Speech of the President of the Government during the round table on business organised by "The Economist"

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

3 December 2007 · Round table on business organised by "The Economist"

Context
Zapatero addressed The Economist's business round table in December 2007, reviewing Spain's economic achievements and future challenges at the end of his legislature.
Main themes
Spanish economic performance, employment creation, budgetary surplus and fiscal policy, public debt reduction, productivity and competitiveness, investment and innovation, global economic uncertainty, social policy advances, labor market stability, export growth
Duration
~47 min
93rd percentile
Words
5,614
93rd percentile
Sentences
169
85th percentile
Readability
32
20th percentile
Grade
16.6
87th percentile
Syntax
3.40
89th percentile
Vocabulary
2.15
37th percentile
Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 55%55%
  • Social 22%22%
  • Environmental 11%11%
  • Institutional 5%5%
  • Technological 4%4%
  • Ceremonial 2%2%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Not in focus 0%

169 sentences in 89 paragraphs

Good morning.

As in previous occasions, I want to thank "The Economist" for its invitation to take part in this Conference, which has always been marked by the rigor and the seriousness that characterise this magazine internationally.

Time and coincidence make us get to the end of a legislature whose results I would like to assess briefly; but, mainly, I would like to talk about the challenges of the future of Spanish economy, challenges that we are facing, and about the strengths of the Spanish economy in order to keep progressing in the global arena, which in this moment is going through a period of uncertainty.

If we consider the results on the economic growth and its composition together with the employment creation and stability, the situation of the public accounts, the decrease of the debt, the average inflation, the tax reduction and the availability of the Social Security System, then we may claim that this Legislature that is coming to an end is going to be the best one of democracy for economy and social policies.

During this last quarter we have been growing at 3.8 per cent, which is a comparatively high rate; we are growing with a better balance, with less negative contribution of the foreign demand, because exports have grown 8 per cent - which had not happened since 2001 -, and, while investments in construction slow down, investments in equipment goods are growing at 11 per cent. We were looking for this type of change, which strengthens the productive system and makes our growth more sustainable in time.

Employment creation has been the best result of the economic growth. In four years' time, we will have created more than three million jobs, more than Germany, France and the United Kingdom together, and more than any other of the previous Legislatures.

With the employment rate beyond the European average and with an unemployment rate that has reached historical minimum quotas, we can now say that in many regions of Spain there are practically full employment rates.

The advances have benefited in particular those collectives whose situations were worst: women, who have occupied 54 per cent of the new employments; young people, whose unemployment rate has decreased five points, and long-term unemployed persons; and we have become the third country with the lowest level in the European Union in this regard.

The stability of labour has progressed, with a temping rate of two points and a lower average, although it is still too high to be compared with the European Union. The purchase power of salaries has increased 1.2 per cent in 2007; the first advance during the last decade and a half, which is surely linked to the improvement of productivity that has grown 1 per cent in the private sector during the last five quarters, as compared to the stagnation at the beginning of 2004, and 0.8 per cent in the economic area, as a whole, during the last quarter.

We have suffered great increases of the price of oil and, more recently, of certain food products; but, in spite of that increase in the price of oil that we have suffered during the whole Legislature, thanks to the responsible behaviour of businessmen and workers it has been possible to avoid inflationist spirals that would have deteriorated our competitiveness. I am convinced that we will maintain this responsible behaviour now that inflation has surpassed the previous levels and the levels of underlying inflation.

The policy implemented by the Government has guaranteed a stable macroeconomic environment, creating favourable conditions for investments and innovation, and using the tax policy for stabilisation during the whole cycle. The new Law on Budgetary Stability combines stability and efficiency and makes it possible to design a countercyclical tax policy.

Some interpreted that this meant a lassitude of the fiscal criteria, but the results have proved that this interpretation was false. We have reached a surplus every year of the Legislature for the first time in the history of democracy, and last year we attained a historical figure: 1.8 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product. In 2007, let me announce that we will attain a similar figure or even something more; thus, this will be the fourth year with budgetary surplus, with a wide budgetary surplus.

