Responses from the President of the Government in the parliamentary control session

Spain Mariano Rajoy · Prime Minister of Spain

13 December 2016 · Parliamentary control session

Context
Rajoy addressed the Spanish Congress during a parliamentary control session on December 13, 2016, responding to questions about the controversial 'Gag Law'.
Main themes
Citizen Security Law repeal debate, freedom of expression and protest rights, separation of powers, parliamentary majority mandate, repressive legislation criticism, civil liberties in Spain, labor reform, government accountability, police conduct and fines
Duration
~20 min
67th percentile
Words
2,452
67th percentile
Sentences
75
49th percentile
Readability
38
31st percentile
Grade
15.7
81st percentile
Syntax
3.38
88th percentile
Vocabulary
2.16
39th percentile

Translated from Spanish

Content
Actors
Style

The broad sphere of national life a sentence belongs to. Every sentence has an Arena, so it is the denominator the other indices are read against.

Other
  • Institutional 65%65%
  • Economic 24%24%
  • Social 5%5%
  • Ceremonial 4%4%
  • Geopolitical 1%1%
  • Technological 0%0%
  • Environmental 0%0%
  • Not in focus 0%

75 sentences in 37 paragraphs

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Antonio Hernando, of the Socialist Parliamentary Group

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. President of the Government, Mr. Rajoy, when you approved the reform of the Citizen Security Law on your own, you said it was an essential, necessary, and timely regulation to improve the effectiveness of public security policy. In light of how the "Gag Law" is being applied and the majority mandate of this Chamber for its repeal, what plans do you have, Mr. Rajoy?

President.- I am and will be absolutely respectful of all the decisions made by this Chamber in the exercise of its competencies, and I also hope that we all respect those made by the Government in the exercise of the same. That is the principle of the separation of powers, which you know very well, and I have no doubt that you fully agree with it.

Mr. Hernando.- Mr. Rajoy, let’s see if you act accordingly, because I am going to give you some examples of how the "Gag Law" is being applied: in six months, more than six thousand procedures for disrespecting the Police; complaints for carrying a backpack or a T-shirt with the initials ACAB; a fine of eight hundred euros for taking a photo of a police car; sanctions against a journalist for posting a video of an arrest online; sanctions against a journalist for asking a question outside the National Court, bypassing a police cordon; permanent identifications of reporters attending police actions… And so on and so forth.

And we must recognize that this Law, Mr. Rajoy, was not imposed by the markets. This Law was not dictated in Brussels; you made it on your own because you wanted to, Mr. Rajoy. You made it loaded with a huge ideology, a repressive ideology, that sought to condition the right to assembly, the right to protest, freedom of expression, and freedom of information, and that also creates enormous legal insecurity, because it poorly defines those behaviors that are subject to subsequent punishment.

In short, this is a law that your Government made, Mr. Rajoy, let’s not deceive ourselves, to condition the right of citizens to protest against the laws, regulations, and policies of your Government.

We said that when the majorities changed, we would repeal the Law, like all those laws that you approved on your own, as we began to do yesterday with the labor reform. And that is what we are going to do: we have presented this bill to repeal the "Gag Law" if you do not heed the majority mandate of this Chamber. Therefore, the deadline is clear: you have until we start processing this Law. So, Mr. Rajoy, do not waste time because if you do not remove the gag, we will.

President.- Mr. Hernando, you will know what is best for you to do; but I believe that repealing all the regulations that have been approved throughout a legislature, many of which have produced very important positive effects for all Spaniards, is not the best way to build or contribute to the general interest of all. In any case, you can make the decisions you deem appropriate and convenient, and the rest of this Chamber can do so as well.

I will tell you one thing with absolute frankness: to say today that there is a problem of absence of rights or enjoyment of freedoms in Spain is something that absolutely no one believes, and to say, as we have just heard here, that we have a problem in Spain with freedom of expression seems like a joke; just as it seems like a joke to tell the Spaniards that we have a problem with the freedom to exercise the right to protest.

