"In Catalonia, the law will also be upheld."

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

24 December 2012

Context
Rajoy gave a year-end interview published on 24 December 2012, reflecting on Spain's most difficult year of austerity, economic reform, and the Catalan independence challenge.
Main themes
Economic crisis management, austerity measures and public deficit, Catalonia and rule of law, political credibility and broken promises, labor and financial reforms, European integration, Spain's recovery prospects, personal leadership style
Duration
~33 min
86th percentile
Words
4,014
86th percentile
Sentences
249
93rd percentile
Readability
66
95th percentile
Grade
8.1
5th percentile
Syntax
2.65
10th percentile
Vocabulary
1.91
4th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 35%33%
  • Institutional 31%29%
  • Social 23%21%
  • Geopolitical 7%6%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

249 sentences in 95 paragraphs

Person of the Year 2012. A president in the midst of the storm.

He faces interviews with a mix of caution and patient kindness, but with the determined purpose of not providing a single drop of fuel that could feed any fire, declared or undeclared, in national life. It is the same strategy he applies to the day-to-day management of his administration. No matter what happens, it will be impossible for anyone to blame Mariano Rajoy for having stirred up any conflict. What is another matter is that it is known that he is determined to act, and to act decisively, when the situation requires it, whether in the realm of politics, the economy, or the social climate. But he will never let it be known in advance. That is one of the few things that the President of the Government has made clear a long time ago through actions, not statements.

Victoria Prego.- Has this been the most difficult year for a Spanish government in democracy?

Mariano Rajoy.- I don’t know if it’s the most difficult, but it has certainly been a very difficult year for the government. And also for the Spanish people.

Casimiro García-Abadillo.- But did you expect something like this a year ago?

M. R.- One thing is to know that you have a difficult year ahead and another is to live through the 365 days; one by one. There has also been an additional factor that made things much more difficult for us: the public deficit was not the 6% we expected, but 8.9%. That has been a burden and will continue to be for the rest of the legislature. If we add the recession, everything has turned out to be even more difficult than we anticipated.

V. P.- Has there been any moment when the situation was out of control?

M. R.- Frankly, no. We had clear priorities. The goal was to tackle the crisis, grow, and create jobs. And we had very clear instruments: to fight against the public deficit, to make reforms to improve the competitiveness of the economy, to restructure the financial system, and to fight for better European integration. We knew what needed to be done. We were always very sure.

C. G-A.- What has been the most important decision you have made this year?

M. R.- All of them have been important: those we adopted regarding the financial system; the labor reform; the battle we fought in Europe... although probably the most important has been to fight decisively against the public deficit, which led us to make decisions that were not in our program. That is what makes it the hardest.

V. P.- Has there been any night when you couldn’t sleep?

M. R.- Knock on wood, but I sleep well, without taking anything. From that point of view, I feel calm, tranquil, and balanced, which is fundamental because things need to be thought through very carefully before doing them and to foresee their consequences to avoid problems.

V. P.- And the most difficult moment?

M. R.- The decisions in July were not easy: the VAT increase and the freezing of the Christmas bonus for civil servants. The decision on pensions was also not easy. In July we did not adopt it because we believed it might not be necessary, but in November we were clear that it had to be adopted.

C. G-A.- Do you feel that your reputation as a person who keeps his word has been weakened after this?

M. R.- That accusation is made to me by many people, especially from the opposition groups. Everyone knows that there are things I have not been able to do, that I have even done things that were not in our program. But I also believe that many people understand that reality forces difficult decisions to be made and that it is better to make them than not to, especially if one wants to face the future with some hope.

V. P.- Do you think that in the three years you have left you will be able to recover your prestige, or are you willing to die politically in this legislature?

M. R.- I have to set priorities. And my most important priority at this moment is to get Spain out of the crisis. To the extent that economic activity improves and the Administration achieves more income, some decisions, such as the income tax, we will change. But the general economic situation will always be prioritized over a specific measure.

C. G-A.- Do you have room to maneuver in what remains of the legislature?

M. R.- We do not know that as of today; it depends on the evolution of the economy. I hope that next year will be better. I am confident, and all international bodies and analysts' reports confirm this, that 2014 will be a year of economic growth and job creation.

C. G-A.- What do you do now in your daily life that you didn’t do a year ago?

M. R.- What has changed is that I lead an infinitely more orderly and disciplined life. There is now a lot of method in my life. I get up every day at 7:00 in the morning, exercise, have breakfast with my wife and children, and by 8:30 I am in the office. I usually go home to have dinner with my family. What I don’t do is go out. In fact, whenever I am not traveling outside Spain, I have dinner with my family.

