from ours, and its impact upon low-quality mortgages and the subsequent liquidity crisis, upon the decrease of financial flows, the high price of oil and of certain raw material.
It is quite obvious that such tensions did not issue from already existing problems in Spain, none of them reflects any weakness whatsoever in our economy and none of them may be said to be due to impacts derived from the management of the Government - honestly speaking.
But it is also obvious that in a progressively more globalised economy, these effects spread out and they do not reach the others only; we become potential targets too.
Yet, it is necessary to keep calm while others give way to an unjustified alarmism. There are enough reasons to hope that such impact will be limited and non-durable, and there are also enough reasons to hope that it will not affect all countries to the same extent; but, besides, in the case of those matters in which expectations are relevant, and in particular in the case of economy, it is always more beneficial to think and to act positively. Pessimism has never created employment and, surely enough, criticising the economic situation or criticising the economy of a country is not like criticising the economic policy of a country. Everyone has the right to criticise the economic policy of a Government as hard as they please, but creating an unjustified alarmism about the economy of a country may damage its expectations. And it is not only unfair and partial, it is the less patriotic thing I know.
Thus, it would be desirable for those who have a certain tendency to talk about our economy in terms that are unconceivable for most of the Governments of the European Union -which praise our progress, our data, what we have achieved so far and what we can keep achieving, the good condition of our public accounts- to be a bit more prudent, a bit more sensible and, of course, a bit more patriotic. I am sure that businessmen, who know the strength of our economy and who, of course, do not share any pessimistic messages, would be grateful.
I repeat it: my approach to the future of the economy in this country is a positive one, not just because of the data I have just mentioned, but also because factors such as the stability of macro economy, the tax surplus and the good situation of our productive system make it possible for us to undertake new policies, new objectives and new initiatives.
The basis of Spanish economy and the relevant elements to face the current circumstances successfully are as firm and safe as ever. Our firmness lays in the fact that now we are a more powerful economy, with high rates of productive investment, and in this regard we have already progressed, changing towards a more balanced growth model, one in which we have a wide margin of manoeuvre as far as taxes are concerned, a competitive, efficient business network and the accredited solvency of our financial system.
Thus, our forecasts for the next few years are optimistic.
We will keep on growing at a good pace, at around 3 per cent; in my opinion, at least at around 3 per cent.
The slight deceleration will be accompanied by a readjustment of the balance of the growth model, which will become healthier and more sustainable, with a constant reduction of the negative contribution of foreign demand; that is to say, with an improvement of competitiveness of Spanish economy.
A lot of jobs will be created, the purchasing capacity of salaries will improve because productivity will keep improving and an outstanding inflation change will take place after next spring.
Thus, the economic capacity of both individuals and families will increase, because the good conditions of public accounts will make it possible for us to face new tax reductions that will keep favouring earned incomes and, in particular, the lowest ones.
We will keep on progressing and gathering physical, human and technological capital, so as to place ourselves where we should be, considering that we are the eighth economy in the world. We will keep on investing more in Research, Development and Innovation, in education and, of course, in the performance of the Transport Infrastructure Strategic Plan.
The efficiency of such measures, together with the reduction of the protagonist role of sectors with a greater intensity of labour force, will favour the growth of productivity and the competitiveness of our companies, which are the key to our future.
We will keep reducing the public debt and leaving enough margin for manoeuvre, in case it might be necessary, improving the long-term sustainability of our public finances. In just a couple of years we will become the country with less debt among the great economic powers in the world. This is doubtlessly a new landmark that we will also achieve.
This is and this will be a fact. Instead of this, instead of common sense, some prophesize, or rather, preach the existence of a recession. This matter does not deserve more time and efforts, but let me mention several data so as to introduce the conclusion.
Never during one single quarter between 2001, 2002 and 2003 did economy grow more than during the third quarter of 2007, and almost in all those quarters it grew one point below its current growth.
Unemployment grew in Spain during 2002 and 2003. Inflation attained 4.2 per cent twice during the previous Legislature, and 4.1 per cent on other two different occasions, and on four occasions it attained 4 per cent, and oil is three times as expensive as back in 2004. Average inflation in 2007 is, as I have already pointed out, the lowest since 1999.
Is this, perhaps, due to the fact that we were not in the Government during the previous Legislature that we lived an economic miracle then and now, instead, that economic miracle has become an awful recession? Citizens do not forget and citizens want political representatives to have credibility and intellectual and political honesty so as to make judgements about the evolution of the country and of our economy.
Therefore, rigor, seriousness and a bit of optimism and, of course, it is necessary to avoid creating false impressions concerning economy and it is necessary to be less pessimistic, because it is no good.
