Press Conference by the President of the Government

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

27 December 2012 · Press conference by the President of the Government

Context
Rajoy addressed a year-end press conference on 27 December 2012, reviewing Spain's economic situation and outlining priorities for the difficult year ahead.
Main themes
Spanish economic crisis and recession, Eurozone financial instability, structural reforms and austerity, European integration and banking union, competitiveness and export growth, national unity and constitutional order, regional centrifugal forces, job creation, fiscal convergence, public sacrifice and solidarity, Spain's international image, future economic recovery
Duration
~68 min
97th percentile
Words
8,198
97th percentile
Sentences
342
96th percentile
Readability
51
66th percentile
Grade
12.0
46th percentile
Syntax
3.13
65th percentile
Vocabulary
1.92
4th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

342 sentences in 110 paragraphs

Ladies and gentlemen,

Here, I also have to bring up the upheaval originating abroad, especially the consequences of the financial and monetary crisis in the Eurozone. You all know what this has meant in terms of market volatility, scarce financing, and the wild swings in the risk premium.

We must recognise that, fortunately, even though the pace of change is not particularly swift nor can results be seen yet, the truth is that our positions-those of Spain-regarding governance, banking union and fiscal convergence are spreading within the European Union, and that, after a highly turbulent year, a little more calm has been restored to the markets.

The Government has been especially active in its commitment to greater European integration and to mitigating the problems caused by a lack of liquidity in certain Eurozone countries. Today, we can also say that Europe has advanced from a discourse that simply focused on cutbacks to one focusing on greater integration. Spain can be proud to have made an active contribution to this change.

That said, we must neither fool ourselves, nor much less try to fool the Spanish people: we still have a very tough year ahead, especially in the first six months, and we must persevere in the reforms that we have launched. The Spanish economy will remain in recession for some time, although we hope that it will begin to improve in the second half of next year, 2013.

In short, we are not where we would like to be, but thanks to a course correction and the sacrifices that have been made, we are not being forced to make larger sacrifices now.

For that reason, we must avoid everything that distracts us from the top priorities of recovering from the crisis and creating jobs. All our energy should be focused on how to eliminate inefficiency, how to improve our competitiveness, how to do more with less and how to, once again, offer opportunities to our young people. All our energy should focus on what unites us, makes us stronger and enables us to overcome adversity.

Far be it for me to aggravate centrifugal forces. I have always expressed a desire to integrate and discuss everything that can be discussed; but as the constitutional President of the Government of this great Spanish nation, I must make it clear that I am fully aware of the responsibilities I have undertaken, the loyalties to which I am bound, and the role incumbent upon me to defend our Constitution. And I will not stray from any of them. My hand remains outstretched to consensus and to the agreed reforms-but always within the framework defined by the Constitution.

There is no doubt that much can be improved; we can rebuild weakened consensus and better accommodate demands for diversity. However, we must do so respecting the rules and procedures, and showing loyalty to one another, prioritising everything that unites us over and above anything that separates us.

Finally, I would not like this long time of hardship we have experienced to cloud how we see our strengths.

We have leading companies in sectors of the future and sectors with a future; healthy companies that are highly international and innovative. We are starting to see the results of the steady debt reduction in our companies and households. We have gained competitiveness, and we are exporting more and diversifying our export strengths.

Now more than ever, we need to believe in ourselves and inspire that confidence in others. Our efforts are starting to be recognised and Spain's image is improving. We must continue along this path and not stray from it.

Once again, I would like to say that I believe in Spain and in its future, and that my actions will be adapted to whatever best suits the general interest in any given situation. I fully understand that what Spaniards care about are results, wellbeing, and signs that we are on the right track. And for this reason, I will not ask for patience, because the Spanish people have already shown much of that; neither will I ask for blind faith, because I believe that politicians should be subject to daily scrutiny of what we do. I will, however, ask for understanding and solidarity: understanding of the need to implement measures that nobody likes, because they are essential if we want to prevail over this situation; and solidarity in the realisation that we must all contribute something to the common sacrifice if we want to overcome our problems.

If we persevere on this course, if we remain united and use that unity as a strength, our voice will be heard louder and we will have a greater chance of garnering respect and influence in Europe and the world. This is our path, based on the secure knowledge that we will recover from this crisis sooner rather than later. If we are all capable of responding to the demands of our responsibility, we might even be able to take advantage of this opportunity to emerge stronger for the experience.

That is all. Thank you very much. I will now take any questions you may have.

