Press conference by the President of the Government and the President of the Council of Ministers of the Italian Republic

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

1 August 2012 · Madrid, Spain

Context
Rajoy and Italian PM Monti held a joint press conference in Madrid on 2 August 2012 to discuss bilateral relations and coordinated European crisis response.
Main themes
Spain-Italy bilateral relations, European crisis response, structural economic reforms, fiscal consolidation, European Union unity, banking union, euro stabilization, public accounts reform, labour market reform, Hispano-Italian agenda, European project, economic competitiveness
Duration
~40 min
90th percentile
Words
4,782
90th percentile
Sentences
159
83rd percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
14.6
73rd percentile
Syntax
3.33
85th percentile
Vocabulary
2.03
15th percentile

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

159 sentences in 71 paragraphs

President of the Government. Good afternoon to you all and thank you very much for attending this session.

I would like to start by expressing my sincere thanks to the Prime Minister, the President of the Council of Ministers, Mario Monti, for visiting Madrid today, on 2 August 2012.

Italy is a strategic partner, a founding member of the European Union and a friend of Spain, with which we share, among many other things, a common history, a united present and a future that we seek to build together, because our present and our future is the European project.

Mario Monti, as well as being a friend, is a pro-European with a very extensive career, whose experience constitutes a valuable asset at this critical time for the European project.

This visit by Prime Minister Monti represents a new milestone in the intense Hispano-Italian agenda this year, which kicked off with my visit to Rome on 27 February and continued with the visit by the Speaker of the Italian Lower House on 11 June and the Four-way Rome Growth Summit on 22 June. This agenda will continue with a visit by the President of the Italian Republic on 3 October, to coincide with the meeting of the Foundation for Technological Innovation, and will culminate with the bilateral Hispano-Italian Summit agreed to be held on 29 October and which will embody the fundamental importance we give to our bilateral relations.

Today's meeting has served, in addition to reviewing the wonderful health of our bilateral relations, to continue consolidating our close coordination and collaboration with the aim of exiting this crisis that so affects both countries, since it affects the European project.

The Government of Italy, in the same way as the Government of Spain, is convinced of the need to adjust the public accounts and undertake structural reforms that are essential to creating quality jobs and driving sustained and sustainable growth for our economies.

We are aware that we are asking for a great effort from our citizens, but we know that this is the only way to exit this current crisis and make us stronger. We should make a virtue out of necessity and correct our weaknesses to avoid so many errors of past and potential future crises, and thus become more competitive in the international society of the 21st Century.

For our part, we reassert our commitments to meeting the obligations and to carrying out the reforms and measures we have committed to, with the aim of cleaning up our public accounts and reforming our economies.

We have agreed to a joint statement, in which we agree on the diagnosis and on the measures to be taken, both in our own respective countries and within a European framework.

As you are aware, the European Council held in Brussels at the end of June was very significant, one of the most significant that has taken place in Europe over the last few years. I believe that steps were taken towards European unity. We spoke about banking union, fiscal union, the stabilisation of the Euro and the irreversibility of the Euro, and both countries intend, seek, desire and are working so that all these measures can be firmed up as soon as possible, because that would be good for the European Union as a whole, it would be good for our two countries and, above all, it would be good for our citizens.

Thank you very much, Mr Prime Minister.

Mr. Monti. President of the Government Rajoy, I am pleased to be here today in Madrid, on an invitation that I greatly appreciated, extended to me by the President of the Spanish Government. This has been an occasion that allowed us to look in depth at how to make relations stronger between our two countries, between our two governments and also, if you will allow me, at a personal level between the two of us.

It has needed but a few months for us to quickly realise, at the meetings of the European Council, the respect and friendship that exists towards the President of the Spanish Government.

As regards relations between our two countries, they go back a long way and there are strong ties at an economic and cultural level, and it gives me great pleasure and motivation to continue strengthening these relations here today.

I have always closely followed relations with Spain with great admiration and interest. In the ten years that I was a European Commissioner in Brussels I had many occasions to talk with the various Spanish authorities that were in power, and have looked on keenly at the changes in the Spanish authority and the process of growth in Spain.