The Spanish society has reached a dimension that is qualitatively different from its past dimension. Now we contend with the most advanced countries in all the areas and businessmen know it well. This is our playground now.
Now our potential is fully available as far as inhabitants and human resources - which are progressively better trained - are concerned, we also have better next-generation physical and technological infrastructures and innovative capacities. We just have to consider the relevance of the Information Society in our country over the last four or five years.
Now we have leading companies in financial sectors, civil construction, communication, energy generation, renewable energies, the textile sector and tourism at a worldwide level. We exert a great attraction on foreign direct investments, and we have more investments abroad than ever: we were the third country of the OECD in investments abroad during 2006.
Thus, this is the time for our country to go for it and to fight for the chances that a globalised world may offer. There is no time for fear; this is the time to give vent to a collective ambition.
This society has endured the heavy load of high unemployment rates for decades, which have weighed many families down and which has blotted the development of our potential power. In 2008 we can aim at something different; we can aim at working and set up a goal in order to achieve full employment in a reasonable time, and turn this full employment into the most powerful factor of social integration and into the strongest guarantee of the welfare policies.
According to the forecasts of the Government, which have always remained behind reality, so far, out of prudence, we intend to create one million six hundred and thousand jobs during the next Legislature, which will maintain the unemployment rates around 8 per cent. But I am still more ambitious and I am willing and committed to leading a greater collective effort in order to attain two million new jobs during the next Legislature, so as to place the unemployment rates around 7 per cent, so as to increase the female employment rates beyond 60 per cent and so as to reduce temping to 25 per cent.
We can make it if we keep having dynamic policies as far as the offer is concerned, if we can count on the employment generation associated to the intense performance of the Infrastructure Plan, to the investments in R+D+i, to the spread of schools for children from zero to three years, to the improvement in education quality or to the actual development of attention to dependence.
Achieving real full employment and creating more stable, high-quality jobs; that must be and that will be the engine of our welfare; a welfare based, in the first place, on the increase of the per capita income in order to match the great European countries, and in order to place ourselves next to those who combine a high average income with the best social indicators, such as Finland, Denmark and Sweden. In order to attain this, it is absolutely necessary to move forward firmly in the area of productivity, continuing to improve our capacity to compete and guaranteeing the full incorporation of women into the labour market.
Progress in the area of productivity will enable us to attain a sustainable growth of the purchasing capacity of salaries. Only this progress will provide us with a solution to the current unbalance in our economy and it will provide our growth with additional sustainability. This progress will also guarantee success against the challenges of population ageing.
In order to improve competitiveness we must reduce the administrative charges on companies and families, a reduction of 25 per cent in four years. This is an issue that - believe me - worries me specially. Being the President of the Government, I must lead a great administration, namely the General State Administration, but I am also acquainted with the work carried out by the rest of the Administrations and I have had the necessary time to analyse the unbearable amount of administrative charges that companies must face in Spain. I can assure you that it does not match the circumstances of a modern, progressive country, and it will be one of our main priorities and we will start to do something about it during the next Legislature: we will reduce the administrative charges.
We must keep moving on towards tax simplification, cancelling, for instance, the Property Increment Tax, which is a compromise that I assumed; an obsolete tax in our context which, besides, sanctions saving. We must improve our competitiveness levels in the goods and services markets, which is doubtlessly the ultimate cause of the different inflation rates between us and the European average and which has also become the structural problem of Spanish economy.
We must keep on working to achieve a tax surplus and keep our macroeconomic context healthy. We must improve our educational system, expanding on professional training and achieving university excellence.
We must keep on working on R+D+i because that is, doubtlessly, the way to obtain the results we are seeking for in the medium term.
We must come up with more solutions to the question of accessing social housing, we must intensify the measures to support renting and refurbishing, by means of an ambitious plan that we want to set forth in order to renew old towns in all our cities, and it will surely be a way to back up the building sector at present.
As to the labour market, we intend to renew a great agreement with the social interlocutors so as to implement new measures to improve the general productivity of our economy and the stability of employment.
All this will enable us to develop social policies with a wide scope; applying the Dependence Law; advancing towards the improvement of the minimum pensions; promoting the construction of one and a half million of social houses during the next ten years - six hundred and thousand of them will be set aside for hiring; increasing the Minimum Salary, which will reach 800 Euros during the next Legislature, and implementing the Equality Act.
Ladies and gentlemen,
As I told you during the first part of my speech, I am convinced that citizens will make their decision after having contrasted the different political styles and the state of mind that is required in order to lead this ambitious project, with which Spain contends to achieve a relevant position in the world, one that may last during the whole 21st century.
