Press conference with the President of the Government following his meeting with the general secretaries of UGT and CCOO, and the presidents of CEOE and CEPYME
Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain
- Context
- Rajoy held a press conference on 15 May 2013 after meeting trade union and employer leaders to announce agreements on employment, social protection, and economic recovery.
- Main themes
- Social dialogue, employment and job creation, economic recovery, social protection, wage moderation, collective bargaining, EU growth policies, banking and fiscal union, credit access for SMEs, public spending efficiency, vocational training, youth employment
- Duration
- ~44 min
- Words
- 5,332
- Sentences
- 215
- Readability
- 50
- Grade
- 12.0
- Syntax
- 3.00
- Vocabulary
- 1.96
This is an interview, press conference or exchange with other speakers. It is split into sentences and counted in the corpus, but its sentences are not tagged on the twelve indices.
215 sentences in 74 paragraphs
President of the Government. Ladies and gentlemen, a very good morning to you all.
After examining the economic and social situation in the country and from the standpoint of undertaking an exercise in responsibility, the Government of Spain and the social stakeholders have sought common ground on a number of issues capable of boosting confidence and fostering growth, job creation and social protection.
We reached an agreement to drive dialogue on social protection, employment and social security in line with the contents of the joint statement. I don't whether you've been given that document yet. If not, it will be made available to you very shortly. To this end, we agreed to set up working groups for the study of social protection measures and to tackle a reform of training for employment and youth employment.
We agreed on the need to promote growth policies within the European Union and for Member States to contribute towards the creation of jobs. To make that possible, we agreed to establish unity of action with regard to the European institutions in order to strengthen national interests in European affairs.
We agreed on the importance of achieving progress on banking union and on fiscal union, and that the next European Union multiannual budget for the period 2014-2020 needs to help boost economic activity and job creation, objectives that should be brought forward for the remainder of the year.
Similarly, we consider it necessary to combine policies seeking public account sustainability as a means to foster economic activity with policies aimed at modernising the productive fabric that help create jobs. These policies should include increased financing for investments and SMEs from the European Investment Bank.
In order to foster competitiveness and jobs, the trade union and employer organisations have reaffirmed the commitment they made to moderation in wages and company profits in the 2nd Agreement on Collective Bargaining in January 2012. This is a highly important agreement and one that, as you are aware, was warmly welcomed by the Government at the time. It is an agreement that has produced results and has served to save jobs on numerous occasions.
The Government, trade union and employer organisations agreed that this wage and company profit containment effort must also be made in terms of price suppression. Public or regulated prices play an important role and the Government is committed in this regard to taking action through the use of all those measures and instruments it has at its disposal.
Also on the issue of collective bargaining, the Government and social stakeholders agreed that a framework of balanced labour relations is essential to independent negotiation and that there needs to be a commitment to internal flexibility. Dismissals must always be a last resort. The use of flexibility instruments as an alternative to job losses is a firm commitment as a mechanism for adapting labour conditions to the changing economic situation of companies.
The Government and social stakeholders agreed on the need to open dialogue for the study of social protection measures so that the most underprivileged sectors of the population can deal with the difficulties they are experiencing as a result of the crisis and unemployment under better conditions.
In turn, the Government has committed to examining the labour reform assessment report, which will be concluded soon, with the trade union and employer organisations.
We agreed to continue working on the reform of training for employment in order to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of public resources, as well as to improve the chances of returning the unemployed to work. To that end, talks have been opened with the social stakeholders to achieve progress on the design of a new Vocational Training for Employment Agreement that can promote and govern a training model that better suits current requirements in the Spanish labour market.
It was also agreed to set up a working group on the oversight of the Entrepreneurship and Youth Employment Strategy.
We all highlighted that the restrictions on credit to households and businesses is one of the greatest obstacles to economic recovery. We therefore consider it necessary to make use of all available instruments and resources. At the same time, we welcome the announcement by the President of the European Central Bank to open inter-institutional dialogue aimed at tackling the lack of credit for SMEs.
As regards efficiency in public spending, the Government and social stakeholders agreed that the public expenditure structure does not always correspond to the needs of Spanish society and the Spanish economy. We agreed that this task of seeking and eliminating duplication and unnecessary spending, together with a more efficient and balanced use of available resources, must be led by all tiers of government to ensure that the Government of Spain and all regional authorities are involved and that it receives the full support of the economic players and social stakeholders. As you are aware, a commission is working as I speak to present a report on the reform of the public administration services, which will be one of the most important challenges for this country over the coming months.