With these results it is evident that the amount saved by the public sector has increased, acquiring an important margin for manoeuvre for the future. By the beginning of the Legislature we set the objective of reducing the public debt concerning the Gross Domestic Product in twelve points, until reaching 34 per cent by 2010; but the rhythm has been even faster, and thus, the aforementioned objective of reaching 34 per cent as far as the debt is concerned is going to be attained by 2008.

Budgetary stability with contention of the public expenditure and, at the same time, and mainly, an increase of the productive expenditure.

The expenditure on Research + Development + Innovation has multiplied by 2.6. The increase in Research, Development and Innovation has been the greatest increase during this period. The expenditure on Education has grown 86 per cent and expenditure on Infrastructures has grown 32.5 per cent and it will surpass 24,000 million Euros in 2008.

We have also progressed in productivity, regulating a better operation of the markets of factors and products and introducing a greater openness in strategic sectors, such as telecommunications, energy, transport and financial services.

The economy is now more competitive as far as the revenues are concerned. The tax reform has progressed towards a simpler system, a more efficient, fair one, in order to incentivise investment and business-related activities. To be prudent, and according to the increasing phase of this cycle, the most outstanding feature is the reduction, in five points, of the general Corporate Tax for the first time in thirty years of democracy.

The excellent evolution of the labour market during 2007 will make it possible to reach a surplus in the Social Security System for the ninth consecutive year and it will also make it possible for the Reserve Fund to have 52,000 million Euros, 4.6 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product, by the end of 2008.

In order to face, in the medium term, the foreseeable demographic changes, we have passed the Law on Measures concerning the Social Security System. Its text, negotiated with the social interlocutors, just as in the case of the rest of the social policies, will enter into force next 1st of January. The incentives for prolonging the working life beyond 65 years of age and the increase of contributiveness will reinforce the financial sustainability of the system.

The surplus in Social Security has made it possible to implement the fair increase of the minimum pensions, which augmented around 34 per cent between 2004 and 2008. Such increase and the increase of non-taxable pensions benefit more than three million persons with a lower income.

Similarly, we have implemented the increase of the minimum salary, which by the 1st of January will amount to 600 Euros per month; the development of the National Dependence System, which will guarantee the health care for more than one million persons; the subsidy of 2,500 Euros per birth or adoption; the Law on Equality, which is making it possible for almost 150,000 parents to use their maternity leaves; the integration of immigrants, whose integration fund has multiplied by 27, and the spread of the rights and aids for hundreds of thousands of Spanish citizens abroad.

Therefore, this Legislature of advances and progress consists of growth, employment, stability and multiple decisions in particular that I have just mentioned with regards to the area of social politics.

Among such policies, and together with the enterprising capacity of workers and with the leadership and the initiative of businessmen, businessmen and managers of the best companies in the world, which turns Spain into an attractive country with a potential for growth, a country with a greater international presence, an attractive country for investors and workers.

We occupy the third position at the OCED through direct investments abroad, only behind the United States and France, and we are in the sixth one in direct investments received, with an average of more than 23,000 million Euros during the last three years.

We are an active country that assumes its decisions and sets forth actions in order to improve competitiveness. The Government is working to develop the National Programme of Reforms for 2010; reforms that involve an important growth in our capital, improvements in the competences and in the regulation, which are already yielding results in terms of more productivity and efficiency.

The improvement of education is also a priority in our project for citizens and for society as a whole. We are acting at an early age and we have increased the schooling rates between zero and three years to 27 per cent. We are acting upon quality and we have set forth support programmes in order to improve it. We are acting to increase the post-obligatory schooling rates.

We are acting in order to form part of the present-day world: we have promoted the study of foreign languages and the use of information and communication technologies. We are acting upon equality and the distribution of opportunities, and we have increased the resources for scholarships and aids for studies in 80 per cent. We are acting upon university and research excellence and we are entering the European Higher Education Space.

But Spanish society is aware, and those who are attending this meeting are aware too, that our main challenge as a country is, of course, to keep on increasing the education rates of our population, especially as far as the percentage of young people with higher studies, after obligatory education, is concerned, and, in particular, as far as the effort for quality in Universities so that we may have a more competitive power at an international level.

