Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session.

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

22 November 2016 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy responded to questions from the Socialist Parliamentary Group during a congressional control session in Spain on November 22, 2016, focusing on labor conditions.
Main themes
Labor precariousness, employment policy, temporary and part-time contracts, wage levels and devaluation, collective bargaining, Social Security affiliates, minimum wage, labor reform, parliamentary debate, economic recovery
Duration
~15 min
53rd percentile
Words
1,838
53rd percentile
Sentences
64
42nd percentile
Readability
44
45th percentile
Grade
13.8
65th percentile
Syntax
3.50
94th percentile
Vocabulary
2.10
27th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Economic 66%66%
  • Institutional 23%23%
  • Social 8%8%
  • Ceremonial 3%3%
  • Geopolitical 0%0%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

64 sentences in 26 paragraphs

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Antonio Hernando, from the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. President of the Government, I have chosen this first question in a session of control, Mr. President, because, beyond discussing the official employment figures, there is an undeniable reality on the street, and that is that today, in Spain, very often having a job does not mean that you can adequately support a family: working poor, without rights, with part-time contracts, with low wages, and yet with endless working hours.

Your model has been to replace permanent employment with temporary contracts or part-time contracts. If we add to this wage devaluation and the precarization of working conditions, these have been the two main tools to improve competitiveness and growth.

But tomorrow you have an important meeting with unions and employers, and that is why we ask you if, in addition to listening to them, you will propose measures to reverse this situation of labor precariousness, because that is one of my party's main objectives in this Legislature: that this be a country where working serves to live with dignity, to be able to support a family, and to have a fair pension in the future.

President.- Mr. Hernando, the first objective of any employment policy is to create jobs, and I would like to remind you, regardless of whether you like to hear the data or not, what has happened in Spain in recent times.

In June 2008, during the second Legislature of the Socialist Party, the number of affiliates to Social Security began to decline. By December 2011, 2,129,031 people had stopped contributing to Social Security because they had lost their jobs; that is the greatest precarization that can occur in the labor market. Affiliation continued to decline during the years 2012 and 2013, because the crisis continued and because measures do not take effect in a quarter of an hour. But starting in February 2014, things began to change, and since then the number of affiliates to Social Security — I am talking about a period of less than three years — has increased by 1,639,000 people.

Undoubtedly, there is still much to be done; the goal is for twenty million Spaniards to be working. Undoubtedly, we would like wages to be higher; but it is not the Government that sets wages, but rather the agreement between unions and business organizations. Undoubtedly, we would like there to be more permanent contracts; but I must remind you that three out of four people work in Spain with a permanent contract, and not long ago the number was clearly lower.

Therefore, I believe we have improved the number of people working, I believe we have improved the situation of those who are working, and the goal is to continue doing so to achieve twenty million Spaniards working under the best possible circumstances.

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. President, I believe it is useless for us to talk about what happened three, four years ago, or two years ago; the issue is to resolve the problems of labor precariousness that workers have now.

We are not here to protest, but to put measures on the table that resolve this situation. That is why we are going to propose in the coming months and weeks that collective bargaining be recovered as an instrument to redistribute income; that the casual nature of temporary hiring be restored, reversing the disastrous effects of your labor reform on the unilateral modification of working conditions, and yes, recovering wage income. Raise wages, to put it plainly; fundamentally, through collective bargaining, but also through an increase in the Minimum Interprofessional Wage.

Look, Mr. Rajoy, in the last seven days you and your Group have suffered resounding defeats in this Chamber; you have also won on some occasions. You have lost when you have been left alone and you have won when you have rectified your policies and negotiated with the rest of the Groups: last week on gender violence and yesterday on the Toledo Pact. Therefore, our conclusion and yours should be clear, Mr. Rajoy: change the policies, dialogue, negotiate not so that your Group does not lose in this Chamber, because that is of no importance, but so that the workers of this country improve the quality of their jobs and earn decent wages.

President.- Talking about what happened, Mr. Hernando, is not useless, because we must see where we started and where we have arrived. And we must see, therefore, what the results have been over a certain period of time, because that is what allows us to say whether the policies that were practiced during that time were effective or not. I believe they have been effective, because jobs are now being created, and a lot, in Spain, and because the situation of permanent contracts is increasingly improving.

