Press conference of the President of the Government

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

25 December 2014

Context
Rajoy held a year-end press conference on 25 December 2014 to review Spain's economic and policy achievements during 2014 and announce new government measures.
Main themes
Economic recovery, employment growth, pension and wage increases, job creation, company formation, export competitiveness, inflation control, fiscal sustainability, social security, foreign investment, autonomous communities finances
Duration
~67 min
97th percentile
Words
7,989
97th percentile
Sentences
338
96th percentile
Readability
54
75th percentile
Grade
11.4
37th percentile
Syntax
3.17
68th percentile
Vocabulary
1.93
5th percentile

Translated from Spanish

This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.

338 sentences in 117 paragraphs

President.- Good morning to everyone. I stand before you to take stock of what this year 2014, which is about to conclude, has been.

As you know, the last meeting of the Council has just concluded, in which, among other things, we have approved decrees on the revaluation of pensions by 0.25 percent and the Minimum Interprofessional Wage by 0.5 percent.

We have also extended for three more months the flat rate of one hundred euros for Social Security contributions for indefinite hiring. The extension will apply to companies that formalize indefinite contracts between January 1, 2015, and March 31 of the same year.

In addition, we have approved new measures for financial sustainability for the Autonomous Communities and Local Entities. We have also approved the Draft Law on Account Auditing and the Agreement on the Foreign Action Strategy.

In the case of pensions and the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, I want to emphasize that, while these are modest increases, they have a greater effect on purchasing power compared to the nominal figure, because they coincide with an inflation rate of zero or negative. The increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage coincides, in turn, with the average increase agreed upon in the agreements by social agents, which is also around 0.5 percent in 2014.

You will find information on all agreements in the Reference of the Council of Ministers, and if you wish, we can return to it in the subsequent questions.

Regarding the balance of the year, I will try to be brief, but it has been an intense year, with many issues that have occupied our interest, which I cannot fail to mention, even if only very succinctly.

As you know, our main priority remains the well-being of Spaniards, and it will be so until we recover what was taken away by the economic crisis. From that perspective, if you remember, a year ago I predicted a much better 2014, and that forecast has been more than fulfilled.

In the second and third quarters of this year, 550,000 jobs have been created in Spain, in terms of the EPA, and pending the December data, Social Security has increased its number of affiliates by 338,000 people this year. In the last twelve months, affiliation has grown by 2.5 percent, that is, more than 400,000 people. I am convinced that the data for December, which will be published, as you know, in a few days, will confirm this trend.

As you know, employment is a central issue for the Government, and in this regard, the change recorded in 2014 has been substantial: after seven years of crisis and uninterrupted declines, this year, for the first time since 2007, net employment has been created in Spain. That is the most important change and the one that marks a before and after. We have moved from destroying jobs to creating them, from increasing unemployment to reducing it.

"Next year, when I appear before you again, there will be fewer people unemployed in Spain and more people working and contributing to Social Security." These are the words I spoke to you twelve months ago. The forecast has been fully confirmed, and with that endorsement, today I dare to tell you, on this employment issue that is crucial for us: 2015 will be a much better year than 2014.

I also want to tell you that each of the numbers in the employment statistics is much more than an economic magnitude. Each of those figures corresponds to a person. The people who have found a job this year are more satisfied and more secure; but they are also a source of hope for all those who have not yet found employment.

From January to November, 71,500 new companies have been created in Spain. The net creation of companies is increasing at a rate of almost 5 percent compared to last year and 10 percent compared to 2011. Social Security has already recovered a good part of the companies that had been deregistered during the worst moments of the crisis. Spain has moved up nineteen places in the World Bank report that measures the ease of creating companies and the elimination of bureaucratic obstacles.

The competitiveness that our economy has gained, 2.3 percent, thanks to reforms is reflected in the great performance of the external sector. Spain is one of the developed countries with the greatest external dynamism. Our exports account for 34 percent of GDP, well ahead of countries like the United States, Japan, or France, and we also surpass Italy and the United Kingdom. Among the G-7 countries, only Germany surpasses us in export capacity.

The correction of the imbalances in our economy has made us a reference country for international investors. We are among the ten countries in the world that receive the most direct investment, and we are the first in Europe.