I think that it is possible to recognise, objectively, that the R+D system has received an unprecedented impulse during this Legislature, a historical impulse. The action of the Government in this area has been managed, as you know, through the so-called Programa Ingenio 2010 and it has made it possible for investment in R+D regarding the Gross Domestic Product to increase up to 1.2 per cent, which has been the greatest growth over the last fifteen years. We are even far from our goal, but the advance that we have made during this Legislature has been a wide-scope one. Figures speak for themselves: the State budgets amounted to 3,000 million Euros for R+D+i in 2004 and the Budgets for 2008 we will have 7,500 million Euros.

With the Plan Avanza we have multiplied by three the resources of this Legislature for the Information Society, which has allowed us to gain some time, spreading the Information Society to business, homes and, thus, placing our country in a competitive level with regards to our European partners.

Apart from human capital and innovation, the physical capital, the contribution to infrastructures, is another essential point for development and competitiveness. Thus, the current Strategic Plan for Infrastructures and Transport, granted with 250,000 million Euros in fifteen years, will place us at the head of the most developed countries, structuring our territory, guaranteeing its territorial cohesion and implanting other more sustainable means of transport, such as trains and ships. Infrastructures are not going to be a restriction or a hindrance to investment.

I would like to mention the following data: in less than three years, Spain will be the country with more kilometres of High Speed Rails in the world, and in less than three years Spain is going to be the country with more kilometres of dual carriageways and highways in Europe, which represents the great symbolic change of Spanish society in its evolution towards modernity, development and progress.

We have identified climatic change as the main challenge at an international level, our planet, and we have assumed international compromises in this area. The aim is to transform environmental challenges into opportunities.

Nowadays, the most innovative economies and the economies with a greater future are those that turn the challenge of climatic change into the main aim, into the priority of their productive system and of their growth with regards to the way they understand the future in general and the economic future in particular.

We have been able to slow down our growth and to turn our traditional tendency the other way round, reducing the hothouse gas emissions in 4.1 per cent in 2006; 2006, which has been a year of high economic growth, which usually makes it difficult to reduce hothouse gas emissions. This reduction has been possible thanks to an ambitious set of actions in all sectors, which will allow us to save almost the equivalent to one hundred tons of oil and to avoid more than 270 million tons of CO2.

I would like to emphasise the importance of the Plan of Renewable Energies, whose objective is to reach - with regards to those sources - 30 per cent coverage of electricity consumption, by 2010, and, in the case of bio fuels, 5.8 per cent coverage with regards to the total consumption of fuels. Besides, next 1st of January the vehicle tax according to the CO2 emissions will enter into force.

This is not a battle to be fought in the future, but a battle to be fought so that we may have a future. Therefore, it is an urgent battle, and it is not only the Government's responsibility, but also the responsibility of society as a whole.

Let me now talk about the sceneries, the challenges and the strength of our economy in order to face them. The economic results of the last few years have also been conditioned by the new globalisation process, in order to achieve a greater economic global integration. Globalisation has generated a new environment that has given way to new development and knowledge opportunities for our companies and for our workers.

The reduction of taxes and the regional integration agreements have made it possible for international trade to reach 50 per cent of the worldwide produce. The globalisation of financial markets provides the benefits of a great amount of new products.

Our integration in the European and Monetary Union has been essential for our transformation into the eighth greatest economy in the world. Spain has benefited from the structural reduction of the interest types and it has contributed to a greater macroeconomic stability in Europe.

Financial globalisation has made it possible for us to finance our investment rates and reach 31 per cent of the Gross Domestic Product, which can only be compared with the economy of Japan - from among all the developed economies - before the first oil crisis.

Globalisation allows us to increase the employment offer with the arrival of immigrants. It allows our companies to access the biggest markets and to set up and carry out their activities in that greater environment.

As the balance brought forward is so positive, globalisation also makes us face new risks, such as those that we have lived during the last few months. Tensions in the international markets affect us, even though they are originated far away from us.

The confidence of investors has decreased due to the "subprime" mortgage market crisis in the United States and the liquidity of international financial markets has decreased too. Should this liquidity crisis have developed ten years ago, its effects would have been much more harmful. Yet, these effects are limited, asymmetric and localised: limited, because this crisis has a transitory character and its macroeconomic impact will be reduced; asymmetric, because this has not affected all the economies in the same way, and localised because investors have isolated and differentiated the real estate sector in the United States, or the exposal to this sector, as the most relevant risk. To sum up, the liquidity crisis is progressively turning into an each time more localised solvency, which will make it possible to differentiate the economic agents.

