Press conference by the President of the Government and the Secretary-General of the Organisation for Economic Co-operation and Development (OECD)
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy held a joint press conference with OECD Secretary-General Ángel Gurría in Madrid on 4 March 2012 to discuss Spain's reform programme and OECD support.
- Main themes
- Fiscal consolidation, structural economic reforms, OECD support for Spain, labour market reform, financial sector reform, Spanish economic recovery, public deficit reduction, competitiveness and productivity, employment, Eurozone situation, education and public policy
- Duration
- ~41 min
- Words
- 4,904
- Sentences
- 186
- Readability
- 54
- Grade
- 11.5
- Syntax
- 3.13
- Vocabulary
- 2.02
The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.
Other186 sentences in 81 paragraphs
President of the Government. A very good day to you all and thank you very much for attending this press conference.
As you are all aware, the Secretary-General of the OECD, Ángel Gurría, and I have just held a meeting. He will address you first, followed by me, and after that we will answer your questions.
Mr. Gurría. Thank you very much, Mr. President of the Government. It is an honour to be here with you.
First of all, Mr. President of the Government, I want to thank you for the opportunity to share some moments of your very busy schedule, to present and offer you the OECD's support for the ambitious reform programme being undertaken by your Government.
Secondly, I wanted to say to you that we appreciate and welcome the reforms being undertaken in the labour markets, the work done on the Budget and regarding the reform of the financial sector.
We have spoken with the President of the Government that, given the competence of the OECD on a series of matters of a short-term fiscal or financial nature, but, in particular, of a medium- and long-term nature, which is where the OECD focuses its work, we would like to offer you our support for the reform plan and to accompany Spain in all its future reforms, in all its efforts, on which the President of the Government places particular emphasis, in addition to current economic matters which, of course, will need to be overcome and which will need to be driven forward particularly looking to the medium and long term of the Spanish economy, in matters of the competitiveness of the Spanish economy, the productivity of the Spanish economy in the hope that the Spanish economy recovers its vibrancy, as well as certain other matters aside from economic growth, such as employment.
We have commented with the President of the Government that the OECD has… You are aware of the work that we do on such matters as education, matters which constitute competitiveness in the economy, including the regulating and de-regulating certain services; the work done with public authorities in all our member countries; the work done with the aim of helping coordinate different types of public policy, and in relation to the work done by neighbouring countries in the region, particularly in Europe, where we closely monitor not only each member of the OECD but also Europe as a whole and the Eurozone.
Finally, Mr. President of the Government, ladies and gentlemen, I want to say to you that we at the OECD consider Spain has sent a very important message and has given an example of a combination, firstly, of great awareness and clarity of the matters that need to be tackled; secondly of its political will to do just this and, thirdly, of technical competence regarding how to do this and of the instruments needed to carry this out. Mr. President of the Government, ladies and gentlemen, the OECD is very proud to be able to assist in these efforts.
President of the Government . Once again, a very good day to you all.
I would especially like to thank the Secretary-General of the OECD, Ángel Gurría. I would like to tell you all that the meeting we have just held has been interesting, fruitful and useful, as always. I would like to make this very clear. The truth is that I feel very reassured and absolutely convinced that this meeting will be good for the future of Spain. I don't know whether for the OECD as well, I would think so, but for Spain it will be very important.
We have exchanged a series of opinions on the global economic situation, on the situation of the Eurozone, and particularly, as is logical and you can perfectly appreciate, on the situation in Spain.
We have spoken about what the Spanish Government is doing on matters of economic policy and what we intend to do in the future. I will briefly summarise some of the things that I have conveyed to the secretary-General and then I will make some points about certain agreements that we have reached which, I repeat, I believe will be important for our country.
I think that you are all well aware of the economic situation in Spain, hence I will not go into detail. This Government has made certain proposals because that was our commitment to the people of Spain, to tackle the economic crisis, generate economic growth and hence, create jobs.
We said that there are two fundamental instruments: firstly, fiscal consolidation, in other words, budgetary stability with reasonable levels of public debt and public deficit - that is the first instrument for growth and job creation - and secondly, structural reforms of our economy.
Over these last two months, in which we have led this Government, we have done certain things - I will briefly summarise them - as I summarised them to the Secretary-General of the OECD - and we have certain other proposals for the future.
