Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

21 November 2016 · Parliamentary control session (Senate) · Senate

Context
Rajoy responded to parliamentary questions in the Spanish Senate on November 21, 2016, addressing the sustainability of the public pension system.
Main themes
Public pension system sustainability, social security reserve fund, pension revaluation and purchasing power, employment creation and precarious work, Toledo Pact Commission, economic policy, social dialogue, demographic challenges, birth rate and life expectancy, pension reform, government accountability
Duration
~54 min
95th percentile
Words
6,468
95th percentile
Sentences
262
94th percentile
Readability
54
74th percentile
Grade
11.1
34th percentile
Syntax
3.10
60th percentile
Vocabulary
2.02
12th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 35%35%
  • Social 34%34%
  • Economic 21%21%
  • Ceremonial 10%10%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

262 sentences in 83 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Ramón María Espinar, of the Parliamentary Group Unidos Podemos-En Comú Podem-En Marea

Mr. Espinar.- Mr. President of the Government, welcome to the Senate. We thank you for coming to a session of government oversight, even if it is eleven months late. What plans does the Government have to guarantee and make the public pension system sustainable?

President.- Mr. Espinar, guaranteeing the public pension system is the most important challenge we have ahead of us, all of us who are here. Do not have the slightest doubt about it, because a public pension system allows something as important as living for many people who, in general, are no longer able to work. Therefore, a country that values itself must do everything in its power to guarantee the public pension system.

I will give you some data that I believe is very illustrative: we spend 26.7% of total public spending in Spain on pensions; Spaniards pay 9.5 million pensions; the average pension is slightly above 1,000 euros; the pension of those who are now entering the system is also slightly above 1,400 euros; during these years of recession, five consecutive years in our country, we have increased them moderately, but low inflation has allowed us to maintain purchasing power.

A significant fact: between 2007 and 2015, state revenues fell by 29 billion; during the same years, spending on pensions increased by 28 billion. And we must add that spending on pensions will increase significantly in the future; that life expectancy, fortunately, for you, for me, and for everyone present, in Spain is increasing -- we are the second country with the highest life expectancy, behind Japan; that the pensions of those entering the system now are higher because they have contributed more and for more years, and that we have a birth rate problem that should increase.

This is the description. What are we going to do? Fundamentally, two things: create jobs and, therefore, implement an economic policy to create jobs; and, secondly, work in the Social Dialogue Table with unions and employers, and in the Toledo Pact Commission, which has begun its work today in Congress, to make the necessary reforms with the aim of ensuring that the public pension system is guaranteed. I hope that you, also in the Toledo Pact Commission, will contribute, along with the other Groups in Congress and also in the Senate, to achieve that objective, which I believe we all share.

Mr. Espinar.- Mr. President of the Government, nothing new under the sun, then. I asked you what you are going to do; you respond by telling me how well you have done and what you will continue to do. No novelty in your speech, Mr. Rajoy.

But we have a problem, and the problem is that you presented yourself in the last investiture session in the Congress of Deputies and said two things that do not fit together: the first thing you said was that you would indeed address the issue of pensions and that the sustainability and guarantee of pensions is a priority for your Government; the second is that you will maintain the course in economic policy. Those two things, Mr. President of the Government, are not compatible, and allow me to explain.

What situation are we in? Today, the Social Security Reserve Fund has gone from having 66.815 billion euros in 2011 to having 25.167 billion in 2016, and it is decreasing; the deficit of Social Security, Mr. President of the Government, was almost 17 billion euros in 2015; the purchasing power of our pensioners has not decreased since you unlinked it from the CPI because we have had a situation of deflation, of negative inflation, but for next year the forecast is that pensions will increase by 0.25%, while the CPI is expected to increase by 0.9%; by the way, very linked to the price of energy in our country.

And regarding the income in Social Security, Mr. President, the outlook is bleak, because it is true that since 2014 jobs have been created in our country, but not net employment; however, even though jobs are increasing in our country, there are fewer contributions to Social Security, that is, the jobs being created contribute less to Social Security. And that is due to the precariousness of employment, and we fear that it will also lead to the precariousness of the lives of pensioners. You do not create jobs; you distribute precariousness, Mr. President of the Government.

