Press conference by President of the Government following meeting with President of Regional Government of Catalonia
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed press after meeting with Catalan President Puigdemont on 20 April 2016, discussing Catalan independence and the refugee crisis.
- Main themes
- Catalonia independence question, unity of Spain, rule of law and democracy, institutional dialogue, refugee crisis, EU asylum commitments, Spain-Catalonia relations, regional cooperation
- Duration
- ~49 min
- Words
- 5,833
- Sentences
- 212
- Readability
- 55
- Grade
- 12.1
- Syntax
- 3.17
- Vocabulary
- 2.02
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
212 sentences in 77 paragraphs
President of the Government.- Ladies and gentlemen, a very good afternoon to you and thank you very much for attending this press briefing.
As you know, I have just held a meeting of an institutional nature with the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, Mr Puigdemont, and I have come here to take stock of the most important issues we tackled in the meeting.
Firstly, I want to state that I give great store to the fact that Mr Puigdemont has requested this meeting, which I have always been willing to hold. I also positively view the fact that this meeting has been held, and it has been held in a very correct manner and with absolute normality, and we have tackled, as I said before, a series of issues that I will outline shortly.
I would like to state that as usual, and I said this to him, I am willing to sit down and talk and work on all those issues that need our loyal collaboration because I have always believed that we can do more by working together.
Let me now outline some of the issues we have tackled at today's meeting.
Firstly, I explained my position to him, after he clearly outlined his position. My position is that we are in favour, and I will repeat this as often as is necessary, of the approach that you are all aware of… It is our assertion that Catalonia is part of Spain. And all of Spain, at least the vast majority of the Spanish people, feel this way. We want to continue living together, as we have done for centuries. We are the oldest nation in Europe and the country that has spent the longest time living together. Hence, I explained my position to him and the position of the vast majority of the Spanish people and that, consequently, we are going to defend our position, which is both political and personal, on the unity of Spain, on national sovereignty - what Spain is must be decided on by all the Spanish people - and also on the equality of all the Spanish people, whoever they may be, wherever they may have been born and wherever they may live.
Also, in my role as President of the Government, I said to him that it is my obligation to uphold the law and to ensure that it is upheld, and I will do that; and I have said to him that democracy does not exist without the law. Hence, I can clarify for you that our positions, as you are all aware, are distinct; they are different. Quite simply, each of us has expressed his position and I, in short, said to him what you all know and what I understand is that I am defending the opinion of the vast majority of the Spanish people; what we want, what we feel, what we are going to defend and, of course, the need for the law to be upheld because, I repeat, without the law we cannot talk about democracy.
Secondly, we have spoken about another important issue, affecting refugees. As you are aware, this is an issue on which a debate was recently held in the Lower House of Parliament and this is an issue that has taken up a considerable amount of the time of the Heads of State and Government of the different Member States of the European Union. We have held many European Council meetings in recent months at which the most important issue was that of the refugees.
I have asked for the collaboration of the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, which he has offered, in relation to this issue and I have made him aware of the following information and the best way in which I believe it is most suitable for us all to act.
Last year, we received 20,000 people, regardless of what is taking place in Syria, who have arrived through different channels to our country. Out of this number, more than 5,000 people are Syrians who have applied for asylum.
We have made a commitment to the European Union to relocate 15,868 people who have entered Europe and who we believe are entitled to asylum, and we are going to try to satisfy this right to asylum through a solution agreed on by all the Member States of the European Union. Spain has undertaken for 15,000 people to come to our country and we have also made a commitment to resettle 1,449 people, which means people who wish to ask for asylum in the European Union but who have not yet arrived.
As you are all aware, this is a process that has now commenced but this is a slow process because it is not easy. Back in the month of March we spoke with the UNHCR and we said that we are prepared to take in 285 people, through the channel of resettlement, that is, of people who are not in the European Union at this time but who have applied for asylum. Hence, we are waiting for the UNHCR to notify us and then this resettlement of people will take place.
We have also notified the Greek authorities that we are now ready to take in 150 people. To date, we have not received a response to enable us to do this, but we believe that this will also take place shortly.
