Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

11 March 2014 · Parliamentary control session (sesión de control parlamentario)

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish Parliament on March 11, 2014, responding to questions on the Garoña nuclear plant's operating license and political corruption.
Main themes
Garoña nuclear power plant, nuclear energy policy, plant safety and technical assessment, Nuclear Safety Council authority, energy mix and sustainability, political corruption, parliamentary accountability, energy capacity and demand in Spain
Duration
~23 min
72nd percentile
Words
2,744
72nd percentile
Sentences
102
64th percentile
Readability
46
50th percentile
Grade
13.1
58th percentile
Syntax
3.16
68th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 48%48%
  • Social 28%28%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Economic 8%8%
  • Environmental 6%6%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

102 sentences in 45 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Aitor Esteban, of the Basque Parliamentary Group EAJ-PNV

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, good morning. I ask you about the oldest nuclear power plant in the European Union, a plant that was built to operate for twenty-five years and has been in operation for forty-two years, no less; a plant where you decreed the cessation of operations in July 2013 and now, surprisingly, in 2014 you issue a Royal Decree so that Nuclenor can again request to renew the license. All this knowing that, if it reopens, it will incur significant costs, because otherwise it would have to reduce the power it produces itself, since otherwise there would be significant costs, for example, in cooling towers, etc., and in safety. Knowing, as you do, that the energy production percentage from this plant is insignificant.

Much has already been obtained from the plant. In fact, the yield has been much greater than the planned yield. It is more than amortized. Therefore, reopening it is an unnecessary threat, considering that there are very significant population centers just a few kilometers away. It is a type of first-generation plant; it is somewhat like insisting, at a time when we are already in phase 6.0, on operating with a 1.0, when the vast majority, if not all, of these first-generation plants are already dismantled and out of operation.

That is why I ask you why you insist on going against the current of what the majority of political parties and many institutions think.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Esteban.

The Government is not insisting on anything nor has it made any decision at this time, and the decision about the future of Garoña must be technical and not political. What I can tell you at this moment is that for Garoña to resume operations, two things are required: first, that the owner of the plant, which, as you pointed out, is the company Nuclenor, requests from the Ministry of Industry, Tourism and Energy a new operating authorization before July 5; and, second, that in response to that request, the Nuclear Safety Council issues a favorable report on the renewal, establishing the safety conditions and any other conditions it deems appropriate and necessary.

Therefore, that is the Government's position. We are waiting for the technical reports; we believe that these should take precedence, that they should be decisive when making any type of decision, and, furthermore, I just want to say one thing: it is not true that everyone is against it. There are people who do not agree with the decision to reopen Garoña if it is done; but there are also many others who do: institutions, companies, municipalities, etc., etc.

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, of course it depends on whether Nuclenor decides; but because you have given them that possibility through the Royal Decree of February, which you could perfectly well have not given, because you had already decided on the logical cessation of operations in such an obsolete facility.

Look, the Minister of Industry pointed out that the installed capacity in Spain for electricity production is one hundred thousand megawatts and the peak demand is forty thousand. What that plant produces is four hundred, 1 percent of the current energy demand, 0.4 percent of the installed capacity. Eliminating this plant does not imply anything in terms of costs, and, of course, what we can never do is provide cheap energy — this is, I insist, a very small percentage — if it is at the cost of serious risks, using technology and plants...

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Esteban.

In reality, I remind you of what I said in my first statement: it is a technical decision and not a political one. Regarding the serious risks you refer to, and I do not doubt your knowledge in the matter, I believe that it should be the Nuclear Safety Council that informs us, those of us who have to make the decision and those who may oppose it, about what the circumstances are, what needs to be done, what measures need to be adopted for the future, and if there are risks, what they are. But, in any case, what I do want to tell you is that the Government's policy, the energy policy, is based on the existence of a diversified, balanced, and sustainable mix from an environmental and economic point of view, which includes all energy sources and available capacities.

Therefore, we will wait to see if there is a request from Nuclenor, we will see what the Nuclear Safety Council says, and from there we will make the decision, and everyone will be able to express their opinion with more knowledge of the facts.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Ms. Rosa Díez, of the Parliamentary Group Union, Progress and Democracy

Ms. Díez.- Good morning, Mr. President.