Q. Mr President of the Government, without explicitly referring to Catalonia, you mentioned your willingness to talk about everything that can be talked about. Does your agenda include a meeting with the re-elected President of the Generalitat [Regional Government of Catalonia], Artur Mas?

On the same subject, have you discussed that with the leader of the opposition? Is there united action involving the Government and the leading opposition party regarding your view of what's happening in Catalonia?

President of the Government. I have indeed spoken about Catalonia, and I have indeed expressed, as I always do, my willingness to talk. I will meet Mr Mas whenever he wants to, as I always have.

I believe that Mr Pérez Rubalcaba and I agree on these issues, at least regarding the basics. There's no other way, and it clearly wouldn't be good if that weren't the case. Therefore, I believe we agree on the basics.

Q. Mr President of the Government, I would like to ask a couple of questions. First, when you took stock of this year's economy, you somehow failed to mention the possibility that Spain might have to invoke or might choose to invoke the European aid mechanisms within the first few months of 2013. I would like to know whether this possibility is still being considered, and to what extent, as we come to the end of the year.

Regarding the issue of Catalonia, and given that all there is in Catalonia at the moment is a parliamentary majority and some parliamentary agreements, I wanted to ask you to what extent and how strongly the Government views Catalonia as being Spain's problem today.

President of the Government. In response to your first question, as you are fully aware, the European Central Bank already announced several months ago that it was willing to intervene in the secondary market, provided that a country with an interest in such action were to request that steps be taken, and as long as this request were to receive support from the other EU partners. Therefore, this mechanism is in place for any country that requests it in the belief that it is necessary. I think this was a very important decision and shows willingness from the European Central Bank to support the euro, whose irreversibility has calmed the markets.

The Government of Spain, like all the other governments within the EU, has not yet considered it necessary to make such a request from the European Central Bank, and that's why we haven't. You can rest assured that we would have contacted the European Central Bank if we had thought otherwise. Therefore, today, our position is the same as it has been up to this point: in other words, we have no intention today of asking the European Central Bank to intervene and buy up bonds on the secondary market; however, this is a very useful instrument that has been made available to every country in the European Union, and if Spain, and its Government, believe that it is necessary to activate that mechanism, have no doubt whatsoever that we will do so. However, in principle, as things stand today, we have no intention of doing so, but we haven't discarded the possibility for the future.

As regards your second question, whether or not Catalonia is Spain's problem, I believe that Spain has many problems at this time. The problem affecting most Spaniards nowadays is probably the economic situation, unemployment, the fact that many people want to find a job but can't, that many young people see no future, that many families are undergoing hardship… These things are happening all over Spain, and also in Catalonia, where there are 750,000 people who want to find a job but can't, and where there are people who have been affected by government decisions that have had an impact on their standard of living and their quality of life.

Moreover, there is a political problem that has arisen from recent events, of which you are fully aware and which I will therefore not repeat here. What I do want to tell you is that I will do everything in my power to change the course of this situation. I have always been willing to talk and to engage in dialogue. The President of the Generalitat has taken the decisions that he thought best and was able to take them because he is the President of the Generalitat and was acting within his mandate. That aside, I heard one of his colleagues this morning say that he would consider it good and positive to have a conversation with me, and I think talking is a very good idea. So, I am willing to talk and, as I said in my previous answer, I will be glad to receive Mr Mas whenever he wants to see me.

Q. Mr President of the Government, do you think the number of unemployed will hit six million? If so, perhaps you regret having generated some, or even too much, expectation when you were in the opposition? Specifically, there's a photo of you that everyone remembers, a highly controversial photo, in front of an unemployment queue. Do you believe that generated too much expectation among the opposition?

My second question; all year, we've constantly heard you say one thing, but then we've seen the opposite actually happen. You must be aware that this has been talked about a lot in Spanish political circles. I wanted to ask you, how much do you think your word is worth right now, when you say one thing but then the opposite actually happens? Is that a credibility problem?

President of the Government. As you know, we've had to take decisions over the course of this year that, as I said earlier, were very tough and very difficult to take. Now, I would ask you a question: What would have happened if the Government had not taken the decisions it took this year-if we had not taken decisions like raising taxes (which, it's true, was not part of our campaign platform), or cutting public spending? If we hadn't done those things, Spain would now have a public deficit of between 11 and 11.5%; and if Spain had had a public deficit of between 11 and 11.5%, the situation would be immensely worse than it is now, to the point of being absolutely unsustainable.