What has been done so far? A sustainability factor has been introduced in pensions that, under the name of "sustainability factor," means that if pensioners live longer, they will receive less, yes, for a longer time. You have introduced a pension revaluation factor, that is, you condition the payment of pensions to the state of the Social Security Fund. The retirement age has been increased -- I acknowledge that you did not do that; pensions have been unlinked from the CPI, that is, if the cost of living increases, pensions do not have to automatically increase; and next year we are going to see a loss of purchasing power for pensioners in our country, even in a favorable context of GDP growth and job creation.

And you have done two other things: promote private pension funds, and this morning the Minister said -- I am still stunned and hope you clarify it for me -- that it will be perfectly compatible to receive a pension while working, which institutionalizes precariousness even after retirement. And I wonder what jobs people who retire will work in. I do not know if the model you have in mind is the model of the United States, where everyone knows that in supermarkets you find pensioners, whose pensions do not provide enough to live on, packing grocery bags for people shopping at supermarkets.

What do we believe should be done, and in this we extend our hand and propose what, believe me, Mr. Rajoy, in our loyal understanding must be done to solve the pension problem? First, to assume that the pension problem is not an accounting problem, it is not just a problem of the Social Security Fund; it is a problem of the productive model. The basis of public services and pensions in our country is jobs, it is salaries. Therefore, betting on a productive model that does not make us compete with salaries of six hundred euros in the international context, but for an intelligent industrialization of our country and for an energy transition that allows us to generate better jobs, is essential to guarantee our pension system.

Second, as I have said, the majority, three out of every four euros, specifically, the weight of our public coffers is supported by salaries and consumption, three out of every four euros, while El Corte Inglés last year did not pay a euro in taxes. Perhaps we need to consider making adjustments in our tax system; perhaps we need to consider that those who have more and those who earn more pay taxes, and, in addition, perhaps we need to consider that it should not only be the Social Security Fund that supports our pensions in a population pyramid model that you know and that is complicating the sustainability of pensions.

Mr. Rajoy, you tell us, you tell everyone and you tell the Spaniards that you are a predictable man and that you will do what you have done, and that you will maintain things as they are; and at the same time, you tell the Spaniards that you will work for the sustainability of pensions.

Well, look, Mr. Rajoy, in the context that our country is living in 2016, those two things are incompatible. You navigate a contradiction, and it is the contradiction of telling the Spaniards: by doing what I do, pensions can be guaranteed. It is not true. The change in our country is already a reality, and the question is whether the change will be towards better living conditions for Spaniards; whether the change will be betting on maintaining social rights, which are a structural part of our democracy and of all those around us since the end of World War II and there was a consensus in Europe on the Welfare State and liberal democracy as models of coexistence, or if your model of change will be a change for the worse, a model of precariousness, not only of employment but also of pensions and the living conditions of pensioners.

We, Mr. Rajoy -- I acknowledge this without reservation -- have a different model of country than yours, and what we tell you, Mr. Rajoy, is that in our model of country democracy must be accompanied by social services. Democracy is not understood without citizenship rights, and we are going to defend a country in color against the black-and-white model of injustice and the precariousness of the living conditions of Spaniards.

President.- Mr. Espinar, I am not as pessimistic as you are, but in any case, each one is as they are.

This is a country that at this moment pays, to fourteen million people, a benefit every month; among them, nine and a half million are pensioners. It is a country that maintains a public service system like few in the world, both the Spanish public health system and our educational system and our social services. We do this after having overcome the greatest economic crisis that Spain has experienced in decades; remember, five years in recession. And from now on, what we have to do is work to maintain this and, if possible, improve it in the future.

I told you before that, in my opinion, there are two things that need to be done: the first is to continue creating jobs. As you know, contributions to Social Security are what ultimately pay the pensions of our pensioners. When I came to the Government, for every person who entered the system to receive a pension, three people lost their jobs. Now it is the other way around: for every person who enters the system, six more people start working. In this year 2016 -- yes, it is an important fact -- until September, the number of contributors to Social Security had increased by 405,000 and the number of pensioners by 65,000. If this were reversed, as it was before, we would have a huge problem.