There is one issue that is very important. This is a very difficult process; this is a very complex process; this is a process in which things must be done correctly and I explained this to the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, I have asked for his support and he has understood this issue and understands how things are being done at a European level.
The European Union has appointed a representative to get in touch with those countries where people have arrived who have applied for asylum and with those countries, such as Turkey, where there are many people who wish to enter the European Union to seek asylum.
Each nation must appoint a representative to coordinate with the European Union, which we have duly done, and to coordinate with those countries where people may come from to seek asylum and also to coordinate within Spain with the regional governments, non-governmental organisations and local authorities. This point of contact in Spain, this person who will take on this responsibility, is the Secretary-General for Immigration and Emigration of the Ministry of Employment and Social Security. A committee has been set up there which includes the directors-general of all the different autonomous regions and that is where work will be done on this issue. And I believe that, if we all work together and each member contributes what he or she can or wishes to contribute, then undoubtedly, this process which, I repeat, is difficult and complex, will be carried through much more effectively for us and also for those people who are seeking asylum in our country.
The work carried out by the NGOs, who logically are very familiar with this issue because they see it every day, is very important; they are the people who know the true situation and they are the ones who work on this every day. And on Friday we will call for a round of aid, for a sum of 83 million euros, for non-governmental organisations so that they can carry on their work as effectively as possible.
Hence, what I have requested on this matter, as I would ask the rest of the regional governments, is for coordination. If everyone tackles this individually, then it will undoubtedly be very difficult to resolve such a complicated situation as this.
We also spoke about energy poverty. I explained to him the energy policy undertaken by this government and the difficulties we have had in recent years with an accumulated debt of some 26 billion euros and a deficit that was going to rise by 10 billion euros each year. We have approved an energy reform and by doing this we have avoided the escalation of electricity prices. The system is now balanced and the latest figures published by the National Statistics Institute (Spanish acronym: INE) shows that the electricity bill has dropped by 16% in the last quarter, which is a very positive figure and I hope that this continues to hold true in recent months.
Fourthly, we also spoke about a series of sundry issues. I will not list all of them, but what I do want to say is that we have reached an agreement whereby the Vice-President of the Government and the Vice-President of the Regional Government of Catalonia will meet up to tackle all these very different issues in more detail, ranging from certain transfers which the Regional Government of Catalonia maintains are pending, through to different investments to be made.
I explained to him the commitment we have made in terms of investments in Catalonia in recent years which although, as you are aware, these have been years in which we have suffered major budgetary difficulties, we have also been very active. In the end, the high-speed railway (Spanish acronym: AVE) now reaches France and the four provincial capitals of Catalonia. In the part of the Mediterranean Corridor that falls in Catalonia, all of the works have been put out to tender. The rail shuttle between Barcelona city and El Prat airport, which was one of the most reiterated requests, and which is undoubtedly an important public work, is now under way.
But, I repeat, I am not going to go into detail, because I don't believe it is necessary. What is important is that there is an intention to jointly review what can be done, and logically, what cannot be done.
Finally, he raised an issued that the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia calls the "judicialisation of politics". I have said that I am in agreement, but there is something that is very important, which is that politics cannot exist without the law being upheld.
During the course of this legislature, the Regional Government has lodged 49 appeals before the Constitutional Court against State laws, while we have lodged 29 appeals. It is clear that an effort should be made by both parties, and it is also clear that the law comes above any other consideration, although the ideal situation is for there to be lowest possible number of conflicts.
One issue is key for me, which is the outlook for the Spanish economy, its economic growth and job creation over the coming years. This, I repeat, is the main priority, as it has been for the last four years and will be for the next four years.
I explained several things to the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia. Economic growth for this year, for 2016, after the latest assessments made by the government, is forecast to stand at 2.7%. This would be the second year with the greatest economic growth, after last year, 2015, since 2007. It is very important to recall that during the years 2009, 2010, 2011, 2012 and 2013, five years in total, Spain had negative economic growth, and hence, well-being and wealth were lost. Growth of 1.4% was posted in 2014; 3.2% last year, in 2015, and this year we expect to post economic growth of 2.7%.
