Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

10 April 2012

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions from Duran i Lleida regarding the government's compliance with court rulings on the territorialization of the 0.7% income tax allocation for social programs.
Main themes
0.7% income tax allocation, autonomous community competences, Supreme Court ruling compliance, Constitutional Court doctrine, regional subsidy distribution, Catalonia fiscal contributions, state vs. regional jurisdiction, social sector funding, government accountability
Duration
~23 min
73rd percentile
Words
2,808
73rd percentile
Sentences
90
58th percentile
Readability
43
44th percentile
Grade
14.2
69th percentile
Syntax
3.47
93rd percentile
Vocabulary
2.22
53rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 47%46%
  • Economic 37%36%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Social 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 3%

90 sentences in 44 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President of the Government, the allocation of 0.7 percent, the classic little cross on the Income Tax Declaration of individuals, is one of the few moments when the taxpayer, within the framework of our legality, is allowed to directly choose the purpose to which a tax they pay will be dedicated.

In this regard, a recent ruling from the Supreme Court, dated December 16, 2011, grants the State the regulation of the central aspects of the subsidy regime for resources, while placing everything related to management, that is, processing, resolution, and payment of subsidies, as well as the regulation of the corresponding procedures, within the realm of autonomous competence.

We know, Mr. President, that you do not share the thesis of the President of the Community of Madrid regarding the end of the autonomous State; but there are other ways to end the autonomous State, and one is by not complying with the transfers, by not complying with the rulings, whether from the Constitutional Court or the Supreme Court, or by also suffocating them financially.

Therefore, Mr. President, I would like to know if you and the Government intend to respect the ruling of the Supreme Court regarding the territorialization of the 0.7 percent, which, I must tell you, is a social outcry from those entities that do great work based on those resources.

President.- Mr. Duran, the Government respects, abides by, and complies with, as it could not be otherwise, judicial resolutions. However, having made this general statement, I must add something. You are undoubtedly referring to a ruling against a challenge from the Generalitat of Catalonia against an Order from the Government of Spain from the year 2008 that established the bases and calls for subsidies for various social programs funded, indeed, by the allocation of the Income Tax of Individuals.

This ruling annuls, as you have said, the Order from the Government of Spain from the year 2008; but it does so not on a substantive issue, or on a matter of competence, but on a procedural issue, and therefore, that ruling does not state that the distribution must be done as you say.

From that point on, the Government of Spain, especially from the year 2009, established a procedure agreed upon by all the Autonomous Communities, supported by the Generalitat of Catalonia itself, which I believe reasonably serves the general interest and allocates, in a sensible, reasonable, and effective manner, the resources that taxpayers want, when they pay the Income Tax of Individuals, to be dedicated to social care.

Mr. Duran.- No, the Generalitat does not support that system of resource distribution. Neither does the Generalitat support it, nor does the social community, the entities of the third sector, which are directly affected.

I feared greatly, Mr. President, that you would make the reflection you just made to me, surely the product of some report from the State Attorney's Office; but I must remind you that, prior to the ruling of the Supreme Court and in general terms, there is a ruling from the Constitutional Court, and I want to read it to you, Mr. President, because it is not regarding a specific call, but rather in general terms. It says the following: "We consider that the regulation of the central aspects of the subsidy regime, the object and purpose of the aid, the technical modality of the same, beneficiaries, and essential access requirements, is included within the sphere of state competence, while we will place within the autonomous competence everything related to its management, that is, processing, resolution, and payment of subsidies, as well as the regulation of the corresponding procedure in all respects, since it is a reiterated doctrine of this Constitutional Court." Ruling 168/2011, of November 8, prior to that of December 16 from the Supreme Court, to which I referred in my question.

Therefore, legally, the Government has no excuse not to comply, especially considering, on the other hand, that a great injustice occurs, because in the case, for example, of Catalonia, with 16 percent of the population, 25 percent of the resources are paid, and the amount that returns to Catalonia in this regard...

President.- Mr. Duran, I do take into account the reports from the State Attorney's Office and, in general, all the legal reports that the Administration may have. What would make no sense is for me, by my own decision, to interpret the rulings of the Courts.

Therefore, the reports from the State Attorney's Office and the reports from the other bodies that have to provide them, as well as the Government's own actions over the past few years, indicate that the actions being carried out respect the procedure and the rulings of the Constitutional Court regarding the distribution of competences, both in social assistance matters and in subsidy activities.