I want to highlight, finally, the control of inflation, which has been, for the whole year, 0 percent. This fact has two fundamental readings: the first is that we have been cutting our differential with the average of the European Union and especially with Germany for fourteen months; that is, we are gaining competitiveness for our exports. Secondly, stable inflation, as I said, has a huge social component, because it maintains the purchasing power of wages and social benefits. That is why this year 2014 pensions, far from being reduced or frozen, will have gained some purchasing power, and the rest of the incomes, with consumer prices declining in recent months, are also gaining.

In summary, as I have said on some occasions, these are the first Christmases of recovery: recovery in terms of employment, economic growth, and activity.

In just three years, Spaniards have managed to turn around the situation and the image of the country: where there was once distrust, today we find security; where jobs were systematically destroyed, today we see a continued and growing process of job creation and recovery of Social Security contributions. If last year the economy contracted by 1.2 percent, this year it will have grown by 1.3 or 1.4 percent, according to the data from the Bank of Spain; that is, a turnaround of more than two and a half points.

This is the reality: Spain is growing more than most of our European partners and is the country that today creates the most jobs in Europe. I know that some find it hard to believe, but that is the reality that no one can deny anymore.

I want to say that we have never deceived Spaniards about the situation of our economy, never. We have not done so when things were very bad, nor now that they are getting better. We have never fallen into triumphalism. We have always been prudent and have always wanted reality to correct our forecasts positively and not downwards.

Now we continue to be prudent; but from that prudence, I can assure you that Spain is growing economically, that it is growing on solid foundations, and that it is clearly doing so above the European average. Moreover, I can assure you that if favorable conditions in the international environment --the euro exchange rate or oil prices-- are maintained, 2015, which will be a good year, could be a very good year for our economy.

If 2012, as I have told you on some occasions, was the year of adjustment and 2013 the year of reforms, 2014 has been the year of recovery, and 2015 will be the year of the definitive takeoff of our economy.

I insist, these are the first Christmases of recovery, and I say the first because more must come. We need this momentum to be sustained over time to recover the scars that the crisis has left on Spanish society. That is also an objective that my Government has set.

Ladies and gentlemen, when I highlight the economic evolution data so much, it is because they constitute the pillars of the policies that seek the well-being of Spaniards.

I would like to pause for a moment on the issue of social policy, because I believe it is important to provide data and not just hear slogans on this matter.

Spain has managed to overcome the worst stage of the crisis, the worst, without undermining the substance of our social protection system. More than half of the expenditure contemplated in the General State Budgets, almost 54 percent, is social expenditure.

Within this chapter, special reference should be made to the public pension system. In the Investiture Debate, held three years ago, as you surely remember, I set a red line in the area of necessary adjustments: pensions. And so, while other countries have been forced to cut their pensions by an average of 10 to 15 percent, in Spain, more pensions are being paid, and they are higher than before the crisis began, and those cuts have not been necessary. In 2014, four hundred thousand more pensions are being paid than in 2011, and in the coming year, which begins in a few days, we will dedicate more than 360 million euros a day to the payment of pensions, reaching a record figure that will approach 132 billion euros.

Regarding unemployment benefits, the final figures for the past year exceeded 30 billion euros, that is, 82.5 million euros each day in paying unemployment benefits.

And since we are talking about unemployment, I want to highlight that employment promotion policies will grow next year by 16.5 percent. This is a consequence of the Social Agreement for Employment Activation that we signed a few days ago, in this same room, with representatives of trade union organizations and employers. It is an agreement by which more than four hundred thousand people will receive help to achieve their effective integration into the labor market. I want to insist now on what I said then: after so much effort made in these three years, Spaniards have earned a margin to be able to implement these types of policies that bring hope to people. Before, we could not carry out certain economic activity programs; it was not possible; now it is possible, and that is why we are doing them.

If you allow me, I would also like to highlight the important social component that the tax reform, which will come into effect on January 1, represents. As you know, this reform entails a general tax cut of 12.5 percent, but its main beneficiaries are people with lower incomes: 1.6 million taxpayers will stop paying taxes, and those with incomes below twelve thousand euros will receive their January salary without withholdings. The average decrease for those Spaniards whose incomes do not exceed twenty-four thousand euros will be 23.5 percent. In addition, large families and those with disabled persons in their care will have a negative tax; that is, they will receive the full deduction so that if their incomes do not allow them to access the full deduction, they can obtain it through a check from the State.