Therefore, what needs to be done is an economic policy that generates employment, because the people who work are the ones who pay with their social contributions the pensions of pensioners.

And the second issue that needs to be addressed is reforms. It is not enough simply with an economic policy that creates jobs, although it is very important, and I believe that by the end of this Legislature we should be at twenty million jobs; reforms need to be made. We have made some: the sustainability factor, indeed; the revaluation, and we have also allowed the compatibility of pensions with employment. This is already in effect. It is not that the Minister said it, I do not know if she said it this morning; if you pointed it out, I am sure she did. It is that this is already in effect today. Therefore, what we need to do is continue making reforms in the future to be able to maintain and improve pensions.

I told you before: two avenues of work: social dialogue and the Toledo Pact. I give this matter the highest priority. You -- you have just said it here now -- are willing to collaborate. Your collaboration is welcome, and I can even tell you that I find it necessary.

I have read your electoral program, and there are some things I share and others I do not share. For example, retirement at 65? I do not share that. The indexing of pensions? I do not share that. The commitment to guarantee the sustainability of the system? Yes. The elimination of special contribution regimes for new affiliations? It can be studied. The promotion of collective public provision versus individual? I will not eliminate those tax benefits for those who also make their own fund; it is simply a matter of freedom for individuals. The increase of non-contributory pensions? Yes, I agree, as long as resources allow it. The elimination of the maximum cap on contributions for the highest salaries? Without a doubt, we can talk about this issue.

But we have also presented an important package of measures, and I invite you and your political force to discuss this matter in the Toledo Pact Commission.

You have also spoken here about the Reserve Fund. The Reserve Fund is precisely to act in times of difficulty. But, of course, in recent years, three and a half million contributors have been lost, and when contributors are lost because employment is lost, the Social Security Reserve Fund comes into play. That is why I say that what needs to be done is to create jobs so that the Reserve Fund does not have to come into play and to be able to provide more resources to the Social Security Reserve Fund. It is not so difficult to understand this, which is so reasonable.

As I believe that, on the other hand, what you have said about how pensions should be financed in the future is perfectly debatable. There is a significant part of our pension system, including all contributory pensions, that is already financed by the General State Budgets. Today, Social Security contributions only finance contributory pensions, widowhood, orphanhood, and some other minor issues. But, without a doubt, like so many other topics, it is a matter open to opinion and discussion.

So I believe that, at this moment, what is appropriate is not so much to criticize what the Government did in the previous term, which was to maintain the pension system and never freeze them, but rather to provide ideas and solutions to face the future. That is what it is about.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Santiago Vidal, from the Parliamentary Group of Esquerra Republicana

Mr. Vidal.- On behalf of Esquerra Republicana, Mr. President, we would like to know if you still believe that the judicial route is the appropriate way to end the independence process in Catalonia.

President.- Mr. Vidal, allow me to remind you of some things that you know very well, but sometimes it is good to recall the obvious. In Spain, no one goes to court for their ideas. Here we live, fortunately, in a regime of freedoms and, of course, freedom of thought and freedom of expression are clearly protected in our country.

Then, there are other things different from ideas, which are acts contrary to the Law. In this case, Justice does act. As you know, when someone violates the Law, whoever that someone may be, Justice acts. These are two principles that all of us here present know perfectly well: the Law obliges us all and Justice guarantees that the Law is upheld. I am absolutely convinced that you fully agree with me on the statement I have just made.

Conclusion: here everyone has the right to think as they see fit and appropriate, and you can be, as you have said on numerous occasions, an independentist. And I can also think as I see fit and appropriate, because I am not of a lesser condition than you, nor than anyone else. Therefore, we can do that here because we live in a regime of freedoms.

In the same way that I tell you this, that is, that you and I can think as we see best, I must tell you that neither you, nor I, nor any of us here are legitimized to disregard the Law. We cannot violate the Law. And we have an obligation, even greater than that of the rest of the citizens, plain and simple, because we are representatives of national sovereignty. Therefore, if we do not comply with the Law, it is logical that someone tells us that we must comply with the Law; otherwise, we would cease to be a democratic and rule-of-law state, and I believe that neither you, nor I, nor anyone here wants to cease being a democratic and rule-of-law state.

