- Context
- Rajoy held a mid-year press conference on 2 August 2012 to review his government's first months in office and address Spain's deepening economic crisis.
- Main themes
- Spanish economic crisis, public deficit and debt, unemployment, fiscal austerity measures, economic reform, public expenditure cuts, risk premium and financing, Spanish families and workers, macroeconomic stabilization, foreign debt, government accountability
- Duration
- ~75 min
- Words
- 8,944
- Sentences
- 336
- Readability
- 51
- Grade
- 12.6
- Syntax
- 3.20
- Vocabulary
- 1.94
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
336 sentences in 125 paragraphs
President of the Government. A very good afternoon to you all and many thanks for attending this session.
As usual at this time of year - I've always done this, albeit not as President of the Government because I've only held this office for a few months - I appear to briefly take stock of the situation, summarise the decisions we have taken over the last few months and also to make certain proposals for the future.
This appearance will centre on the economy, because the economy is presently the greatest concern of the Spanish people. At any event, should you wish to ask me about any other matter, I will, of course, be delighted to respond.
I will refer to the current state of affairs, to where we are at, to the causes, to the measures that we have taken, because we're talking about taking stock of these first few months of this legislature, and I will also point out certain other areas on which I believe we should continue working in the future.
I won't go into too much detail about the situation because you're very much aware of it. Our greatest concern is the situation that many Spaniards are going through; more than five and a half million people who want to work but are unable to, particularly many young people, as you are all fully aware, the situation of many families who are finding it hard to get by, and the situation of many companies that also have problems. Some, many, unfortunately many, as you know, have had to close down lately. We are also concerned by the lack of economic growth due to a lack of activity and the resulting fall in revenue for the public administration services, which also has an impact because what these services do affects our people as a whole.
In summary, these are our concerns; this is the life of the Spanish people; this is the reality of things and I will not labour the matter, because it is not pertinent and because you, like all Spaniards, are well aware of this.
I will move on to the causes of this situation and I will refer to the causes because that is what needs to be resolved and that is what we have been working on for many months now. I will turn now to the public deficit, to public debt, to the risk premium, to financing, etc. What is important is unemployment and what is important is the situation being suffered by many Spaniards; but we cannot resolve this situation if we do not act on these macroeconomic variables: the deficit, the debt, etc.
I will begin this speech on the causes, with two very brief comments, which are actually two numbers, but I believe that they are very indicative of what has happened here over the years.
In 2011, which is the last year for which we have figures available, as you would expect, expenditure by the Spanish public administration services stood at 468.43 billion euros, whilst revenue stood at 377.09 billion euros. In other words, last year the Spanish public administration services spent 91.34 billion euros more than they collected as revenue, which, when converted into pesetas, amounts to more than 15 trillion pesetas. The public administration services collected tax revenue amounting to 15 trillion pesetas less than what they spent; an amount which, logically, must be borrowed because we don't have it to spend, and if we are not lent such amount, under no event can we spend it.
The second figure that I want to draw to your attention is that Spain has foreign debt… In other words, Spain as an economy, Spain as a country, the Spanish people as a whole, we have foreign debt, we owe to other countries, more than 90 billion euros. That is what our public administration services and non-financial companies owe as foreign debt, in other words, what we know as large companies, and the Spanish financial sector which channels the debt held by Spanish small- and medium-sized enterprises, and also household debt
What do I want to say with this? That for a long time we have been living on credit and for a long time we have spent much more than we collect as revenue.
So, these two figures that I have referred to are undoubtedly the greatest problem of the economy of this country. The greatest problem of the economy of this country is what we owe, which is a lot and which must be repaid, and at this time it is very difficult for us to borrow funds or refinance the debts we currently hold.
I repeat, this is a very important lesson to be learnt for the future: we have lived off too much credit and that must now be refinanced, which is very difficult, or we must borrow it and in that case, as you are aware, this debt is very expensive to service. But our foreign debt is in excess of 90 billion euros.
These are the two most serious problems being faced by the Spanish economy, but there are more, and at any event, they need further explanation and that is what I will now do.
The causes of the current economic situation are the following: firstly, a very high public deficit, what is the lesson to be learnt - that you shouldn't spend what you don't have; neither the public administration services, nor companies, nor anyone should do that, because, together with other factors, that is what has brought us to this situation; secondly, the lack of competitiveness of the Spanish economy, which has caused us to make structural reforms to be able to grow and create jobs, which is undoubtedly the major objective of this country; and thirdly, a heavily indebted financial system, including the debt held by small- and medium-sized enterprises, as well as household debt; a financial system with a very high delinquency rate, which can't collect what it loaned but which, logically, must repay what it borrowed.