I sincerely believe that this tax reform will not only put nine billion euros into the pockets of taxpayers; I believe it will be the definitive boost to economic growth and business competitiveness in our country.

Ladies and gentlemen, I also want to mention in this year-end balance Europe and the changes coming from there.

For decades, Europe has been the great project that brings together and unites Spanish society as a whole. What was once a dream is now being built step by step, data by data, reality by reality. And this year, that European project has also advanced substantially.

After the elections and the renewal that they have brought to European institutions, Spain achieved a double commission of great importance, as it refers, no less, to energy and climate change issues. I believe that the experience, knowledge, and attitude of Miguel Arias Cañete is the best endorsement to defend the changes that Europe needs to undertake in this area, which are so important to us. In this regard, it is noteworthy that Spanish demands for energy interconnections have been adopted as priorities of community policies.

This has also been the year in which the Banking Union has started, a fundamental piece of the European construction process and an instrument to prevent financial crises like those we have recently experienced from recurring. Also this year, the foundations of the economic reactivation plan for the continent have been laid, which has been presented by the new President of the Commission, Jean Claude Juncker.

I think it is also worth remembering, in terms of recovering Spain's international image, the fact that we have managed to become a non-permanent member of the United Nations Security Council for the next two years. From that Council, Spain will continue to defend the principles on which our coexistence is based: freedom, respect for human rights, democracy, and cooperation among nations.

On another note, one of the main concerns of Spaniards during this year has been related to corruption issues. It is a logical, justified concern shared by the Government. The accumulation of scandals related to corruption causes social alarm, undermines citizens' trust in their representatives, and casts a shadow of suspicion over all honest politicians.

Since the beginning of the Legislature, the Government has adopted measures for greater control of the activities of political parties and their finances; but this year it has offered a comprehensive and ambitious response to this concern. We have presented to Parliament a broad package of administrative and legislative measures to improve the fight against corruption and address the deterioration that these cases are causing in citizens' trust in institutions. This includes the Criminal Procedure Law, whose reform we have just approved, the Law on Economic and Financial Control of Political Parties, and the Statute of Senior Officials, as well as the amendments we have recently presented to the Penal Code. Furthermore, as you know, two weeks ago the Transparency Portal was launched, establishing a new way of relationship between citizens and the Administration.

Ladies and gentlemen, all this reformist work, which we have carried out throughout this year and during this Legislature, has been possible thanks to stability: political stability and institutional stability. This is what has allowed us to stand on solid ground to advance in the various reforms we have undertaken.

That is why I defend, and will continue to defend, that stability is a virtue that advances societies, that provides security to individuals and businesses, and delineates the framework of disagreements among different political formations. That is what stability, as guaranteed by the Constitution of 1978, means to me.

Regarding Catalonia, I regret that some have abandoned what should be the priority of any ruler: solving problems instead of creating them and attending to the well-being of the people. The Government of Spain will continue to safeguard the interests of the citizens of Catalonia, supporting their businesses, working to ensure that there is also a solid recovery there as soon as possible, and, of course, fostering concord and understanding among Catalans.

And speaking of institutional stability, I cannot conclude this year-end review without mentioning the exemplary manner in which the transition in the Head of State took place, also in 2014. I want to recognize, once again, Don Juan Carlos for his dedication to the Spanish people over so many years and congratulate Don Felipe for the excellent performance of his duties during these first months of his reign, as we were able to witness just a few hours ago with his first Christmas message.

And finally, I want to congratulate the workers of the Spanish healthcare system who have managed to face such a serious crisis as the Ebola outbreak. We all rejoice that Teresa Romero is alive and that no one else has been infected in this outbreak. This also demonstrates the level of our healthcare system and the commitment of its professionals, something of which we all feel very proud.

I will conclude now. It has been an intense year, a year in which we have continued to work with the primary objective of overcoming the crisis and consolidating the recovery of the economy and the well-being of the Spanish people.

All indicators of our economy show that we have passed the worst, and now is the time to reap the fruits of so much effort. Now is when we cannot let our guard down or turn back. We cannot jeopardize the recovery that has begun and that no one can deny. Turning back on the reforms would be tantamount to turning back on the path of recovery.

Undoubtedly, there is still much to be done, especially when it comes to restoring hope to those who were most harmed by the crisis. They are now our priority.