Now Spain, like so many other countries, and like Italy, is facing difficulties, but I would like to stress my great respect for the efforts that the Spanish Government and people are making, under the leadership of President of the Government Rajoy, to clean up the public accounts and in undertaking structural reforms. I refer, in particular, to the intense reform of the labour market and also to the latest intervention made at the end of June. These are important measures and brave measures in an extremely complex context.

Spain is a great country, a stable country, because it is led by a government which holds a broad majority in its mandate from the electorate, which voted for it, as you know, aware that this government was going to adopt severe, tough, but necessary measures, as it is doing.

I am sure that the reforms, which are a restructuring process for those banks that need it, will help to create the conditions to reduce the unemployment rate, which is currently very high.

The agreement reached at the European Council at the end of June was important, as the President of the Government reminded us. It was also important in laying the groundwork towards the direct recapitalisation of the banks, in a way that respects their solvency requirements, without further prejudging the public coffers. That is fundamental to breaking the vicious circle that has been forming between the banks and public finances in a tough situation. We both hope, and I have also spoken about this with President of the Government Rajoy, that the European Union will soon reach an agreement on banking supervision at a European level and that this can soon be firmed up.

At the same time, it is also clear that the stabilisation of the markets and the costs of financing greatly depend on the capacity of the Eurozone to efficiently manage the crisis affecting it over at least the last two years. Employing our usual language, we will only find a solution if each of us works well and quickly to put his own house in order, and if we work together quickly and without entering into conflict with one another, and if we do our homework in our common house - the European Union; in other words, in terms of European policies.

I am convinced that, although we are currently talking a great deal about short-term financing, which is logical, it is also important to speed, up as far as possible, the various initiatives aimed at growth which, with the strong support of Italy and Spain over the last six months, have also been defined at a European level and which were convincingly assumed at the latest European Council.

Furthermore, as the President of the Government reminded us, we have reviewed our excellent bilateral relations and for me it is a pleasure to have the occasion to come back to Madrid soon for the bilateral Summit that will take place. The Head of State, President Napolitano, is looking forward to coming to this great country soon.

Thank you very much.

Q. Prime Minister Monti, you have arrived in Madrid following a week of intense diplomatic activity in defence of the Eurozone, but have you made any progress, despite what has happened today in Frankfurt, with this desire of Mr Draghi to intervene in an unconventional manner with unconventional measures regarding the markets? Mr Draghi has spoken about conditions; are these conditions that the Italian Government has already met or are we talking about another type of conditions?

Mr. Monti. Thank you for this question that deals with important current affairs.

Each European Head of Government, together with his or her Minister for Economic Affairs or Finance, or Minister for European Affairs, must currently divide his or her time between governing at a domestic level and participating in the government of Europe, a more important and higher responsibility. Hence, the various visits made this week, which culminate today in Madrid, were precisely aimed at firming up this progress to materialise what was defined, particularly at the European Council at the end of June, but thanks also to the active contributions from Spain and Italy.

I have noticed various forms of progress and I see the progress in terms of dialogue and understanding in Finland yesterday as important, in particular with the Prime Minister, Jyrki Katainen, and also with his Parliament. This week's work gives rise to hope.

You mentioned the measures and the statements in the press conference of the President of the European Central Bank. I have only had the opportunity to make an initial and brief reading of the text of the statements made by the President and I have few observations to make. At any event, I have been struck by his positive assessment of the decisions made by the Heads of State and Government on 28 and 29 June. I can see various steps forward and none backwards as regards these agreements, in particular regarding that text, which, for the first time with the unanimous approval of the seventeen Member States of the Eurozone, declared a strong effort to comply with whatever may be necessary to ensure the financial stability of the Eurozone, and to use, flexibly and efficiently, the instruments of the Stability Fund and the Stability Mechanism in force to stabilise the markets. Hence, as regards that matter, I can see an effort on the part of the European Central Bank to adhere to these objectives.

