Press Conference by the President of the Government and the Secretary-General of NATO
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy addressed a joint press conference with NATO Secretary-General Rasmussen in Madrid on April 25, 2012, reaffirming Spain's NATO commitments.
- Main themes
- NATO membership and commitments, Spain-NATO relations, Afghanistan mission and ISAF, collective security, trans-Atlantic ties, Chicago NATO Summit, smart defence, military capabilities, Libya crisis, condolences for fallen Spanish Air Force personnel, defence budget constraints, post-2014 Afghanistan strategy
- Duration
- ~43 min
- Words
- 5,147
- Sentences
- 243
- Readability
- 51
- Grade
- 11.4
- Syntax
- 2.97
- Vocabulary
- 2.00
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
243 sentences in 75 paragraphs
President of the Government. A very good afternoon to you all and thank you very much for attending this press conference.
I have just come away from an enjoyable and extensive conversation with the Secretary-General of NATO, Mr. Rasmussen, in which, to put it briefly, we basically agreed on what we think of security, defence, the democracy and freedom.
First of all, on behalf of the Government and of all those Spaniards who wish to join me in this sentiment, I would like to express my condolences to the families of the two Spanish Air Force personnel who lost their lives this morning, as I'm sure you're all aware, here, close to Madrid. To them and to the entire Spanish military family, we are deeply sorry for your loss and we offer all possible support you at this difficult time.
Moving on, I would like to make a few comments about the meeting that Mr. Rasmussen and I just had. I told the Secretary-General of NATO that Spain wishes to reaffirm its commitments as an important player in international affairs and, especially, as a member of NATO; an organisation with a critical role in strengthening collective security.
Developing trans-Atlantic ties as a way to tackle the new global challenges is a priority for the current Government of Spain. For that reason, I want to stress, right here and now, that Spain is a trustworthy ally that always has and always will respond with solvency and commitment to its responsibilities as a part of NATO.
I believe that the recent crisis in Libya is a fine example of how NATO can contribute to a rapid response to avoid any repression of the civilian population and demonstrating, to a good extent, its raison d'être by carrying out its work highly effectively in terms of the new strategic concept: crisis management. As stated by the Supreme Allied Commander Europe, the first lesson learned in Libya is that NATO works.
Now, as I said to the Secretary-General, we need to keep learning our lessons and not just the lessons from that crisis. Our mission in Afghanistan, the building of new capacities and cooperation with other partners in various regional initiatives will undoubtedly be topics for analysis at the next NATO Summit, which will be held in Chicago in May and to which I will be accompanied by the Minister for Defence and the Minister for Foreign Affairs.
Spain is in Afghanistan with the objective to build a solid and viable country from both political and economical perspectives, and Spain is in Afghanistan because our security and our values should also be defended beyond our borders.
Alongside another fifty countries, we are in Afghanistan as the ninth-largest contributor - Spain is the ninth-largest contributor to operations in Afghanistan with more than 1,500 military personnel and 40 officers of the Guardia Civil. It is a mission on which, sadly, 98 men and women from our Armed Forces have sacrificed their lives in the defence of Spain and Spanish interests.
Our contribution to the future of Afghanistan is also being channelled through the Spanish Agency for Cooperation and Development, which has carried out reconstruction projects to the tune of almost two hundred million euros.
Spain is a reliable member of the International Security Assistance Force, ISAF, in Afghanistan. For that reason, I would like to reiterate our commitment firstly to the people of Afghanistan and secondly to the NATO strategy, which, in principle, is due to conclude the current mission on 31 December 2014. One of the main pillars of that strategy is cohesion between the allies. We went in together and we'll come out together. And we'll do so by means of an ordered transition of power to the Afghan authorities; a process that is already under way and will continue as those authorities become increasingly self-sufficient in terms of security. It will therefore be necessary to continue strengthening the capacity of the Afghan security forces and improve governability in this country.
During our meeting we also had an opportunity to talk about the profile of the mission that NATO will eventually lead in Afghanistan post-2014, an issue that will be discussed at the Chicago Summit in May which will determine Spain's future contribution to the operation. In any case, we believe it will require a sound legal basis and will need to be quantitatively and qualitatively different to the current mission.
Besides the matter of Afghanistan, we also touched on other issues of concern to us all, such as developing the military capabilities that we need to carry out our operations.
NATO is not unaffected by the complex problems arising from the current economic and financial crisis. All countries have been forced to reduce spending on defence, while at the same time we are involved in scenarios where new and modern military capabilities are becoming necessary.
