Press conference of the President of the Government after the European Union-Africa Summit.

Spain José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero · Prime Minister of Spain

8 December 2007 · EU-Africa Summit · Lisbon, Portugal

Context
Zapatero addressed press at the EU-Africa Summit in Lisbon on December 8, 2007, reporting on summit outcomes and bilateral meetings.
Main themes
EU-Africa Summit, Africa development, Millennium Development Goals, irregular immigration, Spain-Africa cooperation, legal migration flows, EU political and ethical responsibility, West Africa investment, training and employment programs, bilateral meetings, collective failure of illegal immigration, infrastructure development
Duration
~33 min
85th percentile
Words
3,963
85th percentile
Sentences
142
79th percentile
Readability
40
35th percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.09
25th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

142 sentences in 54 paragraphs

President.- Good morning. I want to inform you about the development of the EU-Africa Summit that we are holding here in Lisbon. I will first provide a general assessment and then give some specifics regarding the bilateral meetings I held yesterday and today.

First of all, I wanted to convey an opinion that is part of a very deep conviction: I believe this is one of the most important Summits that the European Union has held in its history. It has been seven years since Europe and Africa sat down together to dialogue, to share, and to seek ways to build a different relationship that must have as its fundamental objective the development of Africa, the overcoming of so many inequalities and situations of despair, and therefore, opening opportunities for millions and millions of citizens of Africa. In doing so, Europe acquires greatness, political greatness and ethical greatness.

You have heard me say on some occasions that Europe is the richest continent and that Europe is the continent of democracy; but, moreover, Europe must be the best continent. The European Union is better if it dedicates political, economic, and diplomatic efforts to ensure that those who have fewer opportunities have more opportunities in the future and for their peoples.

As you know, in the development of the EU-Africa Summit, I have highlighted two basic ideas. The first of these relates to the need for the European Union as a whole, and each country individually, to be demanding of itself in fulfilling the part that corresponds to it in achieving the Millennium Development Goals. The greatest manifestation of the fulfillment of these Millennium Development Goals is in Africa.

Spain has been making a great effort for three long years, nearly four years. Perhaps it is the country in the European and Western world that has made the most effort in the shortest time in relation to Africa and the fulfillment of the Millennium Development Goals. I want to give you just one figure: our aid for cooperation in Africa has increased from five hundred million euros to one billion five hundred million euros that it will be in 2008. We have tripled our effort in fulfilling the Millennium Development Goals. That should be the trend for all European countries and for the European Union.

Secondly, as you know, at the Summit I have referred specifically to the phenomenon of immigration, and especially to irregular immigration. Irregular immigration is a great collective failure. Those who are most harmed by illegal immigration are those people and those young people who, as a result of despair and the absence of hope, often try, many times with the criminal hand of mafia organizations, to carry out the attempt to immigrate irregularly, illegally, which often ends in a penalty.

I have proposed that there be a great Europe-Africa agreement on immigration, to combat irregular immigration, starting from the collective failure that it represents and assuming that we will only be truly effective in stopping irregular immigration if we provide opportunities for young people in Africa, if we invest in education, in work, and in infrastructure.

I believe I can speak with the example of what Spain has been doing in recent years. I want to remind you that at this moment, as a result of that increase that triples our aid for cooperation in Africa, we are mobilizing, to address that collective failure that is illegal immigration, two essential lines of work. The first of these is a reorganization of legal migration flows, which has had an initial manifestation in Senegal and will have other concrete manifestations; we have just had a meeting with the leaders of Mali in that direction so that there are defined quotas for young people from African countries, especially from West Africa, from Sub-Saharan Africa, who can legally emigrate to work in the needs of our country.

This entails, at the same time, increasing, as I said, the possibilities of employment and expectations. Therefore, we are developing a broad program of training schools that is, without a doubt, a great focus for promoting employment and self-employment. We have thirteen training schools underway in West Africa; the first of them will be launched in Mali, along with an ambitious infrastructure program in which we will concentrate many of the financial efforts that are decisive for the possibilities, in certain geographical areas, of generating economic activity, maintaining it, and recovering it, and therefore, expectations of employment.

Broadly speaking, those are the two main lines we are working on, the result of this political effort that Spain is developing like never before in its history in Africa. Spain has been a country that traditionally only looked at Africa in its first line of relationship, to North Africa, and that has historically been absent from everything that represents West Africa, East Africa, and of course, Southern Africa. The effort has materialized in that in these three long years we have opened six embassies in Africa (Sudan, Mali, Niger, Cape Verde, Guinea Conakry, and Guinea Bissau), thus deploying political potential and political relations that are yielding enormously positive results.