It is now that the new distribution of globalisation is being set as a consequence of the strength of emergent economies. Thus, it is now that we must make the necessary moves in order to be next to those who lead changes, because he who brings about future is always the person who leads and anticipates the necessary changes and reforms.
Now we have the chance and now - and not later on - it is possible and we must take advantage of it. Nothing makes me feel more excited than leading that collective effort during the next few years, that alliance between Spain and progress, in order to lead the future during the 21st century.
I have full confidence in Spanish society, because it is in excellent condition to win and overcome any challenge it may face. And my confidence is based upon information and supported by reality. In fact, we have the confidence of international institutions, which for 2008 foresee - and perhaps this is not up to the expectations of reality - that the growth rates of Spain will be half to one point higher than the growth rates of the United States, Japan, Germany, France, Italy, the United Kingdom, the Eurozone and the OECD average.
And I would like to emphasise that the companies have confidence too, and they are the ones who know better the situation and the evolution possibilities of our economy. Why? Because their decisions, as far as investments in equipment goods and indefinite contracts are concerned keep showing their confidence in the future.
Those who lead big companies - and many of those who are here today lead big companies, and they do it very well, by the way - would never place their renovation strategies in the hands of someone that would lack ambition and confidence in the possibilities of the company, in the hands of someone that would discredit the company in the different markets where it should compete. No one would entrust such an operation to a person who would look back to 2004, instead of looking on towards 2012.
I have never been a catastrophist person; I am not compatible with catastrophist attitudes. Such an attitude has never been part of my temper, for I am, if anything, quite the opposite. That is why I do not quite understand those who turn catastrophist attitudes into their political stance. It must be rather discouraging to base one's possibilities upon the external deterioration of the situation and, it must be even less motivating to move in such a direction instead of working to outline positive proposals. Pessimism leads to defeatism only, it leads to defeat, and defeatism involves defeat even before facing any challenge.
The future of Spain is a great common objective. We must face great challenges. I have spoken today, mainly, about the challenges concerning economy, employment and the welfare policies.
We have all the necessary elements to enter the future; we must use them with ambition and, of course, with a constant effort. That is always absolutely necessary.
In fact, I will work tirelessly in order to achieve such goals. I am more than optimistic as to the results that we may obtain. That is why I will ask Spanish citizens to trust us once more and to trust us fully in order to develop our political project and feel proud, as Spanish citizens, to see that after centuries of being behind the countries that led technological, economic and industrial changes now we can be next to them.
Now is the time for Spain to achieve its plenitude as a modern, ambitious country, a country that has a say, that makes decisions and that, of course, knows very well what it wants for the future. This is what I intend, and that has been the task that I have been carrying out during the last four years, in spite of the fact that it is said that it has been a difficult Legislature believe me, trying to govern this country, with such citizens, is not at all difficult; it is a great pleasure.
Thank you very much
Debate with the President of the Government ------------------------------------------------------------------ Chairman .- It is evident that economy is going to be one of the main axes of the electoral campaign and you, in particular, have devoted your speech to it. There are many questions about it, which I will try to summarise, as I said.
Are you considering the possibility of undertaking immediate measures to restore confidence, to stop the deceleration and the psychosis and to neutralise critical views such as the one published by the "Financial Times" today?
Is the behaviour of the main indicators going to restrain - as many people would like to know - the electoral promises of the PSOE as far as taxes and social improvements are concerned, for instance? Is it going to influence the application of the Budgets during 2008?
How are you going to react against the tax reduction that the PP is going to propose, I mean, for instance, the reduction of the Corporate Income Tax?
Do you think that it is necessary to ask businessmen to try not to give the impression that an economic crisis is going on, for it might increase the sensation that a crisis is going on? Do you think that businessmen do NOT trust Mr. Rajoy?
President .- I will answer all the questions, except for the last one, because I cannot speak on behalf of businessmen; it is businessmen that must speak for themselves. I suppose that they will have their own opinion about Mr. Rajoy.
But I would like to have a look at the relevance of confidence as far as economy is concerned. We have mentioned the word "crisis". In fact, it is surprising, judging by the data I am going to give you now, which have been gathered recently, to hear anyone speaking about the loss of confidence or about the negative evolution of confidence; unless we are going through a dissociation between reality and the debates on the media or between reality and what can be inferred from certain news.
The progress of the sales indicators during last December, according to the information provided by the companies, are good, better than during November. It seems that the first days of January have been better than expected.
The available income of families will keep on growing at a good pace during 2008, with 3 per cent growth rates in real terms.
The results of the Spanish companies are the following: they have continued to grow in 2007.
