Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

14 April 2015 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions on healthcare access and the Marches for Dignity during a Spanish Congress control session on 14 April 2015.
Main themes
Public healthcare policy, universal health coverage, poverty and social exclusion, unemployment, housing and evictions, Marches for Dignity, economic recovery, pharmaceutical spending, health tourism, labor reform, minimum wage, constitutional reform
Duration
~19 min
64th percentile
Words
2,304
64th percentile
Sentences
82
53rd percentile
Readability
56
78th percentile
Grade
11.6
41st percentile
Syntax
3.19
71st percentile
Vocabulary
2.00
10th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Social 62%62%
  • Institutional 13%13%
  • Economic 12%12%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 2%2%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

82 sentences in 35 paragraphs

Mr. Rajoy, you have implemented a health policy that has expelled thousands, tens of thousands, hundreds of thousands of people who needed it from the system. You have done this to save money. You have neither saved money, nor introduced any reform, nor made any improvements to the public system. What have you done? You have thrown out those who need it and, furthermore, put the public health system and the public health of all Spaniards at risk. Because the people who walk down the street without papers carrying infectious viruses do not ask those next to them whether they have papers or not. You have created a serious public health problem and, in addition, abandoned the people who need it the most.

Do not say now that you are rectifying because of emergencies; you are rectifying because you have done it wrong. Rectify. And, by the way, tell me how you are going to rectify, because the Minister has said that he is not going to give them a card. How are you going to do it, then? How are you going to do it and when are you going to do it?

President.- Look, I do not agree with your statements. I will explain what we have done: first, as I explained before, all Spaniards and all foreigners legally residing in Spain have the right to health care, and today it is fully universal; second, we have paid the sixteen billion euros that were owed in health care bills; third, we have controlled pharmaceutical spending and ensured that those unemployed without benefits do not have to pay for medications; fourth, we have ensured that providers who were being paid after 525 days are now paid at reasonable prices; and today we have a common health card. All of this has been achieved.

We have put an end to "health tourism," because it was the Court of Auditors itself that told us there was spending of over one billion euros a year as a result of "health tourism." We were paying for operations of people who lived abroad, registered here, had their insurance, and we had to pay for them, even for people who were operated on in their own country and we had to pay for them.

All of that we have done here, and now what we are doing is that people who were treated in emergencies will be treated in Primary Care.

Therefore, we have put order in a system that was going through enormous difficulties and we have made health care universal for all Spaniards.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Cayo Lara, of the Parliamentary Group of the Left Plural

Mr. Lara.- Mr. Rajoy, what measures does your Government plan to adopt following the demands for bread, shelter, and work from the "Marches for Dignity"?

President.- Indeed, I have seen the recommendations of the so-called "Marches for Dignity" and I have also seen the political parties that support them. I do not agree with many of their demands, such as leaving NATO, reforming Article 135 of the Constitution, opposing the Free Trade Agreement, the right to decide, or abolishing labor reform.

However, on economic matters, I can agree, because the economic policy we have tried to carry out this Legislature has one objective: to overcome the crisis, grow, and create jobs. Fortunately, in this country, we are already achieving results, and therefore, as I believe that employment is the best instrument to generate wealth and well-being, and to maintain and improve public services, on that point, although I fear that the instruments we would implement are different, there would be agreement on the objectives.

Mr. Lara.- In addition to what you have said, Mr. Rajoy, the marches demanded four important elements, which were bread, shelter, work, and dignity. Because poverty, social exclusion, and evictions have increased, and unemployment remains at unbearable levels: almost thirteen million people are on the brink of poverty, five million are in severe poverty, there are more than 180 evictions per day, three million unemployed are without benefits or assistance, and there are almost six million workers earning below the Minimum Interprofessional Wage, that is, below 648 euros. These are millions of people whose dignity is being trampled on day in and day out.

The other day, at an event I had in Paterna, a woman gave me a handwritten note to read here today. The note says: "I would like to know where my dignity is, since Mr. Rajoy keeps saying that Spaniards lead a dignified life. Where is my dignity, Mr. Rajoy?" This woman is named Rosalía Gens Aguayo and she is one of the five million people in Spain living in severe poverty.

That is why, Mr. Rajoy, in your name, I demand an urgent plan to combat poverty and social exclusion. In the name of all the people who cannot pay a mortgage and are evicted from their homes by usurious banks, I ask you to withdraw the appeal to the Constitutional Court regarding the law promoted by Izquierda Unida in Andalusia, which guaranteed the right to housing, and I ask you to bring a similar law here. In the name of the unemployed, without benefits or assistance, I ask for an emergency plan against unemployment, and in the name of all the workers who are on contracts and "slave wages," I demand that you increase the Minimum Interprofessional Wage to reach 1,100 euros in three years.

Mr. Rajoy, for once in your life, put yourself in the shoes of those people, of those who are thrown out of their homes, of those who are unemployed without assistance, who work long hours for a pittance, or who have to go to a soup kitchen. Put yourself in the shoes of those people and govern for them. And recalling Galeano, imagine that all those people are a bank; I’m sure you would have already saved them.

Thank you, Mr. Rajoy.

