Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 April 2014 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to opposition questions during a parliamentary control session in Spain's Congress on April 21, 2014, defending his government's economic record.
Main themes
Economic recovery, unemployment, inequality and poverty, government optimism vs. public pessimism, austerity measures, deficit reduction, electoral politics, child poverty, Spain's fiscal crisis, government accountability, European Parliament elections
Duration
~48 min
94th percentile
Words
5,792
94th percentile
Sentences
223
91st percentile
Readability
52
69th percentile
Grade
12.0
45th percentile
Syntax
3.18
70th percentile
Vocabulary
2.11
29th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 32%30%
  • Economic 30%28%
  • Social 20%18%
  • Ceremonial 14%13%
  • Geopolitical 4%4%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 8%

223 sentences in 81 paragraphs

Mr. President, I would like to be more optimistic than your Vice President and your economic ministers; but you know very well that unfortunately they were quite right, that this is going to be a lost legislature, a legislature that will end with three points more unemployment than the one left by Mr. Rodríguez Zapatero and with very little growth.

However, a few months ago you changed your tune. Someone must have reminded you that we were entering an electoral cycle, that the elections to the European Parliament were coming, and that a discourse as negative as the one you had was not a good calling card to ask for the support of the citizens. That discourse was, in the end, the recognition of a failed legislature and, for that reason, you immediately changed your explanations and decided that the crisis was over.

The miracle was not that the crisis had only ended in Spain, but that the government's adjustment policies had also stabilized the risk premium in all the southern European countries. Of course, I am not going to talk about Mr. Draghi, nor about the flexibility of the deficit, because you were very upset the other day; but, for the moment, whatever you say, Mr. President, and say it by land, by sea, and by air, the citizens are not receiving anything. And that is why I ask you the question that refers to the contrast between the triumphalism of the Government and the pessimism of the citizens.

But allow me to also ask you whether you believe that Mr. Arias Cañete should clarify the relationship of his companies with the Administration.

President.- Thank you very much for your words, Mr. Iglesias.

I am not going to position myself as a spokesperson for anyone, because it makes no sense; but I will tell you that I believe there are many Spaniards who think the following: first, that things, from an economic point of view, are not well yet; second, that they are better than before; and third, that they will be better in the future. That is what I think too, and therefore I see no reason for you to speak of the enormous contrast that exists between what the Government says and what many people think.

I will try to explain it to you with the brevity that an event of this nature requires.

Two years ago we were on the verge of being rescued, Spain was a country that was about to go bankrupt. We had to face, in 2012, a financial crisis and a sovereign debt crisis. We were in negative growth, in recession. Unemployment was rising more and more, and the number of affiliates to Social Security was decreasing. We had to reduce the deficit and take many measures.

Now things are moving after the measures we adopted, and 2013 was already a better year than 2012, and 2014 is going to be much better. Specifically, in 2012, growth was negative, -1.6 percent; in 2013, -1.2 percent, and this year we are going to have positive growth and net job creation.

Our forecasts have been adjusted. We said that in 2013 we would have -1.3 percent, and in the end, we had -1.2 percent. This year we initially talked about +0.7 percent, and I already announced in the State of the Nation Debate that growth would be 1 percent, and it could be greater than 1 percent throughout 2014. That is to say, we did not do like others who ended up being wrong by ten points in the public deficit or three points in growth in one year.

In any case, believing that things are getting better, and it is not bad to acknowledge it because it is pure common sense, we still have many things to do, and while there are more than five and a half million unemployed, I cannot be satisfied. But I am starting to be happy because I see that many of the measures that the Government has adopted are producing effects, and this year we are going to grow, and for the first time in many years, we are going to create, we are already creating, stable employment in our country.

Mr. Iglesias.- Mr. President, Minister Cañete is not an ectoplasm; he is a candidate from your party. I would like to know your opinion.

Whatever you say, Mr. President, citizens do not perceive the exit from the crisis that you proclaim. It is evident that one day or another we will get out of this crisis, and I am even willing to accept that we are starting to come out already. Of course, all of us in my Group want it to be as soon as possible, but what people want to know is when it will affect them.

We know that the crisis has made us all a little poorer, but it should not make us more unequal. What no one accepts is that we have to come out of the crisis more unequal, and you say nothing about that. When institutions like Cáritas or NGOs dedicated to child protection tell us that 30 percent of our children are below the poverty line, Mr. Montoro says that these data do not correspond to reality, that they are mere statistics. For these gentlemen, there are no other statistics than those that agree with them.