These three factors: the public deficit, the lack of competitiveness of the economy and the debt held by Spanish society are what have given rise to this foreign debt that I spoke about before, of more than 90 billion euros, which is the heavy burden weighing down the Spanish economy: more than 90 billion euros of debt outside of the country.
There is another very important factor, a fourth factor: the doubts surrounding the Euro, doubts that affect those countries with the highest public deficit and with the greatest foreign debt and lowest economic growth, which is what is causing us many problems in receiving financing and even when we do, at a high price.
I have set out a brief summary of the causes but what we need to do - that is why I have spoken about the causes of the situation - is to act on these causes to achieve a recovery of the Spanish economy and, within a reasonable time, start to grow economically and create jobs.
We have worked during these first months of this legislature and we will continue working in the future along five lines, which are the lines that mark the economic policy of this government: firstly, to correct the deficit so that we only spend what we collect; secondly, to make reforms to become more competitive; thirdly, to drive reform in the European Union as a whole, which is where we are, and it is important that, as well as making national reforms, there are also European reforms; fourthly, we are working and we must continue working, to resolve the problems of liquidity and financing of the Spanish economy and ensure that we can receive financing at a reasonable price and that interest on the debt does not become excessive; and fifthly, we must also work for the future of the Eurozone and give it some certainty in this future to which I have just referred.
The first two decisions, correcting the deficit and reforms, correspond to the Government of Spain, the other three are decisions that must be adopted by the European Union; but Spain is under the obligation, or that is how I see it, to try to influence and contribute through ideas, applying its criteria and opinions so that things are done on a reasonable basis.
I will move on to briefly comment on the five lines of action that I have mentioned. I will spend more time on the first - the reduction of the public deficit - because undoubtedly the decisions we have taken on this matter are those which most affect the Spanish people. We are talking about reducing spending and increasing revenue through tax increases. That is why I wish to explain this matter, which will be more extensive than the one I give on the other four major lines of action affecting the economy.
Why does the public deficit damage the economy and the lives of Spanish people? Why spend more than is collected in revenue and why does living off credit cause so many problems and cause us to be in the situation in which we find ourselves? I will try to explain this.
Firstly, because, as you can easily understand, it is never good to spend more than you have. That is the case for households, for companies and also for public authorities.
Secondly, because this money that you seek to spend but isn't collected in revenue must be borrowed, and that removes credit from the private sector, specifically from families and companies.
Thirdly, because when you spend more than you have to spend and thus increase the deficit, what you are doing is increasing your debt and at a time like the present, when it is hard to find financing and it is only available at an extremely high price, this is clearly a problem that anyone can appreciate.
Fourthly, it is not good to generate a public deficit because that increases the debt and the cost of servicing debt has risen astronomically in Spain in recent years. We will have to pay eight billion euros more to service our debt next year, I repeat, because we have become so heavily indebted in recent years.
And fifthly, in the current climate it is clear that we lose credibility if we do not reduce our public deficit and that also affects the Spanish people in a very real manner. When we committed to a figure of 6% and it then transpires that the real figure for last year is 8.9%, Spain's credibility is very seriously harmed.
Hence, for these reasons we must correct the deficit, we must try not to spend more than we collect because not doing this causes terrible harm to the Spanish economy and the well-being of the Spanish people. What I am saying is an obligation; please believe me that it is not easy to say, it is very difficult; it is not pleasant, but rather very unpleasant. It is not what we would like to say and I am well aware that it is something that the majority of people don't like, but you can be totally and utterly certain that, if we are doing this, it is because we must do if we want to come out of the situation we find ourselves in and not exacerbate our future even more.
Hence, our first obligation is to spend closer to what we collect. This has obliged all public administration services, from central government, to the autonomous regions and local government, to reduce their spending and to try to increase their revenue. I repeat that this is not optional. There is no other way out. One cannot spend what one does not have and, moreover, you cannot spend what you cannot borrow, and that is what has forced us to take many of the difficult decisions you have seen us take.
But, in the same way as I say this, I will also say that, together with other measures that I will mention later - I pointed them out at the beginning - this is what will help us to grow, this is what will end up generating economic activity, this is what will result in the public authorities being able to collect greater revenue and better finance basic public services.
I will make a brief summary of the decisions we have taken to try to reduce the public deficit in Spain.