It is important to recall that the forecast for the Eurozone average is 1.5%, in other words, 1.2% less than for Spain. And it is important to recall the forecasts for the major economies of the Eurozone: the forecast for Germany is 1.5%; the forecast for France is 1.1% and the forecast for Italy is 1%.
Secondly, the forecast for job creation for this year, for 2016, stands at around 450,000 new jobs. There is another figure that is important: Spain shed jobs each year between 2007 and 2013, 2014 was the first year in which jobs were created. Then, in 2015, even more jobs were created; it was our best year ever. Jobs will also be created this year, as I said, and unemployment will gradually fall. The unemployment rate this year will fall below 20%, while I would remind you that it stood at 25.8% in 2012. So, this year it will stand below 20%, and the only other thing I would say in this respect is that in the years 2017, 2018 and 2019 we will need to continue making a major effort to reduce it even further than the final figure at the end of 2016.
I explained to him that the figures for the foreign trade sector are very positive and that this year we believe that the foreign trade sector will have a surplus of 2.4%, which would be the fifth straight year in a row with a surplus. This says a great deal about Spanish exporters and about the competitiveness of the Spanish economy. I would remind you that in the years 2007, 2008, 2009, 2010 and 2011 there was a shortfall in the balance of payments, which clearly showed a problem of competitiveness vis-á-vis the rest of the countries of the European Union.
In terms of the public deficit, this is a key issue. I would like to make a few comments about this.
In 2009, our country's public deficit stood at 11%, an absolutely unsustainable figure, I repeat 11%, while in 2011 it stood at 9.3%. Last year, 2015, it stood at 5%, which means that in just four years the public deficit was reduced by 4.3 points, which is good if you take into account that two of these four years were years of negative economic growth and hence years with falling revenue; these were years of recession. Last year, it stood at 5%, we reduced it from 5.8% in 2014 to 5%. We have not met our commitments to the European Union, and hence, we must continue to work on this and forge a path towards a situation of below 3%, which is where we want to be and where we can be satisfied. The target for this year is 3.6% and the target for next year, for 2017, will be 2.9%.
It is important that the regional governments make an effort, as it is that the local authorities do and that Central Government continues to do so. And I have asked for his collaboration on this issue which, I repeat, is very important for our country.
We then spoke about public revenue, about public spending, about servicing debt, pensions and unemployment, but the most important thing is that I have asked for his collaboration on the issue of the public deficit and I have also asked for his collaboration in drawing up the new model of regional financing.
At the latest Fiscal and Financial Policy Council, which took place last Friday, an agreement was reached to set up a group of experts so that the new government, when it is formed, with whatever formation it may have, has a workable project that allows it to take decisions which are useful and effective for everyone and, if possible, for this to be consensual. We have asked that the regional governments appoint whoever they consider to be the most suitable and opportune to form part of this committee of experts. I believe that this is the most sensible and reasonable solution, and the one that should be adopted. This is an issue which, as you are aware, is very complicated and very difficult. And more so given the nature of the situation at this time, because we have still not recovered from the fall in revenue suffered in the years 2008 and 2009.
Let me share a fact with you that is very significant: we have still not reached the level of revenue of 2007. 70 billion euros in revenue alone were lost between the years 2007 and 2009. We have gradually made some recovery: in 2015 revenue stood at 413 billion euros; in 2014 this was 401 billion; in 2013, 394 billion and in 2012, 391 billion. But, I repeat, in 2007 this stood at 442 billion euros.
Hence, the challenge and the goal is to grow and to create jobs, and this is a key target in and of itself; but moreover, this is a key target because it is what allows us to fill the coffers to then be able to maintain the major key public services, which is what the vast majority of the Spanish people demand.
In short, I believe that these are, explained in summary, the most important issues that we have tackled at today's meeting. I repeat, I have defended the position that everyone knew I was going to defend, because that is what I believe in - the unity of Spain and the sovereignty of the Spanish people. We want to continue together as we have always done. We have done great things, we have done many things in our recent history and we are undoubtedly in a position to have a great future ahead of us if we do things well and form stable, serious governments that generate confidence and that are able of setting goals and adopting measures to achieve these goals in the near future.