The comparative advantage of Spain in order to face this international uncertainty is based upon three pillars: the changes in the growth model, the wide margin of manoeuvre of the budgetary policy and the solidity of our business system and, in particular, given the specific features of the crisis, of the solvency of our banking system.

As I have pointed out before, our growth is each time more balanced. By the end of the previous Legislature, unbalances still existed and they were considerably ones too. Building construction and consumption at home added far too much, the foreign demand showed a growing unbalanced and productive investment was the component of the Gross Domestic Product with a lower growth.

As a result of these policies to promote productivity, we are growing in a more balanced and sustainable way in the long term, and investment in equipment goods is the most dynamic component of the aggregated demand; investments in equipment goods.

Our growth is now based upon factors linked to the offer, to the dynamism of companies, rather than to factors of demand; which yields a more powerful and sustainable profile in the medium term.

This change will also be reflected in the growth of productivity. Thanks, to a great extent, to this advance, it has been able for us to improve our behaviour in the foreign sector, in spite of the continuous appreciation of the Euro and of the increase of the price of oil. Besides, thanks to the growth of productivity the purchasing capacity of salaries is increasing slightly, as has been seen during 2007.

The second pillar is the excellent management of the budgetary policy, which is due, of course, to the work of the Vice President for Economy, Mr. Pedro Solbes to a great extent. The greatest part of the current surplus in public accounts has a structural character. Thus, the question about whether this part of the surplus should be used and in which way is perfectly legitimate.

The use of the surplus is subject to normative limits, established by the Law on Budgetary Stability, and to limits that derive from prudence and common sense.

We have to consider the pressure upon the expenditure that will derive from the ageing of population and we have to put aside the Social Security surplus for the future. We agreed upon this in the Pact of Toledo and it is quite reasonable.

Therefore, the structural surplus is the margin of manoeuvre of the tax policy and the one that may be used according to the principles of economic prudence.

During this Legislature, moderate tax reductions have already been applied and I think that there is still more margin to keep reducing them, although with prudence. We have already lowered, reduced taxes thanks to the measures we have taken for 2008 and for the new Legislature -and according, of course, to the economic circumstances and to prudence -, new tax reductions might be carried out in case, of course, that citizens would give us a majority to govern.

The tax reforming measures must be carried out with prudence, after the adequate analysis and study of the consequences of the public accounts in the economy as a whole, of course, in our pillars of the Welfare State and, of course, in the very convenient and healthy budgetary stability.

We are governing a mature society that is quite aware about the fact that tax policies are an instrument that must be used with prudence and intelligence. Our taxing system, when compared to that of other European countries, is rather reasonable and balanced and it may move forward towards modernisation and, mainly, towards simplification, as specialist usually demand.

There is only one tax that, when considered globally, does not respond to these principles. I mean the Property Increment Tax, which was created to tax non-producing properties and to contribute to the redistribution of richness; although, in time, it has turned into a tax that affects middle classes and not high ones, which have several instruments in order to contribute to the public accounts; thus, high classes find quite easily mechanisms to elude it and, ever since it was transferred, even by means of normative transfer, to the Autonomous Regions, causes an unequal treatment of the Spanish citizens when it comes to taxing, in this moment.

The Government has been considering the conditions of this tax; the relevance of the public income, which amounted to 1,400 million Euros, approximately, by 2005, its utility as far as the tax roll is concerned with regards to the taxable income and to the possibilities to reform it.

This fact, the fact that this Property Increment Tax still exists, for as you know, this tax has been transferred to the Autonomous Regions, it has made it possible for us to establish a compromise in order to analyse the future of the tax itself within the reform of the autonomic financing system.

Yet, this fact, and the considerations attained after many months of analysis and study, make this possible for us, with regards to the Property Increment Tax, a possibility that I hereby announce formally because we are going to cancel it and, therefore, we are going to compensate the Autonomous Regions for any loss in the frame of the new financing model that we will propose next year.