Spaniards are not entrenched in pessimism out of perversity or to rain on your parade. Pessimism is due to young people being unable to start an independent life because they have no job; the pessimism of women who are being forced to have children that God gives them, even if they have serious malformations or if they cannot support them; the pessimism of people who see that their situation is not recognized, that of dependents; the pessimism of citizens who see their rights and freedoms increasingly questioned… Pessimism, ultimately, of seeing that despite all the cuts, despite all the sacrifices, despite all the suffering, the economy, whatever you say, remains stagnant, and work is very scarce and increasingly of worse quality.

Mr. President, what is increasing in our country is the debt. Do you remember that saying about not spending what you do not have? Well, we are already reaching 100 percent of debt over GDP. Really a success; you have set a record.

But, Mr. President, allow me to insist on the question with which I began this intervention. I believe that you, as the President of the Government, have the obligation to tell us whether or not you are in favor of Minister Arias Cañete clarifying his assets and clearly telling us what the relationship of his companies, which are dedicated to distributing fuel, is with the concessions that the Administration makes in these areas.

President.- In your day, you denied the crisis, and now you deny the beginning of the recovery; that is, you deny reality. That, when you are in opposition, does not matter much; now, when you are in Government, it is a problem because by denying the crisis you did nothing, and that caused the crisis to be even greater and more costly to overcome. I will explain to you with crystal clarity what my position is.

We, as I told you in my first response, had to avoid a rescue; we had to overcome a financial crisis and another of sovereign debt; we have made an effort, and all Spaniards, to reduce the public deficit that we inherited from you; we have made the structural reforms that you did not make; we have restructured the financial system, and all of that led to us being able to reduce the imbalances in the economy, without which it is metaphysically impossible to generate economic growth and create jobs.

Something is visible, Mr. Iglesias. You see nothing. For you, everything is very bad. You did not even see in the last four years of your party's government that 3,400,000 people lost their jobs in Spain and that the State stopped collecting seventy billion euros as a consequence of your Government's management. And it was not bad intention on your Government's part; it was pure incompetence.

But, look, there are some things, Mr. Iglesias, that are positive and that people see: record figures in exports; record figures in tourism; a surplus in the external sector for the first time in many years; inflation at -0.08 percent, and this affects people's purchasing power, and the risk premium at 155 basis points. Today we can already finance ourselves for ten years at 3 percent, something we could not do for the last ten years. Credit is starting to flow; car sales are increasing; industrial production is also increasing, foreign investment, and we are overcoming macroeconomic imbalances. Growth this year is going to be positive, and regarding employment in February, for the first time in 68 months, there were more affiliates to Social Security year-on-year than before.

Recently, the European Commission just published a figure that you cannot deny — it is from the European Commission —: Spain was the country in Europe where the most jobs were created in the last year, and there are the figures from Eurostat. For four years we were the country in Europe that destroyed the most jobs when you were in power. And, finally, in March, eighty thousand more people joined Social Security.

You may find all of this very bad; you may not recognize it; but I recommend that in life you never deny reality, because by denying reality, by saying that at the time there was no crisis in Spain and by doing nothing, you brought this country to the brink of bankruptcy, which is your great responsibility, and now what we are doing is trying to overcome this situation.

Mr. Iglesias, any indicator we use, any — the 80-20 Inequality measure, the Gini Index, or the AROPE rate, which measures the risk of poverty and social exclusion — tells us the same thing: between 2008 and 2011, the social situation in Spain deteriorated at a much faster rate than in the rest of the countries of the European Union.

And I will tell you the latest reports that the European Commission has given on the issues you have raised here, because I believe it is good for you to also know these reports.

In the review of compliance with the poverty reduction target of the European 2020 Strategy, the structural reforms carried out by Spain to combat poverty and social exclusion were rated very positively. Likewise, the European Commission, in its Recommendation regarding Spain's 2013 National Reform Program, states: "progress has been made regarding measures to combat child poverty and to improve the efficiency of support services for families."