Spain has been providing its support to initiatives that, as in the case of smart defence for example, offer multi-national solutions for obtaining systems that are highly costly and very difficult to tackle on a single-State basis. We are also studying the possibility of heading up some of those projects. In this regard, we believe that collaboration with the European Union must be a fundamental pillar when it comes to achieving the harmonious development of our needs, avoiding overlaps and redundancy.
I also wished to convey to the Secretary-General our support for extending the missile defence system; an issue that not only enhances our own security but global stability in general. We will therefore shortly be amending our Defence Agreement with the United States to enable, as was agreed in October by the previous government with the support of the Partido Popular, everything associated with this issue to be set in motion in the very near future.
This contribution I have just mentioned, together with the final agreement on the terrestrial surveillance system, which Spain recently facilitated, represent the most concerted expression of Spain's contribution to allied security.
We also had the opportunity to assess the frameworks for cooperation with our partners outside of NATO; the partnerships. Two of them in particular to which the Government of Spain assigns special importance: firstly, NATO-Russia relations, the Council for which has just celebrated its 15th anniversary and which represents the correct forum in which to resolve possible differences with a country that is a strategic partner of NATO; and, secondly, and something that is fundamental for Spain, the Mediterranean Dialogue that, since it was set up in 1994, has helped achieved greater knowledge and corrected false interpretations of NATO held by our partners in North Africa and the Middle East. We believe that this is the most ambitious initiative for security and defence in this region and a fundamental pillar for its security and stability.
Being the Mediterranean country that we are, Spain has always expressed a great interest in the stability of this region and understands, as I expressed to the Secretary-General, that one of NATO's objectives must be to pay attention to the changes taking place along its southern border, the changes arising from the "Arab Spring", and the requests for cooperation that may follow in terms of security from that part of the world, which for us is very close to home.
I feel ours has been a very frank and pleasant conversation. In short, Spain will maintain its commitments regardless of who is leading the Government of our nation at any given time because that is the serious thing to do. As far as maintaining that type of commitment is concerned, we must always act together.
Mr. Secretary-General, once again, thank you very much for being here with us today.
Mr. Rasmussen. Mr. President, thank you for your kind words.
President Rajoy and I enjoyed a very fruitful discussion this morning. As did the President of the Government, I too wish to express my sincerest condolences to the families of the two military personnel who lost their lives this morning.
The President of the Government and I discussed the economic situation in Spain and Europe because the economy and security are very closely related. A weak economy means fewer resources for security. Therefore, healthy and sound fiscal policies are also secure policies. And that is exactly what we are going to discuss. When the NATO leaders gather in Chicago in three week's time, we will discuss how to provide security in times of economic austerity.
Spain is a key member of our Alliance. In a month's time, we will be holding the 30th anniversary of its joining NATO. You have formed an essential pillar of our Alliance ever since.
Spain is making a significant contribution to our mission in Afghanistan. Spain has almost 1,500 troops in Afghanistan who are helping to make the country a safer place and to enjoy more stability. I recognise the sacrifice made by the Spanish troops and thank them for their service to our Alliance.
Last year Spain also played a leading role in our mission to protect the people of Libya. You are going to have an important, deployable air command centre that is key to future capabilities and also for you to play a significant role in our anti-missile defence system; a system that protects us from a real and growing threat. In this globalised world, security begins at home, in our own countries, and we must protect our borders. However, when we talk about security, we must often think beyond our borders.
At the Chicago Summit, next month's summit, we will discuss our mission in Afghanistan and we will once again show our determination to remain steadfast until the end of the transition at the end of 2014. We will also demonstrate our support, post-2014, for maintaining what we have gained, the achievements we have made with so much investment and so much loss of human life.
Of course, it is also very important that the entire international community and the people of Afghanistan play their own role. That is in the interest of our own security and the security of everyone else.
We are in an election period, a tough time for us all. And Spain is doing an excellent job at tackling the economic situation. We must be realistic: in a world where most budgets are being cut, defence spending cannot remain untouched by those cutbacks. However, when we are in economically difficult times, the challenges of security are still just as important. Therefore, our challenge is to find a balance between economy and security.
In Chicago, we will move forward to enable us to tackle the security challenges of tomorrow, of the future, with the economic resources of today. We will see how we can work together better. That is what we call "smart defence".
I thank Spain for its participation in what is being called the AGF terrestrial surveillance system; a capability that will provide our command centres with a global image on the ground at any time while improving the security of our troops.