In terms of social security and as regards the definition of a sustainability factor, the Government appointed a committee of experts that will be given until the end of May to draft a report containing a proposed definition of said factor. The document drafted by the committee will then be the subject of debate by the Toledo Pact and, at the same time, the Government will meet with the social stakeholders to discuss the sustainability factor within the framework of tripartite dialogue and the current social security regulations. The Government has asked the social stakeholders for their full collaboration on this highly sensitive issue for Spanish society.
Ladies and gentlemen, that is a brief summary of the main issues we discussed and agreed upon for the joint statement, which I don't know whether has been made available but, as I said before, will be made available to you shortly. I will now answer any questions you may have for me.
Q. You have mentioned working groups and talks; but we understand from the trade unions that you do not believe the right climate exists for a government pact to be reached, something which they themselves are calling for and which the opposition party is also calling for, even the head of state with a certain degree of fine-tuning or not. I would like to know why you believe, with six million people out of work, those conditions do not yet exist. What needs to happen for those conditions to be met?
Another question. You have asked for generosity from the heads of regional government and many of those heads of regional government are rebelling against that asymmetric deficit. I would like to know whether you are concerned by those statements, of which we are hearing more each day.
President of the Government . The truth is I am not. This is an issue, as I have already said here on previous occasions - I think I mentioned this issue on Monday after the meeting with the Prime Minister of Portugal and his government - that requires two things: firstly, that the deficit for this year actually be set at 6.3%, something that the Commission needs to definitively decide upon and then the European Council afterwards; and, secondly, a working group has been set up within the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council to tackle this issue, first of all, and will issue a proposal on which the Government will make a decision.
Therefore, this is an issue about which I have said nothing more than that which I will say now, which is common sense: we need generosity and to not forget that difficult times need us to seek the best solutions and the best solution is this: economic growth, jobs and improved well-being for our citizens. One of the requirements is to comply with and post a reasonable public deficit - in this case it would be, if it is confirmed, the 6.3% - and this is a task for us all: central government, the social security system, the regional governments and the local authorities.
Hence, I am absolutely convinced that this is an issue that will be resolved, as was the case on the previous occasion, without great difficulty or problems. I repeat, I am absolutely convinced.
As regards your first question, there are a number of issues we are going to talk about. Allow me to explain which issues we are going to discuss and on which issues we basically agree.
Firstly, we are going to talk about Europe and there is substantial agreement on this issue, and a good part of the problems in the Spanish economy... A good part will be resolved in Spain, but there is an important part that will be resolved in Europe and everyone agrees that Europe needs to implement economic reforms, just as the Member States need to do the same. Everyone - I mean everyone in Spain - agrees that Europe needs to undertake greater integration, everyone wants to see substantial progress on banking union at the European Council meeting in June and for the schedule to maintain the agreement on economic union, fiscal union and political union reached in June last year. Finally, everyone agrees on the need for decisions that improve liquidity and credit, especially with a focus on small- and medium-sized companies.
Therefore, I think the fact we are in agreement on such an important issue as Europe is clearly a substantial step forward.
Something else I mentioned in my speech and which I consider to be of enormous importance because, as I said in that same speech, it is something I referred to when this understanding was reached last year: that the trade union and employer organisations have reaffirmed the commitment they made to wage and company profit moderation in the 2nd Agreement on Collective Bargaining in January 2012 is very important. Sometimes we give greater important to words than to actual specific facts. This is very important. It has been fundamental to improving the competitiveness of the Spanish economy and it has been fundamental to saving a large number of jobs.
It is essential that this be accompanied by a suppression of public or regulated prices because one of the laws we are going to present over the coming weeks is the De-indexing Act, which is one of the laws we included as a fundamental part of our National Reform Plan that we sent to the European Commission on 26 April. It is also very important for there to be a commitment to internal flexibility in collective bargaining.
It is also important that agreement was reached to talk about social protection; it is also important that agreement was reached on the workings of the labour market reform; it is absolutely important that it be realised that the training system currently in place in Spain needs to be changed, that there is an understanding to try to create a better training system that better trains those people who want to work; the fact there is a working group to oversee the Entrepreneurship and Youth Employment Strategy is also very important, I think; that the trade union and employer organisations are willing to collaborate on the reform of the Spanish public administration services is an extremely newsworthy fact, in my opinion; that the sustainability factor, which is an issue of enormous importance for maintaining pensions in our country in the medium and long term... This is one of the most important reforms that any country can implement and the fact we can talk about that is, naturally, something of vital significance.