We are making an enormous effort to cut the public deficit, as everyone is acknowledging, and, what's more, we're doing this during a recession, which is even more difficult. Moreover, as if that weren't enough, we're doing this in a situation where financing is difficult and, furthermore, very expensive.

I can tell you one thing: I know, and I've already said it, that there are many people who disagree with my Government's policies. What nobody can say, however, is that the Government simply stood idly by. We have not stood idly by; we've taken many decisions. The most important ones were those that appeared in our campaign platform: first, to correct the public deficit, and pass a Budget Stability Act; second, to implement reforms, labour reform in particular; and, third, to launch a banking sector restructuring process.

In addition to those decisions, we were forced to take others that were not included in our campaign platform, and we will make an effort, if possible, to rectify them in the future; however, as I said at the beginning of my speech, when we saw that the public deficit was not 6% but rather 9%, it was clear that we were facing a gap of more than 30 billion euros.

Therefore, we've been forced to take a number of decisions that I know-I'm fully aware of this-weren't in our campaign platform, and that's why I found it difficult to take them. However, I must insist that if we hadn't implemented those measures, Spain would now be in an infinitely worse situation: we would have a public deficit in excess of 11%, and who would have lent money to Spain with an annual public deficit in excess of 11%, given the current market situation?

Q. You mentioned dialogue, and perhaps a strategic sector, in many Autonomous Communities, with which this dialogue has apparently been lost, is that of coal. Your Government is going to send Brussels a 2013-2019 Plan without reaching a consensus with the trade unions or with the employer association in this sector. Why do it this way? Don't you think that this is a way of attacking a sector that has experienced a very tumultuous 2012-the year which we are now reviewing?

Moreover, other regions, such as Asturias, are immediately going to introduce a bank tax. What is happening in these regions? I don't know whether or not these regional taxes are going to be declared unconstitutional. Will these taxes be compensated for in any way?

President of the Government. Mining is not the only sector for which this has been a highly tumultuous year. Unfortunately, it has been a very difficult year for the vast majority of the Spanish population, for everyone. Think of our civil servants and pensioners, and think of the healthcare and education measures we adopted. We have raised taxes-very significantly and severely-even for large companies, especially in the electricity industry. In every industry and there have been protests in all of them. It has been a very tumultuous year for everyone.

Though we have not managed to reach an agreement with this sector, it is not for lack of trying, but rather because it has not been possible to reach such an agreement. When all is said and done, this doesn't mean we're spared from our obligation to send our plans to the European Union.

As regards the bank tax, the Government has approved regulations under which the Government defines its own authority-which it has-to tax bank deposits. What does not make sense is that each Autonomous Community should establish its own tax. This could be very dangerous, as it could result in people moving their deposits from one region to another. Consequently, we believe that this is a power which falls under the remit of the national Government; consequently, we have exercised this power, and consequently, the Autonomous Communities do not have the authority to legislate on this, just as the national Government does not have the authority to legislate on issues which fall under the remit of the Autonomous Communities.

Q. I have a couple of questions. First of all, I wanted to ask you whether the Government is going to adopt two specific measures: Whether, in this or the next Cabinet meeting, you are going to appeal against the "euro per prescription charge" that the Autonomous Community of Madrid is going to introduce and that was approved yesterday by its Assembly. Also, I'd like to know whether, as the President of the Autonomous Community of Madrid requested, a Strike Act will be drafted in order to prevent cases such as those taking place in Madrid, which are of such concern to the regional Administration, one governed by your own political party.

In addition, if you don't mind my asking, I wonder if you could tell us what was the most difficult decision you had to make this year. Of all of the decisions you've had to make, many of which have been tough, especially given the cutbacks, which one was the hardest for you, which one did you have to think about the most?

President of the Government. As regards the "euro per prescription", in the case of Catalonia, the Government has already lodged an appeal against it before the Constitutional Court, and, as I'm sure you'll understand, it would be unthinkable for the national Government to make any other decision in the case of the Autonomous Community of Madrid.

In principle, we are not considering a Strike Act because, among other reasons, there is already a 1981 ruling by the Constitutional Court which specifies in detail everything involved in exercising the right to strike. Therefore, just like all previous Governments since 1981, we are not planning to implement a Strike Act.

Regarding the most difficult decision I have made, to be completely honest it is almost easier to say which was the easiest decision I have had to make, because many of the decisions I have made were certainly not easy. However, I have not liked having to make some decisions which went against what I'd said in our campaign platform, nor have I liked making some decisions which I knew would have an impact on people's lives. So there have been many difficult decisions, and it would be nearly impossible to say which one was the most difficult.