According to the latest data published, concerning the period going from January to September this year, we see that the total turnover of the companies listed on the Stock Exchange has increased 15 per cent almost and benefits have surpassed 20 per cent. I surely won't make a mistake, considering the present data, if I claim that Spanish companies have obtained benefits that approach the record established during 2007, and this will be the fifth consecutive year.
If Spanish companies obtain benefits that approach or match that record, just like during the previous five years, who can speak about crisis and lack of confidence in the Spanish economy, with some rigor? Let me tell you that the situation is really amazing.
As we have explained on more than one occasion, there is going to be a deceleration as a consequence, mainly, of the construction sector, which is going to undergo a period of normalisation and adaptation, because we were building 900,000 houses and it was a bit too much for this country, and we will build 500,000, which is quite surely a logical figure, an adequate figure for a country such as Spain, which for quite a long period, for several years, has built more houses than Germany, France and the United Kingdom together, which seemed a bit too much, of course, from an objective point of view.
In 2008, companies will yield two-digit benefits, which is in fact what the best financial analysts are anticipating right now and this evolution will be led by sectors such as telecommunications, energy or services for companies.
Since Spanish companies are already acquainted with such data, they are already acquainted with this reality and they keep improving and investing in fixed capital. That is why investment in equipment goods is growing at a rate of 11 per 100.
I would like to emphasise that we will have positive consumer data by the end of the year, and the data concerning consumer credit and mortgage credit have grown considerably during the fourth quarter. I would like to point out the fact that hotel demand during Christmas has made it necessary for 60 per cent of our hotels to stay open, and thus the hotel demand has been brilliant during this period; and long-distance air transport has also increased.
The movement of companies increased 8 per cent last December, way beyond the expectations. And, as I told you before, foreign tourism has improved considerably, especially in the Canary Islands and in the Balearic Islands it has been amazing. Both national and foreign tourism have experienced a revival.
I have only provided you with certain data concerning the past and the current evolution of consumption and of the movement of companies during the last quarter; as well as concerning the sector of tourism, which has a determining impact on our economy.
For the thing is that those data concerning economy, investments, consumers affairs and employment transmit "confidence". Thus, I must tell those who want to generate distrust that, in the first place, they are going to make a mistake; and, that. in the second place, they are doing no good to a main element of economy, namely, to confidence.
Being the President of the Government of a country whose economy is growing, a country with a public surplus, a country without financing problems, a country without debts and a country that is creating employment, I can tell companies, with stern conviction and firmness, to keep on investing and I can tell citizens to keep trusting us, because we are going to keep improving our per capita income, our welfare and our potential for the future.
I hope and I trust that in a couple of years, for instance, we will be here, we will remember this speech and we will look back on 2008 and 2009, just like four years ago, when I was here and I remembered that I said that I was going to win the elections.
Now I am going to be a bit more prudent as far as this is concerned, although you have also asked me about this. I think that, those who govern must be even more prudent when making electoral forecasts. Those who govern respect citizens even more respect the free decisions of citizens even more and, those who govern or have governed during four years know very well that one must deserve it and one must deserve it every day and that one must do one's best in order to govern with honesty and, of course, fulfilling one's promises.
Chairman .- Could you make any forecasts about employment evolution? What are your plans for this area?
President .- We have lived four great years as far as employment creation is concerned. This Legislature will conclude with three million new jobs. No other country among the most important countries in the world has created so much employment, over 3 per cent, a percentage that we might reach by the end of 2007.
We have created more employment than the United States, Japan, Canada, Germany, France, Italy and the United Kingdom. These data are relevant, in my opinion, and our forecast is for Spain to keep creating employment.
During the next Legislature we intend to achieve between 1,600,000 and 2,000,000 jobs; that is our forecast. If we keep growing at a minimum rate of 3 per cent, and if we manage to achieve a few decimals more in the next few years, we might attain two millions and, thus, we might reduce the unemployment rates slowly but surely, attaining 7 per cent, which would be a new landmark and, of course, a great chance. And this has very little to do with the ups and downs of the unemployment rates in different months.
We have already had this discussion. Let's wait for the Labour Force Sample Survey, which establishes the evolution of employment and unemployment rates; which is the reference, of course, for the different international organs with regards to the last quarter of 2007, as far as employment is concerned.
Chairman .- Will you make any announcement concerning tax reforms or will the Inheritance Tax be the last one? People are interested in this issue.
President .- As to tax policies, I hereby announce two principles that formed part of the electoral programme back in 2004 and that will be included in the electoral programme for next March. The first one is that our country must implement a policy that does not contemplate a raise of global tax pressure; this is an essential principle. The global tax pressure that Spain is going through is below the European average, a few points, which makes us competitive as a country and which enables us to have a bee public sector. This is the first principle.