Europe must be aware, as I have claimed, that, to a large extent, the future of its wealth and the balance in the international order will depend on the future of Africa. The future of Africa is not just the future of Africans; it is the future of all humanity and, therefore, of Europeans. This is the conclusion, for me, the most important of this Summit.

As I was saying, I have also had an intense day of bilateral meetings. I will list them and then refer specifically to the bilateral Summit with France that I held yesterday. I have held bilateral meetings with France; Senegal; Mauritania; Chad; Turkey; Algeria; Nigeria; Angola; Guinea Conakry; Guinea Bissau; and Mali; all of them priority countries for Spanish cooperation and all of them countries that are crucial for good management of immigration and for controlling irregular immigration. And I can certify that with all of them there is a high degree of political relationship, trust, and capacity to work together, which is being demonstrated in a very significant number of examples regarding the management of immigration itself.

I will now make a special reference to the bilateral Summit that I held yesterday with President Sarkozy, a meeting that we had agreed upon two days earlier in our telephone conversation following the arrests of the ETA members who are allegedly responsible for the criminal attack that cost the lives of two civil guards, Raúl and Fernando.

First of all, we have more than gratitude to France for its collaborative attitude; we have a permanent debt to France for its collaboration in the fight against terrorism, in the fight against ETA. I must express that President Sarkozy conveyed to me his determination to carry collaboration with Spain in the fight against ETA and in the defense of the freedom and democratic rights that the terrorist group seeks to threaten to the fullest extent.

We have studied the current situation of collaboration, the frameworks and angles in which that collaboration occurs, essentially in the police realm, in the realm of the respective police forces, and we have agreed to implement a new model that represents a permanent joint investigation team against terrorism in both countries and that comes to complete and expand the practice that we have been developing so far under European regulations of joint investigations for specific criminal acts. Now we are going to build a permanent joint investigation team for everything that represents the prevention and fight against ETA terrorism. It is a further step, an important qualitative step, that will certainly yield results.

Even so, I must remind you that at this moment the absolute priority of the State Security Forces and Corps, both in Spain and in France, is the capture of the third author responsible for what was the vile murder, the tragic attack, that cost the lives of two civil guards. I can assure you that this is the priority objective, and I can assure you that he will fall, and behind him many more activists, terrorists, members of the ETA group will fall.

That is the determination, and the terrorists know very well, and the Spanish public must know, that this absolute will of the two governments, of the two countries, is one of the greatest guarantees for being as effective as possible in collective security and, of course, in the pursuit of those who intend to attack and who intend to violate such sacred and inviolable rights in democracy as the right to life and the freedom of individuals.

From here, I am sure there will be many questions that may be of interest to you.

Q.- Mr. President, I would like a clarification regarding the meeting with Sarkozy. I would like to know if the information they have provided indicates that this third fugitive is the material author of the shots against the two civil guards and if it is suspected that, being the material author, he could be a high-ranking member of the terrorist group.

President.- That falls into the realm of hypotheses that, in the strictly professional field, in the work that the Spanish and French police are very well evaluating. But President Sarkozy did not convey to me any assertion regarding either of your two questions, neither regarding who the material author may be, nor regarding the identity of the third member of ETA, who is currently on the run, and on whom, of course, all efforts are concentrated for his capture and presentation to Justice. It is a task that corresponds to the State Security Forces and Corps, in this case to judicial action, and we must wait for the conclusions that both the police and the Justice system will reach.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted you to explain something that I do not quite understand. Europe and the West give donations to Africa. Specifically, China has just signed a multimillion-dollar contract with Congo for a loan in exchange for mineral wealth. In other words, all the wealth of Congo is already committed to China. Are Europeans and the West already late in arriving, and yet we have heard all kinds of criticisms from African leaders against Europe for these donations? They may prefer, perhaps, the loan. Can you explain this matter to me?

President.- I explain to you that I have heard quite different things, because I can assure you that all the countries with which Spain maintains intense and growing development cooperation are extraordinarily grateful and want that support. One of the examples that I had yesterday, which you know has a high significance for me, is the gratitude that the President of Chad conveyed to me regarding the education program to finance the education of fifty thousand children in his country, which has, from my point of view, a great social impact.

Europe is the largest contributor to the development of Africa, and Africa has the potential to increase and accelerate that development. The formulas cannot be only development aid. Development aid is essential because there are many needs (for education, for health...), but we must help to produce. That means infrastructure; it means training schools; it means teaching how to work agriculture more profitably; it means technology transfer; it means the possibility of return for many immigrants who are qualified young people who would be essential in their countries, and it means acting on many fronts, also through loans, as Europe undoubtedly does.