We started, as you all know, and you knew this at the beginning, with a decision in December last year - it was at the first Council of Ministers in actual fact - with a Royal Decree Law to correct the public deficit by 15 billion euros. We followed that with the Budgetary Stability Act and the Financial Stability Act, so that public authorities couldn't spend what they didn't have. They were followed by the most austere Budget in the history of Spanish democracy, with a reduction in ministerial expenditure of 17%. We then reduced the number of senior civil service offices by 20%; this was followed by the approval of Draft Bills on tax fraud and Social Security fraud, which is a matter that this government undoubtedly gives great importance to and on which it is acting at the present time. Decisions were then taken on National Health Service expenditure and education. Then, on 13 July, we proposed a local government reform, measures were taken on matters of the civil service and public servants, Value Added Tax was raised and measures were taken on matters of unemployment and long-term care.
And so, these measures are not nice and the government is aware of that, these measures are not popular and mean making an effort - not for the government but for the Spanish people and companies. They are arguable. I know that they are all arguable and I know that differing opinions can be made on each of them. But what is not arguable nor subject to opinion is the overriding need to cut expenditure and increase revenue. The obligation to stabilise our accounts and thus show the world and our partners that we remain a serious country that meets its obligations as it always has - this is not open for discussion.
In short, that is the first line of action, and perhaps the most difficult to carry out, because what is gratifying is to spend money and attend the requests of our citizens; but that is not possible today and, moreover, this is a vital step forward, I repeat, for our future.
I would also like to say that the obligation to control the public deficit affects, as it rightly should, all of our public administration services. The government I lead has 20% of the total Spanish public expenditure; out of every 100 euros, the government I lead spends 20; Social Security - an essential item - 32%, principally in pensions; the autonomous regions have between 37 and 38% of the total Spanish public expenditure, and local government - our local councils - have the rest: 11 or 12%.
What I mean to say is that exiting this crisis is a national objective and, to do so, we must all move in the same direction. The government has made a great effort at reducing its expenditure; the autonomous regions also, and both should move in the same direction.
I wish to point out that the government has not ignored the situation of the autonomous regions. I am the President of the Spanish Government and hence, I am responsible to Europe and to the whole world for the situation of our public accounts.
We have helped the autonomous regions, firstly by doubling the period they have in which to repay their debts to the State as a result of bad budgeting in the years 2008 and 2009. We have doubled this period for repayment and that is a great form of relief.
Secondly, we have made payments on account that have resolved many liquidity problems.
Thirdly, we have implemented a Supplier Payment Plan, because there were outstanding debts amounting to almost 30 billion euros; debts with suppliers and with independent contractors that had provided services, because they had been commissioned to do so by the public authorities. I believe that was an economic clean-up measure, but, above all, a primordial moral obligation. If a public authority contracts a service, it seems sensible and responsible that its first obligation should be to pay for it.
And finally, we have made available to the autonomous regions, as from 1 January, through the Official Credit Institute (Spanish acronym: ICO) initially, and subsequently, through the new Liquidity Fund, an instrument so that external maturities can be dealt with and to cover the public deficit they have amassed.
Hence, I repeat, this is an obligation that falls on all of us, but obviously the government will not abandon its obligations.
The first point is the public deficit which I have already mentioned. The second point is economic reform. To achieve economic growth, to create jobs and to ensure that public authorities have more resources, we need to undertake reforms to become more competitive.
Over the last six months we have implemented a series of reforms to lay the foundations for the economic recovery of this country. These reforms have not produced results just yet, it is too early for that, but they will produce results in the future and they are necessary because, if not, we will lag behind. I will make a brief summary, because I don't want to make this speech too lengthy, of the reforms we have undertaken. I would just say that there is no precedent of actions of these characteristics taken by a government in only six months.
Firstly, we have committed to the job of cleaning up our financial system; a task that other countries undertook in 2008, with injections of capital worth more than one and a half trillion euros. EU countries injected capital into their financial entities worth more than one and a half trillion euros. What is true is that they did this in 2008 and that has helped them overcome a large part of their problems.
So, we have implemented a restructuring plan of the financial system with the main objective of having a solvent financial system, one which is seen as such and which can hence offer credit, because without credit it is very difficult to make investments and without investment it is impossible to grow economically and create jobs.
We have subjected our financial system to an independent assessment, something that has not been done by any other European Union country. I would like to stress that the majority of our financial entities are solvent, far more solvent than certain others, but I would also like to say that there are three financial entities that currently belong to the State, as you are aware. In the same way as I tell you this, I should also point out that, at this time, one of the greatest problems of the Spanish economy to grow and create jobs is currently being dealt with and is in the midst of being resolved.