C. G-A.- Doesn’t this bore you?

M. R.- I don’t have time to be bored.

V. P.- I suppose the doctors keep an eye on your health.

M. R.- Well, I feel good. I usually have a check-up once a year, although this time I haven’t had time. But I will.

V. P.- The measures you have adopted have angered all citizens, without exception.

M. R.- I am absolutely aware of that. But I am also aware that everyone believes that measures had to be taken, although when they affect you, it is logical and human not to like them.

C. G-A.- Of everything you have done, do you regret anything?

M. R.- Regret, no. We have thought things through; I don’t like to improvise. But, well, I think the income tax is high in Spain although, as of today, I do not regret it. It has been hard for me to make the decision on pensions and the Christmas bonus, but that was not done whimsically or with the intention of causing trouble.

V. P.- Given the number of conditions coming from Brussels, what room for maneuver do you have left?

M. R.- I have a lot of room for maneuver. We, like the rest of the EU countries, have a commitment to reduce the public deficit. But Europe does not tell us to reduce this item or that one. It is true that the European Commission imposes obligations and can sanction you for excessive deficit, but that happens to Spain and the rest of the countries in the Union.

C. G-A.- Do you think the government has been able to convey why all these sacrifices were necessary and that people have understood it?

M. R.- It is difficult to know. People were clear that the situation was very difficult and that the government had to take measures because you cannot spend what you do not have. What is more complicated is another thing. A civil servant who has their extra pay taken away finds it very hard to understand. And the same goes for someone whose income tax is raised. But the most difficult of all is that these decisions do not produce tangible results right away. I try to explain it, but whether I manage to convince is another matter.

V. P.- Knowing that in economics nothing is certain, can you say that 2014 will be the first year of job creation?

M. R.- I will say that definitively when I present the budgets in 2014, but I think it is reasonable to expect that to be the case.

C. G-A.- Do you think the sacrifices have been distributed fairly and equitably in Spanish society?

M. R.- That has been our top priority. And it has been so in the income tax brackets; in the obligation imposed on financial entities to make provisions; in the adjustment of the remuneration of executives of entities that are now state-owned; in the increase of the tax on electricity companies, etc. The government’s intention has been to ensure that the cost of the crisis is borne by all of us.

V. P.- However, public irritation considers that the government is massively helping the banks, which are partially responsible for the disaster we are experiencing.

M. R.- Look, an economy in which money and credit do not flow will inevitably have problems, which is why we are making decisions that affect the financial sector. In 2008, when action should have been taken seriously in Spain, it was not done; the countries of the European Union injected one trillion five hundred billion euros into their financial entities. I am talking about the United Kingdom or Germany. There is no country in the world that does not operate this way. That is why we have asked the European Union for a loan, under very good conditions, aimed at cleaning up the financial system. It is necessary to do so in the interest of all Spaniards.

C. G-A.- Perhaps you have not explained well why you had to take a series of measures. And that is where the feeling of many comes from that the government is dismantling the welfare state.

M. R.- That statement is simply false. We are not dismantling the welfare state. The welfare state, which some leftist parties claim, exists because Spaniards pay for it with their taxes. It is not paid for by a government or a party. And, to the extent that there are more revenues, the better it will be. What we are doing is working to maintain and improve it. The greatest enemy of the welfare state is a debt that leads you to collapse. The truth is exactly the opposite; we are working to improve it. The problem is that the effects of that work are not seen in a short time.

V. P.- Do you defend a public or private healthcare system as long as it is effective?

M. R.- Look, in the functioning of healthcare in all autonomous communities, including those that are or have been governed by the PSOE, there are many management formulas. One: public hospitals with public management. Two: public hospitals with public management in the medical field, and private management in kitchens, cafeterias, etc. Three: publicly owned hospitals with total private management. Four: public administration agreements with completely private hospitals, where people do not pay. Those four models exist in Spain: in Catalonia, in Andalusia, and also in other countries. What is important is that healthcare is universal, free, and, above all, that it is good.

C. G-A.- There is a widespread feeling that Angela Merkel imposes her adjustment model too much on the rest of the countries, while advocating for growth.

