Press conference of the President of the Council of Ministers of Italy, the President of the French Republic, the Chancellor of the Federal Republic of Germany, and the President of the Government.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 June 2012

Context
Rajoy, Hollande, Merkel, and Monti held a joint press conference in Rome on 21 June 2012 ahead of the EU Council summit to coordinate positions on eurozone growth and stability.
Main themes
Eurozone stability, economic growth and job creation, European integration, growth package (130 billion euros), banking union, macroeconomic discipline, single market, financial market stabilization, structural reforms, European Investment Bank, financial transaction tax, Van Rompuy report on economic integration
Duration
~30 min
83rd percentile
Words
3,649
83rd percentile
Sentences
156
82nd percentile
Readability
51
67th percentile
Grade
11.8
43rd percentile
Syntax
3.11
62nd percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

156 sentences in 76 paragraphs

We have agreed to recognize that since the economic crisis began, the European Union has made significant strides to preserve the integrity and stability of the euro. Today we have new instruments, also for countries in difficulty, that did not exist in the past.

Nonetheless, we also agree on the need to highlight that what has been done so far is still not enough; in particular, in terms of economic growth, the subsequent stability of the eurozone, and providing European citizens and markets with a clear design regarding the medium- and long-term prospects of European integration.

The first objective on which we all agree is the relaunch of growth, investment, and job creation, which must be achieved either through structural reforms at the national level to increase competitiveness or through a new agenda at the European level.

I believe it is a step forward that has been made in recent years in European culture and politics, and it must be noted that growth cannot have a solid foundation without balance sheet discipline, and that, on the other hand, balance sheet discipline risks not being sustainable in the long term from an economic and political standpoint if there are no satisfactory conditions for growth and job creation.

We are working on a European-level agenda and we are working intensively, as members of the European Council, with President Van Rompuy, with the President of the Commission, José Manuel Barroso, and with other partners, to achieve concrete objectives in this European agenda.

At the next European Council, we will support a series of actions to relaunch the economy, investment, and employment; to increase competition in Europe and to more fully realize the European single market, which is a great objective that has still not been fully achieved.

We would like there to be a relevant package of measures for growth at the European level that amounts to about 1% of the European Union's Gross Domestic Product, which means, more or less, 130 billion euros. We are also working to ensure that within this vision of a growth package, there is also consideration for the quality and composition of public spending that recognizes the value of certain investments.

We have renewed our common commitment to respect a sound macroeconomic discipline, essential for the stability and solidity of a financial system capable of sustaining investments for the real economy and job growth; the increase in the capital of the European Investment Bank and the more effective use of community resources to strengthen growth and competitiveness… And I will not make a long list.

We also attach great importance to the report that the group of President Van Rompuy, President Barroso, President Juncker, and President Draghi is preparing on the long-term perspective of European economic integration. This is very important, as I said, both to engage European citizens in such a significant undertaking and to give markets a clear perspective on the irreversibility of that great project that has so far been very successful and is called the "euro." We also place great importance on mechanisms to stabilize financial markets, evidently.

I will stop here. I thank my colleagues for the contributions they have made to this very constructive meeting, and now I ask the President of the French Republic, François Hollande, to take the floor.

Mr. Hollande.- First of all, I want to thank Mario Monti for his invitation here, in Rome, and for his initiative.

This meeting prepares for the European Council that will take place on June 27 and 28. This European Council must mark progress to restore confidence in the eurozone and in Europe. I believe that our meeting today has been useful to achieve this objective.

First of all, we talked about the indispensable growth package. A figure was given: 1% of European GDP should be mobilized with a timeline that is as close as possible to the new mechanisms we are going to have; that is, that we can mobilize this financing in the shortest possible time. 1% of GDP is, more or less, between 120 billion and 130 billion euros, and I think it is a good objective.

Then, we talked about a common vision of Economic and Monetary Union, about a "roadmap" that will involve each stage of the Union: monetary union, banking union, and instruments that correspond to this willingness to work together.

The third objective is to fully utilize all existing mechanisms today to stabilize markets, to restore confidence, and to combat speculation.