That is to say, Europe, to which we have already returned, and believe me it was very difficult, because you do not know what was said at the end of 2011 about us, recognizes a reality that is that things are being done well and progress is being made. Just as it recognized the brilliant management of a minister who managed to overcome the chaos that had been generated in the Ministry of Agriculture, where he was unable to obtain the necessary funds for Spanish agriculture. The best allocation of funds in the shortest budget of the Union.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Josep Lluis Cleries, of the Catalan Parliamentary Group of Convergència i Unió

Mr. Cleries.- Mr. President of the Government, on April 8, in the Congress of Deputies, the only thing you offered to Catalonia was a declaration of love. You said that you love Catalonia. The truth is, we had not noticed that we were so loved. To love is to know how to put oneself in the place of the other, to understand them, to feel affection and empathy; it is to respect and accept the other as they are.

We can see examples of that affection you speak of. Is the LOMCE love for Catalonia, or is it rather an attack on linguistic immersion, an attack on our Catalan language? Is love for Catalonia the deficit target set? The crisis, Mr. President, demands austerity; we agree; but it would be good if we all were solidary with austerity.

Between 2011 and 2013, the Autonomous Communities reduced their deficit by 55 percent; the Central Administration only reduced it by 16 percent. It is an understanding, we believe, that is not very equitable. Concentrating austerity only on the Autonomous Communities puts the Welfare State at risk, education, health, active employment policies, dependency policies, and social assistance. It puts the attention to people at risk. Moreover, the deficit generated by the Central Administration and Social Security was higher in 2013 than in 2012. This is little loyalty, we believe.

Is the process of recentralization of the State love? Every week the Council of Ministers means a setback in the self-government of Catalonia.

Another example. While the officials of the Generalitat of Catalonia have not been able to recover the pay that was suppressed in 2012 for reasons of austerity, the Government announced the call for 950 State official positions for 2014. The same Government that prevents the coverage of vacancies for doctors, teachers, and social workers is the one that says it will create 950 State official positions to carry out its ideological project of recentralization. More Central Administration and less attention to people.

You use the scarce resources for recentralization. We, Mr. Rajoy, want them for health, we want them for education, and we want them for social services.

Your priority, Mr. Rajoy, is recentralization; our priority and commitment is to serve people better. While you recentralize, the IMF notes that in Spain social inequality is growing the most; a social gap is opening, says the IMF. According to Cáritas, as has been said before, Spain is the second country in the European Union with the highest child poverty. Cáritas says it, and we believe it.

Despite the difficulties, the Generalitat is promoting employment, economic growth, maintaining social policies, and encouraging foreign investments. And all this despite the constant threats, especially from your Minister of Foreign Affairs, which aim to discourage investors, entrepreneurs, and the citizens of Catalonia.

Conclusion: many words of love, but the State looks little towards Catalonia. It prefers to talk about love while turning its back on us. They do not count on our values, our projects, our priorities, or our capacity for governance. Does the President believe that the perception in Catalonia at this moment is one of affection, precisely?

President.- Undoubtedly, yours is a very constructive intervention, one of those meant to create, to understand each other, or to foster a good relationship. Everything is wrong, everything is a disaster, the Government does nothing right, and you do everything right. That is the message you have conveyed here, to this Chamber.

I want to tell you with absolute frankness that all the decisions we are making in all areas aim to improve the well-being and wealth of all Spaniards, whether they live in Catalonia or anywhere else in Spain, and they have been many and very difficult, and you know that. We have also tried to help the Autonomous Communities with the FLA, so that the Generalitat could pay its debt maturities, so that it could pay its suppliers, and so that it could cover its deficit, and we do this gladly because we believe it is our obligation.

Now, I am going to tell you something with absolute clarity, Mr. Cleries. Affection does not cloud my conscience nor does it prevent me from seeing things with realism and responsibility, and for me, affection helps me fulfill my obligations as a ruler, to always seek the general interest, and not to play with the feelings of others.

Perhaps you see this affection as a reason for mockery; I do not. I see it as a reason for respect, which I have for you, and I hope you have it for me as well.

Mr. Cleries.- Mr. Rajoy, I always speak with all due respect.

Aside from the credit from the FLA and the Supplier Plan, it seems you cannot tell us many things. You always tell me the same thing. As I have said, from Catalonia, our first commitment is to the people, to the Welfare State.

A few days ago, you said that the Catalan people and the rest of the Spaniards are mixed, that they have the same blood. Of course! What a discovery! Look, Mr. Rajoy, those who talk about blood, borders, and division are you, because in Catalonia we have always been one people and we have always opted for integration and cohesion. Your statements show a lack of understanding of reality.