President.- I will only ask you one thing, Mr. Lara, which is to make your judgments with a little more balance. Spain is not the country you have just described. Spain has gone through a very serious economic crisis, has been on the brink of rescue, has been on the verge of bankruptcy; we have had a period of recession, of negative economic growth; many jobs have been lost and budget adjustments had to be made; but fortunately, things have changed. The first thing that has changed is that Spain was spared from the rescue, because that would have been a serious problem for our country, as it has been, and this whole Chamber knows, for many other countries in the European Union.

But, in addition, we have been able to maintain all the pillars of the Welfare State in a situation of extreme difficulty: we have a public health system like no one else has, we have a public pension system like very few have, an educational system, social services, and the best part is that now jobs are being created in our country. Last year, already 440,000 Spaniards found a job and this year it will be more than half a million, and if we persevere in economic policy, we can have twenty million people working in our country in four years, which must be the great objective for the coming years.

We already know that there are people who have difficulties, of course we know that, and that is why we have made decisions. But we have already been able to start making tax cuts; there are more scholarships; as I said before, more than eight hundred thousand more Spaniards with health cards; we have supported a plan against child poverty; we have created a Social Housing Fund... Undoubtedly, there are still many things to do; but this country has made a very important leap forward in recent years and Spanish society has been able to overcome one of the most serious economic crises we have experienced in many years.

Certainly, speeches like yours do not help at all because Spain, fortunately, is not that country you say, Mr. Lara.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Pedro Sánchez, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Sánchez.- Mr. Rajoy, all I ask is that you tell the truth, that you do not lie. It is not true that you have maintained the Welfare State; you have made cuts against the Welfare State, and the proof is the public health system, the cuts it is suffering, and also the public education system. So I would like to know the balance you make of your educational policy, Mr. Rajoy.

President.- The largest cut to the Welfare State in the modern history of Spain was during the Legislature 2008-2011, when your political management led to 3,400,000 Spaniards being unemployed and when the State lost seventy billion euros in revenue.

The educational policy of the Government has had the following objectives: to ensure that young people do not drop out of school, that their education has more quality, and that they can more easily find a job in the future. I believe we have made progress on all three objectives over these three years.

Mr. Sánchez.- Yes, of course, Mr. Rajoy, and that is why we have a 51 percent youth unemployment rate and seven out of ten contracts that young people have are precarious jobs.

Please, Mr. Rajoy, those things you say, say them at rallies; but do not say them in the Congress of Deputies, because no one believes them. No one believes them, Mr. Rajoy.

The policies of inequality start with you when the policies of equality should begin, which is precisely in school. I have heard you say that education is the greatest guarantee of progress and, at the same time, cut public investment in education by seventeen billion euros. I have heard you say that education is investing in the future and what you have done is lay off thirty thousand teachers from public education and increase the student-to-teacher ratio. I have also heard you say, Mr. Rajoy, that education is a way to influence or instill values in our children, and at the same time what you have done is eliminate civic education, subsidize segregated education between boys and girls, and also impose Religion in the public education system.

Mr. Rajoy, you talk about normal human beings; but you impose inhuman resistance tests on both parents and public education teachers as a result of your cuts.

Last Monday, Mr. Rajoy, I signed a commitment with the Educational Community, something you have not done in these three and a half years of Government, and that is to incorporate and recover public education as a right in our country as a result of the cuts you are making.

Mr. Wert called me an "apostle of equity." It is your habit to always incorporate Religion into the education debate. I would tell Mr. Wert, Mr. Rajoy, that more than an apostle, I am a defender; a defender like millions of Spaniards who want precisely a quality public education so that in our sons and daughters their professional and educational success does not depend on their parents' bank account, but on their effort and merit.

I am a defender who wants to recover education as a right and who wants to prevent what you have been trying to do since you arrived, from minute one, at La Moncloa, which is precisely to end equality of opportunity and to end public education. But you know what, Mr. Rajoy? You are not going to succeed.

President.- The reform of the Education Law contemplates a universal, public, and free education; but, in addition, it emphasizes some things that you forgot: first, to improve the quality of education; second, to improve the possibilities of finding work in the future for our young people, and to set common minimum learning standards throughout Spain.

And we can already present some positive things, Mr. Sánchez: early school leaving, which in 2011, when we came to power, was 26.3 percent has dropped to 21.9 percent, and this is very important because there are now more young people who have the possibility of finding work in the future; in Vocational Training, in the 2011-2012 school year there were 610,000 students and now there are 793,000 students, a very positive figure, because it will allow more young people to find work in the future; Dual Vocational Training, which in the 2011-2012 school year had 4,292 students, now has four times more, and there are ten times more companies working in Dual Training, and scholarships, which in 2011 were 1.1 billion euros, in 2015 are 1.4 billion euros. In the 2013-2014 school year, we have the highest number of scholarship recipients in the history of Spain.

The problem you have is the same as you had, and I told Mr. Pérez Rubalcaba on numerous occasions, both publicly and privately. The education laws that have been made in Spain have always been yours. When we approved an Education Law, it was not allowed to come into force because 48 hours after you came to power, you decided to repeal it. You were within your rights. The problem is that we cannot continue to maintain the same educational system when the world is changing and you have not realized that we have a quality problem, as the PISA report says, of the first order.

Therefore, your immobility, the refusal to change, the desire to leave things as they were more than thirty years ago, does enormous damage to young Spaniards and to the future of education in our country. And I am not willing to allow it.

Thank you very much.