In the analysis, I can see certain points that, objectively, seem very significant and that the markets, which act to the second and to the thousandth of a second, have not fully evaluated; in particular, the fact that the President of the European Central Bank has declared that "the exceptionally high risks of the risk premiums of State-backed bonds in various countries affect the ability of monetary policy to function correctly"; or the emphasis given when saying that the matter of the risk premium affects the very heart of the functioning of monetary policy, and hence, the powers of the European Central Bank; or the observation that "the financial markets are only adjusted once the success of any measure becomes clear"; in other words, the imperfect immediacy of the financial markets to reflect the progress of economic policies of each country. This observation was also clearly made yesterday by the Prime Minister of Finland.

Consequently the assertion made by the President of the Central Bank to the effect that "the Governing Council (of the Bank) can clearly undertake open market operations of an appropriate size to achieve its objectives" is a stability objective. Hence, while at the European Council of Heads of State and Government, it was expected that existing instruments would be used - the Stability Fund and the Stability Mechanism - it would seem the ECB has gone further, since it feels the need to intervene on its own part, not only as an agent of the Fund - the expression used in the June Council. In other words, intervening in the first person in these open market operations.

Now, of course, as the President always says, "in the coming weeks we will establish the appropriate form for each type of measure". I believe it is important that "the appropriate form" should take into account the particular crossroads of this situation because, on the one hand, by issuing this statement he is recognising that the rise in the risk premium for bonds of certain countries is a problem for these countries, but they are problems of the Eurozone, and the conditions, which are the same as those spoken about at the Council in June in the memorandum of agreement for those countries that already respect "the specific conditions", are conditions for each country, but this is a problem that has, to put it that way, a European equivalence.

Forgive me, President of the Government, if I have given an over-lengthy response.

Q. I have a question for both of you and I will refer precisely to the European Central Bank press conference by Mr Draghi. In various responses in this press conference, Mr Draghi invited, not specifically Spain and Italy, but the governments of those countries that have debt problems, to resort to the Bailout Fund, and after that, the European Central Bank would do its part as well by buying up debt. My question for the two of you is whether your governments are going to resort to this Bailout Fund. And if you are, when will you ask for this aid?

Secondly, are you not in any way disappointed by this much-awaited speech by the President of the European Central Bank, who said the other day that he would do everything possible and everyone interpreted this as meaning that it would buy up debt to save the Euro?

President of the Government. As regards the communiqué that Mr Draghi has made public today, that you refer to in your question, I want to say that I can see certain positive aspects. I would like to go back to the European Council held at the end of June. A clear commitment was made there, from a political point of view, by the Heads of State and Government of the European Union to the irreversibility of the Euro, to market stability and to progress on banking and fiscal union.

I believe that we all came out of that Council very satisfied. The President of the Italian Council of Ministers and I were both very pleased at the outcome of that meeting and what we are now seeking is the implementation of the decisions taken therein as soon as possible. And I should say that the decisions taken today are very positive.

Mr Draghi said that in various Eurozone countries, exceptionally high risk premiums have been observed in the price of sovereign bonds and that financial fragmentation is a barrier to the effective operation of monetary policy. Mr Draghi said that the risk premiums related to fears about the Euro not being irreversible are unacceptable and this must be categorically resolved. I believe this to be true and it is truly comforting to hear it, as it is comforting to hear that the Euro is irreversible, because it is what so many Europeans believe in, in Italy, in Spain and in the majority of the European Union countries.

Secondly, I believe that it is also very important what the President of the European Central Bank said when he commented that, within the independence that corresponds thereto, as it does indeed correspond, direct operations may be carried out on the secondary market of an appropriate size to meet the objective. He also said that the Governing Council can consider carrying out unconventional monetary policy measures, and that during the coming weeks we will design the appropriate form of such measures. From my point of view, this is a positive statement.

I am obviously not going to go into what the European Central Bank might do in the future, because the Bank itself is leading us into the future, but what I would like to say is that we will continue working in Spain, as I have said on many occasions, to meet our commitments in relation to the public deficit and to reduce the public debt in the future, and we will continue undertaking structural reforms, aware that we need to take tough measures, very tough measures, unpleasant measures, and that these are unpopular with the vast majority of Spaniards. But you can be absolutely sure that these same measures will be the ones that allow us to lay the foundations for future economic growth and job creation.