Look, tomorrow is the feast of Sant Jordi, a celebration of civility and culture, as expressed by the exchange of roses and books. It is a demonstration of what you were saying, of respect for people, for all people, for all languages, and for all cultures.

Fifty years ago, Paco Candel, who was a senator in this Chamber during the constituent legislature, published the book "Los Otros Catalanes" in which he explained the experience of thousands of people from across the Spanish State who made Catalonia their new land, while remaining faithful, as it should be, to their roots. You will never find anywhere in Candel's book talk of blood or disintegration, but rather of integration and cohesion.

This Catalonia, the one Candel explained and built with thousands of people, all of us who have made this land our land, as a plural land of diversity and a land of welcome, the one that speaks Catalan and the one that speaks Spanish… 80 percent of these people from real Catalonia want to vote to defend the future. If you love Catalonia, dare to listen to what we Catalans think in a free, legal, and democratic consultation.

Mr. Rajoy, with this spirit of Sant Jordi, of coexistence, of exchange, and of civic expression, I am now going to give you, and thus see all my respect towards you, a copy of the 1976 edition of "Los Otros Catalanes" written by Paco Candel, so that you can get to know firsthand this spirit of this Catalonia that has always opted to understand, to respect, and to love people, all people, and to respect all peoples.

I wish you all a good Sant Jordi day.

President.- Mr. Cleries, I participated in the debate you referred to because I believed it was an important issue and because I thought it was my duty to do so as President of the Government of Spain. Others, who were the ones who promoted it, did not consider it appropriate or convenient to come here to explain and dialogue about things. They will know why.

Mr. Cleries, I defended there something that I have the obligation to defend, because I am the President of the Government, and you too, because you are a senator, which is legality. I defended that the transfer of the competence could not be made and I defended that the entire Spanish people could not be deprived of the right to decide what they want their country to be. I did it because it is my obligation and it is also yours, Mr. Cleries, and this position that I defended there had one vote, which was mine, because I only have one vote, but it had the vote of the vast majority of the members of Congress who represent the entirety of national sovereignty and who have the capacity to decide on this matter.

I did not stop there in my intervention, Mr. Cleries, and I explained how some distorted the words. Right to decide, yes, but who decides who are the ones who have to decide? Why do you not want many Spaniards to decide what their country should be? Right to vote, yes, but the right to vote must be exercised only in accordance with what the current legislation says.

I also explained something that I had the obligation, as President of the Government, to explain to all citizens: the consequences of secession. I have the obligation to explain it: impoverishment for Catalonia, exit from the European Union, exit from the euro, exit from the European Central Bank, from the Treaties, effects on trade… Isolation in a world that is increasingly integrating, Mr. Cleries; the path in the opposite direction to that which the whole world is taking.

And I explained my personal situation and I will explain it to you again here. I am in favor of being together and I spoke of centuries living together, of the oldest nation in Europe, which is ours, of the ties of all kinds that unite us, of our common history, of the personal relationships and all kinds that exist among all, among the Spaniards from the rest of Spain who went to Catalonia, among many Galicians, from my town, as many Catalans went to many other places… Of everything that unites us and what has united us in these thirty years, where Spain has been one of the countries that has grown the most in the world, with a democratic Constitution that is the guarantee of our rights and freedoms, with a Constitution that has allowed us to integrate into Europe and with the greatest self-government in history; Mr. Cleries, the greatest. Tell me a single year in the History of Spain where there has been greater self-government than there is today.

How can you come to talk to me here about the withdrawal of competences when we are talking about renouncing the currency, renouncing monetary policy, renouncing exchange policy, and that the figures for deficit and debt are set by the European Union? Do you not realize where the world is heading?

You talk about feelings. I agree to respect your feelings. That is as far as we could go! Who do you think I am? I only ask you one thing: to respect the feelings of other people who may have feelings different from yours, which also exist. Yes, yes, this is very important.

You tell me: you do not put yourself in the other’s place. Well, put yourself in the other’s place too. I try to put myself in your place, believe me I try, and believe me I am in favor of dialogue; but it is very difficult to dialogue when one learns through the media that a press conference is being held at the Generalitat of Catalonia, where the CUP, the former communists, Esquerra Republicana, and you decide to unilaterally call a referendum, set the date and the questions, and do not even bother to communicate it to the Government of Spain, nor to the General Courts, who should have a say in this matter.

