Speech By Senior Minister Lee Kuan Yew At The Nikkei'S Future Of Asia Conference On 19 May 1995, Tokyo
Lee Kuan Yew · Senior Minister of Singapore
- Context
- Lee addressed the Nikkei's Future of Asia Conference in Tokyo on May 19, 1995, urging Japan to deregulate, open its markets and lead trade liberalisation in East Asia through APEC ahead of the Osaka meeting.
- Main themes
- Opening of Japan's markets, East Asian responsibility for free trade, Japanese deregulation and restrictive regulations, US-Japan trade dispute on autos and autoparts, strong yen and Japanese competitiveness, Japanese corporate restructuring and overseas production, Japanese investment and infrastructure finance in East Asia, APEC and the Osaka meeting, Japan as bridge between East and West, Japanese political leadership and bureaucracy
- Duration
- ~29 min
- Words
- 3,474
- Sentences
- 203
- Readability
- 43
- Grade
- 11.4
- Syntax
- 2.88
- Vocabulary
- 2.31
Source: National Archives of Singapore ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other203 sentences in 71 paragraphs
Introduction
The world’s free trading regime under the General Agreement on Tariffs and Trade (GATT) has enabled East Asian nations to grow rapidly. Their exposure to international trade has risen. East Asia’s exports rose by an average 10 per cent per annum in the last one-and-a-half decades, twice the rate of growth of trade elsewhere. According to the World Trade Organisation (WTO), nine East Asian nations are today among the top 25 exporters in the world.
Thailand and Indonesia made it into the league last year.1
The nine East Asian countries, ranked in decreasing importance, are Japan (3), Hong Kong (8), China (11), Singapore (12), South Korea (13), Taiwan (14), Malaysia (19), Thailand (23) and Indonesia (25). [World Trade Organisation press release, 28 March ‘95.]
East Asia’s stake in global trade requires it to undertake greater responsibility for keeping markets open. East Asian countries should not be seen as free riders, abusing the generosity of the industrialised world. The US and Europe will no longer tolerate mercantilist practices that stress exports and restrict imports.
Japan, more than any East Asian country, has the biggest stake in open markets. Japan benefited the most from open trade. Japanese exports, especially to the US, pay for Japan’s essential imports of raw materials and provide the engine for Japan’s rapid growth. It is in Japan’s interests to promote freer trade, both in the region and in the world.
Trade liberalisation in East Asia would not amount to much without Japan leading the way. Japan accounts for more than half of the region’s surplus with US and three-quarters of that with the European Union (EU). Japan also has trade surpluses with the rest of East Asia. These rose by an average of 25 per cent per year since 1986.
US pressure on Japan to open up could become ugly. A White House spokesman said on 15 May 1995 that over time, the inability to resolve a major disagreement in the area of trade could become an impediment to realising the full value of fruitful and productive relationships. Another US official said that it could in time have a corrosive effect. Japan would be short-sighted to continue its tacts of exhausting negotiations before yielding minimal concessions. A US that finds itself frustrated in Asia could look to Europe instead. The US already has in place trans-Atlantic institutions in defence, security and politics, and could extend such institutions into economic areas. Several US and EU officials have recently proposed a “new economic structure” between EU and the North American Free Trade Area (NAFTA). Japan risks serious deterioration in bilateral relations with the US if it persists with its current practices. Such deterioration must eventually affect the US-Japan Security Alliance. So Japan must weigh its trading interests against its need for an indispensable US counterweight to a China growing in weight and influence, and a Russia which is still well-armed but unstable.
Japan’s opening-up is not just an obligation it owes to the US and its other trading partners. Economic deregulation and market opening will promote Japan’s domestic restructuring and make Japanese firms more competitive.
As the largest and richest economy in Asia2 and the current chairman of the Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC), Japan is the key player, one which can set the pace of trade liberalisation. By leading the APEC initiative for freer trade, Japan can push the world towards a better trading order, a world which through increasing trade, will increase interdependence between nations and prosperity for all. If Japan re-examines its past strategy, its leaders must recognise that conditions have changed so fundamentally that they have to break the mould of the last 50 years. That strategy which was designed to maximise exports and minimise imports had served Japan well, but will now limit Japan’s role and damage its growth.
Opening up Japan
There is nothing wrong with the current account surpluses as such.
Britain, in the 19th century, and West Germany before reunification, ran large account surpluses. Japan’s current account surpluses allow it to invest abroad, and to finance deficits in the rest of the world.
Japan’s economy accounts for two-thirds of the region’s Gross Domestic Product (GDP) [37 per cent in PPP terms], and one-third of the region’s total trade in 1993.
The issue is Japan’s restrictive trade practices and closed markets.