And, of course, we will continue working for the future of Europe. Europe is a political project that has been in progress for more than 50 years. In fact, it was in Rome, in 1957, that the first Treaty of Rome was signed, but there had already been steps taken previously towards what was going to be a European union. I believe that we are at a decisive moment. I believe that we are going through a very important phase for Europe and that we need certain things at this time: we need greatness, strength and conviction, courage and determination to drive us forward. Some of us are fixated on this. We will take up this battle, which is a battle in benefit of more Europe and more European Union, and we are convinced that this will be a triumph for a continent which, let us not forget, comprises 25% of world GDP.

Some of us believe in Europe, and we will logically act consequentially.

Mr. Monti. Very briefly, two points in response to what I was asked.

I cannot see, in the statement made today by the President of the European Central Bank, any steps backwards in regard to the statements he made a week ago in London. I can only see continuity, and furthermore, I see it as a statement made after a meeting of the Governing Council of the European Central Bank. A week ago it was a very noteworthy personal statement, and hence, I think that the weight of what was asserted has not diminished as regards the content, but rather has increased in terms of its value.

As regards the second point, I don't know whether the Italian Government will request the activation of this instrument. First, it will be necessary to examine in depth the form and whether we need it or not. But I am convinced of one thing: that this government will continue rigorously, in depth and coherently, doing what it needs to do and what it needs to do for the interests of Italy to coincide with what Europe asks from Italy.

The fact that the European Union, in all its institutions - today through a statement made by the European Central Bank - has displayed to Italy, as well as to the rest of the countries, that it is aware of the problems and that each country has to do its part to find a solution, may increase the conviction and willing of the Italian people, as I believe it does with the conviction and willing of the citizens of other countries, to follow down the path of suitable economic measures, despite this not being easy.

Q. President of the Council of Ministers, yesterday you did not rule out the possibility that Italy may ask for help. I ask you, if a request for aid were to be made, do you believe that the signing of the memorandum would mark the end of your government with the resulting resignation?

Mr. Monti. I don't see the context; I don't mean the logic, because I am sure your question is logical, but I cannot see the relation.

The life of the present Italian Government goes hand-in-hand with the life of this legislature. Parliament can clearly bring this to an end, but I cannot see the relationship with the European decisions taking place at this time.

What I said yesterday was in relation to a potential intervention - I didn't imagine by the Central Bank, but rather by the European Fund - for the decision on the risk premium. I don't know, as I said a minute ago, if Italy will resort to using this mechanism, but it seems a little paradoxical to me that, as a result of the fact that a proposal specifically made by Italy over these last few months has been accepted by the European Council firstly, and subsequently, within the autonomy of their own analyses, by the European financial institutions, it should be seen as something that we regret rather than something positive.

From a point of view of terminology, I believe that in Italy we are the only ones that use the made-up expression "State-saving fund" in reference to the European Financial Stability Fund. That's not its name; it's called the European Financial Stability Fund, and its successor will be called the European Stability Mechanism. Hence, although in certain cases the use of the Stability Fund has been employed to resolve problems of the public finances of certain countries, such as Greece, the current trend of the reflections and statements of the European Central Bank leads to the valuation of another component of the Fund, not of each State, which is financial stability.

At any event, any consideration regarding the use, regarding the how and when of the Italian Government, seems premature to me. We presently have no intention of resorting to it, but rather we have the intention of working with other governments so that Europe has this available, in the same way as other instruments that are necessary in order to be an integrated economy with integrated finances.

Q. This question is for the President of the Government Rajoy and for Prime Minister Monti. You are sending out a very positive message, but the Spanish and Italian stock markets are plummeting, the risk differentials are increasing fast, probably because the President of the Central Bank has made it patently clear that, to receive this aid, countries need to request it from the Bailout Fund.

Mr Rajoy was asked this, but didn't answer it earlier, and I would like him to answer it now, and, above all, to know when it will be requested and what the conditions will be, and if he is concerned about the conditions that may be imposed.

I would like to know from Mr Monti if he could clarify whether Italy is seriously thinking about asking for it at the same time as Spain or if there are other plans on the table.

Finally, regarding the feeling that Germany has put the brakes on the expectations regarding what could be today's decision. I wanted to ask the two of you whether you are planning any type of joint measure or front in response to this attitude by Germany.