I want to thank, once again, all Spaniards for their courage and responsibility during this year we are about to finish, as throughout the entire Legislature. I want to tell them that they can feel proud of their country. If more than sixty million foreigners have come to Spain this year, it must be that we have something good to offer. If foreign governments and the press congratulate us and hold us up as an example, it must be that we have done some things well together.

2012 was a very tough year, the year of the great adjustment; 2013, with the reforms, already improved our situation; this year 2014 has been, as we announced, the year of recovery, and 2015 will be the year of takeoff.

I am at your disposal for any questions you may have.

Q.- I wanted to refer to two issues you mentioned in the last part of your speech. One, regarding the King's speech on Catalonia, where he said that the debate is not only about economics and interests, but about feelings. I would like to know if you share that analysis that the debate with Catalonia is, above all, about feelings and if you have any plan to recover those feelings of the Catalans.

Secondly, the appeals you have made for stability. It seems to me that you could be referring to the situation indicated by the polls. All the polls say that the next political map that emerges from elections will not be like the current one. There is an emerging force that could even become the leading force. My question is what strategy you plan to implement to regain the trust of all those Spaniards who have stopped believing in your party and your Government.

President.- Regarding the first question, I think the words spoken by His Majesty the King are very good, as I believe they are to an immense majority of Spaniards; but I, as President of the Government, believe that I should not comment on them or engage with them.

The strategy, as you know, is not something that is usually shared. What is shared are the objectives, the measures, and the results. This about strategy... What I do say is that stability is a value, and we all know that. Spain, since we approved the Constitution in 1978, is a nation that has been governed by great political forces. Sometimes one was elected, other times another political force was elected, sometimes it was governed with a majority, other times it was governed in coalition, and throughout that period of history, Spain was -- I have said this on some occasions -- one of the four countries in the world where the well-being of citizens increased the most. It was a period of stability, with political changes, and I believe it was very positive for Spaniards, the best. And I, of course, defend that period.

That, on the other hand, is what happens in the vast majority of countries in the world where people live better, where there is more well-being: in the United States, sometimes the Democrats win and sometimes the Republicans; in Germany, the Social Democrats or the Christian Democrats; or in France, the moderate, centrist, and democratic right or the center-left. That is what happens in the great countries of the world… Or in Australia, where we have been not long ago. When that stops happening, other things emerge that only generate instability and, above all, a lack of progress, regression, and loss of well-being. You will understand that I always prefer the best for my country.

Q.- A little linking this question and stability as a value to preserve, we see polls that speak, perhaps, of a very fragmented Parliament, although we will see what the results will be; but the debate has opened about the possibility of a unity government with the PSOE. Do you see a horizon of possible collaboration with the PSOE, either parliamentary or as part of the Government, after the next elections? And do you see it possible with this leader, with the current socialist leader, Pedro Sánchez, if he is ultimately the candidate?

On the other hand, we have a 2015 that is purely electoral; there are local and regional elections in May. The other day, the president of the Popular Party of Madrid spoke of her willingness to lead the candidacy for the Madrid City Council, and I wanted to know if you are going to take up that challenge.

President.- Regarding the first issue, within a year, when we know the electoral results, we can start talking about it. At this moment, you will understand that I have other priorities; the first, the fundamental and basic one, is to govern, consolidate the economic recovery, and do what I have pointed out in my initial remarks.

As for the second issue, it is not something that is on the table at this moment nor is it a concern of the Presidency of the Government. This is a topic that the Popular Party will discuss, as always, and will do so in due time. Therefore, at this moment, I believe it is not appropriate to enter into anything.

Q.- I have three very brief questions. First, I wanted to ask you if you still trust in the innocence of the Infanta, as you said a year ago, or if at this point you have some doubts.

I also wanted to know and understand why you accepted Ana Mato's resignation if you are so convinced that she did not have any dishonest behavior.

And the third is a very simple question, and I am curious to know if you are going to answer it or dodge it. It is: do you want to run again as a candidate for the Presidency of the Government?

President.- I will answer all. To the last one, yes. The second I already explained. And to the first, I am the President of the Government and I believe that I should not engage in those matters.

Q.- There is concern about industrial policy in Spain. Are you considering modifying the electricity tariff system and eliminating the auctions?

And on another note, on Monday the last section of the Cantabrian Highway is inaugurated, and I would like you to confirm whether you will attend the event.