Therefore, the European Council, if we achieve these objectives, can be an important step for Europe.

In addition, we can add -- I will continue to work in that direction and I believe I have been well heard regarding this proposal -- the financial transaction tax.

With this, I summarize what we have done today.

The four main economies of the eurozone, and without prejudging anything that other countries may even decide, we have affirmed common objectives and have given this growth perspective specific content. We are also aware that we must send a signal -- a signal of cohesion, a signal of coherence, a signal of stability, and a signal of solidarity -- and I believe that is what we have done today.

Mrs. Merkel.- Thank you very much, Mr. Prime Minister. I also want to sincerely thank you for the fact that we have been able to meet here today. I believe it has been a meeting at an appropriate time for the four most important economies of the eurozone, and with that we want to highlight that we are doing everything possible to fight for the euro, as our currency, from which we all benefit.

What needs to be done in the future must be as stable as it has been in the last ten years. To achieve this, we must overcome certain problems, although some things have already been done. Countries have implemented many reforms and, above all, we have created instruments of solidity, as well as joint solidarity instruments.

In light of the current discussion, it is now a matter of addressing the issue of employment, of creating jobs for people, much more intensively after we have dealt intensively with the Fiscal Pact and budgetary issues. For the next European Council, it is necessary to send clear signals, and I completely agree with everything that has been said by those who have preceded me in speaking: 1% of the Gross Domestic Product of the common European space invested in growth and other investments is the right signal we need.

I am also very pleased that the four of us can say today that we support a financial transaction tax. People in our countries still have the impression that the crisis has come with the international financial crisis and that financial markets are still not participating enough in the solution.

Thirdly, we have a problem that we want to solve in the medium and long term, and it is a good message that we can give today: we must tighten our political ties, especially in the euro area. Those who have a common currency must have a coherent common policy, which is something that the last three years have taught us. It is something I always call political union. We must work more towards that closer political union.

Herman Van Rompuy, José Manuel Barroso, and others will make proposals in this regard, but these four countries represented here, and Germany in a particularly dedicated way, will contribute everything we can so that discussions can also take place in our respective countries and we can say that Europe is getting closer and closer. The lesson from the crisis is not less Europe, but more Europe. That is the signal we can give today.

Thank you very much for the wonderful hospitality and the excellent atmosphere.

President.- Thank you very much, good afternoon.

I want to begin this brief intervention by thanking President Monti for his initiative, for his reception, and for the treatment he has given us.

It has been, as all speakers have said, a very pleasant meeting, in which we have sincerely discussed the issues that currently concern our countries and the whole of the European Union.

As almost everything has been said, I will simply point out five issues in which I have seen substantial agreement, and I will conclude this intervention with three comments, which are the ones that have mattered most to me today.

I believe, first of all, that there is agreement among all on the need to control our public deficits and not to excessively raise the public debt of our respective countries.

Secondly, there is agreement on making structural reforms at the national level to improve flexibility, the competitiveness of our economy, and thus achieve greater economic growth.

Thirdly, and various speakers have referred to some of the proposals that will be raised at the next European Council, there is also agreement to make structural reforms at the European Union level.

Fourthly, those of us who have spoken at this meeting have expressed our determined will to implement all necessary mechanisms to achieve financial stability in Europe.

Finally, we have made a clear and strong commitment to the future of Europe: we want more Europe, we want a political union, we want an economic union, and we want a banking union and a fiscal union.

For my part, three comments, which I take away and which for me summarize this meeting.

First, there has been an undisputed commitment to the irreversibility of the euro, which is undoubtedly the most important project we Europeans have launched over many years.

Secondly, there has been agreement among all that all necessary mechanisms will be put in place to achieve financial stability in the eurozone.

Finally, there has been a commitment to more European integration in the future: banking, economic, fiscal, and political.

Thank you very much.

Q.- In light of the message that emerges today from these four powers that represent the majority of European GDP, what can be expected in the conclusions of the next Brussels Summit?

Mr. Monti.- One can expect enough. The European Council is the sum of us and others; therefore, it is not a third entity outside of us.