Japan’s imports account for six per cent of its consumption of manufactured goods, compared to 16 per cent for the US and 15 per cent for Germany.
Japan has more than 11,000 regulations covering about 40 per cent of the economy. They include price stabilisation systems, price support policies, the Staple Food Control Act (which blocks rice imports), and the Large Scale Retail Store Act (which restricts the opening of large stores). Self-service gas stations, commonplace in most countries, are not allowed in Japan. Regulations restrict competition. Excessive licensing for retailing products and rigid testing and customs procedures hinder imports. A retail licence for one item requires 10 to 70 pieces of documentation. On an average, for 20 pieces of documentation per item, in order to retail 30 products, a supermarket will have to file 600 forms. As a result, retail prices in Japan are one-third higher than those in other Organisation of Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) countries3.
However, there are hopeful signs of liberalisation and deregulation.
Discount stores are bypassing Japan’s labyrinth distribution system and are setting lower retail prices, which have led to “price destruction” in Japan.
Consumers are paying lower prices for orange juice, imported beef and canned Economic Planning Agency, 1993 Price Report.
beer, because import restrictions have been lifted. Dalel, Japan’s largest retailer, now supplies imported 100 per cent orange juice at less than half the price of locally produced (mandarin) orange juice. Last year, Japan rescinded its 52- year old Staple Food Control Act, lifting the rice import ban.
To continue regulations to restrict trade will set Japan apart from the rest of the world and will reinforce the “Japan is unique” phenomenon. This will cost Japan dearly.
I believe that after Japan has completely deregulated and liberalised trade, US trade deficits will still continue to be large, as long as US savings remain low and budget deficits continue to be large. But that is a different problem and will concern the US but not Japan.
Why Japan Must Open Up
Deregulation will boost competition and raise productivity. Some of Japan’s highly regulated industries - agriculture, transportation and utilities - lag behind the US in productivity by 60 - 80 per cent. The Economic Planning Agency (EPA) estimates that if Japan closes its productivity gap with the US within five years, Japan’s gross domestic product will increase by an additional eight per cent4.
Deregulation will also stimulate domestic investments. Changing Japan’s archaic land zoning regulations will boost private investment in redevelopment and construction. At the same time, the Japanese government can expand public investments in infrastructure, in the manner the Maekawa report had recommended5.
Perhaps the most important reason for deregulation is that it will relieve the upward pressure on the yen. The strong yen is the result of Japan’s persistent current account surpluses. Exchange rate intervention by central banks alone cannot suffice to stem the yen’s appreciation. Greater deregulation and more imports will.
This strong yen will erode Japanese competitiveness. The big manufacturers have moved and are moving overseas. About 1,400 smaller Economic Planning Agency, Raku-ichi Rakuza Kenkyuu-kai Tyuu-kan Hookoku (“Raku-ichi Rakuza Study Group Interim Report”), October 1994 Following the Plaza Accord in 1995, former Prime Minister Nakazone commissioned then Governor Maekawa of the Bank of Japan to come up with recommendations to cope with realignment of the yen. The Maekawa Report businesses collapsed in the month of March this year, a nine-year high6.
Unemployment is rising.
The answer is to deregulate and open up Japan’s economic structure.
Japan must move up continuously into higher-tech, knowledge-intensive industries, as some companies have done. Canon survived the high yen (“endaka”) after the Plaza Accord with its production of the laser printer; its pioneer bubble jet printers will see it through the present yen appreciation7. But increasingly, the growth industries are in the service sector such as information networks and telecommunications8.
proposed that the Japanese government stimulate domestic demand through increasing public investments. Figure from Teikoku Data bank, a credit research agency cited in Financial Times, 18 April 1995. Canon has a dominant 60 per cent share of the world laser printer market and is now competing with Hewlett Packard for the top spot in bubble jet printers. It has been estimated that if the weight of Japan’s telecommunications industry’s production to GDP, 1.4 per cent in 1991, grows to the same level as that of the US, which is 2.7 per cent to G, an additional six trillion yen of production can be generated by the industry. (Source: Economic Planning Agency) Competition and economic deregulation are not new to Japan. In sixteenth century Japan, the regional Lord Oda Nobunaga abolished monopolies and established free market mechanisms in Osaka9. Present-day Japan can learn from this. Nobugana’s so-called “open-market arrangement” (“raku-ichi, rakuza”) has in fact become the Economic Planning Agency’s slogan to rally support for deregulation10.
Corporate Japan’s Response
Corporate Japan has concluded that deregulation and restructuring are necessary and inevitable. Therefore the Keldanren has actively lobbied the Japanese government for deregulation. Japan’s corporate leaders know that its trade policies have alienated many thoughtful American friends of Japan.