I acknowledge that you have advanced in your perception regarding political corruption and no longer deny that it is the greatest scourge of our democracy. The fact is that you constantly talk about democratic regeneration, although operational and useful measures, very few. That is why the perception of corruption continues to grow, for Spaniards, as one of the greatest concerns: we have gone from 12 percent who believed in 2012 that it was the greatest problem to 44 percent who think at this moment that corruption is the greatest problem we Spaniards have.

In addition to the growing concern, scandals are increasing. Just yesterday we saw how twelve people were arrested in Madrid precisely for fraud in the training of the Community of Madrid.

Mr. President, that is why I ask you: How do you evaluate the result of your policies?

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez.

I believe we can agree on some things that I think are essential: first, that corruption is unacceptable; that the concern of citizens is logical; that it generates a shadow of discredit on the institutions that is not good or, in other words, that it is very bad, and that we must act.

For my part, I want to convey to you that the Government has taken this matter seriously. In the Debate on the State of the Nation last year, in February 2013, I made a series of commitments. I stated that we were going to modify a good part of our regulations to be more effective and forceful regarding these cases of corruption. I must say that I have fulfilled this, because before the Debate on the State of the Nation this year, I sent to the Cortes Generales all the laws I had committed to in 2013, and I am also willing, I want to tell you, to consider all initiatives, yours and those of others.

In fact, there is a call that the Deputy Prime Minister has made to the spokespersons of the Parliamentary Groups who wish to attend that meeting, a meeting that will take place here, God willing, on March 19, to, together, be able to take initiatives that prevent undesirable events like those you refer to.

Ms. Díez.- Look, Mr. President, I believe it is time to move from words to actions. The only truly effective reform is the criminal liability of political parties, and it was due to an amendment from this Parliamentary Group, accepted at the last moment in a committee.

Mr. President, as you know very well, corruption is more than just taking money from citizens. Corruption is the politicization of justice or control bodies; corruption is not pursuing defrauders, and corruption is, in addition to everything, not providing resources to those who have to pursue those who defraud and those who are corrupt. All of that is also corruption. We must move from words to actions, but we must do so by changing laws, changing regulations.

You have submitted a reform of the Penal Code that does not contemplate, for example, that the illicit enrichment of elected officials is a crime or that it does not contemplate that the illegal financing of political parties is a crime. You have to do more than just speak. You must end the privileges; we must end the possibility, by reforming the LOREG, that individuals who are charged with political corruption crimes can appear on the lists, embarrassing citizens and poisoning democracy itself.

Mr. President, I believe that, in short, too much time has passed without us wanting to recognize in practice the damage that this entire attitude, this lack of reaction, does to democracy itself and to the institutions themselves. We must self-regulate, we must make laws to control ourselves, Mr. President; laws, not just declarations. When we do that, citizens will perceive that we are serious; citizens will perceive that we are aware of the damage done to democracy and will regain trust in democracy...

President.- Thank you very much, Ms. Díez.

Frankly, it is not fair to use the expression "we must move from words to actions." We have presented the reform of the Organic Law on the financing of political parties; we have presented a Transparency Law, which has been praised by the European Commission; we have reformed the Penal Code to combat tax fraud and Social Security fraud; we have recently presented, and they will be addressed in the meeting on March 19 that I referred to, the Organic Law on the control of the economic-financial activity of political parties and also the Organic Law regulating the exercise of high office, and we will soon present a package of criminal and procedural measures to incorporate as amendments to the Penal Code that is being debated in the Cortes and that we want to discuss with the Parliamentary Groups of this Chamber. The Transparency Council and the Transparency Portal will also soon be put into operation, and there will be regulatory development of the Law.

Recently, the European Commission released a report on the situation of corruption in various countries of the Union and pointed out the legislative advances that have occurred in Spain in recent times. It encouraged us to do other things, we will take that into account, and therefore it is our intention to do so. And we count on you and anyone who wants to loyally contribute their ideas so that this becomes history in Spain and we do not have to keep debating it...