President.- Yes, I will attend the event, indeed. With the inauguration we will carry out of that Cantabrian Highway on Monday or Tuesday, it will be possible to travel on high-capacity roads, highways or motorways, from Faro, in Portugal, to Paris, along the coast. Therefore, I believe it is an important work in which an effort has been made in this Legislature, which, as you know, was not a legislature with many budgetary resources; but I believe that investments, especially in the most complicated moments, must be made by prioritizing well and choosing the right works.

I believe that this highway, I tell you -- from Faro to Paris is certainly not a small distance -- is very important, and I will be there precisely because of its importance and because it has cost a lot. It has been very difficult, it has been delayed, and then there were bad moments from a budgetary point of view; but I will be there.

Regarding the electricity tariff... Energy prices are key elements of competitiveness. From an economic point of view, it is fundamental. The cheaper the price of energy, logically, the better it will go for companies, the more they can invest, and the more well-being they can generate, and more jobs. Also for individuals, because one of the most significant expenses for all Spaniards is, for example, the price of electricity.

This has been one of the issues that the Government has focused on the most over these three years. We arrived in a very difficult situation. The price of electricity had been rising for eight years at an average of 6.9% annually. On the other hand, there was a tariff deficit, which had to be paid, of over twenty billion euros, which is a truly colossal figure.

We have had to make very complicated decisions. I am aware that a very important part of the sector did not like them; but today we have managed to eliminate that tariff deficit, today we have laid solid foundations for the future, and today we have achieved that, both in 2013 and in 2014, the price of electricity has decreased after nine years. The great challenge we have ahead of us, and we have many in this area, is to continue lowering electricity prices, and for that, there is a key issue I referred to in my first intervention, it is true that I mentioned it in passing because I cannot delve into all topics, which are the electrical interconnections.

I hope that in February we will hold a meeting here in Spain with the President of the French Republic, the Prime Minister of Portugal, Mr. Jean Claude Juncker, and myself to definitively address this, and for one of these projects under the Juncker Plan to be the electrical interconnections with the neighboring country, which would undoubtedly be a fundamental leap in improving competitiveness in our country.

Q.- I had two questions. Beyond the agreements that, logically, must be discussed after the elections, I would like to know if you currently find the attitude of the main opposition party sufficiently satisfactory to guarantee stability.

Regarding Catalonia, beyond, of course, that the Government attends to the needs of the Catalans, what measures are you going to take to promote the concord that you advocate? What do you specifically plan to do to ensure that this is the case?

President.- Regarding the first question, some of the things one says are misinterpreted, and therefore, I have no problem with the Socialist Party. The Socialist Party is a great party, it has governed for many years in this country. I do not share many of the things they say and do, but that is normal; they feel exactly the same way. But I believe it is good that there is an agreement between the two major parties on the great issues of the State, as has always happened and as occurs in all the countries I referred to earlier. Honestly, I think it is good. I think it is good that there is agreement in foreign policy, that there is agreement in defense policy, and that there is, of course, agreement on the major norms that govern coexistence among Spaniards.

I would have liked us to reach an agreement on the measures we have proposed against corruption, which are some very important ones. I previously referred to the Criminal Procedure Law. In the Criminal Procedure Law, there are two measures of enormous importance. One of them is that the instructions should be carried out as quickly as possible, and the other is the creation of an office to recover everything that has been the object of a crime, to recover the money, to recover what some people have taken.

These are very important things, and I still believe we can reach an understanding. From there, everything else is the future.

Regarding the second question, I have already said it on numerous occasions, and I have reiterated it to the point of exhaustion: I am willing to talk about everything, but do not ask me to talk about the unity of Spain, or to cooperate in liquidating national sovereignty, or to do anything that affects the equality of Spaniards, fundamental rights, or their freedoms. From there, I am willing to talk about anything that is asked of me.

We are making decisions of enormous importance that benefit all Spaniards. Today we have also approved what were the agreements in the last Council of Fiscal and Financial Policy. Look, what we have approved today has very important value, not only from an economic point of view, but it has very important value from the perspective of what a nation is, of what Spain is. Today we have made a very important decision that the State will take charge of all debt maturities—market debt, bank debt—it will take charge of all the deficits that the Autonomous Communities will accumulate, and the State will become, and I believe this is also very important, the only agent that will go to the markets to seek financing.