According to the second principle, we would like to simplify our tax system. Surely enough many of those who are here share this idea. This is a reasonable tax reduction, which will facilitate investments but which will be, mainly, a simplifying solution. Simplifying the tax system means that citizens will be able to save money, and it means just a tax reduction for companies. This is a great task that depends on taxes and it is there that we are going to make an effort.
As you all know, during the last four years we have reduced the Corporate Tax to 30 per cent, and, by the way, we have made a prudent reduction of the Income Tax. We have the responsibility to cancel the Inheritance Tax and the electoral programme will include several proposals to reform and modify the Income Tax.
And what is the purpose? Simplifying. And what is the purpose? Keep on lessening the fiscal stress on earned income. But our fiscal proposal is based upon coherence. And, by the way, I think that it is no good to compete excessively or make exaggerated fiscal offers before the elections.
I have spoken more than once in favour of tax reduction measures, and I have implemented them, I mean, I have been aware of the importance of taxes in a democracy. They are essential and they guarantee the cohesion of a country, the structure of a country at the social and territorial level and, even though the improvement of the Spanish economy has made it possible for us to bring about a future in which no one thinks (or even dares thinking) of the possibility of raising the taxes, instead, proposals have been made to reduce them, we cannot forget the democratic relevance of taxes. I think that the different reduction measures must be supported by this kind of reflections. But there will not be any modification of the Income Tax.
Chairman .- The next Legislature, just like the one that has come to an end, will be under the Damocles sword of oil prices. Will you keep up your stance against nuclear plants for power production and in favour of promoting the development of renewable energies? If the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party (PSOE) does not do it, do you think that the People's Party (PP) might dare to make a promise in favour of nuclear power?
President .- We can bet that that is not going to take place. Besides, I think that this is an important issue and I think that we should state things clearly and speak our minds. We know that this is a highly debated issue. I think that nuclear energy should not be promoted in our country, instead, it should be progressively reduced, according, of course, to the global energy demand, and we should make a great collective effort in order to promote renewable energies.
Whoever wins the challenges of climatic changes, getting away from carbon energy production, mainly through renewable energies - where Spain has a clear potential - will be among the ones who lead the most creative innovative economies and those economies with a higher added value during the next decades.
Just like in the case of those countries that made it fifteen years ago and foresaw that the Information Society was going to make the difference between the economies in the medium term, nowadays, it is the amount of investments, the preparation degree and the existence of greater efforts in order to face climatic challenges that are going to make a difference between economies during the next fifteen, twenty or twenty-five years.
It is not just a matter of respecting the environment or of making up for the destruction of nature, no; for me, it is, mainly, an economic matter and not a matter of welfare. It is an economic matter because if we implement an innovative economy when it comes to producing and saving energy, we will be implementing an economy with a higher added value and, thus, it will be a richest economy. And if we raise awareness among society concerning the relevance of energy and the relevance of supporting renewable energies, we will be promoting a greater collective welfare in our society.
This is where we stay and now we would like to listen to the position of the People's Party, because one cannot be in favour of nuclear energy or promote it behind the scenes and, then, remain silent while on stage, because then, the question is where to place new nuclear plants in Spain and where to dispose of nuclear waste.
I have a clear position and, besides, let me tell you that my position involves more challenges for a country. I admit it. It is easier to say "we are going to increase nuclear power production", from the point of view of a well-known energy model, firmly settled though questionable sometimes. It would be easier, but I think that we, as a country, are more interested in facing the challenge, the difficult, ambitious challenge - because our economy depends on carbon-energy production, and that dependence amounts to 80 per cent -, trying to create alternative energy sources based upon renewable energies instead of upon nuclear power; apart from the other specific problems that the growth of nuclear power would bring about for a country such as Spain, given the amounts of water required.
I think that I have spoken quite clearly. I hope everyone does.
Chairman .- Many questions have been asked about the future negotiation with ETA and one of those questions emphasises the fact that, according to an interview published, quite recently, by the newspaper "El Mundo", most Spanish citizens think that you will resume the negotiations if you enter the Government once more. People would like to know under which circumstances and under which conditions would you be willing to start a new process? Why keep on encouraging such need instead of cancelling the authorisation granted by the Parliament?
People would also like to know whether your Government will promote the illegalisation of the Basque Nationalist Party (ANV) and of the Communist Party of the Basque Homelands so that they may not present their candidatures for the upcoming elections and whether or not this will be done during the time that you will be in the Congress of Deputies before those elections.