Undoubtedly, there are still many things to be done; but nothing is resolved, as I told you before, in a quarter of an hour. That is why I believe it is advisable to maintain the policies that have been implemented in these years, simply because they have worked. And now, what we need to do is persevere in them.

From there, propose whatever you want because I, for my part, am certainly willing...

Response from the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Albert Rivera, from the Citizens Parliamentary Group

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. President of the Government, next week we will present in this Chamber the first law of Citizens, the Law of Urgent Measures for Self-Employed Workers. Three and a half million Spaniards will see how we care, in the first law that Citizens presents in this Chamber, for self-employed workers. And I also want to thank you for the Government's support for that law, as you have committed, so that it moves forward and so that we can reform the self-employed workers' regime from top to bottom. A first step, without a doubt, for the entrepreneurs of this country.

But I wanted to ask you today, precisely, about wage earners, about the workers who suffer from those four million unemployed in Spain; about seven million workers who go to work every day and are poor, who cannot make ends meet, and, ultimately, about the main problem in Spain, which is not only unemployment, but also precariousness.

Mr. Rajoy, you know that on September 14, 2016, there were important resolutions in European rulings that admonished us Spaniards and the Spanish labor system from top to bottom, and told us that there could be no difference between permanent and temporary workers in terms of compensation. Mr. Rajoy, I ask you what the Government of Spain is going to do, urgently, to adapt to European legislation and comply with those rulings and protect the rights of temporary workers in our country.

President.- Mr. Rivera, indeed, we are going to support the proposal you have made. Undoubtedly, one of the great concerns is the situation of small and medium-sized enterprises and the self-employed, because in small and medium-sized enterprises and with self-employed workers, practically 80 percent of wage earners in our country work.

You now ask me about wage earners and, specifically, about a very specific issue, which is the recent ruling of the European Court. What we have done is create a working group, in which both business organizations and trade union organizations have appointed their representatives, to see how we are going to apply that ruling in Spain and to see if it is necessary to modify any law in order for things to be done, in accordance with the ruling, in the most reasonable way possible for all wage earners.

Mr. Rivera.- Mr. President, those rulings say that the precarious situation of temporary workers cannot be permanent. One of the cases is a worker in a hospital in Madrid who chained eight temporary contracts in a row. Curiously, the one who most precarizes employment in Spain is the Public Administration, and that cannot be. We cannot have people chaining temporary contracts one after another, with uncertainty. The average duration of contracts in Spain is 54 days, Mr. Rajoy. What future does a family or a person have with a job of 54 days, chaining contracts one after another, without any future? What I am proposing to you, Mr. Rajoy, is a comprehensive reform and a reform that does not just patch the situation.

The reform you made is a patch to the situation. I propose that we make a global reform; a reform, ultimately, that ends these figures.

We are champions of Europe in the unemployment rate. Spain is at the forefront along with Greece and Poland in precariousness. Mr. Rajoy, I do not want to settle for being the champion of Europe in unemployment or precariousness, and I ask you, please, to urgently address together the labor market reforms, because neither the PSOE nor the PP in the last thirty years have been capable. Our model has been a complete failure, and I believe the time has come to modernize the Spanish labor system.

President.- Mr. Rivera, I do not intend to put any patches. What I intend is for the decisions adopted by the Government and this Chamber to be as justified as possible. That is why I thought it was most sensible and reasonable to assign a group of people, appointed not by me, but by different business and trade union organizations, to make a proposal to us, both to the Government and, if you wish, to this Chamber, to resolve this issue and provide a solution to the ruling of the European Court.

On the other hand, you do not want to be a champion of unemployment or precariousness, and neither do I. A good proof of this is that the fundamental objective during the last Legislature of the Government I presided over was to create jobs. And a good proof of this is that when I came to this podium and submitted myself to the investiture, I said that the most important objective for the next four years is also to create jobs. And a good proof of this is that, after five years of recession and continuous destruction of jobs in Spain, we have turned the situation around with the policies we have implemented, and today we have already had three years of constant job growth in our country.

Is there still much to be done? Undoubtedly. I agree with you on that; but you must recognize that some things have been done. For example, the year 2015, according to the EPA published at the time, was the year in which the most jobs were created in Spain in the historical series. That is a positive data, we are heading in the right direction, we will continue working together, and we will try to achieve the common goal: that there is more employment in Spain and that we soon put an end to precariousness.