There is something that I believe is very important and that we should all take into account: these social programs are not only autonomous; they are also social services managed by Local Corporations or by national entities. And those national entities, which can operate in one, two, or three autonomous communities, also have the right to use those allocations that taxpayers voluntarily pay when they file the Income Tax Declaration.

I believe that the current system of negotiating, agreeing, understanding, and acting in the Sectoral Conference, with institutional loyalty and respect for the competences of the Autonomous Communities, is a system that has worked well and that, therefore, does not seem reasonable to me...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, of the Parliamentary Group of the Left Plural

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, does the Government consider that the tax amnesty is the best way to combat fraud?

President.- Allow me a brief comment on the economic context in which we find ourselves. Spain has an urgent need to reduce the public deficit if it wants to finance itself, if it wants to meet its voluntarily assumed commitments in the European Union, and if it wants there to be economic growth and job creation.

Therefore, we must reduce the public deficit. This year the target is for it to be 5.3 percent. Instead of asking, as we had to ask last year, 2011, for ninety billion euros in loans, this year we will have to ask for sixty billion and reduce the deficit from 8.5 to 5.3 percent. And this is done by reducing spending or increasing revenues. That is why we have raised some taxes and have tried to do so in a fair and equitable manner, and we have cut public spending.

In this situation, we did not want to raise taxes further, and that is why, in this situation, this measure makes sense. It is a measure that is adopted in a very difficult situation, in an extraordinary situation, and it is an exceptional measure that will only serve and have effects in this year 2012.

It allows undeclared assets, which today pay zero, to surface in order to increase the revenues of the public treasury. Those assets will pay 8 or 10 percent. It is an incentive to end tax havens, an instrument to reduce the underground economy, and it will also bring about or seek continuous revenues in the future.

This is a system recognized by the OECD and that has been practiced in some countries in our environment such as Germany, the United States, or, more recently, Italy, which in 2009 and 2010 raised five billion euros from this concept. It was already done in Spain three times in 1977 and in 1984 and 1991, and that was indeed an amnesty, because those incomes paid zero; now, as I have told you, they pay 8 or 10 percent.

Therefore, it is very important at this moment to improve the State's revenues. It will be accompanied by a plan to combat tax fraud that will be approved this Friday in the Council of Ministers.

Mr. Lara.- We are aware of the serious situation our country is in, which is why the question comes today, and we also understand that this is not the way to combat the deficit situation we have.

When the previous Government proposed a tax amnesty, the Popular Party made two special statements; one was made by you, Mr. Rajoy, and you said literally that "those who already pay will pay more and those who do not pay will be forgiven what they have not paid." That was in opposition to the measure that was being attempted to be adopted. And Ms. De Cospedal said literally: "It is so unfair, so antisocial, that those who pay taxes are raised and those who do not pay are amnestied or forgiven."

Today, as yesterday, Mr. Rajoy, the tax amnesty for the rich remains unjust, useless, unconstitutional, and, moreover, will increase fraud. It is unjust because it rewards the big defrauders; it is useless because the recovery of what has been defrauded, according to the Government's accounts, is meager; it is unconstitutional because it violates the spirit and the letter of Article 31 of the Spanish Constitution regarding the progressivity of tax payments, and you swore to uphold the Spanish Constitution and enforce it, and it is a "call effect" to tax insubordination, to not pay, to those who do pay all taxes regularly. The tax amnesty allows us to continue being robbed by all with impunity.

Mr. Rajoy, the problem of fraud is not solved by cutting resources to the Tax Agency, as in this year's Budget, continuously and rewarding defrauders. I therefore propose to you a serious plan that increases the resources and staff of the Tax Agency, and reforms its methodology, organization, and distribution of work; pursues fraud with the same tenacity that defrauders scam; modifies the tax haven of the SiCAV; limits cash payments to one thousand euros; establishes a tax on financial transactions; imposes a tax on large fortunes; signs an agreement with tax havens, as Germany has done, and proposes, in the eurozone, to abolish five hundred euro bills. And when you announce cuts of ten billion, do it in Parliament.