Look, like you, I talk to many people, I suppose we will be in contact with many individuals, and many people talk to me, for example, about unemployment, which is undoubtedly a real problem, although it is gradually improving; they talk to me about the economic situation of our country, where we still have many things to do in the future, and they talk to me about many real problems of the people. But I have to tell you that not a single person since the approval of the Citizen Security Law has said a single word to me about this issue. I have only heard about this issue in this Chamber. No one has said anything to me about it, and therefore, you can do what you deem appropriate and convenient.

It is good to tell you one thing: complaints about protests, which were always for disturbances or for protests that were called without the permits required by law, are 0.02 percent of the complaints that have occurred, and the vast majority of the complaints related to this Law refer to drug offenses and offenses for possession of weapons and explosives.

Honestly, Mr. Hernando, I do not know if you have read the Law; but I have the impression that you are overreacting and moving away from moderation, which is where common sense and the interest of all lie.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Aitor Esteban, of the Basque Parliamentary Group EAJ-PNV

Mr. Esteban.- Mr. President, do you think that municipalities should have the capacity to consult freely with all their citizens on issues that affect their own scope?

President.- I suspect where you might be going. I am in favor of municipalities being able to consult citizens on issues that affect their own scope; but I am also in favor of there being a minimum control of legality and, therefore, that there is authorization from the Government, which is what the current legislation states, as you very well know.

Mr. Esteban.- Let’s focus on the issue. Mr. President, since the Transition, there has been a great fear of direct democracy, starting with the Constitution; but the restrictions began with the Organic Law of different modalities of referendum, which does not regulate municipal consultations, but requires government authorization to call them. But then there was a tightening with the Regulatory Law of the Bases of Local Regime, which is more restrictive than the previous one. Article 71 already speaks of own competencies, excluding tax matters, and again requires government authorization.

But recently, with the jurisprudence -- ruling 31 of 2015 -- the Constitutional Court, following the Catalan Law of Popular Consultations, makes a distinction between general consultations and sectoral consultations, and this is a call to a more restricted subject than the electoral body of the territorial community in question. Therefore, if a municipality wants to consult all its neighbors on public policies, decisions, or matters within the competence of municipalities, it always needs permission from the Government of Spain, which may or may not grant it graciously.

We are not talking about referendums on independence and sovereignty; we are talking about asking about municipal matters, for example, urban planning, as was denied to a municipality in Biscay not long ago; never with binding character either. And the Basque Municipal Law at this time… you seem to have the intention to challenge it, and I believe that these matters should be resolved.

Here there is a problem: with very strict and preventive legislation from the outset, we have moved to a more restrictive state legislation and a tightening with incomprehensible, timid jurisprudence from the Constitutional Court, limiting the autonomy of managing the own municipal interests, which is even enshrined in the Constitution, in Article 137 and following.

I believe it is time for municipalities to stop being minors, to free them from tutelage that exceeds their jurisdiction. Modify the legislation, Mr. President, if necessary, to undo the blunder of the Constitutional Court and update municipal consultations to European standards; so that they can freely ask all their neighbors about issues that affect their own scope. What is the problem with this? Why must it necessarily go through authorization from the central Government, which may or may not authorize it?

Mr. President, the Swiss are not crazy and the Europeans are not crazy. I believe we should adapt to their standards.

President.- Mr. Esteban, I am not going to give you my opinion here on referendums or consultations because I believe it is not relevant. What I will say is that, indeed, I agree with what you said about the Organic Law of 1980; there, municipal consultations are excluded. The Law of Bases of Local Regime establishes a regulation on consultations and states that they require authorization from the Government of Spain, that the issues must be of municipal own competence, of special relevance to the interests of the neighbors, and cannot refer to local finances.

I understand that you do not agree with the authorization by the Government, and I also tell you that it is debatable; but I would like to say one thing: the Government here does not have the capacity to make discretionary decisions. We are facing a purely regulated act. We are not talking about reasons, therefore, of opportunity; it is a matter of legality control, which seems very reasonable.