Of course we want to dialogue, but do not forget one thing, that neither the Constitutional Court nor the Spanish General Courts admit that referendum because they say it is illegal and, therefore, it is up to you to say now what you want us to do. Do you ask the President of the Government to bypass the will of the General Courts, the national sovereignty, and the rulings of the Constitutional Court? I cannot do that. Therefore, imagination, Mr. Cleries.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Jokin Bildarratz, from the Basque Parliamentary Group EAJ-PNV

Mr. Bildarratz.- Mr. President of the Government, I do not know if you have had the opportunity to see the film "Ocho Apellidos Vascos," by Emilio Martínez Lázaro. As you can see, it is a magnificent comedy starring, among others, Dani Rovira and Clara Lago in the role of Rafa, a Sevillian, and Amaya, a Basque.

The main plot revolves around Rafa's infatuation with Amaya. Rafa travels to Euskadi mainly because he wants to win Amaya over and, in wanting to win her over, he evidently also acquires the will to share certain codes with her. That is to say, we can see a very significant image, a scene, in which Rafa's character is learning Basque. He is seen reading a book titled: "Kaixo, Basque without fear."

What is the conclusion? What is the meaning? What is it that I want to convey to you? If you want to be liked, if you want to coexist with another person, with another group, you must attract them, and to do so, make gestures that positively enhance that relationship. But we must also be aware that today in the Spanish State, wherever there is an area with its own language, there are only problems, such as in Catalonia, Valencia, the Balearic Islands, or Euskadi.

You know that coexistence is not created by magic; coexistence is built, it is worked on, day by day, not by hitting day by day. I bring this up because you know that the Spanish Government delegate in Euskadi has presented more than five hundred appeals against Basque institutions in the short two years he has held his current responsibility.

Law 6/97, of April 14, on the Organization and Functioning of the General Administration of the State, which defines the competencies, objectives, and functioning of the Government delegates, states, among other things, that the function of the Government delegate is the cooperation and coordination of the General Administration of the State with those of the Autonomous Community and with the corresponding local entities. That is to say, do you find more than five hundred appeals normal, Mr. President, to fulfill those functions of cooperation and coordination, among others, with the Local Administrations? Practically all those actions are against Town Halls. Do you know how many times the Government delegate has met with the Association of Basque Municipalities to resolve this problem? Do you know how many? Zero, zero.

That is to say, this number of appeals that are mainly, or largely, related to the use of Basque, more than forty, is a big problem. It is a big problem that we have to solve because at this moment there is a knowledge of Basque in the Basque Country of about 30 percent, and, evidently, the use is lower because if in a group of ten people only three know Basque, evidently, if they want to understand each other, they will understand in which language they have to speak.

The normalization of Basque, coexistence, will not be achieved by taking Town Halls to court because, in addition, a very curious thing happens here: there are a significant number of non-compliances by the different Administrations regarding Basque and Mr. Urquijo does not act in any way, so the question is the following: When will the Government delegate, in addition to being a defender of Spanish, become a defender of Basque?

President.- Thank you very much, Mr. Bildarratz.

What the Government delegate must fundamentally be a defender of is legality, Mr. Bildarratz, and I am going to tell you something that you know as well as I do: the Law is the expression of the popular will. The Law is a set of rules of the game that binds us all, and the Law is that coexistence you spoke of. Coexistence is maintained, among other reasons, thanks to the Law, and for there to be good coexistence, it is essential that there is regulation, which is approved by the majority of citizens. And the Government delegate has, among other functions, the duty to ensure that the Law is complied with.

You have cited the LOFAGE, and I will cite the Statute of Autonomy of the Basque Country: "The common institutions --Article 6-- of the Autonomous Community, taking into account the sociolinguistic diversity of the Basque Country, will guarantee the use of both languages by regulating their official status and will arbitrate and regulate the necessary measures and means to ensure their knowledge." And in its section 3 it states: "No one may be discriminated against on the grounds of language." I subscribe to this: no one may be discriminated against on the grounds of language; neither Euskera nor Spanish, which is what, in the opinion of the Government delegate, and the judges will decide, some Town Halls have done.