This is a very important reform, as you are aware, but we have done even more. I will also refer to the labour reform, because of its importance. It came into force not long ago, and I believe that the labour reform, when economic activity starts to improve, will be instrumental in creating jobs and instrumental in avoiding job losses on a large scale when times are tough, which is what has happened in Spain over the last few years: 2,700,000 people have lost their jobs. I should say that the majority of the lay-off plans (Spanish acronym: ERE) that have been implemented this year were not lay-off plans that ultimately ended up in jobs being shed definitively, but rather were lay-off plans involving a temporary suspension from work or in a reduced working day, which is important because it means that in times of difficulty there exist possibilities for workers to relocate, jobs to be temporarily suspended or a reduction in the working day, rather than the only alternative that existed before, which was the definitive loss of a job position.
And hence, the labour reform was an important reform.
We have implemented the Transparency Act, and the Access to Public Information and Good Governance Act; we have reformed supervisory bodies and created a National Market and Competition Committee; we have approved regulations on matters of the liberalisation of commercial opening hours and services; and also in matters of promoting property rentals and making them more flexible; we have taken the first steps towards liberalising transportation in Spain; we have approved the National Tourism Plan and the Coastal Act. I have only mentioned the most important of the numerous measures taken, rather than boring you with a complete list.
Hence, in these first months, on matters of controlling the public accounts and on matters of structural reforms a great effort has been made on which, I insist, we will continue in the future.
But, as I said at the beginning of my speech, there are three other lines on which it is essential to work as well: firstly, on economic reforms at an EU level; secondly, we need to continue working to resolve liquidity and financing problems, those problems of the infamous risk premium that strongly affect financing our economy; and finally, we need to talk about the Euro and the future of the European Union. Behind these three matters I have just mentioned are the problems that seriously affect the Spanish economy and hence, the well-being of our citizens, such as the problems of financing, the risk premium, the cost of money, the confusion and doubts surrounding the Euro, etc.
I would like to say that during the course of these last few months, I have devoted a good deal of my time to these matters, because I believe that there are many aspects of the future of the Spanish economy in play, because we are clearly a part of the Eurozone and of the European Union as a whole.
I would like to say to you in this respect that the European Council of 28 and 29 June ratified, as you are aware, the irreversible commitment of the European Union to the single currency and the willingness of both Member States and EU institutions to do whatever is necessary to guarantee the financial stability of the Eurozone. That was a positive European Council and many people said that, for the first time in many Council meetings, decisions were taken, an objective was established and a course set. I should say - I didn't say it then but I'll say it now - that I came out of that European Council very satisfied.
At that European Council, we spoke about fiscal and banking union, the direct recapitalisation of banks, we spoke about intervention in the secondary market… Much was spoken about. The important thing now is that this is all firmed up in real decisions. Mr. Van Rompuy, President of the European Council, has a job to do, the Commission as well and I will say that I have sent a letter to Mr. Van Rompuy and a letter to Mr. Durao Barroso in which I have set out Spain's position on these matters: on banking union, on fiscal union and on what, in my opinion, should be done in the future. This is my contribution. As you would expect, I have done this over the course of the last few days and there will undoubtedly be other contributions, but what I am asking for is that these matters be debated in October and that, at least the banking union be approved in the month of December, at the last European Council of the year.
I repeat that Spain is under an obligation - at least I see it that way - to make a clear commitment to the European Union and to give its opinion because, I repeat, a good part of the things that go on here also depend on decisions taken in other places.
In that letter, I talk about what is urgent: a single supervisory system and a direct mechanism for bank recapitalisation; I talk about the need for the European Union to deploy instruments in a flexible and efficient manner to guarantee access to financing, and I present a proposal on banking and fiscal union.
These are, in short, the five main lines of action of the government, which is what we have been working on over the course of these last few months. I would like to say that the government feels committed through a clear mandate from the Spanish people, a mandate to resolve the problems of our country, and we are determined to comply with that mandate. We didn't promise miracles because we knew that that wouldn't happen, but when you do the right things, when you are aware of the problems, when you act calmly, consistently and with perseverance - which is what this Government is going to do - the results will follow and I am sure that, sooner rather than later, we will see these results.
We have worked very hard over these last few months, as you are aware. I know that many of the decisions we have taken are arguable, but no-one can say that the government has not taken decisions, no-one can say that the government has not governed and no-one can say that the government had to govern in easy circumstances. I know that many Spanish families and companies are facing very many difficulties. I am absolutely aware of that, but I want to say to you, to all Spanish citizens, that the government is fully aware of where it is heading, that the government knows what it has to do and that, although the situation is difficult, we will overcome it, as has happened on other occasions, although not quite as tough as the present one, over the course of our history.
We will remain committed to the path of reforms and to the fight to clean up our accounts and, of course, we are going to continue giving our all and doing whatever is necessary - and more if we can - to head towards more Europe, so that the European Union clarifies its position and ceases to arouse doubts regarding an instrument as important as the single currency, the euro.