I will start with fiscal consolidation. You are aware that Spain made a commitment, in which it believed, to reducing the public deficit last year, in 2011, to 6%; this year to 4.4% and next year to 3.3%.
In my Investiture Speech, I announced the steps that we would take and which I then reiterated on a number of occasions, and I will summarise them now. The public deficit last year was not 6%, as you know, but 8.5%, as we know now. But on 30 December, aware of the fact that the public deficit was not going to be 6%, but rather that it was going to be closer to 8% - which was the figure we were working with when we came to power - we took a first decision to reduce the public deficit by 1.5%. We did this on 30 December in what we can call the first meeting of the Council of Ministers.
The announcements that I made subsequently were the following: we would wait until the European Commission made its forecast for growth in Spain and the rest of the EU countries, but above all in Spain, for this year. And afterwards I said that we would approve the macro-economic table, the ceiling on expenditure and the public deficit for this year, we would submit this to Parliament in March for its approval and on 30 March we would approve the Budget for this year.
That is exactly what we have been doing and what we have done. On 23 February, the European Commission announced that growth in Spain would be a negative 1%; before the International Monetary Fund had said a negative 1.7% and the Bank of Spain had said a negative 1.5%.
Once we had been informed of the Commission's forecast on 23 February, seven days later, the Council of Ministers did what we said we would do and present the macro-economic table, announced the ceiling on expenditure and set the public deficit target for this year. That is what we did. We said growth would be -1.7%, set the deficit target at -5.8% for next year and announced budgetary figures: a 4.7% reduction on the start of last year which, as regards the ministerial departments is a reduction of around 10% in total. In other words, the ministerial departments that I preside over will spend 10% less next year.
And at the end of March, as we also announced, we will present the Budget.
In other words, as far as this is concerned, the Government has acted in accordance with the plan we had announced to the public, and it will continue to do so in the future.
Later, in the month of April, we will present the Commission with our Stability Plan and the National Plan of Reforms and we will speak with the Commission, which will make its evaluation and proposal in the month of May that it will present to the European Council at the end of June. That is exactly what needs to be done.
Hence, we are taken the steps that needed to be taken and that we had promised to take. In April we will present the Commission with our Budget and the whole National Plan of Reforms, in May this will be evaluated and in June it will be discussed at the European Council.
I would like to say that, when we announced our deficit objective for this year at last Friday's Council of Ministers, we were fully complying with our voluntarily-assumed commitments to the European Union. I would like to say the following in this regard: the Government that I lead has considered, and continues to consider that it is essential to return to the path of complying with the public deficit, and that is why, on 30 December, as I said earlier, we made our first reduction of 1.5%.
And secondly, I would like to say that the decision taken last Friday and announced to the public, is a decision that everyone understands and which is simply common sense; but that also complies with the recommendation that the European Council made to Spain in 2009, its recommendation on reducing the deficit by 1.5% on average annually; the structural deficit I mean.
Since the previous Government didn't make this reduction in the year 2011, we will have to make the whole reduction in 2012, more than 3.5% over the two years in structural deficit reduction; 3.9% to be precise. And hence, we are complying with the recommendations of the European Council.
Finally, as I said earlier, the ceiling on spending and the deficit objective represent a 4.7% decrease on the ceiling on spending for last year and a 12.5% reduction on expenditure available to the ministerial departments.
Hence, I repeat what is well-known by everyone: our commitment to reducing the public deficit. In April, we will present our Stability Programme and, I say it again, our Programme of reforms to the Commission, in the same way as the other countries; in May the Commission will assess all the countries and in June we will hold the debate at the European Council. I repeat the fact that Spain will comply with its commitments.
Secondly, as I said earlier, it is not enough to just reduce the public deficit, structural reforms also need to be made. I would like to say that this Government does not announce structural reforms, this Government makes and approves structural reforms. We already have the "golden rule" in place in our Constitution that was signed in Brussels not long ago, last weekend in fact, by the Heads of State and Government of the European Union who wanted to - all except two.
We have approved the Budgetary Stability Act that establishes and sets criteria to reduce the deficit and the public debt for the coming years. We are doing this because we believe in this. Of course, Spain has never grown when it has had high public debt and it has never grown when it has had a high public deficit. And we are doing this because we have committed to doing this, because we wanted to do this when we joined the European institutions. Firstly at Maastricht some years ago now.