Therefore, if we were able to reach an understanding... there is already an understanding in terms of European affairs and on the issue of wage, profit and public price moderation. That is important. I think making progress on everything else is a question of setting realistic targets and one of enormous importance.
Having said that, there are certain issues on which we are clearly not in agreement; but that is not a problem. The Government has to assume its responsibilities. In other words, if we have to lower the public deficit, as we did last year, by 22 billion euros, we already know that getting support from anyone will be a very difficult task. At the end of the day, the Government bears the brunt of the consequences, that's what the Government is for: to take decisions that are tough and difficult.
But I repeat, what we spoke about today is very important in my opinion. They are far-reaching reforms that Spanish society has needed for a long time. Therefore, if we move forward in the right direction, as we already have on a number of issues, I will be very satisfied.
Q. Mr. President of the Government, forgive me but I would like to insist on the question of those conditions that you, according to the trade unions, do not believe exist for that grand government pact for employment that are being called for not only by the two main trade unions but also by the main opposition party. Exactly what conditions are missing? Why do you believe that cannot be achieved or that the right political conditions do not exist for reaching that agreement?
Secondly, there has been significant pressure from Brussels in recent days on a number of elements to strengthen, according to them, the reforms being implemented here. There has been talk about the financial reform and also about parts of the labour reform. Do you think you will be able to resist that pressure? Will you need to implement tougher reforms or change those initial reforms?
President of the Government. As I said in response to the question from your colleague, I wouldn't give too much importance to words. The Government has a policy with a three-fold target: growth, job creation and a better level of well-being for the people. It is clear that if we grow and create jobs then revenue will be higher and we will thus be able to maintain and improve our fundamental public services. We're talking about the well-being of people.
The Government is following five lines of action: firstly, controlling the public deficit; secondly, the structural reforms in Spain; and then there are three lines that relate to European affairs - the European reforms, European integration and European liquidity. I think there is basic agreement throughout Spanish society on these three issues. In other words, everyone wants to see economic reforms in Europe, everyone wants to see greater European integration, everyone is committed to banking union and fiscal union, and everyone agrees on the decisions that affect liquidity and that can be taken by both the European Investment Bank and the European Central Bank. So I think there is an important consensus in that regard.
As regards the public deficit, it's clear that it falls on the Government to negotiate with the European institutions about the public deficit target. When I took office, I had a public deficit target for 2012 that increased significantly because it was 4.4% and rose to 6.3%. This year, we had a target of 4.5% and that has now changed to 6.3%. There are some people who therefore think that the public deficit must be lowered, but a more balanced path is more reasonable and makes progress easier because, at the end of the day, this is also about reaching the target of not having a public deficit at all; not spending what you don't have.
Therefore, from that point of view, I am pleased; I can tell you that. We are going to talk about the sustainability of pensions and, naturally, we will see the outcome whether we reach an agreement or not. An agreement has been reached on wage and profit moderation, which I think is enormously important and that, as I said, has greatly influenced the results from those positive parameters we have seen in the Spanish economy; that is also very important.
I would not give so much importance to words. At the end of the day, it falls on the Government to assume the most important responsibility; but I do think we can work together on these issues.
Was there another question? Ah! Yes. Europe. In actual fact, what we have passed to the European Union are our plans: the Stability Programme with a deficit of 6.3%, the accompanying growth forecasts and a Programme of Reforms. That Programme of Reforms is practically what I read to you in my initial speech: the sustainability factor; the reform of the public administration services; the Market Unity Act, which was the subject of a preliminary assessment by the Council of Ministers; the Professional Services Act.... Hence, those are the reforms we are going to propose.
As regards employment issues, we are going to assess the situation. That is what we are doing right now and what we will then do with an independent body. So, that is our plan. Now, it is absolutely normal for there to be people who do not like this labour reform because they find it too tough and for there to be others who believe we should have implemented a different labour reform. The same applies to the tax issue; some people think one way and others think differently, and they are probably all right in one way or another. But it falls on the Government to steer the economic policy and it is the Government that must take those decisions that it believes to be the right ones at any given time in order to achieve - and let's never forget this - the overarching final objective, which is economic growth and job creation.
As I have already said on repeated occasions over the course of recent days, the Government has set a course and the Government knows what must be done. It is clear that if certain issues were to progress faster, especially in Europe, then the situation would improve faster; but we obviously have our own political policy that we naturally, as everybody is doing, discuss with our European partners.