The task ahead of us is enormous; it is huge, but it is not an impossible task and, of course, it is much more bearable if we are all committed to a common objective.
There are some figures that are positive and give rise to hope, and we must continue to head in that direction.
This year, the Spanish foreign deficit will be on almost zero when it had reached as high as 11%. This figure is very positive because it means that we will have to ask for less financing from overseas and that is very important. It is true that our debt still remains, that debt of 90 billion euros, but it is an important step.
It is very important that our trade balance with the Eurozone is in positive figures. In other words, Spain sells more to the Eurozone than the Eurozone sells to Spain. We have a surplus in our trade balance with Germany. That is a milestone; one we had never seen before, and that is important. That means that Spanish companies are exporting and that is a good sign because it generates a culture that always benefits the economy of countries that are capable of doing that.
And it is also important to have controlled inflation below the Eurozone average, because that helps us to gain in competitiveness.
These figures are all positive, but we must still improve on them and we must still resolve some of the most significant problems that I have referred to in this speech. I know I have spoken for a long time but it is not easy to summarise six months of such intensive work of a government in a short time. And now I will take any questions.
Q. I have a couple of very specific questions about what you just said. You say that the task ahead of us is great, but not impossible, and that it would be more bearable if we were all committed to this goal. I would like to know whether, given this complicated situation, you plan to speak with the leader of the opposition and the rest of the parliamentary groups, or whether you have already done so, and if so, what you asked from them.
I have another specific question. You referred to the government's main concern being the five million people out of work; I would like to know whether the government has decided yet what to do with the 400-euro benefit for the unemployed who will soon not be entitled to any benefits and whether this will be extended beyond 15 August.
President of the Government. We haven't taken a decision on this matter.
As regards the first question, I should say that I talk regularly with the leader of the opposition. I should also say there is agreement on something that is fundamental in Spain right now; our position regarding the European Union. The Socialist Party and the majority of the political parties with political representation in the House are in favour of direct recapitalisation for the banks; they are in favour of resolving the liquidity problems being suffered by some Eurozone economies at the moment, including ours; and they are in favour of banking union and fiscal union.
I regularly discuss these matters with the Socialist Group, with their spokesperson, who is also involved in speaking with others and logically trying to defend the decisions being taken in Spain. From that point of view I am very pleased.
I believe that the vast majority are fully aware that we need to reduce the deficit, that we cannot spend what we don't have and that reforms need to be undertaken. And that is where it is most difficult to reach a consensus. In other words, everyone knows that we need to reduce the deficit, but then, when one is personally affected, it is harder to be in agreement. That is human nature and fully understandable. The burden of responsibility must be assumed by the government; that is why we have a government.
I have spoken with many people and I have listened to many people. Everyone says "we cannot spend what we don't collect in revenue". That is basic common sense and everyone knows that. Everyone knows, and is prepared to say, that we cannot live off credit on a permanent basis, but as you would expect, no-one wants to be personally affected. That is human nature, that is logical, that is sensible and the government is aware of that, values that and appreciates that, but that doesn't mean that the government is not going to assume its responsibility and take decisions; that is why we have a government.
It is very difficult for someone in the opposition, albeit aware that we need to reduce the public deficit, to say "I agree that this decision, which negatively affects so many people, should be taken". They won't do that. The problem is that it's also very difficult to propose an alternative to what the government is doing, but that's quite another matter.
And hence, I believe that on the main matter being proposed at this time in Spain - the matter of Europe - there is substantial agreement. I believe that everyone agrees with the general lines of action, in that the deficit must be reduced. Let me share an important figure with you that may shed light on exactly what is happening in Spain: in two years, in only two years - 2008 and 2009 - tax revenue in Spain plummeted by 70 billion euros. In other words, the public administration services collected 70 billion euros less in two years, but yet they didn't reduce spending. That is the problem.
I can give you other figures, for example, of certain autonomous regions; one in particular. The autonomous regions have a tax, as you know, which was previously called rights in rem, Property Transfer Tax, Stamp Duty, related to property sale. In 2007, 2.5 billion euros were collected under this tax; four years later, in 2011, this only amounted to 0.7 billion euros. Just imagine what it means for revenue to fall from 2.5 billion euros to 0.7 billion euros.
Spain's tax collection has fallen by 70 billion euros in total; what should have immediately taken place was a reduction in expenditure, because if not, those 70 billion euros need to be borrowed. That is what caused our public debt to increasingly rise and that is what has brought us to such a difficult situation in terms of interest rates.