This will mean a very important saving for all Spaniards and will provide significant relief for all the Autonomous Communities. I believe this sends a double message: there is a solidarity State that helps everyone, especially in times of greatest difficulty, and that will serve, among other things, because we are talking about more than two billion euros, to better attend to the great fundamental public services such as health and education.

Therefore, what we have to do from the Government and, in general, all of us who are dedicated to politics is to educate and explain where each one stands. I, of course, am trying to solve problems for all citizens and willing to talk about everything; but I will not talk about national sovereignty, nor about the unity of Spain, nor about the equality of Spaniards, because if not, I would not be myself, and for the moment I intend to continue being so.

Q.- You have made a balance, if not triumphalist, let’s say quite optimistic, of 2014; but, in any case, insisting then on the polls that some colleagues have referred to earlier, how is it possible that people do not perceive that improvement, that year of recovery? How is it possible that, ultimately, the Popular Party is being abandoned, even by some of its traditional voters, so to speak? According to the polls, I mean.

Then, you spoke of that historic opportunity represented by Spain's entry as a non-permanent member for two years in the UN Security Council. That entry also means greater international spokespersonship, a greater international presence. I am amazed at the silence that, in this case, a country like Spain maintains, or the Spanish Government maintains, regarding the massacre of Christians in Iraq, which has become one of the major issues in international politics.

President.- I have not made any triumphalist balance; I have made a realistic balance and I have explained what I have pointed out here in recent years.

In 2012, I appeared and said that things were going very badly. It was a very difficult year. We were still battling at that time to avoid the bailout, our risk premium was still at enormous figures, there were still many public institutions in Spain that could not go to the markets, unemployment was still rising in our country, and we were still in negative economic growth. That was 2012, probably, along with 2009, the worst year in many years in our country from an economic and social point of view.

In 2013, things were better, but they were still bad. There was still more unemployment—thankfully, it was no longer growing at the rate of 2012—and there was also negative economic growth; but -2.1 percent was the growth of 2012 and that of 2013 was already -1.2 percent. I said last year, here, that this year would be better. Hey! And it has been better: last year it was -1.2 percent economic growth and this year it is 1.3 percent, and in the last six months in Spain, or the last two quarters, the second and third, the number of people with jobs has increased by 550,000. Hey! Infinitely better than 2013, than 2012, than 2011, than 2010, than 2009, and than 2008. This is the best of the last seven years, and I tell you now that the coming year will be better, and I have to take care of that.

I am not a poll analyst. We will see what the Spaniards say, we will see that. For now, the polls speak; but in a democracy, those who have to speak are all citizens, and, of course, the main obligation of the President of the Government is to tell the Spaniards how he sees things, which is what I am saying here this morning.

Regarding our participation in the United Nations Security Council, I must remind you that Spain is not in the United Nations Security Council and, therefore, plays the international role it plays; but, of course, always in favor of democracy, freedom, human rights, and the fundamental rights of people, starting with their lives; always.

Q.- Fortunately, in this type of balance, ETA is no longer mentioned. Nevertheless, the dissolution of the band is still pending, and in that sense, I wanted to ask you what your opinion is on the Basque Government's proposal for the disarmament of the band and the creation of a specific committee for it.

President.- I believe that the definitive solution to the problem of ETA fundamentally passes through the dissolution of the band. That is what I think, that is what I have reiterated to the point of exhaustion, and that is what I believe will happen. It is the best for everyone, starting with them, their own dissolution to enter into a stage of normality, tranquility, and looking forward, knowing that in Spain there are always many people who have lost their lives and who have lost basic fundamental rights because of others who have attacked them and who have formed a criminal organization that still exists, and what needs to be done is to dissolve it and hand over the weapons.

Q.- You have made a couple of references to the Constitution. You have always said that you would accept a constitutional reform if something concrete were proposed by the opposition. Aside from that proposal that may arise, I would like to know if you believe that in this Legislature, given the time left, a reform of the Constitution can be addressed or not.

Secondly, you said "when I appear again next year." I do not know if it should be understood that the term of the Legislature will end in December and if there will be elections in 2016 or if it will be before.

President.- In reality, that was a quote I made of myself. I told them: in 2013 I said this and in 2014 I said nothing. Now, having said that, I have no objection to answering your question.