Mr. Vidal.- Mr. President, your response to our question was so predictable that you will have noticed, without a doubt, since you have kindly addressed me directly, that I did not need to take any notes.

Allow me to remind you that the main duty of a president of the Government is to provide the Chambers, when requested, with the objective data that allows for at least a glimpse of a willingness to improve the institutions that represent the top of the Judiciary, with special reference, without a doubt, you know it, to the Constitutional Court and the General Council of the Judiciary.

Thank you for coming to the Senate to account before the territorial representatives of the people, but, frankly, after a year of systematically failing to fulfill that duty --I have been here for a year and this is the first time I have the luck to speak with you-- you could have done it much better, I assure you; it must surely be a lack of habit. Do not worry, we hope you will learn.

The essential question today in Spain is not whether there is true separation of powers, but whether the three essential powers of a democratic system (the legislative, the executive, and the judicial) are, unfortunately, increasingly separated from democracy. I fear that this is the case, and allow me to remind you of three empirical facts that I would have liked you to provide us. I believe your Minister of Justice has mentioned them to you on some occasion, but as I see you have forgotten them, allow me to remind you.

Fact number one: last October, that is, very recently, in 2016, the Justice Committee of the Council of Europe ruled, once again --this is not the first time-- that Spain remains one of the countries in the European Union with the lowest level of independence of the Judiciary, motivated by the continuous intrusions and pressures that the Executive frequently exerts on the top of the Judiciary. This report also points out --I am sure you have read it-- that in the previous one, issued already in 2011, a series of recommendations were made to the Government you preside over and, despite five years having passed, none of those recommendations have been implemented. Conclusion: your Government has failed in that first matter.

Fact number two: last week --and you will see that I refer to very recent facts-- the entity International Transparency published, in its annual report on corruption indices in Europe, that once again, Spain remains one of the States where this social scourge is most alarming. Unfortunately for us, only Moldova seems to be worse.

Well, that same document reproaches your Government for its negligence and lack of real will, beyond mere empty words, to fight against the systemic corruption that affects certain political parties, with special mention to yours, of course. You surely know that it is your political party that currently has the most ongoing corruption cases before the Courts.

In the final recommendations, it is stated that to resolve such a serious democratic deficit, you should have introduced some change in the method of electing the members of the General Council of the Judiciary and the Constitutional Court; a change that, evidently, has not occurred. Conclusion: you have also failed in that second matter.

And point number three, which I imagine you must expect: yesterday, no less than yesterday, the Supreme Court issued a ruling in the cassation appeal filed by the judge and senator who speaks to you; yesterday, just yesterday. In that ruling, as you know, the sanction of three years of suspension from employment and salary that was imposed on me by the General Council of the Judiciary back in February 2015 is confirmed; by the way, a resolution in which the decisive vote of its president, Mr. Lesmes, was crucial, since nine of the twenty members voted against my sanction.

I would like you to provide this Chamber with some data regarding why you believe that formulating, thinking, debating with a group of colleagues in the academic field, and writing --it is true, I wrote it, Mr. President-- a legal text that was and is nothing more than a simple draft for a hypothetical constitutional model of a hypothetical future Republic of Catalonia, if in the referendum, which do not doubt, if that is the will of the citizens, we are going to celebrate on September 27, 2017; I would like you to tell me if drafting that document… You have said "in Spain, one is not sanctioned for writing, one is not sanctioned for thinking" and that is precisely what I was accused of.

Mr. President, you have, fortunately, surpassed, advanced, you no longer do what the Holy Inquisition did: there they burned books and their authors at the public stake, as you surely know; today, no, today you limit yourselves to taking away our work.

I conclude with a request, Mr. President: please stop using the courts to pursue and silence the voices of those who only ask that the right of Catalonia to decide its own future be respected. Mr. President, Catalonia will be what its citizens want; perhaps independentists; perhaps not. They will be what they decide, not what you want to impose on us. And do not have any doubt, never forget, freedom is not judged.