Q. You said, or you asked us, what would have happened if the Government had not made the difficult decisions that it has had to make, and the response was that the situation would have been unsustainable, with a public deficit of 11 or 11.5%. Would this have involved Spain having the same fate as Portugal, Greece and Ireland, with a bailout from the European Union? Do you therefore believe that in this first year of Government, the mere fact of avoiding this bailout could be considered an achievement? Do you feel satisfied with this?

And one more specific question: Do you think that the reform of the Judiciary, which was promoted by Justice Minister Ruiz-Gallardón, will put an end to the politicisation of the judicial system?

President of the Government. What I do believe, you can be absolutely sure, is that if we had not taken those measures, Spain would be in a completely unsustainable position. What I mean by that is that we had a commitment to reduce last year's public deficit to 6%, and yet our public deficit was only reduced to 9%. Just imagine if we had made no decision on these issues and we ended up with a public deficit of 11%. I don't know what might have happened, but the best thing to do now is not to think about that-among other reasons, because it never happened.

That said, you asked whether the biggest success this year was avoiding a bailout. No, I believe that the biggest success this year was changing the course, or correcting the course, of economic policy. That was our biggest achievement this year, along with laying the foundations for our economy to grow in a sustained and stable way. That, in my opinion, was our biggest success. We have made reforms that, as I said before, take a little bit of time to have any impact. These situations cannot be resolved overnight, butI think anything that means taking steps in the right direction is extremely positive.

In addition, there are already some promising data. I will refer to something that is very relevant: our foreign sector. Not long ago, Spain had an external deficit of more than 11%; nevertheless, this coming year, I think this deficit will become a surplus. In other words, the increase in our exports, the adaptation of our companies to the situation we are experiencing, and the positive evolution of tourism, are all, logically, very important to the Spanish economy, and this means that we will no longer need financing from abroad. Furthermore, I believe that companies are making a great effort, and the Government has put a lot of emphasis on this.

We have put a lot of work into foreign policy, and I made twenty-nine visits abroad in 2012. For example, just in the area of services, roads, railways and so, Spanish companies have been awarded contracts totalling 23 billion euros. This is very important, because that number is more than 4 trillion of the old pesetas, allowing companies to stay alive and jobs to be kept here in Spain, thus boosting growth.

Consequently, our biggest success this year-where there are no tangible results, meaning where employment has not risen and benefits have not increased-has been to correct the previous course and to begin to lay the foundations for an economic policy able to generate sustained and stable growth.

With regard to the second question, I am of course very much in agreement with the bill presented by the Minister of Justice, on which, if I remember correctly, reports must now be issued by the relevant bodies, and which must be sent to Parliament. However, this bill among other things, prevents the terms of office of current Council members from being extended indefinitely after these terms have finished. I think that this bill makes the Council much more operative, because many of the Council members-currently 22-will not serve full time, but will be basically dedicated to their jobs, and will be in much closer contact with the needs and problems that the Judiciary may have. There will also be six people on the Standing Committee.

Consequently, I believe that it is a good law which brings about substantial change. I now hope that when the people who will become members of this body are appointed, things will improve and function in a way which is increasingly satisfactory for all citizens.

Q. You said that you are willing to engage in dialogue with Catalonia. I would like to know whether you believe there are still points of agreement between the national Government and the Generalitat of Catalonia, given each side's position. And another very specific question: Will Spain meet its deficit target for 2012?

President of the Government. As regards the first question, I have never severed any points of agreement and if, at the moment, there are problems in this regard, you can rest assured that I will do everything in my power to find points of agreement which are to the benefit of all citizens. Have absolutely no doubt about that.

As regards your second question, we will know the answer to that when we have the final budget performance data from the national Government, as well as from the Social Security system, the Regional Autonomous Communities and the local authorities. What I can tell you, bearing in mind what I pointed out before, is that we have made a colossal effort-if I may say so, even though it might seem exaggerated-to lower the deficit. In other words, so much has never been asked of a country in the midst of a recession, and when there are such financing problems.

We have made a very important effort, and all I can tell you is that the European Commission has said that additional measures are not needed for 2012 and 2013, and believe me, this has been very encouraging for the Spanish Government. This is important. It has asked for them for 2014, but there is still a lot of time until 2014, and I hope that economic growth-which is also very important-will help us, too, when determining our public deficit and increasing the revenue of public administrations.