President.- This is not a usual procedure, but as I have already told you, it is a procedure recommended by the OECD in complicated situations. It is a procedure that was already used in Spain in 1977, 1991, and 1994, and, as I pointed out earlier, it will be accompanied by a project to combat tax fraud that we will approve next Friday in the Council of Ministers, where a series of measures will be included. Now I can point out one, which is the limitation of the use of cash in certain operations: operations over 2,500 euros in which at least one professional businessman is involved cannot be paid in cash. Those who violate the previous prohibition will face fines of 25 percent of the value of the cash payment made, and, in addition, that responsibility will be...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. President of the Government, are you going to initiate dialogue on labor reform?

President.- To initiate, no; we are going to continue it, because we have been talking about labor reform for a long time.

In any case, I remind you that the labor reform was validated in this Chamber by the vote of 197 deputies, which I suppose has some value, and those deputies did so because they considered it essential to return to economic growth and employment.

The labor reform is in line with the legislation of other countries in the European Union and has very clear objectives; the most important is to promote economic growth and job creation. Based on those objectives, which are clear and non-negotiable, we are willing to debate, discuss, and dialogue with anyone, including, of course, your Parliamentary Group.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Two weeks ago millions of workers went on strike and demonstrated against a labor reform that your Government has approved, which, by the way, has so far received no response from you. They told you, Mr. President, that this was not just another labor reform, that it was a break from the basic social consensus that had allowed us to build our system of labor relations over thirty years.

Recently you approved the Budget, a Budget that deepens the recession, that deepens unemployment, and from which only the big tax defrauders benefit. You have convinced no one, and that is why, the day before yesterday, through a press release, you announced additional cuts of ten billion euros in health and education. Is it a whim? I don’t know. An improvisation? Neither. Perhaps, an improvised whim. What is certain is that it has grave social consequences and that you have done it without talking to the Autonomous Communities.

You have brought to this Chamber a Budget Stability Law that breaches, that breaks, the agreement that you and we had and that has taken the structural deficit from 0.4 percent to zero deficit.

But the Spanish economy is doing very poorly, Mr. President, and you just said it. I could tell you that hiding the Budgets has generated distrust, that the Budgets have generated distrust, that this false exercise of fiscal sovereignty has generated distrust, or that the fighting between your ministers and your spokespersons generates distrust; but I believe that my responsibility here today leads me to ask you to recover the structural consensuses, the political, social, and institutional consensus that are broken; to call the unions, who have asked you to do so, and the business leaders; to speak with the presidents of the Autonomous Communities and to call the political parties, starting with the Socialist Party, to discuss the economic situation.

I represent a party that has governed and will govern again, and you know, because I have told you, that there are red lines that we will not cross; but between the systematic no of your opposition and the absolute yes that they now intend, I believe there is space for dialogue, which we are willing to explore with the understanding that the defense of the social rights of Spaniards will never be abandoned. And we are willing to explore it because I understand that dialogue, agreement, strengthens our country, and strength and confidence, Mr. Rajoy, is what Spain needs at this moment.

President.- Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, not long ago in Spain you approved a labor reform and you did it without agreement. There was also a general strike and the unions said something similar to what they have said in recent days. Shortly thereafter, you also approved, by Royal Decree Law and without consensus with anyone, legislation on the reform of collective bargaining.

We presented 71 amendments to the labor reform. You did not accept any of them, and you did not accept any… I remind you of what you said at that time: "the labor reform is not going to be touched because it is already in Parliament, now what is going to be done is to develop it and work on it, but it is not going to be touched. The reform is approved and it is not going to be modified." You suffer from selective amnesia, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.

I am not going to do the same as you. I am willing to talk to you and to all the Groups in this Chamber, and we continue to talk with the trade union organizations if they want to contribute something that serves to improve the labor reform.

I have spoken with you whenever you wanted, and you know it. We have seen each other more than once since I became President of the Government, and I am willing to continue talking; but I would like you to approve the Budgetary Stability Law because we, at the time, approved the reform of the Constitution. Probably, not with your criteria, but with the criteria in favor of the Socialist Group and the previous President, who was the one who raised it to me.

It is very good to make proposals for consensuses, to reach agreements and understandings, but one thing is general statements and another is then, when it comes to talking with others, to reach agreements, because I have long asked you to proceed with the renewal of the different bodies that this Chamber has to renew, and you have delayed it and continue to delay it.

Therefore, stop preaching, start giving wheat, and I am willing to talk to you when you deem it appropriate and convenient.