M. R.- These are compatible things, and moreover, both need to be done. Growth requires many things: to begin with, not having a public deficit that collapses the economy. And structural reforms are needed to make that economy flexible and competitive. That is what we are doing now in Spain. But it also requires financing. And then there are those policies that were called Keynesian, which is what was done in Spain in the previous legislature when we lost 70 billion in revenues and it was said: since private activity is stalled, let’s go into much more debt. That was the great mistake of the previous legislature: the E plans and all those activities, the 2,500 euros of the baby check, the 400 euros… Can Keynesian policies be implemented today in Spain? The problem is that there is no money. Nevertheless, we have done some things.

V. P.- For example?

M. R.- For example, the PIVE plan, which has its usefulness. We will try to implement some policies like these next year. I insist, stimulus policies for growth.

C. G-A.- Wouldn’t it be appropriate for fiscal policies to be relaxed depending on the situation?

M. R.- The deficit target that had been set for Spain in 2012 has been relaxed by the Commission itself, which has acted sensibly. Secondly, it would be important for countries that can afford it because they have their public accounts in order to spend more. There are countries at this moment where we have to make a great effort to contain spending. But there are others that could implement more expansive policies because that would ultimately benefit everyone. If there are countries where private and public consumption increases, I can export, and that would help balance the eurozone. We have also debated in the last European Council, based on a Spanish initiative, that in that policy of integration that Europe must pursue, the possibility of policies that allow countries in difficulty, but that are making reforms, to have financing for specific investments be foreseen.

V. P.- Let’s talk about the autonomous communities. What will happen to those that do not meet the deficit target?

M. R.- Anticipating events is not good. The Spanish have made a great effort, and their administrations have too. The central administration and also the autonomous communities. The law is clear, but let’s see how things end.

C. G-A.- You don’t want to specify the government’s response now...

M. R.- Exactly.

V. P.- Has the government done everything it could to slim down public administrations?

M. R.- In the last two active population surveys, the employment that has fallen the most is public employment. So a very hard effort is being made. And I am going to try to carry out a thorough reform of the administration. We have created a commission that has until June 30, 2013, to deliver its conclusions and proposals. Its objectives are the elimination of duplications; the simplification of procedures; the rationalization of autonomous bodies and public entities, and the management of common services and resources. Many would like to carry out this reform in 24 hours, but that is impossible. Moreover, when talking about savings in the public sector, it must be understood that the major expenditure items are pensions, healthcare, education, unemployment, and debt interest. Therefore, the margin is very narrow.

C. G-A.- Your Government and the PP have worn themselves out with adjustment policies, but, in parallel, the PSOE has also worn itself out. Why is this discrediting of the political class occurring?

M. R.- I am aware that at this moment there are many people who are not happy with the decisions that the Government has been forced to make. It is also true that this year there have been five electoral calls, and that the PP has, for the first time, won the elections in Andalusia, that it maintains the government of Galicia with a greater margin, and that in Catalonia it has obtained the best historical result of all the Spanish center-right. The Socialist Party has gone through very difficult times. I am not going to get into that. Many people blame the decisions of politicians for the situation we are living in. I have been in political life for 30 years, and I have to say that politicians, in their behaviors, attitudes, and competence, are not very different from the rest of the Spaniards.

V. P.- You govern with an absolute majority, but in matters of real importance, it would be good if you reached agreements with the main opposition party. Are you trying to do that?

M. R.- Yes. What happens is that, probably, it is not being formalized. We agree, for example, on European matters, as has happened with the debate on the European budgets for the years 2014-2020; on banking union in the reforms of the Administrations I referred to earlier; also on issues of Local Administration… It may be true that what is lacking is a bit of staging, of formalization.

C. G-A.- Do you fear that the opposition will increasingly move from Parliament to the streets? Do you fear that the unions will call for another general strike?

M. R.- The unions have called for two in less than a year. This has never happened in history. It is their decision, which I respect, but there are many people who do not share it, and that is why the results were what they were. I have spoken with union leaders on some occasions throughout this year, and it is difficult for them to share many of the policies we are implementing. And there are some things they have done well, such as the agreement on wage moderation. In any case, having unions is good, and it is good for the government to have dialogue with both employers and workers' representatives. It is not the best time for major agreements, but it is good that we maintain dialogue. I am doing that.

V. P.- But do you not fear that next year, which will continue to be difficult, the climate of tension in the streets will increase or overflow?

M. R.- I hope not, and I am doing everything possible to prevent that. But it does not depend solely on me.

C. G-A.- An agreement has just been signed between CiU and ERC that not only sets the call for a self-determination referendum but also has a project for the construction of a sovereign state. How does legality confront that challenge?