Q. Concerning the topic of deficit reduction, I would like to know whether there is still some room for increased flexibility in the deficit targets set for the Autonomous Communities, as Catalonia, for example, is now requesting.

President of the Government. As things stand today, I must tell you that we have no intention of allowing for any flexibility in deficit targets. We have no intention of doing this because we must take the following into account: a large part, not all, but a large part of the problems the Spanish economy is experiencing and which have put us in the position we are in today were caused by the public administrations spending a great deal more than they were collecting in revenue. I always quote a specific figure, as you will have heard me do many times already: in 2011, we spent 90 billion euros more than the public administrations collected in revenue; in other words, 15 trillion of the old pesetas. Imagine if a family did that with just 1,000 euros a month. That would inevitably, and can only, lead to bankruptcy.

Spending more than you earn cannot go on for very long. Moreover, that overspent money has to be borrowed, and right now, the situation in the markets makes it advisable to exercise caution. Consequently, this is a fundamental priority, as I said in response to a previous question.

The three main instruments of the Government's economic policy, which I have been referring to for years, not only since I have been in Government, are lowering the public deficit, structural reforms (especially labour reform), and restructuring the banking sector. As a result, we must take this very seriously, because this issue will be crucial for a large part of the Spanish economy's health for the next few years.

Q. I would like to ask you to look ahead a little and tell me whether, with the information you have now, you think it will be possible to lower Personal Income Tax in 2014, not raise VAT again this year, and raise pensions next year.

And do you think, since you didn't answer this before, that we will end up with six million unemployed?

President of the Government. I would like to do all of those things. Having said that-as you know, because you've studied the 2013 State Budget bill in depth-this bill states that VAT will not increase in 2013, and no mention is made of Personal Income Tax, as this is indeed an issue for 2014. However, I would like to do that.

Will we reach that figure or not? We will try to make sure that doesn't happen. As I said in my initial speech, there are still hard times ahead and we trust that in late 2013 we will be able to give some positive news, which will doubtlessly be even more positive in 2014.

Therefore, I think that making predictions or trying to foresee the future makes little sense. Nevertheless, at the moment my intention is not to increase VAT. My intention is, in 2014, to take Personal Income Tax to its previous level-but, as I said, that depends on how events unfold-and, at the beginning of the year, introduce a debate on the pension systems' sustainability in the Toledo Pact.

You all know that at the moment this is another topic of vital importance, because pensions in Spain account for more than a quarter of total public expenditure. When you look at total expenditure by our local authorities, our regional administrations and the Central Government, more than a quarter of that total is spent on pensions. This means that, obviously, we need taxpayers and we need people to retire at the age they are supposed to retire, in accordance with the law. If you look at the information for 2010 and 2009, you will see that only 50% of people who retired in those two years were 65. We have made a suggestion that is currently being debated by the Toledo Pact Commission in the Congress of Deputies. I think it is an important suggestion, on the basis of which we can have a debate concerning pension sustainability.

However, in any case and from my point of view, as I have already said on many, many occasions, if there is one fundamental priority in Spanish public expenditure, it is pensions, because pensions go towards people who have the smallest possibility of standing up for themselves. This is exactly why, in the 2012 Budget, pensions were the only item which increased and were also the only item which increased in the 2013 Budget. We have not raised pensions in line with inflation this year, but we have raised them by 2% for everyone who has a pension under 1,000 euros (approximately 67%). For the others, we raised pensions by 1%. This has not been done with any other item in these Budgets and, consequently, for myself and for the Government, this is a priority.

Moreover, something else is very important, a decision we took not very long ago, which has not been considered very significant, but actually is: It concerns the fact that from now on, the Social Security system will only pay pensions to people who have contributed to the system, and non-contributory pensions-for people who have not contributed to the system-will be paid out of tax revenues.

Therefore, I repeat, this is the Government's priority at this time.

Q. A few days ago, at the Madrid People's Party dinner, you praised Ignacio González's "brave and necessary measures". I would like to know whether you advocate extending his healthcare model throughout Spain. I would also like to know whether the Government has any report serving as a basis for defending that private healthcare management is much better than public healthcare management, and that it guarantees quality care to citizens.

Furthermore, in connection with this question, I would like to ask you about the Members of the Madrid Regional Assembly who were playing "Angry Words" yesterday during a session. Don't you think that this gives a very bad image of politics? Do you think that measures should be taken?