I applaud its decision to provide a base, the Rota Base, for housing part of NATO's anti-missile defence system. That is what we call "smart defence in action" and I hope that Spain continues to play an important role so that, together, we can come out of this economic crisis stronger and we can renew that unbreakable trans-Atlantic bond in Chicago, which is the basis for our shared security. It will be a pleasure to see President of the Government of Spain again in Chicago.
Q. For Mr. Rasmussen. In Spain, as is the case in every country, there is a considerable debate going on about the cutbacks in military spending, even about the possibility of cancelling certain missions. Some people are saying that. Do you understand this debate? What would you say to all those people, right now when Spain is cutting back on healthcare and on education, in support of not cutting back so much on defence?
For Mr. Rajoy. As you know, there is increasing resistance in Europe to the policy of spending cuts and there are a lot of expectations ahead of the French elections. Do you still support the recipes put forward by Angela Merkel on austerity no matter what the cost or do you think the time has come for a move towards specific measures for growth, as suggested by others? Specifically, do you agree with the IMF that is asking for public money for the banks?
One more question related to Spain. There is a lot of talk about intervention in the Autonomous Regions. Are you willing to go so far as to intervene in certain regions? Do you think it will be necessary? Along the same lines, do you think it can be said that relations with Convergència i Unió have come to an end or is there a chance of re-establishing them after the Budget?
Mr. Rasmussen. You ask me a question on cutbacks in defence and I'm going to be very frank with you. I was the Prime Minister of my country, Denmark, for more than eight years. So I know the political realities very well. When a government needs to reduce social budgets, healthcare or education programmes, as you say, it is politically obvious that one cannot suggest that defence be untouched by those cutbacks.
I am aware of the reality. We are facing some very tough economic challenges, even when we talk about investment in defence. That is why we need a new approach and that is what I am calling "smart defence". What does that mean? It means a smarter way of spending money on defence; in other words, finding international solutions and not purely national ones because it will be increasingly difficult in the future for each one of the allies, individually, to acquire expensive defence equipment. However, if we help each other, if we form groups and share resources, and if we join forces, then we'll be able to do it.
We have an excellent example that already illustrates this new way of thinking. Twelve NATO allies, in other words, a total of twelve countries, have acquired three expensive transport aircraft and they have done so together. Each one of these countries would have been unable to buy even one aircraft individually but, by grouping together and sharing resources, they can buy three. From an individual point of view, they can now buy flying hours with those aircraft and we can therefore speak of international cooperation. Thanks to this, those countries have been able to achieve a capability that would have otherwise been impossible. That is what we call "smart defence".
We are trying to expand this approach into other areas of defence and that is exactly what we will be discussing in Chicago. In Chicago, we are going to approve a defence package with a tremendous number of multi-national projects. Large projects, small projects, but, generally speaking, they will all offer NATO sufficient military capabilities in the future.
That is what I mean when I talk about offering security in a time of economic austerity, adopting a new approach.
President of the Government. Seeing as you've asked so many questions, I suppose there'll be no more from any of your colleagues! I mean, since you've asked so many I imagine that must be the case.
Firstly; austerity and Angela Merkel. The austerity policy is not Angela Merkel's policy. When we joined the Euro, after meeting the requirements back in 1998 and then joining in 1999, we also assumed certain commitments; Spain and every other EU country that has joined the Euro. One of those commitments was to maintain healthy public accounts; a reasonable requirement. Those commitments were later to be ratified again by the Government of Spain, the previous Government, the one led by José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero, at the European Council and a commitment was made to certain deficit levels.
Therefore, the austerity policy is not a policy of, in this case, the president of one specific country; no. It is a European Union policy, it is a Euro policy and it is the policy of a project we are all in together, because that is the voluntary choice we made at the time.
This speech comes very easily to me because it's something I've always defended. If you remember, over the course of all those years in which I was part of the opposition, I only called attention to two matters of public economics, and that was while we were growing. One of those was: take care with uncontrolled public spending. When Spain hit 11%, the country entered the situation from which we have unfortunately not been able to get out of yet. Secondly, I asked for economic reforms for growth. In other words, I said: firstly, be careful with spending what we don't have and, secondly, let's implement reforms.
I still defend that position today. The objective of this Government, and all of Spain, the objective of all Spaniards, is to create jobs and grow economically. For that to happen, we cannot spend what we don't have. So the deficit must be brought under control and, what's more, reforms need to be made. That is what we're doing.
For that reason, we have come up with a Budget that is the most austere Budget since Spain's transition to democracy. I know that but I'm doing it because it needs to be done, because we have an unacceptable deficit and because we will need to borrow that money from somewhere later - we might get it and we might not; and there are some countries that are not getting the finance they need. For that reason, we took those decisions and, for that reason, we are implementing these reforms. We are on a roll with our reforms and we will continue to make reforms in the near future.