Hence, as well as this, the first reform.
The second reform is the restructuring of the financial system by Royal Decree Law, with the aim of dispelling any doubts surrounding the financial system, of valuing assets at real prices, of reorganising institutions and fostering mergers. The final objective is returning credit to small- and medium-sized enterprises and to entrepreneurs.
The third reform is the labour reform, which is important, which is demanded by all and which the whole world knew was necessary, because Spain cannot be in the situation of having more than five million Spaniards who want to work but can't find work without the Government moving a muscle to rectify that.
I believe that this labour reform, when economic activity begins to move again, will be incredibly useful for creating jobs in our country. I say this with absolute conviction. That is why we have approved it and for no other reasons: to create jobs in our country.
Furthermore, we have made a far-reaching reform - I know that this is a matter which is apparently not very important and that it is also a matter that may have some very technical components - of the regulatory authorities to make them more efficient, to make them more competent, to depoliticise them, so that they are cheaper to maintain and so that there are far fewer than before in Spain.
We will also approve a law to support entrepreneurs shortly, which we announced in my Investiture Speech, and later on, before the summer, we will continue with the reform of Central Government institutions; with the reform of institutions in the autonomous regions, agreed to avoid duplication, and we will try to make a far-reaching reform of our education system to fight against something as unpleasant, sad and tough for the future of young Spaniards and for the future of Spain as the school drop-out rate of 30%.
These are the proposals being made by the Government of Spain. I would thank the Secretary-General of the OECD for his kind words on the reform project and on our work together in the future. The OECD is a very important institution, which is well tuned in to the way of the world and is aware of everything going on in different parts of the world, of the reforms that are needed by economies, of how these are tackled by the different countries. Of course I am greatly interested in accepting the offer of the extensive knowledge and experience of the OECD that has been made to me. Hence, some of my collaborators will shortly go there, to Paris, because, I repeat, we believe that this could be very useful, important and interesting for Spain.
I believe I have run on a bit in my speech. I apologise but I was interested in making certain things clear which I am wholly convinced by.
Thank you very much; we will now take your questions.
Q. I would like to ask you, Mr. President of the Government, if you can really count on the support of the main European leaders regarding this figure of reducing the deficit by 5.8%; in other words, was it agreed beforehand that Spain could present this figure?
I would also like to know whether there is any possibility that the effort the autonomous regions must make will be relaxed at all, because what with the savings and the adjustments they will have to make, this will probably affect expenditure on social matters - I don't know if you agree with that - and whether you think there is some margin of flexibility to the demands weighing on them.
President of the Government. The procedure is the one I stated. I like procedures because I like games to have rules and I always try to follow procedure.
I announced some time back that we were going to wait for the growth forecast, I said that, and then I announced that we were going to approve a ceiling on expenditure, the macro-economic table and also the public deficit. It was necessary to do that, among other things because Parliament must approve this ceiling on expenditure, this macro-economic table and this deficit objective. So the dates were well established and they remain so because we will present our Stability Programme and our National Plan on Reforms to the Commission in April.
So I don't need to make pacts and I hope this is well construed. I am neither making pacts nor breaking pacts. I act and the National Parliament does what it thinks is logical and reasonable; we will then be subject to evaluation, together with the other EU countries, in April - that is not something new but something well established - and that is when we will speak with the Commission. I am absolutely convinced that we will do sensible and reasonable things because, fortunately, people are sensible and reasonable.
But that cannot be construed as people making decisions here or that one does what one wants. No, one does what one feels is sensible, logical and reasonable, on the basis, I repeat, that if there is one thing I cannot be accused of, it is of not being committed to fiscal consolidation and budgetary consolidation. But moreover, as I have just said, we are complying to the letter with our commitments, because the recommendation made by the Council, made to the Government when the former President of the Government, Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero, was in office in 2009, I would ask that you read it and you will clearly be able to see that Spain is meeting its commitments. It is another matter whether Spain met its commitments in 2011, but of course this year we are meeting our commitments with the structural deficit reduction that I referred to. And, of course, our objective for next year, for 2013, is to reach a public deficit of 3%.