That is why everyone is in agreement; there is no other alternative. And so, I appreciate that the lion's share of the responsibility falls to the government. I need help in the European battle so that I can go, in the same way as to the last European Council, with a decent parliamentary majority behind me. And for everything else the government is there, because that is why it was elected by the Spanish people, to meet its responsibilities.
Q. Since we are taking stock, you won the elections with a clear message that your government would bring confidence to the markets, to the European Union and to the Spanish people. I would like you to take stock regarding whether in these last few months, your government has given this level of confidence that you promised before the elections.
And my second question, you're aware that there are many protests in the streets. You were asked for a referendum because you have done the opposite to what you said. I understand that you are not considering a referendum but are you planning any type of measure to strengthen the democratic fabric such as you requested from José Luis Rodríguez Zapatero in the previous legislature, such as a vote of confidence; something to back up this volte-face in some way?
President of the Government. The general message I gave to the Spanish people was that our objective is to grow and create jobs. I believe that all of us who stood at the last elections agreed on that.
I basically said three things: first, as we have done and as I have mentioned today, we need to reduce the public deficit; I was tireless in insisting on that, and I continue to do so and this needs to be done; secondly, we need structural reforms that improve the competitiveness of the economy and I mentioned one specifically: the labour reform; and thirdly, the restructuring of the financial system in order to return to having credit available. Those were the main three ideas, but logically there were many other aspects of our electoral programme.
Confidence? I can say that in these last 48 hours there have been very important statements made regarding the Spanish economy. The International Monetary Fund, no less, said that Spain has made a great effort, that it is doing things well and that this must be afforded its due value. Along the same lines, we have heard the Prime Minister of Finland - I will not mention the person who was here yesterday, because he was here and might think this is out of courtesy - say exactly the same. In other words, the reforms are being valued positively, as is the great effort we are making at this time, but logically Spain needs to continue along these lines and that is why I said that we will continue along the same lines in the coming months.
As regards strengthening the democratic fabric, no-one has mentioned it and no political group that I am aware of has requested one. And the Government of Spain has a clear mandate: the Government of Spain was elected by those who can elect it - the Spanish people - for a term of four years with one sole objective: to grow, to create jobs and take the measures and decisions necessary to that end.
We take stock of the situation when appropriate. I am now taking stock of the first six months, not of four years.
Q. I wanted to ask you if you could explain how it is possible that Spain, which will have a deficit of 6.3% of GDP by the end of the year, if we are lucky, doesn't think that it needs intervention from the Bailout Fund, when Italy, which has a 4% deficit, said yesterday that it didn't rule it out.
President of the Government. Mr Monti, and any other leader, can take the decisions that they deem appropriate and suitable. We can indeed say that Spain is aiming for a public deficit of 6.3% this year; Italy is also suffering from its public deficit, but Italy has, for example, public debt in excess of 120% of its GDP while Spain's public debt doesn't even reach 80%.
That is why the two situations are not comparable, and everyone can take the decisions they deem appropriate and suitable. I said this yesterday; I believe that Mr Monti is governing very well, in very difficult circumstances, and he is taking the decisions that need to be taken, trying to get them right, in the same way as I am.
Mr Monti said yesterday that he didn't rule it out or accept it. If you want me to tell you straight out what I believe and that is that I will do - as I always do - what is in the general interest of the Spanish people. One cannot be the President of the Government unless that is what you do. I will do what is in the general interest of the Spanish people. Not long ago, as everyone is aware, Spain asked for help, for a loan, for a maximum amount of 100 billion euros for recapitalisation, to dissipate any doubts surrounding our financial system and in order to inject credit into our economy. This was a loan under very favourable conditions which, naturally, the financial entities that use it will have to pay back. I did this because I believed that this was in the general interest of the Spanish people, because I believed it was good to bring credit to our country.
What happened yesterday? I told you yesterday that there were two things, in my opinion, that were very positive. The first is something I was convinced of and something I had stated in public on numerous occasions but which has now been stated by the President of the European Central Bank. He said that the differentials in Europe were unacceptable, and hence, that it is unacceptable for some countries to be financed at zero percent while others are financed at 6 or 7%. That was the message we all heard yesterday and is something that is very important. There is a second important factor, which is that the President of the European Central Bank said he was prepared to intervene, something he hadn't said before, or to put it another way, he had said exactly the opposite. Those two things are important.
In addition to all that, he announced that he would take certain unconventional monetary policy measures to resolve the problems of the Eurozone. What I would like to know is what these measures are, what they mean, what they aim to do, establish whether they are suitable and thus, in light of the circumstances, take the appropriate decisions. I have not taken any decision yet but I will do what is in the general interests of the Spanish people as a whole, and as I said, we still don't know exactly what is being proposed.