So, that was the position adopted by the people of Spain when we joined the Euro. Let us not enter into minor debates now over whether someone is saying I will delay a year… no, no; let's not get into minor debates. Let's try and explain the truth about things. Spending money you do not have is bad in itself, but what's more, it means you need to borrow it from somewhere.
I've said it many times: last year, Spain spent ninety billion euros more than it brought in as revenue. That is bad in itself, but what's worse is that we have to borrow that money from somewhere. And this year, even with the cutbacks we're going to make, we have to borrow more than fifty billion euros.
We must start to realise that these are the things that truly matter. I know that we are already asking for a significant effort from the people of Spain, I know that; but it's what we need to do if we want to start growing economically and creating jobs any time soon.
This is basically the Euro policy. We've not just come up with it; it comes from way back. The problem is that the rules weren't being followed. The unfortunate truth is that there were certain European countries that failed to meet those commitments; Spain included, I know. We must now get ourselves back on track, defend the Euro project together and take action with the intelligence that we are supposedly blessed with.
You also mentioned CiU and the autonomous regions. As far as the autonomous regions are concerned, as I said before about the basis on which I've always acted and that I've always been clear on two things: one is that we cannot have a deficit or that we must have a reasonable deficit, and the other is that we need to implement economic reforms, in this case of the autonomous regions… Of course, perhaps others don't see it the same way, but that's how I see it. The Government of Spain must handle and concern itself with what happens in the autonomous regions, in the Government of Spain of course and in the local authorities of course.
We are all a part of Spain. Spain is not the Government of Spain, no; Spain is the Government of Spain, the Government of Catalonia, the Government of Valencia, the Government of Madrid, the Government of Galicia and all the local Councils. In such a difficult situation as the one we're in right now, I truly think it's time for a conscientious political effort to be made. The time has truly come for a conscientious political effort and it's time to act with our sights set on the medium- and long-term future. For now, we need to focus on what matters and the general interest of our country. When I say 'the general interest', I mean the interest of Spain and the interest of Catalonia, and the interest of every person in this country; there really is no other way.
From there, each one of us can take the decisions they think best and most appropriate. I, of course, will always talk to all the regional governments, and particularly with the Government of Catalonia and with Convergència i Unió; but the thing is that right now, let me make this absolutely clear, is the time to work together for the greater good, because these are difficult times. People are talking about the Euro, people are talking about finance, we have the risk premium, more than five million people out of work… Let's talk about the bigger picture, let's talk about what really matters, let's talk about the general interest, the interest of us all, that which unites each and every person in Spain and each and every government, be it regional, local or central.
As regards the autonomous regions, seeing as I believe in the autonomous regions and seeing as I believe that Spain is the responsibility of us all, we are not going to leave the autonomous regions to one side. I think we have taken some decisions over the course of these first few months that I do not think are getting the attention they deserve.
Firstly, we have brought forward the transfers to account paid out to the regional governments. By doing so, we have given them a solution to their liquidity problems. Secondly, we have deferred the deadline for reimbursing revenue received over and above what should have been received in 2008 and 2009. Thirdly, we have implemented a suppliers plan - and here I'm talking about 35 billion euros - for the settlement of unpaid debts. And fourthly, we have set up an ICO line of credit for use by those Regional Governments that cannot refinance their debt in the markets. This is especially important because to those people who say "we need a higher deficit", I would say; what happens if we suffer the same fate as those who cannot refinance their debt in the markets or who aren't loaned enough money to cover their deficit? That is what's at stake here.
So, regarding the Regional Governments, we have taken the decisions that are good for them. But, at the end of the day, we are only asking the Regional Governments for the same thing being asked of Spain by Europe, that the Government of Spain is asking of itself and that common sense would advise: we are asking that they pay their suppliers and we are asking that they hit their deficit targets. I am absolutely convinced that all the Regional Governments are going to collaborate on that, which is the great project that is in the interest of all Spaniards at this moment in time.
Let me make it very clear to you, I am not going to get into discussions or arguments that I either do not want to get involved in or do not interest me. As I said before, I truly think that now is the time to focus on the bigger picture, to target what is important and to make a conscientious political effort. I don't think this is the time for any other type of discussion.
Q. A question for the Secretary-General. Can you give us your opinion on two things? Firstly, on the report from the US Government that criticised the missile defence response due to technological delays and excess cost. What is your opinion on the future of this project?