Finally, people would like to know whether you fear ETA killing again before the elections next 9th of March and whether a terrorist blast - in case it might happen - would have any influence on your electoral expectations and on the results obtained next 9th of March.
President .- I will not make an assessment of the interview you mentioned in the first place because, after having seen the results in the American primary elections obtained by Ms. Hillary Clinton and Mr. Obama, I think that prudence is the best choice as far as polls are concerned. Yesterday, the different mass media all over the world assured that Obama was rocketing to ten points and that he would win, and in the end it was Hillary Clinton that won. Thus, let's give polls their adequate relevance and let's be very prudent when talking about them.
Now then, the anti terrorist policy. I have already said on several occasions, for I have been asked this every now and then, that I entered the Government after a Legislature during which there had just been 192 victims after the blast on 11th March, as a consequence of radical Islamic terrorism, and 42 victims as a consequence of terrorism blasts by ETA. It had been a very hard Legislature, with many mortal victims as a consequence of terrorism.
From the very first day in the Presidency of the Government I felt that my duty was to save lives, the lives of my fellow citizens. That is, working with zeal and devotion in order to bring terrorist violence to an end or to reduce it as much as possible. When this Legislature is over, this will be debated during the campaign, and we will be able to draw out a balance.
What I can tell you, because I know that all citizens have seen it, is that I have worked with zeal and dedication, without thinking of the political risks, in order to put an end to ETA's terrorist violence.
Once more, ETA has not been willing to do it; but it has lost. It has lost the chance that it was granted with by democracy and it has lost because it is weaker and it is going to get weaker, because I am trying to fight ETA's power and reduce it as much as possible with the same zeal that I proved during my different attempts to set up a dialogue in order to put an end to violence, with the same zeal and strength and devotion that I proved in order to set up a dialogue.
And I think that all Spanish citizens are able to see the constant efficiency of the State Security Bodies and Forces with regards to wide scope, important arrests, like the one that took place yesterday; a very important arrest, one of the most important arrests over the last few months, an arrest about which the Minister of the Interior is going to talk in a few hours. But I can assure you that it has been a very important arrest.
This is what I have always longed for: putting an end to terrorism or reducing terrorism as much as possible. A noble, necessary impulse. I have done my best. I haven't been backed as I should have, but I have already forgotten that. I always concentrate in the future and in fact, future means, in the first place, that there are no expectations, and let me emphasise this, no expectations to set up a dialogue with the terrorist group ETA; no expectations whatsoever. The only expectations involve the end of violence and the strength of the Rule of Law in order to bring about the end of that terror, the end of horror, of madness and of insanity. And it would be desirable, and I think that citizens will be grateful for it, for terrorism or rather, for the anti terrorist policy to go back where it should have always been, back to consensus and non-partisan usage.
The State Security Bodies and Forces have been working for weeks, for months, researching the different activities of the Nationalist Basque Party (ANV) and its possible connections with the illegalised party Batasuna. The frame of reference of this research, the context it is aimed at and the context in which it must be used, according to the guidelines of the Rule of Law, of course, is the context of penal institutions, Judge Garzon, who is carrying out a secret research about the Nationalist Basque Party (ANV) and its possible illegalisation according to the Party Law must be carried out by the Crown Prosecutor Service and by the Treasury Counsels.
I can hereby guarantee that the research, just like everything our State Security Forces and Bodies do, has been carried out exhaustively. Now it is the legal representatives (a judge, the Crown Prosecutor Service and the Treasury Counsels) who must decide, in due time, when the research process is over; but, as President of the Government and as I have a great responsibility within the Rule of Law, I am firmly convinced that no one is going to get away with anything and that those who do not observe the Law are not going to have the chance to enjoy the rights granted by Law in order to be in the political arena.
I am sure about it and I respect completely the decisions of the judges, of the Crown Prosecutors, of the Treasury Counsels and, if necessary, of the Supreme Court and of the Constitutional Court.
Chairman .- Is the Government going to take any measures, for instance, in order to promote research actions or in order to take disciplinary measures against anyone with regards to the damage suffered by the members of ETA arrested last Sunday?
President .- Yesterday, the Minister of the Interior and I said a couple of things about this. In the first place, we have the information provided by the Civil Guard about the use of force during the arrest. Force was used during the arrest of those two alleged members of ETA and we, as a Government, trust the State Security Forces and Bodies as much as we trust the Rule of Law. Surely enough, as a legal research process has been started by a Court in San Sebastian, we will trust that research and, of course, we will collaborate in everything.
But I can already tell you that it is, in the first place, the Civil Guard - which is devoted and committed to fight terror, and there is no need to emphasise that now - and, of course, in the second place, the Government that are interested in removing any doubts whatsoever about the actuation of the Police and the Civil Guard.