President.- Mr. Vidal, you began your intervention by saying that you had not taken any notes because mine was predictable. If you already knew what I was going to respond to you, I do not understand why you are asking me a question in this Chamber. It has not happened to me the same way. I have had to take notes because, frankly, I did not expect to hear from you, who is a judge --something you have said and I now repeat-- what you have just said.

You have told us that Justice in Spain is not independent. Can you explain to this Chamber the pressures you have received from the Government to adopt the sentences in one direction or another? Can you do that? If you are willing to do so, stand up in this Chamber and tell us.

Secondly, you have said, and you have cited some reports and some countries, that Spain is not a democratic and rule-of-law state, and that there is no separation of powers. You can be absolutely certain that you have just stated a falsehood in this Chamber and I, of course, cannot accept it.

But the most surprising thing is that you bring your own personal problem here. Sir, you speak of the independence of Justice and the argument you give to demonstrate that Justice is not independent is that it has condemned you, you who cite yourself, the Supreme Court itself. Imagine, Sir, that I in this Chamber, as President of the Government, criticize a court for condemning me. Frankly, Mr. Vidal, you are wrong. Here, plain and simple, what has happened is that the Supreme Court, which is an independent power, the Judiciary, has issued a ruling fulfilling the function established by the Law.

Sir, you cannot, because you have said on some occasion… "Disobedience, when it meets certain requirements, cannot be illegal." This is what you have said and then it is appropriate for some of us to ask you: what are those requirements that disobedience must meet to not be illegal? Who is it that says what those requirements are? Is it you? How can one support the non-compliance of the Law and then tell citizens to comply with the Law? Sir, what laws must be complied with and which ones not? The ones you do not like? And who is authorized to say which ones must be complied with and which ones not? You or anyone else? Who can violate the Law? You? Can those of us here do it? The rest of the citizens?

Sir, it seems to me that you confuse two radically different things that are intimately linked: democracy and the Law. Without Law, there is no democracy and one thing is what you may think. Your first obligation as a judge --which you have been the one to say you are a judge-- and as a senator, the first, is to comply with the Law and then comes everything else.

And we can undoubtedly debate politics. We can understand each other, we can dialogue, we can talk, and I am willing to do so. What I cannot accept is to be told: referendum, yes, negotiated and legal; and, if it is not negotiated and legal, referendum too. Because that is a contract of adhesion and that is an absolutely undemocratic imposition, contrary to the Law and contrary to any principle of separation of powers.

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Vicente Álvarez Areces, from the Parliamentary Group of Socialists

Mr. Álvarez Areces.- Mr. President of the Government, first of all, I would like to welcome you to the Senate at the beginning of this Legislature, not without first reminding you that we have been a year and two months without your presence in this Chamber and unable to carry out the necessary oversight work assigned to us to control the Government. I hope that this situation never happens again. I believe it is a serious democratic anomaly.

Mr. President, the current political situation in Spain, with the correlation of forces emanating from the polls in the last elections, imperatively demands a way of acting quite different from that which has been followed until now, during the time you presided over the Government. We cannot ignore the grave consequences of the crisis in broad social sectors: among workers, both employed and unemployed; the increase in inequality; what poverty has also meant, which did not previously exist in layers of the population, increasing considerably, even poverty within the labor sphere itself, and a lack of response to the political challenges of our country.

In this new time, which is a new time, it is necessary for you to internalize it, and more in this Chamber, where you have an absolute majority, where situations of arrogance must come to an end, where we cannot again witness how the call for the General Commission of Autonomous Communities is denied to us, after having been repeatedly requested, so that it can play its role of dialogue, of concertation, so that the Autonomous Communities come here, to concert in the Parliamentary Group, with our diversity but also with the Government.

You yourself have said that everything is negotiable and have publicly committed to earning daily stability. And that is why I ask you: do you plan to recover the social spending cut by your Governments?

President.- Mr. Álvarez Areces, with absolute frankness, I believe that all of us here, with different political approaches, want the best for our country and for our fellow citizens. The question is how to do things and how to achieve what I just said: the best for our country and for our fellow citizens.

Social spending, which is crucial in our country --63.5 percent of Spanish public spending is social spending-- requires, as anyone can understand, economic resources. If there are no economic resources, we can have all the goodwill we want, which is important, but we will never be able to achieve our objective.