Q.- I wanted to know whether Mr Puigdemont proposed to you his commitment or his intention to hold a referendum of the self-determination of Catalonia as something indisputable.
I also wanted to know if you had the impression, despite this, that the relationship between Moncloa Palace and the Regional Government of Catalonia is now unfrozen.
President of the Government.- Yes, Mr Puigdemont says that it is necessary to hold a referendum and I told him that I did not agree, and that I don't agree with any type of referendum in which the Spanish people as a whole are deprived of the right to decide on the future of their own country. I believe that that was made clear and I believe that things, in order to avoid a misunderstanding, are best made clear. That is the position I believe in and, furthermore, that I am obliged to defend. Hence, on this issue he has maintained his position and I have maintained mine.
As regards whether relations are now more fluid, 7 million people live in Catalonia and they have their own problems, as do the rest of us who live in other parts of Spain, and the obligation of those who govern, even though they are in disagreement on such key issues as the one you have enquired after, is to try to do things to the benefit of the people of Catalonia, who are also Spanish while I am also the leader of the citizens of Catalonia.
Hence, we will work together. A meeting will be held between the Vice-President of the Government and the Vice-President of the Regional Government of Catalonia. We will reach agreement on some issues while on others we will almost certainly not reach agreement, but there are some major issues that affect us all and I have mentioned just two of them: the refugee crisis which, I repeat, is one of the main issues, not just for now but for a long time to come; and the issue of regional financing on which I would say it is almost essential and absolutely necessary to reach an understanding, and bad news if we were unable to do this.
Q.- In the event that the Regional Government or Parliament of Catalonia were to go ahead with the pro-sovereignty process, would this influence the talks between the Vice-President of the Government and the Vice-President of the Regional Government of Catalonia to reach agreements on the issues of investments, the transfer of powers, etc?
On another note, have you spoken about the general political situation of the investiture of the President of the Government?
President of the Government.- I hope that the occurrence you have mentioned doesn't take place. I hope that the law is upheld in Spain and I hope that its governors, who have added responsibility, follow the law. Hence, I hope that we do not reach a situation that forces us to take another type of measure. And we have not reached that state; he has simply expressed his position to me, which I was aware of, and I have expressed my position, which he was aware of.
As regards general political affairs, I have laid out for him the position of the People's Party, which is exactly the same position as I have held since 21 December, and which holds true today. We could have saved ourselves a great deal of problems, of tales, of propaganda, of publicity and, in short, I don't know how to describe it any other way, if we had all been aware since the beginning that, if we don't want to hold elections again, which I believe makes no sense, the most sensible and reasonable option would have been to form a government such as prevails in the majority of countries in Europe.
On 21 December, I proposed a great coalition which the Socialist Party refused to accept. They didn't even want to hear us out. We have sent them a document which they haven't responded to and even now I continue to maintain that the best thing for the general interests of the Spanish people is to have a government in Spain such as exists in the most important countries in Europe; I have listed them on many occasions, including the government such as exists in Germany, in Austria, in Finland, in Holland and in as many as 15 of the 28 Member States of the European Union.
Hence, this remains our position, it is well-known and it is incomprehensible that no heed has been paid to it and that we will probably face an electoral process that no-one wants, at least not me.
Q.- Mr President of the Government, in relation to the national political situation and the meeting you have held with Mr Puigdemont, I would like to know whether you are going to finally take the opportunity to call Mr Pedro Sánchez in the coming days or in the coming hours, or whether you have discounted making this call in the end.
Secondly, this is the first opportunity we have had to ask you about the resignation of Mr Soria, and I would like to know whether you asked the former Minister for Industry to leave and whether you agree that no member of the government should have ties with tax havens.