Therefore, I repeat, by the beginning of the next Legislature, one of our first legislative decisions will be the cancellation of the Property Increment Tax. With this, I think that we will enter the group of the European countries in which this tax does not exist, for it exists only in two or three countries and some of them are already proceeding to its cancellation; and we also guarantee that, with regards to the meaning of the normative capacity of the Autonomous Regions with regards to this tax, the equality of Spanish citizens.

You will remember that this tax was created as an extraordinary tax. As it usually happens, this was a complementary tax to the Income Tax, but it ended up becoming useless for the Board of Inland Revenue, for the Treasury to have all the information. The Treasury is provided nowadays with the necessary elements in order to have all the information about the income of our citizens and, therefore, we think that this is a positive message for the modernisation of our tax system; and, doubtlessly, it is also a stimulus in order to prevent the penalisation of saving in this country, for, in fact, it implies -to a great extent- the payment of the Property Increment Tax.

You know that many Autonomous Regions are taking measures with regards to the interest types and even with regards to an eventual possibility to reduce them to zero; but I think that it is fairer, simpler and more rational to cancel it.

Thus, a compromise, the beginning of the next Legislature, the Bill Draft for the cancellation of the Property Increment Tax for all citizens in this country, who amount to one million approximately, mainly from the middle class, and who are paying this tax.

The third pillar of our economy in order to face the international uncertainty is the bank sector. We have highly productive, solvent banks, as can be seen by the outstanding increase of the net attributed benefit, which has surpassed 25 per cent during 2007, or the increase of profitability before taxes upon the total assets. The non-payment level is still much reduced, below the European average, and even the average of business credits has decreased.

There is a slight, very slight increase of the failure to pay among families, which is very inferior to the one that would account for the increase of the interest types implemented by the European Central Bank.

Thus, if it has not increased so much, it is because the increase of the available income of families, the decrease of the unemployment rates and the growth of the benefits of the companies have made up for the effect of the increase of the interest types by far. Thus, as compared to the main developed economies, the current circumstances involve more opportunities than risks for the Spanish corporative sector.

To sum up, ladies and gentlemen, evidence shows an economy with a high rhythm of growth, a more balanced, sustainable one; an economy with more solid bases; an economy with a wide budgetary margin, which is something unheard of throughout our history; an economy with a solvent, efficient financial system and an economy with good grounds in order to face the future with renewed optimism.

In a few decades, Spain has been able to place itself among the most dynamic economies in the world, but this collective success makes us face new challenges. Our model of growth must keep changing in order to have more capacity to converge with Europe. Once we have taken up this road, there is no other chance but keep moving forward in the economy of knowledge and taking up positions in those sectors of a greater added value, within the current worldwide production chains.

We must promote the leadership of business in those sectors with better perspectives for the future. We must look forward to being among those that lead the economic changes, the changes in innovation, the social and environmental changes that are going to take place in the world.

We must keep on making an effort in infrastructures and reducing the administrative charges of the economic activities, and let me tell you that this is not easy, taking into account the inertia of Administrations in general, also in the case of the General State Administration too.

We must provide ourselves with better human and technological capital, we must respect the environment and provide citizens with the greater welfare and quality of life, improving their health and promoting the sustainability of the effects of ageing.

Spain is taking part in the pervading ageing process in all the industrialised economies that will become even sharper during the next few decades. The vital cycles of citizens are modified, the entrance in the market is delayed, life expectancy increases and the number of years for retirement is extended.

The social protection structures are directly influenced by all these changes and they need to be constantly adapted to the new reality. But we must look forward to guaranteeing and improving the economic situation of citizens after their retirement. And at the same time, as we have one of the highest absolute life expectancies in the world, our objective is to increase the life expectancy without disabilities. In order to achieve it, we must devote more resources to research in order to prevent and treat diseases, as well as to the public health systems, and we must be provided with a powerful system of attention for dependent citizens, as the one we have set forth, which is going to mean a qualitative change in our Welfare State.

During this Legislature we have set up the foundations of the National Dependence System. The full development of its benefits, which have already benefitted one hundred and thousand citizens, will improve -considerably- the daily life of those persons and will provide support to their caretakers and families, just as a socially active policy as far as harmonisation of working and family life are concerned.

The policy in favour of dependent persons and families is also a good contribution to the capacity and to the potential of our population in order to contribute to economic growth and education. Certain social policies, if they are adequately oriented, do not take up richness, they produce richness instead.