Therefore, to obtain economic resources, what we need is to create jobs. Employment is good for those who have it, it is good for those who obtain it, but it is also good for all citizens of the country because, when there is a person employed, that person pays contributions to Social Security and pensions can be improved; that person pays Personal Income Tax, consumes, pays VAT, pays indirect taxes, and all of this allows us to improve essential public services and assist the most needy. That is why the key is to implement an economic policy that generates employment, because it is good for the people but it is also good for the country as a whole, because more resources are collected.

I will briefly explain what we have done in the last Legislature, which is as follows:

First, we arrived after 3.5 million jobs had been lost in Spain; seventy billion euros in revenue were lost, which is the key to the economic crisis we are experiencing: seventy billion euros less in revenue; we were in recession, on the verge of being rescued; we had economic imbalances; competitiveness problems… But, in short, the most important thing, recession, seventy billion euros less in revenue and three and a half million fewer people working.

What did we do? The following: avoid the rescue, which was a very important social policy decision --just look at what has happened to other countries that have been forced to go through that terrible situation--; secondly, an economic policy aimed at generating employment to obtain economic resources and improve social policies, and we have had some success in that policy dedicated to job creation; thirdly, as we had significant revenue problems and could not increase the deficit, which was at 9.3 percent, we made the decision to prioritize spending.

What were the spending priorities in Spain in the last Legislature? First, pensions, and we never froze them, but rather increased them; a little, but we were able to maintain purchasing power. Secondly, to help many Autonomous Communities, which manage health and education, because they had financing problems and were in a state of pre-bankruptcy, and we launched the Payment Plan to Suppliers, which you know well, and we also launched the FLA, which was fundamentally aimed at social care. Thirdly, we also maintained spending on unemployment, which exceeded the combined spending of the Ministries of Justice, Interior, Defense, and Foreign Affairs; this is the crisis we have experienced in Spain in recent years. And finally, in what was our responsibility in education, we increased from 1.168 billion in 2011 to 1.416 billion today.

Therefore, in a critical situation, Spain maintained its economic sovereignty, employment began to be created --the year 2015 was the year in which the most jobs were created in recent Spanish history--, revenue increased, no one talks about the risk premium today, and we have preserved the bulk of our Welfare State.

What are we going to do to increase spending? Well, look, do everything possible so that with a good economic policy, jobs are created, we have more resources and, therefore, we can dedicate them to social spending, which I am as interested in increasing as you are; you and I, as Spaniards.

Mr. Álvarez Areces.- Mr. Rajoy, the reality is that today, five years after your policies and your cuts, there is a social reality that we cannot evade: the population at risk of poverty or social exclusion has increased in Spain to 26.8 percent; a total of more than thirteen million people. One in three children in Spain is at risk of poverty, the fifth highest rate in Europe; 50 percent of the unemployed do not receive benefits; in Spain, there are more than 693,000 households that have no income at all and, as a culmination, your cuts in education, health, and social protection have been glaring.

But, look, Mr. Rajoy, I have always liked --I have been a spokesperson for Education, I have had Mr. Wert here-- to come with figures in hand. I bring you here a document that you have sent to Brussels, titled "Update of the Stability Program 2016-2019." In that program and in that document, the "roadmap" of your Government is to further weaken our essential public services, as can be seen on page 136, by further reducing educational spending, decreasing from 4.4 percent of GDP in 2011 to 3.79 percent in 2019.

I ask you, Mr. Rajoy, what educational pact do you think you will make that decreases educational spending as a percentage of GDP, thus contradicting even agreements with other political formations, with a widespread demand: that we must finance not only what is currently being negotiated, but also the Pact for Science to which parliamentary political forces committed themselves at the time. That, of course, is unthinkable to accept in a new horizon where, according to your own statements, the economy is growing and results are improving; but if they are improving and growing, we will have to, sincerely, prioritize how we can, in some way, support those groups that have been left out of the situation due to this terrible crisis. That is why we want to tell you that we will not accept a scenario similar to that.