President of the Government. The decisions taken by the Autonomous Community of Madrid were taken while exercising the authority that corresponds it as a regional administration. At this time, I can tell you that I am concerned about citizens' rights. What I mean by this is that I don't think it is good that, as a consequence of recent events, there should be people who do not receive the same care as they used to, under normal circumstances.

I want healthcare to continue being universal, free and high quality, and there are many models for managing healthcare. If you look at the healthcare management models that exist throughout Spain, you will see that there are all types, and in Autonomous Communities governed by different parties. There are many regions where there are agreements with private hospitals so that if you are an affiliate of the Social Security system, you can receive healthcare in a private hospital. This is the case in Andalusia, Catalonia, Madrid and many other Autonomous Communities.

The important thing is that people's healthcare, which is what is really crucial, should be universal, free and high quality. From that point, if there is a problem, it would be up to the Government or the people who disagree with the Government's decisions to resolve it. However, fundamental principles must be maintained, and I think that these are indeed being maintained.

Q. In your view, what did the King mean when he spoke of the need for "politics with a capital P"?

And, if you don't mind my asking, did you have prior knowledge or were you in any way involved in the King's Christmas message?

President of the Government. Quite frankly, the speech made by the King is the King's speech, and the only thing I can say about it is that I listened very attentively, at home in Pontevedra with my family, and I thought it was very good.

Q. More than once, we have heard you speak against the public consultation that the two parties supporting the Catalan government intend to hold. We have also heard you ask the Spanish Socialist Workers' Party to explain what is their understanding of a federal model. Do you, as President of the Government, supported by an absolute majority, believe that the Constitution, as it stands at present, is capable of addressing the challenges of the next decade?

And a second question: have you made any major political mistakes this year? And if so, what were they?

President of the Government. If you ask my political opponents, I can assure you that they would go on for hours and hours.

I haven't exactly concentrated my efforts on creating tension or adding fuel to the fire. It's likely that I've done something, but I don't recall talking about this. In any event, you asked me about the Constitution: I am an unconditional supporter of the Constitution and sometimes I have the impression that we Spaniards have not realized the significance of the Constitution in our recent history and, most of all, it seems that we sometimes forget what has happened in Spain in the past.

This Constitution has had one major virtue, which is that it brought the overwhelming majority into agreement, including people from the former regime, people returning from exile and people who were new to politics, but with different perspectives on numerous issues. Among other things, this Constitution recognizes citizens' rights and freedoms; under this Constitution, Spain has the highest degree of self-government in its history and we are living in the most decentralized period of Spanish history; under this Constitution, we have joined the European Union, a space of freedom, democracy, coexistence and civilization; and under this Constitution, despite the current economic crisis, Spain has progressed enormously, because the progress we have seen in Spain over these last 30 years... Well, of course, very young people perhaps cannot see this, but Spain has made enormous progress during this time.

So, the Constitution is not completely untouchable. On the contrary, the Constitution has been amended twice, in connection with two major issues: following Maastricht, and for the Fiscal Agreement some months or little over a year ago, as you are well aware.

However, for the Constitution to be amended, there are certain prerequisites, and I think what I am saying is common sense: first, you need to be very clear about the purpose. This is very important because you can certainly say "let's amend the Constitution", but for what purpose? Second, there needs to be a consensus, in other words, agreement, the greater the majority agreement the better, and, of course, it would be highly desirable for it to enjoy the same degree of consensus as it did when it was adopted in 1978. And, finally, there's timing. So these three elements are necessary.

I don't believe that constitutional reform is the priority in Spain at the moment; that's how I feel. I think that the Constitution is perfectly capable of addressing whatever may occur in Spain over the next ten years, which is the period of time you mentioned. I'm so convinced of this because, under this Constitution, among other things, we have changed currency-look at how flexible the Constitution is. With this Constitution, we have joined the European Union, relinquishing considerable sovereignty: now, we have neither monetary policy nor exchange policy, and we have regulations that we have adopted voluntarily through treaties on budgetary and fiscal policy. So, this Constitution is perfectly adequate and I think that today's priority is political stability.

Political stability is paramount, and is a major determining factor from the point of view of how to deal with the economic crisis. A country needs to give the impression that it has set clear objectives, that people support these objectives, and that there are measures and instruments in place with which to achieve them. And, of course, that there is stability. In economic terms, stability is an enormously important factor.