Hence, I am very relaxed on this matter. The decisions we are taking are thought out.
The effort that needs to be made, and everyone knows this, is great. In other words, all the ministerial departments will need to reduce their expenditure by 10% on average, some more and others less. This is a big effort. And the autonomous regions will also need to make a major effort and the local authorities as well. The deficit objective for this year is 1.3% but I believe that what is now being proposed is to hit 1.5%.
But, I repeat, the Government takes responsibility for all this. I am not going to say "what is important to me is my deficit and not the others' deficit" because, when I go to Europe or when I speak with others, I represent the Government of Spain and hence the deficit of the Local Council of Pontevedra - I use this example because it is my local council - is also mine, as it is the Government of Spain's.
We are trying to help the autonomous regions and the local councils. We have approved, which is a complex and difficult operation, as you are aware, a regulation whereby the suppliers of local authorities and autonomous regions can do something as reasonable as collect on their debts and I believe that this will undoubtedly be of great relief to them. But this is not giving money away, it is a loan. I want the public authorities in Spain to pay their suppliers and hence, when we draft the Transparency Act, it will be prohibited to commit to expenses that aren't provided for in the budget. That won't happen.
Hence, we assume our responsibility as the Government. The problem of the autonomous regions and the local authorities is also our problem. This is a State and we take decisions so that we can all try to extricate this country from the difficult situation in which it finds itself. I repeat, with a pre-conceived, well thought out plan that is being complied with.
Q. Mr. President of the Government, two assessments on two matters. Firstly, it would seem that the performance of the Spanish risk premium has been a little better than the Italian performance.
(…)
President of the Government. The risk premium today should be approximately…, i don't know if it stood at approximately 315, and Italy's one a little higher. Really that is a situation for us but, at any event, it has been much worse. But that can change.
The key to convincing the markets, which is the same as the key to financing ourselves and obtaining that finance at a reasonable price, is to take governing seriously, to take the bull by the horns and reaffirm one's commitments; today I have referred to fiscal consolidation and to the reforms.
At the moment, with a risk premium that stands at three hundred and a bit basis points, this means financing ourselves at a price of close to 5%, I cannot be pleased with that, but it is true that recently the trend has improved and anything that means an improvement pleases me, the same as it does anyone else. I would also like the Italian risk premium and indeed that of all countries to improve as soon as possible.
Just imagine, you have heard me say on many occasions that we need to sort out the matter of Greece, and you have often heard me welcome, because they are doing it very well, the major effort being made by our neighbours, the Portuguese.
Hence, just as in Spain, we have to work together - the autonomous regions, the local authorities and the Spanish central Government. In Europe, we all have to continue working in the same direction and we must be more flexible, we must be quicker and we must make reforms and assume our commitments. That is what I am working on.
Let's hope the risk premium drops. I should say that all the issues made by Spain this year have been at a lower price than in the past, we have managed to place all the money that we sought to place and that is a step in the right direction. But, of course, we mustn't ever let our guard down. I think that the risk premium has dropped a little today and that pleases me. I would like it to drop a lot more, as you would expect, but it doesn't depend on me.
(…)
Mr. Gurría. If you will allow me to make a comment regarding the subject of risk. All the things that have been decided and defined over the course of the last few days and weeks are taking place very close to us. The subject of Greece should be resolved in the coming days and it is almost ready to be launched on the markets. As regards the rescue package for Greece, what was done was to agree the terms.
The package for Greece must be now be offered to the creditors, it must be subscribed by the creditors, they must accept the exchange and then, after the exchange the one hundred million euros of Greek debt will be reduced, which will in the end allow, together with the Greek policies, that it falls to a rate of…
So when did the firewall take place? It has not happened yet, but progress has been made in the recent discussions, in the latest debates - Minister de Guindos was in Mexico a few days ago and we were also present there - and progress was made on the firewalls and there is a growing conviction that the firewalls need to be sufficiently high, extensive, broad and far-reaching so that they can indeed operate as firewalls and avoid speculation. This is taking place as we speak.