Nobunaga eliminated the guilds (za) which had been used by such traditional wielders of power as temples, shrines and the aristocrats to maintain their monopolistic control over commerce. In their place, he supported open-market arrangements (raku-ichi, rakuza) that enabled people to engage freely in the production and sale of goods. He also abolished in many areas the checkpoints (sekisho) that had hindered free flow of goods, thus establishing the early modern commercial market. The EPA has formed a high-level research committee called “Raku-ichi Rakuza Study Group” consisting of academics, and senior executives of selected Japanese corporations to study the issue of deregulation in Japan.
Japan’s overseas production ratio at six per cent is still low compared to 28 per cent for the US; however, the ratio in many product lines is far higher.
Two-thirds of Japanese colour TVs and microwave ovens are now made abroad while fewer cars are exported to the US than are assembled there11.
The recent yen appreciation will accelerate this trend. Sony has moved 42 per cent of its output overseas and is now aiming for 50 per cent12. Japanese manufacturers are preparing to move even their higher-end activities offshore.
For example, Matsushita is making its surface mount technology machines outside Japan, in Singapore. Singapore will replace Japan as the manufacturer for this model worldwide.
Even the keiretsu system is no longer sacred. Japan’s oldest corporate networks are learning to do business with foreign partners. From Toyota to Toshiba, Japanese keiretsu manufacturers are increasingly turning to lower cost foreign parts makers. Toyota, for example, is buying its antilock brake systems from General Motors.
Financial Times, 28 March 1995. New York Times, 18 April 1995
To keep ahead in the technology race, some Japanese corporations have engaged in technology sharing in order to cut costs. Fujitsu has joined up with Hyundai to share know-how, reattach costs and even some production capacity for a new range of products. Such an agreement would have been unthinkable a few years ago. More recently, Toshiba teamed up with Samsung to develop advanced semiconductors [64-megabyte flash memory chips].
These developments illustrate the ability of Japanese corporations to adapt and move with the times. Time and again, this Japanese ability to change, adjust and adopt has saved Japan.
Regional Initiatives in East Asia
The time has come for Japan to take the lead in regional initiatives.
After World War Two, America presided over the building of the key multilateral institutions - GATT, IMF (International Monetary Fund) and the World Bank. It helped to shape the multilateral trading system which has given the world and East Asia unprecedented growth and prosperity. Now it is Japan’s turn to lead. But before Japan can lead, it must set the example and open up its own markets.
I am confident that as Japan deregulates, its corporate sector will innovate and move up into higher value-added activities, including services. I am also sure that Japan will integrate the region’s economies with Japan’s through investments, technology transfers and trade.
In the last decade, Japan’s trade with East Asia has risen two times faster than its trade with the rest of the world. Japanese foreign direct investment (FDI) in East Asia has risen at a time when its total investment worldwide declined. A recent survey by Japan’s EXIM Bank predicted that, over the coming three years, three quarters of Japan’s new FDI will go to Asia.
The strong yen will be a powerful driving force behind this wave of Japanese FDI. The Japanese economy will undergo a challenging and difficult adjustment period. But the strong yen gives Japan powerful advantages. Imports of oil and raw materials quoted in US dollars are cheaper. And it is much cheaper for Japanese companies to acquire foreign assets and increase their stakes in Asia. There is considerable scope for an expansion of Japanese investments in Asia. About 16 per cent of Japan’s stock of FDI is in East Asia today. This compares with 44 per cent in North America and 20 per cent in Europe. Conversely, the devalued dollar makes it expensive for Americans to invest abroad. The strong yen therefore enables Japan to pre-empt American and European investors in moving into key sectors and securing market share in East Asia.
Japan’s role as a capital exporter is a key factor for economic growth in East Asia. East Asia excluding Japan now has an approximately balance in savings and investment. The region will be a net borrower in the coming years13.
The surpluses of the newly industrialised economies (NIEs) will dwindle. The Association of the South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) countries will continue to run deficits. China alone will account for over two-thirds of the projected total account deficits of the region in the next 15 years.
Japan’s ability to generate high savings need not suffer from deregulation and liberalisation. A more open economy does not mean lower savings.
Singapore has one of the most open economies in the world, but also has one of the highest savings rates. High savings in Japan are necessary to ensure the support of its ageing population and to continue Japan’s role as a capital exporter to the region.
In particular, Japan can recycle its surpluses toward financing infrastructure projects in the rest of East Asia. In many parts of East Asia, existing infrastructure (transport networks, telecommunications, power and water) is grossly inadequate for current and future needs.
Opportunities for coordinated infrastructural development have grown and expanded because regional governments have recognised and accepted the need for multilateral joint development. In the Mekong delta, increased economic interdependence has created demand for road and water networks that transports goods across borders, and for power generation and distribution. Japan is best placed to play a big role in the financing and the construction of these infrastructural projects.