The relationship between Europe and Africa in historical terms is a relationship that you know has had difficult moments. To a large extent, a large part of Africa, of African countries, are the fruits of processes of independence and decolonization in relation to European countries. That is history; no one is going to change it, but we can change the future and, of course, the present.

And today, Europe, being the continent with the most economic potential, with the most potential for development aid and with the most technological potential, can do a great job for the development of Africa. However, it must be done with Africa, in a dialogue that represents partnership, that represents cooperation and not simply talking about Africa or having a compassionate feeling towards Africa. No, there must be a constructive feeling with Africa, valuing its advances, demanding changes where serious problems arise from the point of view of coexistence and human rights; but above all, dialoguing constructively between two parties, between two great continents.

Q.- Mr. President, returning to yesterday's statements and Spain's proposal to curb illegal immigration, it seems that it has not been well received, at least in front of Libya, which acted as the spokesperson for the southern part, so to speak. So, is this harmony quite widespread or do you feel that way after your meetings yesterday with the rest of the African countries?

And then, in contrast to this, what does Europe ask of Africa to do its part to curb the phenomenon of immigration?

President.- I insist again, yesterday there was a statement from the President of Senegal, which is one of the reference countries with the most problems of irregular immigration, regarding Spain's policy. He was eloquent, forceful, and I have directly confirmed with this large number of Presidents and Prime Ministers that the model of cooperation that Spain is putting in place is the useful model and the model that African countries want.

Regarding President Gaddafi's statements, I believe that President Gaddafi makes a very general speech, without specifically addressing the elements that currently compromise the phenomenon of irregular immigration more directly, and, of course, with many historical appeals that I have already referred to earlier. We cannot change the past, but we can change the present and future of Africa, and for that, this Summit is extraordinarily important, and even more important is that the plan we deploy for three years is fulfilled, and that in three years Europe and Africa can sit down and say "this has changed," and that all the symptoms of that change are positive symptoms of trust, progress, and development.

Of course, Spain is going to work hard. I insist, without an Africa, without an African continent with possibilities, the world will have many more risks, and Europe, undoubtedly, in a singular way.

Q.- Mr. President, in Africa, every day, tens of thousands of children die unnecessarily due to a lack of preventive health measures. There were promises to help solve the diseases that affect, above all, small children, and now there have been more promises to meet the Millennium Goals and others. How can African children know or have hope that these will actually be fulfilled and that their lives will be different?

President.- Yesterday in my speech, I expressed that the European Union, and not only the European Union, but all developed countries, should engage in self-criticism regarding the degree of compliance with the Millennium Goals and some other commitments, as referenced in the question. Precisely, if I made that assessment in favor of self-criticism, it is because Spain is fulfilling its objectives, tripling development aid, and we have the horizon of being the country that, among the eight major industrial powers of the world, where we are, will be number one in development aid, cooperation, and, of course, in Africa. But I agree that there have been many occasions when commitments have not been met, and, of course, by European countries.

Q.- Mr. President, I wanted to return to the topic of the bilateral meeting with France, to the joint working team that has been decided to create. Within the caution, I would like you to provide some more details; for example, who will be in charge of this team in France, whether it will be the French Ministry of the Interior; if, for example, agents in both countries can carry weapons, and, for example, if another of the things that has also been discussed is that in this joint team, Spanish agents will spend less time in France or... Could you provide us with any details of this kind?

President.- I can only, for reasons of prudence, answer the first of your questions. The joint permanent investigation team is strictly situated within the realm of the police, and as far as the Ministry of the Interior of Spain is concerned, the responsibility lies with the Secretary of State for Security. In France, it will logically be the authority or responsibility that they determine.

The operational characteristics that this joint team represents, from all points of view, must remain, for obvious reasons, within the realm of discretion, out of respect for the work they do, for security, and for the effectiveness in the fight against terrorists.

Q.- Insisting a bit on my colleague's question, I would simply like to know if there are changes in the way of operating or working of the teams compared to how they worked previously.

A second question, when does the Government estimate that ANV can be illegalized? It seems that all mechanisms are in motion.

And a third question: can you provide any information about the two Spanish sailors who are detained in Mauritania?

President.- I will not make any assessment regarding the means and methods that the joint investigation team will use. I want to emphasize that we must have the utmost confidence in the work carried out by the State Security Forces and Corps, which both governments, that of France and that of Spain, want to work with the utmost guarantees and maximum security, and that also this area I believe is perfectly understandable requires prudence, prudence, and more prudence.