The matter of the banks is also taking place as we speak. In other words, emphasis was placed on capital and suddenly they realised that what was about to cause the crisis was liquidity. Now the matter of liquidity has been tackled and was tackled resoundly, with one trillion US or one billion Spanish in the fund, at three years and at 1%. What this obviously does is reduce the pressure on the financial systems, which are also involved in a country's economic activity, with bank loans and with the very stability itself of the banking system. This is happening and this took place only a few days ago.
And then there is the matter of the International Monetary Fund, of whether or not it will pay out the 500 billion, etc. and whether China will join… That is a debate that is also actively taking place as we speak.
What is happening is that the environment is being configured, as well as by the above, by the specific matters of short-, medium- and long-term structural policies being announced by countries, and by the perception that is generated according to the extent to which countries are announcing their policies.
In the case of Spain, it has taken part in all the processes involving Greece, the firewalls and the banks, but it doesn't have the last word in all these matters. It forms a part of a union of countries in which it has a voice and where it calls on this to happen as soon as possible but these are certain processes, democratic processes but also administrative and bureaucratic processes that need to be followed.
But in the part that corresponds to Spain, which is placing on the table the adjustment decisions, reforms, etc. this part, which corresponds to Spain itself, it is complying with. So, as the other matters will be slowly ironed out - progress is being made on all fronts - and matters will be drawn to a close little by little, according to how progress is made in the coming weeks, what we are all is hoping is that this contributes to relieving the pressure, the instability and volatility of the companies and hence that these premiums continue falling in the coming weeks.
That is a little how we see the process at the OECD and, as I said, how we also see the participation of Spain in this process.
Q. I would like to ask Mr. Gurría if he thinks it is correct that Spain has renounced this 4.4% deficit to move to a figure of 5.8%, if he feels it is a good decision or if it concerns him since he has spoken about education and the fact that the cuts in Spain may affect education.
For President of the Government Rajoy, I would like to insist on the matter of the autonomous regions. More specifically, certain regions are saying - Catalonia and Andalusia - "we can't cut 15 billion euros with seriously affecting social expenditure" I wanted to know whether you agree with this analysis whereby spending on social matters could be seriously affected and whether this Government can do anything in that respect. There has been talk about legal reforms and other things.
(…)
Mr. Gurría. If you will allow me, Mr. President of the Government, I believe that perhaps you would not agree with the expression "Spain has renounced". I don't think Spain has renounced anything. What we have just heard the President of the Government say is that he reiterates and ratifies his conviction and his commitment to fiscal stability. Secondly, that his objective hasn't changed from a budgetary deficit in 2013 of 3%.
What the President of the Government has just told us is what I have also described, that things are taking place almost while we speak. This description of the dates that he has just referred to happened yesterday and the day before, and last Friday. So what he has done is make these figures transparent and affirm, without renouncing anything, that there is a challenge of a budgetary and fiscal nature that is greater than was proposed when, among other things, much higher growth was planned for.
The reality is that growth fell and, when growth falls, revenue falls, unemployment increases and the two things compound one another: firstly because revenue drops and secondly because spending rises to protect society's most vulnerable. So what happens? The budgetary deficit rises and you need not to move the goal line or adjust the objectives but perhaps adjust the timeframes and the rhythms along the way.
This is now a technical matter, a matter of details, a matter for the autonomous regions, a matter for the regional governments and a matter for Central Government where, by the way, the greatest imbalance does not lie; this lies, above all with the autonomous regions, which are included in the vision of the Draft Bill on adjustments. In fact all levels of government are included in this Draft Bill. That is very important.
Look, the law here will be called the Fiscal Transparency Act and I remember that Brazil was on the verge of bankruptcy a few years ago because the states had abused credit. So they called the law the Fiscal Responsibility Act, in other countries it is called the Transparency Act and in other countries they have given it other names. But in every case, the matter which equates here to the autonomous regions and regional government, etc. was created at some point in time when stability was threatened despite the fact that the national government was very, very serious in terms of fiscal discipline.
And so, I would say to you that it's not that anything has been renounced, but simply that what the President of the Government has just mentioned is the reiteration of a desire to reach the same end goal, but that he will have to mediate talks at all levels, both technical and political, with the European Union authorities in order to explain how it is that things are being presented and how it is intended to thus reach the same objective.
President of the Government. In relation to the two questions asked of me, regarding the first one, the initial objective was 1.3% and it is now 1.5%.
(…)
Thank you very much.