Listen; we recently received data on what is happening in the European Union and they should be a cause for reflection for us all: six consecutive quarters of negative economic growth in the Economic and Monetary Union, the Eurozone - six consecutive quarters. This has never happened before, not even in the crisis of 2008-2009. But please note that, since the third quarter of 2008, the Economic and Monetary Union has posted growth of 2.9% while, in the same period, to give you an example, the United States posted growth of 3.3%, am I right? I am not going to talk about the emerging countries because it makes no sense to do so; but 2.9% since the third quarter of 2008 in the European Union and more than 3.3% in the United States.
That, in my opinion, demands a certain response and the response it demands consists, at least we believe this is correct, of those five points, those five lines of action we are working on: Europe needs to be much more competitive, its economies need to be more flexible, reforms need to be implemented in Spain and within the various Member States, but also at a European level, and we need more liquidity at the moment. I think that one of the most important issues today, and many people agree with me, is the issue of credit. We need our small- and medium-sized companies to have access to credit because it will be hard for there to be any investment without credit and, without credit, as you will perfectly understand, there will be no growth or job creation.
I therefore support, and I also said this in my initial speech, the European Investment Bank taking on a much more active role than it has done so far, although it has taken some steps and that must be acknowledged. The European Central Bank has also taken certain action, but those latest statements from Mr. Draghi about the possibility of providing more financing to SMEs is a positive move. We will have to see what materialises but it is obvious that we will need to do something.
I will also remind you of the data from this last quarter, the latest figures to be released, those from January, February and March: countries like France have posted results that are not exactly good, although neither are the results from Spain excellent, or Italy or, in general, the Union as a whole, which indicate that we are still in recession and that action needs to be taken. I believe that the lines drawn out are positive but I also think that we all need to be much more active and take more decisive and courageous action, if possible.
Q.- Mr President of the Government, I have two questions. I would like to ask you about the reform of the pension system. I would like to know the position expressed by the social stakeholders and whether you believe it will be possible to reach an agreement with them in this regard.
Also, I would like to ask you about the reports indicating that the European Commission granted Spain a deficit target of 6.5% for this year over the 6.3% set by the Government. I would like to know whether you can confirm these reports.
President of the Government. I have no information regarding your second question. You are saying that...
Q.- There are reports that would suggest that the Commission set a target of 6.5% instead of the 6.3% that the Government decided...
President of the Government. No. Perhaps the 6.5% is the forecast; but, in principle, the target is 6.3%. I do not recall... The truth is that I cannot answer that at this time. I think that it's possible that the 6.5% is the forecast, but the target we have set is the 6.3%. That could be...
Q.- What they set was 6.5%.
President of the Government . No. For now, nothing has been set. The 6.3% is what we have proposed in our Stability Programme. This will be assessed by the Commission, it has been received positively, and then by the European Council.
As regards the sustainability of pensions; this is a priority structural reform for the Spanish economy, am I right? In our Stability Programme, we have issued a forecast this year for a deficit of 1.4% in the Social Security system. That means a shortfall of 14 billion euros. That figure is no trifle, as I am sure will not escape your attention.
So, we need to have a system that establishes the rules of the game clearly and, above all, provides a guarantee regarding the maintenance of public pensions that, naturally, is an issue that concerns everybody: both pensioners and those hoping to receive a pension in the future. So, absolutely everybody here, am I right?
We have commissioned a report from a group of independent experts and that report will be passed to the Toledo Pact so that any pertinent contributions and comments can be made by the various parliamentary groups. We will also discuss it with the employer and trade union organisations. Will it be possible to reach an agreement? We don't know, but I sincerely hope so. An understanding has already been reached on certain issues, as I've already said; it will probably be more difficult to do so on other issues but... And the Government is aware that is the case, that there are issues on which it is easier to reach agreement than others, especially in such complicated times as these.
I mentioned the deficit earlier as an example. Nobody likes to be forced to make cut-backs, as we were forced to last year - 20 billion euros; but we simply have no other option at this time. Even I can understand that the opposition does not support us, which, of course, it did not do; but the Government has its responsibility regardless, it has a mandate from the people and must comply; but it's true that if certain issues, especially the structural reforms and the rules of the game for the future, can be the product of an agreement, then so much the better.
Q.- Mr. President of the Government, all these specific agreements you just mentioned, will you also propose them to the opposition groups? What I mean is, do you intend to meet with Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, for example, and with the other opposition spokespersons?
I would also like to ask, if you will allow me, about the rebellion we have witnessed in recent days from the autonomous regions governed by the PP against an alleged deal in favour of Catalonia regarding the public deficit. First of all, I would like to know whether you can confirm that such a deal in favour of Catalonia exists and, secondly, whether you can guarantee that those regions meeting their deficit targets are not going to be punished.