It is only a matter of time before Japan becomes an “absorber” nation to the rest of East Asia, providing markets for their exports. Only 12 per cent of East Asia’s exports go to Japan now, compared to 22 per cent to the US14.
Japan’s share of East Asia’s exports can easily go up to US levels.
The best way to ensure that markets in the US and Europe remains open is for Japan to set pace in East Asia in deregulation and liberalisation. This will “Savings and Investment Outlook in Developing East Asia” prepared by the Economic Department, (Monetary Authority of Singapore, March ‘95). The Japanese market accounts for only nine per cent and 17 per cent in the exports of the Asian NIEs and China, respectively. Japan accounts for a larger keep the world trading system on an expansion course. APEC is the vehicle to launch this initiative. APEC should build on GATT’s Uruguay Round package, and be the catalyst for another phase of global trade liberalisation. The US and Canada are both members of APEC and the benefits of liberalisation will spread across the Pacific through to them. This will help anchor US interests in the region.
However, East Asia will gain the most from such opening up. A World Bank study15 estimates that if all East Asian countries cut their tariffs by half and liberalise foreign direct investment rules on non-discriminatory basis, about 90 per cent of the increase in world GDP will accrue to countries in the APEC region. China alone would see its national income increase by an additional four per cent. The GDP of the six ASEAN countries would climb by an aggregate five per cent; the four NIEs could expect an average increases of about 1.4 per cent each.
If there is a split between Asia and America, Japan has the most to lose.
After the Second World War, Japan placed itself firmly in America’s orbit. The share in the combined exports of the ASEAN countries other than Singapore, but the share still does not exceed 25 per cent. World Bank, “East Asia’s Trade and Investment : Regional and Global Gains from Liberalisation”, July ‘94.
common phrase then was [“Datsu-Ah, Nyuu-Oh”], meaning “Leave Asia and enter the West”16. Japan’s increasing interests in the region in recent years, however, reflects a deeper integration of its economy with the rest of East Asia.
The present catch phrase in Japan has become “Leave the West and enter Asia” [or “Datsu-Oh, Nyuu-Ah”]. I believe this is too narrow and short-sighted as a slogan. Japan should not leave the West. It should stay in the West even as it re-enters Asia, and be the bridge to straddle both East and West. That is best for the future of Japan, for East Asia and for the world.
I am not taking sides in the present trade dispute between America and Japan on autos and autoparts. American demands amount to managed trade, which is inconsistent with WTO rules. Effectively, the US and Japan have been practising managed trade in various sections for many years. Such arrangements will damage the interests of other countries. It will particularly damage Japan in the longer term because the Americans are going to continue to impose such arrangements using the threat of sanctions. This will widen the areas of managed trade which is opposite of free trade under which Japan and the world have prospered.
The Agenda for Osaka
“Datsu-Ah, Nyuu-Oh” is written in Japanese as
The APEC Summit in Bogor was a good first step. It has generated tremendous confidence in the APEC region and has had a positive demonstration effect on the world. The speedy ratification of the UR agreement, the initiatives to create free trade areas in America and South Asia, and the proposed link-up of existing regional arrangements could not have been mere coincidence. APEC would be foolish to lose the momentum set in motion at Bogor by frittering its energies on efforts that do not promote trade liberalisation. It is Japan’s turn to show leadership. If the APEC meeting at Osaka comes out with a commitment to trade liberalisation, Japan will have played a key role in advancing the cause of regional economic cooperation.
The Kobe earthquake demonstrated Japanese social discipline and ability to adapt in a crisis. Families took the disaster in their stride and adjusted to the dramatic upsets in their daily lives. The social compact between the Japanese company and its employees made Marubeni Corp send emergency food to its staff and provide them with temporary housing. It is this culture of discipline, mutual dependence and social responsibility that had enabled Japan to overcome many crises in the past.
In Japan’s long history, there were repeated examples of how Japanese people, when confronted with a fundamentally changed situation, worked out a national consensus to change course drastically and overcome the challenge.
They did this during the Meiji Restoration. They did it again after World War Two. They did it after the two oil shocks in 1973 and 1979, again after “endaka” the rising yen after the Plaza agreement in 1985. Japan has enormous cultural and institutional strengths to overcome its present difficulties.
For Japan to move beyond its present gridlocked position, it needs a strong government which has mandate from the people to break the mould of the last 50 years and change the conservative policies of Japan’s powerful bureaucracy. I hope the Japanese people will have the opportunity to elect such a government in the next elections. I am confident that the Japanese will be successful in meeting their present challenge.