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, do you think that the LOMCE will improve the quality of the Spanish educational system?

President.- That is the objective, and that is what I think; if not, we would not have logically presented the Bill. And we have proposed it because the results of our educational system, which undoubtedly has many positive aspects, can and must be better.

We want to improve things. It is solely and exclusively about that, and we want to do it because the dropout and failure rates are very high, higher than in the vast majority of countries in the European Union and the OECD, because the results of international tests are in a poor position, and because we have youth unemployment rates that are unacceptable and tell us that we must change something.

This is not a problem of money, as we all know, since spending per student in Spain is 15 percent higher than that of the OECD and the European Union; it is not a problem of teachers, and the problem is that we need to change some things in the model. That is why I am convinced that these changes will serve to improve the quality of education in our country.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Thank you, Mr. President.

You have made an Education Law against the opinion of the parents and mothers of students, against the opinion of students, of teachers, of a large number of Autonomous Communities, and of all the Groups in this Chamber, except yours.

It is a law that has no consensus, Mr. Rajoy, and I will explain why: because it is not a Law of Quality of Education, no, because it has nothing to do with the fact that the land allocated to public centers is given away to private centers with the quality of education; it has nothing to do with the quality of education that education loses the character of a public service that it has always had; it has nothing to do with the quality of education that centers that separate boys from girls can receive funding or that funding is extended from four to six years. That has nothing to do with the quality of education. That is why it has no consensus from anyone.

You know it is a law that has an expiration date, because the Groups in this Chamber have agreed to repeal it in the next Legislature, and for this reason you have initiated a senseless process of implementation, a process that has replaced "alone and against all" with "hurry, hurry, the opposition is coming."

You see, they want to start next year in first, third, and fifth grade of Primary; three years at once: first, third, and fifth. It makes no educational sense whatsoever. They want to start in Basic Vocational Training without having changed Compulsory Secondary Education and, worse still, we are in mid-March, Mr. Rajoy, and the curricula have not been approved by the Autonomous Communities and, therefore, there are no textbooks, no trained teachers, no suitable centers, no money. There is not a euro, Mr. Rajoy.

What is that, Mr. Rajoy? Educational quality? Let me tell you: it is a botch job. It is a botch job that only aims for one thing, which is for the Law to outlive them. Let me tell you: meet with the Autonomous Communities. Not with all of them, call yours, those governed by the Popular Party, and you will see what they tell you, and then stop this reckless calendar, Mr. Rajoy. Stop it, because in any case, you will achieve that we do not repeal it in the next Legislature.

You see, you could have used education to tackle the crisis. Instead, what you have done is take advantage of the crisis to attack education, public education, with the Wert Law, and now with this delirious process of applying that Law, that disastrous Law, to the entirety of Spanish education.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.

Your position on this matter has always been one of outright opposition to the Law. In fact, the only educational laws that have been applied in Spain have been yours because, when an educational law was approved by the Popular Party, you did what you are now announcing you would do in the event that you have the support of the people, which is to repeal it. It would seem that in Spain there cannot be any more current legislation on education than that which is made by the Socialist Party or that which you make.

But, in any case, what I would like to ask is why you oppose us trying to improve things. Because, look, are you in agreement with the school failure rate in Spain? With the dropout rate? With youth unemployment? With the regulations that exist regarding Vocational Training? I believe that many things can be done and that is why we have proposed a reform of the Law to improve this situation.

When you were in the Ministry, more than twenty years ago, the Spanish reality was one; but between twenty and twenty-five years have passed since you made those laws -- you specifically -- and I believe that settling into immobility twenty-five years later, after the changes that have occurred in the world, leads nowhere.

Therefore, I urge you to come out of immobility, because it is necessary to change things because the educational system can be improved, it can be done, and a lot. We have used the best international practices from specialized education organizations to create this regulatory framework of the Law. There is much talk of ideology but, honestly, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba, the only ideology is to ignore the bad data and the recommendations of experts. That is why I tell you: this Law will serve to improve the quality of…