I believe that the normal timeframe set by our Constitution should be respected. That is to say, elections are advanced for two reasons: one, because a Government does not have a majority, in which case this is a political reason; and another, there may be technical advances: if the elections happen to be held on September 5, let’s hold them in June, which seems a more reasonable time. But I, in principle, have no intention of advancing it; moreover, I believe that next year is a very important year to dedicate to some of the things I have referred to in my speech, and for that, I believe it is also very important to have the greatest political stability.

In relation to that, you speak to me about the reform of the Constitution. I am open to everything, it is true that we have other priorities. Sometimes they say: "you do not want to reform." Of course, to say to a Government that does not want to reform when it has made the Budget Stability Law; the labor reform; the restructuring of the entire Spanish financial system; the energy reform, on which I was asked, or at least on some collateral aspects, before; that is engaged in the reform of the Administration; in the reform of the Law of Market Unity; that has made an education reform… Hey, I believe that this Legislature has been a legislature with a huge level of reforms.

Today we have approved a very important one, because it is very important that, in the end, it is the State that goes to the markets and seeks financing for each and every one of the Autonomous Communities. That is very important, and that is a very unequivocal demonstration of that constitutional spirit of solidarity among all, and I believe that these things need to be valued.

Therefore, I believe that we must continue making reforms, I am willing to listen to what is said to me; but I am not going to propose it, because I do not have it clear at this moment. What I am also not going to do is say "I want to reform this" and then, when asked "what do you want to do," ah, I do not know. Look, that seems quite unserious to me.

Q.- President, I wanted to delve a little more into the political balance, and for that, I will cite three issues. I would like you to order them by priority, which worries you the most, which worries you the least, and why, with a view to next year. Those three issues are: corruption, Catalonia, and the rise of the political party Podemos.

President.- We are not going to hold a contest here. All issues, as is natural, concern me, and in fact, I have referred to the issue of Catalonia in my speech, I have referred to corruption in my speech, and I have also referred to the well-being of Spaniards in my speech. Those are the issues that concern me the most, logically; those I have referred to in my speech, because if I were to talk about different ones, I would make a somewhat strange speech and you might think God knows what.

Q.- A nuance to a previous question. You have made it clear that you do not plan to advance elections, but have you considered holding them in January 2016 instead of November 2015?

Then, the questions. A few days or weeks ago, you gave a conference before a group of businessmen, you said that the economic crisis was already a thing of the past and received some criticism for it. You will remember because you were accused of triumphalism. Today, however, a rise in the Minimum Wage is approved, and you have said—I do not remember what word you used—humble or..., the case is that it is very conservative. So, I would like to know what led you to make this decision and if there was really no possibility of doing something else, because that does not help to convey the message, I suppose, socially.

About Catalonia. A few days ago, the president of the Junta de Andalucía was here, and when she appeared before journalists, she told us that she had told you that she believed they were arriving late and poorly in Catalonia, and that the only way she saw possible, just like her party, was a constitutional reform to get out of the deadlock. I would like to know what you replied to her, if it is possible.

President.- That she give it to me, the reform, and that I was willing to consider it; that she give it to me.

About 2016? Frankly, I have not thought about that issue; but, well, it does not seem the most reasonable.

Regarding some criticisms, it was not just some; there were many that I received afterwards. You have been very generous with me, and I thank you; that was good. Indeed, I believe that, in a way, I have responded to that question before, and what I tried to do was to point out there how I saw things. In 2012 or in 2013, some said I was a pessimist, that it was terrible, what things I was saying… I said some things that I believe are reasonable.

Spain is the country that grows the most in the European Union, in the eurozone to be exact. Italy is not growing, and we are growing much more than France and much more than Germany, more than the average of the eurozone and more than the average of the European Union of twenty-eight. We are the ones who create the most jobs in Europe. And the competitiveness data is improving. Of course, I could talk to you about the number of tourists, which is a record, and about an inflation rate of zero. Things are improving. However, we come from seven years of crisis with negative economic growth and constant job destruction, and, therefore, recovering all that does not happen in half an hour; but what we have done during this time is lay the solid foundations so that in the future that does not happen again, and effects are already being produced.