And for President of the Government Rajoy, I wanted to ask whether he is going to travel, as has Mr Monti, or go on any trip. Are you going to do anything is particular to get out of this? Do we have a Plan B?

President of the Government. I explained my opinion earlier on this communiqué from the European Central Bank, which coincides with what the Italian Prime Minister said. I believe that the European Central Bank is saying something that some of us have been asserting for a long time now: that the debt of some European Union countries is being unfairly punished on the basis of our economies. That is what it is saying and it can be clearly confirmed, and it is even saying something which for me is very important: it is saying that this is related to the fears surrounding the non-irreversible nature of the Euro. It is very important that this has been asserted by the President of the European Central Bank, and it is comforting for me to hear, as I suppose it is for everyone, his assertion to the effect that the Euro is the only way forward.

Aside from that there is a very positive fact, which I have never requested, and that is the assertion made by the President of the European Central Bank that it can carry out direct operations in the secondary market "of the right size to achieve its objective". Furthermore, he has spoken about implementing other types of unconventional measures that will be developed in the future. Let us wait and see what these measures are. We will be watching closely, as you can imagine; but that is what seems very positive to me and the most noteworthy feature today.

Aside from that, I am not going to do anything different to what I have been doing over the course of these last few months. In other words, I am not going to change my opinion and criteria at every turn. I have said that we are going to work along five lines of action and I have repeated this on numerous occasions.

Firstly, the commitment to reducing the public deficit, because we cannot have a level of public deficit such as that of last year, standing at 8.9% of GDP, because that means that last year Spain spent over 90 billion euros more than it collected in revenue, and we can't go on like that. We cannot spend 15 trillion pesetas more than we collect; something that anyone can easily appreciate. The public authorities cannot do this, in the same way as a family or a company cannot. Hence, that is our first commitment, which is the toughest and the most difficult; but it is undoubtedly the one that will allow us to lay solid foundations for the future.

And, secondly, I am going to continue making structural reforms and subsequently we will work on the three fundamental agreements that were adopted at the European Council in Brussels. The first, reforms to improve competitiveness in the European Union, which are growth policies, because, furthermore, what was debated there is as a result of a letter that Prime Minister Monti, I and other Heads of State and Government sent to the President of the Council. We also spoke there about the need to improve financing and liquidity in the European Union, we spoke about certain instruments - and now the European Central bank has said this, which is positive - and finally, we spoke about fiscal and banking union. I am going to work on this, I don't intend to follow any other course.

As regards going on tour, I am constantly speaking with everyone else, as I am sure are the other leaders. I have been in Eurozone countries on seventeen occasions during these first few months, as well as three times in America, Asia and Africa. As is both natural and my obligation, due to the importance of the matter, I devote half of my time to committing to Europe; that is really what I do, commit to Europe.

Q. But will you ask for aid?

President of the Government. I have already given a crystal-clear answer to that.

Q. I asked Mr Monti if he plans to ask for aid at the same time as Spain. Have you spoken with Mr Rajoy about this matter?

Mr. Monti. No, we haven't spoken about that. I can confirm to you that, as regards Italy, we are fortunate that the Italian public finances do not need money. We have one of the soundest public finances in Europe at this time, with a public deficit in 2012 of 2% of GDP, which is half the European average, and with an objective, considered realistic by the European Commission, of structural equivalence in 2013.

On the other hand, I will take the occasion to respond to your previous question. Aid such as the bailout, the salvation of a State, etc. is not a problem in the case of Italy. As regards aid, if we choose to use that term, one which I consider inappropriate, or accompanying actions to avoid excessive risk premiums in the market that are expensive for the public treasury of the country that issues the debt and which also create instability and dysfunction for the overall monetary policy of the Eurozone, we will have to analyse them. At this time, I don't believe it is necessary, but first we will have to look closely at the structure of this new type of instrument.

What I have also asserted in Italy, with great conviction, is that the whole Italian economic policy over the last few months has been drawn up so that the first type of aid mentioned is not necessary, and indeed, it is not necessary.

I am always well disposed to answer questions and I hope that I have answered this matter for you.

President of the Government. Thank you very much.