For me there are two positive elements. I repeat, and I feel that this needs to be properly conveyed, if you will allow me, that yesterday the President of the European Central Bank said that the differences in financing that exist between countries in the same monetary area were unacceptable. And I must say this is true and very difficult to understand and that no-one understands this as far as I am aware.
Q. President of the Government, two questions. Firstly, yesterday the President of the ECB said that he wanted the ECB to be explicitly asked to intervene in the secondary market to buy bonds should any country consider this necessary. I wanted to know if you are prepared to specifically request this or whether in a private conversation with him you might have suggested it.
On the other hand, the subject of reforms. You have just said in your speech that you are going to continue undertaking reforms. I wanted to know if you can tell us when you will announce the content of the energy reform, in light of the fact that the markets are harshly punishing much of the uncertainty surrounding companies with energy interests, and also if you are going to make headway with the reform of the pension system, as demanded by international bodies, and when this might take place.
President of the Government. As regards the third question, no-one has demanded anything of me, at least that I am aware of. Hence, it is difficult for me to respond to a demand I am unaware of.
As regards the energy reform, three Royal Decree Laws have already been passed on this matter and the reforms will continue in the future.
And in relation to your question about the European Central Bank, I answered that earlier and I have not had any private conversation with Mr Draghi on the matter.
Q. President of the Government, you have spoken this morning about the economic measures that the government has taken and that are difficult to take, in your words. I have a specific question on this subject; I would like to know whether today you have spoken about the possibility of extending the 400-euro benefit to the unemployed, in light of its expiry on 15 August.
President of the Government. I have already answered that question, put to me in the same way by one of your colleagues.
Q. I wanted to know whether your government is prepared to sit down with Artur Mas to negotiate a fiscal pact and if you see it as viable that Catalonia has a short- or medium-term fiscal pact.
President of the Government. If someone wants to see me, I… Do you understand what I mean? I have already met with Mr Mas. I have no problem whatsoever with meeting with Mr Mas, or indeed with any president of any regional government. This very week I met at Moncloa Palace, as you know, with the President of the Regional Government of Andalusia, Mr Griñán. In reality, I have met with all of them except the President of the Regional Government of Asturias, who I hope to meet with during the course of the summer; and that wasn't deliberate but rather because he has only been the regional president for a short time. He has asked to meet with me, and so, naturally, we will.
At any event, the situation that Spain is currently going through is the one we are aware of and at this time our priority, and what is necessary and essential and what we must do is all work in the same direction. Nothing else makes sense at this time.
I said to you earlier that 37% of Spain's public expenditure corresponds to the autonomous regions and 20% to the central government, and hence it seems reasonable and logical that we all work in the same direction. But furthermore, if we grow and create jobs, we will avoid many problems, because the problem currently being suffered by the Regional Government of Catalonia and other autonomous governments is not due to the financing model, which they supported, voted for and agreed to, but because tax revenue has fallen. The Regional Government of Catalonia receives 50% of the VAT (IVA) collected in Catalonia, 50% of the Personal Income Tax (IRPF) collected in Catalonia and 58% of all taxes collected in Catalonia. And it also receives, as you would expect, Transfer Tax, Inheritance Tax, etc.
If VAT revenue drops, if IRPF revenue drops and if Transfer Tax revenue drops because properties are not being sold, that considerably complicates the situation for everybody, particularly for the Spanish public administration services as a whole. That is why we all need to make cuts in public expenditure now: the autonomous regions, the Regional Government of Catalonia as well, which is making cuts, as we are as well.
Hence, this is the main priority in Spain at this time, and this is the major responsibility that we all have towards our citizens. Aside from that, I will receive anyone when that person considers it opportune and convenient.
Q. You said you've noticed certain changes in the position of the European Central Bank; but what is clear is that it would seem that Germany wants Spain to take the decision to request that bonds be purchased and Spain has not requested that. From what you said, I deduce that the solution will be left until December. I wanted to ask you if you can appreciate any change in the situation after five years of crisis and also whether you are concerned about the effect that this impasse may have on public opinion.
On another note, I also wanted to ask you whether you can specify exactly what the leader of the opposition has committed to in terms of the common position in Brussels.
President of the Government. To dialogue and to trying to find common ground. In fact, this hasn't been at all difficult to date. But, in short, we all have similar positions in regard to these matters. We all want more Europe, fiscal union, banking union that guarantees liquidity, and to do away with doubts and uncertainty… On that we are in agreement. Hence, there are no problems, at least I don't see any, in reaching agreement on this matter. In fact, it is quite a Spanish tradition to be in agreement on the European process.