Article 5 of the Basic Law on the Normalization of the Use of Euskera, in its section 2, recognizes the following rights for the citizens of the Basque Country and calls them fundamental linguistic rights: the right to communicate, in Euskera or in Spanish, orally and/or in writing with the Administration and with any organization or entity based in the Autonomous Community." This is being violated by the decisions of some Town Halls, and that is what the Government delegate is trying to prevent. There is nothing more to it.

The Government delegate defends legality, because that is his duty, and you should not see any attacks or aggressions or any other type of disrespect towards the laws or towards Euskera, but rather what there is, is a defense of the rights that citizens have recognized by the laws and that, when they are harmed, someone has to help them, someone has to protect them, and someone has to ensure that those rights are respected.

Therefore, do not see what is not there in the actions of the Government delegate. I suppose that soon there will be a decision from the courts of justice, and we will all have to abide by that decision from the courts of justice, the Town Halls, the Government Delegation, you and I, whether we like it or not, because that is the law and that is the greatness of democracy.

Mr. Bildarratz.- Do you know what Mr. Urquijo is trying to achieve? That the Town Halls that are going to manage their services indirectly, for example, sports centers, areas of social services, etc., cannot use the criterion of language as a positive criterion towards it and towards providing a service to citizens. Why can’t my mother receive home help from an indirect management in Euskera? Why not? What prevents Mr. Urquijo from doing so? Because that is the problem we are facing; that is precisely the problem. Or why can’t a Town Hall carry out indirect management for a sports center and manage it through Euskera? Because that is what Mr. Urquijo is preventing.

And, since you tell me that the law is coexistence, I totally agree, because we only have to look at Article 3 of the Spanish Constitution and what the Constitutional Court also says: "the co-officiality of the other Spanish languages applies to all public authorities based in the autonomous territory, without excluding the bodies dependent on the Central Administration and other state institutions in the strict sense." Is that being fulfilled? But if Mr. Urquijo does not comply with it, not even on his own website. Mr. Urquijo does not comply. Or is the Spanish State complying with the European Charter for Regional or Minority Languages when the Council of Europe is repeatedly reprimanding the Spanish State for not complying with the Charter signed by the Spanish State? Is that compliance?

I am glad that you have also cited the Basic Law on the Use and Normalization of Euskera, because it is precisely that 30 percent who know Euskera can develop their lives in the language they need or wish, and that is what cannot be. Or what do you say about the Law on Public Radio and Television in Spain? Is the law being complied with regarding languages?

Look, if there is truly a positive attitude towards Euskera and if there is a positive attitude to resolve this issue, we are not going to do it in courts because they will give the reason to some or the other; but we are not going to resolve it because, evidently, there will be different readings, there will be different visions, but what is clear... In the end, what it is about is that always a bad agreement will be better than not, in the end, someone giving the reason to one or the other because it will probably not please anyone, because the expectations will be different, both from one side and the other.

To conclude, what I also want to say is that in a modern civilized country, the responsibility of being bilingual is not the citizen's, it is the State's, and what happens in the Spanish State is that it is a monolingual state and it shifts its responsibility of being bilingual onto the citizen.

President.- Mr. Bildarratz, I want both languages to be treated equally, that no one is discriminated against on the grounds of the language they speak, that any person can go to the contracts of the Town Halls, regardless of the language they speak, and that everyone is on equal terms.

Plain and simple, that is what I want, and that is also what the Government delegate wants, and among his obligations, as I told you before, he has one that is to defend legality. That is his most important obligation, and the Government delegate, nor the Government of Spain, does not question Euskera as the own language of the Basque Country, nor does it question that all citizens who deem it appropriate and convenient use it, that public authorities use it, nor does it ask that it be forgotten in education; but it asks exactly the same for Spanish.

I believe that this is a sensible, reasonable, and balanced position, and the Government delegate understands that some actions of Town Halls that he has challenged are violating these principles to which I am referring and is, with this, defending the rights of many people who apply for contracts and who are clearly harmed by the bases that are being established.

I will tell you one thing, because I think so: I believe that you are a sensible person, I believe it; I believe that you know perfectly well what is happening; you know that there are Town Halls that are violating the law; you know that there are some Town Halls that have changed that regulation because they have become aware that they are violating the law; you know that the European Commission is behind this issue and can open an information file on our country, and you know that there are many issues - unfortunately, I agree with you on this - that are pending before the courts. But it is not advisable to let oneself be manipulated by extremists, because no one can win against extremists, especially if they are not. Believe me, it is so.