Chairman .- Back to the elections, if it is fine with you. People would like to know whether you are considering the possibility of establishing a provisional Government formed by a great coalition, "in the German style", or, at least, of setting up an agreement for the next Legislature with the People's Party about five or six State matters. People would also like to know whether if a Government in coalition with Convergence and Union (CiU) would take place, you would be prone to transfer one of the Ministries of Economy to them. Would that be your way to settle things with Mr. Artur Mas?
President .- I will be very honest: I am going to ask Spanish citizens to vote for me in order to achieve a wider majority, wider than the one I have had during the last four years, because that will strengthen a project that has proved to yield results and to fulfil compromises, a majority that will therefore enable us to keep on implementing such project over the next four years.
I intend to win, and to achieve a clear victory, for that is what someone who asks citizens to trust him to become President of the Government should achieve in a country with 45 inhabitants, a country that we all love, Spain. I don't intend to tie, right! I intend to win, and to achieve a clear victory too. Thus, I haven't even considered the possibility of setting up a great coalition. In fact, this is the first time I am asked such a thing. I haven't thought about it.
And certain political representatives of nationalist forces would be prone or willing to form part of the Government; but, of course, the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party wants to win with a wider majority in order to implement its own programme with as much autonomy and freedom as possible.
Chairman .- The Government and the Socialist Party have reacted explicitly against the words of Spanish cardinals, according to whom the measures or projects carried out by your Government, the Government you lead, go against human rights and lead to the dissolution of democracy in Spain. Are you angry, and how could that affect the relationships with the Catholic Church if you remain in the Government?
People would also like to know your opinion about the reaction of the People's Party after such statements? Are you going to summon the Ambassador of Spain in the Vatican, as the General Coordinator of United Left proposed?
President .- In the first place, there is something I would like to emphasise. The Papal Nuncio was here, wasn't he? I really appreciate the Papal Nuncio, he is a good Nuncio and a good person and I am not going to summon him. What I will do, because I was invited to long ago, is going to the Nunciature to have a soup, because I have been invited to, and I haven't done it yet. This is a compromise I assumed long ago. And I intend to do so.
Firstly, I would like to point out that I have lately heard or read certain headings written by different analysis and politicians that the Government had taken an offensive against the Catholic Church. Yes, that's right. That's the heading of a newspaper, there's no need to say the name. Now, one feels surprised, as much as one can be, because of such bravados, so to say; because it is Christmas time, a time for peace, for union, a time for love, and the 30th of December, right midways between the Birth of God and the Epiphany, in such moments of love and peace, during a supposedly religious event, two cardinals in our country say that the laws of a democratic Government are making human rights go back and that the laws of a democratic Government, which are there to expand on the individual rights, are diluting democracy - there you go. There you go.
Since we are in Christmas time, this serious attack against the Government is carried out by two cardinals and it seems as if the Government had started it all out. Precisely when we were all so quiet! Precisely when there was no problem between the Church and the Government, when things, mainly ever since Mr. Paco Vazquez is in the Vatican, were even going so smoothly! We know that we view things differently, but we are perfectly able to sit at the table and have a nice lunch.
Thus, this is what does not make any sense, in the first place, because that criticism is exaggerated… That is, the laws that have consolidated or expanded on people's rights have been present in different democracies for a while. I cannot understand such an obsession with divorce now, because we reformed the Divorce Act and they say: "there are more divorces now". No, it is not that there are more divorces; the thing is that before people had to wait for a long time before getting divorced and, as usually happens when a law meets the requirements of everyday reality, this Law has succeeded in providing the channels so as to avoid an unnecessary time of suffering and absurd coexistence.
This implies respect to individual rights and it is really weird in my opinion, right, to go back to such evident situations now, situations that involve wanting to force those who do not want to share their lives any longer and who do not want to live as a couple any longer to keep on living together. This is unconceivable for any reasonable person. But it is true that the number of dissolutions of marriages has not decreased, instead it is quite noticeable.
I feel a great respect, I understand and respect the Vatican and the Church when they do not agree with the voluntary interruption of pregnancy, yet, in this country the same Law has been in force without modifications for years and it now seems that it is questioned again, just like same-sex marriages. I respect it. Now then, one thing is being against and one very different thing is saying that it implies an attack against human rights, or that it destroys the family, or that it ruins democracy, such things cannot be assumed, in the first place, because they are unreal, and in the second place, because they are just not true.