Secondly, the report that came out on Wednesday from a group of analysts who criticised the phrase "operations carried out by the Afghans" in cases where there aren't even any Afghan troops present. Can you make any comments on these two reports because it gives the impression that the Afghans are taking care of their own operations when they are almost always NATO, US or American operations?
Mr. Rasmussen. Very quickly on the anti-missile defence system. We are following a previously-defined path. We are going to meet the deadlines. At the Chicago Summit, we will make a statement on provisional capacity regarding the NATO anti-missile defence system. As far as I know, there are no delays, meaning that we will meet the objective and we are going to declare that provisional capacity when we meet in Chicago in three weeks. In other words, we will stick to the schedule.
As far as the cost, I am not aware that the cost has overrun; for now at least. Therefore, we are also meeting our targets in that regard.
On Afghanistan and that other report, it is true that the Afghan security forces are now responsible for leading at least 40% of all security operations in Afghanistan; they are leading 40% of those operations. I have seen training and capacity-building operations with my own eyes now being led by the Afghan security forces. A fortnight ago, I saw them with my own eyes and they were working in a highly professional manner. Lately, there have been some spectacular attacks in Kabul, attacks that were responded to very professionally by the Afghan security forces. I therefore disagree with any comment saying that the Afghan security forces do not have sufficient capability. Quite the opposite.
We are seeing constant progress, both in terms of quality and quantity, meaning that we are on schedule and, little by little, we are going to hand over responsibility to the Afghans themselves. Our objective remains the same and so does our strategy. Our schedule remains the same; that hasn't changed either. This will also be confirmed in Chicago.
Q. I would like to ask Mr. Rajoy a question. This morning, the Minister for Home Affairs announced a reinsertion plan for terrorist prisoners. I would like to know, in the Government's opinion, what has changed for this discourse that was previously heard from the PP and from the Government itself, tough rhetoric against terrorism, to now acquire this much more generous tone. How would you explain this to the victims who, by the way, have rejected this plan? Do you not think that, at the end of the day, such a plan could turn out to be full of holes by which a number of ETA members are in fact closer to being moved to prisons in the Basque Country?
If you will allow me, I would like to add something to the previous economic question. With the tough Budget that you have presented, and the measures in healthcare and education, are you not afraid of a "hot Spring" - with protests in the street by the trade unions and the 15-M movement?
President of the Government. As far as this goes, what I firmly believe is that I must fulfil my duty. That is what I believe. The Government came to power with Spain in this situation. This is very difficult. We are aware of that, I know, that it will be a while before we see the effects of the decisions taken by this Government and I know that there are many people in Spain who do not share our ideas. But we cannot be thinking about what the trade unions might do or about whether they will organise protests because, in that case, we would not be true servants to our country.
Therefore, the Government will fulfil its duty and it will do what Spain needs in order to return to economic growth and job creation. And I think that can happen because the people of Spain have demonstrated that, when the right conditions were created, Spanish society was capable of creating many millions of jobs.
As regards your first point, you are assuming to be true a series of things that, in my opinion, are not certain. I want to say that the Government has not changed nor will it change its anti-terrorism policy; the Government's position is the same has it has always been. I have explained this many times: ETA must disappear; there is no other path available besides that and compliance with the law. There can be no negotiating with a terrorist organisation and we will not negotiate with a terrorist organisation. We've not done so in the past and we won't be doing so in the future.
Secondly, that plan is a plan that attributes no penitentiary benefits whatsoever nor represents any changes to the anti-terrorism policy. Let us make that absolutely clear right here and now.
Thirdly, that plan is for all those imprisoned members of organised gangs who have clearly, publicly and solemnly abandoned all ties with the gang to be able to start working on their reinsertion. But it includes no penitentiary benefits whatsoever. If we already have the "vía Nanclares" in effect, it is much better for there to be people who apologise and repent. But I insist, that does not mean any penitentiary benefits.
Therefore, that is all I have to say on the matter, based on the fact that the Government, I insist, is not changing its anti-terrorist policy. Furthermore, I'm not just saying that the Government is not making any changes; the Government is not going to make any changes either.
Q. Another question for Mr. Rasmussen. François Hollande has said that, if he wins the French elections, he will bring France's combat mission in Afghanistan to an end or, at least, will bring it to an end one year earlier than has been planned. Will that pose a problem for your strategic exit from Afghanistan? Do you have a programme, a contingency plan, were that to be the case?
Mr. Rasmussen. Firstly, I absolutely don't want to get involved in the French election campaign process. That said, I consider France to be a strong ally. France has always been firmly committed to our security operations and I think that this will remain unchanged no matter who is elected on 6 May.
President of the Government. Thank you very much.