President of the Government.- Your first question was whether I am going to call Mr Sánchez? Of course I have been asked that on so many occasions, and I have tried to call him on as many occasions, and my position is well-known and hence I am no longer going to take part in any fun and games that lead nowhere. But if it is of any use what I am saying here, this would be the umpteenth invitation to him to avoid holding new elections and to form a moderate government, which sets certain goals, which establishes certain measures and which generates a minimum level of confidence both within Spain and abroad, to investors and to the markets. This would be my umpteenth invitation. If he remains steadfast in his resolution not to speak to me then it is clear that I cannot do anything. And I won't go into any further details.
As regards Mr Soria's resignation, Mr Soria has resigned. He told me that, he told me that he wanted to resign. The reasons he gave me are exactly the same as I conveyed to the Spanish public, which I have respected, and the only thing I can say now is that, as well as being a good friend, he has served this government very well. He has had to run a very difficult ministerial department, because the energy reform was certainly not an easy issue, with an accumulated debt of 26 billion euros and a deficit that would have amounted to 10 billion euros each year; the tourism sector is a key sector for Spain, we are breaking all records; the industrial sector…
He has been a good minister, he has explained his reasons for resigning, he has shown a level of discipline that other political leaders have not shown and, I repeat, I respect the explanations he has given. And I have nothing further to add.
Q.- President of the Government, from your words I have understood that you are not going to call, or send a letter, to Mr Sánchez, and you send out this invitation to see if he responds in some way.
President of the Government.- I am not going into further detail. If I do something else, I will inform you.
Q.- I then had some more questions for you. I wanted to ask you why you have decided to attend a press briefing today when you don't tend to give one after receiving any regional president.
Then I wanted to ask you what differences you have found between the approach taken by Mr Puigdemont and Mr Artur Mas.
President of the Government.- It seemed to me that this was a good time to give a press briefing. I hope that no-one will reproach me for that. Mr Puigdemont has come here; it is the first time that he has been here, to Moncloa Palace, and he has raised some very important issues, because the issues I have mentioned are certainly not minor issues, particularly some of them. So, it seemed important to me to appear here before all of you. Aside from that, I have nothing further to add on this issue.
As regards the differences, we are not going to get into personal matters. We must try to preserve personal relations and then each one can think… There are two things, personal relations and the law, and this should always be maintained and then, if people think differently it is because we are different.
Q.- Returning to the matter of the meeting, as you have said well, your positions are both well-known on the subject of Catalonia. So, I would like to know, now that you have expressed these matters with clarity and forthrightly, and you have once again reaffirmed the prevalence of the law, of the Constitution and of the rule of law, have you said anything else to the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, in the sense of asking "if you can withdraw or put to one side the issue of a referendum on self-determination, I would be prepared to speak about more issues, and we could tackle the issue of the Constitution…"? If, in addition to the well-known positions, you proposed to him, "is it essential for you to maintain the referendum on self-determination or can you put this to one side and speak about other things?", and whether you would be prepared to do that?
On another note, I don't know whether you have seen before coming out, President of the Government, that it would seem that Podemos and the United Left have reached an agreement regarding the possibility of standing in the elections together, we still don't know under what formula, and whether this would to some extent affect the issue of what you could also offer Mr Sánchez.
President of the Government.- You would have to ask Mr Sánchez that. At any event, my proposal remains the same, I repeat, the same as the one we made following the meeting of the Executive Committee the day after the elections: what is sensible, logical, reasonable, what the vast majority appreciate should be done in a situation like this is to do what is done in Europe. But that depends on Mr Sánchez.
Mr Sánchez has devoted his time to other issues that weren't going to go anywhere while I have maintained my position, but don't ask me for much more. And will this influence it? We don't know. Nor am I clear as to whether this coalition between radicals and extremists is a closed deal. The only thing I have clear is that it would be a dreadful coalition for the general interests of Spain, for the general interests of the Spanish people, for economic recovery and for the well-being of us all.
In relation to your first question, I am prepared to talk because, among other things, that is my obligation. 7 million Spaniards live in Catalonia and, as I said before, I am the President of the Government of Spain, and hence, I am also the leader of all of these Spaniards, whether or not they have voted for the list that I head up. Hence, I am under an obligation to try to resolve the problems they may have and to do that, if I have to see Mr Puigdemont, then I will do that and try to reach an understanding.