Democracy, that great system of coexistence that men have created implies, in the first place, respect for plurality, just like we all must respect the Christian idea of a family. Some couples might decide to have eleven or twelve children, they might decide to oppose divorce and they might decide not to divorce. I feel great respect for that, and they can live under the auspices of the Constitution, as well as those who want to profess a religion. What they cannot do is preventing those who believe otherwise, those whose convictions are quite different and those who have decided to live differently from exerting their rights.
For this is the DNA of democracy and freedom. And, besides, religious freedom, which is the essential pillar of the Rule of Law, is better guaranteed when freedom in general is guaranteed, because in a democracy, whenever we expand on a single aspect of freedom, we are strengthening freedom as a whole, and each time we expand on a single right we are strengthening citizenship rights in general.
Our Constitution is wise as far as this is concerned: Non-denominational State, but of course!, just like all democratic States, but it says: there will be a specific relationship with the Catholic Church. And that is the mandate that we have always observed, the one that I have defended and the one I still defend. That is why we have certain agreements, agreements which work, and that is why we want to maintain them.
But, it goes without saying, we cannot be asked to remain silent when such relevant men in this country, two cardinals, are accusing us of making human rights go back or of ruining democracy with these Laws. We are not going to remain silent and I feel great respect for those who do not agree with the Same-Sex Marriage Law. It goes without saying! I respect it for it is a right granted by the freedom of expression, but there is a place for everything and there is a place for everyone. I wouldn't dare say what the Catholic Church should do so as to improve some of its objectives. I am not going to.
Chairman .- International relationships now. The Ambassador of Morocco is back in Madrid and people would like you to give your opinion about the situation in Latin America; about the populism; the continuity of Castro in Cuba; the forecast concerning primary elections in the U.S.A.; the Summits with the Governments of France and Germany during the next month, which are going to yield interesting results -so it seems-, and also about the fact that the Legislature has come to an end and you haven't held a meeting with the President of the United States, Mr. George Bush.
President .- That is almost everything. It would take a whole debate. Spain occupies a main geopolitical position in the world, which yields great assets, firstly because we are a European country with an innovative, Europeist, active and dynamic profile; secondly, because we have a great heritage, a great mileage, namely, our language, which is growing, which is currently growing more than English in the Internet, in terms of percentages, and which has a great projection in Latin America and in the Mediterranean.
Such a capacity to set up a dialogue in different areas and in different cultures makes us be respected by big countries and admired by emerging and weak countries. This is the position Spain needs to occupy.
Logically enough, Spain must form part of international compromises that promote security; but it must also form part of international compromises that promote peace and aid to cooperation for development.
I haven't said it today, but I am especially proud of having fulfilled my compromise, having made it possible, in 2008, for Spain to set aside 0.05 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product for aid for development, which means that we are helping nearly ten million people all over the world to fight starvation, to get an Education, to reduce poverty and be healthier.
And during the next Legislature we will make it increase to 0.7 per cent, which is a goal that has not been attained by any great economic power yet, and which is not going to be attained by them either; it has only been attained by Nordic countries.
And I dare say: it will be an added value for Spain, as a country, to be placed among those who lead the aid to cooperation for development as far as many policies are concerned. Besides, now I think that we have assumed a very transcendent compromise after the appointment of Mr. Felipe Gonzalez as President of the Reflection Group to design the great objectives of the European Union for the period 2020-2030. I have already said it before and I repeat it today: we should be proud that all Europeans have appointed an ex President of Spain, and besides, it means - let me say this - that the European Union as a whole has a good concept of Spain and feels empathy for us.
Thus, our foreign policy is firmly established and our objectives must be respecting big powers and fulfilling the compromises with collective security, both with those that are trying to grow and develop and wherever there are any difficulties.
It is true, I have not held a meeting with Mr. George Bush. We all know why, but now there seems not to be enough time to make up for that.
Chairman .- To conclude, His Majesty the King will be 70 soon. Would you like to assess the role of King Juan Carlos and the future of the Spanish Monarchy?
President .- The role of King Juan Carlos has been decisive during the last few years. And it is an acting President of the Government, who knows a lot. Thus, I would give him a B+. I'm not giving him an A because it might seem a bit too much. As to the future of Monarchy, I think that it is a solid future.
We have had a Head of State that plays a useful, arbitral and moderating role, that has been able to approach everybody, and that is playing an arbitral role at present. I am deeply convinced of it, and I am positive about it.
Spain needs a Monarchy such as the one that King Juan Carlos has embodied. Besides: as President of the Government, and I should also have enough elements for judgement, I am very confident in the Prince and, thus, about the future.
Chairman .- Thank you very much, President. You know that this Forum remains at your disposal. Just like in 2004, and I hope you will be using it in the future. Thank you very much.