We are here to actively contribute to building a strong, progressive consensus that involves growth and stability at the European Council. The European Council is under the leadership of its president, Herman Van Rompuy, and we have considered that if four countries as important as ours and so diversified in their conditions find a line of convergence among themselves, this can greatly help to achieve an important consensus in the European Council. Therefore, it is something that we offer to President Van Rompuy and to our colleagues in view of that very important meeting.

We hope that the work done over all these months… Because let us not forget that each of the heads of government present here, with their own government and their own collaborators, has stimulated the advancement of European issues.

Europe is a very important, very solid construction; not always very dynamic in the short term. It is necessary for us to help it develop, and therefore we hope, after the further contribution we have made today, for conclusions from the European Council that can be even stronger and more credible than those of previous Councils, regarding a growth perspective for the European Union; that can provide a clear medium- or long-term line for economic, financial, monetary, and banking integration, with some aspect of political integration; and that these conclusions from the European Council, and the joint and solidary way in which they are reached, can meet the expectation in financial markets that the euro is here to stay.

Q.- My question is for President Hollande. Mr. President, you have put growth on the European agenda, but you have placed the issue of "eurobonds" in a ten-year perspective and are preparing a drastic plan to reduce the deficit. Ultimately, will German-style rigor definitely prevail over growth? In terms of European integration, are you ready to accept the purchase of sovereign bonds?

Mr. Hollande.- I believe that "eurobonds" must have a ten-year perspective. As there is a union, an integration, "eurobonds" will be a useful instrument for Europe, and I will continue to work in that direction and to place this mechanism within a perspective.

Secondly, growth. Who could have said a few weeks ago that it would now be on the agenda of a European Council?

Since the G-8, where Mario Monti, Angela Merkel, and I met, we have had the G-20 meeting, and before that, there was a formal European Council, growth, given the situation, has become the priority. Does this mean that states have to give up their budgetary rigidity? No, absolutely not. We have been pursuing this policy for some time, and it is not going badly; considerable and, at times, tough efforts are being made for public opinion.

I believe that budgetary efforts must be made, also in France. This does not mean that nothing has been done until now. I will not make any comments on past French policy, in any case. But wanting growth precisely means allowing that budgetary adjustment to not only be austerity, because I am against austerity.

At the same time, I know that we have to send a message of coherence and stability; and, therefore, of trust. That is what we are doing today, and that is what the European Council must measure. Its role is, at the same time, to send a very concrete message of support for growth, those 130 billion euros that can be committed; also a very firm message of full utilization of the stability mechanisms, and finally, to define a medium-term vision for Europe that allows, precisely, for solidarity, of which "eurobonds" are an example.

Sovereignty relinquishments will be considered based on the elements of solidarity that we can find. There can be no transfer of sovereignty if there is no improvement in solidarity and coherence.

Q.- Were concrete decisions able to be made regarding and looking towards Brussels? Are there indications from your side?

Mrs. Merkel.- We are preparing for the European Council. There are four of us here, and, of course, we will feed the Council with our ideas, we will talk with our partners, and there are good opportunities for others to agree with what we decided here and consider it reasonable. We will defend it, of course.

But it is important that the President of the Council, Mr. Van Rompuy, knows what the member states can do and what they are willing to do when it comes, for example, to the recapitalization of the European Investment Bank. National parliaments have to decide on that, and that is why we are contributing our input in favor of growth.

I believe that the important message today is to say that growth and sound finances are two sides of the same coin. Sound finances are a prerequisite, but they are not enough if growth does not emerge from them, and jobs are not created, and employment is not increased, which is the most pressing problem in Europe. That is why we are going to take a step further, and I want to emphasize that the four of us say that the introduction of a financial transaction tax is something conceivable, and that is very important.

The third message is that we need more Europe. Solidarity, on one hand, and, on the other, competitiveness, cooperation, and cohesion are part of a whole. If solidarity is needed, control is also needed. Europe in the past has had a Stability and Growth Pact, but it has not respected it, it has not complied with it. It is not that there are no rules in Europe. Our problem, rather, is that we have lost trust because too often we fail to comply with our own rules. That needs to be restored, and for that, more Europe is needed. For me, the good message today is that everyone is going to participate to continue moving forward on this path.