Another great challenge that we are facing is that of environmental sustainability, which must be present in all the actions and decisions of a responsible Government, with a capacity to anticipate the future and to understand in which areas will great decisions and great challenges be relevant. It is necessary to make economic growth and the fight against climatic change compatible.

The combustion of the energetic resources causes 80 per cent of the hothouse gas emissions, and thus we must used more advanced technologies and more respectful with the environment too.

Among the main sectors that consume energy we find transport and construction. Thus, it is necessary to develop more efficient transport modalities, with a lower environmental impact, sustainable mobility plans, train corridors and highways in the sea, and we also have to extend the use of bio fuels and improve their quality. It is also necessary to apply the criteria of energetic efficiency in the case of newly built houses, for they have already been established in the Technical Code of Construction for the newly built houses, and to promote the reform, the reconversion of those that are already built, by means of a stimulus provided by the public sector, which will make all this process of renovation possible, a renovation of the residential environment as far as energy consumption is concerned.

The challenge of this energetic change that we need must be considered a great chance to improve our competitiveness and to promote the research of new ways to generate clean energy. Our companies are worldwide leaders in renewable energies and we must take advantage of this comparative benefit from which we start.

This might be the first time -when facing a change of the foundations of the economic process- that our companies are worldwide leaders in the leading, protagonist sector. We have the knowledge and we must achieve higher levels of investment in R+D, so as to open up new ways to the development of more efficient technologies; but, I repeat it, the most innovating technologies, those that will generate more added value, those that will provide new sources of employment, will be the ones that do not use coal and that are able to incorporate a higher percentage of alternative, renewable energies in their energetic plan, with a highly innovating component and in Research and Development.

We must acquire a compromise and exert our leadership in the fight against climatic change and also in the case of an important global challenge, namely, the improvement of social cohesion in the world. Poverty is one of the most serious problems that threat the governability of the planet in different regions. Thus, for the next Legislature, Spain has acquired the compromise to attain the objective of devoting 0.7 percent of the National Gross Income to the Official Aid for Development, anticipating the international compromises.

In order to face all these challenges we need our human capital to be adequately prepared. This is the moment of the history of our country in which Spain must firmly support the development of personal talent so that our citizens may compete in equal conditions with the citizens of those countries that have the best educational systems, so as to share the global knowledge, so that our companies may invest in R+D+i and may compete in design, technology and productivity and so that the brand Spain may become a synonym of quality in all the international markets.

Our aim is to place our youngsters side by side with those youngsters in leading countries as far as basic skills such as reading, mathematics or the deductive capacity are concerned. We must create an attractive professional training, in order to motivate a significant number of students so that they may cover the need for qualified staff in our society. The essential objective of the Spanish society in the next few years is to make four out of five young people keep studying after the obligatory cycle, that is to say, Secondary Teaching or the equivalent Professional Training.

We must form part of the avant-garde of science and technology, which has always posed great difficulties to Spain. We will try to provide our university and research system with the adequate resources and incentives in order to reach these objectives. We will make our best in order to turn research into a more attractive career, as it has been a traditionally forgotten career in Spain and it has practically been ignored by a great part of society. It is absolutely necessary for university teaching to meet the needs of our society, training professionals that may also develop their enterprising capacities and their innovating spirit too.

Spain has walked a long way in just a few decades, and I think we can state this. There might not be an example of the change that has taken place in Spanish society over these last twenty five or thirty years.

Fortunately, we have walked quite a consistent distance during this Legislature that is now coming to an end. We have attained good results that make it possible for us to place ourselves among the first positions in order to achieve progress and welfare quotas that may be compared to those of the most developed countries.

The priorities for the next few years are, from my point of view, increasing welfare and reaching, definitively, full employment rates in Spain; turning our country into an economy of knowledge fully compromised with research, development, innovation and the fight against climatic change; and improving, for there is still a long way to go, the best institutional operativeness for the economic area. Of course, all this forms part of the attempt to improve the best co-existence in our society, among the citizens of this great country that, let me say this with determination, is moving forward, at the beginning of the 21st century, in the best conditions of its contemporary history.

Thank you very much.