So, my opinion on this question is that it is not necessary at the moment; but I have nothing against it-in fact, I voted for two constitutional reforms. However, I must stress the importance of crystal clear objectives, of consensus and of making no empty gestures on this issue, which are the rules of the game of our coexistence and what unites the Spanish people.

Q. I wanted to ask you three questions. First, you mentioned that the first half of the coming year is going to be tough and that it will be necessary to persevere with the measures and reforms that have been embarked upon. Could you tell us what type of measures? Are you talking about a greater tax burden, for example?

Second, you were very clear in saying that you are not going to be flexible about deficit targets, and for this reason I would like to know whether your Government intends to intervene in the Autonomous Communities that fail to meet this objective?

And, third, could you tell us something about your proposed reform to guarantee the stability of pensions? Will the increase or revaluation of pensions no longer be linked to the CPI [Consumer Price Index], will the periods on the basis of which pension entitlement is calculated be extended, or will raising the retirement age to 67 be accelerated?

President of the Government. The first question is what we are going to do next year. The economic policy will be the same as the economic policy we have pursued over this past year. That is to say, the main objectives are, and can only be, economic growth and job creation, and the major instruments will remain the same: first, cutting the public deficit; then, implementing the Budget Stability Act in the central Government as well as in all of the governments of the different Autonomous Communities; third, the banking sector restructuring process will continue, which, as you are aware, is no small or easy task. It is a very complex and complicated task, but one that was absolutely necessary if we are to have a financial sector that doesn't arouse mistrust, one that can finance itself and, above all, that provides loans to small and medium-sized businesses and families in order to revive the economy. And we're going to continue with structural reform.

Some of the acts that we intend to introduce are: the Draft Bill on the Streamlining and Sustainability of Local Government; the Crime Victims' Statute Act; the Market Unity Act, which is very important; the Urban Renewal, Regeneration and Renovation Act; the Free Legal Assistance Act; the Act Regulating Mutual Funds for Workplace Accidents and Illnesses and, very importantly, the reform of public administration. As you know, there is a working group that has already begun, and we believe that this is one of the major challenges of this parliamentary term. In actual fact, it has been one of the major challenges since 1978. No reform of the public administration has been undertaken in Spain, and we believe that it is necessary.

There is one issue of particular concern to me and that concerns anyone who wants to see the country improve and grow, and that is access to credit, especially for small and medium-sized businesses, which are the ones who will see us out of this crisis. So, some measures will be introduced to stimulate economic growth and there will also be measures to ensure that these small and medium-sized businesses can finance themselves and continue to export because-and I must stress this point because I've mentioned it before-the foreign trade sector is doing very well nowadays, and at present it is keeping many people in employment and ensuring that economic growth in Spain does not fall any lower than it already has.

As regards whether or not we are going to intervene, the Government has made a great effort with the Autonomous Communities, and I sincerely believe that what is being done is very good for Spain because, first, it prevents many Autonomous Communities from being in an impossible situation because they can't pay their debts, or pay anyone; so for that reason, it's a very good thing. Second, because when it comes down to it, it means that we all share a common goal, which is to have sustainable public accounts and-I'm stressing here what I said earlier-it is essential to have sustainable public accounts and not to have any major deficit or debt that could lead us into insurmountable problems.

Next year, with the Regional Liquidity Fund, known as the FLA, we are going to go to the markets so that the Autonomous Communities which have asked for this, and most of them have, can service their debts-because if they don't, you know full well what will happen and what the outcome will be-and, at the same time, cover their public deficit.

Of course, if people say, "How are they going to bring down the deficit targets?", the thing is that there isn't even enough money to cover this deficit, and it can't be borrowed. The Central State Administration itself has to borrow it, and in this regard, the primordial objective is for suppliers to be paid; that is paramount. You know that this year we created a Supplier Payment Plan for 27 billion euros of unpaid invoices; in other words, invoices that weren't anywhere. So this is a key objective for the future.

As regards whether or not to intervene, I hope it doesn't come to that and if it were to do so, we would inform you and all of your colleagues.

Looking at pensions, we are going to hold an open debate on the pension system, with the understanding that what is extremely important is that there are contributors to the Social Security system. This is key. At the end of the day, Spain's wealth depends on employment. In other words, employment means wealth for those who have jobs, but it is also means wealth for all the public services, because the public services are paid for by people in employment who make Social Security contributions and, at the same time, pay income tax, are consumers and pay VAT, etc. So, for this reason, we will hold an open debate on our pension system.