As regards the European Central Bank, I said before that I can see a change. Of course, the fact that the President of the European Central Bank says that risk premiums don't respond to the situation of countries' economies, or, at least, don't fully respond to the reality, but rather, on the contrary, are due to the doubts surrounding the Euro seems to be a very important statement, one about which I should take note, and about which all the Member States of the European Union should take note. Hence, that is important and it is important he has said he is disposed to intervene on the secondary market and has announced another series of measures and modalities for the coming weeks.
This took place yesterday but prior to that I hadn't heard anything about this, not me and not anybody else. We heard him a week ago in London saying he would do everything possible to save the Euro, but I had heard many times that he wasn't going to intervene on the secondary market. Hence, this is a significant change.
No-one has asked anything of me. This talk about the Germans… I don't know if your information is better than mine, but I can clearly state that no-one has asked anything of me. I am unaware of this date in December and I can't add much more than what I said earlier.
What is the ultimate objective? It's not the same if the ultimate objective is to resolve the doubts surrounding the Euro once and for all or it that ultimate goal is something else. What is intended to be bought on the secondary market? Six-month debentures or 10-year, 5-year or 7-year bonds? This is clearly not the same. Is that enough? It depends on the situation of the markets at any given time. What is the procedure that will be used? Is it the ESM, which doesn't exist? What are the modalities that Mr Draghi said yesterday he was going to announce? We are not aware of them.
Whenever anyone takes a decision, he must have, as you would expect, above all when it is a decision of these characteristics, the greatest volume of information possible. Once cannot act irresponsibly. And hence, I will act, as I said at the beginning, in the way that I consider is best for the general interests of the Spanish people, but to do so I need to know exactly what we are talking about.
And so, I repeat, there are two things that are very important for me, and I, of course, when I said to you that I was going to talk about Europe… Europe cannot accept, the Eurozone cannot accept, if we want to truthfully talk about a political project, a project for the cohabitation of millions of citizens, differences in financing of this magnitude between one country and another. That does not happen in any monetary region of the world, none of them. It is impossible for it to happen. That is why it is important to resolve this issue.
Q. In Japan, we are paying close attention to everything that is happening here in the Eurozone, and we appreciate that Spain has taken some major decisions. But in order to have competition within the Eurozone, as you have mentioned, a major labour reform is needed. Within this labour reform, could more cuts in labour costs also take place?
President of the Government. We have already implemented a labour reform and have no intention of making another different labour reform. So that is where we are and that is where we are staying. We believe that the labour reform is a good labour reform. As I said earlier, it is working. There are many indefinite contracts, the entrepreneur contract… There are many indefinite contracts and I am convinced it is a wonderful instrument for the future. The data from the latest Active Population Survey show that indefinite contracts are indeed on the rise, as are new hirings in the private sector, but that these are decreasing significantly in the public sector as a result of the adjustments being forced on the various public authorities for the reasons I mentioned earlier.
Q. I will be brief. With the figures in your possession and the forecasts on the table, would you be prepared to rule out cuts in pensions for next year?
I would also like to make a request; would it be possible for us to see a copy of the letter you sent to Mr Van Rompuy and to Mr Durao Barroso?
President of the Government. Yes, that's not a problem. We will set the procedure in motion to do that. This is our contribution to a debate which had to take place out of necessity, and hence, today, through the usual procedures we will send out a copy to those who wish to read it.
With the figures in my possession, I have no intention of lowering pensions next year and, as I have said on numerous occasions, this would be the last budgetary item that I would touch. I repeat that I have no intention of lowering pensions next year.
Q. Seven and a bit months of what I imagine have been tough times for you and your government have now passed. Perhaps some of your ministers are tired or burnt out in their careers. There are some who say that the economic team needs an economic vice-president of the government. Are you thinking about some kind of reshuffle in the short term?
President of the Government. To be frank, no. This usually… I have spent 30 years in politics, almost 31 years now, and no summer goes by in which there isn't a debate about some kind of change or another, about whether someone is going to resign, about whether someone is tired or burnt out…
I am very pleased and very satisfied with my government. They are working very hard. I will repeat what I said at the start of my speech: many decisions have been taken; furthermore, this has been done at a particularly tough time; these have also been difficult decisions; they are also decisions that are hard to understand and people find them so because they are not easy decisions, which is logical and I appreciate this. I am proud of how the government has performed and how they have stood their ground in parliament, where, logically, the opposition complains and protests, as well as in other situations.
Hence I agree with what you said. These have been tough times, but you can be absolutely certain that the government I lead, and I myself, will act with consistency and with all the perseverance with which I have acted during the course of my political life, and I am absolutely convinced that Spain will overcome this situation.
Honourable Members, thank you very much and those that can, have a great summer.