M. R.- Well, with the calm that comes from knowing that we are all subject to the rule of law. And also with concern, because everything that is happening is bad for Catalonia and bad for the whole of Spain. Even today, I cannot explain to myself how the situation in Catalonia has improved after the decisions that have been made in the last three months. I do not know what positive effects the traumatic break of a legislature in which things were being done that made a lot of sense from an economic point of view and that were done with our support has brought. I do not know what has been gained with this operation. It is contradictory. But, in addition to what you have said, which is the most important, it is a government that commits to doing things that, from an economic point of view, make no sense whatsoever and that I am absolutely convinced have nothing to do with what a good part of the people who supported CiU thought. It is a complex and difficult situation. And I am willing to help overcome it. The only thing I have to say is that the law binds us all. It binds the 46 million people who live in Spain.

V. P.- Do you expect Mas to rectify?

M. R.- I would like him to rectify; it would be good for Catalonia and for all of Spain.

V. P.- Is the Government studying the application of Article 155 of the Constitution and suspending the autonomy of Catalonia or disqualifying Artur Mas? Or do you rule that out?

M. R.- Well, this idea of ruling out and not ruling out is very complicated. The Government rules out anticipating events. I have to say that we are all subject to the rule of law and that I hope everyone acts accordingly and that nothing is done that contravenes the law.

C. G-A.- Will the law also be enforced in Catalonia?

M. R.- I am the first to be subject to the rule of law. And the law will also be enforced in Catalonia.

V. P.- You talk with major businessmen in Catalonia; what could be the response of the financial and economic world to this proposal for rupture?

M. R.- I do not know what their response will be, but I do know what their desire is: to restore a situation of normality and for the Government to address the real problems of the people. That is, the economy, ensuring growth and employment, and not generating instability or making rupture proposals. That is the desire of the majority of the people I have spoken with.

C. G-A.- Have Catalan businessmen asked you to say or do something? Have you asked them to say or do something?

M. R.- No. As president, I must be prudent. Everyone knows what my position is, which is that I am subject to the rule of law. From there, people can be very calm.

V. P.- Why has the situation in Catalonia broken down?

M. R.- The only explanation given was that I did not accept the economic concert. And I believe that this was compounded by a misinterpretation of a demonstration. But a ruler should not be impressed by moments of emotion or by what a media outlet may say. I have always been clear about that, but now I reaffirm it.

C. G-A.- When Mas was with you in La Moncloa, did he give you any hint of what might happen?

M. R.- No. He told me that from then on, he felt free to make his decisions. I did not know that he was going to call the elections when he left here, nor that what happened afterward was going to happen. He did not tell me.

V. P.- Do you have the feeling that this is a sudden conflict or a sought-after conflict?

M. R.- I am not an analyst; I am a ruler. I do not know.

C. G-A.- Would it not now be necessary for the Government and the PSOE to establish a common position on the challenge posed in Catalonia?

M. R.- Yes. It would be good, and I also have the conviction that we both think the same. Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, when the PSC introduced the right to self-determination in its electoral program, said that he was not at all in agreement. Which reassured me.

V. P.- Are you talking to Rubalcaba about this issue?

M. R.- We talk about many things regularly.

C. G-A.- But in secret...

M. R.- Obviously.

V. P.- Will the Government maintain its position regarding language? Will Spanish have a reasonable presence in education in Catalonia?

M. R.- The Government is open to dialogue. It is not true that we are against Catalan. We want children to learn to speak Catalan, English, and Spanish. And let it not be forgotten that the recipient of education is the child, not ideologies or territories. And while the child is a child, parents have the right to have a say. There are very clear laws and rulings. It is possible to find formulas that preserve the freedom and rights of people. It is possible to reach a model in which children come out speaking Catalan, Spanish, and English. The main challenge of the reform is to improve the quality level of the system.

C. G-A.- Do you think that the investigation of corruption cases affecting CiU is related, as its secretary general has stated, to the Government's intention to stop the sovereign process?

M. R.- That is not true. The investigations that have taken place have nothing to do with any sovereign process. There are investigations, some of which were already judicialized. We are all subject to the law. Corruption is something absolutely reprehensible, and this is a matter that the courts will have to decide.

V. P.- What will you do if the polls continue to show a constant decline in voting intention towards the PP?

M. R.- I am doing what I have to do. My idea is to maintain this policy throughout the entire legislature. The Government has a clear course, knows where it is going, and as of today, I do not see the need to change it.

NOTE: Interview published with the authorization of "El Mundo."