Regarding health, you intend to reduce from 6.47 percent of GDP in 2011 to 5.74 percent of GDP in 2019; an official document of yours, Mr. Rajoy. Words are words and documents sent to Brussels are documents sent to Brussels. Here it is, I have mentioned the page. Verify it.

The cuts applied in 2012 resulted in the loss of the universal nature of health coverage, the reduction of twenty-eight billion euros in these years cumulatively during that period, as well as the loss of tens of thousands of health professionals, more copayments for pensioners, and an increase in waiting lists to very concerning levels… For example, in surgical waiting times, the time that is now, evidently, objective is 22 percent longer than in December 2011. That is the real situation. No matter how many words, there are facts.

In the chapter on social protection, likewise --take the document--, it goes from 16.70 percent of GDP in 2016 to 15.87 percent in 2019. If within that spending we take dependency, what do we see, and the Autonomous Communities know it? I have presided over an Autonomous Community and we have seen how in the Dependency Law, from the initial commitment of 50 percent funding by the State, it has now dropped to an average of less than 20 percent from the State Administration, pressuring the Autonomous Communities to finance the spending from their own budgets.

How is it possible for you to say that we are better off, if we are much worse and there are many people outside coverage and services? I am not even mentioning the number of rights that have been taken away from them.

That medium- and long-term scenario you outline is a dismal scenario. In pensions, which has already been discussed here and I have also listened to the responses to the questions, we have to look at the horizon of 2030 in this document you outline a pension expenditure of 11.2 percent of GDP, a level of spending lower than the current one, but with almost three million more people than the new cohorts entering the system. This equation, which is resolved in primary education, is: with less money and more people to attend to, what will happen to pensions? They will decrease and, if pensions decrease, we cannot accept that.

We want to negotiate, we want to reach an agreement, but we want to agree on other objectives; other objectives that are not these, because with this do not count on us, Mr. Rajoy. Objectives that allow us to move forward, to look to the future with hope; that those groups that have been terribly affected by the crisis can regain their own dignity and their role in our society. Count on us for that; for cuts, no.

President.- Mr. Álvarez Areces, you have made a tremendous effort to demonstrate how badly things are going in our country. Do not worry, I will not make a tremendous effort to demonstrate the opposite. I do want to comment on two words you used in your speech: the first "prioritize" and the second, "improve."

I will tell you how we spend money in Spain, because it is important that we all know this. Social spending? 63.5 percent of total Spanish spending. It is very difficult to find any country in our environment, and, of course, impossible outside our environment, with a similar level of spending. Pensions? 26.7 percent. You talk about pensions and I want to remind you that I have never frozen them, and I have been increasing them for five consecutive years. Health? 14.2 percent of spending. Education? 9.3 percent. Unemployment? 4.4 percent; it is true that it is decreasing. Social expenses? 8.2 percent. Remember what I told you before: we spend more on unemployment alone than on Justice, Interior, Defense, and Foreign Affairs combined.

We have a Welfare State of which, honestly, we can be proud. Undoubtedly, it needs to be improved and more things need to be done; but it is very difficult to find a country with a level of social spending like ours: fourteen million people receive a state benefit every month; 25 percent goes to education and health.

Mr. Areces, from there, can we improve? Yes. From there, are there people in a situation of enormous difficulty? Yes; that is our challenge, to ensure they are no longer in that situation. From there, do we need to work to be better? Yes. But to do all these things, Ladies and Gentlemen, we need to implement economic policies that create jobs.

If an economic policy like the one we experienced in Spain in some years generates the loss of three and a half million jobs, it is very difficult to make any social spending because revenue --I have already told your colleague Mr. Espinar-- falls by seventy billion euros and, if it falls by seventy billion euros, something has to be done, because one cannot spend what one does not have, neither being in government, nor being at home, nor in any company.

There are many things that have improved in recent times and there are many things we need to work on in the future. Eurostat poverty rates have decreased from 7.4 to 7.1 percent in the euro area and in Spain, from 7.1 to 6.4 percent. It is undoubtedly one of the most important, most concerning issues; but I invite you, just as I did with Mr. Espinar, to sit down, to come together, in the Toledo Pact Commission or wherever appropriate and start making fewer speeches and taking more effective decisions for the benefit of everyone.

Thank you very much.