Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

18 March 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions on Catalan self-determination and Spain's role in European gas supply during a congressional control session on 18 March 2014.
Main themes
Catalan self-determination, rule of law and constitutionalism, Spanish national unity, Midcat gas interconnection, European energy security, Ukraine crisis and gas supply, Spain's role in European energy infrastructure, democracy and legal compliance
Duration
~18 min
61st percentile
Words
2,173
61st percentile
Sentences
97
61st percentile
Readability
57
80th percentile
Grade
10.3
24th percentile
Syntax
2.94
39th percentile
Vocabulary
2.08
23rd percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 33%29%
  • Ceremonial 26%23%
  • Institutional 22%20%
  • Geopolitical 18%15%
  • Social 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 12%

97 sentences in 32 paragraphs

Mr. Rajoy, a famous quote: "The vote is the best thing we have to decide our collective future." Does that phrase sound familiar to you? A great statesman. It was said by Mariano Rajoy Brey. Yes, Mr. Rajoy, you have your inspired days. So take advantage of them. You will tell me that it is the content, that the content is problematic. Listen, Official State Bulletin - here it is --: "All peoples have the right to self-determination. By virtue of that right, they freely determine their political status." BOE 103, constitutional period. Signed: King of Spain.

Mr. Rajoy, comply with the BOE; Mr. Rajoy, comply with the Law; Mr. Rajoy, comply with your word. Turn the traffic light of democracy green. Green, how I want you green.

President.- You intend to place yourself above the Constitution and the Law. That is indeed a red traffic light, and that is what is not democratic. What you are saying is that constitutionalism is incompatible with democracy, when the truth is just the opposite. Constitutionalism enables a democratic political system by creating an appropriate political framework in which people can make political decisions. You should know: without law, there is no democracy. If you do not like the Law, propose that it be changed. You can do that. I will only tell you that you can think as you wish, so can I, but we are all obliged to comply with the Law, and I, for my part, will certainly do so.

And having said that, which is the most important thing, I will give you my opinion. I want us all to continue being part of the same nation as we have been for centuries, during which, as I pointed out in the debate that took place here not long ago, the Debate on the State of the Nation, we have shared the same history, the same fortunes, calamities, mixed our blood and crossed our families. I believe that what we did was and is worth it for centuries.

In recent times, and in the last few years, we have all together made the transition to democracy; we have approved a Constitution, the one of our rights and our freedoms; we have established a regime of self-government for the different nationalities and regions of Spain that has no parallel in our history; we have entered the European Union; we have adopted the euro… I believe we have done well. We have a tradition, a memory, and a common heritage that I believe we must preserve.

Moreover, I do not want a impoverished Catalonia, which is where what some intend would lead us, nor do I want a Catalonia outside the European Union, the euro, the UN, or the Treaties. I believe that no one deserves that, and not even you, Mr. Bosch, deserve it.

Thank you very much.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Antoni Duran i Lleida, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

Mr. Duran.- Mr. President of the Government, yesterday we had the visit of a parliamentary delegation from Hungary's Foreign Affairs. In the context of that visit, one of my colleagues made an observation -- we were talking about the crisis in Ukraine -- about what would happen when winter arrived regarding energy supply, and the response given was: we are not worried about winter, we are worried about tomorrow, because we need gas, energy for the functioning of our industries, etc., etc. It is, therefore, logical that you, as President of the Government, take into account that the current and future situation in Ukraine will entail serious difficulties in central Europe, even in a neighboring country like France, which sources a third of its gas from Russia.

In light of this situation, does the Government plan to recover and, therefore, relaunch and prioritize the gas infrastructure known as Midcat?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Duran. I agree with what you have said, and rest assured that we will continue to promote the gas connection with Europe through the Midcat interconnection.

Europe has a high dependence on gas supplies, and today, for the reasons you have mentioned, it is more evident than ever and has become very noticeable to the general public.

Therefore, the interconnection between Spain and France is very important and is a priority for this Government, and it is also for the entire European Union: first, because our country is the natural entry point for gas from North Africa; second, because we have a high regasification capacity for liquefied natural gas that can arrive by ship to our country, and, in addition, we have a large storage capacity and excellent transport networks.

In summary, we have a high surplus capacity of gas from which Hungary and many other countries in the European Union could benefit, and therefore, we will continue to promote that connection, and it will be a priority for the Government I lead.

Mr. Duran.- Thank you, Mr. President. I appreciate the agreement and, therefore, the positive response to my request, which, I reiterate, I believe gives Spain a strategic value in relation to Europe that, if I may say so, must be capitalized on, both in political terms and in economic terms, and that, even in the medium term, could be favorable to the consumers' energy bills.

For a long time in this country, the energy authorities have criticized the excessive weight, the excessive number, of gas infrastructures. Well, now, as you recalled, those infrastructures give Spain extraordinary strategic value, and you must leverage it, especially considering that the European Commission, when it selects 250 projects of strategic connection interest, places this one precisely as a project of interest and, moreover, offers a sum of money that can be accessed, a subsidy of 5.8 billion euros in the financial period 2014-2020.