President of the Government. I have already been asked that question, albeit in a different way; but I will answer you. I will answer the question.
Your first question was about the political groups. In the debate we held in Parliament, I said what I think: the Government has a duty to assume its responsibilities and it is doing precisely that. If that means taking a blow to the chin, we will have to accept that. Our main duty is to govern at a very difficult period in history, during very complicated times, with a European scenario as I have just defined, which is not easy; but, above all, it would be very important if we could reach an understanding on the structural reforms.
I am going to be frank with you and tell you some of the reforms we have proposed and what has happened.
In the reform of the Budgetary Stability Act, which is a priority structural reform -among other things, it is the reform that enables us to set an overall deficit target for all regional governments, something that was impossible before, as you are perfectly aware- on that issue, we received no support from the Socialist Party.
The labour reform is a reform that has given flexibility and competitiveness to the Spanish economy, which has produced good results and enabled what always ended in dismissals before to now end in solutions that eventually enable jobs to be saved. We received no support there either.
The restructuring of the financial system, which is another of the major structural reforms, a difficult and complicated issue, we have had to nationalise three banks, a very important issue given their size; we received no support.
On such issues as how to deal with the preferred shares or the evictions, which were left over from before we came to power, on which we have made every effort possible; we received no support.
In other words, we have received no support on any of the major issues tackled by the Government. Now, having said that, I am still willing to keep talking. I would very much like them to come on board with us.
I have spoken to the general secretary of the Socialist Party on many occasions in recent weeks and months. Our conversations were not negative; but no agreement could ever be reached in the end. What I will not do is deny anyone the chance to reach an understanding, nobody; but what I will clearly not do, and what I mustn't do, is not take the decisions needed by the Spanish economy.
I am willing to accept the cost and take that blow on the chin; perhaps others are not willing to make that sacrifice. I think that we can reach an understanding on certain issues and I will work towards achieving that; but, I repeat, a course has been set and that is important. I think that the economic policy being implemented at the moment is important. The support on European issues reassures me greatly. The fact there is a position shared by everyone in Spain on these issues is positive; but, when I read certain documents handed to me by certain political groups saying "you have to raise spending under all budget headings"... Well, that is simply impossible. Perhaps such comments are easier to make from the opposition; but the Government cannot say that spending should be raised across the board because there is simply not enough money for that to be done. In other words, I have to implement realistic and balanced economic policies that naturally respect all parties concerned.
In any case, I repeat, I do think that today's meeting was very positive. I also explained to the trade union organisations, as I had done on previous occasions at non-public meetings, what the Government has been doing, the lines of action it is following and the major obstacles encountered. This serves to reaffirm the agreement on wage and profit moderation, and also for the Government to make a commitment in the De-indexing Act to increased control over public prices - the regulated prices. That is important. And the fact that we share a perspective on European issues is also very positive.
We will talk about training at a later date -we agree that things can be improved in this regard, about the sustainability of pensions and the reform of the public administration services. Today, we focused on the major structural reforms left to be implemented in Spain following those we implemented over the course of last year and the first quarter of this year. In other words, we must continue with our reforms; we must continue to reduce the deficit; and, together with our European partners, we must realise that we cannot accept six consecutive quarters in the Eurozone with negative economic growth because that path leads us nowhere.
As regards the action of heads of regional government, there really isn't much more I can add. We had a deficit target of 0.7% for all the regional governments as a whole, and that has now been raised to 1.2%. It is certainly not a minor change. Having said that, what I need to know is where the deficit target for next year will be set; and then we will need to listen to everyone at the Fiscal and Financial Policy Council, and then a decision will be taken.
But - and I can understand that some people do not agree with me - this is not the most important issue facing the Spanish economy at the moment, it really isn't. The European issues are far more important, as are the structural reforms, and we need to focus on working together to meet the public deficit target because, listen, 6.3% means we need to borrow 63 billion euros this year. That is what 6.3% means and that is a vast amount of money, regardless of the fact that the markets have improved and regardless of the fact that Spain can now finance itself. We have overcome the major debt crisis. Just remember how things were a year ago, with the risk premium at 500 points and even over 600 points... it reached 639 basis points at one point. The situation is far more reasonable now, but that is a consequence of many things; among others, the implementation of serious policies and policies that generate credibility and confidence.
I do not think that public arguments have a useful effect in this regard. You already know that I am not a great fan of such action; but what can we do. However, I am not overly concerned by this issue. We will take sensible, reasonable and balanced action, which is what the Spanish economy needs and what everyone will congratulate us on.
Thank you very much.