For example, if there is a municipality that wants to consult the neighbors about that municipality's membership in NATO, it seems logical that the Government does not authorize it because it does not fall within its competence; but if it is a purely municipal problem, the Government has always authorized them, and you know that because in recent years… Some yes and others no, but in municipal policy matters, it has always authorized them. Specifically, in the Basque Country, since 2010, six have been accepted and five have not been accepted because they were not within the municipalities' competencies, such as issues related to fracking.

Therefore, I insist, it is an act in which the Government has no decision-making capacity, other than the capacity to control legality, which seems quite reasonable, as it is good for institutions to adjust our behaviors to the Law.

Response of the President of the Government to the question posed by Mr. Isidro Manuel Martínez Oblanca, of the Mixed Parliamentary Group

Mr. Martínez Oblanca.- Mr. President of the Government, I am extraordinarily interested in knowing the importance of your commitment to fulfilling the first point of the program for Asturias of the electoral coalition Popular Party-Foro, and that is why I ask you about a new system of autonomous financing that responds to constitutional mandates.

President.- As you very well know, solidarity and equality are constitutional principles that inspire our legal system; they are two basic pillars of our coexistence. Therefore, it is a priority, and also an obligation of the Government that I preside over, and of any, to guarantee these principles, and to guarantee them in the new system of autonomous financing and in the State investments, to which your question also refers. These are two areas of the Government's action, but in principle, this should be something that inspires all the actions that the Government adopts.

At the Conference of Presidents of Autonomous Communities, which will take place on January 17, we will begin work to approve a new model of autonomous financing that must, without a doubt, be inspired by the principles of solidarity and equality. And it is also our intention to present a project for the General State Budgets for next year, in the first quarter of that year, where we will also have to take into account those principles that you are interested in when distributing investments among the different territories.

Mr. Martínez Oblanca.- Mr. Rajoy, the current system of autonomous financing was approved in 2009 by the then socialist government of Rodríguez Zapatero, tailored to the demands of the Catalan tripartite. It is a perverse, unjust, antisocial system that should have been corrected in its first term; but it even worsened by adding discretionary measures for the forgiveness of interests, through which 22,647 million euros were distributed, 75 percent of which, according to official data from the Ministry of Finance, went to Catalonia, Valencia, and Andalusia, precisely the Communities that are the most non-compliant, which, in terms of euros per inhabitant, establish differences of 1 to 3 between Autonomous Communities, with the consequent negative effect on economic growth and employment, which in the case of Asturias also affects the accumulation of a historical debt of the State's lack of solidarity.

Mr. President, the allocation of public investment with criteria of efficiency and inter-territorial balance is also a great instrument to achieve homogeneous convergence of growth in Spain and is the decisive tool to articulate the cohesion of the national territory following the European model.

Spain needs a greater effort of solidarity and constitutional equality. We require this knowing, as you well know, that the people of Asturias do not want to be more than anyone else, but neither do we want to be less than others, enduring the consequences of a discriminatory financing system, suffering the worst growth figures reported by the National Institute of Statistics, and occupying, year after year, the last place in the active population rate.

Mr. Rajoy, it is urgent to put an end to the drift that you yourself accurately predicted seven years ago, but for which the Government has yet to apply a remedy.

President.- Mr. Martínez Oblanca, regarding the financing model, we all know that the current one, as you have said, has deficiencies. We also know that, consequently, these need to be corrected, and the objective we will pursue is to ensure a level of services in all territories, defining a common portfolio in the fundamental areas and, secondly, ensuring stable and sufficient financing. It is about ensuring that all Spaniards can access public services on equal terms, regardless of where they live.

The debate will begin after the meeting on January 17, which I referred to earlier. You know that this is a topic of enormous difficulty; you know it. Whenever a debate on this matter has taken place, things have not been easy; but, well, to resolve things that are not easy, we are all here, in this Chamber, and I am absolutely convinced that we will reach an understanding among all.

The same goes for investments. When we present the Budgets, we will try to seek an equitable distribution, promote actions that benefit the general interest, and, of course, we will emphasize policies that improve our economy, expand our productive fabric, generate employment, and, therefore, result in wealth and well-being for the people.

There is an important matter that we will soon put into action, which is the attempt to reach a national pact for (…)