Mr. Hollande.- I want to respond, based on an old French tradition, to a question that has not been asked of me.

Angela Merkel speaks of the financial transaction tax. It is true that we agree here on this tax and that it can only be considered based on the formula of enhanced cooperation. I will act, along with my partners, so that the European Council authorizes us to make this enhanced cooperation so that we can implement the financial transaction tax as quickly as possible. We are debating it now.

Mrs. Merkel.- The finance ministers have also talked about it, and we will convey it to the Council.

Q.- My question is for Chancellor Merkel and Spanish President Mariano Rajoy. I wanted to know if you agree that the rescue funds should be used to buy debt from countries in difficulty.

If so, when would it be implemented? Would it have conditions? What would those conditions be, and what would be the red lines of the Spanish president?

If not, why does Chancellor Merkel not allow the ECB to inject money directly into banks, when France, Italy, Madrid, Obama, or tonight the International Monetary Fund have asked her to do so?

Mr. Rajoy.- I understand that the last part of the question was not directed at me. The first part was directed at me.

I believe that currently the EFSF can indeed buy debt in the secondary market under the established conditions that were approved at the time. Therefore, I have nothing more to say, but to reflect what is an objective reality. The EFSF can do it, and it can do it, as everyone knows, the European Central Bank did at one time in an exceptional circumstance.

In any case, I believe that it is not very relevant to go into details here today. I believe that one of the most important things we have agreed on today is one of the things I said in my first intervention: we have all committed to implement all the mechanisms necessary to achieve the financial stability of the European Union.

That satisfies me; that is a clear, strong, and understandable commitment to the irreversibility of the euro. I believe that now everyone understands exactly where we are all going, and we have also agreed to move towards greater integration of all kinds; with which I leave this meeting enormously pleased with its content, with the people I have been with, also with all of you, and for being in this city called Rome, which is one of the most beautiful in the world.

Mr. Hollande.- On that subject, we could talk. We should talk about it.

Mrs. Merkel.- At least, it is a very beautiful city, certainly.

I will return to the second part of the question. This is not about allowing or not allowing. The EFSF or the ESM are mechanisms of solidarity, and each country, with its guarantees, contributes to helping a country in difficulty.

I have said that responsibility and control go hand in hand. That is to say, for me and, therefore, for the taxpayer in Italy, Germany, or France, who is the authority that guarantees to me that everything is being done to put things in order? For me, in this case, it is the Spanish state, because the Spanish state can naturally tell its banks, "you have to change this and that, you have to do these and other things differently." But if I simply give money to a Spanish bank or any other bank—I do not want to focus on Spain in this case—I can do it, but I cannot tell that bank what it has to do, because I, as German chancellor, do not have the capacity to say that in another country; I have it in my country, to my banks. And that cannot be done, according to the Treaty.

That is the problem. It is not that I do not want to give money; it is that the Treaties are made so that states are partners with each other, and with this condition, we have founded the EFSF and the ESM. That is how I will proceed.

If you talk about President Obama, we are a structure that does not exist anywhere else in the world. We are seventeen who have the same currency, and yet all of us have national parliaments and all have our state sovereignty. At some points, we have ceded it to Brussels, and now we have to ensure that in our own currency, the necessary political structures are also created so that, as the French president has very well said, there is greater control, greater responsibility, and greater community cooperation. Control and responsibility are two sides of the same coin.

Mr. Monti.- I believe that time has run out, and I would like to conclude with two observations. The first is that if you may find the insistence on the rules regarding European construction exaggerated, I invite you to consider that almost ten years ago, in 2003, Germany and France, with the authorization and complicity of the Italian Presidency, exceeded the euro rules, and we have spent almost ten years rebuilding the credibility that was not broken by Greece or Portugal, but by the main countries of the euro. That is the importance of the rules.

The second consideration is that the call for more Europe, which has been expressed today by everyone, has been articulated today in Rome, where European construction was born. I am very grateful to my colleagues because, with their presence today in Rome to discuss together a step forward in the construction of Europe, they have shown that, once again, all roads lead to Rome.

Thank you.