Therefore, Mr. President, this is tremendously important. In my opinion, we have not been able to respond adequately in Ukraine as Westerners. I believe we have also demonstrated, once again, that Europe lacks a foreign policy; but be capable, as President of this Government, of positioning yourself strategically in the heart of Europe and mitigating the effects that, without a doubt, will have not only for central Europe but also for neighboring countries like France.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Duran. Indeed, if that interconnection existed today, we could supply Europe with half of the gas that comes from Russia through Ukraine.

This is a topic that, as you know, is not new, although the events in Ukraine, as I pointed out earlier, have brought it back to the forefront. It has been raised on numerous occasions, and I can say that I did so at the European Council in May of last year, 2013, dedicated specifically to energy; I did it at the Hispano-French Summit in November of that same year, 2013, and at the Council dedicated to Ukraine a few days ago. In fact, as you pointed out, the European Union on April 16, 2013, included this interconnection in the list of European projects of common interest, which have the possibility of obtaining European funds and other facilities.

On March 11, that is, a few days ago, I sent a letter to Mr. Van Rompuy and announced that at the European Council that begins tomorrow, I will advocate for the interconnection to become a true binding objective of European energy policy and that measures be put in place so that no member state has an interconnection lower than 10 percent of its installed capacity. I hope this is well received for the reasons you have mentioned, although it is an act of justice, I hope our French neighbors understand it that way too, and I hope that if we really want to build a single internal market, we take a decisive step. Therefore, I agree with what you propose.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Alfredo Pérez Rubalcaba, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, do you consider that your decision to raise the cultural VAT was a good one?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. To judge the goodness or not of a decision, it is not enough to look only at its content, but one must also consider the context in which it is made. I do not like raising taxes, neither on culture nor on other products or services, nor on individuals; but this decision was made at a time, which was July 2012, when Spain was on the verge of entering a rescue situation. That decision was preceded by a rise in the Income Tax for all Spaniards and was accompanied by spending cuts and an increase in VAT on many other products.

If we had not done that, probably the VAT, the IRPF, and the Budget would have been imposed on us by others who could have imposed a VAT of 23 percent, as happened in some other countries in the European Union, or simply a 10 percent cut in pensions, as happened elsewhere. It was a very tough moment; we had to choose, we tried to be equitable in the distribution, and all of this happened because we had a public deficit above 9 percent, we had lost seventy billion euros in revenue in two years, and that is precisely one of the reasons we are working. Fortunately, things are getting better; but it takes time to recover those seventy billion euros lost.

Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba.- Mr. Rajoy, we told you in August 2012 that the thirteen-point increase in the cultural VAT was going to have a devastating effect. Your measure emptied cinemas and theaters; it has driven away audiences from concerts and shows; many companies have closed, and four out of ten workers in the cultural sector have lost their jobs. It has been, therefore, a disaster; a cultural disaster, of course, a human disaster, and an economic disaster as well. You have made a mess, Mr. Rajoy.

The latest data on live music that we have -- live music is the cultural activity preferred by young people -- from the Association of Cultural Promoters, tells us that their revenue has fallen by 28 percent and that the State has stopped collecting thirty million euros. A mess.

Was it a blunder? I think not, Mr. Rajoy. I think you had it in for the cultural sector, a lot of desire. It has been a punishment, Mr. Rajoy. You have had a relationship with it that is documented in the archives.

Now you are going to make a tax reform. There has been a report from the experts that is true did not recommend lowering the VAT, it recommended raising the VAT; but we already know from the pension reform how this works with experts. The experts propose all the bad things, you take away some. Let me explain. The experts propose eliminating deductions for housing, the Government immediately says: "no, no, the deductions for housing are not." There we have it. Long live the Government! This is the story.

Therefore, although the experts have not proposed any reduction in VAT, I propose that you lower the cultural VAT. There will be more revenue, there will be more jobs, more people will go to cinemas and theaters, and young people will return to concerts. Lower the cultural VAT, Mr. Rajoy. Rectify your blunder because, believe me, it is a blunder to think that culture is a luxury item in Spain.

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba. You have not responded to the arguments I have used. I do not like… I want to remind you that I do not like raising VAT on culture, and therefore I cannot accept the argument you have used. The increase did not occur only in relation to culture, but it also occurred with many other products and services, as you know, and therefore the same reasoning you have used here today could be applied.

Not all cultural services are taxed at 21 percent. The reduced rate of 10 percent applies, for example, to libraries, archives, documentation centers, and many other products. The super-reduced rate of 4 percent applies to books, newspapers, and magazines; books account for more than 50 percent of cultural activity, 5.4 billion euros in revenue. The vast majority of educational services and cultural services provided by public law entities and by private social entities are exempt.

We are now trying to improve budgets when things are already getting a bit better: this year's increase in allocations for theater is 57.4 percent; the increase for music and dance is 22.1 percent; we have modified the VAT for the first sale of works of art; we are discussing how to resolve the problems of the Film Fund, and we will make some decisions in the tax reform; but I remind you that all of this, without your disastrous economic policy, would not…