In relation to the other issue, there was nothing else to say. I clearly explained my position to him and I then told him that, as President of the Government, I was obliged to uphold the law. And there were no more considerations on this matter. I hope that this will be paid heed to, because, in all honesty, it is not going anywhere. I believe that this is very bad for the people of Spain and very bad, most particularly, for those Spaniards who live in Catalonia.
Q.- Two questions about your meeting. During the meeting, the government, the presidency of the government, has announced a new deficit path. It has been said that this was tackled in the meeting with Mr Puigdemont. What attitude was there? Tell us, has he asked for a slightly greater reduction for the regions? Was an agreement, an understanding, reached? Do you believe that the possibility of collaboration exists on this point?
Secondly, we have also been told about the issue of the judicialisation of political life, which was one of the questions that the regional president raised. Have you agreed on any issue of trying to resolve litigation before it reaches the courts? You have listed how many claims have been lodged by the Regional Government of Catalonia and how many you have lodged, but tell us, ultimately you have the appeals that you make against certain actions that you consider affect the process. How do things stand on this point? Did you reach any form of agreement?
President of the Government.- The issue of the deficit is key. I give this issue great importance, as do many people and rightly so; Europe views this as important, as do the markets, the ratings agencies, the European Commission, and indeed all of us.
The public deficit cannot be solely and exclusively reduced as a result of decisions taken by the government. As in so many things it falls to all of us. That is, the public deficit is not a deficit of the Government of Spain; it is the deficit of the Government of Spain, plus all the local authorities, plus all the regional governments, plus the deficit of the Social Security system.
In 2015, we managed to decrease the deficit from 5.8% to 5%; in other words, we are on the right path. I would have liked to have seen it fall even more. The target for this year was 2.8%, but what we are proposing now is 3.6%, and, I repeat, below 3% for 2017.
In principle, the deficit of the regional governments, the forecast, was going to be 0.3% but we are going to increase this, it will be above 0.3% in the end. The Government of Spain will make an effort in this regard. The other day we took a decision on non-availability for the sum of 2 billion euros, which is 0.2% of the public deficit, and I have asked the regional governments for their collaboration. These are difficult times. 2012 and 2013 were much more difficult, but things are still tough now, albeit less so. But this is where we are gambling with the recovery of the Spanish economy.
If we are growing more than anyone else and if we are creating more jobs than anyone else, it is not down to luck; it is because all of our public authorities have made an effort and, above all, because the Spanish people have done things well. And now we must persevere with this effort. I repeat, I assign great importance to this issue and I hope to receive the collaboration of everyone, not only of the President of the Regional Government of Catalonia, but also of the rest of the presidents of the other regions. Of course, the government will also meet its commitments and I am sure that the local authorities, who have been fantastic in this whole issue of reducing the deficit, will continue with their efforts in the future.
As regards the second issue, there are indeed 49 appeals by one party and another 29 by the other. Now, it is clear that the Constitutional Court has this role to play. Its basic functions are to resolve conflicts of powers and then to oversee that the laws adapt to the Constitution. But I agree that we should make an effort to reduce litigation. With some regions we also have a lot of litigation and with others less so. I believe that this requires that we all make an effort and these efforts, when we are talking about two parties, should be made by both parties. Let's see whether we are capable of doing this in the future, but, I repeat, we must all respect the law.
Q.- I would like to know whether you share the opinion of Esperanza Aguirre on whether the Minister for the Treasury, Cristóbal Montoro, should resign because of the leaks from his ministerial department which would seem to have seriously annoyed, among others, the former President of the Government, José María Aznar.
President of the Government.- I have not heard these statements and hence I am not going to fall into the trap of discussing rumours, because that makes no sense. I never do that, as you full well know.
The only thing I can say in relation to this issue is that Mr Montoro has been a wonderful Minister for the Treasury and the Public Administration Services. It has fallen to him to head up the public accounts at the most difficult time in recent decades in our country and he has been one of the people responsible for the tremendous reduction in the deficit of this country. I repeat, he has headed up the most difficult and the most complex ministerial department, and he has done this very satisfactorily
Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much.