We don't intend to raise the retirement age any further-I think you asked about that. At the moment, what we are most concerned about, and what we consider most pressing, is that the retirement age be respected. At present in Spain, there are nearly 9 million people who receive a pension, and there must be-don't quote me on this but there may be-some 17 million people in the Social Security system, and those 17 million people are paying the nine million's pensions. We need more than 17 million people, and we need these people to not retire at 54, 58, 60 or 62. This is what we need. This is fair, and shows solidarity.

Q. You mentioned earlier that you hope to reach points of agreement with the regional government of Artur Más. I would like to know what points of agreement you are referring to, and whether you are referring to regional financing, for example, or to something else. Educational reform is pending. Might there be an opportunity to find a point of agreement here?

President of the Government. Points of agreement? Clearly there are things that we can agree on, and there are others that are more difficult. I'm prepared to talk about regional financing, but I already said so at the time. Talking and negotiating is one thing, and having to say yes or no to a proposal is another, because then you have no option. What I did at the time, anyone would do, even if they weren't the President of the Government. Negotiation doesn't mean "do this and if you don't, I'll do what I want." You can't do things like that. You can talk; you can discuss things and see what comes up.

What I think is most important to talk about right now is resolving the economic crisis in Catalonia, and in the whole of Spain. That is what I think is most important to talk about. Other people may want to talk about other things, because they consider them more important and they consider them priorities. I'm ready to listen. However, one thing is discussion, another is talking and quite another is the agreements that are finally reached. They're different things, but I am certainly ready, and always have been.

Q. I wanted to ask you about the justice system, which you are aware is of particular interest to me. You said that, in your opinion, the reform of the General Council of the Judiciary would not undermine judicial independence, quite the contrary in fact; yet there is considerable turmoil in this area. I wanted to know whether you agree with all these reforms to the same extent? Fees, for example, and, in short, whether you think that we are headed towards another judiciary strike, as has been declared likely, and whether this is of particular concern to you? I am aware that you come from a family of judges.

Second, with relation to this same area, I would also like to ask whether you believe the balance of powers of the state is adequate. I say this because there have been a number of incidents that have attracted attention, such as civil servants carrying out investigations on their own, without any apparent monitoring by either the governmental or judicial authorities. And also as concerns the Constitutional Court, because very frequent recourse is made to this Court, both by the opposition and by the Government. Don't you think that it is now true to say that the Constitutional Court has really become a third Chamber?

President of the Government. You asked me whether I'm concerned about strikes? Yes, quite frankly, I am. I'm not an irresponsible person. Anything that falls outside the norm worries me, because, in addition, there's always an underlying problem about which you can be right or wrong. So from that point of view, strikes will always worry me.

Let me tell you something brutally honest about taxes. When people talk about whether or not the justice system is free, you are the ones who pay for the justice system, all of us who pay taxes do. It's not free; all taxpayers pay for it, and now the proposal is that 10% of the cost of the justice system, only 10%, should be paid by the people instituting legal proceedings, rather than by those who do not. Furthermore, this 10% will be used to provide free legal assistance for people with no resources.

This amount, which those who institute legal proceedings in Spain will have to pay, is far higher than 10% in other European Union countries. If you look at Council of Europe data, the average is 29%; in Germany, these fees amount to 43%, and there are even some countries, such as Austria, where more than 100% of the cost is paid for, which is odd. So, I think that it is fair and reasonable that 10% be paid for by the people instituting legal proceedings, and the remaining 90% is met by taxpayers, because up until now, taxpayers have paid 100%.

As regards justice, you and I would both have to give a speech to each other. In the end, we would probably get nowhere; but I believe that Spain is a democracy that works fairly well. Certainly, if we go looking for problems, we would all find some; but Spain is part of the European Union, and the European Union is the largest area of coexistence, freedom, respect for citizens' rights, respect for people and respect for court rulings. That is also very important, to respect court rulings and to abide by them, as is only natural.

Everything in life can be improved, but seriously, to talk here-or to even ask-about an imbalance of powers… frankly, I think that's going too far. I think that in Spain we have a democratic system, and I don't think that there are many in the world which work better. I know that much can be said about this, but sometimes we also have to take pride in what we have achieved and, as I said earlier, what has worked well for 30 years. With problems, with difficulties, there may be things that are not very fair or even things that are unfair, but I think we have an important democratic system, and I don't think there are many other places that can take pride in having done things much better than we have in this regard.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you for your questions and for your attention. I wish all of you a happy New Year and, I hope, a better one than 2012.

Thank you.