Speech By Senior Minister Lee Kuan Yew At Tanjong Pagar And Tiong Bahru Lunar New Year Get-Together At Silat Community Centre On Sunday, 5 February 1995, At 7.30 Pm
Lee Kuan Yew · Senior Minister of Singapore
- Context
- Lee addressed a Tanjong Pagar and Tiong Bahru Lunar New Year get-together at Silat Community Centre in Singapore on February 5, 1995, predicting a shift from Western to Asian cultural influence within 20 years.
- Main themes
- Revival of East Asian self-confidence, decline of Western cultural dominance, Western lounge suit and fast food as universal norms, Asian values versus Western influence, Western media influence on Asia, Christmas versus Chinese New Year commercialisation, prediction of Asian influence rising to 60 per cent within 20 years, American decline after the 1960s and the Great Society, British welfare state and economic decline, Singapore's emphasis on wealth creation and meritocracy
- Duration
- ~10 min
- Words
- 1,237
- Sentences
- 80
- Readability
- 44
- Grade
- 10.9
- Syntax
- 2.71
- Vocabulary
- 2.33
Source: National Archives of Singapore ↗
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other80 sentences in 13 paragraphs
The 50 years since the end of World War II have seen a revival in self-confidence of the peoples of East Asia. For 300 years, the European and later the American civilisations have dominated the world. They made the scientific discoveries. They had the highest standard of living. Their arts, their lifestyles, their foods, their dress styles, their entertainment were dominant throughout the world. One simple example is the Western lounge suit with neck tie. It is now the accepted universal dress for Japanese, Chinese, Vietnamese, Southeast Asians, and Africans. We have all given up our traditional robes, except for religious and formal occasions. American fast foods, hamburgers, pizzas, Coca Cola, Pepsi Cola, prevail worldwide.
They are the outer trappings of inner strength, a strength acknowledged by the world. The Japanese were the first non-white race to match the West. In certain sectors they have excelled, producing superior, zero-defect goods. They have also created new products like the Walkman, Discman. Japan’s success has encouraged South Korea, Taiwan, Hong Kong and Singapore. Their success in turn has moved the ASEAN countries, and then China and Vietnam. East Asians now know that given the time and the opportunity to engage in trade, investments and technology transfers, they can industrialise and catch up with the West. This self-confidence arises from an understanding of the factors and qualities that gave the West their lead, and the discovery that we too can do it.
As East Asia develops there will be re-affirmation of Asian culture, Asian tradition and Asian values. Japanese foods, Japanese dress styles are now admired and widely accepted. Sushi bars and Japanese restaurants are common in East Asia, in Europe and in America. Their thongs, or sandals, are now popularly used throughout East Asia.
Our past attitudes of deference to European and American standards arose from the overwhelming superiority of America and Europe. The Western media had exercised influence derived from this clout. They saturated our TV, radio and the print media. American cartoons, documentaries, and CNN bring the outside world into our sitting rooms, and American voices interpret the meaning of these events to Asians using American terms of reference. As East Asia develops, and its people master the media, Asian cartoons, documentaries and commentators will interpret these same world events to us and the world, as seen from an Asian perspective.
It is overall success which wins admiration for life styles, dress styles, food or entertainment. Compare Christmas and Chinese New Year. Twenty years ago, Christmas was a non-event in Singapore, except for Christians going to church. Today, the barrage of commercial Christmas in shop windows, gift giving, Christmas cards and carols, have overwhelmed Singapore as they have many other countries in East Asia including Japan, Hong Kong, South Korea, and Taiwan. Chinese New Year was becoming an insignificant holiday. Hence Singapore Federation of Chinese Clan Association fought back with the River Hong Bao show. But the day is coming when Taiwan, Hong Kong and the 1,200 million Chinese on the mainland will get into the act of the consumer society.
They will master the techniques of commercialising Chinese New Year, making it festive and profitable. The Chinese in these three territories will throw up their exterior and interior decorators, their mass products, to generate festivity during the spring festival. They will update the traditional legends and figures. They will take the high points of historical festivals and market them for the consumer society. Asians will regain their self-confidence. Within 20 years, I believe the Chinese and other Asians will break into the fast foods market. Today’s instant noodles, frozen wontons, siew mais, baos, roti pratas will be followed by other delicacies, and they will become as universal as pizzas or hamburgers. And Asian fashion designers, like Japan’s Hanae Mori or Issey Miyake, already selling fashions in Europe and America, will be joined by dozens of talented and creative Chinese, Thais, Malays, Indonesians and Filipinos. Large numbers of artistic and talented Chinese from the 1,200 million will be drawn into the fashion industry. From traditional Chinese robes they will create fashionable dresses and suits to compete against fashion leaders in Europe and America.
Singapore’s lifestyles and its political vocabulary have been heavily influenced by the West. I assess Western influence at 60 per cent, compared to the influence of core Asian values at 40 per cent. In 20 years, this ratio will shift, as East Asia successfully produces its own mass products and coins its own political vocabulary. The influence of the West on our lifestyles, foods, fashions, politics and the media, will drop to 40 per cent and Asian influence will increase to 60 per cent.
Of course this renaissance of East Asian civilisation can be aborted by wars, civil conflicts, or revolutions. If Asians avoid these calamities, progress will be unstoppable. The question whether Asian or Western values are better will not be settled by argument alone. It will be settled by the economic transformation of Asia. The West can of course slow East Asia’s economic development. But America and Europe both want to participate in the industrial transformation of East Asia, not to slow it down.
Therefore Singapore is not fighting a losing battle in resisting the Western media when they try to impose their will and their values on us. During the next 20 years, the influence of the Western media will decrease from 60 per cent to 40 per cent. East Asia’s economies is closing the lead which the West now has.
The commanding lead America enjoyed in economic and scientific fields began eroding in the 1960s. America’s economy and society ran into difficulties because of the Vietnam war (1965 to 1975). In the 1960s, blacks in America engaged in violent protests against white discrimination. President Johnson answered with the Great Society programmes, welfare schemes designed to reduce black backwardness. American liberals in Congress began solving social problems by throwing money at them. This lead to budget deficits and inflation, which further weakened America’s economy.
In Britain’s case, World War II had already weakened her. Nevertheless, Britain embarked on the welfare state. They rewarded average performers nearly as much as high performers. They extolled mediocrity, downgraded excellence, and denounced meritocracy as “elitism”. Successive British governments had to yield to populist pressures for more welfare, which forced the government to concentrate on wealth re-distribution, not wealth creation. Mrs. Thatcher from 1979 to 1990 had the courage to reverse this, but she did not have the time nor the support to turn Britain around. The majority of the British newspapers crusaded for policies which leveled everyone down. The relative result was economic decline which led to a loss of self-esteem, and relegation from the first to the second division.
My old colleagues and I learned from these costly lessons. Watching their setbacks, we decided to take the opposite road. We concentrated on wealth creation, not re-distribution. We rewarded excellence more than mediocrity. We encouraged personal savings and family asset enhancement, not spending on collective subsidies and welfare. The result has been high growth, low inflation, no budget deficit, no public debt, high savings, high investments, family asset enhancement and a strong Singapore dollar. Every Singapore family is worth more with each passing year.
The tide is rising for East Asia. We have learned from the West from their mistakes as well as their strengths. Soon we shall talk to them on more equal terms.