Of course, compare for yourselves --I compare it because it is my duty and I have to see it-- how we ended December 2012 --I won't even mention 2011, because we had only been here for seven days-- or how we were in 2011, with a public deficit of more than 9 percent. On December 31, 2012, we were in very bad shape, and in 2013, as well. But this is the first year we are growing in seven years. That is a positive fact, and I believe that next year --I don't just believe it; I affirm it-- we will grow more than this year. That is also positive. So, we must tell the truth. You will understand that at this point in my life… But it is very important.

We must convey things that are true. That is to say, if the Spanish economy is recovering… I told a group of businesspeople, why would I tell them, if they already knew. The fact is that for the first time in many years, tax collection is recovering. For the first time, we are collecting, because one of Spain's major problems was the loss of seventy billion euros in tax collection in 2008 and 2009. It is very difficult to recover from that, and that was what generated that monumental public deficit, and what forced us to make very complicated decisions. Seventy billion euros were lost. This year, tax collection is already increasing by a little over four percent. That is already a positive fact, especially with zero or below-zero inflation as we have had throughout the year.

Therefore, I understand that governments are, among other things, to be criticized; but that the Spanish economy has begun to recover and that many people are starting to see it, but that there is still much to see and that I will work for that, I believe is quite difficult to dispute.

We had the Minimum Wage with zero increases, even, for two years. I believe those were 2012 and 2014; but I am not sure, I could be wrong. I think there was an increase in 2013 and now there is an increase. What have we primarily attended to? First, to the inflation which is zero; we have attended to the average increase of agreements signed between trade unions and business organizations this year, which was 0.5 percent, zero and a little; we have attended to the general conditions of the economy and, in the end, after listening to everyone, we believed that this was the best decision.

Now, there is one fact that is very important and that we all must take into account. Look, there is some country in the world that, if it now raises people's salaries by 25 percent, is sinking them, because inflation is at 60 percent. So, what good is a 25 percent increase to them? What is important is to have solid growth. If prices go down, there is no need for salaries to rise much later, and people will be better off, more jobs will be created, we will be more competitive, and there will be greater well-being. The thing is, these things do not happen overnight; but I believe that these policies of low prices and low inflation are very important for our country.

Q.- Mr. President, recognizing the macroeconomic achievements of the Spanish economy, I really want to insist on the issue of the Minimum Wage and pensions because do you think that a three-euro increase in the Minimum Wage and a two-euro increase in pensions can reactivate consumption? Above all, will this recovery reach the real economy in 2015? Will credit flow to small and medium-sized enterprises, which are the ones that create jobs in this country? I would like you to answer that, and especially regarding employment, whether 2015 will not only create jobs but will create quality jobs.

President.- It will arrive, it is arriving. Look, when I came to government, we were coming from a legislature where 3,400,000 jobs were lost. In the second and third quarters of this year, 550,000 jobs have been created in Spain. This last quarter will also go well, and December will too, and 2015 will as well. In other words, it is arriving, and in fact, the number of affiliates to Social Security today is four hundred thousand more than last year at this time. Therefore, these are positive data that are good to recognize.

Permanent full-time hiring --I insist, permanent and full-time-- is growing in Spain at an annual rate of 30 percent. That is also a fact.

You talk about private consumption. It has increased by 2.7 percent in the third quarter of this year and has accumulated four consecutive quarters of growth, after more than ten continuously declining.

Interest rates for SMEs are today lower --I would like them to go down more-- than at the beginning of the legislature, but look at how Spain was financed. When I was in government, we paid more than seven points for the ten-year bond, more than 7 percent, now it is below 2 percent, and this is what allows us, among other things, to carry out operations like the one we did today, which benefits the Autonomous Communities and, above all, the functioning of public services that depend on the Autonomous Communities, which are primarily health and education.

Car registrations this year have risen by 17.3 percent. Look, something is going a little better; we cannot convey that nothing is going well here. The number of passengers on high-speed lines has increased this year, compared to 2013, by 12 percent. There are already some signs of recovery in construction, and as I said, tax revenues are growing by more than 4 percent, and inflation has been below zero for many months. That is, the drop in prices is a very important fact for people; first, for the people, but also for the Spanish economy and for Spanish companies that are more competitive, sell better, and can hire more people because they need to produce.

Therefore, that is what is happening in the Spanish economy. We must continue, but if we continue along this line and with this determination, next year will be better.

Ladies and gentlemen, thank you very much and Happy New Year. May it go well for all of you.