Secondly, I have recently referred to the situation of ANV. I want to reiterate that the work of the Police, the Civil Guard, the Prosecutor's Office, and the State Attorney's Office, in what concerns the Executive's area of responsibility, is a work that is progressing regarding the legal situation of ANV; we must be aware that there is also an investigation work that is strictly within the realm of Justice, of the National Court, which has been ongoing for some time and that the analyses that arise from the data will determine the decision. There is no deadline. The deadline is the application of the Law, and the decision will depend, logically, on what the facts conclude based on what our legal system establishes.

Finally, regarding the two sailors who are in Mauritania, I must say that their situation is good. As you know, they will testify tomorrow, they are not detained, and I am confident that tomorrow we can have a definitive resolution of the situation, in which, logically, our diplomacy is working, also coinciding with the fact that yesterday we were practically meeting with Mauritania when the news broke, and we have made, logically, the appropriate and logical efforts. But I am confident that there will be a quick and positive resolution.

Q.- Mr. President, the European Union is preparing a military humanitarian mission for Chad, and for many weeks this mission has not been able to start because some helicopters are missing. Is this mission in difficulty? Is it possible for Spain to help provide these helicopters, this material that is always needed?

President.- Whenever a military humanitarian mission is organized, logically gathering all operational needs and all means requires a difficult effort. I must say that Spain currently has no forecast. It has commitments in many other parts of the world in similar missions, which practically exhaust our operational capabilities. There is no forecast. We are always willing to make efforts in the humanitarian field, but as of today, we do not have a forecast regarding Chad.

Q.- President, I wanted to ask you regarding the permanent investigation team. It is understood, from what you have said, that this team will have its headquarters in Paris and Madrid. The question is: will this permanent coordination team involve any type of coordination at the political or higher level, also permanent? In some way, does this not mean that even the decision-making scope of counter-terrorism policy will be more shared, that is, it will be shared with France and Spain will lose a certain autonomy?

President.- It implies expanding capabilities, it implies expanding means, it implies expanding personnel, and it implies, indeed, a permanent coordination, not only in response to a specific event but also having a disposition for day-to-day, minute-to-minute work in the fight against terrorism. This means, it should mean, more effectiveness and more strength, and it also means, logically, more effort from both the Government of France and the Government of Spain.

Q.- I would like to know what you expect from the new relationship that is going to be initiated with Angola and if you confirm the statements of the Spanish Minister of Industry and Commerce a few weeks ago that Spain wants to surpass China in investments in Angola. Do you confirm this? If it were true, would this initiative in Angola be extended to other African countries?

President.- I cannot confirm that news regarding that statement. In any case, I do want to emphasize that Spain wants to have an extraordinarily positive relationship with Angola, to help overcome all difficulties, to guarantee its stability, and also, because it has been part of our relationship, what development cooperation represents.

Q.- President, you have spoken of an ambitious infrastructure program in Africa. I wanted to know if you could quantify this program and know which countries it was intended for.

You also mentioned that, in the case of Mali, a workshop school would be opened and there would be a quota program. I wanted to know if this quota program for young people and this system of workshop schools would be repeated in any of the other countries with which you have met.

President.- Yes, the infrastructure program is currently in the phase of elaboration, preparation, determination, and fixing of its financing. The essential area of action for the infrastructures will be West Africa, sub-Saharan Africa. It will affect some countries more significantly, such as Senegal, Guinea Conakry, Mali, and a few others. I believe that we will be in a position in the coming weeks to present what the plan represents, which affects both railway infrastructure and road infrastructure, as well as infrastructure, let’s say, in the rural area or rural roads for some countries. It will be known. In some cases, there will be direct intervention by Spanish Government agencies, from the Central Administration, in the realm of the Ministry of Development; in others, there will be financing for private initiatives. It will be known in all its extent.

As I mentioned, the workshop school program, in which we have placed great confidence, encompasses thirteen workshop schools. Indeed, the first one to be put into operation is in Mali, and I confirm that, just as is happening with Senegal and will happen with Mali, where we have already announced today that there will be an offer to that country for work in the area of strawberry harvesting, more specifically, it can be extended to other countries. Every time we channel legal immigration, we are reducing the horror, the tragedy, and the unacceptable nature of irregular and illegal immigration, which we have all seen, which we all suffer from, and which we all reject so forcefully when we see what happens on the coasts of the Canary Islands.

Q.- Is there any agreement to participate in the entry into force of the economic partnership agreements? Has an agreement been reached at the Summit?

President.- We are about to conclude an agreement in that direction.

Thank you very much.